Collaborative Modeling Collaborative Modeling Incorporating new - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Collaborative Modeling Collaborative Modeling

Incorporating new technologies into the collaborative process Incorporating new technologies into the collaborative process

FRAME Project FRAME Project

• Christine Turner: US Geological Survey

Christine Turner: US Geological Survey

• Jimmie Chew: Rocky Mountain Research Station

Jimmie Chew: Rocky Mountain Research Station

• George Leavesley: Colorado State University

George Leavesley: Colorado State University

FRAME Project FRAME Project Mesa Verde National Park Mesa Verde National Park

Collaborative Ecosystem Collaborative Ecosystem Management Management

GREM GOVERNANCE Top-down Bottom-up

GREM 1980s-------- Contemporary 1960s----------- Conservation 1900s----------- Preservation

• ----late 1800s-

GOVERNANCE Top-down Bottom-up ROLE OF PUBLIC Consultative Participatory ROLE OF SCIENCE Dominate politics Balance with politics

Weber, E. P., (2000) A new vanguard for the environment: Grass-roots ecosystem management as a new environmental movement, Society and Natural Resources, 13:237-259.

Fundamental Paradox Fundamental Paradox

American Policy Formation Open Process Technical Competence

Daniels, S.E., & Walker, G.B. (2001) Working through environmental conflict: the collaborative learning approach, Westport, CT: Praeger.

Decision Decision-Making Making

Grounds for decisions Deliberative discourse Scientific discourse

Daniels, S.E., & Walker, G.B. (2001) Working through environmental conflict: the collaborative learning approach, Westport, CT: Praeger.

Collaborative Learning Collaborative Learning

Scientific Discourse Deliberative Discourse

Collaborative Learning Collaborative Learning

Identify Problem Describe Problem Implement Dialogue about interests/concer ns Develop Improvements Compare Models with Reality Deliberate about change

Daniels, S.E., & Walker, G.B. (2001) Working through environmental conflict: the collaborative learning approach, Westport, CT: Praeger.

Collaborative Modeling Collaborative Modeling

Deliberative Discourse Scientific Discourse

“Finding ways to increase the quality of technical “Finding ways to increase the quality of technical expertise, while simultaneously increasing the expertise, while simultaneously increasing the inclusivity of decision processes, is perhaps the inclusivity of decision processes, is perhaps the inclusivity of decision processes, is perhaps the inclusivity of decision processes, is perhaps the fundamental challenge of effective policy formation.” fundamental challenge of effective policy formation.”

Daniels, S.E., & Walker, G.B. (2001) Daniels, S.E., & Walker, G.B. (2001) Working through environmental conflict: Working through environmental conflict: the collaborative learning approach, the collaborative learning approach, Westport, CT: Praeger, p. 4. Westport, CT: Praeger, p. 4.

FRAME FRAME Project Project

Mesa Verde Mesa Verde National Park National Park

Deliberative Discourse

National Park National Park

a prototype for a prototype for collaborative collaborative modeling modeling

Scientific Discourse