Ausa ble Ba yfie ld Conse r Ausa ble Ba yfie ld Conse r va tion - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Ausa ble Ba yfie ld Conse r Ausa ble Ba yfie ld Conse r va tion Author va tion Author ity ity Shore line Ma na g e me nt Pla n Upda te Shore line Ma na g e me nt Pla n Upda te hursda y, Ma y 12 th , 2016 (10:00 3:00) hursda y,
Ausa ble Ba yfie ld Conse r va tion Author ity – Shore line Ma na g e me nt Pla n Upda te Ausa ble Ba yfie ld Conse r va tion Author ity – Shore line Ma na g e me nt Pla n Upda te
Ste e ring Co mmitte e Me e ting : T hursda y, Ma y 12th, 2016 (10:00 – 3:00) Ste e ring Co mmitte e Me e ting : T hursda y, Ma y 12th, 2016 (10:00 – 3:00)
Ma rks o f Suc c e ss fo r T
Ma rks o f Suc c e ss fo r T
T ime De ta ils L e a d 9:30
Offic ia l We lc o me
Re c a p o f Pro je c t Ove rvie w & Antic ipa te d Outc o me s
Ro und T a b le I ntro duc tio ns Ale c Sc o tt, Wa te r & Pla nning Ma na g e r, ABCA
9:40
Me e ting Purpo se & Ob je c tive
Me e ting Struc ture & L
Pa rtic ipa nt Ma rks o f Suc c e ss K a re n Wia ne c ki, Dire c to r o f Pra c tic e , Pla nning So lutio ns I nc .
9:45
Pro g re ss Upda te Sinc e the I na ug ura l Oc to b e r Ste e ring Co mmitte e Me e ting
Syno psis o f Pro g re ss in Se ve ra l K e y Are a s
I de ntific a tio n o f T a sks Unde rwa y (Rive r Dre dg ing , Sho re line Pro te c tio n Wo rks Disc ussio n Pa pe r, L a ndo wne r F a c t She e t)
Que stio ns & Co mme nts fro m Pa rtic ipa nts Ale c Sc o tt & K a re n Wia ne c ki
10:00
Re c e ssio n Ra te Ca lc ula tio n – I nitia l Re sults
Ove rvie w o f Me tho do lo g y
I nitia l Re sults
Que stio ns & Co mme nts fro m Pa rtic ipa nts Ro b in Da vidso n-Arno tt
10:45
Re fre shme nt Bre a k
11:00
Clima te Cha ng e – Antic ipa te d I mpa c ts On Co a sta l Pro c e sse s Affe c ting the Sho re line o f ABCA
Ove rvie w o f Me tho do lo g y
No ta b le Ob se rva tio ns & Co nc lusio ns
Que stio ns & Co mme nts fro m Pa rtic ipa nts Ro b in Da vidso n-Arno tt
12:00
L unc h (Pro vide d)
12:45 Struc ture s in the 3:1
Ove rvie w o f the I ssue
Outline o f ABCAs Go F
K e y De c isio n Re q uire d: Dire c tio n fro m Ste e ring Co mmitte e is re q uire d: Wha t will we re c o mme nd to the ABCA Bo a rd o f Dire c to rs? Ale c Sc o tt 1:45 Upda te d Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n
Dra ft T a b le o f Co nte nts
Ove rvie w o f De fic ie nc ie s F ro m I na ug ura l Me e ting
Que stio ns & Co mme nts fro m Pa rtic ipa nts K a re n Wia ne c ki 2:15 Ove rvie w o f Upda te d E ng a g e me nt Stra te g y
Ste e ring Co mmitte e E ng a g e me nt
Munic ipa l E ng a g e me nt
Co mmunity E ng a g e me nt
Pro po se d T iming fo r the Pub lic I nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns
Que stio ns, Co mme nts & Sug g e stio ns K a re n Wia ne c ki 2:40 Co mme nts/ Que stio ns fro m Ob se rve rs? Additio na l I te ms fo r Disc ussio n? All Pa rtic ipa nts 2:55 K e y L e a rning s
Ne xt Ste ps & Whe re T
ro m He re K a re n Wia ne c ki 3:00 Me e ting Co nc lude s Ale c Sc o tt
T
Re c e ssio n Ra te pro g re ss Clima te Cha ng e – Antic ipa te d I
mpa c ts
Sho re line Sta b ility I
ssue s & Oppo rtunitie s - Ste e ring Co mmitte e Re c o mme nda tio n Re q uire d
T
me mb e rs:
Se c o nd Co mmunity Ne wsle tte r Ripa ria n L
a ndo wne r F a c t She e t
Dra ft T
a b le o f Co nte nts fo r the Upda te d Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n
T
me e ting s.
T
T
T
Re c e ssio n Ra te pro g re ss Clima te Cha ng e – Antic ipa te d I
mpa c ts
Sho re line Sta b ility I
ssue s & Oppo rtunitie s - Ste e ring Co mmitte e Re c o mme nda tio n Re q uire d
T
me mb e rs:
Se c o nd Co mmunity Ne wsle tte r Ripa ria n L
a ndo wne r F a c t She e t
Dra ft T
a b le o f Co nte nts fo r the Upda te d Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n
T
me e ting s.
