特定領域研究「ストレンジネスで探るクォーク多体系」理論班主催 「ストレンジクォークを含むクォーク多体系分野の理論的将来を考える」研究会 2009年2月27-28日, 熱海市
ハイパー核反応の今後
原田 融
Harada, Toru 大阪電気通信大学
Osaka Electro-Communication University Neyagawa 572-8530, Osaka, Japan harada@isc.osakac.ac.jp
Harada, Toru Osaka - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
2009227-28,
特定領域研究「ストレンジネスで探るクォーク多体系」理論班主催 「ストレンジクォークを含むクォーク多体系分野の理論的将来を考える」研究会 2009年2月27-28日, 熱海市
Harada, Toru 大阪電気通信大学
Osaka Electro-Communication University Neyagawa 572-8530, Osaka, Japan harada@isc.osakac.ac.jp
原子 v.s.(反応 ・中性子過剰ハイパー核生成 シグマ混合率
~270 MeV/c
q MeV/c
1.20 GeV/c
N→
0.6 GeV/c
n→ n→ n→
Stopped
q MeV/c q MeV/c
・反応の特徴を生かす ・状態を選択的に励起
(K,)
720 MeV/c
(,K)
1040 MeV/c
q~300MeV/c q~350MeV/c q~60MeV/c
1 max
[ ]
N J J
j j
1
[( ) ( ) ]
N J
n j n j
“Spin-Stretched’’ “Substitutional” H.Bando, T.Motoba, J.Zofka, Int.J.Mod.Phys. A5(1990)4021
neutron Lambda
1s 1p 1d 2s 1f d f7/2
3/2 n
(,K) reactions
by R.Hausmann and W.Weise
(K,)
Stooped K-
Elementary cross sections (Fermi-averaging)
Double-Differential Cross Sections
( )* ( ) 2
( , ) | | | | ( )
K K f
S f U i E E
q
Meson distorted-wave functions (Eikonal approximation )
Strength function
2
( , )
n K
d d S dE d d
q
( )* ( ) ( )
ˆ ( ) ( ) 4 (2 1) ( ) ( )
L K LM LM L
L i j r Y
r r r
' ( ) ( ) ( ) 2 ' '
2 1 ( ) ( ) 4 (2 ' 1) ( ; ) ( ; ) 2 1
l l L LM l l K ll
l j r l j k r j k r L
* '
ˆ ( 0 ' | )( 0 '0| 0) (k )
l M K
l l M LM l l L Y
観測/測定
素過程 π+ + “n” → K+ +
Y
K
入射粒子 標的核 核内核子 (陽子・中性子)
放出粒子
T.H and Y.Hirabayashi, NPA744(2004)323
=206 MeV
(K,)
720 MeV/c
q~60MeV/c 14 MeV =245 MeV
C.B. Dover et al., PRC22 (1980) 2073.
(,K)
1225 MeV/c
q~300MeV/c 73 MeV
R.H.Dalitz, A.Gal, PL64B(1976)154
2 2
( )(1 ) ( ) 4 2
F N N N
k q M M U U M M M
F F
k q k q M M
peak position
elem
( , )
L L
d d R d dE d
width
270 MeV /c -58 MeV -28 MeV 174 MeV 30 MeV (K-,): 2 MeV (,K+,): 56 MeV (K-,): 14 MeV (,K+,): 73 MeV
(+,K+)反応による-QF生成
12C
P.K.Saha et al., KEK-E438, E521
q~380 MeV/c q~400 MeV/c
peak width (MeV) (MeV) ~~
1.20GeV/c 1.20GeV/c
~~
1.05GeV/c 1.05GeV/c
T.O.Binford, et al. PR183(1969)1134
(b/sr)
1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 200 400 600 800
momentum (MeV/c)
LAB
d d
1050 1200
1200
N(1650)S11 N(1675)D15 N(1710)P11 N(1720)P13
K+ K+ K+ K+
2
2
ˆ ( ; , ) (2 )
K K p K
k E d t p d v
q
+ +
N
K
*
2
2
Lab N N
N N N N N N N N
p p
On-shell T-matrix
* 2 * 2 f i
( )
N N N
E E m m
p q p
* N K
p p p p
“On-energy-shell’’ equation
given given
S,A.Gurvitz, PRC33(1986)422: Optimal factorization
2
2
ˆ ( , ) (2 )
K K p K
k E d t E d v
1.05 1.20 ++n→K++Cross Section
M(+n)
28Si
KEK-E438
/ d d
1s(1/2)h 1p(3/2)h 1d(5/2)h 1p(1/2)h
S p d
1.20GeV/c 1.05GeV/c
