CENG5030 Part 1-1: Introduction Bei Yu (Latest update: January 7, - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

ceng5030 part 1 1 introduction
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

CENG5030 Part 1-1: Introduction Bei Yu (Latest update: January 7, - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

CENG5030 Part 1-1: Introduction Bei Yu (Latest update: January 7, 2019) Spring 2019 1 / 19 Question Why Energy Efficient Computing? Question In computing, where the energy consumption comes from? 2 / 19 Overview Background: Digital Logic


slide-1
SLIDE 1

CENG5030 Part 1-1: Introduction

Bei Yu

(Latest update: January 7, 2019)

Spring 2019

1 / 19

slide-2
SLIDE 2

Question

Why Energy Efficient Computing?

Question

In computing, where the energy consumption comes from?

2 / 19

slide-3
SLIDE 3

Overview

Background: Digital Logic Power Modeling Power Reduction: First Glance

3 / 19

slide-4
SLIDE 4

Overview

Background: Digital Logic Power Modeling Power Reduction: First Glance

4 / 19

slide-5
SLIDE 5

Digital Logic

◮ Digital logic circuits operate on logical values, represented by voltage ranges.

Logic 0 Logic 1 False True Off On LOW HIGH No Yes Open switch Closed switch

0.0 V 1.0 V 2.0 V 3.0 V 4.0 V 5.0 V HIGH (1) LOW (0)

◮ Voltages between ground and a certain threshold represent the logical value 0. ◮ Voltages between a higher threshold and VDD represent the logical value 1. ◮ The threshold levels are design choices. ◮ If a voltage falls in the gap between the defined logical ranges, the result is undefined

and there must be an error in the logic circuit that produced it.

4 / 19

slide-6
SLIDE 6

MOSFET Approximations

MOSFETs can be approximated as either open or short circuits between drain and source.

5 / 19

slide-7
SLIDE 7

CMOS Logic Circuits

◮ CMOS logic circuits consist of complementary arrangements of NMOS and PMOS

transistors.

◮ A CMOS circuit is reliable because its design guarantees that its output is always

shorted to either ground or VDD but not both at the same time.

◮ As a consequence, the design also ensures that VDD is never shorted to ground

through Z, which makes CMOS circuits power-efficient.

(a) Bad Design 1 (b) Bad Design 2

6 / 19

slide-8
SLIDE 8

Logic Gates

AND OR NAND NOR XOR XNOR NOT (Invertor)

7 / 19

slide-9
SLIDE 9

Logic Gates

AND OR NAND NOR XOR XNOR NOT (Invertor)

Question:

What is the schematic view of an AND gate?

7 / 19

slide-10
SLIDE 10

Question:

Please draw NOR gate schematic view.

8 / 19

slide-11
SLIDE 11

Overview

Background: Digital Logic Power Modeling Power Reduction: First Glance

9 / 19

slide-12
SLIDE 12

Dynamic Power

Dynamic Power Modeling P ∝ C · V2 · A · f ◮ C: total capacitance seen by the gate’s outputs ◮ V: supply voltage ◮ A: activity of the gates in the system ◮ f : frequency of the system’s operation

9 / 19

slide-13
SLIDE 13

Dynamic Power

Dynamic Power Modeling P ∝ C · V2 · A · f ◮ C: total capacitance seen by the gate’s outputs ◮ V: supply voltage ◮ A: activity of the gates in the system ◮ f : frequency of the system’s operation Question:

What’s the most effective way to reduce dynamic power consumption?

9 / 19

slide-14
SLIDE 14

Static (Leakage) Power

The power dissipated by a transisotr whose gate is intended to be off.

Static Power Modeling P ∝ V · Ileak Ileak ∝ exp(−q · Vth) ◮ Vth: threshold voltage ◮ Minimum gate-to-source voltage that is needed to create a conducting path between

the source and drain terminals

◮ Click here for an animation of threshold voltage.

10 / 19

slide-15
SLIDE 15

Compensation of Voltage Scaling

fmax ∝ (V − Vth)2 V ◮ Maximum frequency is roughly linear in V ◮ Voltage should be larger than threshold voltage

11 / 19

slide-16
SLIDE 16

Compensation of Voltage Scaling

fmax ∝ (V − Vth)2 V ◮ Maximum frequency is roughly linear in V ◮ Voltage should be larger than threshold voltage ◮ Motivation of parallel computing

Apple A11 chip, in 2017.

