arXiv:1807.10188 andrea.bracco@su.se - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Andrea Bracco

Nordita, KTH, Stockholm University Ecole Normale Supérieure - Paris

andrea.bracco@su.se bracand.wixsite.com/cosmicogits

In collaboration with :

Simon Candelaresi (U. of Dundee), Fabio Del Sordo (U. of Crete), Axel Brandenburg (Nordita)

arXiv:1807.10188

IS THERE A LEFT-HANDED MAGNETIC FIELD IN THE SOLAR NEIGHBORHOOD?

HELICAL MAGNETIC FIELDS IN THE ISM THROUGH DUST POLARIZATION POWER SPECTRA

Planck

Cosmic Dust and Magnetism 2018 - KASI - 2.XI.2018

Outline

• Intro & Motivations:

* Resuming Planck results on E - B modes of linear polarization from Galactic dust

.What have we learned so far on the link between dust polarization power spectra and the physics of the interstellar medium (ISM) ? .What are the open questions ?

Outline

• Our contribution:

* Analytical toy models with data driven approach

arXiv:1807.10188

• Intro & Motivations:

* Resuming Planck results on E - B modes of linear polarization from Galactic dust

.What have we learned so far on the link between dust polarization power spectra and the physics of the interstellar medium (ISM) ? .What are the open questions ?

ψ = 1 2tan−1(U/Q)

p = p Q2 + U 2 I

Observables:

A glance at dust polarization

x y

An alternative base : E - B modes decomposition

Rotationally invariant quantities (Zaldarriaga & Seljak 1997, Zaldarriaga 1998, 2001) symmetric parity antisymmetric parity Expansion in spherical harmonics (Fourier transform in the limited flat sky)

An alternative base : E - B modes decomposition

Rotationally invariant quantities symmetric parity antisymmetric parity Power spectra analysis

DXY

l

= l(l + 1)CXY

l

/2π

where X and Y : I (T), E , B

(Zaldarriaga & Seljak 1997, Zaldarriaga 1998, 2001)

Summary of the Planck results:

What have we learned so far on the link between dust polarization power spectra and the physics of the interstellar medium (ISM) ?

All sky Planck polarization maps at 353 GHz

850 µm

(Planck 2018 results. XII.)

I P U Q

* These maps are smoothed to FWHM = 80’ from the nominal resolution of ~5’

E-B modes dust contamination to cosmological parameters

Unpredicted!

BB EE TE

Power spectra

• n the sphere:

Tensor-to-scalar ratio map (r < 0.12 BKP , 2015, PhRvL,114,10)

DXY

l

= l(l + 1)CXY

l

/2π

(Planck int. Results. XXX. 2015)

50

E-B modes dust contamination to cosmological parameters

(Planck int. Results. XXX. 2015)

Unpredicted!

BB EE TE

Power spectra

• n the sphere:

DXY

l

= l(l + 1)CXY

l

/2π

Tensor-to-scalar ratio map (r < 0.12 BKP , 2015, PhRvL,114,10) 50

Latest Planck results : Planck int. res. LIV. 2018. arXiv:1801.04945

Correlation parameter from Caldwell et al. 2017: (First author F. Boulanger)

TB, EB

rXY

l

= DXY p (DXX × DY Y )

NEW!

rXY

l

= DXY

l

q DXX

l

× DY Y

l

(First author F. Boulanger)

TB, EB

rXY

l

= DXY p (DXX × DY Y )

NEW!

** The TE correlation extends to very large angular scales (low multipoles) ! *** The TB correlation shows a systematic positive excess!

Latest Planck results : Planck int. res. LIV. 2018. arXiv:1801.04945

* The BB/EE different than 1; on average at high-latitude ~0.5!

rXY

l

= DXY

l

q DXX

l

× DY Y

l

Correlation parameter from Caldwell et al. 2017:

Histogram of relative orientation (HRO) (Planck int. results XXXII, XXXV)

B⊥

Orientation of

Galactic emission at 353 GHz (~850 um) (Planck 2013 results. I) with drapery tracing magnetic field lines (LIC)

Histogram of relative orientation (HRO) (Planck int. results XXXII, XXXV)

parallel for NH ≤ 1022 [cm−2]

Mensa filament (see Penprase et al. 1998)

Galactic emission at 353 GHz (~850 um) (Planck 2013 results. I) with drapery tracing magnetic field lines (LIC)

Histogram of relative orientation (HRO) (Planck int. results XXXII, XXXV)

parallel for NH ≤ 1022 [cm−2]

perpendicular for NH ≥ 1022 [cm−2]

Mensa filament (see Penprase et al. 1998) Taurus molecular cloud

Galactic emission at 353 GHz (~850 um) (Planck 2013 results. I) with drapery tracing magnetic field lines (LIC)

Histogram of relative orientation (HRO) (Planck int. results XXXII, XXXV)

parallel for NH ≤ 1022 [cm−2]

perpendicular for NH ≥ 1022 [cm−2]

Mensa filament (see Penprase et al. 1998) Taurus molecular cloud

Comparison with MHD simulations: trans/sub-Alfvenic turbulence in the ISM (e.g. Soler et al. 2013, Hennebelle 2013)

A bridge between cosmology and ISM

Dust contamination of B modes to cosmological parameters across the south Galactic hemisphere