T
T
Our T e a m & Pro je c t Sc o pe o f Wo rk Our T e a m & Pro je c t Sc o pe o f Wo rk
Pla nning Solutions Inc . Ka re n Wia ne c ki (Pr
e a d)
Sta ke ho lde r E ng a g e me nt & F a c ilita tio n Pro vinc ia l Po lic y E xpe rtise Re po rt Writing Aqua Solutions 5 Judy Sullivan (I nte g ra te d Sho re line Ma na g e me nt, CA Re g ula tio ns (F lo o ding E ro sio n, Dyna mic Be a c h a nd Slo pe Sta b ility Ha za rds), Pro vinc ia l Po lic y a nd T e c hnic a l Guide line s fo r Sho re line s o f the Gre a t L a ke s, Struc tura l Asse ssme nt a nd Co a sta l E ng ine e ring )
(Co a sta l Ge o mo rpho lo g y, Be a c h/ Dune I nte ra c tio n, E ro sio n o f Co he sive Sho re line s) Pro vinc ia l Po lic y a nd T e c hnic a l Guide line s fo r Sho re line s
a ke s
Unive rsity of Gue lph Ada m Bonnyc a stle (Ge o ma tic s, Spa tia l Ana lysis, E ro sio n a nd Re c e ssio n Ra te Ha za rd)
Dr . Rya n Mullig a n Que e n’s Unive rsity, Civil E ng ine e ring
(Co a sta l E ng ine e r & Oc e a no g ra phe r, Nume ric a l Mo de lling , Dre dg ing , Clima te Cha ng e Ana lysis a nd Co a sta l Pro c e ss e xpe rtise ) Mic ha e l T a nos, P. E ng ., Billy Sing h, T e r r apr
(Ge o te c hnic a l Ha za rds, Re vie w
g e o te c hnic a l issue s, if re q uire d)
T
ime fra me : Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n c o mple te d b y No ve mb e r 2016 (Appro xima te ly 16 mo nths)
De live ra b le s: Upda te d Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n fo r tha t po rtio n o f the sho re line tha t
fa lls unde r ABCA’ s jurisdic tio n
Pro po se d Appro a c h:
L
I
te ra tive
Stra ig htfo rwa rd I
n ke e ping with the pre sc rib e d re q uire me nts o f the RF P
T
ime fra me : Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n c o mple te d b y No ve mb e r 2016 (Appro xima te ly 16 mo nths)
De live ra b le s: Upda te d Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n fo r tha t po rtio n o f the sho re line tha t
fa lls unde r ABCA’ s jurisdic tio n
Pro po se d Appro a c h:
L
I
te ra tive
Stra ig htfo rwa rd I
n ke e ping with the pre sc rib e d re q uire me nts o f the RF P
Re vie w e xisting ma pping a nd a e ria l pho to g ra phy, histo ric a l a nd re c e nt e ro sio n da ta a nd
do c ume nta tio n
Re vie w a va ila b le info rma tio n a nd de te rmine a de fe nsib le a nd upda te d lo ng te rm e ro sio n ra te
(100 ye a r) fo r the ABCA sho re line
Re vie w a va ila b le da ta a nd pro vide a te c hnic a l po sitio n o n sho re pro te c tio n a nd its impa c t o n
sho re line pro c e sse s a nd lo ng te rm e ro sio n
Re vie w a va ila b le info rma tio n a nd pro vide a g e ne ra l a sse ssme nt o n ha rb o r dre dg ing a lo ng the
ABCA sho re line
Brie f disc ussio n o n the impa c ts o f c lima te c ha ng e o n sho re line pro c e ss F
a c ilita te Ste e ring Co mmitte e a nd Pub lic Me e ting s a s we ll a s T e c hnic a l Pre se nta tio ns
Pro vide te c hnic a l e xpe rtise a s re q uire d Dra ft Re po rt o utlining ke y finding s a nd re c o mme nda tio ns fo r upda ting the Sho re line
Ma na g e me nt Pla n
Dra ft & F
ina l Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n
Re vie w e xisting ma pping a nd a e ria l pho to g ra phy, histo ric a l a nd re c e nt e ro sio n da ta a nd
do c ume nta tio n
Re vie w a va ila b le info rma tio n a nd de te rmine a de fe nsib le a nd upda te d lo ng te rm e ro sio n ra te
(100 ye a r) fo r the ABCA sho re line
Re vie w a va ila b le da ta a nd pro vide a te c hnic a l po sitio n o n sho re pro te c tio n a nd its impa c t o n
sho re line pro c e sse s a nd lo ng te rm e ro sio n
Re vie w a va ila b le info rma tio n a nd pro vide a g e ne ra l a sse ssme nt o n ha rb o r dre dg ing a lo ng the
ABCA sho re line
Brie f disc ussio n o n the impa c ts o f c lima te c ha ng e o n sho re line pro c e ss F
a c ilita te Ste e ring Co mmitte e a nd Pub lic Me e ting s a s we ll a s T e c hnic a l Pre se nta tio ns
Pro vide te c hnic a l e xpe rtise a s re q uire d Dra ft Re po rt o utlining ke y finding s a nd re c o mme nda tio ns fo r upda ting the Sho re line
Ma na g e me nt Pla n
Dra ft & F
ina l Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n
Re vie w e xisting I nfo rma tio n Co nduc t F ie ld I nve stig a tio n & T e c hnic a l Asse ssme nt Sha re I nfo rma tio n – finding s a nd re c o mme nda tio ns Ob ta in fe e db a c k (ABCA Sta ff, Ste e ring Co mmitte e , Pub lic )
Dra ft SMP F ina l SMP
4 Me e ting s: 4 Me e ting s:
Me e ting Purpose
1 Re vie w & a ppro ve T e rms o f Re fe re nc e Re vie w & e ndo rse E ng a g e me nt Stra te g y Re vie w dra ft ma te ria ls (F AQ, Co mmunity Surve y) I de ntific a tio ns o f issue s, c o nc e rns & e xisting SMP e nha nc e me nts ne e de d SC a s Cha mpio ns o f the Pro c e ss – Ca ll to Ac tio n 2 Sha re E a rly F inding s a nd T e c hnic a l/ E xpe rt Re c o mme nda tio ns 3 Pla n fo r Pub lic Me e ting s 4 Re vie w Dra ft SMP
K a re n Wia ne c ki & Ale c Sc o tt K a re n Wia ne c ki & Ale c Sc o tt
Pro g re ss re a lize d in a numb e r o f ke y a re a s…
mpa c ts o n L a ke Huro n Co a sta l Pro c e ss (Ro b in to pro vide a n upda te )
ssue s Disc o ve re d (Ale c Sc o tt to pro vide a n upda te ) – Ste e ring Co mmitte e Re c o mme nda tio n is Re q uire d.