Need careful consideration for energy-dependent
2
( , )
n K
d d S dE d d
q
-nucleus potential
well-known well-known
Strength function “Optimal Fermi-averaging” t-matrix
ˆ ( ; , ) t p
q
make the width look narrow
CReactions
T.H and Y.Hirabayashi, NPA759(2005)143 T.H and Y.Hirabayashi, NPA767(2006)206
Isospin dependence of -nucleus potentials for N > Z
C.J. Batty, et al.,Phys.Lett.B 74 (1978) 27 R.J. Powers, et al.,PRC47(1993)1263
RMF
n=3 n=4 n=5 n=6 n=9 n=10 n=3 n=4 n=5 n=6 n=9 n=10
Shifts Widths
C →u →u Mg →u Al → u Si → u S → u Ca →u Ti →u Ba →u W → u Pb → u
DD RMF LDA-S3 WS-sh teff LDA-NF
DD-A’ LDA-S3 WS-sh RMF LDA-NF teff ρ
DD RMF LDA-S3 WS-sh teff LDA-NF
DD-A’ LDA-S3 WS-sh RMF LDA-NF teff ρ
Real part Imag. part Real part
(weak) attractive weak (< 10MeV)
Type I
repulsive strong (30-40MeV)
Type II
C.J.Batty et al., Phys.Rep.287(1997)385
RMF
LDA-NF DD-A’ LDA-S3 WS-sh teff ρ
T.Yamada and Y.Yamamoto, PTP. Suppl. 117(1994)241 T.Harada, in: Proceedings of the 23nd INS Symp. 1995, p.211 C.J.Batty, E.Friedman, A.Gal, PTP. Suppl. 117(1994)227 R.S.Hayano, NPA478(1988)113c
1 1
( ) ( ) 2 4 1 ( ) ( ) (0) (0) r r U b B r b B r m
Density-dependent (DD) potential Relativistic mean-field (RMF) potential Local density approximation (LDA) with YNG-NF
Local density approximation (LDA) with SAP3 (simulates ND) Shallow Woods-Saxon potential:
teff ρ–type potential (B0=B1=0): Repulsive Attractive
p n
( ) ( ) ( ) r r r
n p
( ) ( ) ( ) r r r
(V0,W0)=(-10,-9) MeV a0=0.36+i0.20 fm
28Si
DD-A’ teff ρ
核半径
C.J. Batty et al., Phys.Rep.287(1997)385
H.Noumi, et al. PRL89(2002)072301
(-,K+)反応による生成
標的: 28Si, 58Ni, 115In, 209Bi 原子核内部から粒子を生成
28Si
1 exp[( ) / ] V iW U r R a
1/3 0(
1) fm R r A
0.67 fm a 1.1fm r 150 MeV V
15 MeV W
+90 MeV
-40 MeV
(NEW) P.K.Saha, et al., PRC70(2004)044613
“Optimal” elementary cross sections
Double-Differential Cross Sections
( )* ( ) 2
( , ) | | | | ( )
K K f
S f U i E E
q
Meson distorted-wave functions (Eikonal or Full optical model approximation ) Strength function
Strength function
f i
E E
K
q p p
2
( , )
n K
d d S dE d d
q
' ( ) ( ) ( ) 2 ' '
2 1 ( ) ( ) 4 (2 ' 1) ( ; ) ( ; ) 2 1
l l L LM l l K ll
l j r l j k r j k r L
( )* ( ) ( )
ˆ ( ) ( ) 4 (2 1) ( ) ( )
L K LM LM L
L i j r Y
r r r
* '
ˆ ( 0 ' | )( 0 '0| 0) (k )
l M K
l l M LM l l L Y
2
2
ˆ ( ; , ) (2 )
K K p K
k E d t p d v
q
Standard
DD-A’ LDA-S3 WS-sh RMF LDA-NF teff ρ
T.Harada, Y.Hirabayashi, NPA759 (2005) 143
DD-A’ LDA-NF teff ρ LDA-S3 WS-sh RMF
28Si
T.Harada, Y.Hirabayashi, NPA759 (2005) 143
PWIA Analysis with the Square-Well potential
+20 +10
+40 +20
“The s.p. potential is repulsive inside nucleus. Only NHC-F is acceptable.”
