A presentation by hilldickinson.com Gross Negligence Manslaughter - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

hilldickinson.com

A presentation by

Gross Negligence Manslaughter

Emma Galland Partner emma.galland@hilldickinson.com 020 7280 9294

hilldickinson.com

Contents

• What is the current position
• Recent cases:

– Dr Sellu – Dr Bawa-Garba

• Williams Review
• Current position/what about the future?

hilldickinson.com

Gross Negligence Manslaughter (GNM): Legal Definition (1)

• No separate offence of Medical Manslaughter: GNM

applies

• Common law offence: R v Adomako [1994] 3 WLR 288

– Existence of a duty of care to the deceased – Breach of duty of care – Causes (or significantly contributes to) the death of the victim – Breach should be characterised as gross negligence

hilldickinson.com

Gross Negligence Manslaughter: Legal Definition (2)

“…the offence of [GNM] requires breach of existing duty of care which it is reasonably foreseeable gives rise to a serious and obvious risk of death and does, in fact, cause death in circumstances where, having regard to the risk of death the conduct of the defendant was so bad in all the circumstances as to go beyond the requirement of compensation and to amount to a criminal act or

• mission”

R v Rose [2017] EWCA Crim 1168

hilldickinson.com

Context

• Prosecutions of healthcare professionals for GNM since

1994:

– 38 deaths – Prosecutions of 47 healthcare professionals (37 doctors, 9 nurses, 1

• ptometrist)

– 23 convicted; 4 overturned on appeal

• Since 2013

– 9 deaths – 15 healthcare professionals – 6 convictions; 2 overturned on appeal

hilldickinson.com

Dr Sellu – the facts

• 2100: 11 February 2010 – 2200: 12 February 2010

– Not asking a radiologist to review whether there was free gas in the abdomen – Not asking RMO to commence antibiotics (or not documenting in medical records that RMO was asked) – Not requesting a CT scan that evening – requesting in the morning – No documented visit the following morning – No discussion with the nursing staff/RMO as to Ps condition in the morning

• Consultant Surgeon: Higher standard of care

hilldickinson.com

Dr Sellu: Outcome

• Prison sentence: 2.5 years
• 15 months served in prison
• Conviction quashed in 2016
• Returned to work under supervision
• GMC pursued FTP proceedings
• 6.3.2018 – MPTS found GMC’s allegations not proved

hilldickinson.com

Dr Bawa-Garba: Case Details

• February 2011: 6 year old Jack Adcock was admitted to

the Children’s Assessment Unit (CAU) at Leicester Royal Infirmary

• Presenting with Down’s Syndrome, a cardiac condition,

difficulty breathing, vomiting and diarrhoea

• Dr Bawa Garba ( Dr BG) was responsible for Jack’s

care

• No senior Consultant available
• Dr BG solely responsible for CAU

hilldickinson.com

Case details ( 2)

• Blood tests ordered at 10.45am results given 4.15pm
• No request for Consultant review
• Enalapril (drug given for heart failure) not discontinued
• One hour later Jack “crashed”
• Dr Bawa Garba confused him with another patient and

briefly put a stop to the CPR – this action was not thought to contribute to his death

• 9.20 pm Jack died of cardiac arrest as a result of sepsis

hilldickinson.com

Court proceedings (1)

• January 2015 - MPTS hearing: 18m suspension

pending conclusion of GMC FTP investigation

• March 2015: Dr Bawa-Garba successfully appeals

MPTS suspension

• November 2015: Criminal Proceedings – found guilty

and receives 2 year prison sentence (suspended)

• December 2016: Dr Bawa-Garba is denied permission

to appeal

hilldickinson.com

Court Proceedings (2)

• 12/13 June 2017: MPTS suspends Dr Bawa-Garba for

12 months. GMC’s application to strike Dr Bawa-Garba

• ff the register rejected
• 30 June 2017: GMC appeals against decision not to

strike off Dr Bawa Garba

• 25 January 2018: GMC’s appeal is successful: Dr

Bawa-Garba’s suspension is substituted for erasure

• August 2018: Dr Bawa-Garba successfully appeals
• April 2019: Dr Bawa-Garba’s suspension lifted (subject

to conditions)

hilldickinson.com

Meanwhile…

• February 2018: Jeremy Hunt (the SoS for Health)

announces review of manslaughter in healthcare

• March 2018: LMC representatives back a vote of no

confidence in the GMC. There are calls for doctors to disengage from written reflection

• June 2018: Williams Review (into manslaughter in

healthcare) is published

hilldickinson.com

Williams Review: Recommendations (1)

• Agreed and clear position on the law of GNM
• Improving assurance and consistency in the use of

experts

• Consolidating expertise of GNM in healthcare settings

in support of investigations

• Improving quality of local investigations
• Review of how healthcare professionals conduct

reflection

hilldickinson.com

Williams Review: Recommendations (2)

• Remove GMC’s right to appeal MPTS decisions [NB:

PSA to retain its right of appeal]

• Consistency of FTP decisions across the regulators
• Diversity of FTP proceedings
• Review of legal representation in FTP proceedings
• Support for familys/patients in FTP proceedings

hilldickinson.com

Where are we now?

• Cultural Change in healthcare?
• Health Select Committee to examine GNM in

healthcare: Offence of Medical Manslaughter?

• Overwhelming dissatisfaction with the GMC

“A lightening rod for the dissatisfaction of doctors and medical staff”

• Concerns by clinicians as to the status of reflective

practice – not privileged

About the firm

• An international commercial law firm
• More than 850 people, including 175 partners and legal directors
• Offices in the UK, mainland Europe and Asia
• Over 200 years of heritage
• Full-service offering
• Specialists in a wide range of market sectors
• Comprehensive corporate responsibility programme of activity

hilldickinson.com

A presentation by