Leptogenesis Koichi Hamaguchi (University of Tokyo) Revealing the - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

leptogenesis
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Leptogenesis Koichi Hamaguchi (University of Tokyo) Revealing the - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Leptogenesis Koichi Hamaguchi (University of Tokyo) Revealing the history of the universe with underground particle and nuclear research 2019 @ Tohoku Univ., March. 7, 2019. Mostly review See the poster by + partially based on Shih-Yen Tseng K.


slide-1
SLIDE 1

Leptogenesis

Koichi Hamaguchi (University of Tokyo)

Revealing the history of the universe with underground particle and nuclear research 2019 @ Tohoku Univ., March. 7, 2019. Mostly review

+ partially based on

  • K. Asai, KH, N. Nagata, S. Tseng, K. Tsumura, [arXiv:1811.07571]
  • K. Asai, KH, N. Nagata, [arXiv:1705.00419]

See the poster by Shih-Yen Tseng tomorrow!

slide-2
SLIDE 2

2

Plan

Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe Why ``Lepto”genesis? Right-handed Neutrino’ s triple role Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

Summary

slide-3
SLIDE 3

2

Plan

Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe Why ``Lepto”genesis? Right-handed Neutrino’ s triple role Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

Summary

slide-4
SLIDE 4

http://pdg.ge.infn.it/particleadventure/frameless/chart_cutouts/universe_original.pdf

In the very early Universe,.... 0.000001 sec

380,000 yrs 1.4x1010 yrs 1 sec

slide-5
SLIDE 5

matter antimatter In the very early Universe,....

The number of particles and anti-particles were almost the same.

slide-6
SLIDE 6

matter antimatter In the very early Universe,....

The number of particles and anti-particles were almost the same. O(10-9)

But there was tiny excess of matter over anti-matter.

slide-7
SLIDE 7

O(10-9)

When the Universe got cooler, they pair-annihilated,..

In the very early Universe,....

The number of particles and anti-particles were almost the same.

matter antimatter

slide-8
SLIDE 8

O(10-9)

When the Universe got cooler, they pair-annihilated,..

matter - antimatter annihilation

γ γ

In the very early Universe,....

The number of particles and anti-particles were almost the same.

matter antimatter

slide-9
SLIDE 9

O(10-9)

When the Universe got cooler, they pair-annihilated,..

In the very early Universe,....

The number of particles and anti-particles were almost the same.

matter antimatter

slide-10
SLIDE 10
  • nly matter remains

(no antimatter)

All of us(Galaxy, the Earth, the human beings,...) are made from this leftover matter.

When the Universe got cooler, they pair-annihilated,..

In the very early Universe,....

The number of particles and anti-particles were almost the same.

slide-11
SLIDE 11

Puzzle

How was the initial excess of matter created ?

O(10-9)

matter antimatter

slide-12
SLIDE 12

Puzzle

How was the initial excess of matter created ?

O(10-9)

matter antimatter

Something beyond the Standard Model is necessary.

slide-13
SLIDE 13

8

[Planck 2015]

(2) Cosmic Microwave background (cosmic time about 400,000 yrs)

(68%)

Observations (two independent evidences)

(1) Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) (cosmic time about 1 sec)

[Particle Data Group]

  • 24. Big-Bang nucleosynthesis
3 Figure 24.1: The primordial abundances of 4He, D, 3He, and 7Li as predicted by the standard model of Big-Bang nucleosynthesis—the bands show the 95% CL range [5]. Boxes indicate the observed light element abundances. The narrow vertical band indicates the CMB measure of the cosmic baryon density, while the wider band indicates the BBN concordance range (both at 95% CL). October 18, 2016 13:34

He4 D Li7

slide-14
SLIDE 14

9

time temperature ?? ?? Inflation

TR Reheating

100 GeV Electroweak phase transition 1 GeV QCD phase transition 1 MeV Big Bang Nucleosynthesis

1 sec 400,000 yrs 3000 K Last Scattering Surface 14 billion yrs 3 K Now

  • 24. Big-Bang nucleosynthesis
3 Figure 24.1: The primordial abundances of 4He, D, 3He, and 7Li as predicted by the standard model of Big-Bang nucleosynthesis—the bands show the 95% CL range [5]. Boxes indicate the observed light element abundances. The narrow vertical band indicates the CMB measure of the cosmic baryon density, while the wider band indicates the BBN concordance range (both at 95% CL). October 18, 2016 13:34

sometime in this range

When was the Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe generated?

