SLIDE 1 Traceability of a Breakthrough Food Science Technology
Russ Miller & Hilary Taylor, SCM 2018 Advisor: : Bruce Arntzen Sponsor Company: Apeel Sciences
SLIDE 2
The Team
Before MIT, Russ was a Pr Process Engineer in biotech. He has experience with FD FDA re regulations, as well as a deep Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) knowledge in the phar pharmac maceut utic ical al indus industry. Before MIT, Hilary was a su supply ch chain system ems project lead for a Canadian retailer. She has experience in bus busine iness pr process en engineer eering, change management and te technology im imple plementatio ion.
Russ Miller Hilary Taylor
SLIDE 3
Agenda
§ Introduction § Apeel’s Supply Chain § Recommendations § Q&A
SLIDE 4
Sponsor Company - Apeel Sciences
§ 45% 45% of produce is wasted due to spoilage - $750B 750B annually § Food science st start-up up § Founded in San Santa B a Bar arbar ara, a, C Cal alifornia a in 2012 2012
SLIDE 5 Apeel uses na natur ural pl plant- ba based ed tec echno hnologies es to protect crops and harvested produce, helping to el elimi mina nate e food d spo poilage e and re reduce re reliance on ch chemicals
Co Company Mission
This means we will wa waste le less food, water and energy, hel helpi ping ng to pr pres eser erve e our ur na natur ural ec ecosystems ems while creating economic
million small family farms worldwide
Co Company Purpose
In the future, less food will be wasted, we will use smarter, more natural methods for growing and protecting crops, and there will be an an ab abundan ance of f fr fresh food for everyone
Co Company Vision
Source: http://apeelsciences.com/apeel-mission.html
SLIDE 6
Introducing… EdipeelTM
TRE TREATE TED with Edipeel UN UNTREATED
SLIDE 7 EdipeelTM
§ Edible, natural, odorless, flavorless § Produced as a powder and re reconstituted with water § Mimics the protection of the plant’s natural peel § DO DOUBLES the viable shelf-life of harvested produce
Source: http://apeelsciences.com/edipeel.html
SLIDE 8 Project Purpose – Lot Traceability of Edipeel
§ Ensure Apeel’s lot traceability program is co compliant from a re regulatory sta tandpoint and sc scalable § Apeel must identify the origin & location of all Edipeel inventory - cu current and historic c - upo upon n reques equest § Cr Critical data points from production to applying Edipeel are lo logged & lin linked § Av Avocados are the current commercial Edipeel product § La Lack o
standardization for collecting and communicating data along the supply chain
SLIDE 9
§ Shifts focus from reactive to preventative § Written recall plan, re respond within 4 hours § Initiated Track ckin ing & & T Tracin cing P Pilot ilots
Regulatory Environment
§ Establish a re recall plan § Packaging requirements – include: lot #, commodity name, date/time, operator signature, supervisor review
Co Code of Federal Regulations
§ Companies must maintain a record of: “immediate previous sources and the immediate subsequent recipients of food” § One u up / on / one d down traceability
Bi Bioterrorism Preparedness & Response Act 2002 Fo Food Safety Modernizat ation Act (FS FSMA) of 2011
§ Bu Built upon one up / one down § Reportable Food Registry (RFR)
Fo Food & Drug Amendments Act of 2007
SLIDE 10
Agenda
§ Introduction § Apeel’s Supply Chain § Recommendations § Q&A
SLIDE 11 Edipeel Supply Chain
SUPPLY RAW MATERIALS & MANUFACTURING MANUFACTURING INVENTORY (APEEL) INVENTORY (CUSTOMER) RECONSTITUTION APPLICATION EDIPEELTM FINISHED GOODS INVENTORY MANAGEMENT RECONSTITUTION & APPLICATION RECEIVING SHIP TO RETAILER
SUPPLIER A SUPPLIER B COMPONENT 1 LOT #A1 CONTAINER 1 COMPONENT 2 LOT #B1 CONTAINER 1
EdipeelTM Lot #1
Sales Order 1 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg
Reconstituted Batch Data #1
SLIDE 12 Edipeel Supply Chain
SUPPLY RAW MATERIALS & MANUFACTURING MANUFACTURING INVENTORY (APEEL) INVENTORY (CUSTOMER) RECONSTITUTION APPLICATION EDIPEELTM FINISHED GOODS INVENTORY MANAGEMENT RECONSTITUTION & APPLICATION RECEIVING SHIP TO RETAILER