Pro g re ss re a lize d in a numb e r o f ke y a re a s…
mpa c ts o n L a ke Huro n Co a sta l Pro c e ss (Ro b in to pro vide a n upda te )
ssue s Disc o ve re d (Ale c Sc o tt to pro vide a n upda te ) – Ste e ring Co mmitte e Re c o mme nda tio n is Re q uire d.
I
ssue s re la ting to rive r dre dg ing in thre e lo c a tio ns:
Po rt F
ra nks
Gra nd Be nd Ba yfie ld
Po lic y dire c tio n is ne e de d in a numb e r o f a re a s (e .g . re mo va l/ re te ntio n o f spo ils, e tc .) Judy Sulliva n wo rking with Dr. Rya n Mullig a n to re vie w lo c a tio n a nd spe c ific dre dg ing
de ta ils – ABCA to pro vide lo c a tio n a nd dre dg ing de ta ils.
Disc ussio n Pa pe r a nd re c o mme nde d po lic y a ppro a c h to b e fo rthc o ming …sta y tune d. Po te ntia l T
iming : June .
I
ssue s re la ting to rive r dre dg ing in thre e lo c a tio ns:
Po rt F
ra nks
Gra nd Be nd Ba yfie ld
Po lic y dire c tio n is ne e de d in a numb e r o f a re a s (e .g . re mo va l/ re te ntio n o f spo ils, e tc .) Judy Sulliva n wo rking with Dr. Rya n Mullig a n to re vie w lo c a tio n a nd spe c ific dre dg ing
de ta ils – ABCA to pro vide lo c a tio n a nd dre dg ing de ta ils.
Disc ussio n Pa pe r a nd re c o mme nde d po lic y a ppro a c h to b e fo rthc o ming …sta y tune d. Po te ntia l T
iming : June .
Upda te po lic y/ po sitio n o n sho re line pro te c tio n wo rks c o nside ring c urre nt sc ie nc e Do we …
Pe rmit no ne ? Pe rmit so me ? Pe rmit a ll? Ha ve a diffe re nt a ppro a c h fo r c o nstruc tio n o f ne w wo rks a nd re pa ir o f e xisting ?
Disc ussio n Pa pe r a nd re c o mme nde d po lic y a ppro a c h to b e fo rthc o ming …sta y tune d. Po ssib le T
iming : June .
Upda te po lic y/ po sitio n o n sho re line pro te c tio n wo rks c o nside ring c urre nt sc ie nc e Do we …
Pe rmit no ne ? Pe rmit so me ? Pe rmit a ll? Ha ve a diffe re nt a ppro a c h fo r c o nstruc tio n o f ne w wo rks a nd re pa ir o f e xisting ?
Disc ussio n Pa pe r a nd re c o mme nde d po lic y a ppro a c h to b e fo rthc o ming …sta y tune d. Po ssib le T
iming : June .
T
e rra pro b e re ta ine d to de ve lo p a L a ndo wne r F a c t She e t
L
e tte r o f Unde rta ke n b e twe e n ABCA & T e rra pro b e to b e sig ne d
Wo rk to c o mme nc e o n the F
a c t She e t
Antic ipa te d T
iming : Ma y
F
a c t She e t to b e de ve lo pe d first in dra ft a nd re vie we d b y Pro je c t Co mmitte e (ABCA & Co nsulting T e a m)
T
F
a c t She e t to pro vide impo rta nt info rma tio n to la ndo wne rs a b o ut wha t to lo o k fo r a s e a rly wa rning sig ns o f po te ntia l slo pe fa ilure .