CMB

slide-15
SLIDE 15

10

Plan

Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe Why ``Lepto”genesis? Right-handed Neutrino’ s triple role Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

Summary

slide-16
SLIDE 16

11

Why ``Lepto”genesis? Within the Standard Model,…

Both Baryon # (B) and Lepton # (L) are conserved at classical level. However, B and L are violated at quantum level! [’

t Hooft,’76]

Note: B-L is conserved Although there is essentially no effect at low energy,…

∂µJµ

B = ∂µJµ L = 0

@µJµ

B = @µJµ L = Nf

g2

2

32⇡2 ✏µνρσTrF µνF ρσ Γ /

B,/ L ∼ e−16π2/g2

2 ∼ 10−170

∂µ(Jµ

B − Jµ L) = 0

6= 0

<latexit sha1_base64="s1+uKM9Mlgh8oPmvonEvfK8vjY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="s1+uKM9Mlgh8oPmvonEvfK8vjY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="s1+uKM9Mlgh8oPmvonEvfK8vjY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="s1+uKM9Mlgh8oPmvonEvfK8vjY=">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</latexit>
slide-17
SLIDE 17

12

Why ``Lepto”genesis?

[fig. from W.Buchmuller, 1210.7758]

Sphaleron process

processes involving 9 quarks (B=3) and 3 leptons (L=3). Note that B-L is conserved.

Within the Standard Model,…

At high temperature, T >> 100 GeV , B and L violating processes (sphaleron) become very rapid, and in thermal equilibrium!

[Kuzmin, Rubakov, Shaposhnikov,ʼ85]

slide-18
SLIDE 18

13

Therefore, if the Baryon asymmetry is generated via a B-L conserving process,… B=100 L=100 B=0 L=0

e.g, GUT baryogenesis

slide-19
SLIDE 19

14

B=100 L=100 B=0 L=0 B=0 L=0

sphaleron process

Finally B=0 at equilibrium. Therefore, if the Baryon asymmetry is generated via a B-L conserving process,…

e.g, GUT baryogenesis

slide-20
SLIDE 20

14

B=100 L=100 B=0 L=0 B=0 L=0

sphaleron process

Finally B=0 at equilibrium.

B-L violating process is necessary.

Therefore, if the Baryon asymmetry is generated via a B-L conserving process,…

e.g, GUT baryogenesis

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Sakharov’ s 3 conditions

・Baryon number (B) violation ・C and CP violation ・Out-of-equilibrium

15

B-L violation

slide-22
SLIDE 22

Sakharov’ s 3 conditions

・Baryon number (B) violation ・C and CP violation ・Out-of-equilibrium

15

B-L violation

Baryogenesis can work, not only via B-violation, but also via L-violation. and L-violation implies,… Majorana neutrino, and 0νββ decay!!

slide-23
SLIDE 23

16

B=0 L=-100 B=0 L=0

Lepgogenesis [Fukugita, Yanagida, ʼ86]

generate Lepton asymmetry

N

e

e

  • N

h h

right-handed neutrino decay (CP-violating)

slide-24
SLIDE 24

17

B=0 L=-100 B=0 L=0

Lepgogenesis [Fukugita, Yanagida, ʼ86]

generate Lepton asymmetry

N

e

e

  • N

h h

right-handed neutrino decay (CP-violating)

B=35 L=-65

sphaleron process Then, B≠0 remains at equilibrium!

slide-25
SLIDE 25

18

Plan

Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe Why ``Lepto”genesis? Right-handed Neutrino’ s triple role Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

Summary

slide-26
SLIDE 26

Just by adding (2 or) 3 heavy right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model,…

Higgs RH neutrino L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

Right-handed Neutrino’s triple role

New Physics

slide-27
SLIDE 27

Just by adding (2 or) 3 heavy right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model,…

Higgs RH neutrino L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

(3) Leptogenesis (1) small neutrino masses (2) matter unification in 16 of SO(10)

Right-handed Neutrino’s triple role

New Physics

slide-28
SLIDE 28

Just by adding (2 or) 3 heavy right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model,…

Right-handed Neutrino’s triple role

Higgs RH neutrino L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

(3) Leptogenesis (1) small neutrino masses (2) matter unification in 16 of SO(10)

