M&O Expenditure for 2018
- A. Charkiewicz, RRB-48, 15 April 2019
CERN-RRB-2019-032
- cf. CERN-RRB-2019-033
for 2018 CERN-RRB-2019-032 cf. CERN-RRB-2019-033 A. Charkiewicz, - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
M&O Expenditure for 2018 CERN-RRB-2019-032 cf. CERN-RRB-2019-033 A. Charkiewicz, RRB-48, 15 April 2019 CMS is growing Several Institutes have joined CMS since the last RRB meeting, and more are in the application process. This
15 April 2019 CERN-RRB-2019-032 2
Several Institutes have joined CMS since the last RRB meeting, and more are in the application process. This obviously means more resources and more partners to share the costs
ASSOCIATED
University of Bath, UK University of Wisconsin-Madison, Computing Sciences Department, USA University of Bahrain, Bahrain
COOPERATING
Bethel University, USA
FULL MEMBERS
Kyung Hee University, Korea Universidad de Antioquia, Medellin, Colombia Istanbul University, Turkey Zhejiang University (ZJU), China
(open commitments, related to delivered goods or services, are reported globally)
3 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
4 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
Budget Year
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Invoiced kCHF 925 1'765 2'498 3'692 6'565 8'847 10'984 11'216 12'742 13'366 14'051 14'537 14'406 13'224 13'321 12'880 13'127
Paid before following year April RRB (kCHF)
805 1'549 2'302 3'372 6'384 8'839 10'664 10'977 12'711 13'329 13'203 13'541 13'095 12'333 12'939 12'488 12'867
Outstanding % before following year April RRB
12.9% 12.3% 7.9% 8.7% 2.8% 0.1% 2.9% 2.1% 0.2% 0.3% 6.0% 6.9% 9.1% 6.7% 2.9% 3.0% 2.0%
5 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
in past years, CMS has managed to limit gas expenditures
462 kCHF of outstanding commitments are to be paid in 2019
8 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
2018 Budgeted Costs Budget kCHF Expenditure 2018 A.1. Detector related costs 3'916 3'999 A.2. Secretariat 312 319 A.3. Communications 130 130 A.4. On-line computing 3'565 3'561 A.5. Test beams, calibration facilities 96 95 A.6. Laboratory operations 584 656 A.7. General services 1'853 1'918 A.9. Core Computing Infrastructure & Services 1'964 1'946 M&O-A without Power Cost 12'420 12'623 A.8. Electricity 1'700 1'700 Total 14'120 14'323 Μ&Ο-Α
7 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
Year 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Budget allocation 1'905 2'818 1'900 2'918 2'618 3'000 2'046 2'600 2'560 2'360 2'500 2'500 2'500 Expenditure/ Expenditure plan 609 489 1'441 3'191 4'183 2'770 728 3'116 3'100 5'500 1'500 3'300 3'300 Deposits/Withdrawls from Special DAQ Account 1'296 2'329 459
230 1'318
1'000
Cumulative Cash Balance - Special DAQ Account 1'296 3'625 4'084 3'811 2'246 2'476 3'794 3'278 2'738
598
As CMS does not centrally invoice for M&O-B, the Collaboration is reporting qualitatively on these expenses. A large part of them are in-kind contributions from participating institutes The overall Subsystem arrangements made in 2018 have functioned satisfactorily
8 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
No major problems have been encountered by the Subsystems in
funding for their M&O-B budgets A detailed qualitative assessment
included in the Expenditure Report
CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019 9
The RRB is invited to take note of the present M&O Expenditure Report for 2018 In view of the operational
2019
the latest PhDs list from September 2018) and will change for the
11 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
The final M&O-A budget request for 2020 (and the projection until 2023) will be revised after discussions with the RRB Scrutiny Group in the course of the
shown to the RRB at the October 2018 meeting The proposed modifications in the allocation are due to the following factors Implemented in the Preliminary Draft Budget Request
Still requiring a more precise estimate
12 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
present arrangements for providing shift crew are evident
the Scrutiny Group, for which an initial allocation was already granted
(additional 180 kCHF in Cat. A.1.17 Counting and Control Rooms)
experimental areas, provided free of charge until now (additional 102 kCHF in Cat.
