Annie E. Fales Elementary School Westborough, MA July 12, 2018 H - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

SCHOOL BUILDING COMMITTEE Annie E. Fales Elementary School Westborough, MA July 12, 2018 H M F H A R C H I T E C T S

MSBA Module 3 Feasibility Study • 3.1 Preliminary Design Program • 3.2 MSBA Review of Preliminary Design Program • 3.3 Preferred Schematic Report • 3.4 Approval to Proceed into Schematic Design MSBA Module 4 Schematic Design • 4.1 Schematic Design Submittal • 4.2 MSBA Review and Approval of Schematic Design

3.1 Preliminary Design Program • Educational Program • Initial Space Summary • Evaluation of Existing Conditions • Site Development Requirements • Preliminary Evaluation of Alternatives • Local Actions and Approvals

3.1.6 Preliminary Evaluation of Alternatives No Build OPTION 6 Renovation Only OPTION 5 Renovation / Addition OPTION 4 New Construction OPTION 3B New Construction OPTION 3A New Construction OPTION 2 New Construction OPTION 1B New Construction OPTION 1A Accommodates 400 Students Supports Educational Program Goals Meets Code and Facility Condition Requirements Maximizes Land for program Uses Minimizes Impact on Classrooms During - Construction Minimizes Impact on Site - Use During Construction Construction Duration 30 20 20 20 20 20 - - (in months) $32.3 $33.5 $33.2 $33.3 $32.9 $33.7 Estimated Construction - - Cost (in millions) $3.1 Estimated Swing Space - - - - - - - Cost (in millions) $__ $__ $__ $__ $__ $__ Estimated Project Cost - - (in millions) Does Not Meet Criteria Partially Meets Criteria Meets Criteria

Option 1A

Arrowhead Lane Enrollment: 400 Students 3rd Grades: K - Demolition: 50,690 GSF F a l e s Renovation: 0 GSF S c h o o l New Construction: 68,735 GSF Total Area: 68,735 GSF Estimated Cost: ECC: $34,83,766 ETPC: $45,348,909 Eli Whitney Street

LOADING E C I V R E S W W O L O E L E B B F O F O O R O R STOR M Y G M Y G W O L B E MECH EXIT TO PLAY 3 AREA & N FIELDS 3 CR E H C T 3 K I CR N E C H T K I 2 W STAIR O CR L B E SPED 2 STOR 2 CR STAIR STAIR V E CR O B CR A CAFETERIA E L V L E D R 3 V E O K B SPED A E L V L E A D R I R E R 3 E T K CR P F STAGE C A W O S E L M B K CR R STOR P STAGE K WK CR BELOW CR 3 ADMINISTRATION MEDIA CENTER 3 ART CR MAIN K 2 CR ENTRANCE MUSIC CR 2 CR MECH T O CR STAIR MECH T 1 P BELOW STAIR STAIR 1 CR WK 1 CR 1 CR T X I E 1 CR CR UPPER STUDENT ENTRANCE Second Floor First Floor Third Floor

Option 1B

Arrowhead Lane Enrollment: 400 Students 3rd Grades: K - Demolition: 50,690 GSF F a l e s Renovation: 0 GSF S c h o o l New Construction: 67,520 GSF Total Area: 67,520 GSF Estimated Cost: ECC: $34,113,396 ETPC: $44,347,415 Eli Whitney Street

W O E L B F O R O ROOF M Y M BELOW G Y G W L O E B LOADING E C 3 I V R E STOR S 3 CR 3 CR 2 CR STAGE STAGE 2 MECH/ CR STAIR STAIR STAIR BELOW SPED 2 CR STOR N E R WK H C CR T I K K V E STOR P O MEDIA B CAFETERIA K SPED S A CR M E L A V R I L E T E D E R R A F 3 CENTER C P W Y K LG L O L A CR E P B O T S I T L D E X E MEDIA F I K & CR GP A R E CENTER A STAIR STAIR CR BELOW STAIR 3 3 CR T R A ADMINISTRATION 2 CR K 2 MUSIC CR CR T O WK CR 1 T P 1 CR K O T I T E X A 1 R E CR A Y A P L 1 CR 1 MAIN CR ENTRANCE CR Third Floor Second Floor First Floor

Option 2

Arrowhead Lane Enrollment: 400 Students 3rd Grades: K - Demolition: 50,690 GSF F a Renovation: 0 GSF l e s S c h New Construction: 68,120 GSF o o l Total Area: 68,120 GSF Estimated Cost: ECC: $34,462,625 ETPC: $44,801,112 Eli Whitney Street

