419 Broadway New York, NY United American Land, LLC
Community Board 2 Landmarks Committee Presentation
Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
11 September 2017
Community Board 2 Landmarks Committee Presentation 11 September - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Community Board 2 Landmarks Committee Presentation 11 September 2017 419 Broadway New York, NY United American Land, LLC Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com Map showing project site 419-423 Broadway and 301 Canal Street So-Ho Cast Iron
419 Broadway New York, NY United American Land, LLC
Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
11 September 2017
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419-423 Broadway and 301 Canal Street
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
Map showing project site So-Ho Cast Iron Historic District Map
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
Photo 1. 301 Canal Street. TO BE REPLACED Photo 3: 419-421 Broadway Photo 4: 423 Broadway Photo 1: 301 Canal Street Photo 2: 419 Broadway, looking east along Canal Street
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
1854, INSURANCE MAP - BLOCK 231, SOURCE: PERRIS 1856, WEST SIDE OF BROADWAY FROM CANAL, SOURCE: METROPOLITAN MUSEUM OF ART 1891, NORTHWEST CORNER OF BROADWAY AND CANAL, SOURCE: MUSEUM OF THE CITY OF NEW Y ORK
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
1899, INSURANCE MAP - BLOCK 231, SOURCE: BROMLEY 1914, NORTHWEST CORNER OF CANAL AND BROADWAY, SOURCE: NEW Y ORK HISTORICAL SOCIETY
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
1955, INSURANCE MAP - BLOCK 231, SOURCE: BROMLEY 1973, NORTHWEST CORNER OF CANAL AND BROADWAY, LPC DESIGNATION PHOTO 1973, WEST SIDE OF BROADWAY, LPC DESIGNATION PHOTO
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
423 BROADWAY, OVERALL 423 BROADWAY NON-HISTORIC ALUMINUM STOREFRONT. NO HISTORIC STRUCTURE OR FABRIC REMAINS. WINDOW LINTEL AT SECOND FLOOR. PAINTED BROWNSTONE WITH SOME MINOR DAMAGE. BROWNSTONE WINDOW SILLS HAVE NON-HISTORIC ALUMINUM CAPS. THE BRICK FACADE IS EXPERIENCING SOME STEP CRACKING. GRAFFITI EXISTS AT THE SECOND FLOOR OF THE PRIMARY FACADE AND ALONG THE SOUTHERN SIDE WALL. CENTRAL BAY FIRE ESCAPE. 423 BROADWAY ITALIANATE SHEET METAL CORNICE. THE CENTRAL LINTEL AT THE TOP FLOOR APPEARS TO BE PARGED
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
REAR ELEVATION. THE FACADE HAS COMMON BOND BRICK WITH SEGMENTAL ARCH LINTELS. THE ROOF IS CLAD IN A NON-HISTORIC ASPHALTIC MEMBRANE AND THERE ARE NON-HISTORIC DORMERS. GROUND FLOOR. ORIGINAL REAR WALL IS NOT EXTANT AT GROUND FLOOR. IT WAS LIKELY LOCATED WHERE THE SIDE WALLS PROJECT OUT SLIGHTLY. DETAIL OF REAR ELEVATION WINDOW. ROOF OF EXTENSION AT REAR, LOOKING WEST.
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
Architecture/Planning, P.A.
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
Architecture/Planning, P.A.
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
Photo 1. 301 Canal Street. TO BE REPLACED Photo 3: 419-421 Broadway Photo 4: 423 Broadway Photo 1: 301 Canal Street Photo 2: 419 Broadway, looking east along Canal Street
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
557 Broadway , 1973 LPC Designation Photo 107-111 Greene Street, 1973 LPC Designation Photo 557 Broadway , 2017 107-111 Greene Street, 2017 529 Broadway, 1973 LPC Designation Photo 529 Broadway, 2017
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
HAUGHWOUT BUILDING 1856-57, JOHN GAYNOR 357 WEST BROADWAY
487 BROADWAY 1895-96, JOHN T. WILLIAMS
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
E.V. HAUGHWOUT BUILDING, 1857 427 BROADWAY, 1870 101 SPRING STREET, 1870-71
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
487 Broadway 1895-96, John T. Williams 476 Broadway 1902-03, Robert Maynicke Broadway and Howard, looking east Broadway and Grand, looking east Map of buildings 8 stories or taller along Broadway
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
WEST BROADWAY AND GRAND STREET 143 SPRING STREET 137 GREENE STREET 357 WEST BROADWAY 129 SPRING STREET
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
392 WEST BROADWAY, C. 1977 393 WEST BROADWAY, C. 1977 DONALD JUDD AT 101 SPRING STREET, 1970 RICHARD HAAS, 1975 THE WALL. FORREST MYERS, 1973 KEN HIRATSUKA, 1984
Higgins Quasebarth & Partners, LLC
consultants in preservation and rehabilitation of historic properties
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
BROADWAY WEST SIDE (80’ WIDE ST.)
