LEADING BY GOING THE DISTANCE
Se ssio n 3: Ac c o unta b ility – Giving F e e db a c k
De c e mb e r 19, 2017 Sta rb o a rd L e a de rship Co nsulting L a ura Mitc he ll lm@ sta rb o a rdle a de rship.c o m
LEADING BY GOING THE DISTANCE Se ssio n 3: Ac c o unta b ility - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
LEADING BY GOING THE DISTANCE Se ssio n 3: Ac c o unta b ility Giving F e e db a c k De c e mb e r 19, 2017 Sta rb o a rd L e a de rship Co nsulting L a ura Mitc he ll lm@ sta rb o a rdle a de rship.c o m EFFECTIVE MANAGEMENT Tasks
Se ssio n 3: Ac c o unta b ility – Giving F e e db a c k
De c e mb e r 19, 2017 Sta rb o a rd L e a de rship Co nsulting L a ura Mitc he ll lm@ sta rb o a rdle a de rship.c o m
Tasks
roles/responsibilities
environments
effective teams
up
Goals
employee has to offer
loyalty
excitement for the work and results of the company
Low Bar High Bar
Low bar = the minimum threshold for acceptable behavior (below which employment termination is an easy decision) High Bar = the behavioral expectations you collectively agree on are critical to being smart and healthy This gap = your culture differentiator and the source of most managerial challenges
Se ve n pie c e s o f info rma tio n ma tte r
Co nsiste nt Ac c o unta b ility & F e e db a c k
Making str ate gic choice s habitually to talk about uncomfor table topics with anothe r pe r son to he lp the m be come mor e succe ssful and str e ngthe n your r e lationship.
WARM UP: HOLD THIS PERSON IN YOUR MIND
Pe rha ps this is so me o ne :
hig hly e mo tio na l o r de fe nsive
issue s
a sso c ia te d with he r po sitio n to o the rs
pe rfo rma nc e – a fte r a ll, the y mig ht le a ve in a ye a r
T hink o f a n e mplo ye e yo u ha ve fo und c ha lle ng ing to c o a c h o r pro vide fe e db a c k to – a pe rso n who m yo u ha ve a vo ide d de a ling with a t time s.
Se lf Asse ssme nt Wha t a re yo ur na tura l c o nflic t te nde nc ie s?
histo ry o f ha b it…
wo rkpla c e s…
What other factors have shaped your approach to conflict?
hinking a b o ut yo ur pa st, we re yo u a lwa ys mo re o f a fig hte r? Or did yo u te nd to a c c o mmo da te
e a rly in yo ur life a nd c a re e r—we re yo u re wa rde d
pit in yo ur sto ma c h a nd fe e l like fle e ing ? Or do e s yo u he a rt ra c e a nd yo u fe e l the urg e to jump in?
he la st time te nsio n wa s hig h with so me o ne a t wo rk o r a t ho me , ho w did yo u re a c t?
Positive Feedback
learning and growth Developmental Feedback
learning and growth
Corrective Feedback
learning and growth Informal Warning
employees – they are not where they need to be; there are serious gaps
Natural Consequences
The Start of Progressive Discipline This is a Bottom -Line Conversation!
Most m anagers need to focus m ore here!
– Re c o g nize s whe n a n e mplo ye e is do ing
we ll
uc tive) feedbac k
– Sha re s wa ys a g o o d e mplo ye e c o uld do
e ve n b e tte r
r ec tive feedbac k
– Co nve ys thing s tha t must c ha ng e in o rde r
fo r the e mplo ye e to me e t yo ur e xpe c ta tio ns
WONDERFUL THINGS TO SAY OFTEN
re ally value yo ur input.”
re ally appreciate yo ur wo rk o n this pro je c t!”
…but not examples of effec tive positive feedbac k!
rhe to ric ally)
do n’t kno w why we ’re ge tting this info rmatio n just be fo re the me e ting, but I gue ss we ’ll have to go ahe ad and talk abo ut it.”
in yo ur time she e ts pro mptly and le ave the building c le an.”
…and also not examples of effec tive feedbac k
is a nd wha t yo u wa nt to sa y.
f yo u’ re fuzzy a b o ut wha t the re a l issue is a nd/ o r ho w to a ddre ss it, ta lk to a c o lle a g ue .
a mo unt o f he a ds-up.
e nviro nme nt a s c o mfo rta b le a s po ssib le .
