T a c kling Diffic ult SE QR T o pic s COMMUNIT Y CHARACT E - PDF document

10/26/2016 Pre se nte d by Na n Stolze nburg AICP CE P a nd Don Me ltz AICP T a c kling Diffic ult SE QR T o pic s COMMUNIT Y CHARACT E R, HIST ORIC/ ARCHAE OL OGICAL RE SOURCE S & HABIT AT S/ E NDANGE RE D SPE CIE S T ra ining Ag e nda  I ntro duc tio ns  Co mmunity Cha ra c te r De fining a nd Me a suring • SE QR F o rms  Online / GI S T o o ls • Co nne c tio n to • Co mpre he nsive Pla ns  Histo ric / Arc ha e o lo g ic a l Impa c ts o n the Re so urc e • Re so urc e s E xa mple (s) •  Ha b ita ts/ E nda ng e re d Spe c ie s  Que stio ns/ Answe rs 1

10/26/2016 Pa rt 1 – I nfo rma tio n Ab o ut Pro je c t F ro m Applic a nt Pa rt 2 – De te rmina tio n A Minute SE QR By Re vie wing Bo a rd On Po te ntia l I mpa c t And I ts’ Prime r Size Pa rt 3 – Ana lysis By Re vie wing Bo a rd And Sig nific a nc e Of I mpa c t COMMUNIT Y CHARACT E R – Co mmunity Cha ra c te r WIL L WE KNOW IT WHE N WE SE E IT ? 2

10/26/2016 Que stio n 6, SE AF Pa rt 1  “I s the pro po se d a c tio n c o nsiste nt with the pre do mina nt c ha ra c te r o f the e xisting b uilt o r na tura l la ndsc a pe ? ”  Wha t is ‘ c o nsiste nt’ ?  Wha t is ‘ pre do mina nt c ha ra c te r’ ?  Wha t is the ‘ e xisting b uilt o r na tura l la ndsc a pe ’ ? Que stio n 3, SE AF Pa rt 2  “Will the pro po se d a c tio n impa ir the c ha ra c te r o r q ua lity o f the e xisting c o mmunity? ”  Ho w do yo u de fine ‘ c ha ra c te r’ ?  Ho w do yo u me a sure the ‘ q ua lity’ o f the e xisting c o mmunity? 3

10/26/2016 Wha t is Co mmunity Cha ra c te r?  Wha t is the c o mmunity c ha ra c te r in the se pic ture s?  Ho w do yo u kno w it? Wha t is Co mmunity Cha ra c te r?  Wha t a b o ut the se ? Do the se ha ve a nything to sa y a b o ut c o mmunity c ha ra c te r? 4

10/26/2016 Wha t is Co mmunity Cha ra c te r?  And wha t a b o ut the se ? Ofte n Cite d, Ra re ly De fine d  T a ng ib le - Me a sura b le F e a ture s  I nta ng ib le F e a ture s  Built E nviro nme nt (Ma n-Ma de )  Un-Built E nviro nme nt (Na tura l)  Visua l/ Ae sthe tic  E c o no my E ithe r the intrinsic se nse of a  De mo g ra phic s pla c e , or the me a ning  Ac tivitie s/ Culture pe ople g ive to it, but, more  Va lue s ofte n, a mixture of both. 5

10/26/2016 Co mmunity Cha ra c te r I nc lude s…  Ae sthe tic s a nd De sig n  E ve nts  So c ia l a nd Arc hite c tura l  Na tura l Re so urc e s Histo ry  Sig na g e  L a ng ua g e s a nd F o o d  Art fo rms Culture  E duc a tio na l I nstitutio ns  Curre nt L a ndsc a pe  Histo ry  Sc a le , I nte nsity, Ho urs  E c o no mic Co nditio ns  Pub lic Spa c e s  Po pula tio n/ De mo g r.  T ra nspo rta tio n Syste ms Co mmunity Cha ra c te r & Sho rt E AF  Pa rt I – Offe rs Dire c t Que stio n (# 6)  Pa rt I I – Offe rs Dire c t Que stio n (# 3) BUT BE CAUSE COMMUNI T Y CHARACT E R I NCL UDE S SO MANY F E AT URE S… ANSWE RS T O AL L PART 2 QUE ST I ONS COUL D BE RE L E VANT . It’s All About Sc a le a nd Conte xt 6

10/26/2016 Que stio ns to Ask …  Cha ng e in the na ture a nd inte nsity o f la nd use s?  Cha ng e in visua l c ha ra c te r? I n a rc hite c tura l c ha ra c te r?  Cha ng e na ture o f ho using ?  Cre a te ne e d fo r mo re pub lic se rvic e s?  Cha ng e tra ffic pa tte rns?  Co nsiste nt sc a le a nd inte nsity o f pro je c t?  Cha ng e the de mo g ra phic s o f the c o mmunity?  Cha ng e dyna mic s o f c o mmunity? Co mmunity Cha ra c te r a nd F ull E AF  Pa rt I – Do e s Not Offe r Dire c t Que stio n.  Pa rt I I – Doe s Offe r Dire c t Que stio n (# 18) b ut # 9, # 10, a nd # 17 hig hly c o nne c te d AND ma ny o the rs sho uld b e c o nside re d! 7