CANAL ST. HOWARD ST. GRAND ST. LIPENSARD ST. BLEEKER ST. BLEEKER ST. 345' 79' 82' 73' 178' 75' 75' 75' 92' 59' 42' 79' 55' 89' 168' 80' 84' 130' 68' 15' 90' 122’-8” 419 BROADWAY HOWARD ST. GRAND ST. WALKER ST. BLEEKER ST. 88' 74' 55' 77' 67' 126' 152' 85' 94' 80' 120' 76' 31' 20' 85' 62' 39' 132' 99' 74' 71' 43' 27'
BROADWAY EAST SIDE
423 BROADWAY 135’-8”
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
BROADWAY MERCER ST. LAFAYETTE ST. GREENE ST. CORTLANDT ALLEY LAFAYETTE ST. CHURCH ST. BROADWAY
CANAL STREET SOUTH SIDE (100’ WIDE ST.) CANAL STREET NORTH SIDE (100’ WIDE ST.)
85' 36' 60' 72' 46' 46' 16' 71' 74' 77' 81' 50' 123' 52' 60' 60' 75' 50'56' 26' 80' 45' 87' 75' 86' 20' 16' 46' 75' 122’-8” 35' 48' 88' 40' 68' 77' 76' 81' 31' 71' 57' 135’-8” 122’-8” 35' 135 8 ' 419 BROADWAY 45'
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
SITE DATA
ADDRESS: BLOCK: 231 LOTS: 1, 11, & 12 LOT DIMENSIONS (APPROX.): IRREGULAR - SEE DIAGRAM ZONING LOT AREA (APPROX.): 6,077 SF DEVELOPMENT SITE (APPROX LOT): 3,608 SF ZONING MAP: 12a ZONING DISTRICT: M1-5B SPECIAL DISTRICT: NONE LANDMARK STATUS: SOHO-CAST IRON DISTRICT COMMUNITY DISTRICT: 2 STREET FRONTAGE: CANAL STREET (WIDE) BROADWAY (WIDE) FLOOD HAZARD: ZONE 'X' COASTAL ZONE: YES 'E' DESIGNATION: NONE
EXISTING CONDITIONS
LOT 1 (AREA/ HEIGHT/ USES/ STYLE): 1,748 SF / 2 ST. / COM. LOT 11 (AREA/ HEIGHT/ USES/ STYLE): 4,808 SF / 3 ST. / MIX. LOT 12 (AREA/ HEIGHT/ USES/ STYLE):
ZONING SUMMARY
USE REGULATIONS * RESIDENTIAL: NONE COMMUNITY FACILITY: 3-4 (LIMITED) ZR 42-10 MANUFACTURING: 17 ZR 42-10 COMMERCIAL: 5-14 *, 16 ZR 42-10; 42-14(D)(2) FLOOR AREA REGULATIONS
5.00 ZR 43-12
ZR 43-122
HEIGHT, SETBACK, & YARD REGULATIONS ** MAX BASE HEIGHT: LESSER OF 85' OR 6 ST. ** ZR 43-43
15' ** ZR 43-43 SKY EXPOSURE PLANE ABOVE 85': 5.6:1 (V:H) ** ZR 43-43
ZR 43-311 PARKING & LOADING REGULATIONS REQ'D. PARKING SPACES: ZR 13-12
0 IF <25,000 SF (RETAIL) ZR 44-52
0 IF <100,000 SF (OFFICE) ZR 44-52 NO PARKING REQUIRED 419-423 BROADWAY & 301 CANAL ST. 30,384 SF 6.50 39,499 SF 2,679 SF / 1 ST. / COM. NONE WITHIN 100' OF CORNERS ONLY USES LISTED IN USE GROUPS 7, 9, 11,16 ,17, ARE PERMITTED BELOW THE FLOOR LEVEL OF THE 2ND STORY ZONING DISTRICT: M1-5B
TAX MAP DETAIL ZONING MAP DETAIL
BLOCK: 321 LOTS: 1,11,& 12
AERIAL VIEW
SITE
LEGEND
TAX LOT LINE ZONING LOT BOUNDARY REQUIRED SETBACK LINE
ZONING LOT DIAGRAM NOTE: PRELIMINARY ZONING ANALYSIS. LOT AREAS AND FLOOR AREAS ARE ESTIMATES SUBJECT TO SURVEY VERIFICATION. ALL INFORMATION OBTAINED FROM PUBLICLY AVAILABLE RESOURCES MAINTAINED BY THE CITY OF NEW YORK. FINAL APPROVAL OF ALL NEW DEVELOPMENT BY AUTHORITIES HAVING JURISDICTION. MA HAS NOT REVIEWED ANY INFORMATION REGARDING EASEMENTS OR ENCUMBRANCES ON THIS PROPERTY.