A.1.12) Shutdown Activities)
Thorough analyses have clearly demonstrated that the
solution is the construction of a new facility in the vicinity of the existing Control Room Proposal of a building with a 445 m2 footprint including:
room – Storage, engineering services, etc.
Functional Specification derived from User Requirements Document Layouts proposed to demonstrate that the space is sufficient to meet user requirements
13 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
The M&O-A cost estimates have changed with respect to the October 2018 RRB meeting The budget projection up to the year 2021 shows the budgetary implications of LS2 The increases in the budget are approximately at the same level as in LS1 After 2021, the total M&O-A allocation will decrease to a level corresponding to the 2017 and 2018 allocation
14 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
1 002 1 888 2 659 3 835 7 395 9 698 11 959 12 208 13 711 14 353 15 035 15 439 15 346 14 160 14 257 13 816 14 120 15 497 15 577 14 208 14 208 14 058
2 000 4 000 6 000 8 000 10 000 12 000 14 000 16 000 18 000 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
M&O-A Budget Evolution
Apr-19
The total estimated budget for M&O-A excluding power is 13’877 kCHF The total estimated budget for M&O-A with power is 15’577 kCHF
15 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
2020 Description Budget in kCHF A.1. Detector related costs 5'129 A.2. Secretariat 312 A.3. Communications 130 A.4. On-line computing 3'325 A.5. Test beams, calibration facilities 96 A.6. Laboratory operations 649 A.7. General services 2'272 A.9. Core Computing Infrastructure & Services 1'964 Total without Power Cost 13'877 A.8. Electricity 1'700 Grand Total 15'577 M&O-A
Implications of the Phase-2 Upgrade
15 April 2019 CERN-RRB-2019-032 16
CMS R&D and CORE budget of the Phase-2 will not cover the operation and maintenance of the upgraded areas and facilities needed for assembly and
CMS is currently working on establishing some common rules/guidelines with respect to requesting M&O-B funds for costs resulting from the implementation of the Phase-2 Upgrade One should note that the Muon M&O-B already has a component related to the GEM GE1/1 Project which is part of the Phase-2 Upgrade Some examples of items relevant to the pre-production and production period:
those not replaced as part of the upgrade
This request will be discussed in detail with the RRB Scrutiny Group, especially in view of the fact that the HGCal System would need an M&O-B Budget to be established for 2020
With respect to the forecast of the M&O-B budget for 2020, as presented at the October 2018 RRB, the budget has decreased by 25 kCHF amounting to 5’545 kCHF All subsystems have substantially used their carry-over funds in accordance with agreement with the RRB Scrutiny Group As requested by the RRB, the M&O-B expenditures will undergo formal scrutiny by the RRB Scrutiny Group as in previous years (following an internal CMS Scrutiny
process)
Below is the current M&O-B forecast for the next four years
17 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
1'320 4'355 5'644 6'073 6'262 5'827 6'464 6'033 6'418 6'639 5'915 5'997 5'463 5'582 5'414 4'908 5'491 5'545 5'241 5'166 5'219
2'000 3'000 4'000 5'000 6'000 7'000 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023
M&O-B Budget Evolution
Apr-19
18 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
Description Ref. Details Tracker ECAL HCAL Muon Trigger BRIL PPS Core Computing Grand Total B.1.01 Mechanics 10 20 5 2 37 B.1.02 Gas-system 59 33 92 B.1.03 Cryo-system
Cooling system 95 4 3 102 B.1.05 FE electronics 7 5 6 18 B.1.06 Standard electronics, PS (LV, HV) 73 50 7 157 10 7 304 B.1.07 Standard electronics, Crates 17 20 40 4 3 84 B.1.08 Standard electronics, RO Modules 10 17 52 50 16 17 162 B.1.09 Controls, (DCS, DSS) 16 10 15 13 2 56 B.1.10 Sub-Detector Spares 115 42 56 6 219 B.1.11 Areas 25 10 42 1 1 79 B.1.12 Communications 40 10 25 50 5 8 5 143 B.1.13 Store Items 25 20 21 50 5 8 4 133 B.1.14 Hired Manpower @ CERN 780 350 920 1'344 279 180 264 4'117