(Planck int. Results. XXX. 2015)

Stacked properties of 260 filaments at intermediate and high Galactic latitude

(Planck int. Results. XXXVIII. 2016) (Zaldarriaga 2001)

• E

+E

• B

+B

A bridge between cosmology and ISM

Dust contamination of B modes to cosmological parameters across the south Galactic hemisphere

(Planck int. Results. XXX. 2015)

Stacked properties of 260 filaments at intermediate and high Galactic latitude

(Planck int. Results. XXXVIII. 2016)

A bridge between cosmology and ISM

Dust contamination of B modes to cosmological parameters across the south Galactic hemisphere

(Planck int. Results. XXX. 2015)

Stacked properties of 260 filaments at intermediate and high Galactic latitude

(Planck int. Results. XXXVIII. 2016)

These results are triggering analytical and numerical works to explain the observed signal in terms of MHD processes in the ISM. e.g. Caldwell et al. 2017; Kandel, Lazarian, and Pogosyan 2017, 2018; Kritsuk et al. 2018; Brandenburg et al. 2018 ** The TE correlation extends to very large angular scales (low multipoles) ! MAYBE! *** The TB correlation shows a systematic positive excess! NO CLUE! * The BB/EE different than 1 ! MAYBE!

Parity violation with non-zero TB

* T and E have opposite parity sign compared to B so <TB> and <EB> are 0, unless parity violation (e.g. Grain et al. 2012) * Non-zero TB correlation in the CMB polarization if primordial magnetic fields have helicity:

(Kahniashvili et al. 2014)

Magnetic helicity in the ISM ?

HST optical image B-field vectors in the radio Contours of synchrotron intensity

* How to explain the origin and structure of large-scale galactic magnetic fields ?

(Beck et al. 1996) (Fletcher et al. 2011)

Large-scale flows and small-scale turbulent dynamo

Magnetic helicity in the ISM ?

* Helical magnetic fields have been observed (maybe) in interstellar clouds

(e.g. Tahani et al. 2018)

* Helical magnetic fields threading filaments were proposed against gravitational collapse (Fiege & Pudritz 2000 )

(Credits to Saxton, Dame, Hartmann, Thaddeus 2006)

Blos towards you Blos away from you

Our contribution: arXiv:1807.10188

Can we relate the observed dust polarization power spectra to specific properties of the Galactic magnetic field in the Solar neighborhood ? * The TB correlation, if true, implies parity violation in the ISM.

Toy models to begin with

lines from PIPXXX

Approach

* We build 3D analytical models of the vector potential so that the diverge-free condition is always verified: ** We compute the total magnetic helicity and helicity column : (integrating along the y-axis) *** Given a density field, we produce synthetic observations of the Stokes parameters assuming uniform properties of grain alignment, p0 : (north : z-axis ; line of sight : y-axis) **** We compute E and B modes from Q and U and retrieve power spectra and correlation parameter: (see also Planck int. res. XX. 2016) (Caldwell et al. 2017)

rXY

l

= DXY

l

q DXX

l

× DY Y

l

Helical magnetic fields around cylindrical filaments

* Density field: ** Vector potential is the sum of that of a poloidal field and a toroidal field : (toroidal-to-poloidal field)

+

(Zaldarriaga 2001)

Paraview visualizer

Helical magnetic fields around cylindrical filaments

Helical magnetic fields around cylindrical filaments

l i n e

• f

s i g h t

Means and standard deviations of 100 random filament orientations with respect to the line of sight

Change of perspective!

Our contribution: arXiv:1807.10188

Can we relate the observed dust polarization power spectra to specific properties of the Galactic magnetic field in the Solar neighborhood ? * The TB correlation, if true, implies parity violation in the ISM.

(Fujimoto & Miyamoto 1969)

Helical mean field in the Solar neighborhood

* Uniform-field direction in the local Solar neighborhood towards (l,b)=(70˚, 10˚) (PIPXLIV. 2017, A. Bracco; Alves et al. 2018)

** p0 = 26% (PIPXLIV) *** = -20% (left-handed helix)

αb

Helical mean field in the Solar neighborhood

= -20% (left-handed helix)

αb

= 0% (no helicity)

αb

= 20% (right-handed helix)

αb

Multipole-binned power spectra

Helical mean field in the Solar neighborhood

= -20% (left-handed helix)

αb

= 0% (no helicity)

αb

= 20% (right-handed helix)

αb

Multipole-binned power spectra = -500% (left-handed helix)

αb

Helical mean field in the Solar neighborhood

** Since the observed TB correlation increases at large scales, we propose an alternative (complementary) interpretation: the mean magnetic-field structure in the Solar neighborhood may be responsible for the large-scale TE and TB signals through a helical component with a small pitch-angle! * Based on the today common interpretation of the E-B modes dust polarization signals (i.e. MHD processes in the ISM, matter-magnetic-field correlation), toy models of helical magnetic fields around filamentary density structures are not able to produce any B-modes! (Kinematic information of the diffuse HI gas (HI4PI) may help in exploring this new scenario!)

Summary

andrea.bracco@su.se bracand.wixsite.com/cosmicogits

*** TAKE AWAY message: imprint on the dust polarization spectra of the large-scale structure of the Galactic magnetic field in the solar vicinity, i.e. local bubble? (Alves et al. 2018)