νL

Higgs

NR

Higgs

NR νL

Right-handed Neutrino mass

New Physics

slide-29
SLIDE 29

New Physics

Higgs RH neutrino L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

(3) Leptogenesis (1) small neutrino masses (2) matter unification in 16 of SO(10) Just by adding (2 or) 3 heavy right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model,…

Right-handed Neutrino’s triple role

(1,1)+1

U

( )R

d

( )R

e

νe

( )L

U

d

( )L

(3,2)+1/6 (3,1)-2/3 (3,1)+1/3 (1,2)-1/2

  • e

( )R

(1,1)+1

N

(1,1)0

+

U

d

( L R R L R R)

e

U

e

νe

d

N1

16

=

(↑↓ ↓↓↑) (↑↓ ↓↑↓) (↑↓ ↑↓↓) (↓↑ ↓↓↑) (↓↑ ↓↑↓) (↓↑ ↑↓↓) (↑↑ ↑↑↓) (↑↑ ↑↓↑) (↑↑ ↓↑↑) (↓↓ ↑↑↓) (↓↓ ↑↓↑) (↓↓ ↓↑↑) (↑↓ ↑↑↑) (↓↑ ↑↑↑) (↑↑ ↓↓↓) (↓↓ ↓↓↓)

=

SM quarks and leptons RHν

slide-30
SLIDE 30

New Physics

Higgs R.H.neutrino L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

(3) Leptogenesis (1) small neutrino masses (2) matter unification in 16 of SO(10)

N

e

e

  • N

h h

matter > anti-matter

Just by adding (2 or) 3 heavy right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model,…

Right-handed Neutrino’s triple role

slide-31
SLIDE 31

Just by adding (2 or) 3 heavy right-handed neutrinos to the Standard Model,…

Higgs RH neutrino L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

(3) Leptogenesis (1) small neutrino masses (2) matter unification in 16 of SO(10)

Right-handed Neutrino’s triple role

New Physics

slide-32
SLIDE 32

24

Plan

Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe Why ``Lepto”genesis? Right-handed Neutrino’ s triple role Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

Summary

slide-33
SLIDE 33
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • via neutrino oscillation (with the LHLH operators)

[…, Hamada, Kitano, Yin ,’18……]

  • Leptogenesis from Inflaton Decay

[…… Kumekawa, Moroi, Yanagida,’94,… Asaka, KH, Kawasaki, Yanagida,’99……]

  • Leptogenesis from RH-Sneutrino dominated Universe

[Murayama, Yanagida,’93, …… KH, Murayama, Yanagida,’01……] [Murayama, Suzuki, Yanagida, Yokoyama,’93,… … ]

  • Affleck-Dine Leptogenesis

[Murayama, Yanagida,’93, …… Asaka, Fujii, KH, Yanagida,’00, Fujii, KH, Yanagida,’01, ……]

+ many others …

Various Leptogenesis scenarios All of them require L-number violation, and predict 0νββ decay!!

Exception: “Dirac leptogenesis”. [Dick, Lindner, Ratz, Wright, 99, Murayama, Pierce, 02]

slide-34
SLIDE 34

26

Model: Standard Model + RH𝜉 Cosmology: Standard thermal cosmology

Extremely simple! No complicated model/cosmology required.

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

L = LSM + 1 2NR(i/ @ + MR)NR + yνNR`LH + h.c.

slide-35
SLIDE 35

27

scenario

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-36
SLIDE 36

28

step 1: T > MR : are in thermal bath.

temperature RH𝜉’ s mass

N1

scenario

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-37
SLIDE 37

29

step 1: T > MR : are in thermal bath. step 2: T ∼ MR : decay. (CP violation + out-of-eq.)

  • -> generate Lepton asymmetry, ΔL ≠ 0.

temperature RH𝜉’ s mass

N1 N1

scenario

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-38
SLIDE 38

29

step 1: T > MR : are in thermal bath. step 2: T ∼ MR : decay. (CP violation + out-of-eq.)

  • -> generate Lepton asymmetry, ΔL ≠ 0.

temperature RH𝜉’ s mass

N1 N1 N

e

e

  • N

h h

CP violation is essential. scenario

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-39
SLIDE 39

sphaleron process 30

step 1: T > MR : are in thermal bath. step 2: T ∼ MR : decay. (CP violation + out-of-eq.)