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
FLOOR AREA SUMMARY SECTION ROOF PLAN MASSING DIAGRAM
423 BWAY B R O A D W A Y CANAL STREET
PRELIMINARY FLOOR AREA CALCULATIONS (1) FLOOR LEVEL GROSS SF (2) ZONING SF (3) 9 (R) 1,793 8 2,378 2,295 7 3,477 3,355 6 3,477 3,355 5 3,477 3,355 4 3,477 3,355 3 4,642 4,480 2 4,638 4,476 1 (G) 6,005 5,795 CELLAR 6,060 TOTALS 39,424 30,466 DEVELOPMENT LOT AREA 6,104
5.0
30,520
FLOOR 1 0" FLOOR 2 16'-10" FLOOR 3 31'-8" FLOOR 4 46'-6" FLOOR 5 61'-4" FLOOR 7 91'-0" FLOOR 8 105'-10" BULKHEAD 132'-8" CELLAR
EXG ROOF 46'-0" FLOOR 6 76'-2"
85'-0" ROOF 120'-8"
ELEVATOR OVERRUN &
12'-0" 14'-10" 14'-10" 14'-10" 14'-10" 14'-10" 14'-10" 14'-10" 16'-10" 12'-0" CL. 11'-2" CL. 14'-0" CL. 14'-0" CL. 14'-0" CL. 14'-0" CL. 14'-0" CL. 14'-0" 4'-2" 2'-4"
423 BWAY (EXIST.)
RETAIL RETAIL OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE BASE PLANE 0" T.O. CORNICE 122'-8" ELEVATOR BULKHEAD 135'-8"
CL. 16'-0"
7 ST. 3 ST. (T.O. EXG ROOF) 1 ST. EXG SLOPED ROOF OPEN TO BELOW SUBWAY STAIR SUBWAY STAIR
24'-9" 76'-4"
16'-10" 46'-6"
25'-1" 54'-2" 79'-3" 47'-6" 13'-8" 38'-5" 53'-6" 46'-6" 100'-0"
132'-8" T.O. BULKHEAD
4 '
"
DORMER 135'-8" T.O. ELEV BULKHEAD
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
UP DN UP UP DN UP
RETAIL
MECH WATER ELEC TELE DATA JC
RETAIL 79'-3" 100'-0" 25'-0" 24'-10" 40'-6" 76'-5" RETAIL OFFICE LOBBY
UNDERSIDE OF STAIR (7'-6" TO 16' CLG HT)
79'-3" 76'-5" 25'-0" 100'-0"
SUBWAY STAIR SUBWAY STAIR
15'-0" 40'-6" 24'-10" OFFICE
1ST FL ROOF
76'-5" 79'-3" 53'-6" 46'-6" 100'-0" 25'-0" 25'-1" 8'-0" 8'-0" 24'-10" 40'-6" OFFICE 79'-3" 7'-0" 76'-5" 28'-8" 25'-1" 46'-6" 6'-0" 40'-5" OFFICE
EXISTING SLOPED ROOF EXISTING ROOF
54'-2" 25'-1" 28'-2" 47'-0" 76'-5" 75'-2" 79'-3" 40'-5" OFFICE
1,026 SF
TERRACE 54'-2" 25'-1" 76'-5" 13'-8" 61'-6" 75'-2" 40'-5"
1ST FL 2ND FL 4TH-7TH FL 8TH FLOOR CELLAR 3RD FL 6,060 SF 6,005 SF 4,638 SF 4,642 SF 3,477 SF 2,378 SF
LEGEND RETAIL OFFICE
1. REQ’D MINIMUM 30’ SEPARATION BETWEEN STAIR ENCLOSURES. 2. EGRESS DOORS MUST BE SEPARATED BY A MINIMUM 1/3 OF THE DIAGONAL DISTANCE OF AREA BEING SERVED.
EXISTING FOOTPRINT EXISTING FOOTPRINT
419 Broadway United American Land, LLC Landmarks Preservation Commission Presentation / 11 September 2017 Morris Adjmi Architects www.ma.com
LINE OF EXISTING DORMER
1ST FLOOR 3RD FLOOR 4TH FLOOR 2ND FLOOR 0’-0” 31’-8” 46’-6” 16’-10” EXG ROOF 46’-0”
423 BROADWAY REAR ELEVATION
423 BROADWAY SECTION RETAIL OFFICE OFFICE 8’-0”