WI T H COL L E AGUE S
a sk re la te d
ro o te d
WI T H COL L E AGUE S
a sk re la te d
ro o te d
WI T H E MPL OYE E S
re la te d WI T H E MPL OYE E S
re la te d Wha t type o f issue is it?
WHAT TYPE OF FEEDBACK DOES YOUR EMPLOYEE NEED?
Behaviors HIGH LOW HIGH Job Competence
How the employee conducts him/herself. Behaviors can include interpersonal skills, teamwork and collaboration, commitment, motivation, tone, approach, and other defined
Job competence represents work results, the ability of the employee to accomplish his/her responsibilities and meet goals, which requires possessing the requisite skills.
Positive feedback plus stretch assignments Developmental
feedback focused on behavior Developmental
feedback focused on job competence plus skills training Corrective feedback plus a structured plan for improving quickly
g o o d a nd mo tiva te the m, b ut o fte n it do e s just the
mployees don’t tr ust the pr
sho e dro p?
mployees r esent it. Ma na g e rs o fte n use po sitive
fe e db a c k to o ve rc o me re sista nc e to re q ue sts.
aise the wr
mind set
eally pr aise anything: “Gre a t jo b ” so unds
like no ise a fte r a while .
Po sitive fe e db a c k is hig hly spe c ific info rma tio n de live re d in suc h a ma nne r to a c c e le ra te e mplo ye e le a rning a nd g ro wth.
T he most under utilized tool for ac c eler ating employee lear ning and gr
de ntify o ne e mplo ye e who wo rks fo r yo u who wo uld b e ne fit fro m he a ring dire c tly a nd spe c ific a lly fro m yo u a b o ut so me thing yo u o b se rve the y a re do ing re a lly we ll.
wha t yo u will sa y to the m.
e a c h o f yo u wa nts to de live r.
yo u he a r o ne a no the r sa ying .
Before you say anything
mo st a t this time .
– Wha t pe rfo rma nc e o r b e ha vio r g a p sho uld yo u
re a lly a ddre ss?
– Ho w do yo u unb undle a b unc h o f e le me nts a nd
de c ide wha t to a ddre ss?
The first step is all in your head!
he fir
st time so me thing ha ppe ns (o r yo u
a re a ddre ssing it), de a l with the sing le e ve nt – the he re a nd no w.
ha ve a histo ry. F
r equent and c ontinued violations o f
e xpe c ta tio ns a ffe c t the e mplo ye e ’ s pre dic ta b ility a nd e ve ntua lly ha rm re spe c t a nd trust.
he e mplo ye e ha s r
epeatedly br
tha t ha s c a use d yo u to lo se trust in the m.
CPR helps identify the issue you need to address
BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING: PERFORM CPR
Ma na g e rs g o o d a t a c c o unta b ility c o nve rsa tio ns do n't disc uss re pe a te d infra c tio ns a s if e a c h suc c e ssive o ne wa s the first o ne .
1st time late = she 's la te = Co nte nt 2nd time late= fa ile d to live up to a pro mise = Pa tte rn 3r
d time late = ma y ha ve re la tio nship issue a nd he a d
to HR a nd disc ipline = Re la tio nship
BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING: PERFORM CPR
– I
f pr
essur ed by time and hyped up emotions, we
c a n miss the re a l pro b le m a nd sta y o n Co nte nt.
– What is bother
ing you (or your team) the most?
– I
f yo u do n’ t, yo u’ ll like ly a ddre ss the wro ng ta rg e t
– Distill the issue to a single sentenc e.
EXPAND THE OPTIONS AFTER CPR BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING
xpa nd the po ssib le list o f issue s b y c onsider
ing the c onsequenc es and the employee’s intentions.
– Wha t a re the c o nse q ue nc e s to me ? – T
– T
– T
you most want for an outc omes fo r yo u, fo r o the rs,
fo r the re la tio nship.