  • -> generate Lepton asymmetry, ΔL ≠ 0.

step 3: Lepton asymmetry Baryon asymmetry

ΔL ≠ 0 ---> ΔB ≠ 0

temperature RH𝜉’ s mass

N1 N1

scenario

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-40
SLIDE 40

31

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-41
SLIDE 41

31

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-42
SLIDE 42

31

final baryon asymmetry

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-43
SLIDE 43

31

RH𝜉’ s mass final baryon asymmetry

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-44
SLIDE 44

31

RH𝜉’ s mass final baryon asymmetry heaviest neutrino mass (~ atmospheric)

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-45
SLIDE 45

31

RH𝜉’ s mass final baryon asymmetry heaviest neutrino mass (~ atmospheric) wash-out factor (< 1)

(calculable: by Boltzmann eq.)

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-46
SLIDE 46

31

RH𝜉’ s mass final baryon asymmetry heaviest neutrino mass (~ atmospheric) wash-out factor (< 1)

(calculable: by Boltzmann eq.)

effective CP violating phase

< 1

Yukawa

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-47
SLIDE 47

31

RH𝜉’ s mass final baryon asymmetry heaviest neutrino mass (~ atmospheric) wash-out factor (< 1)

(calculable: by Boltzmann eq.)

effective CP violating phase

< 1

Yukawa

Predictable / Calculable in terms of [SM + RH𝜉] Lagrangian !

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-48
SLIDE 48

32

RH𝜉’ s mass final baryon asymmetry heaviest neutrino mass (~ atmospheric) wash-out factor (< 1)

(calculable: by Boltzmann eq.)

effective CP violating phase

(observed) = (0.88 ± 0.02) x 10-10

It works !! (for MR > 109-1010 GeV).

  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Result: (* the simplest case. flavor effect omitted.

for more recent progresses, See e.g., arXiv:1711.02861~ 1711.02866.)

slide-49
SLIDE 49
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-50
SLIDE 50
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • Nearly degenerate, light RH𝜉 with small Yukawa.

(e.g., M2,3 ∼ GeV , 𝛦M = M3 - M2 ∼ keV , Yukawa ∼ 10-7).

  • RH𝜉 oscillation generates lepton asymmetry for both the active and

sterile sectors. (* Lepton number is generalized, and RH𝜉s also have L-number.)

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

  • Fig. from S. Eijima’

s seminar (Tokyo, U. 2019)

slide-51
SLIDE 51
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • Nearly degenerate, light RH𝜉 with small Yukawa.

(e.g., M2,3 ∼ GeV , 𝛦M = M3 - M2 ∼ keV , Yukawa ∼ 10-7).

  • RH𝜉 oscillation generates lepton asymmetry for both the active and

sterile sectors. (* Lepton number is generalized, and RH𝜉s also have L-number.)

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

  • Fig. from S. Eijima’

s seminar (Tokyo, U. 2019)

∆B ' 0.35 ∆L

<latexit sha1_base64="rIvIEXchjtLdKAtWBd/AHMvKdk=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="rIvIEXchjtLdKAtWBd/AHMvKdk=">AC/nichVE7TxRFP4YREfrNqY0EzcrLFxc0YlG0IQkJhwcMFEoZsZmYPcMO8nLm7ASebWPsHKw0kcQY2tvY0thgf4CY4mJDYVnZicqktUzmXvP4/vO/e49buyrVBMdDBinTg+eOTt0bvj8hYuXRiqXrymUTvxuOFfpQsu07Kvgq5oZX2eTlO2Alcn5fczYd5fanDSaqi8LHejnk1cNZDtaY8R0uqWZm2NW/pok8mJQ61083sKfa1Y052TtVAT8xb1H9zpj94A9swq1fuEfdZqVKdSrMPOlYpVNFabNRZR82WojgoY0AjBafB8OUvlWYIEQS24VmeQS8VRZ3QxLNy2oFgQjmQ3ZV2XaKXMhLnPdOC7ckpvyJME3U6BO9oUP6SHv0lY769sqKHrmWbdndHpfj5sjzaws/sKZNfY+M36p2aNdwrtCrRHheZ/BZej95unO4cH+lt2gV/RN9L+kA/ogNwg7373Xcz/QrX+iraOvYC/ZWn5etvSNTKkTJU6+8RnQWb9ctqltzd6sTk+V4hzCK67gpMxzHBGYwi4actId9fMYX45mxa7w13vWgxkDJuYpjZrz/CVLKt80=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="rIvIEXchjtLdKAtWBd/AHMvKdk=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="rIvIEXchjtLdKAtWBd/AHMvKdk=">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</latexit>
slide-52
SLIDE 52
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • Nearly degenerate, light RH𝜉 with small Yukawa

(e.g., M2,3 ∼ GeV , 𝛦M = M3 - M2 ∼ keV , Yukawa ∼ 10-7).