T
e rra pro b e re ta ine d to de ve lo p a L a ndo wne r F a c t She e t
L
e tte r o f Unde rta ke n b e twe e n ABCA & T e rra pro b e to b e sig ne d
Wo rk to c o mme nc e o n the F
a c t She e t
Antic ipa te d T
iming : Ma y
F
a c t She e t to b e de ve lo pe d first in dra ft a nd re vie we d b y Pro je c t Co mmitte e (ABCA & Co nsulting T e a m)
T
F
a c t She e t to pro vide impo rta nt info rma tio n to la ndo wne rs a b o ut wha t to lo o k fo r a s e a rly wa rning sig ns o f po te ntia l slo pe fa ilure .
E njo y! E njo y!
Ale c Sc o tt Ale c Sc o tt
T he Issue :
Whe the r a nd ho w to a ddre ss po te ntia l sig nific a nt c o nc e rns a b o ut the numb e r o f struc ture s c urre ntly lo c a te d in the L a ke sho re Are a 1, no rth o f Gra nd Be nd. A r
e c omme ndation by the Ste e r ing Committe e to the ABCA Boa r d of Dir e c tor s is r e quir e d.
Afte r a fie ld re vie w o f the ABCA sho re line , the c o nsulting te a m ha s e xpre sse d sig nific a nt
c o nc e rn a b o ut the numb e r o f dwe lling s tha t we re within L a ke sho re Are a 1 in the b luff a re a no rth o f Gra nd Be nd.
T he Issue :
Whe the r a nd ho w to a ddre ss po te ntia l sig nific a nt c o nc e rns a b o ut the numb e r o f struc ture s c urre ntly lo c a te d in the L a ke sho re Are a 1, no rth o f Gra nd Be nd. A r
e c omme ndation by the Ste e r ing Committe e to the ABCA Boa r d of Dir e c tor s is r e quir e d.
Afte r a fie ld re vie w o f the ABCA sho re line , the c o nsulting te a m ha s e xpre sse d sig nific a nt
c o nc e rn a b o ut the numb e r o f dwe lling s tha t we re within L a ke sho re Are a 1 in the b luff a re a no rth o f Gra nd Be nd.
A de ta ile d inve stig a tion of the de g re e of risk wa s not pa r
t of the sc ope of wor k assigne d to the c onsulting te a m - if this issue a rose in the c onte xt of the ir wor k, T e r r apr
ide ntifie d in the or iginal Pr
Unsolic ite d Pr
e c e ive d fr
e r r a pr
T
e r r a pr
Phase 1: A de skto p re vie w o f the available info rmatio n (to po graphic maps pro vide d by the c lie nt, ae rial pho to graphic data and publishe d ge o lo gic al subsurfac e info rmatio n c o mprising sho re line slo pe s) and c o nsultatio n with Aqua S
nc . to ide ntify the Are as o f Co nc e rn within the study limits re quiring furthe r asse ssme nt. Phase 2: A highe r le ve l re vie w o f the available info rmatio n fo r the Are as o f Co nc e rn in c o njunc tio n with site visit, slo pe mapping, site me asure me nts o f the se tbac ks o f se le c te d struc ture s fro m the e xisting c re st, and c o nsultatio n with Aqua S
nc ., to c ate go rize zo ne
ignific ant (Z
ailure ) and Z
lo pe I nstability Risks.
A de ta ile d inve stig a tion of the de g re e of risk wa s not pa r
t of the sc ope of wor k assigne d to the c onsulting te a m - if this issue a rose in the c onte xt of the ir wor k, T e r r apr
ide ntifie d in the or iginal Pr
Unsolic ite d Pr
e c e ive d fr
e r r a pr
T
e r r a pr
Phase 1: A de skto p re vie w o f the available info rmatio n (to po graphic maps pro vide d by the c lie nt, ae rial pho to graphic data and publishe d ge o lo gic al subsurfac e info rmatio n c o mprising sho re line slo pe s) and c o nsultatio n with Aqua S
nc . to ide ntify the Are as o f Co nc e rn within the study limits re quiring furthe r asse ssme nt. Phase 2: A highe r le ve l re vie w o f the available info rmatio n fo r the Are as o f Co nc e rn in c o njunc tio n with site visit, slo pe mapping, site me asure me nts o f the se tbac ks o f se le c te d struc ture s fro m the e xisting c re st, and c o nsultatio n with Aqua S
nc ., to c ate go rize zo ne
ignific ant (Z
ailure ) and Z
lo pe I nstability Risks.
ABCA unde rto o k a ma pping e xe rc ise (no fie ld wo rk ve rific a tio n) a nd fo und… ABCA unde rto o k a ma pping e xe rc ise (no fie ld wo rk ve rific a tio n) a nd fo und…
Dista nc e to T
T
Numbe r of Dwe lling Units T
Ac c e ssory Building s/ Str uc tur e s T
Additiona l Comme nts 5 m
108 126 234 Struc ture s within 5 me tre s o f the to p o f b a nk a re g e ne ra lly sc a tte re d a lo ng the sho re line ra the r tha n b e ing c luste re d in spe c ific sub divisio ns.
10 m
153 55 208 Struc ture s within 10 a nd 15 me tre s o f the to p o f b a nk a re g e ne ra lly c luste re d in spe c ific sub divisio ns ra the r tha n b e ing sc a tte re d a lo ng the sho re line .