11 / 19

slide-17
SLIDE 17

Background: Moore’s Law to Extreme Scaling

1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 10,000,000,000 1 10 100 1,000 10,000 100,000 1,000,000 10,000,000 100,000,000 1,000,000,000 Intel Microprocessors

Invention of the Transistor

10 1 0.1 0.01

45nm

<latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit>nm <latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="DCiRJ1BVzI7mhdLE5r9XfdF1SuA=">AB7HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLUlsLDHxgAQuZG/Zgw37cdndMyEXfoONhcbY+oPs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLU86M9f1vr7S1vbO7V96vHBweHZ9UT86RmWa0JAornQvxoZyJmlomeW0l2qKRcxpN57eLfzuE9WGKfloZymNB5LljCrZPCukSiPqzW/Ia/BNokQUFqUKA9rH4NRopkgkpLODamH/ipjXKsLSOcziuDzNAUkyke076jEgtqonx57BxdOWEqVdSYuW6u+JHAtjZiJ2nQLbiVn3FuJ/Xj+zyW2UM5lmlkqyWpRkHFmFp+jEdOUWD5zBPN3K2ITLDGxLp8Ki6EYP3lTdJpNgK/ETw0a61mEUcZLuASriGAG2jBPbQhBAIMnuEV3jzpvXjv3seqteQVM+fwB97nD6q2jd0=</latexit>

Year Number of Transistors per Integrated Circuit

Moore’s Law

Process Technology (µm

<latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit>µm <latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1XOQUpYJ4Navgj2rMp+JfrNOobQ=">AB7nicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmI5hYkTsaLElsLDERMIEL2VsW2LC7d9mdMyEXfoSNhcbY+nvs/DcucIWCL5nk5b2ZzMyLEiks+v63V9ja3tndK+6XDg6Pjk/Kp2cdG6eG8TaLZWweI2q5FJq3UaDkj4nhVEWSd6Pp7cLvPnFjRawfcJbwUNGxFiPBKDqpW+2rlKjqoFzxa/4SZJMEOalAjtag/NUfxixVXCOT1Npe4CcYZtSgYJLPS/3U8oSyKR3znqOaKm7DbHnunFw5ZUhGsXGlkSzV3xMZVdbOVOQ6FcWJXfcW4n9eL8XRTZgJnaTINVstGqWSYEwWv5OhMJyhnDlCmRHuVsIm1FCGLqGSCyFYf3mTdOq1wK8F9/VKs5HUYQLuIRrCKABTbiDFrSBwRSe4RXevMR78d69j1VrwctnzuEPvM8fNUyOxg=</latexit>

)

4004 8086 286 386 486 Pentium Pentium II Pentium 4 Core 2 Duo Core i7

Doubles every 2.1 yrs 12 / 19

slide-18
SLIDE 18

Background: Scaling of Apple SOC

Apple A7 (2013)

◮ 1,000,000,000 Transistors ◮ 102mm2 die size ◮ 1.3GHz

Apple A10 (2016)

◮ 3,300,000,000 Transistors ◮ 125mm2 die size ◮ 2.34GHz

13 / 19

slide-19
SLIDE 19

Background: An Inverter Example

14 / 19

slide-20
SLIDE 20

15 / 19

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Question if Moore’s Law Can Continue

Question:

What is the bottleneck of further scaling?

16 / 19

slide-22
SLIDE 22

Static Power Challenges∗

∗M. Brink, “Many ways to shrink: The right moves to 10 nanometer and beyond”, 2014.

17 / 19

slide-23
SLIDE 23

Static Power Challenges∗

∗M. Brink, “Many ways to shrink: The right moves to 10 nanometer and beyond”, 2014.

17 / 19

slide-24
SLIDE 24

Overview

Background: Digital Logic Power Modeling Power Reduction: First Glance

18 / 19

slide-25
SLIDE 25

Logic Level Techniques

Clock Gating

Turn off clock tree branches to latches or flip-flops whenever they are not used.

Half-frequency Clocks

Use both edges of the clock to synchronize events

Asynchronous Logic

Without global clock signals, the system can save considerable power. (Drawback?) Others: gate sizing; wire-sizing; scaling voltages...

18 / 19

slide-26
SLIDE 26

Architecture Level Techniques

Memory Systems ◮ Small cache in front of L1 cache – reduce total activities ◮ Memory banking: split memory into banks and only one bank ◮ Shut down part of memory – reduce static power Buses ◮ Gray code – switches the least number of signals in neighbor data ◮ Transmitting the delta ◮ Data compression Parallel and Pipeline

19 / 19