  • RH𝜉 oscillation generates lepton asymmetry for both the active and

sterile sectors. (* Lepton number is generalized, and RH𝜉s also have L-number.)

  • Target of various experiments.

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

  • Fig. from 1609.09069, M.Drewes et.al.

(* maybe updated more recently)

slide-53
SLIDE 53
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

slide-54
SLIDE 54
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • via neutrino oscillation (with the LHLH operators)

[…, Hamada, Kitano, Yin ,’18……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Manga by HiggsTan(ひっぐすたん) http://higgstan.com/

slide-55
SLIDE 55
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • via neutrino oscillation (with the LHLH operators)

[…, Hamada, Kitano, Yin ,’18……]

Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Manga by HiggsTan(ひっぐすたん) http://higgstan.com/

Ask Yin-kun for details !

slide-56
SLIDE 56
  • Thermal Leptogenesis

[Fukugita, Yanagida,’86, …… Buchmuller, Plumacher, Di Bari,……]

  • via RH𝜉 oscillation (𝜉MSM)

[Akhmedov, Rubakov, Smirnov,’98, Asaka, Shasposhnikov,’05……]

  • via neutrino oscillation (with the LHLH operators)

[…, Hamada, Kitano, Yin ,’18……]

  • Leptogenesis from Inflaton Decay

[…… Kumekawa, Moroi, Yanagida,’94,… Asaka, KH, Kawasaki, Yanagida,’99……]

  • Leptogenesis from RH-Sneutrino dominated Universe

[Murayama, Yanagida,’93, …… KH, Murayama, Yanagida,’01……] [Murayama, Suzuki, Yanagida, Yokoyama,’93,… … ]

  • Affleck-Dine Leptogenesis

[Murayama, Yanagida,’93, …… Asaka, Fujii, KH, Yanagida,’00, Fujii, KH, Yanagida,’01, ……]

+ many others …

Various Leptogenesis scenarios All of them require L-number violation, and predict 0νββ decay!!

Exception: “Dirac leptogenesis”. [Dick, Lindner, Ratz, Wright, 99, Murayama, Pierce, 02]

slide-57
SLIDE 57

39

Plan

Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe Why ``Lepto”genesis? Right-handed Neutrino’ s triple role Various Leptogenesis scenarios

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

Summary

slide-58
SLIDE 58
  • gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ (α= e, 𝜈, 𝜐) models: anomaly-free gauge extension of the SM.
  • U(1)𝜈-𝜐 may explain muon g-2 anomaly.
  • In minimal models (with just one scalar, either singlet or SU2 doublet)

neutrino mass matrix is constrained -> predictions!. In particular,

40

Predictions of minimal gauged U(1)Lα-Lβ models

  • K. Asai, KH, N. Nagata, [arXiv:1705.00419]
  • K. Asai, KH, N. Nagata, S. Tseng, K. Tsumura, [arXiv:1811.07571]
  • K. Asai, KH, N. Nagata, S. Tseng, + more [work in progress]

For more details, see the poster by Shih-Yen Tseng tomorrow!

  • Interestingly, it also predicts

the sign of the baryon asymmetry in the Universe!

slide-59
SLIDE 59

Summary

  • The Baryon Asymmetry of the Universe = one of the evidences of BSM.
  • Leptogenesis can naturally explain it.
  • Right-handed neutrino (with large Majorana mass) plays a triple role.

(1). Small neutrino masses. (seesaw) (2). Unification of all quarks and leptons. (16 rep. of SO(10).) (3). Leptogenesis. (matter-antimatter asymmetry) … and it predicts 0νββ decay !!

  • There are various kinds of Leptogenesis. (Most of them predict 0νββ decay.)
  • 0νββ decay will also test various other new particle physics models

(e.g., gauged U(1)μ-τ model).

41