Design and status of the Mu2e crystal calorimeter
Raffaella Donghia
National Laboratory of Frascati of INFN On behalf of the Mu2e calorimeter group June 11, 2019 New Perspectives 2019 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
Design and status of the Mu2e crystal calorimeter Raffaella Donghia - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Design and status of the Mu2e crystal calorimeter Raffaella Donghia National Laboratory of Frascati of INFN On behalf of the Mu2e calorimeter group June 11, 2019 New Perspectives 2019 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory CLFV @ Mu2e CLFV
Raffaella Donghia
National Laboratory of Frascati of INFN On behalf of the Mu2e calorimeter group June 11, 2019 New Perspectives 2019 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
25 m
Production Solenoid / Target
mostly π Tr Transport Solenoid
momentum μ-
PS TS
De Detector Sol
for 105 MeV/c momentum
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 1
DS
à Observation would indicate New Physics
à discovery sensitivity to many NP models
µ e Al
ECE = mµc2 – Eb – Erecoil= = 104.97 MeV < 8.4 x 10-17
M
e i n f
m a t i
i n Y u j i n g t a l k
Redundancy in readou
senso sors+ rs+FEE /c /crystal)
Radiation
fety fa factor
100 kr krad (4 (45 kr krad) ) dose for crystals (s (sensors)
3x10 1012
12 n1M 1MeV eV/c
/cm2
2 (1
(1.2x1012
12 n1M 1MeV eV/c
/cm2) ) for crystals (s (sensors) )
The electromagnetic calorimeter (EMC) should provide high acceptance for reconstructing energy, time and position of conversion electrons (CE) and provide: 1) 1) PI PID: e/μ se separa rati tion 2) 2) EMC EMC seeded track fi finder 3) 3) Fa Fast and nd track-in independent trig igger
Requirements @ 105 MeV/c
Front Disk Dose – 1 year [krad] June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 2
Tw Two annular disks with 674 und undoped ed Cs CsI (3 (34 x x 34 x x 200) ) mm3
3 sq
square cryst stals s each
2 2 UV-ex extended ended Si SiPMs/c /crystal (Mu2e Si SiPMs) à 50 50 um um pi pixel el, 12x 12x18 18 mm2 ac active ar area
Long R&D phase to select final producer
BETTER PICTURE!!
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 3
~ 150 V i1≈ i2 ≈ i3 Ctot ≈ C/3
6x6 mm2 K1 A1
t wrapped
Large EMC prototype: 51 crystals, 102 SiPMs, 102 FEE boards Mechanics and cooling system similar to the final ones but smaller scale à Main goals:
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 4
Readout: 1 GHz CAEN digitizers (DRS4 chip), 2 boards x 32 channels
Highest Energy Crystal [MeV]
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 5
σE E = a √ E ⊕ b E ⊕ c
σE ~ 7.3 % Beam @ 50°
Energy response Time response
TimeHist
/ ndf
2106.6 / 20 0.0444 0.6526 1.21 17.12 0.7 216.6 N 640.2 8782 t [ns] 200 400 600 800 1000 Amplitude [mV] 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
TimeHist
/ ndf
2106.6 / 20 0.0444 0.6526 1.21 17.12 0.7 216.6 N 640.2 8782
Χ η σ µ
Δ
Energy [MeV] 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 [ns]
T
σ 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35
/ ndf
2χ 1.631 / 5 a 0.2011 ± 6.29 b 0.006919 ± 0.08285 / ndf
2χ 1.631 / 5 a 0.2011 ± 6.29 b 0.006919 ± 0.08285 / ndf
2
χ 2.776 / 3 a 0.1399 ± 4.85 b 0.004284 ± 0.06402 / ndf
2
χ 2.776 / 3 a 0.1399 ± 4.85 b 0.004284 ± 0.06402
Cosmic Rays - Hamamatsu
Cosmic Rays - SensL
σT = a/E + b
Δ
Entries 1531 / ndf 2 19.56 / 15 Constant 7.6 240.9 Mean 0.0049 0.1664 Sigma 0.0035 0.1874t [ns] 1.5 1 0.5 0.5 1 1.5 Entries / (0.075 ns) 50 100 150 200 250
Entries 1531 / ndf 2 19.56 / 15 Constant 7.6 240.9 Mean 0.0049 0.1664 Sigma 0.0035 0.1874Central crystal (TSiPM 1 – TSiPM2) Δ