N E I A C M N A R T N E First Floor R I A T S N EXIT TO PLAY O I AREA & FIELDS T CAFETERIA A R T G S N I N I I D M A D O A L KITCHEN STAGE SERVICE STAIR T OT I X E PT R I 3RD LEVEL ABOVE M A Y T G S Second Floor R I A T S A I D R E E M T N E C CAFETERIA C I BELOW S U M T R A STAGE BELOW STAIR MECH / STORAGE R I A T GYM BELOW S Third Floor 3 CR R I A T S 3 2 CR CR PR 2 CR 3 CR 2 MS CR 3 PR WK CR 1 R 3 C CR 1 R 2 C CR 1 R 2 C CR 1 D R E C P S 1 D R R E C P I K S A T R C S K T I X E R C K R WK C K R C K R C

Option 3A

Arrowhead Lane Enrollment: 400 Students K - 3rd Grades: Demolition: 50,690 GSF F a l e s Renovation: 0 GSF S c h o o l New Construction: 68,735 GSF Temporary Parking Total Area: 68,735 GSF Estimated Cost: ECC: $34,396,047 ETPC: $44,714,861 Eli Whitney Street

EXIT 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 1 3 WK MECH / STORAGE 1 CR MECH R R CR CR I CR D CR D CR I MUSIC A A CR CR CR ART T CR T E /STOR S E S P P S S SERVICE O T KITCHEN K 2 PR STAIR STAIR P T M E D I A C R CR MS C E N T E R LOADING MEDIA CENTER BELOW K 2 S CAFETERIA Y D A C R L CR L E E P I F PR O G S T A G E & C A F E T E T R I A G Y M GYM B E L O W T A A B E L O W B I E E L O W W K X R K T E K A K S 2 2 C R 2 C R C R CR CR CR STAIR STAIR MAIN ENTRANCE ADMINISTRATION ROOF BELOW Second Floor First Floor

Option 3B

Arrowhead Lane Enrollment: 400 Students K - 3rd Grades: Demolition: 50,690 GSF F a l e s Renovation: 0 GSF S c h o o l New Construction: 69,055 GSF T e m p Total Area: 69,055 GSF o r a r y P a r Estimated Cost: ECC: $34,681,653 k i n g ETPC: $45,086,149 Eli Whitney Street

EXIT R R MECH / STORAGE I I A A T T S S MECH LOADING ART MUSIC 3 /STOR 1 3 1 3 1 CR CR CR CR CR CR SERVICE 1 3 KITCHEN CR CR O T P T PR 3 1 S P E D CR S P E D CR CAFETERIA MS GYM E G Y M K 2 C A F E T E R I A G B E L O W S B E L O W T A G E MEDIA C CR A M R E D I B E L O A W CENTER T BELOW C E N T S E R PR 2 K WK W K CR C R STAIR STAIR E X I T T O P L A Y A R MAIN E A & F I E L D S STAIR STAIR ENTRANCE K K K 2 2 2 C R C R C R CR CR CR ADMINISTRATION ROOF BELOW Second Floor First Floor

Option 4

Arrowhead Lane Enrollment: 400 Students K - 3rd Grades: Demolition: 4,700 GSF F a l e s Renovation: 40,290 GSF S c h o o l New Construction: 33,225 GSF Temporary Parking Temporary Parking Total Area: 73,515 GSF Estimated Cost: ECC: $38,429,809 ETPC: $49,958,712 Eli Whitney Street

LOADING SERVICE Second Floor N GYM E H C T I E K C E N N R I A A I G A M R T A T S N T E EXIT TO PLAY S AREA & FIELDS CAFETERIA N O I T A R T S I N I M D R A I A T S MEDIA CENTER BELOW First Floor R I A T W O S L E B L E V E L R I A A I D T R E E S M T N E C SPED R I A T S PR CRAWL SPACE MECH ART R I A T S WK MUSIC CRAWL SPACE R I A T S Fourth Floor ROOF BELOW GYM BELOW 3 CR R I A T S 3 CR 3 CR 3 CR PR 3 CR E C M R V I W Y W R G E O O I S L L A E E Third Floor B B T S STAIR E G A W T S O L E B A I R E T E W F O A C L E B N O T I A R T S W I N O M I L E D B A K ROOF BELOW CR R I A D T E S P S MEDIA CENTER BELOW K CR K 1 CR CR SM K GP CR 1 K CR 1 CR CR 1 CR PR 2 1 CR CR 2 R CR I A SM T S GP WK 2 CR 2 CR R I PR A T S 2 CR