1'248 450 1'067 1'788 379 295 318 5'545
B.2.01 Technical Manpower @ CERN B.2.02 Core Computing Manpower @ CMS 8 8 8 8 Human Resources Total
2020 M&O-B Budget Request
Detector Amount (kCHF/FTE) Material Resources
Material Resources Total
Human Resources
15 April 2019 19 CERN-RRB-2019-032
review its M&O-B sharing scheme with a view to finding ways to reduce discrepancies in the per-capita cost of M&O-B to FAs
Finance Board. It was noted that any such global revision could potentially have major implications for FA-specific cost as well as for the Subsystems
a more detailed assessment
the current system is necessary to better understand the issues and potential implications
single CMS M&O-B sharing method. There is a general guideline that this should be determined by the annually-revised PhD List. This is applied by most Subsystems, but not by all (some take into account FA responsibility for
initial construction)
up, with the majority of physicists still involved in already well-established systems
CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019 20
The total M&O-A Preliminary Draft Budget 2020 amounts to 15’577 kCHF The M&O-B Preliminary Draft Budget 2020 amounts to 5’545 kCHF and some 8 FTEs
Collaborating Institutes manpower (for Core Computing) CMS is currently analysing the implications of the Phase-2 Upgrade, in the long-term, on the M&O-B Budget The RRB is invited to take note of the present, unscrutinized, cost estimates for M&O-A and M&O-B
2019
The CMS Phase-1 Upgrade Project is now in its final stage and will be completed during the Long Shut-down 2 (LS2) There is no change to the overall budget of the Phase-1 Upgrade as the estimated cost at completion corresponds to approximately 65 MCHF for all CMS Subsystems There are no specific problems related to funding
22 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
New systems, installed in LS1
subsequent stops,
very smoothly in the course of last year, providing very high-quality data from a higher than ever fraction of active channels The remaining detector upgrade work is described in more detail below and concerns the Pixel Tracker and HCAL The Phase-1 DAQ Upgrade is foreseen to be finalized towards the end of LS2
0,00 1,00 2,00 3,00 4,00 5,00 6,00 7,00 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Pixel Tracker HCAL HF - Phototubes Muon CSC Muon DT Muon RPC DAQ Trigger
Updated Cost Profile for all the Subsystems
The Phase-1 Upgrade is completed for Trigger and Muons within cost estimates and schedules specified in their respective TDRs
23 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
0,00 1,00 2,00 3,00 4,00 5,00 6,00 7,00 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Pixel Tracker HCAL Trigger
Pixel Upgrade:
affecting 2018 operations and it is being permanently corrected during LS2
required because of deterioration due to radiation (a provision of 520 kCHF has been made)
Cost Profile for the TDR Projects (MCHF/year)
HCAL Upgrade:
a year ahead of schedule, including the replacement
Phase-1 Upgrade is the HB photo-detectors and front-end electronics
DAQ Upgrade:
back-end electronics, which was implemented in LS1 for Trigger and subsequently for other upgraded sub-detectors: Pixel, Muon, and Hadron Calorimeter. The system performed reliably in Run-2
done in LS2
The Common Fund has been almost fully paid with only one Funding Agency contribution missing As for the rest of the Phase-1 Upgrade, the Common Infrastructure part, currently fully financed from the Upgrade Common Fund, is in the final stage of completion It was nevertheless possible to make some savings, which, in agreement with the RRB Scrutiny Group, are being used to launch some useful items descoped from the Phase-1 Upgrade to keep estimated costs within the available ceiling
24 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