EXAMPLE: CPR AND CONSEQUENCES
I ma g ine yo u ha ve a sta ff spe c ia list who pro mise d to ha ve he r fina nc ia l a na lysis to yo u b y T ue sda y, no o n. She misc a lc ula te s ho w lo ng it will ta ke he r a nd de live rs it to yo u just b e fo re da y’ s e nd o n We dne sda y. Be ing la te is no t ne c e ssa rily the pro b le m e xc e pt tha t the a na lysis wa s due to g o o ut in the Bo a rd Me e ting pa c ke t ma ile d la te T ue sda y a fte rno o n to the a g e nc y’ s Bo a rd. You’r
e wor r ied that having to send along the financ ial analysis separ ately (and late) will make your depar tment and senior leader ship look bad. I
t’ s a lso the third time tha t she ha s le t yo u do wn and you’r
e beginning to wonder whether you c an c ount on her . Per haps you’ll now have to super vise her mor e c losely to make sur e she stays on tr ac k o f he r
a ssig nme nts a nd de a dline s. T
his will c ost you pr ec ious time and will likely make her feel mic r
Each of these responses on your part is a consequence of the original act. W hich one w ill you address? Her late? Departm ent looks bad? Need to m icrom anage?
T he 4 Cs:
p
se
T he 4 Cs:
p
se
We are triggered by an event Which leads to a story Which generates a feeling Which leads to a behavioral impulse
Don’t ask, “What’s the matter with that employee?” Do ask, “Why would a reasonable, rational and decent employee do that?” This is the root of empathy. You’re ready to have an accountability conversation when you can demonstrate empathy.
–
Wa it until yo u’ re c a lm e no ug h to la y o ut the pro b le m “in fro nt o f us” ra the r tha n “b e twe e n us” o r “so le ly o n yo u.”
–
De sc rib e g a p c a lmly a nd witho ut judg me nt.
his/ he r b e ha vio r
like / e xpe c ta tio ns
ry to ide ntify whic h c o nse q ue nc e s/ impa c ts a re mo tiva ting fo r the e mplo ye e .
to me re mo rta l
pra c tic e o f g iving a rmo re d fe e db a c k
he g o a l is no t to g e t c o mfo rta b le with ha rd c o nve rsa tio ns, b ut to a llo w disc o mfo rt in the ro o m
to me re mo rta l
pra c tic e o f g iving a rmo re d fe e db a c k
he g o a l is no t to g e t c o mfo rta b le with ha rd c o nve rsa tio ns, b ut to a llo w disc o mfo rt in the ro o m
T his is ha rd fo r me to o
sandwich.
upstairs.
to read your mind.
sandwich.
upstairs.
to read your mind.
Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3
You observe a new employee, Kim, in client reception snapping back at the mother of a pediatric client who is checking in 20 minutes late for her child’s
bumped from the schedule and now will be seen on a walk-in basis.) Kim says, in response to Mom’s push back, “well, it’s not our fault you were so late.” This comment, in turn, evokes an angry tirade from Mom. You’re observing Tim managing a client injury. Everything’s going well until it’s time to clean up and you notice that Tim doesn’t put on gloves, which he’s required to do (he straightened up the room, emptied the trash, stepped out once to consult with another staff member, etc.). It’s come to your attention that Phil has been late several times over the past month in submitting his time sheet. This has resulted in folks from payroll having to track him down to determine his hours, causing extra work for the office at a time when they’re under tight deadline.
DEVELOPMENTAL FEEDBACK EXERCISE
1. Sta rt with sa fe ty 2. Sha re yo ur pa th 3. E nd with a q ue stio n 1. Sta rt with sa fe ty 2. Sha re yo ur pa th 3. E nd with a q ue stio n
How to get started
e bad things….
espec t)
pur pose)
e xpe c ting a nd wha t wa s o b se rve d.
he fir st 30 sec onds matter s!
f yo ur to ne o f vo ic e , fa c ia l e xpre ssio n o r wo rds sho w disre spe c t, b a d thing s a re c urre ntly ha ppe ning to the e mplo ye e .
the so urc e a nd re sto re sa fe ty b e fo re yo u c o ntinue
asting Statements” to e sta b lish a nd
re sto re sa fe ty:
–
I ma g ine wha t the e mplo ye e mig ht ha ve e rro ne o usly c o nc lude d.
–
I mme dia te ly e xpla in tha t this is wha t yo u
do n’t me a n. –
T he n e xpla in wha t yo u do me a n.
I don’t want you to think I’m unhappy with
ho w we wo rk to ge the r. Ove rall, I ’m ve ry satisfie d. I just want to talk about how we
make de cisions toge the r
.
I’m not saying it was wr
disagr e e with me in the me e ting. We ne e d
to he ar e ve ryo ne ’s ide as in o rde r to make the be st c ho ic e . I t’s just that I think the te am
he ar d your tone and wor ds as attacking.
