ANALYSIS OF CREDIT PORTFOLIO FCERA May 2014 SEATTLE | 206.622.3700 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
ANALYSIS OF CREDIT PORTFOLIO FCERA May 2014 SEATTLE | 206.622.3700 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
ANALYSIS OF CREDIT PORTFOLIO FCERA May 2014 SEATTLE | 206.622.3700 LOS ANGELES | 310.297.1777 www.wurts.com E X E C U T I V E S U M M A R Y Since the asset liability study was presented in mid-2013, spreads for High Yield (HY) and
E X E C U T I V E S U M M A R Y
- Since the asset liability study was presented in mid-2013, spreads for High
Yield (HY) and Investment Grade (IG) corporate bonds have tightened considerably.
- The purpose of this presentation is to dimension the go‐forward range of outcomes
associated with these planned exposures.
- While we still advocate these asset classes as long-term strategic allocations, the entry
point for investment is not as favorable as mid 2013 (which is the case for many risk assets).
- The analysis herein uses starting yield to maturity (YTM), duration, and historical credit
spreads to estimate future returns under different time periods given changes to credit spreads.
Assumptions:
- Median spread based on the last 10 years of spreads (monthly).
- Assumes no change in Treasury (i.e. risk-free) rates.
- Ignores the impact of active management, and associated fees.
- No assumptions are made about corporate default rates.
10 Year Return Forecast Standard Deviation Forecast
Investment Grade
4.0% 5.8%
High Yield
4.4% 10.5%
2
H I S T O R I C A L C R E D I T S P R E A D S
3
High Yield:
- Current spread: 344 bps
- 72nd percentile relative
to 20 year history
- 140 bps tighter than 10
year avg. Investment Grade:
- Current spread: 101 bps
- 61st percentile relative to
20 year history
- 42 bps tighter than 10
year avg.
55 77 101 100 200 300 400 500 600 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012
Investment Grade Spreads: Trailing 20 Years
US IG Credit Spread 20 Year Avg. (123) 10 Year Avg. (143) 5 Year Avg. (162) 239 238 344 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009 2012
High Yield Spreads: Trailing 20 Years
US HY Credit Spread 20 Year Avg. (468) 10 Year Avg. (484) 5 Year Avg. (573)
As of April 30, 2014
D O W N S I D E R I S K
4
- Currently, spreads are narrower (bonds are priced more expensive) relative to historical levels.
The following table, illustrates the increase to credit spreads if the market reverts to the median
- r 25th percentile of the last 10 years:
- Currently High Yield is priced to yield 5.04% while the YTM on Investment Grade is 3.0%.
- The graph to the right illustrates the
depreciation in market value of the bond indices if spreads widen instantaneously.
- But with wider spreads the bonds
are subsequently priced to deliver higher yields.
- The next page estimates the total return
- ver three and five year time frames, assuming
spreads widen at the beginning or end of the period.
‐14% ‐12% ‐10% ‐8% ‐6% ‐4% ‐2% 0%
Downside Risk
High Yield Investment Grade
Median Spread 25th Percentile
Median 25th Percentile High Yield 140 316 Investment Grade Corporate 42 99 Changes to Spreads (in basis points)
S C E N A R I O A N A L Y S I S
5
Scenario 1: If credit spreads widen to either the median or 25th percentile of historical spreads at the end of year 1, what is the annualized return for the 3 year period.
Duration of HY index: 4.2 years. Duration of IG index: 7.6 years. 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5%
3 Year Annualized Total Return
High Yield Investment Grade
Median Spread 25th Percentile
Scenario 2: If credit spreads widen to either the median or 25th percentile of historical spreads at the end of year 3, what is the annualized return for the 3 year period.
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5%
3 Year Annualized Total Return
High Yield Investment Grade
Median Spread 25th Percentile
Scenario 3: If credit spreads widen to either the median or 25th percentile of historical spreads at the end of year 1, what is the annualized return for the 5 year period. Scenario 4: If credit spreads widen to either the median or 25th percentile of historical spreads at the end of year 4, what is the annualized return for the 5 year period.