15 m
274 83 357
ve rything
ve rything
Do no thing to a ddre ss the po te ntia l risk a nd c a rry o n with the SMP upda te . Numb e r o f pro s a nd c o ns… Do no thing to a ddre ss the po te ntia l risk a nd c a rry o n with the SMP upda te . Numb e r o f pro s a nd c o ns…
Pros
Cons
No a dditiona l c ost to ABCA. Do e s no t pro vide ABCA o r la ndo wne rs with re q uire d info rma tio n a b o ut the le ve l o f risk. Allows the SMP to pr
As part of the SMP project, communicate the slope stability risks to shoreline property owners and educate property owners and municipalities. This would include a press release on the current erosion and slope stability risks along the shoreline as well as the development of an “Early Warning” Fact Sheet for shoreline bluff property owners. The Fact Sheet will be developed by Terraprobe and will provide information about the early warning signs that property owners should be looking for that may indicate slope stability issues and concerns. Please note: a Press Release has already been issued by ABCA. In addition, ABCA provided direction to PSI on May 4th confirming that Terraprobe is to be retained to complete the Landowner Fact
Fact Sheet.
Phase 1 of the Terraprobe proposal. Estimated cost = $10,000.00 plus applicable taxes.
Pros Cons Would e nable ABCA to pr
tant but ge ne r alize d r isk-base d infor mation to landowne r s and c ommunity me mbe r s.
Do e s no t pro vide spe c ific de ta ils
info rma tio n re g a rding the de g re e o f risk o n a pro pe rty spe c ific o r a re a wide b a sis. Wo uld no t de fine the limits o f a ny a re a s c urre ntly a t imme dia te risk.
T he initial inve stigation option would pr
additional insight and infor mation for ABCA, munic ipalitie s and landowne r s r e gar ding the de g re e of risk.
Do e s no t pro vide a de ta ile d a sse ssme nt o f a re a s o f c o nc e rn. Re q uire s a dditio na l funds to b e a llo c a te d e ithe r fo r the de ve lo pme nt o f the F a c t She e t
Ma y impa c t timing fo r de live ry o f upda te d SMP.
Do e ve r
ything – inc re a se the sc o pe o f the c urre nt c o nsulting c o ntra c t to inc lude the de ta ile d a sse ssme nt (Pha se 1 a nd Pha se 2) b y T e rra pro b e . Additio na l c o st = $29,000.00 plus a pplic a b le ta xe s.
Numb e r o f pro s a nd c o ns… Do e ve r
ything – inc re a se the sc o pe o f the c urre nt c o nsulting c o ntra c t to inc lude the de ta ile d a sse ssme nt (Pha se 1 a nd Pha se 2) b y T e rra pro b e . Additio na l c o st = $29,000.00 plus a pplic a b le ta xe s.
Numb e r o f pro s a nd c o ns…
Pros Cons Would pr
tne r s a nd la ndowne r s with c ompr e he nsive infor ma tion a bout the de g r e e of r isk.
Re q uire s a dditio na l funding .
Would pr
t an update d polic y platfor m. Would e nsur e that a ll par tie s (inc luding c ommunity le ade r s, landowne r s and r e gulator s) have the same update d infor mation.
Ma y impa c t the timing fo r de live ry o f the upda te d SMP.
Wha t Option Do You Colle c tive ly Support? Wha t Option Do You Colle c tive ly Support?
Dra ft T a b le o f Co nte nts Dra ft T a b le o f Co nte nts
Draft Table of Contents 1.0 BACKGROUND & CONTEXT 1.1 Study Background 1.1.1 Study Purpose, Objectives & Principles 1.1.2 Study Limits, Approach & Methodology 1.2 Why An Updated Shoreline Management Plan is Needed: Overview of Existing & Emerging Issues and Opportunities 1.3 Policy & Legislative Context 1.3.1 Policy Platform Ontario Provincial Policy Statement (MMAH, 2014) County Official Plan Technical Guide for the Great Lakes – St. Lawrence River System and Large Inland Lakes 1.3.2 Legislative Platform Planning Act Conservation Authorities Act Ontario Regulation 97/04 Individual CA Generic Regulations
2.0 TECHNICAL ANALYSIS 2.1 ABCA Shoreline Description (Consolidated Version) 2.2 The ABCA Shoreline ‐ Field Observations 2.3 Recession Rates
2.4 Evaluation of Lake Levels 2.5 Slope Stability Considerations 3.0 SHORELINE HAZARDS 3.1 Understanding Shoreline Hazards: An Overview 3.2 Erosion Hazard 3.3 Flooding Hazard 3.4 Dynamic Beach Hazard
4.0 ADDRESSING SHORELINE HAZARDS 4.1 Overall Management Philosophy & Approach 4.2 Addressing the Erosion Hazard 4.3 Addressing the Flooding Hazard 4.4 Addressing the Dynamic Beach Hazard 4.5 Addressing Areas Subject To More Than One Hazard 4.6 Protection Works 4.6.1 Bluff Stabilization Works 4.6.2 Shore Protection Works 4.7 Emergency Response Considerations 4.8 Best Management Practices 4.8.1 Riparian Landowners Non‐Structural Slope Management Practices Dune Beach Management Practices 4.9 River Mouth Dredging 5.0 ADDITIONAL REFERENCES & RESOURCES APPENDICES Appendix A: ABCA Hazard Maps Appendix B: Statistical Analysis of Recession Data Appendix C: Climate Change – Anticipated Impacts – Discussion Paper Appendix D: Shore Protection Works Discussion Paper Appendix E: Community Engagement Process: An Overview
Po lic ie s we re de ve lo pe d fo r sma ll sc a le de ve lo pme nt – na ture o f de ve lo pme nt a nd
g ro wth a c ro ss the wa te rshe d is c ha ng ing (c o mple xity is inc re a sing ; de ma nds a re e sc a la ting ). Po lic ie s ne e d to a ddre ss the la rg e r sc a le o f de ve lo pme nt tha t is no w c o mmo n pla c e .