Among them are Magnet protection facilities, a hydraulic
system and a second bridge crane in the experimental cavern The last of these is installed and in use in LS2, allowing for simultaneous operation in 2 zones The principal remaining activity is the connection and integration of all systems by the end of LS2
0,00 0,20 0,40 0,60 0,80 1,00 1,20 1,40 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Magnet power and cryo Beam Instrumentation Infrastructure Test Beam Facilities Upgrade Safety systems upgrade Electronics Integration Engineering Integration
Cost Profile for the Upgrade Common Items (MCHF/year)
The Phase-2 Upgrade Project of CMS is intended to adapt the experiment to the unprecedented luminosity levels foreseen in the High Luminosity LHC era Efforts to ensure readiness for this new stage in the life of the experiment, expected to start sometime in the middle of 2026, have been ongoing already since several years The foreseen technical configuration of the future experiment has been described in the Technical Proposal More detailed descriptions of each of the Detector Systems were contained in the subsequent Technical Design Reports (TDRs) for each Subsystem Upgrade The cost estimate for the CMS Phase-2 Upgrade has already been presented to the RRB in its October 2018 Meeting
25 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
Four new MoU Addenda (to the Memorandum of
Understanding for the Construction of CMS) have been
finalized: They will now be transmitted to participating Funding Agencies for signature
26 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
CMS COLLABORATION CERN-MoU-2019-006 1 April 2019 Page 1/ 13 CMS-MoU-Upg Add No. 11Addendum No. 11 to the Memorandum of Understanding
for Collaboration in the Upgrade of the CMS Detector (comprising an Upgrade to the Tracker Subsystem) between The EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH, hereinafter referred to as CERN, Geneva, as the Host LaboratoryAddendum No. 12 to the Memorandum of Understanding
for Collaboration in the Upgrade of the CMS Detector (comprising an Upgrade to the Barrel Calorimeter Subsystem) between The EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH, hereinafter referred to as CERN, Geneva, as the Host LaboratoryAddendum No. 13 to the Memorandum of Understanding
for Collaboration in the Upgrade of the CMS Detector (comprising an Upgrade to the Muon Subsystem) between The EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH, hereinafter referred to as CERN, Geneva, as the Host LaboratoryAddendum No. 14 to the Memorandum of Understanding
for Collaboration in the Upgrade of the CMS Detector (comprising an Upgrade to the Endcap Calorimeter Subsystem) between The EUROPEAN ORGANISATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH, hereinafter referred to as CERN, Geneva, as the Host Laboratory(CERN-MoU-2019-006)
MoU Addendum No. 12 for Barrel Calorimeter
(CERN-MoU-2019-008)
(CERN-MoU-2019-007)
Calorimeter (HGCal)
(CERN-MoU-2019-009)
27 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
The CMS Phase-2 Money Matrix has been updated in the process of finalizing the MoU Addenda The resulting changes show an increase of the funding available for the Phase-2 Upgrade The cost was not changed although a revision on MIP Timing Detector (MTD) is expected in the coming months
FA/Subsystem EC-CALO Barrel - CALO Muons Tracker MIP-TD BRIL TDAQ Common Fund Total Phase-2
CORE Costs (kCHF) 67'127 13'255 25'187 111'900 15'796 2'600 18'500 25'000 279'365