28Si 9Be
Chiral dynamics in the nuclear medium
UMeV repulsive W~ 21MeV
Semi-Classical Distorted Wave Model Analysis
“The repulsive potential is not so strong as ~100MeV.”
Local Optimal Fermi-averaged t-matrix DWIA
T.H, A.Umeya, Y. Hirabayashi, PRC79(200)014603
10 10Li
KEK-PS-E521
Li Li
2.5 MeV FWHM
g.s. g.s.
L
d d
~1/1000 17.5±0.6 b/sr at 1.20 GeV/c
12 12
C( , ) C K
L
d d
5.8±2.2 nb/sr
10 10
0 p
- coupling K+
p p p n
-
p n
K0
K p K n
p K K+
p p p p n
-
n
Doorway
p K
X X
U U U U
(0) (0) (0)
ˆ ( ) G G
G
(0) (0)
ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) G G G UG
Green’s function method
Morimatsu, Yazaki, NPA483(1988)493
( ) (0) ( ) ( ) (0) ( ) ,
ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ Im {Im } {Im } { }
Y T
G G G G W G
† † †
escape escape Spreading (nuclear-core breakup) = Complicated excited states
2
1 ˆ ( ) | | | | ( ) Im d d ( )G( ; , ) ( )
K f
S f O i E E F i F
r r r r
†
Green’s function
K+
p p p p n
-
n
T.Harada, NPA672(2000)181
(0)† † (0) (0) p K p K p K p K
t G t t G U G U G t
10 9 9
2 2
1
9Li+ 9Be+
68 MeV
3 2 T
Eikonal distortion: ( ) / 2 20 mb,
K
K
,
Y Y Y
Woods-Saxon form
0.6 fm a
2/3
1.128 0.439 fm r A
1/3 0(
1) fm R r A
9 9
X j X j
-coupling pot. spreading potential : energy-dependent = excited states 30 MeV for
p K
Spreading potential dep.
10B 11 MeV
X
U
W=
Li
Coherent - coupling dep.
20 MeV W
10B
0.075 %
0.57% 0.68% 0.47% 0.30%
Beでも混合が
と仮定した場合
10Be
data
これまでの解析との矛盾しない。
10 9 9
生成スペクトルは波動関数の性質に強く影響を受ける。
A.Umeya, T.H, PRC79(200)014603
10 10Li
“The 0+-1+ difference is not a measure of N spin-spin interaction.” by B.F. Gibson
p p n
p p n
p p n
+ +
three-body force
4He
PRL84(2000)3539
Coherent coupling
1+
1+
0+
0+
D2
coh.Σ
9% 1. P
1+
1+
0+
0+
SC97e(S)
coh.Σ
7% 0. P
1+
1+
0+
0+
SC97f(S)
coh.Σ
9% 0. P
1+
1+
0+
0+
SC89(S)
coh.Σ
0% 2. P
Coherent coupling Coherent coupling Coherent coupling
Breuckner-Hartree-Fock
NPA684(2001)586c (unit in MeV)
0.0
1+
0+
Exp.
1+
0+
VMC
4
( H)
6.20 V 0.38 0.86 spin-spin
NN force
ΛN ΛNN
V +V
phenomenological
4He 4He
without without ・couplingの効果はスペクトル の再現に重要 ・を経由したハイパー核生成
production via production via
17% per
NSC97e,f
10 Li
0.071 0.162 0.098 0.086 0.070 0.159 0.104 0.187 0.128 0.098 0.096 0.183 -mixing Prob.
数100keV
Umeya, Harada, PRC79(200)014603
Li) = 0.345%,
Fermi型 Gamow-Telleri型 Total
Coherently enhanced reduced
(1) コヒーレントな Fermi型とGT型結合 (2) 中性子過剰核ではT(T+1)に比例
Umeya, Harada, PRC79(200)014603
10 Li
T.H and Y. Hirabayashi, (2009) in preparation.