L
a ke sho re Are a 1 & Are a 2 – de ve lo pe d mo re tha n 20 ye a rs a g o . Do we ne e d mo re de finitive la ng ua g e (e .g . flo o ding ha za rd, e ro sio n ha za rd).
SMP Upda te ne e ds to use c le a r de finitive la ng ua g e – no t o pe n to inte rpre ta tio n F
ill po lic y g a ps
Po lic ie s ne e d to re fle c t e xisting Pro vinc ia l Po lic y a s we ll a s c urre nt le g isla tio n a nd
re g ula tio ns.
Ste e ring Co mmitte e to ha ve pro vide d a ny a dditio na l c o mme nts b y Ja nua ry 15th, 2016. Po lic ie s we re de ve lo pe d fo r sma ll sc a le de ve lo pme nt – na ture o f de ve lo pme nt a nd
g ro wth a c ro ss the wa te rshe d is c ha ng ing (c o mple xity is inc re a sing ; de ma nds a re e sc a la ting ). Po lic ie s ne e d to a ddre ss the la rg e r sc a le o f de ve lo pme nt tha t is no w c o mmo n pla c e .
L
a ke sho re Are a 1 & Are a 2 – de ve lo pe d mo re tha n 20 ye a rs a g o . Do we ne e d mo re de finitive la ng ua g e (e .g . flo o ding ha za rd, e ro sio n ha za rd).
SMP Upda te ne e ds to use c le a r de finitive la ng ua g e – no t o pe n to inte rpre ta tio n F
ill po lic y g a ps
Po lic ie s ne e d to re fle c t e xisting Pro vinc ia l Po lic y a s we ll a s c urre nt le g isla tio n a nd
re g ula tio ns.
Ste e ring Co mmitte e to ha ve pro vide d a ny a dditio na l c o mme nts b y Ja nua ry 15th, 2016.
F irst Dra ft: e nd o f Ma y/ e a rly June
Sha re with Pro je c t Co mmitte e & ABCA Sta ff first Sha re with Ste e ring Co mmitte e se c o nd Sha re with ABCA Bo a rd (fo r info rma tio n) Sha re with Munic ipa l Pa rtne rs
Ob ta in fe e db a c k a nd pre pa re 2nd Dra ft
Se c ure Ste e ring Co mmitte e e ndo rse me nt a nd ABCA e ndo rse me nt to po st to the we b site
Dra ft # 2 = Pre se nte d to the Co mmunity (I nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns)
I nput re c e ive d o n Dra ft # 2 a nd re visio ns ma de
F ina l SMP Upda te Pre pa re d
Re vie we d b y Pro je c t T e a m & Ste e ring Co mmitte e
F
F irst Dra ft: e nd o f Ma y/ e a rly June
Sha re with Pro je c t Co mmitte e & ABCA Sta ff first Sha re with Ste e ring Co mmitte e se c o nd Sha re with ABCA Bo a rd (fo r info rma tio n) Sha re with Munic ipa l Pa rtne rs
Ob ta in fe e db a c k a nd pre pa re 2nd Dra ft
Se c ure Ste e ring Co mmitte e e ndo rse me nt a nd ABCA e ndo rse me nt to po st to the we b site
Dra ft # 2 = Pre se nte d to the Co mmunity (I nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns)
I nput re c e ive d o n Dra ft # 2 a nd re visio ns ma de
F ina l SMP Upda te Pre pa re d
Re vie we d b y Pro je c t T e a m & Ste e ring Co mmitte e
F
Upda te : Sug g e ste d Appro a c h & T iming Upda te : Sug g e ste d Appro a c h & T iming
Multi-fa c e te d a ppro a c h
Re g ula r me e ting s with the ABCA Pro je c t T e a m
4 me e ting s o ve r the c o urse o f the pro je c t with the Ste e ring Co mmitte e , a s o utline d
Bro a de r Co mmunity E ng a g e me nt… Ra the r tha n ho st two Pub lic Me e ting s to a llo w c o mmunity input, we ha ve o pte d fo r a Co mmunity Surve y with
no tic e b e ing pro vide d to a list o f ABCA sta ke ho lde rs tha t the SMP upda te is unde rwa y a nd pro viding a dire c t link to the we b surve y
ABCA list o f sta ke ho lde rs (Go ve rnme nt, I
ndustry & Co mmunity)
Me e t whe n we ha ve info rma tio n to sha re Offe r e q uita b le a c c e ss to a nyo ne with a n inte re st in pro viding the ir tho ug hts Po p Up E
ve nts – o nc e the SMP is a va ila b le – Wha t fe stiva ls a re pla nne d fo r July & Aug ust?