10/26/2016 Sma ll I mpa c ts  Ge ne ra lly c o nsiste nt in de sig n, pla c e me nt, size , inte nsity, sc a le , a rc hite c ture .  Simila r to e xisting la nd use s.  E xisting re so urc e s c a n ha ndle pub lic se rvic e de ma nd.  Ade q ua te ho using o ppo rtunitie s will e xist.  Cha ng e s to na tura l la ndsc a pe sma ll a nd no t in sha rp c o ntra st. Mo de ra te to L a rg e I mpa c ts  Mo de ra te ly o r sig nific a ntly c ha ng e s visua l c ha ra c te r.  Ac tio n is muc h la rg e r sc a le tha n c urre ntly e xists in a re a ; de sig n, lo t la yo ut, stre e tsc a pe , inte nsity, sc a le is in sha rp c o ntra st.  Will c ha ng e de mo g ra phic s, tra ffic , lig hts, o do rs.  De ma nds o n pub lic se rvic e s will inc re a se .  L a rg e de c re a se in a ffo rda b le ho using will o c c ur.  E xisting fa c ilitie s ha ve no a dde d c a pa c ity.  Sig nific a nt c ha ng e s to na tura l la ndsc a pe . 8

10/26/2016 Do e s Yo ur Co mpre he nsive Pla n He lp?  A c o mpre he nsive pla n c a n a nd sho uld de fine c o mmunity c ha ra c te r.  Pla n c a n pla y a ma jo r ro le in yo ur SE QR e va lua tio n.  Pla n sho uld inc lude :  I nve nto ry, a sse ssme nt, ma pping o f re so urc e s.  Pub lic input to de fine b o th c urre nt a nd future c ha ra c te r.  Do c ume nt the histo ric , c ultura l, e c o no mic a nd so c ia l c o nte xt.  Visio n fo r the future . An E xa mple : Sha ro n Spring s 9

10/26/2016 Still Strug g ling : Sha ro n Spring s I mpa c ts? 10

10/26/2016 Ae sthe tic Re so urc e s? • Histo ric a nd Arc ha e o lo g ic a l Re so urc e s? • Co nsiste nc y with Co mmunity Pla ns? • T ra nspo rta tio n? • No ise , Odo r, L ig ht? • Online / GI S T o o ls L OT S F OR YOU AND APPL I CANT S T O USE ! 11

10/26/2016 Online / GI S T o o ls L OT S F OR YOU AND APPL I CANT S T O USE ! HT T P:/ / WWW.DE C.NY.GOV/ PE RMI T S/ 90211.HT ML T o o ls to Use  SE QR Wo rkb o o ks http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ pe rmits/ 90125.html  E AF Ma ppe r http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ e a fma ppe r  DE C E nviro nme nta l Re so urc e Ma ppe r http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ g is/ e rm  Ne w Yo rk Na ture E xplo re r http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ na ture e xplo re r/ a pp  Cultura l Re so urc e I nfo rma tio n Syste m (CRI S) - https:/ / c ris.pa rks.ny.g o v  Na tio na l Re g iste r I nfo rma tio n Syste m (NRI S) https:/ / www.nps.g o v/ nr/ re se a rc h 12

10/26/2016 E AF Ma ppe r  E AF Ma ppe r http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ e a fma ppe r T o o ls to Use  DE C E nviro nme nta l Re so urc e Ma ppe r http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ g is/ e rm 13

10/26/2016 T o o ls to Use  Ne w Yo rk Na ture E xplo re r http:/ / www.d e c .ny.g o v/ na ture e xplo re r/ a pp T o o ls to Use  Cultura l Re so urc e I nfo rma tio n Syste m (CRI S) - https:/ / c ris.pa rks.ny.g o v 14

10/26/2016 T o o ls to Use  Na tio na l Re g iste r I nfo rma tio n Syste m (NRI S) https:/ / www.nps.g o v/ nr/ re se a rc h Othe r T o o ls to Use  L o c a l Re so urc e s  Co mpre he nsive Pla ns  Na tura l Re so urc e I nve nto rie s  Histo ric Re so urc e I nve nto rie s  Do n’ t ha ve to wa it fo r a n a pplic a tio n  Co mpile info rma tio n a t a munic ipa l-wide le ve l b e fo re ha nd 15

10/26/2016 Histo ric & Arc ha e o lo g ic a l Re so urc e s AL SO PART OF COMMUNI T Y CHARACT E R? Wha t Are T he se Re so urc e s?  Histo ric Re so urc e s vs.  Arc he o lo g ic a l Re so urc e s 16

10/26/2016 Cla ssifying the Ac tio n  §617.4 T ype I a c tions  (b ) T he fo llo wing a c tio ns a re T ype I if the y a re to b e dire c tly unde rta ke n, funde d o r a ppro ve d b y a n a g e nc y:  (9) a ny Unliste d a c tio n (unle ss the a c tio n is de sig ne d fo r the pre se rva tio n o f the fa c ility o r site ) o c c urring who lly o r pa rtia lly within, o r sub sta ntia lly c o ntig uo us to , a ny histo ric b uilding , struc ture , fa c ility, site o r distric t o r pre histo ric site tha t is liste d o n the Na tio na l Re g iste r o f Histo ric Pla c e s, o r tha t ha s b e e n pro po se d b y the Ne w Yo rk Sta te Bo a rd o n Histo ric Pre se rva tio n fo r a re c o mme nda tio n to the Sta te Histo ric Pre se rva tio n Offic e r fo r no mina tio n fo r inc lusio n in the Na tio na l Re g iste r, o r tha t is liste d o n the Sta te Re g iste r o f Histo ric Pla c e s. Histo ric a nd Arc he o lo g ic a l Re so urc e s in the SE AF  Pa rt 1:  12. a . Do e s the site c o nta in a struc ture tha t is liste d o n e ithe r the Sta te o r Na tio na l Re g iste r o f Histo ric Pla c e s?  12. b . I s the pro po se d a c tio n lo c a te d in a n a rc he o lo g ic a l se nsitive a re a ?  Pa rt 2:  8. Will the pro po se d a c tio n impa ir the c ha ra c te r o r q ua lity o f impo rta nt histo ric , a rc ha e o lo g ic a l, a rc hite c tura l o r a e sthe tic re so urc e s? 17