SLIDE 1
7/20/2017 https://www.sog.unc.edu/resources/microsites/indigent - - PDF document
7/20/2017 https://www.sog.unc.edu/resources/microsites/indigent - - PDF document
7/20/2017 https://www.sog.unc.edu/resources/microsites/indigent defense education 1 7/20/2017 Hodari D . and S v. Mangum , p. 3 2 7/20/2017 A Fourth Amendment violation would likely have occurred if Lt.
SLIDE 2
SLIDE 3
7/20/2017 3
“A Fourth Amendment violation would likely have occurred if Lt. Andrews had stopped defendant’s vehicle based solely on the tip.” Slip op. at 26.
SLIDE 4
7/20/2017 4
- WasWilsonseizedbytheofficerwhenhestopped
histruck?
- Courtofappeals:No,hewasnotseized.
- Officerwasalone
- Hedidnotdrawhisweapon
- Lightsandsirenoff
- NolanguageortonethatindicatedWilsonhadtostop
- Wilsonwasintruckandcouldhavedrivenaroundpolice
car
SLIDE 5
7/20/2017 5
- ReasonableSuspicion
- InnocentFactors
SLIDE 6
7/20/2017 6
SLIDE 7
7/20/2017 7
ODonnell v.HarrisCounty
SLIDE 8
7/20/2017 8
Preservetherecord! Please. Walker,p.57;Malachi,p.54
SLIDE 9
7/20/2017 9 NoObjection Objection
SLIDE 10
7/20/2017 10
SLIDE 11
7/20/2017 11
forexample,byfailingtoinflictaseriousinjury
Statev.Floyd,NCSC,p.40
SLIDE 12
7/20/2017 12
- Courtofappealstakes
anotherlookat retrogradeextrapolation testimony
SLIDE 13
7/20/2017 13
- 7hourdelaybetweenarrest
andinitialappearance
- Ct:Defendantcannotshow
prejudice
- Advisedofimpliedconsentand
Miranda rights
- Didnotexerciserighttohave
witnessesorattorneypresent
SLIDE 14
7/20/2017 14
SLIDE 15
7/20/2017 15
SLIDE 16
7/20/2017 16
- Justvisiting
- Didn’tknowaboutpresenceofweed
- Nopossessoryinterestinhouse
- Nopaymentforupkeep
- Nokeytohouse
- Nofingerprintsoncontraband
- Noincriminatingevidenceonperson
punishable
“offense” “guilty”
- ffense
conditions
- ffense
conditionspresent “punishable” recidivist
- Defendant“punished”
asfelonyifrecidivist
SLIDE 17
7/20/2017 17
- Defendantfiredasingleshotintoacaratcloserange,
killingthevictim.
- Isthisfelonymurder?
- Yes,sayscourtofappeals
- Mergerruledoesnotapply
- Noexceptiontofelonymurderrulefordischarginga
weaponintooccupiedproperty
- Mergerrulemaybarfelonymurderchargesifdefendant
commitsoneassault crimeagainstonevictim,killing victim
SLIDE 18
7/20/2017 18
SLIDE 19