+ DD-A’ + LDA-NF
Coulomb
+ teff ρ
LDA-NF teff ρ DD-A’
1,3/2 0,3/2
1 1 2 6
D
U g g
1,1/2 0,1/2
1 1 4 12 g g
strongly repulsive repulsive attractive attractive
Quark Pauli- forbidden
58Ni Coulomb
LDA-NF DD
Coulomb Coulomb
~270 MeV/c
180MeV/c
110MeV/c
DD
58Ni
1.5MeV FWHM
DD LDA-NF teff ρ LDA-S3 WS-sh RMF
58Ni
T.Harada, Y.Hirabayashi, (2009), in preparation.
1.5MeV FWHM
208Pb
1 11/ 2
DD LDA-NF teff ρ DD LDA-NF teff ρ
1 11/ 2
1h
1 5/ 2
2d
1 7/ 2
1g
T.Harada, Y.Hirabayashi, (2009), in preparation.
1.5MeV FWHM
16O(K, K+)16C at pK=1.65GeV/c
-
W= 1MeV
U= 16MeV
rc= 0.454 DWIA
Tadokoro et al.,PRC51(1995)2656
2MeV FWHM U=24MeV
208Pb(K-,K+) at 1.65GeV/c
Folding pot. T.Koike, Y.Akaishi
BNL-E885
4MeV FWHM
ラメータを決める
DWIA
12 + 12
‐
P.Khaustov et al.,PRC61(2000)054603-1 核ポテンシャル Well depth~12-14MeV
素過程 ~35b/sr
YNG Folding potentialによる解析(rc=0.47)
T.H, A.Umeya, Y. Hirabayashi, (2009), in preparation
16 16C
H.Takahashi et al.,PRL87(2001)212502
6He
静止-によるハイブリッド・エマルジョン法 KEK-E37 KEK-E373
6He
12 6 4
C He He t
5He
p
H
2M B M
:{ 1 } 1/8 4/8 3/8 H N
H-dibaryon
R.L. Jaffe, PRL38(1977)195
6
( He) 4.7 MeV B
D.J. Prowse, PRL17(1966)783
10
( Be) 4.5 MeV B
1.3 MeV
10 9 *
( Be Be (3.1MeV)+ + ) p
13
( Be) 4.8 MeV B
6He
0.18 0.11
1.01 0.20 MeV B
0.18 0.11
7.25 0.19 MeV B
6 6 5
( He) ( He) 2 ( He) B B B
0 p
- coupling
K+
p p p p
K-
K+
p p p p
0
K-
0 p
K
K p
Doorway
K p K
Bando et al., Int.J.Mod.Phys. A5(1990)4021
K p K
p K
K n
, K p p K
Dover and Gal, Ann. Phys, 146 (1983) 309.
1.65 MeV/c 1.65 MeV/c
4He
Spin-nonflip Spin-nonflip Spin-fl Spin-flip ip
Short-range Short-range correlation correlation
q q ef
eff ~350MeV/c
MeV/c
with the recoil effects
OFA
attractive attractive repulsive repulsive N→N conv. Strong absorption
SAP-D(F): S-matrix equivalent to Nijmegen model-D (model-F)
Bando-Yamamoto 1985 Yamamoto et al. 1999
( , )
F
U k
1
1.35 fm
F
k
G-matrix calc.
NSC89
fss2
(unit in MeV)
NHC-F
NHC-D
1/2,1S0
1/2, 3S1- 3D1 3/2,1S0 3/2, 3S1- 3D1
NSC97f
ESC04a
ESC04d
Rijken-Yamamoto 2006 Fujiwara et al. 2006
0,3/2 1,1/2
1 1 2 2
N N
g g
1,1/2 0,1/2
3 1 4 4
N N
g g
1,3/2 1,1/2
2 1 3 3
N N
g g
SAP-F SAP-D
Bound
Y.H.Koike, T.Harada, NPA611(1996)461
Chiral constituent quark model pot.+ Faddeev calc. → =2.1MeV UBS ND NF
G.P.Gopal, et P.Gopal, et al., NPB119(1977)362 al., NPB119(1977)362
Non-spin-flip Spin-flip
Non-spin-flip Non-spin-flip +Spin-flip
3He(K-,+) spectrum at 600 MeV/c
Theoretical calculations
-conv. E= 1.46 MeV (+0.55 MeV) = 9.05 MeV
原子 v.s.(反応 ・中性子過剰ハイパー核生成 シグマ混合率