SUPPLIER A SUPPLIER B COMPONENT 1 LOT #A1 CONTAINER 1 COMPONENT 2 LOT #B1 CONTAINER 1
EdipeelTM Lot #1
Sales Order 1 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg
Reconstituted Batch Data #1
Apeel’s Service Model:
§ Integrate into customer pa packing ng ho hous use § Own inventory on customer’s site § Manage reconstitution and application § Inventory ti titl tle tr transfer upon applicati tion
SLIDE 13 Edipeel Supply Chain – Scenario Review
SUPPLY RAW MATERIALS & MANUFACTURING MANUFACTURING INVENTORY (APEEL) INVENTORY (CUSTOMER) RECONSTITUTION APPLICATION EDIPEELTM FINISHED GOODS INVENTORY MANAGEMENT RECONSTITUTION & APPLICATION RECEIVING SHIP TO RETAILER
SUPPLIER A SUPPLIER B COMPONENT 1 LOT #A1 CONTAINER 1 COMPONENT 1 LOT #A1 CONTAINER 2 COMPONENT 2 LOT #B1 CONTAINER 1 PO#101 PO#102 PO#201
EdipeelTM Lot #1 EdipeelTM Lot #2
Sales Order 1 Sales Order 2 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg 1kg
Reconstituted Batch Data #1 Reconstituted Batch Data #2
SLIDE 14 Key Data Elements
Treated Product
§ Lot # CCO3-AVOCAD-001 § Sales order # § Reconstitution date § Quantity § Container ID-01/02/2018 § Work Order # § Production Date § Quantity § Expiry Date
Raw Material Inventory Edipeel Inventory
Upon Receipt: § Raw Material § Supplier § Supplier Lot # § Date § Quality Inspected
Container ID-01/02/2018 Lot # CCO3-AVOCAD-001 2017-1-ABC-180301-1172
= = =
SLIDE 15 Raw Material Inventory Edipeel Inventory Treated Product
1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg
A A A B B B A
pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet
issue identified
1 identify batch data # 2 find sales order-line 3 identify Apeel Lot #
CC03-AVOCAD-001
2017-1-ABC-180301-1172
2017-1-ABC-180301-1172 2017-1-ABC-180301-1172
Recall Traceback – example
SLIDE 16 Raw Material Inventory Edipeel Inventory Treated Product
1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg
A A A B B B A
pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet
4
identify raw material container IDs used to create CC03-AVOCAD-001 A-12012016 B-11012016
A-12012016 B-11012016
CB01-AVOCAD-001
5
identify all Apeel lot #’s using A-12012016 & B-11012016 CC03-AVOCAD-001
Recall Traceback – example
SLIDE 17 Raw Material Inventory Edipeel Inventory Treated Product
A A A B B B A
pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet
6
identify all finished goods inventory of the identified lots: Warehouse In-Transit At Customer
1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg
Customer Location ABC Customer Location DCE In-transit Warehouse
CB01-AVOCAD-001 CC03-AVOCAD-001
Recall Traceback – example
SLIDE 18 Raw Material Inventory Edipeel Inventory Treated Product
A A A B B B A
pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet pallet
7
identify any additional processed batches of the identified lots:
1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg 1Kg
Customer Location ABC Customer Location DCE In-transit Warehouse
2017-1-ABC-180301-1172 2024-1-DCE-180228-1011 2024-1-DCE-180228-1012
Recall Traceback – example
SLIDE 19
Reporting Requirements
Given: Identify: Treatment Batch ID Any Additional Treatment Batch IDs All relevant Apeel Lot #s Apeel Lot # All relevant Raw Material Container IDs All relevant Treatment Batch IDs Raw Material Container ID All relevant Apeel Lot #s
SLIDE 20
Agenda
§ Introduction § Apeel’s Supply Chain § Recommendations § Q&A
SLIDE 21
§ Vertical integration – consider raw material lot tracking § Future customers – different inventory tracking processes must integrate with Apeel tracking § Future products – may require different steps § Cost of Apeel Engineer applying Edipeel
Recommendations and Considerations
§ Reporting requirements – 5 reports § Minimize manually generating batch data number when applying Edipeel § Automate inventory reconciliation after Edipeel is applied § Address limitations of current ERP system Re Recommendations Co Considerations for Operating at Scale