Time response
More details on E.Diociaiuti poster
Dedicated QA laboratory at SiDet (FNAL) è production started on March 2018 Additional laboratories for crystals and irradiation testing at Caltech and HZDR
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 6
Light Yield
Crystals SiPMs
More than 1000 crystals already tested from SICCAS (rate: 60 crystals/month), SG almost same rate
LY, LRU, resolution, slow component, RIN About 3200/4000 Mu2e SiPMs already characterized Producer: HAMAMATSU
RMS (Vbr) RMS (Idark)
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 7
De Dedica cated FEE board on each ch Si SiPM PM: :
à Rise time 50 ns à Full width 200 ns
10 10 crates es per er disk with h 6-8 8 digital boards/crate
(MB): input FEE signals, HV to SiPMs
DIRAC board provides digitization at 200 Msps, 12 bit ADC
15 kr krad
MB DIRAC
June 11, 2019 8
Crystals stacked from the bottom to the top inside an external stainless steel cylindrical support
mockup with fake iron crystals Geant4 simulation NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 9
Cosmic Rays DIO electrons
Calibration relative to tracker measurements
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 10
Getting ready to start assembly in November 2019!
Stacking procedure
New Photo
Mu2e requirements:
§ Excellent LRU and LY > 100 pe/MeV ( PMT+Tyvek wrapping ) § τ of 30 ns, negligible slow component § Radiation hardness OK: 40% LY loss at 100 krad
§ Good time and energy resolution achieved @ 100 MeV
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 11
Raffaella Donghia
On behalf of the Mu2e calorimeter group June 11, 2019 New Perspectives 2019 Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory
Time [ns] 50 100 150 200 Amplitude [mV] 100 200 300 400 500
Entries 102900 Mean 90.09 Mean y 60.63 RMS 63.51 RMS y 110.6 Entries 102900 Mean 90.04 Mean y 33.18 RMS 63.51 RMS y 33.26Time [ns] 50 100 150 200 Amplitude [mV] 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Entries 102900 Mean 90.04 Mean y 33.18 RMS 63.51 RMS y 33.26/MeV
peN 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200
Entries
2 4 6 8 10
Entries
σ
Entries Entries
LRU (%) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Entries
2 4 6 8 10 12 σ
Entries
SICCAS, Am Amcrys, Sa Saint nt Go Gobai ain
511 ke keV γ’s ’s
Tyvek+UV-extended PM PMT readout
Light Yield Longitudinal Resp. Uniformity
RMS/MEAN of Light Output values along axis
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 13 Entries 72
Crystals Mu2e-SiPM Mu2e custom photosensors: 2 2 arrays of 3 3 6x 6x6 6 mm2 UV UV-ex extend ended ed Si SiPM PMs
Single cell of 6 x 6 mm2 Series of 3 cells
Prototype TB
h
Entries Mean 0 RMS 0 Energy [GeV] 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 [ns]
ts 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3
h
Entries Mean 0 RMS 0 / ndf
2c 38 / 17 a 0.00015 ± 0.0049 b 0.0033 ± 0.087 / ndf
2c 38 / 17 a 0.00015 ± 0.0049 b 0.0033 ± 0.087
b Å = a/E
t
s
Single crystal @ 0 deg All crystals above 10 MeV @ 0 deg Cosmics Neighboring crystals @ 50 deg Single crystal @ 50 deg Most energetic crystal @ 50 deg All crystals above 10 MeV @ 50 degTotal energy [GeV] 0.07 0.075 0.08 0.085 0.09 0.095 0.1 0.105 /E [%]
Es 4 4.5 5 5.5 6 6.5 7 7.5 8 8.5 9 / ndf
2c 2.866 / 3 a 0.3253 ± 1.38 b 1.092 ± 4.911 / ndf
2c 2.866 / 3 a 0.3253 ± 1.38 b 1.092 ± 4.911
data Monte Carlob Å E [GeV] a = E
Es
Small prototype 3x3 tested @ BTF (LNF, 2015)
80-120 120 MeV eV e-
~ 150 V
i1≈ i2 ≈ i3 Ctot ≈ C/3 6x6 mm2 K1 A1
JINST 12 (2017) P05007
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 14
