SIGAPS, an innovative use of bibliometrics for the IHU IHU - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
sigaps an innovative use of bibliometrics for the ihu ihu
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

SIGAPS, an innovative use of bibliometrics for the IHU IHU - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Apr 08, 2024 273 likes •607 views

Mditerrane Infection Mditerrane Infection Foundation Foundation October October 2012 2012 Gordes Gordes SIGAPS, an innovative use of bibliometrics for the IHU IHU Franois-Jrme AUBERT Deputy Director Clinical research and

slide-1
SLIDE 1

Méditerranée Infection Méditerranée Infection Foundation Foundation October October 2012 2012 Gordes Gordes

SIGAPS, an innovative use

  • f bibliometrics for the

IHU IHU

François-Jérôme AUBERT Deputy Director Clinical research and innovation Marseille Universitary Hospital (AP-HM)

slide-2
SLIDE 2

EVERYTHING IN A NUTSHELL

SIGAPS software : analyzing collective scientific

performance and informal research networks

The scientific production of the IHU: astonishing

numbers

SIGAPS-IHU Méditerranée Infection, a new

Méditerranée In

SIGAPS-IHU Méditerranée Infection, a new

approach for bibliometrics and corporate communication

An unrivalled experimentation

2

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-3
SLIDE 3

SIGAPS: ANALYZING COLLECTIVE SCIENTIFIC

PERFORMANCE AND INFORMAL NETWORKS

A software initially developped by Lille Universitary

Hospital in 2002 (CHU de Lille).

In 2006, the french Ministry for Health decided to

assess the scientific performance of french universitary hospitals with the SIGAPS software

Méditerranée In

universitary hospitals with the SIGAPS software managed by Lille Universitary Hospital.

3

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-4
SLIDE 4

SIGAPS: ANALYZING COLLECTIVE SCIENTIFIC

PERFORMANCE AND INFORMAL NETWORKS

Data bases such as Medline includes

comprehensive scientific medical production.

Pubmed provides access to abstracts, citations,

and full articles from any author.

But existing softwares do not evaluate and mapp

Méditerranée In

But existing softwares do not evaluate and mapp

research teams and fields.

The attractiveness of a world level hub for

biomedical research such as the IHU has to be shown through specific criteria:

Critical mass Proportion of top level publications Most effective collaborations

4

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-5
SLIDE 5

SIGAPS: ANALYZING COLLECTIVE SCIENTIFIC

PERFORMANCE AND INFORMAL NETWORKS

SIGAPS means « Système d’Interrogation, de

Gestion et d’Analyse des Publications Scientifiques ».

SIGAPS gives a survey of the research fields of a

research team, as well as of its standard.

Méditerranée In

research team, as well as of its standard.

A software to : List Analyse Aggregate Value

5

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-6
SLIDE 6

SIGAPS: ANALYZING COLLECTIVE SCIENTIFIC

PERFORMANCE AND INFORMAL NETWORKS

SIGAPS synthesizes scientific production, wether

  • n an individual or a collective viewpoint.

SIGAPS shows qualitative valuation: Journal ranking Author’s position

Méditerranée In

Author’s position Research fields (keywords) Most effective collaborations

6

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-7
SLIDE 7

Méditerranée In

SIGAPS

Recenser Télécharger Analyser Visualiser Agréger Évaluer Navigateur Web 7

Infection Foundation/Gordes

Impact Factor Categorie Couleur IF > P90 A Q3 < IF < P90 B MED < IF < Q3 C Q1 < IF < MED D IF < Q1 E Inconnu NC

+

Agréger Évaluer Hôpital Pôle

A B C D E

Service

A B C D E

Service Service Pôle

slide-8
SLIDE 8

A SIX LEVEL RANKING BASED ON THE IMPACT

FACTOR

Méditerranée In

Max Q3 P90

A B

  • Problem: the IF strongly varies

according to the research fields: – Medical computer science, 0.513 à 3.59 (medium=1.65) – Cellular biology , 0.24 à 31.35 (medium =3.18)

  • Statistic classification by research fields,

8

Infection Foundation/Gordes

Min Médiane Q1 +

C D E N C

Not classified by Institute for Scientific Information

  • Statistic classification by research fields,

5 categories (A/B/C/D/E) corresponding to percentiles of the IF.

  • Non registered reviews (congress acts,

for instance ), belong to the NC category.

Each medical discipline has 10% journals in A level, 15% in B, 25% in C, …

slide-9
SLIDE 9

SIGAPS, A SOFTWARE INITIALLY DEVELOPPED TO

ASSESS THE SCIENTIFIC PERFORMANCE OF FRENCH UNIVERSITARY HOSPITALS

Medline data base Quotation criteria: Author’s position

1st or last author :

4 points

2nd author:

3 points

Méditerranée In

2

author: 3 points

3rd author:

2 points

Other position:

1 point

Journal level

Top 10% of a discipline:

8 points

… Not classified:

1 point

Multiplication of both scores: 1st author for an article

published in Lancet Infectious Disease (A level journal): 4x8 = 32 points

9

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-10
SLIDE 10

SIGAPS, A SOFTWARE INITIALLY DEVELOPPED TO

ASSESS THE SCIENTIFIC PERFORMANCE OF FRENCH UNIVERSITARY HOSPITALS

SIGAPS score allows an allocation for universitary

hospitals from the french ministry for health:

SIGAPS point = 1 600 € 32 points article = 51 200 €

Méditerranée In

10

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-11
SLIDE 11

THE SCIENTIFIC PRODUCTION OF THE IHU

ESTIMATED BY SIGAPS : SURPRISING NUMBERS

2011: 588 papers

Méditerranée In

11

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-12
SLIDE 12

THE SCIENTIFIC PRODUCTION OF THE IHU

ESTIMATED BY SIGAPS : SURPRISING NUMBERS

Méditerranée In

12

Infection Foundation/Gordes

Caution: Universitary Hospitals’ production is estimated with Medline Database, and the IHU’s with World of Science, which is slightly more exhaustive. This ranking is an approximation.

slide-13
SLIDE 13

NOT GOOD SCIENCE, BREAKTHROUGH (2/3

ARTICLES IN TOP 25% JOURNALS).

