Rhodes Community/Health Liaison Group Meeting 27 th November - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Rhodes Community/Health Liaison Group

Meeting 27th November Concord West Public School

Background

• NSW Health involved since mid-1980’s
• One of the primary goals of NSW Health is to protect

the health of the public

• We achieve this through advice to other government

agencies and community liaison.

Overview of presentation:

Historical cancer study – discussion Dioxin serum study – discussion

Rhodes historical cancer study

• Background: Part of the community liaison process

involved NSW health responding to concerns from residents that previous practices at the Union Carbide plant had resulted in an increased rate of cancer in the local community.

• Purpose: To determine if there was a difference in

rates of and death due to cancer in people living close to the Union Carbide site, compared to NSW and compared to Ryde and Concord local government areas.

What did we do?

• Define study area – 20 collector districts were

selected within 1.5km of the former union carbide site

• NSW Cancer Registry supplied data on cases of

cancer and deaths from cancer for the years 1972- 2001

• All cancers, lung and bronchus carcinoma &

hemopoietic cancers (such as leukaemia and lymphoma).

Study area

• Map with collector districts

What did we find?

• Overall, we found no difference in rates of

cancer or deaths from cancer between the study area compared with the rest of NSW and compared with Ryde and Concord statistical local areas.

92.87 (85.09-101.17) 88.72 (81.28-96.65) 90.50 (85.24-95.99) 87.57 (82.48-92.89)

All cancers

78.29 (57.32-104.43) 80.82 (59.17-107.8) 74.98 (59.89-92.71) 80.55 (64.34-99.6)

Leukaemia and lymphoma

116.19 (96.41-138.84) 107.09 (88.86-127.96) 115.70 (97.51-136.29) 105.46 (88.89-124.24)

Lung and bronchus cancer Standardised mortality ratio in study area compared with Concord and Ryde (95% confidence interval) Standardised mortality ratio in study area compared with NSW (95% confidence interval) Standardised Incidence ratio in study area compared with Concord and Ryde (95% confidence interval) Standardised Incidence ratio in study area compared with NSW (95% confidence interval) Type of cancer

Rates of cancer in the study area compared to control areas

Conclusion

• There is no evidence that dioxin from the Union

Carbide plant resulted in increased cancer rates in the study area.

Dioxin Serum Survey

Serum Survey

• Background

– Some members of the community are concerned that the control process during remediation may not be strict enough, and that they will be exposed to dioxins during the clean up. They would like some guarantee after the clean up is finished that their long-term health has not been adversely affected.

• Purpose

– The aim of this study is to determine if there is a change in community blood dioxin levels before and after the works on the peninsula.

Methods

• Three phases

– Baseline – After peak remediation (approximately 2 years) – After remediation complete (?5 years)

Methods continued

RHODES TEST GROUP

• 200 volunteers - complete a brief questionnaire and

donate 50ml blood at baseline

• Males 30-45, 45-60, 60+
• Females 45-60, 60+
• Collect another 50ml of blood from same people at 2

years and 5 years.

Methods continued

CONTROL GROUP

• 1100 volunteers from Red Cross Blood Bank

(Clarence St) - complete a brief questionnaire and donate 5ml blood at baseline.

• Matched to test group by age and sex.
• Exclude postcodes 2138 and 2114.
• Collect another 5ml of blood from same people at 2

years and 5 years.

Dioxin analysis

• All blood samples frozen and stored
• Blood samples pooled at the end of the study
• Analysis of pooled samples dioxin levels performed

What results can we expect?

• We expect to see dioxin levels in these age groups to

be quite stable, or to increase slightly to over time.

• What we look for is if these levels increase at a rate

greater than that seen in the control group.

Limitations:

• There are many.
• The study will not provide individual results.
• The study does not measure any health effects.
• The study cannot provide results until after the

remediation has occurred.

• Dependant on adequate numbers of participants.
• Dependant on funding.

More information?

• Newsletter is available at:

www.health.nsw.gov.au

• Cancer study report is currently under peer

review - will be available in early 2004

• Serum survey should commence in early

2004.

• Any questions/comments or to register

interest in serum survey ph:9816 0244