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 15
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 16
Time (ns) 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08
POT pulse 1M ) × arrival/decay time (
400 ) × arrival time (
400 ) × decay/capture time (
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 17
ion Simulation includes full background
properties of the crystals
LRU: RMS/MEAN of Light Output values along axis
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 18
LYSO BaF2 CsI Radiation Length X0 [cm] 1.14 2.03 1.86 Light Yield [% NaI(Tl)] 75 4/36 3.6 Decay Time[ns] 40 0.9/650 20 Photosensor APD RMD APD SiPM Wavelength [nm] 402 220/300 310 $
Laser system to monitor SiPMs gain and timing performance
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 19
Liquid source FC 770 + DT generator: 6 MeV + 2 escape peaks à E-scale 2k entries/crystal/min
q all analog parts of Amplifier and HV regulator OK q LT ADC/DAC of digital session suffering from 10-15 krad up q new rad-hard ADC/DAC identified from Texas Instrument q PCB with TI ADC/DAC ready for new irradiation test è 28 January
June 11, 2019 20
0,000 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 600,000 700,000 800,000 900,000
Output pulse amplitude [mV] DOSE [Krad]
Analog output pulse amplitude reading
Gamma tests in detail - Analog electronics (1 of 6)
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
June 11, 2019 21
PolarFire test with evaluation board DC-DC converter test
looks due to DC DC converter
Krad two times. Both still ok for ECAL. Test in B field to be repeated
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
June 11, 2019 22
SICCAS
§ 622 crystals received /725 = 86% § Rejection factor 3%
End of SICCAS production: Apr 2019
à StGb getting stabilized
à October 2018: 25 crystals received with high rejection factor: 41% à Dec 18: 63=25+38 crystals received Rejection factor = 10/63 = 16% Þ End of January +48 crystals Þ Very good quality + 30 arrive this week Bi-weekly phone call established End of SgB production è Oct 2019
Siccas St.Gobain Total
Shipped
622/725 242/725 864/1450
Arrived 622 242 864 CMM + inspection 622 242 864 Sent to Caltech 184 16 210 Back to Vendor 13 44+20 73
Irradiation at Caltech 8
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
June 11, 2019 23
q All 12 shipments of the standard production (3360) received q Schedule is to complete QA production test for end of March. q Two additional shipments expected with the schedule of
Up to yesterday: è Geometry checked: Batch # 12 (3360) è QA station (Idark, I-V and Gain) checked: Batch # 10 (2750) è Irradiation test up to batch #7 (see next page) è MTTF test keep working w.o. deads .. à MTTF > 10 million hours
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
June 11, 2019 24
0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5
0,0
Batch 1-2; Comparison @ -10C
0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5 4 4,5
0,0
Batch 4; Comparison @ -10C
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
0,0
Batch 6; Comparison @ -10C
Irradiated up 0.9 1012 n/cm2 Irradiated up 1.2 1012 n/cm2 Irradiated up 2.3 1012 n/cm2
§ 5 SiPMs/batch “passively” neutron irradiated @ Dresden § For Mu2e, the max n-flux in SiPM area is of around (4 )x10^10 n/cm^2 § Safety Factor 3(MC)x5(Years)x2(Prod) = 1.2 10^12n/cm^2 § Max Idark current for operation of 2 mA è Requires cooling of -10 C, Lower operation overvoltage to Vop-3V (for the MU2E serie) , 20% of PDE relative loss
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