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5%
5 Year Annualized Total Return
High Yield Investment Grade
Median Spread 25th Percentile
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5%
5 Year Annualized Total Return
High Yield Investment Grade
Median Spread 25th Percentile
C O N C L U S I O N
6
- While spreads could certainly stay at current levels or tighten further, a more likely
- utcome appears to be some form of reversion to historical averages.
- The timing and magnitude of an increase in spreads will drive the realized returns.
- All things equal, an increase earlier in the period is generally more favorable than an
increase at the end of the period.
- As the time period under consideration is extended, the average returns improve.
- While their may be some significant depreciation of market value at some point in
the future, the downside risk is still materially less than equities, and the yield component serves an important role within the broader portfolio.
A P P E N D I X
7
S U M M A R Y O F A S S U M P T I O N S : R E T U R N S
8 Asset Class Index Proxy Ten Year Return Forecast Standard Deviation Forecast Sharpe Ratio Forecast Ten Year Historical Sharpe Ratio Geometric Arithmetic
Equities
US Large S&P 500
5.9 6.9 14.6 0.23 0.47
US Small Russell 2000
5.1 6.9 19.7 0.13 0.46
International Developed MSCI EAFE
8.3 9.8 18.2 0.32 0.43
International Small MSCI EAFE Small Cap
8.5 10.3 20.0 0.30 0.52
Emerging Markets MSCI EM
10.1 12.6 24.0 0.32 0.55
Private Equity Cambridge Private Equity
8.1 10.5 23.6 0.24 0.96
Fixed Income
Cash 30 Day T‐Bills
2.5 2.5 0.5
US TIPS Barclays US TIPS 5 ‐ 10
3.1 3.3 6.7 0.09 0.56
US Treasury Barclays Treasury 7 ‐ 10 year
3.0 3.3 6.9 0.08 0.61
Global Sovereign ex US Barclays Global Treasury ex US
2.2 2.5 8.1 ‐0.03 0.42
Core Fixed Income Barclays US Aggregate Bond
4.1 4.2 3.6 0.45 0.92
Investment Grade Corp. Credit Barclays US Credit
4.0 4.2 5.8 0.26 0.68
High Yield Corp. Credit Barclays High Yield
4.4 4.9 10.5 0.18 0.71
Bank Loans S&P/LSTA
3.5 3.9 8.7 0.12 0.46
Global Credit Barclays Global Credit
3.1 3.4 7.6 0.08 0.60
Emerging Markets Debt (Hard) JPM EMBI Global Diversified
5.8 6.2 9.0 0.37 0.77
Emerging Markets Debt (Local) JPM GBI EM Global Diversified
6.6 7.3 12.6 0.33 0.61
Private Credit High Yield + 200 bps
6.4 6.9 10.5 0.37 ‐
Other
Commodities S&P GSCI
4.9 6.4 18.2 0.14 0.11
1Hedge Funds
HFRI Fund of Funds
6.3 6.7 9.2 0.41 0.35
Core Real Estate NCREIF Property
6.5 7.3 13.4 0.30 0.99
REITs Wilshire REIT
6.5 9.7 26.8 0.15 0.39
Inflation
2.4
1 All returns are gross of fee with the exception of hedge funds.
This year we have included both geometric and arithmetic return forecasts. It is important that users of this information understand how we derived it. Our forecast process involves the use of a wide range of data inputs (of a variety of different types) to create geometric return forecasts for individual asset classes – this is the process described at length in this document. We use an industry standard formula to convert these to arithmetic return forecasts, and provide both for client use. Investors wishing to produce expected geometric return forecasts for their portfolios should use the arithmetic return forecasts provided here as inputs into that calculation, rather than the single‐ asset‐class geometric return forecasts. This is the industry standard approach, but requires a complex explanation only a heavy quant could love, so we have chosen not to provide further details in this document – we will happily provide those details to any readers of this who are interested. More broadly, it is important that the user of these forecasts remembers that return forecasts (whoever provides them) are there to provide a guide to the likely future, no more. While we believe that the approach described in this document is an appropriate one to use for those purposes, and that the forecasts resulting from that approach are meaningful and fit for the uses to which they will be put, users of any such forecasts should always bear in mind the fact that the single most difficult thing to predict is the future, and approach that exercise with appropriate skepticism.