De mo nstra te to the b ro a de r c o mmunity ho w input ha s ma de a diffe re nc e – Wha t Did We He a r & Ho w Ha s T
his Sha pe d the Outc o me ?
Re c o mme nd Pub lic Me e ting s o nc e the T
e c hnic a l Asse ssme nt ha s b e e n c o mple te d a nd a dra ft SMP ha s b e e n de ve lo pe d
Use the ABCA we b site to po st re g ula r pro je c t upda te s
Multi-fa c e te d a ppro a c h
Re g ula r me e ting s with the ABCA Pro je c t T e a m
4 me e ting s o ve r the c o urse o f the pro je c t with the Ste e ring Co mmitte e , a s o utline d
Bro a de r Co mmunity E ng a g e me nt… Ra the r tha n ho st two Pub lic Me e ting s to a llo w c o mmunity input, we ha ve o pte d fo r a Co mmunity Surve y with
no tic e b e ing pro vide d to a list o f ABCA sta ke ho lde rs tha t the SMP upda te is unde rwa y a nd pro viding a dire c t link to the we b surve y
ABCA list o f sta ke ho lde rs (Go ve rnme nt, I
ndustry & Co mmunity)
Me e t whe n we ha ve info rma tio n to sha re Offe r e q uita b le a c c e ss to a nyo ne with a n inte re st in pro viding the ir tho ug hts Po p Up E
ve nts – o nc e the SMP is a va ila b le – Wha t fe stiva ls a re pla nne d fo r July & Aug ust?
De mo nstra te to the b ro a de r c o mmunity ho w input ha s ma de a diffe re nc e – Wha t Did We He a r & Ho w Ha s T
his Sha pe d the Outc o me ?
Re c o mme nd Pub lic Me e ting s o nc e the T
e c hnic a l Asse ssme nt ha s b e e n c o mple te d a nd a dra ft SMP ha s b e e n de ve lo pe d
Use the ABCA we b site to po st re g ula r pro je c t upda te s
T
ho se a ffe c te d b y the SMP
T
ho se with the a b ility to imple me nt
T
ho se with the a b ility to impe de imple me nta tio n
E
xisting sho re line la ndo wne rs c o nc e rne d with pro te c ting the ir sho re line pro pe rtie s thro ug h re pa irs, re pla c e me nt a nd/ o r upg ra de s to e xisting struc ture s o r to inc re a se the ir sho re line inve stme nt thro ug h wo rk o n e xisting struc ture s o r ne w de ve lo pme nt
Po te ntia l sho re line pro pe rty o wne rs Org a nize d sta ke ho lde rs inte re ste d in wa te rshe d ma na g e me nt a nd sho re line pro te c tio n Munic ipa litie s Re g ula to ry pa rtne rs (MNRF
, CAs)
Othe rs
T
ho se a ffe c te d b y the SMP
T
ho se with the a b ility to imple me nt
T
ho se with the a b ility to impe de imple me nta tio n
E
xisting sho re line la ndo wne rs c o nc e rne d with pro te c ting the ir sho re line pro pe rtie s thro ug h re pa irs, re pla c e me nt a nd/ o r upg ra de s to e xisting struc ture s o r to inc re a se the ir sho re line inve stme nt thro ug h wo rk o n e xisting struc ture s o r ne w de ve lo pme nt
Po te ntia l sho re line pro pe rty o wne rs Org a nize d sta ke ho lde rs inte re ste d in wa te rshe d ma na g e me nt a nd sho re line pro te c tio n Munic ipa litie s Re g ula to ry pa rtne rs (MNRF
, CAs)
Othe rs
Build a wa re ne ss, kno wle dg e a nd unde rsta nding tha t the pro c e ss is unde rwa y a nd why a n
upda te d SMP is ne e de d – fo r ABCA a nd its pa rtne rs a nd c lie nts
Se c ure e a rly insig ht a b o ut c urre nt issue s, c o nc e rns a nd o ppo rtunitie s Pro mo te info rma tio n sha ring a nd ide a g e ne ra tio n Cre a te c o nne c tio ns a nd b uild inte re st Cre a te a se nse o f sha re d purpo se a nd suppo rt fo r the pro c e ss a nd the pro duc t Build a wa re ne ss, kno wle dg e a nd unde rsta nding tha t the pro c e ss is unde rwa y a nd why a n
upda te d SMP is ne e de d – fo r ABCA a nd its pa rtne rs a nd c lie nts
Se c ure e a rly insig ht a b o ut c urre nt issue s, c o nc e rns a nd o ppo rtunitie s Pro mo te info rma tio n sha ring a nd ide a g e ne ra tio n Cre a te c o nne c tio ns a nd b uild inte re st Cre a te a se nse o f sha re d purpo se a nd suppo rt fo r the pro c e ss a nd the pro duc t
Ba c kg ro und E
xpla na to ry I nfo rma tio n: F AQ/ Ba c kg ro unde r
Co mmunity Ba se d Surve y (N= 68) Co mmunity Ne wsle tte r # 1 Co mmunity Ne wsle tte r # 2 (Dra ft) Pre ss Re le a se – I
ssue d b y ABCA (Slo pe Sta b ility)
Ba c kg ro und E
xpla na to ry I nfo rma tio n: F AQ/ Ba c kg ro unde r
Co mmunity Ba se d Surve y (N= 68) Co mmunity Ne wsle tte r # 1 Co mmunity Ne wsle tte r # 2 (Dra ft) Pre ss Re le a se – I
ssue d b y ABCA (Slo pe Sta b ility)
Me e ting with Munic ipa l pla nne rs a nd b y-la w e nfo rc e me nt o ffic e rs (e .g . fro nt line sta ff) to
re vie w po ssib le po lic y a ppro a c he s
Co mmunity Me e ting s (fo r b luff a nd dyna mic b e a c h situa tio ns) Po p-Up E
ve nts in July & Aug ust – ABCA staff to c o o rdina te . Ste e ring Co mmitte e me mb e rs to a ssist…
ARE
YOU AWARE OF ANY F E ST I VAL S OR COMMUNI T Y E VE NT S T HAT COUL D OF F E R A PL AT F ORM T O PROF I L E T HE DRAF T SMP?