q all analog parts of Amplifier and HV regulator are rad-hard but LT ADC/DAC of digital sector suffering from 10-15 krad up à new rad-hard TI ADC/DAC identified q PCB with TI ADC/DAC completed q 1 week of gamma irradiation done @ end of January up to 110 krad
June 11, 2019 25
SET
4 5 8 8 4 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
DAC SET
Difference A0-A1 [mV]
SET
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500
DAC SET
Difference D2-D1 [mV]
DAC ADC
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
June 11, 2019 26
à FEE rad-hard chip format frozen à New cable selected to handle rad-hard ADC/DAC à Routing of FEE-MB cables in CAD model à First realistic estimate of cable lengths, weights 4 km cables , 55 kg/disk à Final mockup in progress
NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
q Next round of measurement with TID for FEE planned for end of November in Italy. Also FPGA polar fire for digital board will be tested q Version v3 of FEE and V2 of DIRAC are under way to get them much radiation dose harder q Aiming for CRR for electronics in spring 2019 q Vertical slice test planned with FEE-v2 and Dirac-V1 in December with 20 channels of Module-0 SLICE test with FEE-V1 and CAEN digitizer
June 11, 2019 27
TMu_4 Entries 16 Mean 0.00625 Std Dev 0.01053 [ns] µ 2 − 1.5 − 1 − 0.5 − 0.5 1 1.5 2 Entries / 25 ps 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 TMu_4 Entries 16 Mean 0.00625 Std Dev 0.01053 TMu_4 Entries 16 Mean 0.00625 Std Dev 0.01053 Starting values 1st iteration 2nd iteration 3th iteration 4th iteration 5th iteration
TMu_4
Entries 16082
Energy [MeV] 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Entries / 0.5 MeV 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
Entries 16082 3 crystals 4 crystals 5 crystals
Figure 7.22 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia
SG crystal + Hamamatsu SiPM + FEE Optical coupling in air.
Time [ns]
80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220
Amplitude [mV]
5 10 15 20 25
Hamamatsu 4 - DIstance from Crystal 0 mm 1 mm 2 mm
~ 10% loss
2 SiPMs
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 28
(slewing)
After jitter subtraction: SiPM 1 – σT ~ 330 ps SiPM 2 – σT ~ 340 ps T(SiPM1 - SiPM2)/2 à ~ 215 ps @ ~ 23 MeV energy deposition (MIP energy scale from Na22 source peak) Timing result well compares with old tests: à Reduced light output/SiPM (22 vs 30 pe/MeV) à 2 SiPMs/crystal à LY of 44 vs 30 à 215 ps (now) vs 250 ps (old).
Entries 727 Constant 6.2 ± 133.6 Mean 0.0161 ± 0.1234 Sigma 0.012 ± 0.429
Time [ns]
1 2 3 Entries / 25 ps 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
Entries 727 Constant 6.2 ± 133.6 Mean 0.0161 ± 0.1234 Sigma 0.012 ± 0.429
SiPM 1 - SiPM 2 Σ June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 29
Few samples per vendor have been exposed both to ionizing dose and neutrons
normalized LY after 10/100 krad > 85/60%
do not satisfy the required limit
Most crystals have LY larger than 100 p.e./MeV after 100 krad (40% max. loss), promising a robust CsI calorimeter
85% 60%
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 30
]
2
/cm
1MeV
Integrated flux [n 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800
9
10 I [mA] 10 20 30 40 50 60
Entries 102900 Mean 90.04 Mean y 33.18 RMS 63.51 RMS y 33.26Time [ns] 50 100 150 200 Amplitude [mV] 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160
Entries 102900 Mean 90.04 Mean y 33.18 RMS 63.51 RMS y 33.26 Entries 102900 Mean 90.09 Mean y 60.63 RMS 63.51 RMS y 110.6Time [ns] 50 100 150 200 Amplitude [mV] 100 200 300 400 500
Entries 102900 Mean 90.09 Mean y 60.63 RMS 63.51 RMS y 110.6150 sensors: 3×50 Mu2e pre-production SiPMs from Hamamatsu, SenSl and AdvanSiD