Austria 900 800 326 2'026 Belgium FNRS 100 4'800 489 5'389 Belgium FWO 5'000 417 5'417 Brazil/FAPESP 1'291 127 1'418 Brazil/RENAFAE 380 380 Bulgaria 360 181 541 CERN 21'500 2'000 1'524 19'500 1'200 4'500 1'322 51'546 China 900 1'450 400 254 3'004 Colombia 80 72 152 Croatia 1'350 145 1'495 Cyprus 127 127 Egypt 200 54 254 Estonia 522 54 576 Finland 150 1'100 1'000 236 2'486 France-CEA 1'000 1'815 500 308 3'623 France-IN2P3 6'400 600 4'600 924 12'524 Germany BMBF 1'920 9'450 1'196 12'566 Germany Helmholtz 100 9'107 500 634 10'341 Greece 350 1'400 1'000 326 3'076 Hungary 225 300 150 225 181 1'081 India 2'060 1'479 2'000 250 598 6'387 Iran 1'390 145 1'535 Ireland 36 36 Italy 1'900 5'150 14'000 3'600 200 3'007 27'857 Korea 2'056 562 2'618 Lithuania 348 36 384 Malaysia 870 91 961 Mexico 1'000 199 1'199 New Zealand 70 36 106 Pakistan 1'100 550 1'600 36 3'286 Poland 300 272 572 Portugal 420 460 960 109 1'949 RDMS-DMS-Russia 8'200 629 350 1'522 10'701 Serbia 80 54 134 Spain 1'500 1'200 200 100 779 3'779 Switzerland 2'500 9'113 1'000 707 13'320 Taipei 2'600 272 2'872 Thailand 100 54 154 Turkey 2'094 217 2'311 United Kingdom 3'500 500 2'500 500 1'033 8'033 USA-DOE 14'500 2'698 13'691 5'000 3'886 5'431 45'206 USA-NSF 4'194 2'199 12'512 900 1'381 21'186 USA-DOE-NP 5'305 525 5'830 Ecuador 36 36 Montenegro 190 36 226 Sri Lanka 760 72 832 Latvia 380 36 416 Qatar 300 300 Georgia 500 36 536
Funding (kCHF) 69'014 13'449 26'320 113'964 12'410 1'845 18'711 25'071 280'784 Uncertainty low 90% 99% 84% 96% 92% 100% 63% 100% 92% Uncertainty Medium 6% 1% 14% 4% 8% 0% 7% 0% 5% Uncertainty High 4% 0% 1% 0% 0% 0% 30% 0% 3% Funding/CORE Costs 103% 101% 104% 102% 79% 71% 101% 100% 101% Funding-CORE Costs 1'887 194 1'133 2'064
211 71 1'419
CMS Phase-2 Internal Money Matrix (in kCHF), 15 April 2019
28 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
The MM presented to the RRB includes a color-coding scheme, common to all experiments with three levels:
funding and includes this in their spending plan
request as a target to work towards
described in the MM, has been submitted to the FA or is considered to form the basis for further discussion
Funding Agencies have reviewed their funding confidence level, with significant progress, as many have recently ‘upgraded’ their colour code to one designating a higher confidence level
92% 5% 3%
Uncertainty level
Uncertainty low Uncertainty Medium Uncertainty High
The CMS Phase-2 Upgrade requires a substantial investment in new, specific infrastructure facilities, collectively used systems and commonly executed integration and installation tasks. These are covered by the Upgrade Common Items category, financed chiefly through the Common Fund The level of the Common Fund has been established at 25 MCHF (below 9%
Agencies, based on the same sharing system as applied for the M&O-A, using the proportion of PhD authors The formal framework for this is stipulated in the Addendum No. 10 to the Construction MoU (CERN-RRB-2017-060). This document has been elaborated at the end of 2017 and already signed by the majority of CMS Funding Agencies By now, 5.8 MCHF have been collected into the Common Fund, with several Funding Agencies already having covered their full contribution Expenditures from the Common Fund are already ongoing since the beginning of 2018 and these will be reported on a regular basis to the Scrutiny Group and to the RRB
15 April 2019 CERN-RRB-2019-032 29
30 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019
The Subsystem Projects are already advancing in preparations for the construction phase of the Upgrade. Most of them are already engaging some expenditures. The most advanced of the Phase-2 projects are the Muon GEM and CSC Invitation to tender for the Tracker and HGCal sensors is out to be ready for the June Finance Committee and hopefully issuance of contract in October The MTD TDR, which has been recently finalized, is under review by the
which, an Addendum to the MoU will be prepared. The TDR for the BRIL Phase-2 Upgrade is planned to be submitted at the end of 2020 A Letter of Intent for PPS is under discussion and supported by LHCC. It should be noted that this project is not in current scope of the Phase-2 Upgrade.
electronics is on-going. The super-chamber assembly has started.
proceeding according to schedule
foreseen expenditure profile
31 CERN-RRB-2019-032 15 April 2019