E
a rly Wa rning F a c t She e t fo r Ripa ria n Pro pe rty Owne rs (in de ve lo pme nt thro ug h T e rra pro b e )
Me e ting with Munic ipa l pla nne rs a nd b y-la w e nfo rc e me nt o ffic e rs (e .g . fro nt line sta ff) to
re vie w po ssib le po lic y a ppro a c he s
Co mmunity Me e ting s (fo r b luff a nd dyna mic b e a c h situa tio ns) Po p-Up E
ve nts in July & Aug ust – ABCA staff to c o o rdina te . Ste e ring Co mmitte e me mb e rs to a ssist…
ARE
YOU AWARE OF ANY F E ST I VAL S OR COMMUNI T Y E VE NT S T HAT COUL D OF F E R A PL AT F ORM T O PROF I L E T HE DRAF T SMP?
E
a rly Wa rning F a c t She e t fo r Ripa ria n Pro pe rty Owne rs (in de ve lo pme nt thro ug h T e rra pro b e )
Sug g e st the fo llo wing sc he dule :
munic ipa l pa rtne rs
a lig ne d with e xisting pro vinc ia l po lic y dire c tio n
ina l Dra ft SMP to ABCA We b site
nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns sc he dule d a nd no tific a tio n o f sa me pub lishe d o n ABCA we b site a nd in lo c a l ne wspa pe rs (Sug g e st 2 (o ne fo r b luff; o ne fo r dyna mic b e a c he s) – I s this a ppro pria te ? Any sug g e stio ns fo r c ha ng e ?
a rly Aug ust: Co mmunity I nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns
nput o n the Dra ft SMP o ve r Aug ust a nd re visio ns to the Dra ft
Sug g e st the fo llo wing sc he dule :
munic ipa l pa rtne rs
a lig ne d with e xisting pro vinc ia l po lic y dire c tio n
ina l Dra ft SMP to ABCA We b site
nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns sc he dule d a nd no tific a tio n o f sa me pub lishe d o n ABCA we b site a nd in lo c a l ne wspa pe rs (Sug g e st 2 (o ne fo r b luff; o ne fo r dyna mic b e a c he s) – I s this a ppro pria te ? Any sug g e stio ns fo r c ha ng e ?
a rly Aug ust: Co mmunity I nfo rma tio n Se ssio ns
nput o n the Dra ft SMP o ve r Aug ust a nd re visio ns to the Dra ft
Ne wsle tte r T iming Sugge ste d De tails
2 Spring 2016 T e c hnic a l Pro g re ss; Re c e ssio n Ra te Me tho do lo g y; Clima te Cha ng e I mpa c ts o n L a ke Huro n Co a sta l Pro c e ss; Slo pe Sta b ility 3 E a rly Summe r 2016 Pro je c t Sta tus Upda te ; E a rly F inding s; Da te s fo r Pub lic Me e ting s; 4 L a te Summe r 2016 Outc o me o f Pub lic Me e ting s; K e y L e a rning s; Ne xt Ste ps 5 F a ll 2016 Hig hlig hts o f Dra ft Sho re line Ma na g e me nt Pla n Ho w Co mmunity I nput ha s sha pe d the Pla n Oppo rtunitie s to o ffe r a dditio na l c o mme nts o n the Dra ft 6 Winte r 2016 T ha nk Yo u to a ll who pa rtic ipa te d; L ink to the F ina l Pla n
T
Sug g e ste d T
iming : Summe r 2016 - Aug ust
Me e ting s to b e inte ra c tive :
Me e ting Ma rke tpla c e Glo b a l Ca fé Co nve rsa tio ns I
nfo rma tio n Bo o ths
Oppo rtunitie s & Prio ritie s Sta tio n
T
Sug g e ste d T
iming : Summe r 2016 - Aug ust
Me e ting s to b e inte ra c tive :
Me e ting Ma rke tpla c e Glo b a l Ca fé Co nve rsa tio ns I
nfo rma tio n Bo o ths
Oppo rtunitie s & Prio ritie s Sta tio n
Que stio ns, Co mme nts, Sug g e stio ns? Que stio ns, Co mme nts, Sug g e stio ns?
Any De puta tio ns? Any De puta tio ns?
We L
ha nk Yo u So Muc h F
ime T
We L
ha nk Yo u So Muc h F
ime T