Gain Mu2e custom silicon photosensors: à 2 arrays of 3 6 x 6 mm2 UV-extended SiPMs: total area (12x18) mm2 The readout series configuration reduces the overall capacitanceàfaster signals ~ 150 V i1≈ i2 ≈ i3 Ctot ≈ C1/3
6x6 mm2 K1 A1
A1-1 A1-2
Single cell of 6 x 6 mm2 Series of 3 cells
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 31
We need to cool down SiPMs at 0 ° Neutron test Hamamatsu SenSl AdvanSiD
t [ns] ∆ 2 − 1.5 − 1 − 0.5 − 0.5 1 1.5 2 Entries / (0.075 ns) 50 100 150 200 250
Entries 1633 / ndf 2 χ 29.69 / 21 Constant 7.2 ± 225.1 Mean 0.0054 ± 0.1647 Sigma 0.0043 ± 0.2131June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 32
Time [ns] 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 340 Amplitude [mV] 50 100 150 200
10%max
90%max
=T
rise
T = 29 ns
rise
Hamamatsu - T = 38 ns
rise
SensL - T = 37 ns
rise
AdvanSiD - T
Ebeam = 100 MeV Energy fluctuation CF discriminator
Entries 1857 / ndf 2 c 18.68 / 23 Constant 7.0 ± 237.8 Mean 0.0054 ± 0.1584 Sigma 0.0042 ± 0.2313t [ns] D 2
1 1.5 2 Entries / (0.075 ns) 50 100 150 200 250
Entries 1857 / ndf 2 c 18.68 / 23 Constant 7.0 ± 237.8 Mean 0.0054 ± 0.1584 Sigma 0.0042 ± 0.2313σT ~ 115±2ps SensL σT ~ 106.5±2.1ps
Entries 1531 / ndf
219.56 / 15 Constant 7.6 240.9 Mean 0.0049 0.1664 Sigma 0.0035 0.1874
t [ns] 1.5 1 0.5 0.5 1 1.5 Entries / (0.075 ns) 50 100 150 200 250
Entries 1531 / ndf
219.56 / 15 Constant 7.6 240.9 Mean 0.0049 0.1664 Sigma 0.0035 0.1874
σT ~ 93.5±2ps AdvanSiD
Hamamatsu
Mu2e
strongly suppressed in SM: BR ≤10-54 à Observation indicates New Physics
e conversion in a nucleus field à discovery sensitivity on many NP models
104 improvement w.r.t. current limit (SINDRUM II) (@ 90% CL, with ~ 1018 stopped muons in 3 years of running)
Contact dominated Loop dominated
µ-e conversion in the presence of a nucleus
< 8 x 10-17
Nuclear captures of muonic Al atoms
µ e Al
arXiv: 1303.4907 June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 33
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 34
Noise width in the new charge increase linearly with the number of crystals added
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 35
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 36
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 37
20 40 60 80 100 [MeV]
MC
E 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 Q [pC]
/ ndf
2
χ 89.91 / 4 p 0.02236 ± 12.47 / ndf
2
χ 89.91 / 4 p 0.02236 ± 12.47 pC to MeV = 1 / p = 0.0802
38
With a CRV inefficiency of 10-4 an additional rejection factor of ~ 200 is needed to have < 0.1 fake events from cosmics in the signal window
A rejection factor of 200 can be achieved with ~ 95% efficiency for CE
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 38
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 39
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 40
flash (interaction of proton beam on target)
~ 100 krad, 1012 n/cm2
~ 1012 n1MeVeq/cm2
This includes a safety factor
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 41
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 42
Mu2e Collaboration, November 2013
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 43
Mu2e Collaboration, November 2013
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 44
Mu2e Collaboration, November 2013
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 45
Mu2e Collaboration, November 2013 µN→eN µ→eγ µ→eee Loops dominate for κ << 1 Contact terms dominate for κ >> 1 κ µN→eN µ→eγ µ→eee
Λ (TeV)
June 11, 2019 NP19 - Mu2e Calorimeter, R.Donghia 46