I’m sor r
it o n purpo se . I be lie ve you we r
e unawar e o f the
impac t yo u we re having, whic h is why I wante d to bring it up in the first plac e .
I f it’s OK with yo u, I ’d like to spe nd a c o uple o f minute s talking abo ut ho w yo u handle d that disgruntle d c lie nt this mo rning. My go al is to c o me up with an appro ac h that we ’re bo th c o mfo rtable with.
I don’t think we ’r e talking about a huge pr
do think that with a couple of
small change s, yo u wo uld have an e asie r time
de aling with c lie nts that push bac k like that wo man did this mo rning, and I will fe e l c o mfo rtable that we ’re no t adding ano the r laye r to the pro ble m.
yo ur he a d. E xpla in w hat no t why.
e nta tive ly sha re yo ur sto ry. Avo id a b so lute s.
tho ug ht we a g re e d’ …no t, ‘ Yo u sa id’
wa s wo nde ring if’ …no t, ‘ I ts c le a r’
We are triggered by an event Which leads to a story Which generates a feeling Which leads to a behavioral impulse
“Did I miss something?” “Did you run into a problem of some kind?”
Sta c y, a n e mplo ye e who wo rks fo r yo u, fa ile d to c o mple te a n impo rta nt q ua lity c he c k. Yo u
a nd trie d to de te rmine the rig ht pro b le m to disc uss. Sinc e this wa s the first infra c tio n, yo u've de c ide d to ta lk a b o ut the c o nte nt: she didn't c o mple te the q ua lity c he c k. Yo u a dmire Sta c y a nd so ha ve impute d g o o d mo tive . Ho w will yo u sta rt the c o nve rsa tio n?
What is your opening line?
Yo ur o ffic e a ssista nt ha s do ub le -b o o ke d yo u fo r a ppo intme nts se ve ra l time s in the la st mo nth. Ye ste rda y, yo u re c e ive d a c a ll fro m a no the r de pa rtme nt he a d’ s a ssista nt wa nting to c o nfirm a me e ting da te with yo u dire c tly. She indic a te d tha t she wa nte d to ma ke sure yo ur c a le nda r wa s, in fa c t, c le a r b e c a use yo ur pa rtic ipa tio n in the me e ting wa s impo rta nt. Ho w will yo u sta rt a c o nve rsa tio n with yo ur o ffic e a ssista nt? Wha t will yo u sa y?
Wha t is yo ur o pe ning line ?
EXPLORE THE SOURCES OF MOTIVATION
Personal Social Structural
Motivation Ability
Carrots and sticks Peer pressure Want to Structures, environments, tools Help from
Can do
Personal Social Structural
Ability
pe rmissio n
fe e db a c k
pump
pe rmissio n
fe e db a c k
pump
MAKE IT SAFE TO SEARCH TOGETHER
s tha t to o ha rd fo r yo u?
– No te the ne w pro b le m. – Se le c t the rig ht pro b le m to sta y fo c use d o n:
the o rig ina l pro b le m, the ne w o ne , o r b o th.
– Re so lve the ne w pro b le m a nd re turn to the
– De a l with o ne pro b le m a t a time . – Co nsc io usly c ho o se to de a l with ne w issue s;
do n’ t a llo w the m to b e fo rc e d o n yo u.
Loss of Safety Loss of Trust New Issue Explosive Emotions
When an employee starts to back out of the conversation or push too hard, you need to reestablish
resolve the topic at hand, if the employee feels unsafe talking about it. Broken promises are violations of trust and
trust issues slide. You’re talking about an expectation gap and the employee does something even worse during the conversation. What if the employee becomes quite emotional (angry, frustrated, sad, anxious)? How do you deal with
stories? Use the skill of Contrasting to restore mutual respect and shared purpose. Remember this sentence, “I f som ething com es up, let m e know as soon as you can.” Bookmark the original topic and focus on the new one. Say, “I ’d like to pause our
conversation and talk about w hat just happened.” Ensure your safety. Go straight to the emotion. Explore the other person’s path to action. Use AMPP to listen deeply.
Ask - “Wha t’ s g o ing o n? ” Mirror – de sc rib e the diffe re nc e b e twe e n
wha t he sa id a nd ho w he sa id it
Paraphrase – put in yo ur o wn wo rds wha t
yo u think the e mplo ye e is te lling yo u (do n’ t pa rro t!)