Méditerranée In

13

Infection Foundation/Gordes

On the 2007-2010 era, the proportion of A+B articles of current IHU researchers was over 55%. On the same period, it was between 35% and 45% in the french universitary hospitals.

slide-14
SLIDE 14

IHU MÉDITERRANÉE INFECTION, A TOP

LEADER FOR SCIENTIFIC PRODUCTION IN I.D.

Pr Didier RAOULT, a world top gun (top 3 in terms

  • f citations in the microbiology literature)

A performing team in every field of infectiology Top level universitary hospitals units:

Over 1000 publications/year (18% AP-HM)

Méditerranée In

Over 1000 publications/year (18% AP-HM) 20% A level publications (top 10%)

14

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-15
SLIDE 15

IHU RESEARCHERS: A GROWING SCIENTIFIC

PRODUCTION

Méditerranée In

15

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-16
SLIDE 16

AUTHOR’S POSITION : EVIDENCE OF

LEADERSHIP

Méditerranée In

16

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-17
SLIDE 17

A WIDE MAJORITY OF HIGH LEVEL JOURNALS (2002-2011)

Méditerranée In

17

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-18
SLIDE 18

VISIBLE IMPROVEMENT

Méditerranée In

18

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-19
SLIDE 19

MOST COMMON JOURNALS

Méditerranée In

  • !"

# $$ #%& $

19

Infection Foundation/Gordes

'()'* + # ,

  • ,

'&*

  • "

*

  • '*
  • #
  • ,

'

  • .

('*/' ! $ # $ '#0*12 " * " ''&& + #'&&

slide-20
SLIDE 20

KEYWORDS (MESH TERMS YET TO COME)

Méditerranée In

324*

  • 20

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-21
SLIDE 21

AN EXEMPLE: PR RAOULT (YEAR 2011)

Méditerranée In

21

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-22
SLIDE 22

74% ARTICLES IN TOP 25% JOURNALS

Méditerranée In

22

Infection Foundation/Gordes

Pr RAOULT

slide-23
SLIDE 23

TOP 20 JOURNALS

Méditerranée In

  • #'&&

+

  • #
  • ('*/'
  • 23

Infection Foundation/Gordes

(0 , '0* , ' , # , , #'' , 56%7 , % , 0*1&

  • (4
  • #
  • **
  • Pr RAOULT
slide-24
SLIDE 24

MOST COMMON COLLABORATIONS

Méditerranée In

'

  • !"#$
  • %#&'&(!
  • " $ ))#

. * $ *#('&(+ $ , "

  • +

#((#+-.&(+ +

  • +

24

Infection Foundation/Gordes

  • +

, + $-(#'!#

  • ,
  • &//" #.
  • (&'!0
  • %,
  • "( 1/#$$#
  • *
  • *
  • Pr RAOULT
slide-25
SLIDE 25

KEYWORDS

Méditerranée In

324*

  • 2
  • *
  • 25

Infection Foundation/Gordes

*,

  • *
  • *
  • Pr RAOULT
slide-26
SLIDE 26

Méditerranée In

  • 26

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-27
SLIDE 27

SIGAPS-IHU MÉDITERRANÉE INFECTION, A NEW

APPROACH FOR BIBLIOMETRICS AND CORPORATE COMMUNICATION

An upgraded SIGAPS for the IHU Transparency and open data

Méditerranée In

27

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-28
SLIDE 28

AN UPGRADED SIGAPS FOR THE IHU

Additional tools for the IHU: Citation index H factor A more comprehensive data base: World of Science

Méditerranée In

28

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-29
SLIDE 29

CITATION INDEX

Méditerranée In

29

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-30
SLIDE 30

H FACTOR: 95

Méditerranée In

8* 9 ,.., 6 ,. (* ( * ( 2* : ; ( 8** ; <&

30

Infection Foundation/Gordes

* :

  • ;

8**

  • ;

<&

  • 22

3

slide-31
SLIDE 31

TRANSPARENCY AND OPEN DATA

IHU Méditerranée Infection, first non universitary

hospital user of SIGAPS

Tester for the others IHU A crisscross logic : SIGAPS as a communication

tool

Méditerranée In

tool

31

Infection Foundation/Gordes

slide-32
SLIDE 32

TRANSPARENCY AND OPEN DATA

SIGAPS data are to be published ont the

Foundation’s website.

SIGAPS as a communication tool : Let reseachers have a look at IHU’s overview Let potential sponsors know the IHU’s impressive

Méditerranée In

Let potential sponsors know the IHU’s impressive

numbers A new management for bibliometrics.

32

Infection Foundation/Gordes