Prim e – g ue ss wha t the o the r
pe rso n ma y b e thinking
When we ar e willing to talk about an employee’s thoughts and feelings without moc king, squelc hing or attac king them, they ar e muc h mor e likely to c alm down. Onc e they’ve c almed down, they’r e muc h mor e likely to be able to expr ess their
r ationally and listen to our s.
Yo u ha ve a ske d K e ith, a pe rso n who re po rts to yo u, why he fa ile d to a tte nd the c o mpute r tra ining tha t he ha d a g re e d to sit in o n. He e xpla ins tha t he ha d inte nde d to b e the re , b ut “so me thing c a me up.” Yo u c a n’ t te ll whe the r his re spo nse is c o de fo r a mo tiva tio n pro b le m o r a n a b ility pro b le m, so yo u a sk him e xa c tly wha t pre ve nte d him fro m ke e ping his pro mise . Yo u’ re thinking tha t if it wa s a nything o the r tha n a fa mily e me rg e nc y, yo u’ re no t inc line d to b e sympa the tic . Yo u kno w K e ith ha te s c o mpute r tra ining , a nd he re a lly ne e ds it. Yo u ha d g o ne o ut o f yo ur wa y to a rra ng e the sc he dule so K e ith c o uld a tte nd the tra ining , a nd no w he ’ s te lling yo u tha t so me thing c a me up.
(wha t).
b y a c e rta in da te ).
f the re a re a c tio ns yo u will ta ke summa rize the se a s we ll.
Wha t do yo u do whe n yo u do n’ t a c tua lly se e the pro b le m? Co wo rke rs c o mpla in e ndle ssly, sa ying thing s like , “He ’ s impo ssib le to wo rk with,” a nd, “He c a n’ t b e truste d,” a nd, “He ne ve r liste ns to fe e db a c k.” Ho w do yo u ha ndle he a rsa y? Wha t do yo u do whe n yo u do n’ t a c tua lly se e the pro b le m? Co wo rke rs c o mpla in e ndle ssly, sa ying thing s like , “He ’ s impo ssib le to wo rk with,” a nd, “He c a n’ t b e truste d,” a nd, “He ne ve r liste ns to fe e db a c k.” Ho w do yo u ha ndle he a rsa y? We ’ re ma king a b re a k fro m the pa st. I t use d to b e tha t we to le ra te d wide diffe re nc e s in b e ha vio r whe n it c a me to c usto me r se rvic e . But no w we ’ re suppo se d to ho ld pe o ple a c c o unta b le to a c o mmo n se t o f sta nda rds. Ho w do yo u c ha ng e the rule s in the middle o f the g a me ? We ’ re ma king a b re a k fro m the pa st. I t use d to b e tha t we to le ra te d wide diffe re nc e s in b e ha vio r whe n it c a me to c usto me r se rvic e . But no w we ’ re suppo se d to ho ld pe o ple a c c o unta b le to a c o mmo n se t o f sta nda rds. Ho w do yo u c ha ng e the rule s in the middle o f the g a me ?
A wo ma n who wo rks fo r me is a lwa ys me ssing up the de ta ils. She ’ s no t b a d e no ug h to b e c a lle d inc o mpe te nt, b ut she ’ s so b o rde rline tha t yo u a lwa ys wo rry a b o ut he r wo rk. Wha t c a n yo u do ? A wo ma n who wo rks fo r me is a lwa ys me ssing up the de ta ils. She ’ s no t b a d e no ug h to b e c a lle d inc o mpe te nt, b ut she ’ s so b o rde rline tha t yo u a lwa ys wo rry a b o ut he r wo rk. Wha t c a n yo u do ? Wha t if the pe rso n is to ta lly o ut o f line mo st o f the time b ut thre a te ns to file a g rie va nc e if yo u c o nfro nt him? And the wo rst o f it is tha t b e c a use o f his spe c ia l c irc umsta nc e s, he ’ d pro b a b ly win. T he n wha t? Wha t if the pe rso n is to ta lly o ut o f line mo st o f the time b ut thre a te ns to file a g rie va nc e if yo u c o nfro nt him? And the wo rst o f it is tha t b e c a use o f his spe c ia l c irc umsta nc e s, he ’ d pro b a b ly win. T he n wha t?
feedback conversations; 1 developmental
Reference Books: