What Does Quality Mean? Operational meanings: CISC 323: Intro to - - PDF document

what does quality mean
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

What Does Quality Mean? Operational meanings: CISC 323: Intro to - - PDF document


slide-1
SLIDE 1

1

✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

CISC 323: Intro to Software Engineering

✤✦✥★✧✪✩✬✫✮✭✰✯✲✱✴✳✮✵✶✭✸✷✺✹✻✩✽✼ ✔ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

What Does Quality Mean?

  • Operational meanings:

– Software does what is wanted and expected – On budget and on schedule – Users are happy – Level of bugginess is tolerable – Changes are not too expensive – Software is cost-effective in use and supports

  • rganizational mandate
✒ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Definitions of Quality

  • OED: the standard of something when compared to other

things like it (a wine of excellent quality); of high quality, general excellence

  • Crosby: zero defects
  • ISO: The totality of features and characteristics of a product
  • r service that bear on its ability to satisfy specified or implied

needs.

  • Juran: Fitness for Purpose
  • DoD: The degree to which the attributes of the software

enable it to perform its intended end use.

✾ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Quality is Relative

  • Rolls Royce: quality when cost is no object
  • Ford Taurus: quality tradeoffs when cost

is a factor

  • Mini: minimum acceptable quality when

cost is the dominant factor.

  • Costs include initial cost, cost of operation, and

cost of repairs.

✿ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Quality -- General

  • is multidimensional (all aspects of a car)
  • is subject to constraints (e.g. cars must fit on

roads)

  • is about acceptable compromises (e.g. poorer

ride for lower cost)

  • criteria are not independent (e.g. fuel use vs.

vehicle weight)

  • is not absolute (all levels of cars have quality)
❀ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Characteristics of Software

  • not physical
  • needs are usually uncertain
  • needs change
  • platforms change (CPUs, OS, network)
  • high expectations, especially of adaptability
slide-2
SLIDE 2

2

✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Changing Approaches to Software Quality

  • increasing use of metrics
  • increasing emphasis on process, components

and intermediate products, as opposed to the end product

  • software crisis persists, but progress is being

made

✁ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Dimensions of Quality

  • A Partial List:

– Timeliness – Functionality – Cost – Correctness – Reliability – Maintainability

✂ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Quality - Software

  • is multidimensional (portability, usability, functionality)
  • is subject to constraints (regulations, rules,

resources)

  • is about acceptable compromises (e.g. less

functionality / lower cost)

  • criteria are not independent (e.g. efficiency vs

maintainability)

  • is not absolute (different levels of quality are

acceptable for different software types

✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

How can the Dimensions of Quality be assured?

☎✝✆✟✞✡✠☞☛✍✌ ✎☞✆✑✏ ✒ ☛✔✓✑✒ ✕☞✖✗✎✑✕☞✘✗✠✑✕✚✙ ✛✑✜ ✢✣✒ ✕☞✖✗✎✗✤✑✜ ✛☞✢✔✠☞☛✔☛ ☎✝✤✑✜ ✛✑✢✔✠☞☛✥☛✧✦✩★☞☛✍✌✪✒ ✕☞✢✣✏ ★☞✘☞✠✫✦✧✠☞✎☞☛✔★✑✜ ✠✑✦✧✠✑✕✟✌ ☎✝✆✟✞✬✦✧✎✑✭✣✒ ✕☞✖✗☛✣★✑✜ ✠✗✠✟✮✟✠☞✜ ✞✟✛✯✕☞✠✗★✑✕✣✘✑✠✑✜ ☛✰✌ ✎✑✕☞✘✑☛✱✌ ✓☞✠✩✲✑★☞✎✑✏ ✒ ✌ ✒ ✠☞☛ ✌ ✓☞✎✟✌✪✦✗★✣☛✍✌✪✆☞✠✩✠✑✦✩✆☞✠☞✘✑✘☞✠☞✘✫✒ ✕✡✌ ✓☞✠✗✤✑✜ ✛☞✘✯★☞✢✍✌ ☎✝✆✟✞✬✭✔✠☞✠✑✤✑✒ ✕✣✖✬✙ ✛☞✢✣★☞☛✔✠☞✘✗✛✑✕✡✌ ✓☞✠✗✜ ✠✑✏ ✠✟✮✟✎✑✕✟✌✳✲✯★☞✎☞✏ ✒ ✌ ✒ ✠☞☛ ✌ ✓✑✜ ✛✑★☞✖✯✓✣✛✯★✚✌✴✌ ✓☞✠✩✘✑✠✟✮✟✠✑✏ ✛✯✤☞✦✩✠✑✕✚✌✵✏ ✒ ✙ ✠☞✢✍✞✟✢✣✏ ✠ ☎✝✆✟✞✡✘✑✠✟✌ ✠✑✜ ✦✗✒ ✕☞✒ ✕☞✖✡✶✚★✑✤✡✙ ✜ ✛✑✕✟✌ ✷✸✓☞✛✺✹✻✌ ✛✗✎☞✢✣✓✑✒ ✠✟✮✟✠✩✠☞✎☞✢✣✓ ✲✯★✣✎✑✏ ✒ ✌ ✞ ☎✼✮✟✠✑✜ ✒ ✙ ✒ ✢✔✎✟✌ ✒ ✛✑✕✗✎☞✕☞✘✬✮✟✎✑✏ ✒ ✘✑✎✟✌ ✒ ✛✑✕
✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Cost of Quality

☎✝✤✑✜ ✠✟✮✟✠✑✕✟✌ ✒ ✛✑✕ ✽✿✾✣❀✥❁✔❂ ❃ ❄ ❅✱❆✥❂ ❁✔❇✔❇✔❃ ❇✥❈ ✽❊❉ ❋✣● ❍✸❁✔❂✰❄ ■✥❏✥❑✔❇✔❃ ❏ ❁✣❂✥● ■✍▲✍❃ ■✰▼✳◆ ✽❊❄ ■✔◆ ❄✺■✥✾✣❀✔❃ ❆✥❍✸■✔❇✰❄ ✽❊❄
  • ❁✔❃
❇✔❃ ❇✥❈ ☎❖✎✑✤✑✤☞✜ ✎✑✒ ☛✥✎✑✏ ✽P❃ ❇✥◗ ❆✔● ❋✔❏ ■✥◆ ◆❙❘✗❃ ❇✰❄ ■✔● ❆✔● ❋✔❏ ■✥◆ ◆ ❃ ❇✥◆❚❆✥■✥❏ ❄ ❃ ❋✣❇ ✽✿■✥✾✣❀✔❃ ❆✥❍✸■✔❇✰❄✺❏❚❁✔❂ ❃ ❯✥● ❁✰❄ ❃ ❋✣❇✸❘ ❍✸❁✔❃ ❇✰❄ ■✔❇✥❁✔❇✥❏❚■ ✽❊❄ ■✔◆ ❄ ❃ ❇✥❈ ☎✼✙ ✎☞✒ ✏ ★✑✜ ✠✩❱❲✒ ✕✚✌ ✠✑✜ ✕☞✎✑✏ ✽P● ■✰▼✳❋✣● ❳ ✽P● ■✔❆✥❁✔❃
  • ✽❊❉
❁✔❃ ❂ ❀✔● ■✸❍✸❋✔❨✔■✸❁✔❇✥❁✔❂ ❅✰◆❚❃ ◆ ☎✼✙ ✎☞✒ ✏ ★✑✜ ✠✩❱✸✠✟❩✔✌ ✠✑✜ ✕☞✎✑✏ ✽✿❏❚❋✥❍❲❆✔❂ ❁✔❃ ❇✰❄❬● ■✔◆ ❋✔❂ ❀✰❄ ❃ ❋✔❇ ✽P❆✔● ❋✔❨✔❀✥❏ ❄❬● ■✍❄ ❀✔● ❇✸❘
  • ■✔❆✔❂
❁✥❏❚■✥❍✸■✔❇✰❄ ✽P❑✥■✔❂ ❆❲❂ ❃ ❇✥■✸◆❚❀✔❆✔❆✥❋✣● ❄ ✽❊▼✳❁✔●
  • ❁✔❇✰❄
❅✴▼✳❋✣● ❳
✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Views of Quality (not software specific)

❭❫❪❵❴ ❛✴❜✯❝☞❞☞❡✴❜❙❢❙❡✴❜✯❣❚❛✴❤ ✐❦❥✟❡✴❧❙❴❚❡✴♠☞❛❲♥ ♦✥♣❫❥✟❣✥q❙❡sr ❢✴❡✯❛✴❤ ♦ ❭✝t❲❝☞❡❙❴✣✐✴✉✥r ❣❚❜❙❡❙❝✣❝✫✉ ✈✴❴✧✇✴❧❙❴✥✇✯✈✴❝✣❡ ❭②①✩❛✴❜❙❧❙✉ ❛❙❞☞❣✥❧❙❴✥r ❜❙③❲✐✸❞☞✈✴❜❙✉ ✈✴❴✥④❊❛✴❜✯❞☞❡s❣❚✈s❝✑✇✯❡❙❞ ❭②⑤✯❴❚✈❙❢✸❧✯❞✑❣✔✐✸❞✑q❙❛❙❴❚❛✯❞✑❣ ❡✴❴✥r ❝✣❣✥r ❞☞❝✫✈❙✉❲❣✥q❙❡s✇✴❴ ✈✴❢✴❧❙❞☞❣ ❭✼⑥✵❛✴❤ ❧✯❡✴⑦✥⑧✯❛❙❝✣❡❙❢❲✐✸⑨✫r ❤ ❤ r ❜✯③✸❜❙❡✯❝☞❝✗❣❚✈✻✇❙❛❬⑩
slide-3
SLIDE 3

3

✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

User View

❭❖❞☞❛✴❜s⑧❙❡sq✴r ③✸q❙❤ ⑩ ✇✯❡✴❴ ❝☞✈✴❜❙❛✴❤ r ✁ ❡❙❢ ❭❖❣ ⑩❦✇✴r ❞☞❛✴❤❙❧✯❝☞❡❙❴✄✂✳r ❡✯⑨✗❝❙✐ ☎ ✜ ✠✑✏ ✒ ✎☞✆✑✒ ✏ ✒ ✌ ✞ ☎ ✤☞✠✑✜ ✙ ✛✑✜ ✦✧✎✑✕☞✢✔✠ ☎ ★☞☛✥✎✑✆✑✒ ✏ ✒ ✌ ✞
✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

ISO 9126

source: http://www.cse.dcu.ie/essiscope/sm2/9126ref.html

✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Manufacturing View

❭❖❛✆✂❬✈✴r ❢ ❴❚❡✯⑨✗✈✴❴✥♠❊❛❙❜❙❢s❛❙❝☞❝✣✈❙❞✯r ❛✯❣❚❡✯❢✻❞☞✈❙❝☞❣❚❝ ❭❖✈❙✉ ❣❚❡✴❜s❤ ❡❙❛✯❢✴❝✫❣ ✈✻✇✴❴❚✈❙❞☞❡❙❝✣❝✫✉ ✈❙❞✯❧✯❝✞✝✠✟☛✡✌☞✎✍✑✏✑✏✓✒✯⑦✕✔✑✖ ❭✝✇❙❴❚✈❙❞✑❡✯❝☞❝✫❢❙✈❙❡❙❝✫❜❙✈❙❣ ③✴❧❙❛✴❴ ❛✴❜❙❣ ❡❙❡ ③✴✈❙✈❙❢ ✇❙❴❚✈❙❢✸❧✯❞☞❣❚❝✘✗ ✈✴❜✴❤ ⑩✿③✸❧❙❛❙❴❚❛❙❜❙❣❚❡✯❡❙❝❊❧❙❜✴r ✉ ✈✴❴✥④ r ❣ ⑩P✈❙✉❲✈✴❧❙❣✥✇❙❧❙❣
✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Product View

❭✝④ ❡✯❛❙❝☞❧✴❴❚❡sr ❜❙❣❚❡❙❴✥❜❙❛❙❤✯❞✑q❙❛❙❴❚❛❙❞☞❣❚❡❙❴✥r ❝☞❣❚r ❞✑❝✚✙ ☎✜✛ ✠☞✎☞☛✔★✑✜ ✠✑✦✧✠✑✕✟✌ ☛ ✢✣✓☞✛☞☛✔✠☞✕✗✘☞✠✑✤☞✠✑✕☞✘✗✛✑✕✡✌ ✞✺✤☞✠✩✛✺✙✪✤☞✜ ✛☞✘✯★☞✢✍✌ ✢ ✠✘✣ ✖✌✣✑✢✔✛☞✘✑✠✚✤✯✘✑✠☞☛✔✒ ✖✯✕✚✤✦✥✄✧ ☎ ✦✧✎✟✞ ✕✣✛✺✌✳✠✑✕☞☛✔★✑✜ ✠✩✲✯★☞✎✑✏ ✒ ✌ ✞✡✛✟✙✳✠✟❩✣✌ ✠✑✜ ✕☞✎✑✏✣✢✣✓☞✎✑✜ ✎✣✢✍✌ ✠✑✜ ✒ ☛✍✌ ✒ ✢✔☛ ❭✝④ ❡✯❛❙❝☞❧✴❴❚❡ ❡✆★❬❣❚❡✴❴❚❜❙❛❙❤✯❞✯q✯❛✴❴❚❛✯❞☞❣❚❡✴❴❚r ❝☞❣✥r ❞☞❝✘✙ ☎✪✩ ✛✑✜ ✜ ✠☞☛✔✤☞✛✑✕☞✘✑☛✱✌ ✛✫★✣☛✔✠✑✜ ✫✰✦✧✎✑✕✑★✟✙ ✎✣✢✍✌ ★✑✜ ✠✑✜❦✮✺✒ ✠✟✹❵☛ ☎ ✦✧✠☞✎☞☛✣★☞✜ ✠✑✦✧✠✑✕✟✌ ☛ ✢✣✓☞✛☞☛✔✠✑✕✩✘☞✠✑✤☞✠✑✕☞✘✗✛✑✕✗✤✑✜ ✛☞✘✯★☞✢✍✌ ✢ ✠✌✣ ✖✌✣ ✬✮✭ ✤❙☛✔✤✑✜ ✠☞✎✣✘✑☛✣✓✣✠☞✠✟✌ ✤✮✥✯✧
✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Value-based view

❭✝q❙❡❙❤ ✇❙❝✗❣❚✈s❢✴❡✯❞✯r ❢❙❡s❣❚❴❚❛❙❢❙❡✴⑦ ✈✴✉ ✉ ❝✫❢✴❧✴❴❚r ❜❙③ ❢❙❡✆✂❦❡❙❤ ✈✴✇✴④❊❡✴❜❙❣ ☎ ✢✔✛☞☛✍✌❙✮✟☛✚✣✑✜ ✠✑✏ ✒ ✎✑✆☞✒ ✏ ✒ ✌ ✞ ☎ ✢✔✛☞☛✍✌❙✮✟☛✚✣✟✙ ★✑✕☞✢✍✌ ✒ ✛✑✕☞✎✑✏ ✒ ✌ ✞ ❭❖❞☞✈❙❝☞❣ ❣❚✈s❞☞✈✴❜❙❝☞❧✴④ ❡❙❴✧r ❝✫❛✯✉ ✉ ❡❙❞☞❣❚❡❙❢✻⑧❬⑩P❝☞❞☞❛✴❤ ❡ ☎ ✓✑✒ ✖✑✓✬✮✟✛✑✏ ★✑✦✧✠✗✤✑✜ ✛☞✘✯★☞✢✍✌ ☛✧✓✣✎✟✮✟✠✗✎✗✓✑✒ ✖✑✓☞✠✑✜✴✤☞✠✑✜ ✢✔✠☞✒ ✮✟✠☞✘ ✮✟✎✑✏ ★☞✠ ❭✰✂❦❛❙❤ ❧❙❡sr ❝✫❢✴❡✯✉❚r ❜❙❡✯❢ ⑧❬⑩ ☎ ✤☞✛✟✌ ✠✑✕✟✌ ✒ ✎✑✏✣☛✥✎✟✮✺✒ ✕☞✖✑☛✱✫✍✤☞✜ ✛✑✘✑★☞✢✍✌ ✒ ✮✺✒ ✌ ✞✬✠☞✕✑✓☞✎✑✕☞✢✔✠✑✦✧✠✑✕✚✌ ☛ ☎ ✤✑✜ ✛✺✙ ✒ ✌✪✛✑✤✑✤✣✛✯✜ ✌ ★☞✕✑✒ ✌ ✒ ✠☞☛
✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Problems with Qualities

❭✳✲✴❧❙❛✴❤ r ❣❚r ❡❙❝✫❛❙❴❚❡s❛✯❣ ✈❙❢❙❢✴❝✫⑨✫r ❣✥q ✈✴❜❙❡s❛❙❜❙✈❙❣✥q✯❡✴❴ ☎ ✎✑✏ ✹✱✎✟✞✟☛ ✎✩✢✔✛✯✦✩✤✑✜ ✛✑✦✩✒ ☛✔✠ ✴ ❆✥❋✔● ❄ ❁✔❯✔❃ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❅✴▲✍■✔● ◆❚❀✥◆✴❆✥■✔● ❉ ❋✔● ❍✸❁✣❇✥❏ ■ ✴ ◆ ■✥❏✥❀✔● ❃ ❄ ❅✸▲✰■✣● ◆❚❀✥◆❦❉ ❁✔❀✔❂ ❄☞❄ ❋✔❂ ■✔● ❁✣❇✥❏ ■ ✴ ❍✸❋✔❨✣❀✔❂ ❁✣● ❃ ❄ ❅✴▲✍■✔● ◆❚❀✥◆❙■✍❉ ❉ ❃ ❏✥❃ ■✔❇✥❏ ❅ ❭❖❢✴r ✉❚✉❚r ❞✑❧✴❤ ❣ ⑩ r ❜s❣❚❴ ⑩✳r ❜✯③✻❣❚✈✻④❊❡❙❛✯❝✑❧✴❴❚❡✵✲✸❧✯❛✴❤ r ❣✥r ❡✯❝✫❡✦✶ ③✮✶ ♣ ❛❙❞☞❞✑❧✴❴ ❛❙❞✟⑩❦♣❲❧❙❝☞❛❙⑧✴r ❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❭❖⑨✫q❙❛✯❣ ❢✴✈❙❡✯❝✷✲✴❧❙❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❴❚❡✯❛✴❤ ❤ ⑩P④ ❡✯❛✴❜✦✙
slide-4
SLIDE 4

4

✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Proposed solution 1: Focus on Product

❭✝④ ✈❙❝✣❣ ❢✸r ④❊❡✴❜✯❝✑r ✈✴❜❙❝✫✈❙✉✓✲✴❧❙❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩P❛✴❴ ❡✻④❊❡❙❛✯❝✑❧✴❴ ❡❙❢ ❛❙✉ ❣ ❡✴❴ ❣✥q✯❡s✉ ❛✯❞✑❣ ❭✝❜❙❡✯❡❙❢s❣❚✈✻r ❢✴❡❙❜❙❣✥r ✉ ⑩✿❛❙❞☞❣✥r ✈✴❜❙❝✗❣✥q❙❛✯❣ ❞☞❛✴❜ ❡✴④s⑧✯❡❙❢ ❜❙❡✯❡❙❢❙❡❙❢ ✲✸❧✯❛✴❤ r ❣✥r ❡✯❝❊r ❜s❣❚q❙❡✻✇❙❴❚✈❙❢✴❧❙❞☞❣❚❝☞♣❲❧✴✇ ✉✥❴ ✈✸❜✯❣ ❭✝r ④s✇❙❤ ❡✴④❊❡✴❜✯❣❚❛❙❣❚r ✈✸❜✵✲✸❧✯❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩P④ ✈❙❢❙❡✴❤ ✐✸r ❢✴❡❙❜❙❣✥r ✉ ⑩P⑨✫q✯❛❙❣ ❣✥q✯❡✻✇❙❴❚✈❙③✸❴❚❛❙④s④❊❡✴❴❲❞✑❛❙❜s❢❙✈s❣❚✈s❡✴❜❙❝☞❧✴❴❚❡✵✲✸❧✯❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩ ☎ ✏ ✒ ✕✑✭✱✌ ✓☞✠☞☛✥✠✗✎☞✢✍✌ ✒ ✛✯✕☞☛✱✌ ✛✗✓✑✒ ✖✯✓✗✏ ✠✟✮✟✠✑✏✣✲✯★☞✎☞✏ ✒ ✌ ✒ ✠☞☛ ✔ ✄ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Proposed Solution 1 (cont’d)

❭✝❴❚❡✌✲✸❧❙r ❴❚❡✴④❊❡✴❜✯❣❚❝✷✲✴❧❙❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩ ④❊✈✴❢❙❡✴❤ ✐✴❛✴❤ ❤❙❴ ❡✑✲✴❧✴r ❴❚❡❙④ ❡❙❜❙❣ ❝☞❣ ❛❙❣❚❡❙④ ❡❙❜❙❣❚❝❊④ ❧❙❝✣❣✧⑧❙❡s④ ❡✯❛❙❝✑❧❙❴❚❛❙⑧✴❤ ❡ ❭❖❢❙❡❙❝✑r ③✴❜ ✲✴❧❙❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩ ④❊✈✴❢❙❡✴❤ ✐✴❢✴❡✯✉❚r ❜❙❡✵✲✸❧❙❛❙❤ r ❣✥r ❡✯❝✫✉ ✈✴❴ ❢❙❡❙❝✑r ③✴❜❙♣ r ❢❙❡✴❜✯❣✥r ✉ ⑩P❞✑q❙❛❙❴❚❛✯❞✑❣ ❡✴❴✥r ❝✣❣✥r ❞☞❝✫✈❙✉❲❢✴❡✯❝✑r ③✸❜ ❣✥q❙❛✯❣ ⑨✗✈✴❧✴❤ ❢s❡✴④ ⑧❙❡✯❢✻❣✥q✯✈✴❝✣❡ ✲✴❧❙❛❙❤ r ❣✥r ❡❙❝ ✔
✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Proposed solution 2: Focus on Process

❭✝r ❜❙❣ ❡❙③✴❴❚❛❙❣ ❡ ✲✸❧✯❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩P❢✴❡✯❞✑r ❝✑r ✈✴❜❙❝❊r ❜✯❣❚✈s❣✥q❙❡ ❢✴❡✯❝✑r ③✴❜ ✇❙❴❚✈❙❞✑❡✯❝☞❝☞♣✸❡✮✶ ③✓✶❚✐ ☎ ✆✟✞✬★☞☛✔✒ ✕☞✖✗✲✯★☞✎✑✏ ✒ ✌ ✞✬✢✣✓☞✠☞✢✣✭✣✏ ✒ ☛✰✌ ☛ ✘✯★✑✜ ✒ ✕☞✖ ✒ ✕☞☛✣✤✣✠☞✢✍✌ ✒ ✛✯✕ ✤ ✘✑✠☞☛✔✒ ✖✯✕ ☎ ✆✟✞✡✘✑✠✟✌ ✠✑✜ ✦✗✒ ✕☞✒ ✕☞✖✬✌ ✠☞☛✍✌ ✒ ✕✣✖✫✢✣✜ ✒ ✌ ✠✑✜ ✒ ✎✗★✑✤✡✙ ✜ ✛✑✕✟✌ ☎ ✆✟✞✧✙ ✛✑✏ ✏ ✛✟✹✡✒ ✕✣✖✫✎✩✘☞✛✑✢✣★✑✦✧✠✑✕✟✌ ✠✣✘✫✘☞✠☞☛✣✒ ✖✑✕✗✤✑✜ ✛☞✢✔✠☞☛✔☛ ✔ ✔ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Qualities Discernable at Runtime

❭✝✇✯❡✴❴❚✉ ✈✴❴✥④❊❛✴❜❙❞☞❡ ❭❖❝☞❡✯❞✑❧✴❴✥r ❣ ⑩ ❭❖❛✆✂❬❛✴r ❤ ❛❙⑧✴❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❭❖✉❚❧✴❜✯❞✑❣❚r ✈✸❜✯❛✴❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❭✝❧❙❝✣❛✴⑧❙r ❤ r ❣ ⑩ ✔ ✒ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Qualities Not Discernable at Runtime

❭✝④ ✈❙❢✴r ✉❚r ❛✴⑧❙r ❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❭✝✇✯✈✸❴ ❣❚❛✴⑧❙r ❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❭✝❴❚❡❙❧❙❝☞❛❙⑧✴r ❤ r ❣ ⑩ ❭❖❣❚❡✯❝☞❣❚❛❙⑧✴r ❤ r ❣ ⑩ ☎ ✠☞✎☞☛✥✠✬✹❵✒ ✌ ✓✡✹✡✓☞✒ ✢✣✓✗☛✥✛✟✙ ✌ ✹❵✎☞✜ ✠✗✢✔✎☞✕✫✆✣✠✫✦✧✎☞✘☞✠✬✌ ✛ ✘✑✠✑✦✧✛✑✕☞☛✰✌✰✜ ✎✟✌ ✠✫✒ ✌ ☛✵✙ ✎✑★✑✏ ✌ ☛✱✌ ✓✑✜ ✛✯★☞✖✑✓✩✠✟❩✟✠☞✢✣★✟✌ ✒ ✛✑✕✗✆☞✎☞☛✥✠☞✘ ✌ ✠☞☛✰✌ ✒ ✕☞✖ ☎ ✜ ✠✑✏ ✎✚✌ ✠✣✘✬✌ ✛✩✎✑✜ ✢✣✓✑✒ ✌ ✠☞✢✍✌ ★☞✜ ✎✑✏☞✘☞✛✑✢✣★☞✦✩✠☞✕✟✌ ✎✟✌ ✒ ✛✯✕ ✤❙☛✥✠✑✤☞✎✑✜ ✎✚✌✰✒ ✛✯✕ ✛✟✙✳✢✔✛✯✕✣✢✔✠✑✜ ✕✚✤✴✒ ✕✟✙ ✛✑✜ ✦✧✎✟✌ ✒ ✛✑✕✫✓✑✒ ✘✯✒ ✕☞✖✚✤✴✒ ✕☞✢✣✜ ✠☞✦✩✠✑✕✚✌ ✎✑✏ ✘✑✠✟✮✟✠☞✏ ✛✯✤☞✦✩✠✑✕✚✌ ✔ ✾ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

Business Qualities

❭❖❣✥r ④❊❡s❣❚✈✻④❊❛✴❴✥♠☞❡❙❣ ❭❖❞☞✈❙❝☞❣ ❭✝✇❙❴❚✈ ✁ ❡❙❞☞❣❚❡✯❢ ❤ r ✉ ❡❙❣❚r ④ ❡ ✈✴✉❲❝✚⑩❦❝☞❣ ❡✴④ ❭❖❣❚❛❙❴❚③✴❡✯❣❚❡✯❢ ④❊❛✴❴✥♠☞❡❙❣ ❭✝r ❜❙❣ ❡❙③✴❴❚❛❙❣❚r ✈✴❜ ⑨✫r ❣✥qs❡ ★✳r ❝☞❣❚r ❜❙③✻❤ ❡❙③❙❛❙❞✟⑩P❝✚⑩❦❝☞❣❚❡❙④ ❝
slide-5
SLIDE 5

5

✔ ✿ ✁ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎✝✆✞✝✟ ☎ ✠ ✡ ✄ ☛ ✞ ✠ ☞ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✎✓✒ ✔ ✒ ✕ ☞ ☞ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✞ ✚ ✜ ✂ ✄ ✄ ☎ ✞ ✂ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✠ ✞ ✛ ✒ ✔ ✒

What's Ahead

  • ❡❙④
❛❙r ❜❙❢✴❡❙❴ ✈❙✉ ④ ❛✯❣❚❡✴❴❚r ❛✴❤✯❛❙⑧❙✈✴❧❙❣✓✲✸❧❙❛❙❤ r ❣ ⑩✿✉❚✈❙❞✑❧❙❝✣❡❙❝✫✈✴❜ ❣❚⑨✗✈s❣❚✈✴✇❙r ❞✑❝✫❴❚❡✴❤ ❛✯❣❚❡✯❢✻❣❚✈s❝☞✈❙✉ ❣❚⑨✗❛❙❴❚❡ ✲✴❧❙❛❙❤ r ❣ ⑩✵✐ ☎✂✁ ✠✣☛✍✌ ✒ ✕☞✖☎✄❬✙ ✒ ✕☞✘✑✒ ✕☞✖✗✘✑✠✟✙ ✠☞✢✍✌ ☛✧✆✟✞✡✠✟❩✟✠☞✢✣★✟✌ ✒ ✕☞✖✗☛✥✛✺✙ ✌ ✹❵✎✑✜ ✠✗✎✑✕✣✘ ✠✟❩✟✎✑✦✩✒ ✕✑✒ ✕✣✖✫✜ ✠☞☛✣★✑✏ ✌ ☛ ✢ ✎✑✕☞✘✬✌ ✓☞✠✑✕✡✙ ✒ ❩✺✒ ✕☞✖✬✌ ✓☞✠✩✘✑✠✟✙ ✠☞✢✍✌ ☛ ✧ ☎✝✆✟✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✒✓✞☎✔✓✕✗✖ ✒✙✘ ✚✛✕✓✜✣✢✤✕✦✥✗✒✦✖✧✕✓✞✡✕✓✜ ✥✦★✩✑ ✞✡✪✫✠✬✒✭✖ ✎ ✢✮✕✓✘ ✌ ✕✓✞✡✯✫✒✦✎ ✰✡✌✓✘☎✯✓✒✡✍☞✱✓✚✲✌✓✞✦✎ ✠ ✳ ✴ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

What is Software Inspection?

❑▼▲✡◆P❖✟◗❙❘☎❚☎❯❱❖✟◆☎❲✡❳✙❨✡❨❬❩✟◆❭❨✡❩ ❘☎❩✬❪ ❲✡❘☎❚ ❚ ❫❴❘❱❵✙❘❱❚ ❫❜❛✡❳❭❘ ❨✡◆☎❝ ❩✟❞✫❘☎❖✟❳❡❯☎❖✟◆☎❢P❣✙❲✡❩❤❘❱❵✙❢✐❖✟❳✙❲✡◆❱❖✟❢✐◗✂❳☎❩✟❖✬❪ ❲✡❨✂❖✟❳☎❚ ❘☎❩✟❳✙❢ ❩✟◆❭❩✬❥✙❘☎❩✲❯☎❖✟◆☎❢P❣✙❲✡❩✩❦ ❑▼❧❤❪ ❝ ❝ ❳❱❖ ❨❬❝✟❖✟◆❱◗♠❪ ❵✙❝✟◆❱❖✟◗❙❘❱❚☎♥✬❞✫❘☎❚ ♦✙♣✟❩✟❥❱❖✟◆❱❣☎q❱❥☎❨✡♥✛◆❱❖ ♥✩❖✟❳❜r✧❪ ❳☎❞✫❨✡♥✡s t✂✖ ✒✓✘ ✚✲✕✓✜✡☛✓✘ ✒✡✍✩✌✡✠✬✠ t❴☛✓✘ ✒✓✯✓✱✡✍✏✎ ✠✲✑ ✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✌✡✯✫✕✦✎✧✪✙✘ ✌✡✕✦✎ ✌✓✘❱✜ ✌✦✉✦✌✡✜✡✒✦✖✧✯✓✌✦✎ ✕✓✑ ✜ t❴✚✲✌✦✎ ✘ ✑ ✍✩✠ ✳ ✈ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

IEEE Definition

♥☞❦ ❦ ❦ ❘❭❝ ◆❱❖✬◗✂❘❱❚✙❳❜r✇❘❱❚ ❣✙❘☎❩✟❪ ◆❱❵❙❩✟❳☎❲✓❥☎❵❱❪ ①P❣✙❳❡❪ ❵❙❞❬❥❱❪ ❲✓❥ ❨✡◆☎❝ ❩✟❞✫❘☎❖✟❳❡❖ ❳☎①❱❣❱❪ ❖✟❳☎◗❙❳☎❵☎❩✟❨✡②P❢❱❳✙❨✓❪ q❱❵☎②③◆❱❖❤❲✡◆☎❢☎❳ ❘❱❖ ❳ ❳✇④❜❘❱◗❙❪ ❵☎❳✙❢✐❪ ❵❙❢❱❳✙❩✟❘❱❪ ❚☎⑤❜❫❴❘❭❯☎❳☎❖✟❨✡◆❱❵❭◆❱❖③qP❖✟◆❱❣☎❯ ◆☎❩✬❥☎❳☎❖ ❩✬❥✙❘❱❵❭❩✟❥☎❳❭❘☎❣☎❩✬❥✙◆❱❖ ❩✟◆❭❢☎❳☎❩✟❳✙❲✓❩③❝ ❘❱❣❱❚ ❩ ❨✡②⑥r✇❪ ◆P❚ ❘✙❩✬❪ ◆❱❵☎❨✫◆❱❝ ❢☎❳✇r✇❳☎❚ ◆❱❯❱◗✂❳❱❵☎❩③❨✡❩✟❘☎❵☎❢☎❘❱❖✟❢☎❨✡②③❘☎❵☎❢❭◆☎❩✬❥☎❳☎❖ ❯☎❖✟◆❱⑤❱❚ ❳☎◗❙❨✙❦ ❦ ❦ ♥ ⑦ ⑦☞⑧ ⑨✩⑨☞⑨P⑩✡❶ ❷✬❸☞❹✬❷✬❺ ❹③❻✡❼ ❽✟❾✟❾✟❷✬❺ ❿P❽✩➀☞⑩☞❽✩➀ ❶ ➁✓❷✬❺ ➂P⑨✩❸➄➃✦➅ ❸✩➂✬➂✬❺ ➅ ❸➄➃➇➆ ➂✩❺ ➈③➅ ❸✩❽✬❼ ❽➄➃✣❿ ✳ ➉ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

History

❑➋➊✮❖ ❘☎❢❱❪ ❩✬❪ ◆❱❵☎❘☎❚☎◗❙❳☎❘☎❵❱❪ ❵✙q❡◆☎❝❤❪ ❵☎❨✓❯✙❳☎❲✡❩✬❪ ◆❱❵Ps t✝✆✟✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✞✡✪✗✎ ✰✡✌✫☛✓✘ ✒✡✯✙✱☞✍✏✎➌✒✦✖✧✕❬✚✲✕✓✞✓✱✣✖ ✕✡✍✏✎ ✱✓✘ ✑ ✞✡✪❬☛✓✘ ✒✡✍✩✌✡✠✬✠ t❴➍✓✰✣✥✭✠✩✑ ✍✩✕✓✜✡☛✓✘ ✒✡✯✙✱☞✍✏✎ ➎☎✌✦✉✦✕✓✜ ✱✡✕✣✎ ✌❬➏✣✥➇✜ ✒✡✒✙➐☞✑ ✞☞✪✓➎❱✚✲✕✓✞✡✑ ☛✓✱✓✜ ✕✦✎ ✑ ✞☞✪ t✝➑➌✖ ✎ ✌✓✞✫☛✓✱✦✎☎✎ ✰✓✘ ✒✓✱✡✪✙✰✫✘ ✑ ✪✡✒✙✘ ✒✙✱✡✠⑥✎ ✌☞✠✏✎ ✠✬➎❱➐✩✌✡✌✓☛✫✚✲✌✦✎ ✘ ✑ ✍✩✠ ❑▼➒✫❪ ❲✓❥☎❘☎❳☎❚❱▲✡❘☎q☎❘❱❵❭❘✙❩✲➓✩➔P➒✂s t❴✱✡✠✬✌✡✯✫✠☞✑ ✚✛✑ ✜ ✕✓✘❱☛✓✘ ✒✓✍✩✌✡✠✬✠✩✌✡✠⑥✎ ✒✫✑ ✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎✧✠✩✒✦✖ ✎ ✢✤✕✓✘ ✌✫→ ✍✩✒✡✯✓✌✦➣ t❴✜ ✕✓✞✡✯✓✚✛✕✡✘ ➐✛☛☞✕✓☛✡✌✓✘❱✑ ✞❬↔☞↕✡➙✓➛ t✝✒✦✖ ✎ ✌✓✞✛✍✩✕✓✜ ✜ ✌✡✯❬➜✟➝☞✕☞✪✓✕✓✞✛✆✟✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✒✙✞☞✠☞➜ t✝✆✟✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✒✓✞❬☛✡✘ ✒✓✍✬✌✡✠✩✠✲✰✡✕☞✠✲➏✡✌✡✌✓✞✛✌✦➞☞✎ ✌✓✞✡✯✡✌✡✯✫➟❡✘ ✌✦✖ ✑ ✞✡✌✡✯ ✠☞✑ ✞✡✍✩✌✡➎☎✒✓✞✡✪✡✒✙✑ ✞☞✪✂✘ ✌✡✠✩✌✡✕✓✘ ✍☞✰ ✳ ➠ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

What Gets Inspected?

➡ ✆✟✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✒✓✞❬☛✡✘ ✒✓✍✬✌✡✠✩✠✲✑ ✞✓✑ ✎ ✑ ✕✓✜ ✜ ✥➇✱☞✠✩✌✡✯✗✎ ✒❬✑ ✞☞✠☞☛✡✌☞✍✏✎➌✠✬✒✭✖ ✎ ✢✮✕✓✘ ✌ → ✍✩✒✡✯✓✌✣➣ ➡➤➢ ➞☞✎ ✌✓✞✡✯✡✌✡✯✗✎ ✒❬✑ ✞✡✍☞✜ ✱☞✯✓✌✛✕✓✜ ✜✡✯✡✒✓✍☞✱✡✚✛✌✡✞✦✎ ✠✓✔ ➥✝➦✩➧✬➦✩➨ ➩✏➫✟➭ ➫ ➯ ➲ ➳✬➵☞➸✩➭ ➲ ➳✬➺P➳✩➧➄➻ ➫ ➥✝➼✩➳✬➫✟➭ ➽☞➧P➼✬➾✩➚✬➸✬➺P➳✩➧➄➻ ➫ ➥✂➻ ➳✩➫ ➻❜➪✩➨ ➦✩➧✬➫ ➥❴➸✬➫ ➳✩➲✡➺P➦☞➧✩➸✬➦✩➨ ➫ ➥✝➳➄➻ ➚✟➶ ➡➘➹ ➏✡✒✦✉✦✌✫✑ ✞✡✍☞✜ ✱✡✯✓✌☞✠❤✯✙✑ ✕✡✪✓✘ ✕✓✚✲✠✩➎☎☛✓✘ ✒✡✠✩✌✡➎☎☛✡✠✬✌✓✱✡✯✓✒✡➴ ✍✩✒✡✯✓✌✡➎✙✌✦✎ ✍✡➷ ➡➮➬ ✒✓✚✲✌✫✒✦✎ ✰✡✌✓✘❱✑ ✞✡✯✓✱✡✠✏✎ ✘ ✑ ✌☞✠✲✰✡✕✦✉✦✌✛✕✡✯✓✒✓☛✦✎ ✌✡✯✫✆✟✞✡✠☞☛☞✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✒✓✞✗✖ ✒✙✘ ✯✓✌✡✠✩✑ ✪✙✞✛✯✡✒✓✍☞✱✓✚✲✌✓✞✦✎ ✠✬➎☎✯✓✘ ✕✦✢➱✑ ✞✡✪✓✠✬➎☎✌✦✎ ✍✡➷ ❅ ✃ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Inspection Versus Testing (1)

❑➘❐❱➊✤❒⑥➊❮❲✓❚ ❘☎❨☞❨✓❪ ❝✟❪ ❳☎❨✂❪ ❵✙❨✓❯✙❳☎❲✡❩✬❪ ◆❱❵❭❘✙❨❬❘❙❝✟◆❱❖✟◗❰◆☎❝③❩✟❳☎❨☞❩✬❪ ❵☎q ❑➤➓✬❵❭Ï③➓✬Ð☎Ï➮Ñ☎Ò☎Ñ☎②P❞✫❳❡❣☎❨☞❳❭❩✬❥✙❳❭❩ ❳❱❖✬◗❰♥✬❩✟❳☎❨☞❩✬❪ ❵☎q❱♥✛❩ ◆ ◗❙❳✙❘❱❵❙❢✧❫✇❵☎❘☎◗❭❪ ❲❬❩✟❳☎❨☞❩✬❪ ❵☎q③sP❳❜④✇❳✙❲✓❣☎❩✬❪ ❵✙q❡❨✡◆☎❝ ❩✟❞✫❘☎❖✟❳❭❩ ◆ ❝✟❪ ❵☎❢❭❝ ❘❱❣❱❚ ❩ ❨ ❑➤❪ ❵☎❨✡❯☎❳✙❲✓❩✟❪ ◆P❵❙❢❱◆☎❳✙❨✂❵☎◆☎❩✲❖ ❳❱❯☎❚ ❘☎❲✡❳❭❢✇❫✧❵✙❘❱◗❙❪ ❲✂❩ ❳☎❨✡❩✟❪ ❵☎q ❑➮❨✡◆☎❝ ❩✟❞✫❘☎❖✟❳❡❯☎❖✟◆☎❲✡❳☎❨☞❨❬❨✓❥☎◆❱❣☎❚ ❢✐❪ ❵✙❲✙❚ ❣✙❢❱❳❭⑤☎◆☎❩✬❥ ❪ ❵☎❨✡❯☎❳✙❲✓❩✟❪ ◆P❵❙❘❱❵✙❢❡❩✟❳✙❨✡❩✬❪ ❵✙q
slide-6
SLIDE 6

6

✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Inspection Versus Testing (2)

❑➮❢❱❪ ❝✟❝✟❪ ❲✓❣❱❚ ❩③❩✟◆❡❪ ❵☎❨✓❯✙❳☎❲✡❩❤❝ ◆❱❖❤①❱❣☎❘☎❚ ❪ ❩✬❪ ❳☎❨✫❨✓❣☎❲✓❥❭❘✙❨ ❯✙❳❱❖✟❝ ◆❱❖✬◗✂❘❱❵☎❲✡❳✙②③❩✬❪ ◗❙❪ ❵☎q☎②❤❚ ◆☎❘☎❢ ❑➤❪ ❵☎❨✡❯☎❳✙❲✓❩✟❪ ◆P❵❙❲✡❘❱❵❡⑤✙❳❭❘☎❯❱❯☎❚ ❪ ❳☎❢❭❳☎❘☎❖✬❚ ❪ ❳☎❖❤❩✬❥☎❘☎❵❭❩✟❳✙❨✡❩✬❪ ❵✙q ❑➤❪ ❵☎❨✡❯☎❳✙❲✓❩✟❪ ◆P❵❙❲✡❘❱❵❡⑤✙❳❭❘☎❯❱❯☎❚ ❪ ❳☎❢❭❩✟◆❭❘❱❵❜❫❴❨☞◆❱❝ ❩✟❞✫❘☎❖✟❳ ❯☎❖✟◆☎❢P❣✙❲✓❩ ②❤❵☎◆☎❩✂✁➄❣✙❨✡❩❤❲✡◆☎❢❱❳ ❅ ✳ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Defects vs. Faults

❑➤➓✬❵☎❨✓❯✙❳☎❲✡❩✬❪ ◆❱❵❙❝✟❪ ❵✙❢❱❨✫❢❱❳✙❝✟❳✙❲✡❩✟❨☎sP❯❱❖ ◆❱⑤❱❚ ❳❱◗✂❨✂❪ ❵ ❨✡◆☎❝ ❩✟❞✫❘☎❖✟❳ ❑➋➊✤❳✙❨✡❩✬❪ ❵✙q❡❝✟❪ ❵☎❢☎❨❬❝ ❘☎❣❱❚ ❩✟❨☎sP❪ ❵☎❲✡◆❱❖✬❖ ❳☎❲✡❩✲⑤✙❳❱❥☎❘❜r✧❪ ◆❱❖ ❑☎✄❮❥✙❳❱❵❴❫❜◆❱❣❭❝✟❪ ❵☎❢❭❘❭❝ ❘☎❣❱❚ ❩✲⑤❜❫❴❩✟❳✙❨✡❩✬❪ ❵✙q❤s t❴✚✛✱✡✠✏✎✧✯✓✌✓➏✡✱✡✪✗✎ ✒✗✎ ✘ ✕✡✍✩✌➱✎ ✰✡✌➱✖ ✕✓✱✡✜ ✎❱✎ ✒✫✕✛✯✓✌✣✖ ✌✡✍✏✎➌✑ ✞✗✎ ✰☞✌ ✍✩✒✡✯✓✌ ❑✝✆✛❝ ❩✟❳☎❵❡◗✂◆P❖ ❳❭❲✡◆☎❨✡❩✬♣ ❳☎❝ ❝ ❳☎❲✡❩✬❪ r❜❳❭❩✟◆❭❝✟❪ ❵☎❢❭❢❱❳✙❝ ❘❱❣❱❚ ❩ ❨➇r✧❪ ❘ ➓✬❵☎❨✓❯✙❳☎❲✡❩✬❪ ◆❱❵ ❅ ❅ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Analysis Tools

❑➮❨✡❩ ❘☎❩✬❪ ❲❬❘❱❵✙❘❱❚ ❫❜❨✓❪ ❨❬❩✟◆☎◆❱❚ ❨❬❲✡❘☎❵❭❝✟❪ ❵☎❢❭❨✡◆❱◗❙❳❙❩ ❫✧❯✙❳☎❨✫◆☎❝ ❢☎❳☎❝ ❳☎❲✡❩✟❨ t✝✍✩✒✓✚✫☛✡✑ ✜ ✌✓✘ ✠✤✖ ✑ ✞✡✯❬✱✓✞✡✯✡✌✡✍☞✜ ✕✓✘ ✌✡✯✗✉✦✕✓✘ ✑ ✕✡➏✓✜ ✌✡✠✬➎☎✠➄✥✭✞✦✎ ✕✦➞✗✌✡✘ ✘ ✒✓✘ ✠ t✝✒✦✎ ✰✡✌✓✘☎✠✏✎ ✕✦✎ ✑ ✍❤✕✓✞✡✕✓✜ ✥✦✠✩✑ ✠✤✎ ✒✡✒✙✜ ✠✲✚✲✕✦✥➱✍☞✰✡✌✡✍☞➐✤✖ ✒✓✘✬✔ ✞ ➸✩➧✩➲ ➳✬➦✬➚✠✟✬➦☛✡✩➨ ➳P➚✟➾✬➼✩➳ ✞ ➸✩➧✩➸✬➫ ➳✬➼✂☞✏➦✩➲ ➭ ➦☛✡✩➨ ➳✬➫ ✞ ➺P➳✬➺P➾☞➲ ➩✤➨ ➳✩➦☛✌ ➫ ✞✎✍ ➸✩➧✬➫ ➦✑✏ ➳ ✍ ➪✩➲ ➾✩➽☞➲ ➦✬➺P➺③➭ ➧✬➽❤➪✩➲ ➦✬➚ ➻ ➭ ➚ ➳✩➫ ✞ ➺③➭ ➫ ➫✟➪✬➳✩➨ ➨ ➳✬➼✂✒✇➾☞➲ ➼✩➫ ✓✡➫ ➾✬➺P➳P➽☞➲ ➦✩➺P➺P➦➄➻ ➭ ➚✟➦✩➨✬➳✩➲ ➲ ➾☞➲ ➫ ❑➮❨✓❥✙◆P❣☎❚ ❢✐❪ ❵✙❨✓❯✙❳☎❲✡❩❤❝ ◆❱❖❤❩✬❥☎❪ ❵☎q❱❨✫❩✟◆☎◆❱❚ ❨❬❲✡❘❱❵✕✔ ❩❤❝✟❪ ❵✙❢ ❅ ✖ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Inspection Metrics

➡ ✎ ✒❬➏☞✌✫✍☞✜ ✕✡✠✬✠☞✑ ✖ ✑ ✌✡✯✫✕✡✠✂✗✣✑ ✞✡✠✩☛✡✌✡✍✏✎ ✑ ✒✓✞✙✘ ➎☎✚✛✌✣✎➄✘ ✑ ✍✩✠✲✚✛✱✡✠✏✎➌➏✡✌✫➐✩✌✓☛✦✎ ➡ ✘ ✌✡✍✩✒✓✘ ✯❱✔ ➥✝➼✩➳✑✏ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➫✚✏ ➾☞➸✩➧✬➼❤➭ ➧③➪✩➲ ➾✩➼☞➸✬➚ ➻✇➸✩➧✬➼✬➳☞➲✓➭ ➧✬➫✬➪✟➳✩➚ ➻ ➭ ➾✩➧ ➥✛✒✜✟✬➳✩➲ ➳P➼✩➳✑✏ ➳✬➚ ➻✢✏ ➾☞➸✩➧✬➼❤➭ ➧③➪✩➲ ➾✩➼☞➸✬➚ ➻ ➥✂➻ ➭ ➺P➳➌➻ ➦☛✌✟➳✩➧➌➻ ➾❤➪✬➳✩➲ ✏ ➾☞➲ ➺❭➭ ➧✬➫✟➪✬➳✬➚ ➻ ➭ ➾☞➧ ➥✝➫✟➭ ✣ ➳P➾✤✏❜➪✩➲ ➾✬➼☞➸✬➚ ➻❜➭ ➧✬➫✟➪✬➳✬➚ ➻ ➳✬➼ ➡ ✚✲✕✦✥✗✕✓✜ ✠✩✒❬✘ ✌☞✍✩✒✙✘ ✯ ➥✝➚✟➦➄➻ ➳✩➽✬➾☞➲ ➩⑥➾✑✏✭➼✩➳✑✏ ➳✬➚ ➻✦✥ ➳✩➶ ➽✩➶ ✓ ➺③➦ ✧ ➾✩➲ ➯ ➺③➭ ➧✬➾☞➲ ★ ➥✛✒✜✟✬➦➄➻❜➪✩➲ ➾✩➺③➪➄➻ ➳✬➼③➼✩➳➄➻ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➭ ➧✬➽➌➻ ✟✬➳P➼✩➳✑✏ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➥✝➫✟➸✬➽✩➽✩➳✬➫ ➻ ➳✬➼③➭ ➺③➪✩➲ ➾✤☞✏➳✬➺P➳✩➧➄➻ ➫ ➥✛✏ ➦✩➭ ➨ ➸✩➲ ➳P➚✟➾✩➸✩➧➄➻ ➫☎➚ ➾☞➨ ➨ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➳✬➼③➼☞➸✩➲ ➭ ➧✬➽➌➻ ➳✬➫ ➻ ➭ ➧✬➽③➦✩➧✬➼❤➭ ➧➌➻ ✟✬➳✜✏ ➭ ➳✩➨ ➼ ❅ ✩ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Use of Metrics

➡✫✪ ✕✦✎ ✕✫✍✩✒✓✜ ✜ ✌✡✍✏✎ ✌✡✯✫✍✩✕✡✞✗✎ ✌✓✜ ✜✣✥✦✒✓✱☎✔ ➥✂➻ ➾✏➻ ➦✩➨✟➼✩➳✤✏ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➫❱➪✬➳✩➲✓➨ ➭ ➧✬➳P➾✤✏✭➚✟➾✬➼✩➳P➾☞➲✓➪✬➳✩➲✦➻ ➭ ➺P➳③➸✩➧✩➭ ➻ ➥❴➪✬➳✩➲ ➚✟➳✩➧➄➻ ➦✩➽✬➳P➾✤✏✭➼✩➳✑✏ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➫✚✏ ➾☞➸✩➧✬➼③➦➄➻✭➼☞➭ ✏ ✏ ➳✩➲ ➳✩➧➄➻❜➫ ➻ ➦✩➽✬➳✩➫ ✞ ➳✩➶ ➽☞➶☛✬☛✭✠✮➮➾✑✏✭➼✩➳✑✏ ➳✬➚ ➻ ➫✚✏ ➾✩➸✩➧✬➼✎✡➄➩✜✯ ➧✬➫✟➪✬➳✬➚ ➻ ➭ ➾✩➧✠✓✱✰✤✭☛✮✝✡➄➩P➻ ➳✬➫ ➻ ➭ ➧✬➽ ➥❴➪✬➳✩➲ ➚✟➳✩➧➄➻ ➦✩➽✬➳P➾✤✏✡➻ ➭ ➺P➳P➫✬➪✟➳☞➧➄➻✭➾☞➧❱➼☞➭ ✏ ✏ ➳✩➲ ➳☞➧➄➻✭➦✬➚ ➻ ➭ ☞✣➭ ➻ ➭ ➳✬➫✠✲ ✞ ➼✩➳✬➫✟➭ ➽☞➧✠✓☞➚✟➾✬➼☞➭ ➧✬➽☛✓☞➼✩➾✩➚✟➸✬➺P➳☞➧➄➻ ➦➄➻ ➭ ➾✩➧✠✓✓➭ ➧✬➫✬➪✟➳✩➚ ➻ ➭ ➾✩➧✠✓✦➻ ➳✬➫ ➻ ➭ ➧✬➽☛✓☞➳➄➻ ➚✟➶ ➡✫✪ ✕✦✎ ✕✫✍✩✕✡✞❬➏☞✌❬✱☞✠✩✌✡✯✗✎ ✒☎✔ ➥✳✧ ➸✬➫ ➻ ➭ ✏ ➩❱➻ ➭ ➺P➳P➫✟➪✬➳☞➧ ➻✇➭ ➧✬➫✟➪✬➳✬➚ ➻ ➭ ➧✬➽✵✴➱➻ ➳✬➫ ➻ ➭ ➧✬➽ ➥✝➫✟➸✬➽✩➽✩➳✬➫ ➻❜➭ ➺③➪✩➲ ➾✤☞✏➳✬➺P➳✩➧➄➻ ➫❱➭ ➧P➼✩➳✑☞✏➳✩➨ ➾✩➪✬➺P➳✩➧➄➻✇➪✩➲ ➾✬➚✟➳✬➫ ➫ ➥✝➳✑☞✏➦✩➨ ➸✬➦➄➻ ➳P➚✠✟✬➦✩➧✬➽✩➳✬➫❱➭ ➧③➪✩➲ ➾✩➚ ➳✬➫✟➫ ❅ ✴ ✵ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸✟✹✺✟✻ ✸ ✼ ✽ ✷ ✾ ✺ ✼ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❂✬❅ ✳ ❅ ❆ ✿ ✿ ❇ ❈ ❉ ❉ ❊ ❊ ❊ ❋
❋ ❍ ✶ ✷ ✷ ✸ ✺ ✶ ❋
❉ ❏
✳ ❅

Inspection Process

from Software Inspection, Tom Gilb & Dorothy Graham

slide-7
SLIDE 7

7

✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • People Involved in Inspection
✤✦✥✞✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✳✰ ★✵✴✶✮ ✬✩✴✲✷✸✪✲✹ ✱✩✭✺✬✩★✺★✩✻✼✰ ✽✲✬✩✴✩✾ ✾ ✿❁❀✫❂ ❃✳✪✩✬✩✱✲✪✲✾ ✬ ✤✦✥✞✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✳❄✺✬✩✴✫✽✲✬✲✹✓✻ ❅❇❆✫❈ ❉✺❊✺❋✺● ❍ ■✓❏▲❑◆▼❖❊✺❋✓❊✓❉✺■✓❏▲P ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙
  • ❆✺❋❚◗✺❈
❆✺❘ ■✺❏ ❏ ❅❇▼❖❆✺❯✺■✺❈ ❊❱❙ ■✓❏▲▼❖■✓■❱❙
  • ❋✓❉✺❏
❅❇❏✞❲✓❆✫❳✺❨ ❯❚❲✓❊❱❩✯■❖❏✞◗✓■✓❘✓● ❊✺❨❱❙ ❈ ❊✺● ❋✺● ❋✓❉❚❬ ▼❚❳✺❨ ❙
❯✺❊❱❪❫❘✞❆✺❳✺❈ ❏ ■✺❴✫❘✞■✺❈ ❙
  • ❘✞❊❱❙
  • ❆✫❋✺❛
✤✦✭✫❜✩✬✩✭✫❝✺✬✲✹ ★❡❞✞✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✱✲✹ ★❱❢ ❅❇❏✞◗✓■✺❋✓❯❫❙
  • ▼❖■❚❈
■✺❊✓❯✫● ❋✓❉✯❣ ❊✺❋✓❊✺❨ ❪✯❍✞● ❋✓❉❫❙ ❲✓■❚◗✓❈ ❆✓❯✫❳✓❘ ❙ ❅❇▼❖❊❱❪❤● ❋✓❘✓❨ ❳✓❯✺■❖❊✺❳❱❙ ❲✓❆✫❈ ❬ ❏✞❛ ❴✩❨ ■✓❊✓❯✺■✺❈ ❅❇❏✞❲✓❆✫❈ ❙✩❙ ❈ ❊✺● ❋✺● ❋✓❉✫✐✲❥✞❭ ❯✺❊❱❪❦❘✞❆✫❳✺❈ ❏ ■❖❆✫❈✩❧ ❆✺❋❦❙ ❲✓■♥♠ ❆✫♦✞❧ ❅♣❙ ■✺❘✞❲✺❋✺● ❘✞❊✺❨✺q✞❋✓❆✯r♥❨ ■✓❯✺❉✺■❚❈ ■✫❨ ❊✯❙
  • ❋✓❉❦❙
❆❚◗✺❈ ❆✺❯✫❳✓❘ ❙
  • s
✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Entry
✤✦✬✲✧t✮ ✹ ✿✶✭✫✹ ✰ ✮ ✬✲✹ ✰ ✴✉★✓✬t✮❫✈✩✪①✇ ✱✲✹❖✪✩✹ ✱✲✽✲✈✩✭✯✮ ★❤✮ ✱✳②✫✬✳✰ ✧✫★✫✪✩✬✩✭❱✮ ✬✫✽ ✤✦✴✉✾ ✱③✮♥✱t✇♥✭✺✱✼✧t✮ ✹ ✱③④t✬✲✹ ★❱✿①✴✩②✩✱✲✈t✮⑥⑤⑦❜✩✬✲✧✶✮ ✱✳✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮♥✭✺✱✩✽✲✬ ❅⑧♦✓■❱❵ ❆✫❈ ■❖❆✫❈✩❊❱❵ ❙ ■✺❈t❙ ■✓❏ ❙
  • ❋✓❉
❅⑧♦✓■❱❵ ❆✫❈ ■❖❆✫❈✩❊❱❵ ❙ ■✺❈✩❘✞❆✺▼❚◗✺● ❨ ■ ✤✸✰ ✇♥✬✲✧t✮ ✹ ✿①✭✫✹ ✰ ✮ ✬✲✹ ✰ ✴✳✧✩✱t✮❦✷◆✬⑨✮ ⑩▲✪✲✹ ✱✩✽✼✈✫✭✯✮❫✧✩✱t✮❦✰ ✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✬✩✽ ❅❇■✺❶ ❉✫❶ ❴⑨❙ ❆✺❆❖▼❖❊✺❋❱❪❖❙ ❪⑨◗✺● ❋✞❉❚■✺❈ ❈ ❆✺❈ ❏ ❅❇■✺❶ ❉✫❶ ❴✫❏✞❆✺❳✺❈ ❘✞■❖❘✞❆✓❯✺■❖❯✺❆✺■✓❏⑥❋✓❆✯❙③❘✞❆✓▼❚◗✺● ❨ ■❖❘✞❨ ■✓❊✫❋✺❨ ❪ ✤✸✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩★✵✴✲✹ ✬✉✬t❷③✪✫✬✲✧✩★✺✰ ④t✬ ❅❇❯✺❆✺❋✓❸ ❙✩r♥❊✓❏ ❙ ■❚● ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙ ❆✺❈ ❏❹❙
  • ▼❖■
✤✦✴✲✈t✮ ❜✩✱✲✹▲✱t✇ ✇ ✬✲✹ ★❡✈✲✪✉✪✲✹ ✱✩✽✼✈✫✭✯✮⑥✇ ✱✲✹⑥✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧ ✤✸✾ ✬✩✴✩✽✩✬✲✹ ★✵✽✲✬✫✭✫✰ ✽✲✬✩★❡✰ ✇❦✰ ✮ ❺ ★❡✹ ✬✩✴✩✽t✿①❂ ❂⑥❻✼✈✲✰ ✭✫❝✵✬t❷t✴✲✷◆✰ ✧✩✴t✮ ✰ ✱✲✧
✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Kickoff
✤✸✰ ✧✲✰ ✮ ✰ ✴✩✾✲✷❡✬✩✬t✮ ✰ ✧✩❽①✇ ✱✼✹▲✴✲✾ ✾✩✪✩✴✲✹ ✮ ✰ ✭✫✰ ✪✩✴✲✧t✮ ★ ✤✦✱✲✹ ❽✲✴✲✧✲✰ ❾✺✬✩✽✳②⑨✿❁✾ ✬✩✴✩✽✩✬✲✹ ✤❿✇ ✴✩✷✉✰ ✾ ✰ ✴✲✹ ✰ ❾✓✬✉✬t④t✬✲✹ ✿t✱✼✧✩✬✉✰ ✧t④t✱✲✾ ④t✬✩✽①⑤⑦✰ ✮ ❜①✮ ✴✩★✺❝❡✴⑨✮❫❜✩✴✲✧✫✽ ✤✦✽✲✬t✇ ✰ ✧✩✬◆✬t④t✬✲✹ ✿t✱✲✧✩✬✩➀ ★❡✹ ✱✲✾ ✬✩★ ✤✸❜✩✴✲✧✫✽✳✱✲✈t✮❦✷❡✴t✮ ✬✲✹ ✰ ✴✲✾ ★❡✧✩✬✫✬✩✽✲✬✩✽ ✤✦✽✲✬✩✴✩✾t⑤⑦✰ ✮ ❜◆❽✲✬✲✧✩✬✲✹ ✴✲✾✩❻✲✈✩✬✩★❱✮❱✰ ✱✼✧✩★ ✤✦★✺✬⑨✮❦❽✲✱✩✴✲✾ ★ ✤✦✽✼✰ ★✓✭✫✈✩★✓★✵✱③④t✬✲✹ ✴✲✾ ✾✲✪✩✾ ✴✲✧✩⑩➁✮ ✰ ✷◆✬⑨✮ ✴✩②✲✾ ✬ ✤✸✾ ✱✲✧✩❽✉✽✲✱✩✭✫✈✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮ ★✵✽✼✰ ④➁✰ ✽✲✬✩✽✳✰ ✧t✮ ✱✳➂ ✭✫❜✩✈✲✧✲❝✺★✫➂✺✻✲★✓✬✲✪✩✴✲✹ ✴⑨✮ ✬ ✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧◆➃➄✾ ✱✩❽✲❽✼✰ ✧✩❽①✇ ✱✲✹⑥✬✫✴✩✭✫❜◆✭✫❜✲✈✲✧✲❝ ➅ ➆ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Individual Checking (1)
✤✦✬✩✴✩✭✫❜◆✭✫❜✩✬✩✭✫❝✺✬✲✹❹⑤❤✱✼✹ ❝✫★❚✴✲✾ ✱✼✧✫✬✳✈✩★✺✰ ✧✩❽✉✽✩✱✲✭✫✈✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮ ★❡❜✫✴✲✧✩✽✲✬✩✽ ✱✲✈t✮❫✰ ✧✉❝✫✰ ✭✫❝✺❂ ✱t✇ ✇❦✷❡✬✩✬t✮ ✰ ✧✩❽ ✤✦✴✲✰ ✷❡★❤✮ ✱①✇ ✰ ✧✩✽✳✷◆✴⑨❷③✰ ✷✉✈✩✷➇✧✲✈✲✷◆②✩✬✩✹⑥✱t✇❦✈✲✧✲✰ ❻✲✈✩✬✉✷◆✴✯➈ ✱✲✹ ✪✩✱t✮ ✬✲✧t✮ ✰ ✴✲✾✫✽✲✬⑨✇ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★ ✤✸✷❡✴✲✰ ✧✲✾ ✿①②t✿①✾ ✱✲✱✲❝✫✰ ✧✩❽①✇ ✱✲✹▲✽✼✰ ★✓✭✫✹ ✬✲✪✩✴✩✧✩✭✫✰ ✬✩★❡②✩✬⑨✮ ⑤⑦✬✩✬✲✧◆★✓✱✼✈✲✹ ✭✺✬ ✽✲✱✩✭✫✈✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮ ★✵✴✲✧✫✽♣✪✩✹ ✱✩✽✼✈✩✭✯✮ ★❡②✫✬✲✰ ✧✩❽✳✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✬✩✽✩⑩⑥✰ ➉ ✬✼➉ ✻ ❅⑧❈ ■✓➊✫❳✺● ❈ ■✓▼❖■✺❋❱❙ ❏❹❙ ❆❚❯✺■✓❏✞● ❉✫❋ ❅❇❯✺■✓❏✞● ❉✫❋❦❙ ❆❚❘ ❆✺❯✺■ ❅⑧❈ ■✓➊✫❳✺● ❈ ■✓▼❖■✺❋❱❙ ❏❹❙ ❆❫❙ ■✺❏ ❙➁◗✺❨ ❊✺❋ ➅ ➋ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Individual Checking (2)
✤✸✈✩★✺✈✩✴✲✾ ✾ ✿①✈✩★✺✬✩★❚✴✉✭✫❜✩✬✫✭✫❝✫✾ ✰ ★✯✮ ✤✸❝✫✰ ✭✫❝✺✱t✇ ✇❦✷❡✬✩✬t✮ ✰ ✧✩❽✉★✺✈✩❽✲❽✩✬✩★✯✮ ★✵✴✲✷❡✱✲✈✲✧t✮♥✱③✇▲✮ ✰ ✷❡✬✶✮ ✱✉★✫✪✫✬✲✧✩✽⑥✻ ❅♣❙ ❪⑨◗✺● ❘ ❊✫❨✓❈ ❊❱❙ ■❚● ❏❖❥⑥❲✓❆✫❳✺❈✲◗✓■✺❈✩❯✺❆✓❘✓❳✓▼❖■✺❋❱❙❹◗✞❊✺❉✓■ ✤✦✭✫❜✩✬✩✭✫❝✺✬✲✹⑥✹ ✬✩✭✺✱✲✹ ✽✩★✵✴✩✭✯✮ ✈✩✴✲✾⑨✮ ✰ ✷❡✬①✮ ✴✲❝✺✬✲✧ ✤✸❝✺✬✩✬✲✪✫★❡✧✩✱③✮ ✬✫★✵✱③✇❦✰ ★✓★✫✈✩✬✫★❤✇ ✱✲✈✲✧✩✽ ❅❇❯✺■✓❏ ❘✓❈
  • ◗❱❙
  • ❆✫❋✞❴✲❨
❆✓❘✞❊❱❙
  • ❆✫❋✓❴✲◗✞❆✺❏
❏✞● ♦✺❨ ❪❫● ▼❚◗✓❊✓❘ ❙ ✤✸➂✞✰ ★✺★✺✈✩✬✲➂❚➌➄✷❡✴t✮ ✮ ✬✲✹⑥✹ ✬✩❻✲✈✲✰ ✹ ✰ ✧✩❽✉✴t✮ ✮ ✬✲✧⑨✮ ✰ ✱✼✧ ❅⑧◗✓❆✓❏✞❏✞● ♦✓❨ ■❖❯✺■❱❵ ■✺❘ ❙ ❅❇❧ ➊✫❳✓■✓❏ ❙
  • ❆✺❋❖❆✯❵➁●
❋❱❙ ■✺❋❱❙ ❧ ❅❇❏✞❳✓❉✺❉✺■✓❏ ❙
  • ❆✫❋
➅ ✔ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Logging Meeting (1)
➍✸➎➐➏⑥➑▲➒✓➏✼➓⑥➔✫→▲➔▲➣ ↔ ✾ ✱✩❽✳✰ ★✺★✺✈✩✬✩★❡✰ ✽✩✬✲✧t✮ ✰ ✇ ✰ ✬✫✽♣②⑨✿①✬✩✴✫✭✫❜✉✭✫❜✫✬✩✭✫❝✺✬✲✹ ↔ ⑤❤✱✼✹ ❝✵✴✩★✵❽✼✹ ✱✼✈✲✪✶✮ ✱✶✇ ✰ ✧✩✽✳✷❡✱✼✹ ✬✳✰ ★✓★✫✈✫✬✩★ ↔ ★✫✈✫❽✲❽✲✬✫★✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩★❤✇ ✱✲✹⑥✪✲✹ ✱✩✭✺✬✩★✓★❡✰ ✷✉✪✩✹ ✱t④t✬✲✷◆✬✲✧⑨✮❫❞ ✰ ✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧ ✪✲✹ ✱✲✭✺✬✩★✓★✵✴✲✧✩✽✉✱t④t✬✲✹ ✴✲✾ ✾✫★✺✱t✇ ✮ ⑤❤✴✲✹ ✬✉✪✲✹ ✱✩✭✺✬✩★✓★✯❢ ➍✦↕✩➓⑥➙▲➛✓➒ ➓❖➜ ➜ →✼➝➟➞➁➠➢➡♣➓▲➝⑥→▲➒✞➤▲➛✞➓⑥➒✵➥✺➑▲➔✩➑▲➤▲➜ ➜ ➠⑧➛✓➦▲→➐➜ →▲➤✼➝⑥→▲➒✞➧ ↔ ✷◆✈✩★✯✮❦②✩✬✶④t✬✲✹ ✿✶★✫❝✫✰ ✾ ✾ ✬✩✽✳✰ ✧✉❜✩✴✩✧✩✽✼✾ ✰ ✧✩❽✳✪✫✬✩✱✲✪✲✾ ✬◆✴✲✧✩✽✳✰ ★✺★✺✈✩✬✩★ ↔ ✷❡✴✲✰ ✧t✮ ✴✲✰ ✧✶✮ ✰ ✷❡✬✉✽✲✰ ★✺✭✫✰ ✪✲✾ ✰ ✧✩✬◆✴✲✧✩✽✳✰ ★✓★✫✈✩✬◆✽✼✰ ★✺✭✫✰ ✪✩✾ ✰ ✧✩✬ ➍✸➙▲➓➐→➁➨❹➤▲➜ ➑▲➤▲➛✞➩ ➓❖➙➫➓▲➭❡➩ ➔✫➔✲➑▲→✼➔ ↔ ➈ ✈✩★✯✮❦✾ ✱✲❽✳✰ ★✓★✫✈✫✬✩★✺⑩▲✾ ✰ ❝✺✬✉②✲✹ ✴✲✰ ✧✩★❱✮ ✱✲✹ ✷✉✰ ✧✫❽
slide-8
SLIDE 8

8

✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Logging Meeting (2)
✤✸✷◆✈✩★✯✮❦✧✩✱t✮❫✾ ✴✩★❱✮❦✷◆✱✲✹ ✬✶✮ ❜✩✴✲✧✉❀✉❜✩✱✲✈✲✹ ★ ✤✸✧✩✱t✮⑥✇ ✱✼✹▲✬t❷③✪✩✾ ✴✲✰ ✧✲✰ ✧✫❽✲⑩▲✽✩✬t✇ ✬✲✧✫✽✼✰ ✧✩❽✩⑩▲★✫✈✫❽✲❽✲✬✩★❱✮ ✰ ✧✩❽①✇ ✰ ❷t✬✩★✺⑩✼✱✼✹ ✮ ✹ ✴✲✰ ✧✩✰ ✧✩❽ ✤✸✰ ✽✲✬✩✧t✮ ✰ ✇ ✿①✰ ★✺★✺✈✩✬✩★✓⑩❹✮ ❜✩✬✲✧✉✾ ✱✩❽①✮ ❜✩✬✲✷ ✤✸✰ ★✓★✫✈✩✬✩★✵✭✺✴✩✧✳②✫✬✉❻✲✈✩✬✩★❱✮ ✰ ✱✼✧✩★❫✮ ✱✉✪✲✹ ✱✩✽✼✈✩✭✯✮♥✴✲✈t✮ ❜✩✱✲✹▲✴✲✧✩✽ ★✫✈✫❽✲❽✲✬✫★✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩★❤✇ ✱✲✹⑥✰ ✷◆✪✲✹ ✱t④t✬✲✷◆✬✩✧t✮ ★ ❅⑧❋✓❆✯❙③❯✫● ❏ ❘✞❳✓❏✞❏ ■✓❯✵● ❋❖▼❖■✓■✯❙
  • ❋✓❉
✤✁✄✂✆☎ ✴✲✧✉✴⑨✮ ✮ ✴✫✭✫❝❡✱✲✹⑥✬⑨④t✴✲✾ ✈✩✴t✮ ✰ ✱✲✧◆✱③✇❦✪✩✹ ✱✲✽✲✈✩✭✯✮❦✴✩✈t✮ ❜✩✱✲✹ ✤✸✷❡✴✲✧✩✴✩❽✩✬✲✷◆✬✲✧⑨✮❫✪✫✬✲✹ ★✺✱✲✧✲✧✩✬✲✾✫★✺❜✩✱✼✈✩✾ ✽✝✄✂✞☎❇②✫✬✳✰ ✧◆✴t✮ ✮ ✬✲✧✩✽✩✴✲✧✩✭✺✬ ➅ ➅ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Edit
➍✸➜ ➓✄✟➄➓▲➭✵➩ ➔✩➔✩➑▲→▲➔✠✟❖➩ ➨➁→⑥➙➐➛ ➓➐➤⑥➑▲➛✞➦▲➓⑥➒✵➛✞➓➄➒✞→✼➔✩➓⑥➜ ➨❹→ ➍✦➤⑥➑✼➛✓➦▲➓⑥➒❚↕✲➤▲➙ ↔ ✭✫✾ ✴✩★✓★✫✰ ✇ ✿①✱✲✹⑥✹ ✬✩✭✫✾ ✴✩★✓★✫✰ ✇ ✿❁✰ ★✓★✫✈✩✬✫★❡❞ ⑤✶❜✩✰ ✭✫❜◆✴✲✹ ✬✉✹ ✬✩✴✲✾ ✾ ✿ ✽✲✬t✇ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★✯❢ ↔ ④t✱✲✾ ✈✲✧t✮ ✴✲✹ ✰ ✾ ✿①✰ ✷◆✪✲✹ ✱t④t✬✉✪✲✹ ✱✩✽✼✈✩✭✯✮♥✴✩★❡✪✩✬✲✹⑥✰ ★✓★✫✈✩✬✫★❡✹ ✴✲✰ ★✓✬✩✽ ↔ ✹ ✬✩❻✲✈✩✬✩★✯✮❦✹ ✈✲✾ ✬✫★✵✱✼✹▲✭✫❜✩✬✩✭✫❝✫✾ ✰ ★❱✮❫②✫✬◆✭✫❜✩✴✲✧✩❽✲✬✫✽ ➅ ✡ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Follow-up
➍✸➩ ➙▲➔✩➏▲→✼↕✲➛✞➩ ➓❖➙➐➜ →▲➤✼➝⑥→▲➒❡➡➫➤✄☛✲→✼➔✳➔✲➑▲➒✞→➐➔✫➤▲➛✓➩ ➔✫➭ ➤▲↕✩➛✞➓⑥➒ ➠ ↕✲➜ ➓▲➔✲➑⑥➒ →➄➦▲➤✼➔✳➛✞➤✄☛✲→▲➙➄➏▲➜ ➤▲↕✩→➐➓⑥➙➫➤⑥➜ ➜▲➩ ➔✩➔✩➑▲→▲➔ ↔ ✴✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩★❤✮ ✱✉✭✺✱✲✹ ✹ ✬✩✭✯✮♥✴✲✾ ✾✫✽✲✬t✇ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★❡❞ ✭✫❜✩✴✩✧✩❽✲✬◆✱✲✹⑥✭✫❜✩✴✩✧✩❽✲✬ ✹ ✬✩❻✲✈✩✬✩★✯✮ ❢ ↔ ★✫✈✫❽✲❽✲✬✫★✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩★❤✇ ✱✲✹⑥✪✲✹ ✱✩✭✺✬✩★✓★✵✭✫❜✩✴✲✧✩❽✩✬✩★❡✹ ✬✲✪✩✱✲✹ ✮ ✬✩✽ ➍✸➩ ➭✵➡➫➤✌☞ ➓⑥➒✵↕✲➦▲➤▲➙✄✟▲→▲➔✎✍❚➏⑥➒✞➓▲➝⑥➑▲↕✩➛❡➡♣➤❹➠➢➙✼→▲→✼➝➄➛✞➓➄➞✼→ ➩ ➙▲➔✩➏▲→✼↕✲➛ →▲➝➐➤✄✟▲➤⑥➩ ➙ ➅ ✏ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Exit
➍✸➙▲→✼→▲➝➐→✒✑❹➩ ➛✵↕✲➒✓➩ ➛✞→▲➒✓➩ ➤ ➍✸➙▲→✼→▲➝➐↕✲➜ ➓⑥➔✩➑⑥➒✞→➫➓⑥➙➐➤▲➜ ➜▲➩ ➔✫➔✲➑▲→✼➔♣➩ ➙✔✓♣➒✞➩ ➛✓➩ ➙✄✟ ➍✸➒✞→✼↕✩➓❖➒ ➝➟➡♣→▲➛✓➒✞➩ ↕✲➔✉➭ ➓❖➒✵➩ ➙▲➔✲➏✼→▲↕✩➛✓➩ ➓⑥➙➐➏⑥➒✞➓▲↕✩→▲➔✫➔♣➥✓➭ ➓⑥➒ ➏▲➒✞➓▲↕✲→✼➔✩➔♣➩ ➡➫➏⑥➒ ➓❹➨❹→⑥➡♣→⑥➙✼➛✞➧ ➍✸➏▲➒✞➓▲➝❖➑✼↕✲➛✵➙▲➓✄✓ ↕✲➓⑥➙✼➔✲➩ ➝⑥→▲➒✞→✼➝✖✕t➔✩➤✼➭ →✘✗❡➛✞➓➄➏✼➤▲➔✩➔✉➓❖➙➫➛✞➓ ➙▲→✙✑❹➛✵➏⑥➦▲➤✼➔✩→➐➩ ➙➐➔✩➓▲➭ ➛✚✓✉➤▲➒✞→➐➝▲→❹➨➁→⑥➜ ➓⑥➏▲➡➫→⑥➙✼➛ ➅ ✁ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • The V-model

Requirements Cost of running inspections is about 10-15% of cost of development budget. Inspection Architecture Inspection Design Inspection Code Inspection Unit Test Integration Test System Test

➅ s ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Costs of Inspection
➍✁✛✓➙▲➔✲➏✼→▲↕✩➛✓➩ ➓⑥➙➫➛✞➤✘☛✩→▲➔✳➛✞➩ ➡➫→ ➍✢✜❚➠❹➏⑥➩ ↕✩➤▲➜ ➜ ➠✢✣✥✤✘✦✧✣✩★✄✪ ➓▲➭❚➝⑥→➁➨❹→▲➜ ➓⑥➏⑥➡♣→⑥➙▲➛✵➞⑥➑▲➝✄✟▲→▲➛ ➍✬✫❤➜ ➔✩➓➐➔✩➛ ➤⑥➒✞➛✚✦✓➑⑥➏➫↕✩➓⑥➔✫➛✞➔▲➣ ↔ ✬✩★❱✮ ✴✲②✲✾ ✰ ★✺❜✲✰ ✧✩❽✳✪✲✹ ✱✲✭✺✬✩✽✲✈✲✹ ✬✩★ ↔ ✮ ✹ ✴✲✰ ✧✩✰ ✧✩❽✳✾ ✬✩✴✩✽✲✬✩✹ ★✺⑩▲✰ ✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✱✲✹ ★ ➍✁✛✞➔♣➩ ➛✭✓✉➓⑥➒✞➛✞➦➄➩ ➛✯✮
slide-9
SLIDE 9

9

➅ ❼ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Benefits of Inspection (1)
➍✁❚→✼➭✞→✼↕✩➛✞➔✳➭ ➓⑥➑⑥➙✼➝➄→✼➤⑥➒✓➜ ➠❇➔✩➤❹➨➁→➐➛✞➩ ➡➫→➐➤▲➙▲➝➄➡➫➓⑥➙✼→❹➠ ➍✸➡➫➤▲➙❹➠❇➝⑥→✼➭ →▲↕✩➛✞➔✳➭ ➓⑥➑⑥➙✼➝➟➞✼→▲➭ ➓⑥➒✞→➫➛✞→▲➔✫➛✓➩ ➙✄✟ ↔ ✮ ✬✩★❱✮ ✰ ✧✩❽✳✰ ★❡✷◆✈✩✭✫❜◆❻✼✈✲✰ ✭✫❝✺✬✲✹ ➍✦➛✞➓▲➛✞➤▲➜✼➝⑥→➁➨❹→▲➜ ➓❖➏▲➡➫→▲➙▲➛✵➛✞➩ ➡➫→➐➩ ➔♣➒✞→✼➝❖➑▲↕✩→✼➝ ↔ ✬t④t✬✲✧✶⑤✶❜✫✬✲✧◆✭✺✱✼✈✲✧⑨✮ ✰ ✧✩❽①✮ ✰ ✷❡✬①✇ ✱✼✹⑥✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧ ➍✸➩ ➙▲➔✩➏▲→✼↕✲➛✞➩ ➓❖➙✼➔♣➩ ➙▲↕✲➒ →▲➤✼➔✩→➄➏▲➒✞➓▲➝❖➑✼↕✩➛✓➩ ➨♥➩ ➛ ➠ ✡ ➆ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Benefits of Inspection (2)
➍✁❚→✼➭✞→✼↕✩➛✞➔✳➭ ➓⑥➑⑥➙✼➝➄→✼➤⑥➒✓➜ ➠⑧➒✞→▲➔✩➑⑥➜ ➛❡➩ ➙➐➞▲→✼➛✞➛✞→▲➒❡➏⑥➒ ➓⑥➝⑥➑▲↕✩➛ ➍✸➩ ➙▲➔✩➏▲→✼↕✲➛✞➩ ➓❖➙➐➒✞→✼➔✲➑⑥➜ ➛✞➔✳➩ ➙ ↔ ✭✫✾ ✬✩✴✲✧✫✬✲✹⑥✽✩✬✩★✫✰ ❽✲✧ ↔ ②✩✬t✮ ✮ ✬✩✹⑥✽✩✱✲✭✫✈✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮ ✴⑨✮ ✰ ✱✼✧ ↔ ②✩✬t✮ ✮ ✬✩✹⑥✭✺✱✩✽✲✬ ↔ ✇ ✬⑨⑤⑦✬✲✹▲✽✲✬t✇ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★ ↔ ✽✲✬t✇ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★❤✮ ❜✩✴t✮❦✹ ✬✲✷❡✴✲✰ ✧✶⑤✶✰ ✾ ✾✲②✫✬✉✬✩✴✫★✫✰ ✬✲✹❹✮ ✱①✇ ✰ ❷◆⑤⑦❜✩✬✲✧ ✇ ✱✲✈✲✧✩✽ ✡ ➋ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Benefits of Inspection (3)
➍✦➭ →▲→✼➝❖➞✼➤▲↕✥☛♣➭ ➓⑥➒❡➡♣➤⑥➙✩✟⑥→▲➡➫→▲➙▲➛✵➤▲➞▲➓⑥➑▲➛❚➔✩➓▲➭ ➛✚✓✉➤⑥➒✞→ ➏▲➒✞➓▲↕✲→✼➔✩➔▲➣ ↔ ✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✱✲✹ ❺ ★✵✭✺✱✼✷◆✷❡✬✲✧t✮ ★❡✪✲✾ ✈✩★❡✷◆✬⑨✮ ✹ ✰ ✭✺★ ➍✦➝▲→▲➭ →▲↕✩➛✞➔✉➭✞➓⑥➑▲➙▲➝➐→▲➤⑥➒✞➜ ➩ →⑥➒❡➡♣→▲➤▲➙▲➔✉➭✞→✩✓✉→⑥➒✵➝▲→▲➤✼➝❖➜ ➩ ➙✼→ ➔✲➑▲➒✓➏⑥➒✞➩ ➔✩→▲➔ ➍✸➩ ➙▲➔✩➏▲→✼↕✲➛✞➩ ➓❖➙➫➛✓➒✞➤▲➩ ➙▲➔♣➩ ➙✼➔✲➏✼→▲↕✩➛✞➓⑥➒✞➔▲➣ ↔ ✾ ✬✩✴✲✹ ✧①✇ ✹ ✱✲✷✸❽✲✱✩✱✲✽✉✭✺✱✩✽✲✬◆✴✲✧✩✽✉✽✩✱✲✭✫✈✩✷◆✬✲✧⑨✮ ✴t✮ ✰ ✱✼✧◆✱t✇ ✱t✮ ❜✩✬✲✹ ★ ↔ ✾ ✬✩✴✲✹ ✧①✇ ✹ ✱✲✷➇✷◆✰ ★✯✮ ✴✲❝✺✬✩★✵✱t✇♥✱t✮ ❜✩✬✲✹ ★ ✡ ✔ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Success Stories (1)
➍✁✛✄✂✆☎✞✝✩→▲➝⑥→▲➒✞➤▲➜✠✟❹➠❹➔✫➛✞→⑥➡♣➔✡✵➩ ➨❹➩ ➔✲➩ ➓⑥➙ ↔ ❝✺✬✲✪t✮❦✷❡✬t✮ ✹ ✰ ✭✺★❤✇ ✱✲✹▲★✫✰ ✷◆✰ ✾ ✴✲✹⑥✪✩✹ ✱⑨➈ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★❡②✩✬t✇ ✱✲✹ ✬✉✴✩✧✩✽✉✴t✇ ✮ ✬✲✹ ✰ ✧t✮ ✹ ✱✩✽✼✈✫✭✫✰ ✧✩❽✉✥✓✧✫★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✼✧✉✰ ✧t✮ ✱◆✽✲✬t④t✬✲✾ ✱✲✪✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮❦✪✲✹ ✱✩✭✺✬✩★✓★ ↔ ✽✲✬✲✾ ✰ ④t✬✲✹ ✬✩✽✳✾ ✰ ✧✩✬✩★✵✱t✇♥✭✺✱✩✽✲✬✉✪✩✬✲✹❹⑤❤✱✼✹ ❝✺❂✞✷❡✱✲✧t✮ ❜▲✻ ☛ ❥ ☞✌☞❚r❦● ❙ ❲✓❆✫❳ ❙➁P ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙
  • ❆✫❋
☛✎✍✄✏✌✏ r❦● ❙ ❲❖P ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙
  • ❆✫❋
✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Success Stories (2)
➍✁✛✒✑✎✓♣➥✓➩ ➙✕✔✗✖ ✘✆✖ ➧✲➣ ↔✚✙✜✛ ➉ ✛✣✢ ✱t✇♥✽✲✬⑨✇ ✬✩✭✯✮ ★❤✇ ✱✼✈✲✧✫✽✳②t✿①✥✞✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧ ↔ ✭✺✱✩★✯✮♥✱③✇▲✇ ✰ ✧✩✽✼✰ ✧✫❽✉✽✲✬t✇ ✬✫✭✯✮❫②t✿✶✥✞✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧▲✻✠✤✲➉ ✙✜✥ ⑤⑦✱✲✹ ❝ ❜✩✱✲✈✲✹ ★ ↔ ✭✺✱✩★✯✮♥✱③✇▲✇ ✰ ✧✩✽✼✰ ✧✫❽①⑤✶✰ ✮ ❜✩✱✲✈t✮♥✥✓✧✫★✫✪✩✬✫✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✼✧▲✻ ✥ ➉ ✦ ✛ ⑤❤✱✲✹ ❝ ❜✩✱✲✈✲✹ ★ ↔ ✱✲✧✲✾ ✿①❃ ✢ ✱t✇♥✽✲✬t④t✬✲✾ ✱✲✪✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮▲✮ ✰ ✷❡✬✉✽✩✬t④t✱③✮ ✬✩✽①✮ ✱ ✥✞✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧ ✡ ➅ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Success Stories (3)
➍✁✓✫➤⑥➒✚✟▲→ ✛✄✂✆☎ ➏▲➒✞➓✙☞ →▲↕✩➛✫➣ ↔✚✙✜✧★✧ ⑩ ✧✩✧★✧ ✾ ✰ ✧✩✬✩★✵✱t✇♥✭✺✱✲✽✩✬✳❞ ✧✩✬t✮ ⑤❤✱✼✹ ❝✺✬✩✽✉✱✲✪✩✬✩✹ ✴t✮ ✰ ✧✩❽ ★✯✿t★❱✮ ✬✲✷⑦❢ ↔ ②✩✴✩★✓✬✩✽✉✱✲✧✳✪✫✴✩★✯✮♥✬t❷③✪✩✬✩✹ ✰ ✬✲✧✩✭✺✬✶⑤✶✰ ✮❱❜✫✱✼✈⑨✮❫✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩⑩ ✬t❷③✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✬✩✽①✮ ✱①✇ ✰ ✧✫✽✉✴✲②✩✱✲✈t✮ ✥✩✧★✧ ②✩✈✩❽✲★✵✽✲✈✲✹ ✰ ✧✩❽①✮ ✬✩★❱✮ ★✵✴t✮ ✮ ✹ ✰ ✴✲✾✫★✫✰ ✮ ✬ ↔ ✈✩★✓✬✩✽✳✰ ✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✉✴⑨✮✪✤✩✤❡★✯✮ ✴✩❽✩✬✩★✵✱③✇♥✽✩✬t④t✱✲✪✲✷❡✬✲✧t✮ ↔ ✇ ✱✲✈✲✧✩✽ ✥ ②✩✈✩❽✲★✵✴⑨✮⑥✮ ✹ ✰ ✴✲✾✫★✺✰ ✮ ✬✣✫
slide-10
SLIDE 10

10

✡ ✡ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Software Inspection

Research (1)

➍✁⑥→✼➔✩→▲➤▲➒✞↕✲➦➄➩ ➙✼➛✞➓➄➩ ➙▲➔✲➏✼→▲↕✩➛✓➩ ➓⑥➙ ↔ ✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✉✪✲✹ ✱✩✭✺✬✩★✓★ ↔ ✮ ✬✩✭✫❜✲✧✲✰ ❻✼✈✩✬✩★❤✇ ✱✼✹⑥✰ ✧✩✽✲✰ ④③✰ ✽✼✈✩✴✲✾✩✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✱✲✹ ★ ✡ ✏ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Software Inspection

Research (2)

➍✸➒✞→✼➔✩→▲➤▲➒✞↕✲➦➐➤✼➛ ✓✩➑▲↕✩→⑥➙✼➛✞✜❤→✼↕✲➦⑥➙▲➓⑥➜ ➓✄✟❖➩ →✼➔♣➥✌✔✵➙⑥➩ ➨❹→▲➒✞➔✲➩ ➛ ➠ ➓▲➭✗☎◆➤⑥➒ ➠❹➜ ➤⑥➙▲➝▲➧ ↔ ✬t❷③✪✫✬✲✹ ✰ ✷❡✬✲✧t✮⑥⑤⑦❜✩✬✲✹ ✬①✮ ❜✩✬t✿❡④t✴✲✹ ✰ ✬✩✽ ☛ ❋✺❳✓▼❚♦✓■✺❈✩❆✯❵➁● ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✺❘ ❙ ❆✺❈ ❏ ☛ ❋✺❳✓▼❚♦✓■✺❈✩❆✯❵✩❙ ■✓❊✓▼❖❏⑥● ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙
  • ❋✓❉❫❙
❲✞■❚❏ ❊✓▼❖■❖❘✞❆✓❯✺■ ☛ ❙ ■✺❊✓▼❖❏❹r♥❆✺❈ q✓● ❋✓❉❚● ❋❚◗✓❊✺❈ ❊✺❨ ❨ ■✺❨✓❊✺❋✓❯❫❙ ■✓❊✺▼❖❏❹r❹❆✫❈ q✓● ❋✓❉❚● ❋❦❙ ❊✫❋✓❯✓■✺▼ ❬ r♥❲✓■✺❈ ■❚♦✓❳✓❉✺❏❹r♥■✺❈ ■❦❵
  • ✂✯■✓❯❚♦✓■❱❵
❆✫❈ ■☎✄✫❋✓❯✵● ❋✓❏✓◗✞■✺❘ ❙
  • ❆✺❋❦❙
❆✓❆✫q ◗✺❨ ❊✓❘ ■✫❛ ↔ ✱✲✧✩✬◆✱③✇▲✮ ❜✩✬◆✭✺✱✲✧✩✭✫✾ ✈✩★✺✰ ✱✼✧✫★ ☛ ▼❖❆✺❏ ❙③❏✞● ❉✫❋✺● ❵
❊✺❋❱❙❹● ▼❚◗✓❈ ❆❱❩✯■✓▼❖■✺❋❱❙ ❏⑥● ❋❖● ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙
  • ❆✫❋❖❘
❆✺▼❖■✓❏❹❵ ❈ ❆✺▼
  • ▼❚◗✺❈
❆❱❩⑨● ❋✓❉❫❙ ❲✓■❦r♥❊❱❪⑥❙ ❲✓■❚● ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙ ❆✫❈ ❏▲❯✺❆❦❙ ❲✓■✺● ❈✲● ❋✓❯✫● ❩⑨● ❯✫❳✓❊✺❨❱r♥❆✺❈ q ✡ ✁ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Software Inspection

Research (3)

➍✸➙▲→✩✓ ➛✞→▲↕✲➦▲➙⑥➩ ✆❖➑✼→▲➔✉➛✞➓➄➦▲→⑥➜ ➏✔✟⑥➑⑥➩ ➝⑥→➐➩ ➙▲➔✲➏✼→▲↕✩➛✞➓⑥➒ ➔♣➩ ➙ ➛✓➦✼→⑥➩ ➒✭✓✉➓⑥➒✯☛ ↔ ★✺✭✓✬✲✧✩✴✲✹ ✰ ✱✩❂✞②✩✴✩★✓✬✩✽✳✹ ✬✩✴✩✽✲✰ ✧✩❽ ☛ ■✓❉✫❶✫◗✺❳❱❙✲❪❱❆✫❳✺❈ ❏ ■✺❨ ❵➁● ❋❦❙ ❲✓■❚❈ ❆✫❨ ■❖❆❱❵③❊❦❙ ■✓❏ ❙ ■✺❈ ☛ ❲✓❊❱❩✯■❖❊❖❏ ■✺❈
  • ■✓❏▲❆✯❵③➊✫❳✓■✓❏
  • ❆✫❋✓❏▲❊✺❋✓❯❚❏
❘✞■✺❋✓❊✺❈
  • ❆✺❏❹❙
❆❫r❹❆✫❈ q♥r♥● ❙ ❲❖❊✺❏ ❪✯❆✺❳❚● ❋✓❏✞◗✓■✓❘ ❙ ✡ s ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Checklists
➍✦↕✩➓⑥➡➐➡♣➓❖➙✔✟❖➑▲➩ ➝⑥➤▲➙▲↕✩→➄➑✼➔✩→▲➝➐➭ ➓⑥➒❡➩ ➙▲➔✩➏▲→▲↕✩➛✞➩ ➓❖➙✼➔ ➍ ✟▲➓⑥➓▲➝➐↕✲➦▲→▲↕✥☛✲➜ ➩ ➔✩➛✞➔✳➤▲➒✞→➐➦▲➤⑥➒ ➝➄➛✞➓➄➡♣➤✘☛✩→➄➑⑥➏ ↔ ✹ ✬✲✾ ✿✶✱✲✧✳✪✫✴✩★✯✮♥✬t❷③✪✩✬✲✹ ✰ ✬✲✧✩✭✺✬ ↔ ✭✺✴✲✧◆❽✲✬t✮▲✮ ✱✩✱✳✾ ✱✲✧✩❽✉✴✲✧✩✽✳✈✲✧t⑤⑦✰ ✬✲✾ ✽③✿ ↔ ✧✩✬✩✬✩✽①✮ ✱✉②✩✬✉✈✲✪✩✽✲✴⑨✮ ✬✩✽✉✴✩★❡✧✩✬t⑤❿★✺✰ ✮ ✈✩✴t✮ ✰ ✱✲✧✩★✵✴✲✹ ✰ ★✓✬ ↔ ✰ ✧✩★✺✪✩✬✩✭✯✮ ✱✲✹ ★❡❜✩✴t④t✬◆✴✶✮ ✬✲✧✩✽✲✬✲✧✫✭✯✿◆✮ ✱①✇ ✱✼✾ ✾ ✱③⑤➟✮ ❜✫✬✉✭✫❜✩✬✫✭✫❝✫✾ ✰ ★✯✮ ✴✲✧✩✽✉✽✩✱✳✧✩✱✳✷❡✱✲✹ ✬ ↔ ✭✺✴✲✧✉②✩✬✉✷◆✰ ★✫✰ ✧⑨✮ ✬✩✹ ✪✲✹ ✬t✮ ✬✩✽ ↔ ✷❡✴t✿❁✧✫✱③✮♥✭✺✱③④t✬✲✹▲✬t④t✬✲✹ ✿✩✮ ❜✩✰ ✧✩❽✳✧✩✬✩✭✺✬✩★✓★✺✴✲✹ ✿◆✮ ✱①✮ ❜✩✬✉✹ ✰ ❽✲❜t✮ ✾ ✬t④t✬✲✾✫✱t✇♥✽✲✬t✮ ✴✲✰ ✾ ✡ ❼ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Approach for Checklists
✤✸❞ ❽✩✬✲✧✩✬✲✹ ✴✲✾✫✴✲✪✩✪✲✹ ✱✩✴✩✭✫❜✶✇ ✱✲✹⑥✰ ✧✩★✫✪✫✬✩✭✯✮ ✰ ✱✼✧✫★✵✴✩★❤⑤⑦✬✩✾ ✾ ❢ ✤✦✽✲✬t✮ ✬✩✹ ✷✉✰ ✧✩✬①⑤⑦❜✩✴t✮♥❻✼✈✩✴✲✾ ✰ ✮ ✰ ✬✩★✵✴✲✹ ✬✉✰ ✷◆✪✩✱✲✹ ✮ ✴✲✧t✮▲✇ ✱✲✹♥✮ ❜✫✬ ★✺✱t✇ ✮ ⑤⑦✴✲✹ ✬◆★❱✿③★❱✮ ✬✲✷ ✤✦✽✲✬t✮ ✬✩✹ ✷✉✰ ✧✩✬①⑤⑦❜✩✴t✮♥★✺✱t✇ ✮ ⑤❤✴✲✹ ✬◆✽✲✬✩★✺✰ ❽✼✧✞✝ ✭✺✱✩✽✲✬◆✭✫❜✩✴✲✹ ✴✩✭✯✮ ✬✲✹ ✰ ★✯✮ ✰ ✭✺★ ✭✺✱✲✧t✮ ✹ ✰ ②✲✈⑨✮ ✬①✮ ✱①✮ ❜✫✱✲★✓✬✉❻✲✈✩✴✲✾ ✰ ✮ ✰ ✬✩★ ✤✦✽✲✬t✮ ✬✩✹ ✷✉✰ ✧✩✬①⑤⑦❜✩✴t✮▲✿t✱✼✈✶⑤❤✴✲✧t✮▲✮❱❜✫✬✳✰ ✧✫★✫✪✩✬✫✭✯✮ ✱✼✹ ★❤✮ ✱✉✾ ✱✲✱✲❝❤✇ ✱✲✹ ❅❇❊✺❨ ❏ ❆❚❯✺■❱❙ ■✺❈ ▼❚● ❋✓■✺❏⑥◗✓❈ ❊✺❘ ❙
■✓❏❹❪✯❆✫❳❦r❹❊✺❋❱❙✲❙ ❲✓■❖❏ ❆✯❵ ❙ r❹❊✺❈ ■❖❯✓■✯❩❱■✺❨ ❆✫◗✓■✺❈ ❏ ❙ ❆❫❵ ❆✫❨ ❨ ❆✯r ✤✦✭✫❜✩✬✩✭✫❝✫✾ ✰ ★❱✮❫✈✫★✺✬✩✽①✇ ✱✼✹✠✟❹★✺★✺✰ ❽✼✧✩✷◆✬✲✧⑨✮ ✦✳✰ ★❡②✫✴✩★✺✬✩✽✉✱✲✧☛✡❚✭✌☞▲✴✩✾ ✾ ❺ ★ ✍ ✈✩✴✲✾ ✰ ✮ ✿✎✡✵✱✩✽✲✬✲✾

McCall's Quality Model

slide-11
SLIDE 11

11

✏ ➋ ✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✓ ✔
✌ ✌ ✖ ✗ ✘ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✛ ✟ ✚ ✜ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✚ ✛ ✢ ✘ ✣ ✛ ✡ ✟ ✛
  • Testing
➍✁❚➓✄✓ ✓✉→➐➡➫➓❹➨❹→➫➛✞➓➐➛✓➦▲→➫➔✲➑⑥➞✌☞ →✼↕✲➛❚➓⑥➭❚➛ →▲➔✩➛✓➩ ➙✩✟ ➍✁⑥→✼↕✲➤▲➜ ➜✼➛✓➦▲➤✼➛✵➔✩➓▲➭ ➛✚✓✉➤▲➒✞→➄➏▲➒✞➓▲↕✩→▲➔✫➔✳➔✲➦✼➓❖➑▲➜ ➝➟➩ ➙✼↕✼➜ ➑✼➝⑥→ ✂☎✄✝✆ ✞✠✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✓✒✠✔☎✑✌✕✖✎ ✑✌☞✘✗✓✡✌✙✍✟✏✎ ✚☎✑ ✛✢✜ ✑✓☞✘✗✌✡✓✙✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒✣✕✓✚✓✙✘✤☎✥✦✡✓✑✓✟☛☞★✧✁✙✍✚✓✕☎✡✠✩✓✡✌✪☛✚☎✫ ✡✠✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ✫☛✡✌☞✘✤☎✬ ✟ ☞✭✎ ✑✠✪ ✡✌✮✯✡✓✫✰✕✓✡✓✪ ✡✓✙✍✟ ☞✯✪ ✚☎✫✰✟☛✡✓☞✱✟✏✎ ✑✓✒✠✟☛✚✠✪☛✎ ✑✓✕✳✲ ☞✘✗✌✡✓✡✌✕☎☞✯✤☎✗✠✟ ✡✓☞✍✟☛✎ ✑✓✒ ✛✵✴ ✩☎✎ ✟✶✚✓✪✷✎ ✑✌✪ ✚✝✫☛✥✦✔✓✬✌✟☛✡✓☞✱✟✏✎ ✑✓✒✣✩✓✡✌✪☛✚☎✫ ✡✠✙✍✚✓✕☎✡ ✎ ✑✓☞✍✗✓✡✌✙✘✟☛✎ ✚✝✑✠✥✠✎ ✒☎✸✓✟✰☞✱✔✺✹✻✡✠✟✏✎ ✥✭✡✳✲✼✒✓✡✓✟✷✫✏✎ ✕✠✚✓✪ ✚☎✩✺✹✺✎ ✚☎✤✓☞✭✩✓✤✓✒✓☞✯✽✝✤✓✎ ✙✘✾✌✬ ✿ ❀ ❁ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Testing is Hard!

✛ ✸☎✎ ✟ ☞✭✩☎✤✌✕☎✒✓✡✓✟✰✔✓✑✓✕✠☞✍✙✘✸✓✡✌✕✝✤✓✬ ✡✣✬ ✎ ✥✦✎ ✟☛☞ ✛ ✥✦✔✻✿✼✎ ✑✌✙✘✬ ✤✌✕☎✡✠✸✓✡✌✔✺✹✘✿✳✕☎✡✓✩☎✤✌✒☎✒☎✎ ✑✓✒ ❳✳❨✷❩❭❬❫❪❭❴❭❪✍❵✯❛ ❵✱❜✱❝ ❞✍❡✘❪★❢✘❣ ❤✍❡✌❞✱❜❥✐❧❦ ❣ ❪✍♠ ♥♦❡✍❪❭❴❭❪✘❝ ❤✌❢✍❨✷❪✘❵❭✐ ✛ ✩✓✤✓✒☎☞★☞✘✬ ✎ ✗✠✟☛✸☎✫☛✚☎✤✌✒✝✸✠✟ ✚✣✙✘✤✌☞✍✟☛✚☎✥✦✡✓✫☛☞ ❳✳❞✍♣✏❪✘❣✓❪❭q❭❪✍❜✱❞❭✐ ❪✍♣✷❞✘❵r✐ ❪✍♣❥✐ ❪✍❡★❜s❤✍❡✘❪ ❳t❤✘❣ ❡✘❪✘❣☎❛ ❵✈✉✈✇✍❛ ❜✱✇★♣♦✐ ❩❭✐ ❪✘❨✷❪✘❵❭✐ ♣✰❩✘❣ ❪①❪❭q❭❪✱❜✱❞❭✐ ❪✍❡✯❛ ❵①❩✍❜❥✐ ❞✍❩✘❝ ❞✍♣✏❪★❡✘❛ ② ② ❪✘❣✺② ❣ ❤✘❨③✐ ✇✍❩❭✐④❛ ❵✈✐ ❪✍♣❥✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤ ❳✳❞✍♣✏❪✘❣✓❩✘❢✘❢✘❝ ❛ ❪✍♣✰❜s❤✌❨①⑥✘❛ ❵✍❩❭✐ ❛ ❤✘❵★❤❭②④❞✘❵❭✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❪✍❡✯❛ ❵✘❢✍❞❭✐☎❴❭❩✘❝ ❞✱❪✍♣ ❳✳❞✍♣✏❪✘❣ ⑦ ♣✰❤✌❢✱❪✘❣ ❩❭✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❪✘❵❭❴⑧❛ ❣ ❤✌❵✍❨①❪✘❵r✐❧❛ ♣✷❵✍❪r❴⑧❪✍❣⑨✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❪✍❡ ❀ ▼ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Skills of a Tester (1)

⑩✢❶ ❤❭✐④❩✘❝ ❝r✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❪✍❣ ♣✰❩✘❣ ❪①❡✘❪❭❴❭❪✘❝ ❤✘❢✍❪✍❣ ♣ ❷t❸s❹ ❺✱❹❥❻ ❸s❼ ❻ ❸s❽ ❼✓❾♦❻⑧❿✱➀✱❽ ❸s➁♦➂④➃✏➀✝❾s❽ ❸✶➄s➃✏➀❥❻ ➀s❺✱❽ ❾s➄s➃✏❸s❽ ❼✓➅ ❿✱➀✱❽ ❸s➁s➆✘❽ ❾♦➂ ❻ ❸s❼ ❻ ➇ ➈✏❺✱➉ ❷t❸s❹ ❺✱❹❥❻ ❸s❼ ❻ ➇ ➈✏❺✰➊s➋✏➌✏➌✱➇ ❸✏❼✓❾♦❻✺➍✓➇ ➎✏❽ ➀✏❼ ➀❥➏ ❻ ⑩ ✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❪✘❣ ♣➐✉✈✇✱❤★❩✘❣ ❪①❡✘❪❭❴❭❪✘❝ ❤✘❢✍❪✍❣ ♣✷❨①❞✍♣❥✐④✇✍❩❭❴❭❪ ❷t❾s➊s➇ ➁ ➇ ❻ ➑☎❻ ➀✝❼☛❸s➁ ❸✏➎ ❻✻❺s➀✏➀s➌❧❻ ❸✏❼ ❻✻➎ ❾s❼ ❸✏❼ ❷t❾s➊s➇ ➁ ➇ ❻ ➑☎❻ ➀④➂④➇ ❻ ➃✏❼ ❻ ❾s➈✏➌❧❻ ➃✏❸✝➒✝➀s❼ ❻✻❼ ❸♦➓♦❸✱❽ ❸✝➌s❸✏❾✏➌✱➁ ➇ ➈✏❸✝❾s➈✏➌✶❽ ❸✏❼ ➀✱➋s❽ ➎ ❸ ➄s❽ ❸✏❼ ❼☛➋s❽ ❸✏❼ ❷t❾s➊s➇ ➁ ➇ ❻ ➑☎❻ ➀✝➀✱❽ ❺s❾s➈s➇ ➔ ❸✝❾s➈✏➌✶❾s➈✏❾s➁ ➑❥➔ ❸✶➁ ❾s❽ ❺s❸④➓❥➀s➁ ➋✏➒✝❸✏❼✓➀❥➏⑧➌s❾♦❻ ❾ ❷t❾s➊s➇ ➁ ➇ ❻ ➑☎❻ ➀✝❼☛➀s❽ ❻✻➀s➋♦❻✻➎ ➀s➒✶➄s➁ ❸♦→☎➓❥❸s❽ ❼☛➇ ➀✱➈☎➎☛➀✱➈♦❻ ❽ ➀✱➁s➇ ❼☛❼☛➋✏❸✏❼ ❷✳➄s➁ ➋✏❼✺❻ ➃✏❸✝❾s➊s➇ ➁ ➇ ❻ ➇ ❸✏❼✓➀❥➏⑧❾✝➌s❸♦➓♦❸s➁ ➀✱➄✏❸s❽ ❀ ➣ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Skills of a Tester (2)

✛✁↔ ✚☎✫☛✡✠☞✍✾✌✎ ✬ ✬ ☞✯✡✓✥✠✗✓✬ ✚✺✿✺✡☎✫ ☞✭✬ ✚✓✚☎✾✭✪ ✚☎✫✱↕ ❳t♣s❤❭② ✐ ✉➙❩✘❣ ❪①❪✘❵✍⑤✘❛ ❵✍❪✍❪✘❣ ❛ ❵✍⑤★♣✱➛✱❛ ❝ ❝ ♣ ➜ ➋s➈✏➌s❸s❽ ❼ ❻ ❾s➈✏➌✱➇ ➈✏❺④❻ ➃✏❸✶❽ ➋s➁ ❸✏❼✓➀❥➏❭❼☛➀♦➏ ❻ ➂✺❾✱❽ ❸✝❸s➈✏❺✱➇ ➈✏❸✏❸s❽ ➇ ➈✏❺ ➜ ➎☛➀✏➒✶➄s➋♦❻ ❸s❽✘➄s❽ ➀✏❺✱❽ ❾s➒✝➒✶➇ ➈✏❺ ➜ ➀✱➄☛❸✱❽ ❾♦❻ ➇ ➈✏❺✶❼ ➑❥❼ ❻ ❸s➒✦➁ ❸♦➓❥❸s➁s➝☛➈✏➀❥➂④➁ ❸✏➌s❺✏❸ ❳t❜s❤✘❨★❨①❞✘❵✘❛ ❜s❩❭✐ ❛ ❤✌❵①♣s➛✱❛ ❝ ❝ ♣ ❳t❤✘❣ ⑤✘❩✘❵✘❛ ➞s❩❭✐ ❛ ❤✘❵✍❩✘❝✱♣s➛✍❛ ❝ ❝ ♣ ❳✳✇✍❩✘❵✱❡✘♣s♠ ❤✘❵①❪❭q⑧❢✍❪✘❣ ❛ ❪✘❵✍❜s❪ ❀ ➟ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Attitude For Testers

⑩ ❡✘❪✍♣♦✐ ❣ ❞✍❜❥✐ ❛ ❴❭❪①❜✱❣ ❪✍❩❭✐ ❛ ❴⑧❛ ✐ ❬ ⑩ ❡✘❪❭✐ ❪✱❜❥✐ ❛ ❴❭❪★♣s➛✱❛ ❝ ❝ ♣ ⑩ ❞✘❵✍❡✍❪✘❣ ♣♦✐ ❩✍❵✍❡✌❛ ❵✍⑤❫✐ ✇✍❪★❢✍❣ ❤✘❡✘❞✍❜❥✐④❩✱♣➐✐ ✇✍❪★♣s❞✘❨✢❤❭②④❛ ✐ ♣✷❢✱❩✘❣ ✐ ♣ ⑩ ❩✘❢✘❢✍❣ ❪✍❜✱❛ ❩❭✐ ❛ ❵✱⑤❫✐♦✇✱❪★❜✱❞✱♣❥✐ ❤✘❨①❪✘❣ ⑦ ♣✷❢✱❪✘❣ ♣✱❢✱❪✍❜❥✐ ❛ ❴❭❪ ⑩ ❣ ❪✍➠✘❞✘❛ ❣ ❪✘❨✷❪✘❵❭✐ ♣✰❜✱✇✍❩✍❵✍⑤✘❪ ⑩ ♣✱➛s❪✍❢❭✐ ❛ ❜s❩✘❝✍⑥✘❞❭✐④❵✍❤❭✐❧✇✍❤✍♣♦✐♦❛ ❝ ❪★❩❭✐ ✐ ❛ ✐ ❞✱❡✘❪ ⑩ ❩✘⑥✘❛ ❝ ❛ ✐ ❬①✐ ❤✯⑥✱❪❫✐ ✇✱❪✯⑥✱❪✍❩✘❣ ❪✘❣✓❤❭②④⑥✍❩✍❡✯❵✍❪❭✉➐♣✰❩✘❵✍❡✯❣ ❪✘❨✷❩✘❛ ❵①❤✘⑥❥➡ ❪✍❜❥✐ ❛ ❴❭❪ ⑩ ❩✘❵①❪✍❩✍⑤✍❪✘❣ ❵✍❪✍♣✏♣➐✐ ❤★❪✘❨①⑥✘❣ ❩✍❜s❪★❵✍❪❭✉✖✐ ❪✱❜✱✇✘❵✍❤✘❝ ❤✘⑤✘❛ ❪✍♣ ❀ ❀ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Definitions of Testing (1)

✛✁↔ ✿✺✡✓✫☛☞✍➢✝➤①✬ ✡☎✑✌✪ ✚✝✫ ✕✼➥⑧➦ ➢④➧➐✸✓✡ ✴ ✫☛✟✰✚✓✪✰➨✓✚✓✪ ✟☛✮★✔☎✫ ✡ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒☎➢④➩③✎ ✬ ✡✺✿✻➢✷➫✘➭☎➯✌➭ ❳✯➲✏➳⑨✇✍❪★➵✍❣ ❤✘❜s❪✱♣s♣✰❤❭②⑨❪❭q❭❪✍❜✱❞❭✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❩★❢✘❣ ❤✘⑤✘❣ ❩✘❨③✉➙❛ ✐ ✇✈✐♦✇✱❪ ❛ ❵❭✐ ❪✘❵r✐④❤❭②✓② ❛ ❵✍❡✘❛ ❵✍⑤★❪✘❣ ❣ ❤✘❣ ♣s➸ ✛✁➺ ✡✌✟☛➻✍✡✓✬ ➢✷➼☎✎ ✬ ✬ ➢ ✴✵➽ ✚☎✥✦✗☎✬ ✡✌✟☛✡✠➤✷✤☎✎ ✕✓✡✠✟☛✚✣➨✓✚✓✪ ✟☛✮★✔✓✫☛✡ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒☎➢✝➾✯➚☎➪ ✜ ✑✓✪ ✚☎✫✏✥✭✔✓✟✏✎ ✚☎✑✠➨✓✙✘✎ ✡☎✑✌✙✘✡✌☞ ✜ ✑✓✙✌➦ ➢✰➫✘➭☎➶✓➶ ❳✳➹ ➳✺❪✍♣♦✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤✯❛ ♣✰❩✘❵r❬❫❩✍❜❥✐ ❛ ❴⑧❛ ✐ ❬✈❩✘❛ ❨✷❪✍❡★❩❭✐④❪❭❴❭❩✘❝ ❞✍❩❭✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❩✘❵ ❩❭✐ ✐ ❣ ❛ ⑥✍❞❭✐ ❪★❤✘❣✓❜s❩✘❢✍❩✘⑥✍❛ ❝ ❛ ✐ ❬✈❤⑧②⑨❩★❢✘❣ ❤✍⑤✌❣ ❩✘❨✢❤✘❣☎♣♦❬❭♣❥✐ ❪✘❨➘❩✘❵✍❡ ❡✘❪❭✐ ❪✍❣ ❨★❛ ❵✘❛ ❵✍⑤❫✐ ✇✍❩❭✐④❛ ✐❧❨✷❪✍❪❭✐ ♣✷❛ ✐ ♣✷❣ ❪✍➠✌❞✘❛ ❣ ❪✱❡✯❣ ❪✍♣✱❞✘❝ ✐ ♣✍➴ ➹
slide-12
SLIDE 12

12

❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Definitions of Testing (2)

✛✢✜ ➚☎➚☎➚✠➨✌✟☛✔☎✑✌✕☎✔✓✫☛✕✂✁✶➫☎✄✝➦ ➫✝✆✟✞s➫✘➭✓➭✟✄ ❳✯➲✏➳⑨✇✍❪★❢✍❣ ❤✘❜s❪✱♣s♣✰❤❭②⑨❤✌❢✱❪✘❣ ❩❭✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❩①♣♦❬⑧♣♦✐ ❪✘❨✢❤✘❣✓❜s❤✌❨①❢✍❤✘❵✍❪✘❵r✐ ❞✘❵✍❡✍❪✘❣✓♣✱❢✍❪✱❜✱❛ ② ❛ ❪✍❡★❜s❤✘❵✍❡✌❛ ✐♦❛ ❤✌❵✍♣✡✠✓❤✘⑥✍♣✏❪✘❣ ❴⑧❛ ❵✍⑤★❤✘❣☎❣ ❪✍❜s❤✘❣ ❡✌❛ ❵✍⑤ ✐ ✇✍❪★❣ ❪✍♣s❞✘❝ ✐ ♣☛✠✌❩✘❵✍❡✯❨✷❩✘➛✱❛ ❵✍⑤★❩✘❵①❪❭❴❭❩✘❝ ❞✍❩❭✐ ❛ ❤✌❵①❤❭②⑨♣s❤✘❨①❪ ❩✍♣s❢✍❪✍❜❥✐⑨❤⑧②✓✐ ✇✍❪①♣♦❬❭♣❥✐ ❪✘❨✢❤✘❣✓❜s❤✌❨①❢✱❤✌❵✍❪✍❵❭✐ ➸ ✛✢✜ ➚☎➚☎➚✠➨✌✟☛✔☎✑✌✕☎✔✓✫☛✕✠➶☞✆✌➭✌✞s➫✘➭✓➶✌✍ ❳✯➲✏➳⑨✇✍❪★❢✍❣ ❤✘❜s❪✱♣s♣✰❤❭②⑨❩✘❵✍❩✘❝ ❬❭➞s❛ ❵✍⑤★❩①♣s❤❭② ✐ ✉➐❩✘❣ ❪★❛ ✐ ❪✘❨③✐ ❤ ❡✘❪❭✐ ❪✱❜❥✐☎✐ ✇✍❪①❡✌❛ ② ② ❪✘❣ ❪✍❵✍❜s❪✍♣✷⑥✍❪r✐ ✉➐❪✍❪✘❵①❪❭q⑧❛ ♣♦✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❩✘❵✍❡ ❣ ❪✍➠✘❞✘❛ ❣ ❪✍❡★❜s❤✘❵✍❡✌❛ ✐ ❛ ❤✘❵✍♣✷❦ ✐ ✇✍❩❭✐④❛ ♣✎✠☎⑥✍❞✍⑤✘♣♦♥➐❩✍❵✍❡❫✐ ❤★❪❭❴❭❩✘❝ ❞✍❩❭✐ ❪ ✐ ✇✍❪✈② ❪✍❩r✐♦❞✍❣ ❪✍♣✰❤❭②✓✐ ✇✍❪①♣s❤❭② ✐ ✉➐❩✘❣ ❪★❛ ✐ ❪✘❨①♣s➸ ❀ ✏ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Purposes of Testing

⑩ ➳✺❤✈② ❛ ❵✍❡✯⑥✍❞✍⑤✘♣✰♠✝❛ ❵✍❜✱❝ ❞✍❡✘❛ ❵✍⑤✯⑥✘❞✍⑤✍♣✷❛ ❵✈✐ ✇✍❪✈✐ ❪✱♣❥✐ ♣✒✑ ⑩ ➳✺❤①❪✍♣❥✐ ❛ ❨✷❩❭✐ ❪★❣ ❪✘❝ ❛ ❩✘⑥✍❛ ❝ ❛ ✐ ❬ ❛ ❵✯❞✍♣✏❪★⑥❭❬✷✐♦❣ ❩✍❜✱➛✱❛ ❵✍⑤❫✐ ✇✍❪ ❪❭q❭❪✍❜✱❞r✐♦❛ ❤✌❵✈✐ ❛ ❨✷❪✯❛ ❵❭✐ ❪✘❣ ❴❭❩✘❝✍⑥✍❪❭✐ ✉➐❪✍❪✘❵✈② ❩✘❛ ❝ ❞✍❣ ❪✍♣ ⑩ ➳✺❤①❪✍♣❥✐ ❛ ❨✷❩❭✐ ❪①❡✘❪❭② ❪✍❜❥✐ ♣✷❣ ❪✘❨✷❩✘❛ ❵✘❛ ❵✱⑤✭⑥r❬①✐ ❣ ❩✱❜✱➛✍❛ ❵✍⑤❫✐ ✇✍❪①❡✘❪❭② ❪✱❜❥✐ ♣ ② ❤✘❞✘❵✍❡✯❢✱❪✘❣☎❢✍❪✘❣ ♣✏❤✌❵✱♠☛✇✍❤✌❞✍❣☎❤❭②✓✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❩✘❵✍❡★❡✘❪✘⑥✍❞✍⑤✘⑤✘❛ ❵✍⑤❫✐ ❛ ❨✷❪ ⑩ ➳✺❤①❡✘❪✍❜✱❛ ❡✍❪★❤✘❵✈✉✈✇✍❪✍❵❫✐ ❤★❣ ❪✘❝ ❪✍❩✍♣✏❪✟✓✘❪✌➴ ⑤✓➴✌⑥r❬❫❡✍❪✍❜✱❛ ❡✌❛ ❵✱⑤ ✐ ✇✱❩❭✐ ✐ ✇✍❪★❣ ❪✘❨✷❩✘❛ ❵✘❛ ❵✱⑤✭➛✱❵✱❤⑧✉➙❵①❡✘❪❭② ❪✱❜❥✐ ♣✰❩✘❣ ❪①❩✍❜s❜s❪✘❢❭✐ ❩✘⑥✍❝ ❪✯❛ ❵❫✐ ✇✍❪ ✐ ❩✘❣ ⑤✍❪❭✐❧❨✷❩✘❣ ➛s❪❭✐ ⑩ ➳✺❤★❝ ❪✍❩✘❣ ❵✈✉✈✇✱❪✘❣ ❪★❢✘❣ ❤✍❜s❪✍♣s♣✰❢✘❣ ❤✘⑥✘❝ ❪✘❨✷♣✰❩✘❣ ❪★⑥❭❬✈❜✱❝ ❩✍♣✏♣✱❛ ② ❬✻❛ ❵✍⑤ ❩✘❵✍❡★❜s❤✘❞✘❵❭✐ ❛ ❵✱⑤✯❡✍❪❭② ❪✍❜❥✐ ♣❧② ❤✘❞✘❵✍❡ ❀ ✔ ❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

What Testing Can't Do

✛ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒✣✙✍✔✓✑✌✕ ✟✰✒✝✤✌✔☎✫☛✔✓✑✓✟☛✡✌✡✠✙✍✚✓✕☎✡✠✎ ☞✯✙✍✚☎✫✏✫☛✡✌✙✍✟ ✛✗✖ ✚☎✤✠✙✍✔☎✑✟✕ ✟✰✟☛✫ ✿✳✡✻✹✺✡✓✫ ✿✼✗✌✚✓☞✍☞✘✎ ✩✓✬ ✡✠✙✍✚☎✥✠✩✓✎ ✑✓✔✌✟✏✎ ✚☎✑✠✚✓✪ ✎ ✑☎✗✓✤✓✟☛☞✱➢✶✡✻✹✺✡☎✫ ✿✳✡✓✑✺✹⑨✎ ✫ ✚✝✑✓✥✦✡✓✑✓✟ ✛✙✘ ✎ ✒✓✚☎✫☛✚☎✤✓☞✯✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒✖✎ ✑✌✙✌✫ ✡✓✔✌☞✍✡✓☞★✙✍✚✝✑✌✪☛✎ ✕☎✡✓✑✓✙✍✡✠✟✏✸✌✔✓✟ ☞✍✚✓✪ ✟☛✮★✔✓✫☛✡✣✫☛✤☎✑✓☞★✙✘✚☎✫☛✫☛✡✓✙✍✟✏✬ ✿✻➢✶✚☎✫✰✟✏✸✌✔✓✟✰✪ ✡✌✮ ✩☎✤✓✒✓☞ ✫☛✡✓✥✦✔✓✎ ✑ ✛✙✚ ✚✝✫✶☞✍✚☎✥✦✡✦✙✘✫✏✎ ✟✏✎ ✙✍✔☎✬✌☞✱✚☎✪ ✟ ✮✯✔✓✫☛✡✌➢✶✪ ✚☎✫✏✥✦✔✓✬ ✥✦✔✌✟✏✸✌✡☎✥✦✔✌✟✏✎ ✙✍✔☎✬✓✥✭✡✓✟☛✸✓✚✓✕☎☞✯✤✓☞✍✡✌✕✣✟☛✚✜✛s✗✓✫☛✚✺✹✺✡✟✛ ✙✍✚☎✫✏✫☛✡✌✙✘✟☛✑✓✡✌☞✍☞ ✲ ✩☎✤✌✟✰✟✏✸✌✔✓✟✡✕ ☞✯✔✓✑✓✚✓✟✏✸✓✡✓✫✰✟☛✚☎✗✓✎ ✙✯✪☛✚☎✫ ✚✓✟✏✸✓✡✓✫✰✙✍✚☎✤☎✫☛☞✱✡✓☞
❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Stages of Testing (1)

✛✙✘ ✡✌✽✝✤✓✎ ✫ ✡☎✥✭✡☎✑✌✟☛☞✯✔☎✑✌✕➘➪✶✡✌☞✘✎ ✒☎✑✠✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ❳✭✉➙✇✍❪✘❵ ❣ ❪✍➠✌❞✘❛ ❣ ❪✘❨①❪✍❵❭✐ ♣ ❩✘❵✍❡ ❡✘❪✍♣s❛ ⑤✌❵ ❩✘❣ ❪ ✉✈❣ ❛ ✐ ✐ ❪✘❵ ❛ ❵ ♣✱❢✱❪✍❜✱❛ ❩✘❝✦❝ ❩✘❵✍⑤✘❞✍❩✍⑤✘❪✱♣ ✉✈✇✘❛ ❜✱✇ ❢✱❪✘❣ ❨①❛ ✐ ➹ ❪❭q❭❪✍❜✱❞r✐ ❛ ❤✌❵✍➹③✐ ❤ ♣✱❛ ❨★❞✘❝ ❩❭✐ ❪★❩✍❜❥✐ ❞✱❩✘❝✍♣♦❬❭♣❥✐ ❪✘❨ ✛✤✣ ☞✍✡✓✫ ✜ ✑✓✟☛✡✓✫☛✪ ✔✓✙✍✡✦✟☛✡✓☞✱✟✏✎ ✑✓✒ ❳✦✥④② ✐ ❪✘❵①❡✘❤✘❵✍❪①❩❭✐❧❢✍❣ ❤❭✐ ❤⑧✐ ❬⑧❢✘❛ ❵✍⑤★♣❥✐ ❩✍⑤✍❪ ✛✤✣ ✑☎✎ ✟ ✧ ↔ ✚✓✕✝✤☎✬ ✡ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ✛➘➽ ✚☎✥✠✗✌✚✝✑✌✡☎✑✌✟ ✧r☞✍✤☎✩✌☞❭✿✺☞✍✟ ✡☎✥ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✓✒
❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Stages of Testing (2)

✛✢✜ ✑✓✟☛✡✌✒✝✫ ✔✓✟✏✎ ✚☎✑ ➧➐✡✓☞✱✟✏✎ ✑✓✒ ❳✦✩☛❵✍❜✱❣ ❪✘❨✷❪✘❵❭✐ ❩✘❝ ➳✻❪✍♣❥✐ ❛ ❵✱⑤ ♠ ✐ ✇✍❪ ❞✍♣s❞✍❩✘❝ ❴❭❪✘❣ ♣s❛ ❤✌❵ ❤❭② ❛ ❵❭✐ ❪✍⑤✘❣ ❩❭✐ ❛ ❤✘❵❫✐ ❪✱♣❥✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤✌➴ ✛ ➪✶✔✓✎ ✬ ✿✼✩☎✤✓✎ ✬ ✕☎☞★✔☎✑✓✕✣➨✓✔✓✑☎✎ ✟ ✿t✟☛✡✓☞✱✟✏✎ ✑✓✒ ✛ ➨✺✿✻☞✍✟☛✡✓✥ ➧❧✡✓☞✍✟☛✎ ✑✓✒ ❳✳➵✍❪✘❣ ② ❤✘❣ ❨✷❩✘❵✍❜s❪①❩✘❵✍❡✫✪s❤✘❩✱❡✭✬✯✮❭✐ ❣ ❪✍♣s♣➐➳✻❪✍♣❥✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤ ❳✱✰✓♣✏❩✘⑥✘❛ ❝ ❛ ✐ ❬✖➳✻❪✍♣♦✐♦❛ ❵✍⑤☎✠✯⑥✘❞r✐✯✐♦✇✍❛ ♣✖❛ ♣✠❩✢❝ ❩❭✐ ❪➘♣♦✐ ❩✍⑤✘❪✵✐ ❤✢⑥✍❪ ❡✘❤✘❛ ❵✍⑤✯❛ ✐✯✑
❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Stages of Testing (3)

✛✵✴ ✬ ✗☎✸✌✔✠✔✓✑✓✕✖➼✓✡✓✟ ✔t➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ❳t❩✘❝ ❢✍✇✍❩✳✲t✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤❫② ❞✘❝ ❝✱♣♦❬❭♣❥✐ ❪✘❨✁❛ ❵✱♠☛✇✍❤✌❞✱♣s❪ ❳✳⑥✍❪❭✐ ❩✫✲✦❤✌❞r✐ ♣✱❛ ❡✘❪★❞✍♣✏❪✘❣ ♣ ✛✵✴ ✙✍✙✍✡☎✗✌✟☛✔☎✑✌✙✘✡ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ✛✢✜ ✑✓☞✍✟ ✔☎✬ ✬ ✔✌✟✏✎ ✚☎✑✴✧ ➽ ✚☎✥✦✗✓✔✌✟✏✎ ✩☎✎ ✬ ✎ ✟ ✿✯➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ✛✙✵ ✬ ✔✓✟☛✪ ✚☎✫✏✥✶✧ ➽ ✚☎✑✓✪☛✎ ✒☎✤☎✫☛✔✌✟✏✎ ✚☎✑✴✧ ✵ ✚☎✫☛✟✶✟☛✡✓☞✱✟✏✎ ✑✓✒
slide-13
SLIDE 13

13

❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Stages of Testing (4)

✛✢✜ ✑✓✟☛✡✌✒✝✫☛✎ ✟ ✿✳✔✓✑✓✕ ✘ ✡☎✬ ✡✌✔✓☞✍✡✦✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✓✒ ➜ ➌s➀✏➎✏➋✏➒✝❸s➈♦❻ ❾♦❻ ➇ ➀✱➈✝➎ ➀✱➈✏❼☛➇ ❼ ❻ ❸s➈♦❻✍➂④➇ ❻ ➃✶➄s❽ ➀s➌s➋✏➎ ❻ ➜ ➒✝❸✏➌✱➇ ❾✶➈✏➀❥❻✻➇ ➈♦➏ ❸✏➎ ❻ ❸✏➌❧➂④➇ ❻ ➃④➓❥➇ ❽ ➋✏❼ ❸s❼ ➜ ➇ ➈♦❻ ❸s➈✏➌s❸✏➌❧➓❥❸s❽ ❼☛➇ ➀✱➈✶➇ ❼✺➂④➃✏❾♦❻✺➇ ❼✓❾s➎ ❻ ➋✏❾s➁ ➁ ➑➐❽ ❸s➁ ❸✏❾✏❼☛❸✏➌✁ ❹ ❹ ❹ ✛✙✘ ✡✓✬ ✎ ✔☎✩✓✎ ✬ ✎ ✟ ✿✝✧ ➽ ✡✓✫☛✟✏✎ ✪☛✎ ✙✍✔✌✟✏✎ ✚☎✑t➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✌✒ ➜ ❸✏❼ ❻ ➇ ➒✝❾♦❻ ❸s❼☎➍✄✂☎✂✄✆☎➅ ➒✝❸✏❾s➈④❻ ➇ ➒✝❸④❻ ➀④➏ ❾✱➇ ➁ ➋s❽ ❸s➉⑧➂④➇ ❻ ➃✶❽ ❸♦➏ ❸s❽ ❸✱➈☛➎☛❸④❻ ➀ ➀✱➄☛❸✱❽ ❾♦❻ ➇ ➀✱➈✏❾s➁s➄s❽ ➀♦➏ ➇ ➁ ❸✏❼ ➜ ❼ ➀s➒✝❸♦❻ ➇ ➒✝❸s❼✺➏ ➀s❽✍➎☛❸s❽ ❻ ➇ ➏ ➇ ➎☛❾♦❻ ➇ ➀✱➈✝➀❥➏❭➎☛➀✱➈♦➏ ➀s❽ ➒✝❾s➈✏➎ ❸④❻ ➀✝❾✶❼ ❻ ❾s➈✏➌s❾s❽ ➌ ✝✘❸s❹ ❺✱❹✟✞❭❿✡✠❭❿✰➅ ✞❭➌✏❾✱➉ ☞☛ ✌✁✍✯➄✏❽ ➀♦❻ ➀✏➎☛➀✱➁ ❻ ❸✏❼ ❻✻❼☛➋s➇ ❻ ❸✏❼ ✛ ➨✓✡✌✙✘✤☎✫✏✎ ✟ ✿☎✧ ✚ ✔☎✤✓✬ ✟❧➧➐✚☎✬ ✡✓✫☛✔☎✑✌✙✍✡✴✧ ✘ ✡✓✙✍✚✺✹✺✡✓✫ ✿✳✟ ✡✓☞✍✟☛✎ ✑✓✒ ✛✙✘ ✡✌✒✝✫☛✡✌☞✍☞✘✎ ✚☎✑ ➧➐✡✌☞✍✟✏✎ ✑✓✒
❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Black Box Testing

✛ ✗✓✎ ✙✌✾✯✟☛✡✓☞✱✟✰✙✍✔✓☞✍✡✌☞✭✩✌✔✓☞✱✡✓✕✠✚✝✑✠✫☛✡✓✽☎✤☎✎ ✫ ✡☎✥✭✡☎✑✓✟ ☞✯✚☎✑☎✬ ✿ ✛ ✕✓✚✝✑✟✕ ✟✰✤✓☞✍✡✠✾✌✑✓✚✓✮✯✬ ✡✌✕☎✒✓✡✠✚✓✪✰✎ ✥✠✗✓✬ ✡☎✥✭✡☎✑✌✟☛✔✓✟✏✎ ✚☎✑ ✛ ✹⑨✎ ✡✌✮ ✙✍✚☎✕✓✡✠✔✌☞✯✔✠✩☎✬ ✔✌✙✌✾✭✩✓✚✏✎④↕✶✎ ✑✌☞✘✎ ✕☎✡✌☞✭✑✌✚☎✟❧✹⑨✎ ☞✘✎ ✩✓✬ ✡ ✛ ✙✍✔☎✑✠✩✓✡✠✤✓☞✍✡✌✕✣✔✌✟✰✔☎✑✻✿✳☞✍✟ ✔✓✒✓✡✶↕ ❳✳❞✘❵✘❛ ✐ ✠✌♣✱❞✍⑥✍♣❥❬❭♣♦✐ ❪✘❨ ✠✓♣♦❬⑧♣♦✐ ❪✘❨③✐ ❪✍♣♦✐ ❛ ❵✍⑤
❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Black-Box Testing Strategies

✛ ✬ ✚✓✚☎✾✭✔✌✟✰☞✘✗✌✡✓✙✘✎ ✪☛✎ ✙✘✔✌✟✏✎ ✚☎✑✓☞★✪☛✚☎✫✰✎ ✑☎✗☎✤✌✟☛☞ ✛ ✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✷✑✌✚✝✫☛✥✦✔✓✬✓✤✓☞✍✡✝↕ ❳t♣s❩✍❨★❢✍❝ ❛ ❵✍⑤★❤❭②④➹☛❵✍❤✌❣ ❨①❩✘❝ ➹✝❛ ❵✘❢✍❞❭✐ ♣✷❦☛❣ ❩✘❵✱❡✘❤✘❨③❴❭❩✘❝ ❞✍❪✍♣♦♥ ✛ ✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✰✔✓✩☎✑✌✚✝✫☛✥✦✔✓✬✓✤✓☞✍✡✝↕ ❳t❡✌❛ ② ② ❪✘❣ ❪✘❵❭✐❧➛✱❛ ❵✱❡✘♣✰❤❭②⑨❪✘❣ ❣ ❤✘❵✍❪✍❤✘❞✍♣ ✬♦❛ ❝ ❝ ❪✍⑤✍❩✘❝✍❛ ❵✘❢✘❞❭✐ ❳t❜s❤✘❨★⑥✍❛ ❵✍❩❭✐ ❛ ❤✘❵✍♣✰❤❭②⑨❪✘❣ ❣ ❤✘❣ ♣ ✛ ✟☛✡✌☞✍✟✷✩✌✚☎✤☎✑✓✕✓✔☎✫ ✿✳✙✍✚☎✑✓✕✝✎ ✟☛✎ ✚✝✑✌☞✓↕ ❳✭❴❭❩✘❝ ❞✍❪✍♣✶❜✱❝ ❤✘♣✏❪❫✐ ❤★⑥✍❤✘❞✘❵✍❡✘❩✍❣ ❬ ⑥✱❪❭✐ ✉➙❪✍❪✘❵★❵✍❤✘❣ ❨✷❩✘❝✱❩✘❵✍❡ ❩✘⑥✘❵✱❤✌❣ ❨✷❩✘❝
❂ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅☛❆❇☛❈ ❅ ❉ ❊ ❄ ❋ ❇ ❉
■ ❏ ❑ ▲ ❏✏▼ ❁ ▼ ◆
P ◗ ◗ ❘ ❘ ❘ ❙ ❚ ❇ ❙ ❯ ❃ ❄ ❄ ❅ ❇ ❃ ❙ ❚ ❱ ◗ ❲ ❚ ❉ ❇ ❚ ▼ ❁ ▼

Example

/** * Raises a number to an integral power. * * @param base the number to be raised to a power * @param pow the power to which base is to be raised. * Must not be negative. * @return base raised to the pow-th power */ static double power(double base, int pow) {

  • error inputs: negative values for pow
  • boundary cases: pow = 0, pow = 1, pow = -1
  • normal cases:

– pow >= 2, range of values – base: negative, 0, positive – combinations of these

✑ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕✗✖✘✗✙ ✕ ✚ ✛ ✔ ✜ ✘ ✚ ✢ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✦ ✧ ✥✩★ ✪ ★ ✫ ✢ ✢ ✬ ✭ ✮ ✮ ✯ ✯ ✯ ✰ ✱ ✘ ✰ ✲ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕ ✘ ✓ ✰ ✱ ✳ ✮ ✴ ✱ ✚ ✘ ✱ ★ ✪ ★

Possibilities For Automation

✵✷✶✗✸✺✹✼✻✺✽ ✾❀✿ ❁✺❁✺✽❂✿✗❁✷❃✺✹❅❄❅✹✺❆ ✻❅✿✗✹✷❇☎✹❅✿❈❁❅❉❈✿✗✹✼❇☞✿❈❊☞✻❅❇☞✹✼❇❋✻✺❄❅✸ ✹✏●✏❍✼✹❅❊☞✿✗✹✼✸■❆✗✹✼❇❑❏✺✽ ✿ ❇❈❉✗❆✗❁✺▲▼❇☞❍❅✹✼❊✼◆ ❉✗◆ ❊☞✻✼✿✩◆ ❁✺❄❅❇ ✵P❖✺✹✼✻✺✽ ◆ ✿ ◗❘✾❂❄✼✹❅✹✼✸✺❇❚❙❯✹✺❆ ◗❱❍✺❆ ✹❅❊❑◆ ❇☞✹✼❲❳▲❨✻❅✿✩❩✼✹✺▲❬✻✼✿✩◆ ❊☞✻✺✽ ❇❑❍✼✹❅❊❑◆ ❉✗◆ ❊☞✻❅✿✩◆ ❁✺❄✼❇☞❲❳❏✼❇❑❏❅✻❅✽ ✽ ◗❱❄❅❁❅✿❳✻❯❙✏✻❅◆ ✽ ✻✺❭❅✽ ✹ ✵✷❪❅❁❫❏✼❇❑❏❅✻❅✽ ✽ ◗❴❃✺✹❅❄❅✹❅❆✗✻❅✿ ✹▼✿✗✹❅❇☎✿❵❊☞✻❅❇☞✹✼❇❜❛❝✹✏●✏❍✼✹❅❊☞✿✗✹❅✸ ❆✗✹✼❇❑❏✺✽ ✿ ❇❨❭✏◗❞❩❅✻❅❄❅✸ ✵❢❡❣❏❅✿ ❁❤▲❨✻❅✿ ✹❅✸❋✹❯●❯✹❅❊❑❏❅✿✩◆ ❁✺❄✐◆ ❇❈❇☞✿✩◆ ✽ ✽❅❍✼❁❅❇☞❇❑◆ ❭❅✽ ✹ ✑ ❥ ✒ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕✗✖✘✗✙ ✕ ✚ ✛ ✔ ✜ ✘ ✚ ✢ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✦ ✧ ✥✩★ ✪ ★ ✫ ✢ ✢ ✬ ✭ ✮ ✮ ✯ ✯ ✯ ✰ ✱ ✘ ✰ ✲ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕ ✘ ✓ ✰ ✱ ✳ ✮ ✴ ✱ ✚ ✘ ✱ ★ ✪ ★

Test Harness

✵❧❦❣✻❅♠❑✹✼❇❈❇☞✹✼✿❳❁❅❉❂✿✗✹❅❇☎✿♥◆ ❄✺❍❅❏❅✿✗❇♦❛P✹✏●✏❍❅✹✼❊☞✿✗✹❅✸❋❆✗✹✼❇❑❏✺✽ ✿ ❇ ✵P❖❤❏❅❄❅❇❨❍❅❆✗❁❅❃❤❆ ✻✺▲♣❁❤❄❬✹❅✻✼❊✼❩❬✿✗✹✼❇☞✿♥◆ ❄✺❍❅❏❅✿✗❲❤❊☞❁❤▲❬❍❅✻❅❆✗✹✼❇ ❆✗✹✼❇❑❏✺✽ ✿ ❇❈q❈◆ ✿✩❩✐✹❯●r❍✼✹❅❊☞✿✗✹✼✸ ✵P❖✺✹❅❍❅❁✺❆✗✿✗❇♦✻✺❄❯◗❞✸✺◆ ❇☞❊❑❆✗✹✺❍✼✻✺❄✼❊❑◆ ✹✼❇ ✵❵s❤❁✺▲✐❍❅✽ ◆ ❊❑✻✼✿✗✹✼✸❋✿✗❁✐q❈❆✩◆ ✿ ✹✐❉ ❁✺❆❳t❀✉❳✶✗❇☞❲❤✹✺▲❬❭❅✹✼✸✺✸❅✹❅✸ ❇✈◗❯❇☞✿✗✹❅▲❬❇☞❲❂❭✺❏✼✿❳❁❅❉ ✿✗✹✺❄✐❍❅❁❅❇☞❇❑◆ ❭❅✽ ✹ ✵❧❦❣✻❅♠❑✹✼❇❨✽ ❁❅✿✗❇❈❁❅❉❂✸✺❆✩❏❅✸❅❃✺✹❅❆ ◗❞❁✺❏✼✿❳❁❅❉❳✿ ✹❅❇☞✿✗◆ ❄❅❃ ✵P✇❀✻✺♠☞✹❅❇❈✿ ✹❅❇☞✿ ✹✺❆✗❇♦q❈◆ ✽ ✽ ◆ ❄❅❃❋✿ ❁■❆✗❏✺❄✐✻❅❄❅✸❋❆✗✹❅①✩❆✩❏✺❄✐✽ ✻✺❆ ❃✺✹ ✿✗✹✼❇☞✿❳❇❑❏❅◆ ✿✗✹✼❇
slide-14
SLIDE 14

14

✓ ✔ ✔ ✕✗✖✘✗✙ ✕ ✚ ✛ ✔ ✜ ✘ ✚ ✢ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✦ ✧ ✥✩★ ✪ ★ ✫ ✢ ✢ ✬ ✭ ✮ ✮ ✯ ✯ ✯ ✰ ✱ ✘ ✰ ✲ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕ ✘ ✓ ✰ ✱ ✳ ✮ ✴ ✱ ✚ ✘ ✱ ★ ✪ ★

White Box Testing

✵✂✁✼◆ ❊✼♠❈✿✗✹✼❇☞✿❳❊☞✻❅❇☎✹❅❇❨❭✼✻❅❇☎✹❅✸✐❁❤❄❬✿✩❩❅✹❬✻❅❊☞✿✩❏✼✻✺✽✼❇☎❁✺❉ ✿✗q♦✻❅❆✗✹ ✵❵✻✺✽ ❇☎❁✐❊❑✻❅✽ ✽ ✹❅✸☎✄✩❊✼✽ ✹✼✻✺❆❳❭❅❁✏●✆✄❀❁✺❆✝✄✁❇☎✿✩❆✩❏✼❊❑✿✗❏✺❆✗✻❅✽ ✄♥✿✗✹❅❇☎✿✩◆ ❄❅❃ ✵✷♠❑✹❯◗❞q♦❁✺❆✗✸❋◆ ❇✟✞✡✠☞☛✍✌✏✎✒✑✏✓✔✌✺✾ ✕✗✖✏✘✚✙ ✛✡✜✢✙ ✜✍✣✤✙✦✥✒✧✡✣✒✜✡✣✩★✫✪✭✬✯✮✡✰✭✧✏✱ ✱✍✘✳✲✭✙ ✛✡✜✩✥✒✘✡✖✏✜✏✴ ✵❵✸✺◆ ❉✗❉ ✹❅❆✗✹✺❄✼✿♥▲❬✹✼✻❅❇☞❏✺❆✗✹✼❇❈❁❅❉❂❊☞❁r❙❯✹✺❆ ✻❅❃❅✹ ❥ ✵ ✒ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕✗✖✘✗✙ ✕ ✚ ✛ ✔ ✜ ✘ ✚ ✢ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✦ ✧ ✥✩★ ✪ ★ ✫ ✢ ✢ ✬ ✭ ✮ ✮ ✯ ✯ ✯ ✰ ✱ ✘ ✰ ✲ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕ ✘ ✓ ✰ ✱ ✳ ✮ ✴ ✱ ✚ ✘ ✱ ★ ✪ ★

Statement Coverage

✵✂✶❯❙❯✹✺❆ ◗ ❇☞✿✗✻✼✿✗✹✺▲❨✹✺❄✼✿♥◆ ❄✐✿✩❩✼✹✐❇☎❁✺❉ ✿✗q♦✻❅❆✗✹✐▲✐❏❅❇☎✿♥❭❅✹ ✹✏●❯✹❅❊❑❏✼✿✗✹❅✸✐✻❅✿❳✽ ✹❅✻❅❇☎✿❳❁✺❄❅❊☞✹❋❭❯◗❞✿✗❩❅✹✐✿ ✹❅❇☞✿❂❊❑✻✼❇☞✹✼❇ ✵✸✷♦❏✼❁✺✿ ✹✐❉✗❆✗❁✺▲▼✿ ✹✏●❯✿✺✹☎✇♦❏❅❆✩❆✗✻❯◗✆✻☞✾ ✕✽✼ ✾✆✜✡✣✿✙ ❀ ❁✡❂❃✱ ✜✡✣✫✣❄✙ ✛✡✧✏❁✚✙ ✛✏❀ ✣❄✲ ✘❆❅❇❁✡✜❉❈❊✣✫✘❉✲ ✙ ❈❋✧✡❅ ✜❃❀ ✣
  • ❁✡✥✒✘✏❁✡✣✫✥✍❀
✘✏❁✡✧✏❍✏✱ ✜✩✧✏❁✡✖■✣✒✛✡✘
✖❃❍✡✜✩✥✍❅ ❀ ❏✩❀ ❁✡✧✏✱ ❀ ❑✫✜✡✖❆✼ ✵✂▲ ❡❣❪❯❡❢❇☞✿✗❁✺❆ ◗ ❥ ▼ ✒ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕✗✖✘✗✙ ✕ ✚ ✛ ✔ ✜ ✘ ✚ ✢ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✦ ✧ ✥✩★ ✪ ★ ✫ ✢ ✢ ✬ ✭ ✮ ✮ ✯ ✯ ✯ ✰ ✱ ✘ ✰ ✲ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕ ✘ ✓ ✰ ✱ ✳ ✮ ✴ ✱ ✚ ✘ ✱ ★ ✪ ★

Branch Coverage

✵✂✶❯❙❯✹✺❆ ◗❞❭✺❆ ✻✺❄❅❊❑❩❬✻✺✽ ✿✗✹❅❆✩❄❅✻✼✿✩◆ ❙✏✹✐▲✐❏✼❇☞✿♥❭✼✹✐❊☞❁✏❙✏✹❅❆✗✹❅✸❋❭✏◗ ✻❅✿❳✽ ✹❅✻✼❇☞✿❳❁✺❄❅✹❬✿✗✹❅❇☎✿❳❊☞✻❅❇☎✹ ✵P✇❀❁✺❆✗✹✐✸❅✹✺▲❨✻✺❄✼✸❤◆ ❄✼❃❋✿✩❩✼✻✺❄✐❇☎✿✗✻❅✿ ✹✺▲❨✹✺❄❅✿❂❊❑❁✏❙❯✹✺❆✗✻✼❃✺✹❤✾

if (x > 3) y = 14; // continue -- no else part

✵❊◆❢✹✐❄❅✹✼✹❅✸✐✻❅✿♥✽ ✹✼✻❅❇☞✿❂❁❤❄✼✹✐✿ ✹❅❇☞✿❳❊☞✻✼❇☞✹❬q❨❩✼✹✺❆ ✹❞●P❖✂◗✐◆ ❇ ✻✺❄✼✸❋✻✼✿♥✽ ✹❅✻✼❇☞✿❳❁✺❄✼✹✐q❈❩❅✹❅❆✗✹
  • ❊❖❘◗❋◆
❇♦❉ ✻✺✽ ❇☞✹❇❙ ❥ ✪ ✒ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕✗✖✘✗✙ ✕ ✚ ✛ ✔ ✜ ✘ ✚ ✢ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✦ ✧ ✥✩★ ✪ ★ ✫ ✢ ✢ ✬ ✭ ✮ ✮ ✯ ✯ ✯ ✰ ✱ ✘ ✰ ✲ ✓ ✔ ✔ ✕ ✘ ✓ ✰ ✱ ✳ ✮ ✴ ✱ ✚ ✘ ✱ ★ ✪ ★

Path Coverage

  • Every possible path through the program must be

covered by at least one test case

void tst(int x) { if (x>0) pos = pos+1; if (x%2==0) even = even+1; return; }

  • Needs 4 test cases:

– all combinations alternatives

√ √

❚❱❯ ❲ ❳✒❨✫❨

√ √

❚❱❯ ❲ ❩✿❬✤❩✒❭ ❚❱❪❆❫■❴ ❚❄❵✺❴ ❛ ❜ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

Example

void tst(int x) { if (x>0) pos = pos+1; if (x%2==0) even = even+1; }

⑦❘⑧✭⑨ ⑩✭⑨✯❶✭❷✟❶✭❸✭⑨✝❹✔❺✆❻✆❶✭❼✯⑩✭❽✭❶☞❾❇⑨✯❿✍⑨✫➀✒➁❆➂ ⑦✂➃❇❼ ⑩❇❸✭➄✏➅➆❹☞❺✆❻➇❶❇❼✯⑩❆❽❇❶✔❾✔⑨ ❿✡⑨✫➀✫➈✒➉✏➂✒➊ ⑨ ❿✡⑨✫➀✫➁❆➂ ⑦✂➋✏⑩✭⑨✫➅➆❹✔❺✦❻➇❶❇❼✯⑩❆❽❇❶✔❾❇⑨✯❿✡⑨✫➀✫➈✫➁❆➂✒➊ ⑨✯❿✡⑨✫➀✫➈✒➉✏➂✒➊ ⑨✯❿✡⑨✯➀✍➉✏➂✒➊ ⑨✯❿✡⑨✫➀✫➁❆➂ ❛ ➌ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

What About Loops?

⑦✂➍✩⑩✆➎✽❼✯❶✭➏❇➐❇➑ ❼ ❶➒⑨✯❶❆❿✡⑨✝➄✡⑩❆❿✡❶✭❿■➓➔➅✭➑ ➄✏➅☎❷✟⑩✭→✏❶✟❶✭⑩❆➄✏➅☎➣ ❺✭❺❇↔ ❶✆↕➇❶✭➄✏➐❆⑨✯❶➒➙➒⑨✫➑ ❷➔❶✭❿✍➊✺➉➔⑨✫➑ ❷✟❶❆➊✝❷➔⑩❇❸➇➎✽⑨✫➑ ❷➔❶✭❿
  • for (int i = 0; i < n; i++) {...}
➛❃➜ ❶❆❿✡⑨✝➄✡⑩❆❿✡❶✭❿■❿✏➅✭❺❇➐✭➣ ➝➞➑ ❸✭➄✏➣ ➐❆➝❇❶✔❾ ➟✝➠❃➡☞➢➒➤❃➥ ➠✡➦✢➧ ➨ ➩✺➫✡➭✝➯✏➲ ➦✏➳✏➠✡➵✢➧ ➸✍➫❃➺ ➦✡➦✏➻❉➼ ➟✝➠❃➢➞➽✩➥ ➦❆➠✍➫✢➧ ➨ ➩✺➫✩➯✏➲ ➦✏➳✏➠✡➵✢➧ ➸✡➫■➺ ➦✡➦❆➻➾➼ ➟✝➠❃➚➞➽✩➥ ➭✒➫❉➪❉➫✏➲ ➯✏➺❉➧ ➨ ➩✺➫✡➭✝➯✏➲ ➦❆➳✡➠✡➵✢➧ ➸✡➫❃➺ ➦✏➦✏➻❉➼
slide-15
SLIDE 15

15

❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

More About Loops

⑦❘❼✯❶❆⑩❇➣❃⑨✫➑ ❷➔❶ ❿✡❺✂✁ ⑨✯➓■⑩✭❼✯❶ ❽✭❶❇❸✭❶✭❼✯⑩✭➣ ➣ ➎ ❼✫➐❇❸❆❿ ➑ ❸✭❿✏➑ ➝✭❶ ⑩✭❸ ➑ ❸✂✁✯➑ ❸✭➑ ⑨✯❶☎➣ ❺✭❺❇↔ ✄ ➠✡➫✡➫✡➵✢➧ ➦✆☎✒➯✏➲ ➫✞✝ ➳✏➺ ➺ ✟✚➵✏➫✞✝ ➨ ➠✡➫✡✠✚➸✡➯❉➧✂✟❉➦❆➳■➩✺➫✡➯✏➠☞☛✌✟ ➻✡➯❉➧ ➸✩➦❆➲ ➺ ➦✡➦❆➻✍☎✒➦❉➪❉➫✏➲ ➯✏✎✡➫ ❛ ✑ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

Path Coverage: Impossible Combinations

⑦✓✒☞❺✭⑨✝⑩✭➣ ➣❆➄✡❺❇❷✕✔✭➑ ❸✭⑩✭⑨✯➑ ❺✔❸❆❿❃⑩✭❼✯❶☎↔❆❺✭❿✡❿✏➑ ✔✭➣ ❶☞❾

if (x > 2) ... else ... if (x > 4) ... else ...

⑦❘➑ ❷➒↔❆❺✭❿✡❿✏➑ ✔✭➣ ❶➒⑨ ❺➞➅❆⑩✆❻➇❶✕✁✯➑ ❼✯❿✡⑨✝➣ ❺✭❺✔↔✖✁ ⑩❇➣ ❿✡❶❆➊☞❿✍❶✭➄✡❺❇❸✭➝ ⑨✫❼✫➐❆❶ ➛ ❸❆❺☎⑨ ❶✭❿✡⑨☞➄✏⑩❆❿✡❶✖✁✯❺❇❼☞⑨✫➅✭⑩❆⑨✝➄✡❺✔❷✖✔❇➑ ❸❆⑩✭⑨✫➑ ❺❇❸ ❛ ✗ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

Path Coverage: Combinatorial Explosion

⑦✙✘✍⑩❇❼✯❽✭❶☎❷➔❶✭⑨✫➅❆❺✭➝☎➓❃➑ ⑨✫➅➒❷✟⑩✭❸✆➎✚✔✭❼✯⑩✭❸✭➄✏➅✭❶❆❿❃⑩❇❸❆➝ ➣ ❺✭❺❇↔✭❿✭❾ ✄ ➩✺➯✏➠✞✟✡☎✒➦❆➩✍☛✏➨ ➠✍➯❉➧ ➨ ➦❆➠✍➭✜✛✭➺ ➦✳➧ ➭✝➦✞✝✭➧ ➫✡➭✤➧✢☎✒➯✡➭✫➫✡➭ ✄ ➵❆➨ ✝ ✝ ➨ ☎✍➳✡➺ ➧❇➧ ➦❃➩✺➯✏➠✡➯✣✎✏➫ ✄✥✤ ➯✞✟✦☎✒➯➾➧ ☎✍➸✩➭✫➫✏➻✏☎✍➨ ➯✏➺✡➨ ➠✏➻✡➳❉➧ ➭❄➧ ➸✡➯❉➧✭➧ ➲ ➨ ✎✧✎✡➫✏➲❇➯✡➠■➫✡➲ ➲ ➦❆➲ ⑦✙★✏➐❇➣ ➣✭↔✭⑩❆⑨✫➅✟➄✏❺✆❻➇❶❇❼✯⑩❆❽❇❶✟❺❇❸❇➣ ➎ ↔✭❼✯⑩❆➄✏⑨✯➑ ➄✏⑩✭➣✩✁ ❺❇❼✺➐❇❸✭➑ ⑨ ⑨✯❶❆❿✡⑨✫➑ ❸❆❽ ❛ ❛ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

Example

static double power(double base, int pow) { double answer = 1; while (pow > 0) { if (pow % 2 == 0) { // pow is even pow = pow / 2; base = base * base; } else { // pow is odd pow = pow - 1; answer = answer * base; } // end if } // end while return answer; } // end power

White box checklist: pow = 0, 1, 2, bigger (so while loop executed 0, 1, many times) even and odd powers to exercise both parts of if statement

❛ ✪ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

Data Flow Testing

⑦✬✫❄❸✭❺✭⑨✫➅❆❶❇❼✺→✏➑ ❸✭➝➒❺✂✁✝➓❃➅✭➑ ⑨✯❶✭✔❆❺✆↕✽⑨ ❶✭❿✡⑨✫➑ ❸❆❽ ⑦✸❶✆↕➇❶❇❼ ➄✏➑ ❿✡❶ ➥ ➨ ➠✩➦❆➲ ➵✡➫✏➲✭➦✮✝✂✠❄➫✡➯✧✯✒➫✡➭✿➧❇➧ ➦■➭✿➧ ➲ ➦✏➠✏✎✏➫✡➭✿➧❇➧ ➫✡➭✿➧ ➨ ➠✏✎✳➼ ✄ ➯✏➺ ➺✡➨ ➠✏➻✡➳❉➧ ➯✏➠✍➵❃➦✏➳❉➧ ➻✡➳❉➧❇➪❉➯✏➲ ➨ ➯✧☛✏➺ ➫✡➭ ✄ ☛✡➦❉➧ ➸✚➧ ➲ ➳❉➧ ➸✚➪❉➯✏➺ ➳✡➫✡➭✝➦✞✝✦➯✏➺ ➺✡➻✏➲ ➫✡➵✏➨ ☎✒➯❉➧ ➫✡➭ ✄ ➯✏➺ ➺✏➵✏➫✞✝ ➨ ➠✏➨ ➧ ➨ ➦❆➠✍➭■➦✞✝✔➪❉➯✏➲ ➨ ➯✧☛✏➺ ➫✡➭❃➥ ➫✏✎✗➪❉➯✏➲ ➨ ➯✧☛✏➺ ➫✡➭✩➦✏➠✖✰✣✱✳✲✟➦✞✝ ➯✡➭✫➭✍➨ ✎✏➠✏➩✩➫✡➠❉➧ ➭✤➼ ✄ ➯✏➺ ➺✡➳✡➭✫➫✡➭✝➦✮✝✭➪❉➯✏➲ ➨ ➯✧☛✏➺ ➫✡➭❄➧ ➸✍➯❉➧ ➯✏➲ ➫■➵✡➫✞✝ ➨ ➠✡➫✍➵ ✄ ➯✏➺ ➺✡➺ ➦✡➦❆➻✍➭ ✪ ✴ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✯❣❤✯✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣✫❜ s ❜ t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ ❜ s ❜

Possibilities For Automation

➟✶✵ ➵✏➫✡➯✏➺ ✷❋➧ ➦✡➦❆➺❱➧ ➦✶✎✏➫✏➠✡➫✡➲ ➯❉➧ ➫✸➭✫➫❉➧ ➦✞✝■➧ ➫✡➭✤➧✸☎✒➯✍➭✒➫✡➭➒➭✒➯➾➧✿➨ ➭✹✝ ✟✳➨ ➠✣✎ ☎✒➦❉➪❉➫✏➲ ➯✏✎✏➫■➲ ➫✏✺✏➳✏➨ ➲ ➫✏➩✺➫✏➠❉➧ ➭ ✻ ❬✤❩✜✼ ✽ ❨✍❯ ✾ ✾ ❯ ✿❁❀✜❂ ❃ ➟✶❄❆➯✏➠✧❅ ➧❆✎✡➫✏➠✡➫✏➲ ➯❉➧ ➫✩➫✞❇✳➻✍➫✏☎✤➧ ➫✡➵■➦❆➳➾➧ ➻✏➳❉➧✂✝ ➲ ➦✏➩❈☎✒➦✡➵✏➫✩❉ ➟✶✲✏➦✏➩✺➫❃➸✡➫✡➺ ➻✂✷✳➧ ➦✡➦❆➺ ➭❄➧ ➦■➸✡➫✏➺ ➻✚➪❉➫✏➲ ➨ ✝ ✟✦☎✒➦❉➪❉➫✏➲ ➯✏✎✏➫✩✷ ❊●❋■❍✣❏ ❑✜❍✆▲❁▼ ◆✜▼ ❖✣P■❖✣◗✜▼ ▲❘❋❙❖✏❚ ❖✆❖✜❯✣❖✜❑✜❱❲▼ ❖✜❳✖❨❲❩✆▼ ❍✣❏ ▲■▼ ❖✣▲ ▼■❑❲◆✜▲❁❖✣❬✳❭✧❚ ▼ ❍✏❏ ▲❙▲❁❖✜▼✂❭✜❪✧▼ ❖✜▲❁▼✂❑❁◆✣▲❁❖✣▲❁❫ ❊●❋■❍✣❏ ❑✜❍❘❨✣❚ ◆✏◗✜❑✜❍■◆✣❴ ▼ ❖✣❚ ◗✣◆❲▼ ❏ ❵✣❖✜▲✳❋❛❖✣❚ ❖❘❖❲❯✣❖✜❑✜❱✜▼ ❖✜❳✏❫ ❊●❋■❍✣❏ ❑✜❍❘❜✜◆✜▼ ❍✜▲❲❫ ❊●▼ ❖✣▲ ▼☞❍✜◆✣❚ ◗✣❖✜▲❲▲☞▲❁▼ ❏ ❴ ❴❙❱✜▲❲❖❲❪ ❱✏❴ ❬■❭✏❚❘◆✏❨✜❭✜❵✣❖✕❑❁◆✏◗✕❨✜❖✭❏ ◗✜▼ ❖✣❝✏❚ ◆❲▼ ❖✜❳ ❏ ◗✜▼ ❭✍❍✜◆✏❚ ◗✣❖✜▲❲▲
slide-16
SLIDE 16

16

✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✔✓ ✕ ✓ ✖ ✌ ✌ ✗ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✜ ✟ ✛ ✢ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✛ ✜ ✣ ✙ ✤ ✜ ✡ ✟ ✜ ✓ ✕ ✓

White Box Alone

✥✧✦✩★✫✪ ✬✞✭✯✮✱✰✳✲✵✴✫✶ ✰✸✷✱✭✯✪ ✹✺✷✫✰✫✬✻✴✽✼✫✰✫✰✫✾✯✿❀✴❂❁✵✬✞✰ ✼✫✭❃✷✫✭✫❄✞✴✱✬✞✭✽✬✞✭✱✹❅✬✻❆❅✴✱✹❅✭✫✹❈❇ ❉✵❊●❋■❍❑❏ ▲▼❋❅◆P❖ ◗P❘ ◗❅❙▼❚❅❯✻◗❈❱❀❏ ▲❅❯❲❯●❳ ❊❩❨❅◗❈❬ ❖ ❋❈❱❭❖❪❨❅❋❅❬ ❖ ❯ ❉✵❳ ❱■❖ ❬ ❳ ❱▼❯▼❳ ❙❲❋❈❏ ❏ ❍❑❏ ▲❅❋❅◆❅❯❫❖ ◗✺❳ ❱❅❙❲◗❈❊❩❨❈❏ ▲■❖ ▲❴❖ ▲❅❯❵❖ ❳ ❱▼❛ ❉✵❳ ❘❜❙❲◗❅◆❈▲❈❬❃◗■❝■▲❈❬ ❏ ◗❅◗✱❞❲▲❅◆❡❨❅◗❅❯✔❯▼❳ ❢❅❳ ❏ ❳ ❖ ❳ ▲❅❯❲❣✳❖ ▲❅❯❵❖❜❙❲❋❅❯❲▲▼❯✐❤❴❳ ❏ ❏❈❱❅◗■❖ ◆❈▲■❖ ▲▼❙❵❖❃❖ ❥❅▲❈❊
✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✔✓ ✕ ✓ ✖ ✌ ✌ ✗ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✜ ✟ ✛ ✢ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✛ ✜ ✣ ✙ ✤ ✜ ✡ ✟ ✜ ✓ ✕ ✓

Black Box Alone

✥❧❦❃✶ ✴✱❆❈♠♥✮✱✰✳✲♦✴❃✶ ✰❃✷✫✭q♣❡✴✳❁r✷✫✰✫✬s❆❅✰✉t❂✭❃❄s✬✔★✱✭q❆❅✰✫✾✫✭ ✴✫✾✫✭✫✈❃✇✫✴✱✬✞✭❃✶ ❁ ❉①❯❲◗❈❊●▲②❯▼❨❅▲▼❙▼❳ ❋❈❏③❙❲❋❅❯❲▲❅❯④❋❅❬ ▲⑤❱❅◗⑥❖♦◗✱❢❭❝⑥❳ ◗✱❚▼❯⑦❘ ❬ ◗❈❊ ❯▼❨▼▲❅❙▼❳ ❘ ❳ ❙❲❋■❖ ❳ ◗✱❱▼❯❲❣✱◆❈▲❈❨❅▲❅❱❅◆❀◗✱❱❩❋❈❏ ❛❅◗✱❬ ❳ ❖⑧❥❅❊❩❯ ✥⑩⑨✫✬✞✇✫✾✸✪ ✭✱✹✺✭❂✲✳✴✫♣✽✪ ✷✱✭✫✾❶✮✫✶ ✴✫❆❈♠❡✮✫✰✳✲①✬✞✭✫✹▼✬✻✹❈✇❃✪ ✬ ✭✫✹ ✾✫✭✳t✳✭✫✶ ✰❃❷✫✭✫❄✞✹✺❆❅✰❃✷✫✹❅✪ ✾❃✭❃❄ ✭✫✾✽✭✳✲❂✬✔❄✞✭✫♣❸✭✫✶ ❁✵✬✔★✱✰✸❄ ✰❃✇✫✼✸★ ❉①◗❈❱❈❏ ❍P▲❭❹■▲❈❬ ❙▼❳ ❯✔▲❅◆❡❺❭❻ ❼P❖ ◗❡❺❭❻⑧❽❩◗■❘✉❙❲◗❈◆❅▲✱❾
✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✔✓ ✕ ✓ ✖ ✌ ✌ ✗ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✜ ✟ ✛ ✢ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✛ ✜ ✣ ✙ ✤ ✜ ✡ ✟ ✜ ✓ ✕ ✓

Another Example: Background

❿⑩➀ ▲❈❬ ◗❈❱❈➁ ❯❫❘ ◗✱❬ ❊❀❚❈❏ ❋P❘ ◗✱❬✫❋❈❬ ▲▼❋❀◗■❘✫❖ ❬ ❳ ❋❈❱❅❛❈❏ ▲✫➂ ❉✵❏ ▲■❖✉❯❩➃ ❉①❋❈❬ ▲❅❋✺➃ ❿⑩➄ ❹■❋❈❊❩❨❈❏ ▲❀❨❈❬ ◗❈❛❈❬ ❋❈❊✩❖ ❋❈❞❲▲❅❯❫❖ ❥❅❬ ▲❅▲❩❯▼❳ ◆❈▲▼❯✻◗⑥❘✫❖ ❬ ❳ ❋❅❱❅❛✱❏ ▲❩❋❅❯ ❙❲◗❈❊❀❊●❋❈❱❅◆❅➅✞❏ ❳ ❱❅▲❩❋❈❬ ❛✱❚❅❊❩▲❅❱■❖ ❯●➆ ❯⑧❖ ❬ ❳ ❱❅❛P❘ ◗❈❬ ❊✐➇ ❿ ❙▼❥❅▲❅❙▼❞❲❯❫❖ ◗❀❊❩❋❈❞❲▲❩❯▼❚❅❬ ▲❀❳ ❖ ➁ ❯✻❋❈❱❩▲❅➈❈❚❈❳ ❏ ❋■❖ ▲❈❬ ❋❈❏❭❖ ❬ ❳ ❋❈❱▼❛✱❏ ▲ ➉✵➊ ➋❂➌✔➍⑧➎ ➏❅➐❲➑ ➊ ➌⑧➎ ➒✫➓▼➑ ➑ ➍▼➑▼➔→➓✔➒ ➒ ➣✔↔❲➓ ➉✵➊ ➋❅↕⑧➓✔➒✞➏▼➙✞➍✔➔→➐❲➛⑧➎ ➓✔➒✫➣❲➌✔➜✻➐❲➑ ➊ ➌⑧➎ ➒✫➣❲➑ ➓✔➣

2 c b a + + ) )( )( ( c s b s a s s − − −

✂ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆✞✝✟✞✠ ✆ ✡ ☛ ☎ ☞ ✟ ✡ ✌ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✏✔✓ ✕ ✓ ✖ ✌ ✌ ✗ ✘ ✙ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✜ ✟ ✛ ✢ ✄ ☎ ☎ ✆ ✟ ✄ ✛ ✜ ✣ ✙ ✤ ✜ ✡ ✟ ✜ ✓ ✕ ✓

Example Code with two Branches

public class Triangle { public static void main(String args []) { int sideA = Integer.parseInt(args[0]); int sideB = Integer.parseInt(args[1]); int sideC = Integer.parseInt(args[1]); if ((sideA == sideB) && (sideA == sideC)) { double s = 0.5 * (sideA + sideB + sideC); double area = Math.sqrt(s / (s - sideA) * (s - sideB) * (s - sideC)); System.out.println("area = " + area); } else System.out.println("not equilateral"); } // end main } // end class

➞ ➟ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Branch Coverage

➬➱➮❃✃✫❐✽❒ ❮✻❰▼Ï✞Ð✫Ï ❐❃Ñ❡❐❃✃✫Ï Ò→❰❅➮✽Ï✞Ó❀➮✽Ï✞❐✱❰❅Ï✻Ô❅Ð✱❰❅❐✫❰✺✃✫❐✫❐✱Õ❃❐✱Õ ➬➱❮ Ð❃Ö ❰▼❐✽Ô❅Ð✫❰▼❐→×✸Ø❃❒ Ô❈Ù❡❰❅❒ Õ❃❐✱❰✺Ï✔Ú✱Ð✫Ï✻Ð✫Û✞❐❃✃✫Ü Ï→❐✫Ý❃Þ✫Ð❃Ö ß✵à á❈â

Triangle 2 3 4

ß①ã❈á■ä å❈á■ä❵æ not equilateral ➬➱Ï✔Û✔Þ✱❐✽Ô❅Ð✱❰❅❐→×✸Ø❃❒ Ô❈Ù✺❐✫Ý❃Þ✫Ð❃Ö✱❰❅❒ Õ❃❐✱❰ ß✵à á❈â

Triangle 2 2 2

ß①ã❈á■ä å❈á■ä❵æ area = 1.7320508075688772 ➬➱➮❃Þ✫Ï✔Ø✫Þ✫Ï✻❒ ❰✺Ô❅➮✸Û✞Û✞❐✫Ô❅Ï✞Ò→Ö ➮✫➮✸Ù❅❰❡Ö ❒ Ù❅❐✽Ð❃Ö Ö✫❒ ❰❀Ó❀❐❃Ö Ö ➞ ç ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Two Errors not Caught by Test Cases

public class Triangle { public static void main(String args []) { int sideA = Integer.parseInt(args[0]); int sideB = Integer.parseInt(args[1]); int sideC = Integer.parseInt(args[1]); if ((sideA == sideB) && (sideA == sideC)) { double s = 0.5 * (sideA + sideB + sideC); double area = Math.sqrt(s / (s - sideA) * (s - sideB) * (s - sideC)); System.out.println("area = " + area); } else System.out.println("not equilateral"); } // end main } // end class should be 2 should be *

slide-17
SLIDE 17

17

➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Combining the Two Approaches

  • pick a set of test cases from the specification

(black box)

  • then look at code (white box) and see if test cases

cover the code adequately

  • it not, add more to complete coverage
  • power example:

– black box alone didn't tell us it was important to make sure we tested both odd and even powers – suggests additional test cases: pow = 16, pow = 15

➞ ✁ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Testing at Different Levels

➬✄✂✻✃❃❒ Ï✻Ï ❐✫❰❅Ï✞❒ ✃✆☎→× ß✞✝✱á✠✟☛✡☛☞✌✡ ✟✌✍✠✎✏☞▼ã✒✑✠✓ ✍✠✡ ✔✌✟❈à✕☞❅ã✖✑✗✟❈å❈å❅à ã☛✟✠✍✠✘ ß✙✡ ✔✖✚✖✔☛✡▼ã✖✛✢✜✠✣✤✟☛✡ ✡ ✔✌✜⑧ä✦✥❈à ✟❈â❈á☛✡ ✟❈à ✧ ä ★✳æ✪✩✫✟❈â■ä✫ä ã✬✡ ã❅ã✭✎✮✟■ä✢✍❲ã☛✝✌✔ ➬✰✯✫✱✫➮✳✲❂❐✯Þ✫✃❃❒ Ï✻Ï✞❐✱❰❅Ï✔❒ ✃✭☎♥Ö ❐✪✲✳❐❃Ö ×✕☎❃Û✞Ð✳✴✙✱✫➮✳✵ ß✞✟✖✩✫✟❈à ✔❈â✌✔✌✜✶✜✻ã✖✛✢✜❵ä à á✌✍❵ä á❅à ✔✌✷✕☞❅á■ä❪â▼ã⑥ä✢✟☛✡ ✡✠✝☛✔■ä ✟☛✧ ✡ ✜✶✷ ➬✄✸✳✴❂❰❅Ï✞❐✫Ñ Ï✞❐✱❰❅Ï✔❒ ✃✭☎✻×✸Ø❃Û✞❒ Ñ❸Ð✫Û✔❒ Ö ✴✹✱✫Ö Ð✫Ô❈Ù✺✱✱➮✳✵ ➞ ➞ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Stages

➬✼✻❃❒ ☎✽✻✫Ð❃✃✭☎✙✾❪❐✫❰▼Ï✔❒ ✃✆☎→×✿☎✫➮✯Û✔❒ ☎✸Ú✱Ï✻Ï✞➮❀✸✳✴❂❰❅Ï✞❐✫Ñ❁✾❪❐✫❰❅Ï✞❒ ✃✆☎ ß✞✥☛✔❈â✠✔❈à ✟☛✡ ✡ ★❂✡ ✔✌✟✌✜⑧ä✦✔✖✛ ✛ ✔✌✍❵ä ✧ ✚✖✔ ß❃✚✖✔❈à ★✗✝✭✧ ✛ ✛ ✧ ✍▼á☛✡ ä✫ä ã❂✛ ✧ â✌✝✬☞❈á✌✥✌✜ ß✞✟✖✚■ã☛✧ ✝Pä ✘☛✧ ✜✌❄ ➬✼✻✫❐✱Ï✞Ï✞❐✫Û✻Ó❀Ð✳✴❜× ß❡ä ✔✌✜⑧ä✦✟☛✡ ✡✌✣●ã☛✝❈á☛✡ ✔✌✜✤✧ â✌✝☛✧ ✚✒✧ ✝✱á✌✟✌✡ ✡ ★❆❅ á❈â☛✧ ä✫ä ✔✌✜❵ä ✧ â✌✥✖❇ ß✵å❈á❭ä❃ä ã✌✥☛✔■ä ✘✌✔❈à✆✥✱à ✟✌✝✱á✌✟☛✡ ✡ ★❂❈✵ä ✔✠✜❵ä✦✡ ✟❈à ✥☛✔❈à❃å☛✧ ✔✌✍❉✔✌✜ ❊✮❋
  • ❍❏■
❑✶▲✠▼ ◆❏■
  • ❖✠❍❏P
◗❙❘❉❚✶◗ ❯❏◗ ■ ❑✶❱✞■ ❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲✠❲
ß❃✛ ✧ â✌✟☛✡ ✡ ★❩ä ✔✠✜❵ä✆✩✗✘❅ã☛✡ ✔✏✜❳★✖✜⑧ä ✔☛✣ ❨ ❩ ❩ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Integration Testing

➬❬✾❫❐✱❰❅Ï✞❰❡Þ✫❰❅❐✱❰✺✱✫❐✱Ï✞Ó❀❐✫❐✫✃❶Ñ❡➮❃Õ❃Þ❃Ö ❐✱❰✺❭●❰❅➮❃Þ✫Û✞Ô❅❐✯➮✫❮✮❪✆❫✿❴ ➮✫❮→Ð❃Ö Ö✱❐✫Û✔Û✞➮❃Û✞❰✺❒ ✃✽Ô❅➮✫Õ❃❐✕❵ ➬✄❛✔✃✫Ô❈Û✞❐✫Ñ❸❐✫✃✫Ï✞Ð✫Ö ×✢✾❪➮❃Ø✽❜→➮✫Ó✺✃✙✲❂❰✭❵❝✻✱➮❃Ï Ï✞➮❃Ñ❞✂✻Ø ß✞✜❵ä ✟❅à ä✕✩❡✧ ä ✘❴ä ✔✌✜❵ä ✔✌✝✬✣●ã✌✝✱á☛✡ ✔✌✜✤✧ â✏✔☛✧ ä ✘✠✔❈à✕✍❉✟✠✜❉✔ ß✵å☛✡ ✟❅â❈â☛✧ â✌✥❀ã✖✛✦✧ â✌✍▼à ✔☛✣✤✔❈â■ä ✜✮✜⑧ä ✟❈à ä ✜✮✔✌✟❈à ✡ ★ ❊✮◗❙❢✶❖✠❘❉❣ ❤❝▼ ❑❳✐❏❖✠❣ ✐❏❑✿◆❉▼ ❖❉❘❉❍✶❤✮❘✶◗ ❑✶◗✕❢❉● ❑❉▼ ◆✠▼ ❥❙❢❏❯ ß❡ä ã❈å✏✝❈ã✖✩❴â❀à ✔✌❦✱á✌✧ à ✔✌✜✮✜⑧ä á☛☞✌✜ ß✙☞❅ã■ä ä ã☛✣❧á❈å❀à ✔✌❦❈á☛✧ à ✔✌✜✮✝❈à ✧ ✚✖✔❈à ✜ ß✙❧ ✜❉✟❈â✌✝✖✩✗✧ ✍✠✘✌❧♠✚✖✟❈à ✧ ✟❈â■ä ✜✮✔✖✑✖✧ ✜❵ä ❨ ❩ ❨ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

System Testing

♥✄♦ á❈â✠✍❵ä ✧ ã✱â✠✟☛✡✖♣✪✔✌✜❵ä ✧ â✠✥✬❅ ✝❈ã✌✔✌✜✤✧ ä✆✩✐ã❈à ✎✠q❏❇ ♥✰r ✡ ✜✔ã❃æ s✬t
  • ❱❝●
❍✶▲❉✉✌✈❙❖❉◆✶❤❉✉✌✇✶❑❉▼ ① ❖✠▼ ❱✿◆❉❍✶❥❙❑✿◆❉❍✶❤❝②❳■ ▼ ❑❉◗ ◗ t ❑❉◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
s✙③ ◗❙◆❉❚❉● ❣
❯ t ❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
s ②❉❑✶❥✶❘❉▼
❯ t ❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
s ②❳■ ❖✠▼ ◆✶▲❉❑✦■ ❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
s ✇❉▼ ❖❉❥ ❑✶❤✠❘❉▼ ❑✿◆✠❍✶❤✿❤❉❖❉❥❙❘✶❱✿❑✠❍❏■✌■ ❑❉◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
④✮⑤✶⑥ ⑦✶⑥❉⑧❙⑨ ⑤✶⑩✠❶✭❷✶❸✶⑧ ❷✶❹ ⑨ s✙❺ ❑✶❥ ❖❳✐❳❑❉▼ ❯✕■ ❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
s✙❻ ◆❉▼ ❤❳❼✢◆❉▼ ❑✿❥❙❖❉❍❏①
  • ▲✠❘❉▼
◆❏■
  • ❖❉❍✦■
❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
ß✞✔■ä ✍✌❽ ❨ ❩ ➻ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Regression Testing

➬➱Ð✫❮ Ï ❐❃Û✻❰♠✴✳❰❅Ï✞❐✫Ñ ❒ ❰✺Ñ❸➮✫Õ✸❒ ❮✞❒ ❐✱Õ✻× ß✙☞❈á✠✥❆✛ ✧ ✑✖✷✆✍❉✘✌✟❈â✌✥☛✔❩ã❈à✕✔♠✑▼ä ✔❈â✌✜✠✧ ã✱â ➬➱❰❈Ú✱➮✸Þ✫Ö Õ❶Û✞Þ❃✃✽Ð✫Ö Ö✱Ï✞❐✫❰▼Ï✞❰✺➮✳✲❂❐❃Û✻Ð✭☎❃Ð✫❒ ✃ ➬✄✱✫Þ✆☎✯❮✞❒ ✵✵❒ ✃✽➮❃✃✫❐✽Ñ❸➮✫Õ❃Þ❃Ö ❐✽Ô❅Ð✫✃✽❰❈Ú✱➮✫Ó③Þ❃Ø❀✱✫Þ✆☎✫❰❡❒ ✃ Ð❃✃✱➮✫Ï✔Ú✫❐✫Û✫❾ Ñ❸➮✫Õ❃Þ❃Ö ❐✯❒ ✃✱Ï✞❐❃Û Ð✫Ô❅Ï✔❒ ➮❃✃✫❰❀Ô❈Ú✫Ð❃✃✭☎❃❐ ➬➱Ð❃Þ✱Ï✞➮❃Ñ❸Ð✱Ï✔❒ ➮❃✃✯❒ ❰✺Ð✺☎✸Û ❐✫Ð✱Ï●Ú✫❐✫Ö Ø✯Ú✱❐❃Û✞❐
slide-18
SLIDE 18

18

❨ ❩ ➺ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Regression Testing Issues (1)

♥✰r ✛ ä ✔❈à✏✍✠✘✌✟❈â✠✥☛✔✌✜①ä ã✽✜❏★✒✜⑧ä ✔☛✣✤✷ ✣✤✟✖★✧â✌✔✌✔✠✝✧ä ã➱á❈å✠✝☛✟■ä ✔ ä ✔✠✜❵ä å☛✡ ✟❅â✌✷✳ä ✔✌✜⑧ä✦✍❉✟✌✜✶✔✌✜✠❽ s ✁✄✂
  • ❍✶▲✦■
❑✶◗ ■✪❥ ◆✶◗❙❑✶◗✆❱✿◆❏❯✫❚❙❑❝▼ ❑✠❘✶◗ ◆❉❚❉❣ ❑ ✉✌▼ ❑❳■ ❑✶◗ ■ ◆❉❚❉❣ ❑ ✉✠❖✠▼✌❖✠❚❙◗❙❖❉❣ ❑❏■ ❑ s✬t ❢✶❑❉▼ ❑
  • ◗❃◆✞■
▼ ◆✶❤❉❑✆☎ ❖❳① ①❂❚✶❑❏■ ❼✢❑✶❑❉❍✞✝✶❖❉◗ ◗❙● ❚❉❣ ❑ ▼ ❑✶❤✠❘❉❍✶❤✶◆✠❍❏■✤■ ❑✶◗ ■
  • ❍✶▲
❥❙❖✶◗ ■ ◗✤◆❉❍✶❤❆■ ❢✶❑ ❥ ❖❉◗ ■ ◗✤❖❳① ❤❉❑✶❥❙● ❤✠● ❍✶▲❆❼✢❢❉● ❥✶❢❂■ ❑✶◗ ■✫▼ ❑❉◗❙❘❉❣ ■ ◗✤❥❙◆❉❍✬❚✶❑ ▼ ❑❉❘✶◗ ❑❉❤✿◆✠❍✶❤✦❼✦❢❉● ❥❙❢✦■ ❑✶◗ ■✒❥❙◆✶◗ ❑✶◗✆❥❙◆❉❍❝❚✶❑❝▼ ❑❉▼ ❘❉❍✠✟ s ②❉❖❉❱✿❑✦■ ❑✶◗ ■✒❥❙◆✶◗ ❑✶◗✆❱✿◆❏❯✫❍✶❑✶❑✶❤ ■ ❖✮❚✶❑✿❤✠▼ ❖✠✝✠✝✶❑✶❤ s ❍✶❑❏❼✬■ ❑✶◗ ■✒❥❙◆✶◗ ❑✶◗✆❱✿◆❏❯✫❚✶❑❝❍✶❑✶❑✶❤❉❑✶❤ ♥☛✡ ä ★⑥å✌✔✌✜✻ã✖✛❜à ✔✌✥❈à ✔✌✜✶✜✠✧ ã❈â❴ä ✔✌✜❵ä ✧ â✌✥ s ✝❉▼ ❖❉▲❉▼ ❑✶◗ ◗❙● ✐❏❑ ❋ ◗☞✝✶❑✶❥✶● ①
◆❏■
  • ❖❉❍❝❢✶◆✶◗✆❥✶❢✶◆❉❍✶▲❉❑✶❤✠❲
s ❥❙❖❉▼ ▼ ❑✶❥ ■
  • ✐❏❑
❋ ◗☞✝✶❑✶❥✶● ①
  • ❥❙◆❏■
  • ❖✠❍❝●
◗✕❘❉❍✶❥❙❢✶◆❉❍✶▲❉❑✶❤✠❲ ✟ ❨ ❩ ✌ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Regression Testing Issues (2)

♥ ✍❲ã❈à à ✔✌✍❵ä ✧ ✚✖✔ ✣❩ã✌✝✭✧ ✛ ✧ ✍❉✟■ä ✧ ã❈â✌✜ ✣✤✟✖★ à ✔✌❦✱á☛✧ à ✔qå❈à ã☛✥❈à ✔✌✜❉✜❉✧ ✚✖✔ à ✔✌✥❈à ✔✌✜❉✜❉✧ ã❈âPä ✔✌✜⑧ä ✧ â✌✥✬✧ ✛✫ä ✘✌✔❀ã❈à ✧ ✥✭✧ â✠✟☛✡✌✜❲å✌✔✌✍✠✧ ✛ ✧ ✍❉✟■ä ✧ ã❈â✌✜❡✩✫✔❈à ✔ ✧ â ✔❈à à ã❈à ♥✎✍ ✔❈à ✜❉✧ ã✱â✏✍❲ã❈â■ä à ã☛✡✌✧ ✜✮✟✬✣✤✟✑✏ ã✱à✕✧ ✜✶✜▼á✌✔ s ❍✶❑✶❑✶❤❉❑✶❤ ❖✠❍ ❑❏✐❳❑❉▼ ❯✶■ ❢❉● ❍✶▲✓✒ ❥ ❖❉❤❉❑✶✉ ■ ❑✶◗ ■ ◗❙❘❉● ■ ❑❉◗ ✉ ❤❉◆❏■ ◆✶✉ ❤❉❖✶❥✶❘✶❱✿❑❉❍❏■ ◆❏■
  • ❖✠❍✶✉✿❣
❑❳✐❏❑❉❣☛❖❳①✦❖✔✝✶❑❉▼ ◆❏■
  • ❍✶▲
◗ ❯❳◗ ■ ❑✶❱✿✉✕❥ ❖❉❱✕✝❉● ❣ ❑❉▼ ✉✕❣
  • ❍✠✖❙❑❉▼
✉ ✝✶❖✶◗❙◗❙● ❚✶❣ ❯✫❢✶◆❉▼ ❤❳❼✳◆✠▼ ❑❝● ①✒❥❙❢✶◆❉❍✶▲❉❑✶◗✆◆✠▼ ❑❝❚✶❑❉● ❍✶▲✿❱✿◆✶❤❉❑✶✉✗✟ ✟ ✟ ❨ ❩ ➟ ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Acceptance Testing

➬❬✾❫❐✱❰❅Ï✔❒ ✃✭☎ ❰❅Ø✫❐✱Ô❈❒ ❮✔❒ ❐✱Õ ❐✫Ð❃Û✞Ö ✴ Ð✱❰ Ô❈Û✔❒ Ï ❐❃Û✔❒ Ð ❮ ➮❃Û Ð✫Ô❅Ô❅❐✫Ø✫Ï✔❒ ✃✭☎❶Ø✫Û✞➮✫Õ✸Þ✱Ô❈Ï ➬✙✘✸Ð❃✃✄✱✱❐⑩Õ✫Ð❃✃✭☎❃❐✫Û✞➮❃Þ✫❰✛✚✤❛✞❮❀Ï✞❐✱❰❅Ï✞❰✽Ð❃Û ❐❧Ø✫Û✞❐✆❭✞❰❈Ø✱❐✫Ô❈❒ ❮✞❒ ❐✫Õ✫Ò ❰❅➮✫❮ Ï✞Ó❀Ð✫Û✞❐✯Ñ❡Ð✳✴✵Ø✫Ð✱❰❅❰✺Ï✞❐✱❰❅Ï✞❰✬✱❃Þ✫Ï●✃✱➮✫Ï✻Õ❃➮✯Ñ✽Þ✱Ô❈Ú✽❐❃Ö ❰▼❐ ✜ ✯❪Õ✫Ð✽Ô❅➮❃Ñ❸Ø❃❒ Ö ❐❃Û ❰✓✢ ➬✙✣●➮✫➮✫ÕqÐ✫Ô❅Ô❅❐❃Ø✱Ï✞Ð❃✃✱Ô❅❐qÏ✞❐✱❰❅Ï✔❒ ✃✭☎ Õ✫➮❃❐✱❰ ✃✱➮❃Ï ❒ ✃✳✲✳➮❃Ö ✲❂❐ Õ✫❐✫Ï✞Ð✫❒ Ö ❐✫Õ Ø✫Û✔❒ ➮❃Û✯❰❈Ø✱❐✫Ô❈❒ ❮✞❒ Ô❈Ð✱Ï✔❒ ➮❃✃③➮✫❮✯Ï✔Ú✱❐③Ï✞❐✫❰▼Ï✞❰❅Ò❀✱❃Þ✱Ï Õ✫❐❃Ø✱❐❃✃✫Õ✫❰ ➮❃✃qØ❃Û ❐✫Ô❈❒ ❰❅❐✱Ò❧Ô❅➮❃Ñ✽Ø✫Ö ❐✫Ï✞❐♥Ð✫✃✫ÕqÔ❅➮❃Û✔Û✞❐✱Ô❅Ï ❰✖✴❂❰❅Ï✞❐✫Ñ ❰❈Ø✱❐✫Ô❈❒ ❮✞❒ Ô❅Ð✫Ï✞❒ ➮✸✃✱❰✭❵ ❨ ❩ ç ➠ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Resources That Limit Testing

➬✼✻❃Þ✱Õ✕☎✫❐✫Ï ➬✄✸✫Ô❈Ú✱❐✫Õ❃Þ❃Ö ❐ ➬✥✤→Ð✫Û✞Õ✫Ó✺Ð✫Û✞❐ ➬❬✾❫❐✱❰❅Ï✞❐✫Û✞❰ ➬✼❜→❐✆✱❃Þ✆☎✆☎✫❐❃Û✞❰ ➬✄✂→❰❅❐✫Û✞❰ ✜ ❮ ➮✸Û✻Þ✫❰❅Ð✆✱❃❒ Ö ❒ Ï ✴①Ï✞❐✱❰❅Ï✔❒ ✃✆☎✛✢ ❨ ❩
➡ ➢ ➢ ➤✞➥➦✞➧ ➤ ➨ ➩ ➢ ➫ ➦ ➨ ➭ ➯ ➲ ➳ ➵ ➸ ➳✔➺ ➻ ➺ ➼ ➭ ➭ ➽ ➾ ➚ ➚ ➪ ➪ ➪ ➶ ➹ ➦ ➶ ➘ ➡ ➢ ➢ ➤ ➦ ➡ ➶ ➹ ➴ ➚ ➷ ➹ ➨ ➦ ➹ ➺ ➻ ➺

Object-Oriented Testing

♥☛✦ á✌✍✠✘✗✩✗✧ ✜✶✝❈ã☛✣✄✟☛☞▼ã✱á■ä✫ä ✔✌✜⑧ä❏✧ â✌✥ ✟✌✍❉✍▼á☛✣❩á☛✡ ✟■ä ✔✌✝✬☞✠✔✖✛ ã❈à ✔ ✧✓★✗✧✗✩✓✪ ✫✗✬ ✭ ✮ ✯✰★✲✱✴✳✵✳✷✶ ✸☛✹ ★✻✺✼✭ ✽✾✮ ✿✔❀✰✮ ❀✓✽✄✮ ✭ ❁✓❂✰✮ ✫✓✽✠❃❅❄❆✭ ✱ ✱ ❀✓✬ ❀✗❁✲✮✛✱ ★✗✬❇★✗❈✑❉ ❀✓❊✑✮ ❋ ★✗✬ ✭ ❀✗❁✲✮ ❀✓❄ ❊✠★✓❄✗❀✗● ✸ ✽✠★✗✩✗✬ ❊✠❀✓✽✗❍ ■❑❏✗▲ ▼ ◆✠❖ P ◗ ❏✗❘ ❙ ◆✆❚✔P ◆✔❯✷❱☞◆☞❲✆P ❙ ❚✄❳✲❨✓❩❆❬✔P ❭✵❪✠❚✔❯❇❫✓◆✆❪✆❴ ❙ P ❬ ❵❅❛✆❜✆❝☞❞✆❡ ❢✓❣✆❤ ✐☞❥☞❞✆❡ ❦✠❧✗❝ ♠ ❞☞♥ ❢✔♦✗♣☞q☞♣☞r ❤ ✐☞❞✵s t✆t☞✉
  • http://www.rbsc.com/pages/myths.html
  • lectures by
✈✗✇ ①✄②✻③✠✇ ✇ ④⑥⑤✔⑦✆③✔⑧☞⑨✔✇ ⑩ ❶ ❛✆❜☞❷☞♣☞❸✆♦✗❤ ❸ ❤ ❢ ♣✆❡ ❷✛❹✆❜✠❸ ❸ ❞☞q☞❞✛❜✆❺✠❹✆♣✆✐☞♣☞❥☞♣ ❶❼❻ ❸ ❞☞♥ ❢ ❡ ❤ ♥ ♣✆❸☞♣✆✐ ❥❇❹✆❜✠❽✛❾☞❿☞❢ ❞✆❡ ❻ ✐☞q✆❤ ✐☞❞☞❞✆❡ ❤ ✐☞q ➀ ➁ ➂ ➃ ➄ ➅ ➅ ➆☞➇➈☞➉ ➆ ➊ ➋ ➅ ➌ ➈ ➊ ➍ ➎ ➏ ➐ ➑ ➒ ➐✆➓ ➔ ➓ → ➍ ➍ ➣ ↔ ↕ ↕ ➙ ➙ ➙ ➛ ➜ ➈ ➛ ➝ ➄ ➅ ➅ ➆ ➈ ➄ ➛ ➜ ➞ ↕ ➟ ➜ ➊ ➈ ➜ ➓ ➔ ➓

Myth #1

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩➭➫✵➫✼➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺✞➵ ➳➼➻✗➸✗➸✓➲✓➽✠➲✔➳✠➳✆➾✗➚ ➪➹➶❇➫✵➫✥➘✓➚ ➴✗➷➬➴✲➯ ➲✓➳➮➵ ➯ ➲✗➚ ➾✲➯ ➵ ➴❆➸ ➾✗➸✓➱✙➚ ➲✗➻✓➳✠➲✔✃➬➳✆➴❒❐✾➲❰❮✓➾✲Ï✲➲Ð➾❰➷➬➴✗➚ ➲Ð➲✲Ñ Ñ ➲✓➽✑➯ ➵ Ï✲➲❑❐Ò➾✲➪✞➯ ➴ ➱✗➲✲Ï✲➲✓Ó ➴❆➘➤➯ ➚ ➻✓➳✄➯ ❐Ò➴✗➚ ➯ ❮✲➪➤➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳✠➲✓➳✔➶ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩❼Ù❇➻✗➷➬➾✓➸➼➲✓➚ ➚ ➴❆➚❇➵ ➳✷➾✔➳❅Ó ➵ Ú✠➲✗Ó ➪✰➾✔➳✷➲✲Ï✲➲✗➚☞➶✻ÛÜ➲➼❮✓➾✲Ï✲➲➤➯ ➴➼➽✔❮✓➲✓➽✔Ú ➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳✾Ñ ➻✗➸✔➽✑➯ ➵ ➴❆➸✓➾✓Ó ➵ ➯ ➪✰➾✗➸✔➱Ý➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✗➚ ➾✓➽✑➯ ➵ ➴✗➸✓➳❅Þ✓➲ß➯ ❐Ò➲✓➲✗➸ ➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳✠➲✓➳
slide-19
SLIDE 19

19

✂ ✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #2

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩Ý➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺ ➵ ➳☛➾ ➳✑➯ ➚ ➻✓➽✑➯ ➻✓➚ ➲✓➱ ❐Ò➾✲➯ ➲✗➚ Ñ ➾✗Ó Ó➮➵ ➱✗➲✔➾ ➾✗➸✔➱ ➵ ➳✠➸✧✦ ➯ ➽✠➴✗➸✓➳✔➵ ➳✄➯ ➲✗➸✲➯✛❐➤➵ ➯ ❮➼➵ ➸✓➽✔➚ ➲✗➷➬➲✗➸ß➯ ➾✗Ó✓➫✵➫Ð➱✓➲✲Ï✲➲✗Ó ➴✗➘✗➷❅➲✗➸✲➯ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩Ý➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➳☛➽✠➾✗➸ Þ✔➲ ➱✗➲✓➳✠➵ ➺❆➸✓➲✓➱ ➾✗➸✓➱ ➲✩★✲➲✗➚ ➽✔➵ ➳✠➲✓➱ ➾✲➯❒➷➬➾✗➸ß➪ ➘✓➴✗➵ ➸✲➯ ➳❅➵ ➸➤➯ ❮✓➲➼➘✗➚ ➴✓➽✠➲✓➳✆➳ ➩❼➘✓➾✗➚ ➾✓➱❆➵ ➺✗➷✥➴✲Ñ✫✪✑➱✗➲✓➳✠➵ ➺❆➸➼➾➮Ó ➵ ➯ ➯ Ó ➲✔✃❇➽✠➴✓➱✗➲➼➾➮Ó ➵ ➯ ➯ Ó ➲✭✬✕Þ✓➲✔➽✠➴❆➷❅➲✓➳ ✪✑➱✗➲✓➳✠➵ ➺❆➸➬➾➼Ó ➵ ➯ ➯ Ó ➲✓✃❆➽✠➴✗➱✓➲➼➾➼Ó ➵ ➯ ➯ Ó ➲✓✃➹➯ ➲✓➳✑➯✴➾➼Ó ➵ ➯ ➯ Ó ➲✭✬ ➩✯✮✩★✔➯ ➚ ➲✗➷❅➲✱✰✗➚ ➴✓➺❆➚ ➾✗➷➬➷➬➵ ➸✓➺✳✲ ✴✵✰✩✶Ò➘✗➚ ➴❆➷❅➴✲➯ ➲✓➳❅➲✓➾✗➚ Ó ➪➼➯ ➲✔➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✓➺ ✲☞➷❅➴✗➚ ➲➼Ó ➾✲➯ ➲✗➚ ✶
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #3

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩Ý➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺➮➵ ➳✾➯ ➴✗➴➬➲✩★✻➘✓➲✗➸✔➳✔➵ Ï✲➲ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩❼➘✓➾✲➪✰➷❅➲➮➸✔➴✻❐✎➴✗➚❇➘✓➾✲➪✰➷➬➲✸✷✺✹✫✻✛Ù✞➷❅➴✗➚ ➲➮Ó ➾ß➯ ➲✗➚ ➩ÝÑ ➾✓➵ Ó ➻✗➚ ➲✓➳✞➵ ➸Ð➴✗➘✓➲✗➚ ➾ß➯ ➵ ➴❆➸✔➾✗Ó✕➳✄➪✲➳✑➯ ➲✗➷❅➳ ➽✠➾✗➸Ð➽✠➾✗➻✓➳✆➲Ð➳✠➲✲Ï✲➲✗➚ ➲ ➳✠➲✔➽✠➴❆➸✓➱✓➾✗➚ ➪✰➘✗➚ ➴✗Þ✗Ó ➲✗➷❅➳ ➩❼➘✗➚ ➴❆➘✔➲✗➚✾➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺✞➵ ➳✰Ï✲➲✗➚ ➪➭➽✔❮✓➲✓➾✗➘ Þß➪➭➽✠➴✗➷➬➘✓➾✗➚ ➵ ➳✆➴✗➸✓✃✕➲✲Ï✲➲✗➸ ❐Ò❮✓➲✗➸➬➱✗➴✗➸✓➲➼➷➬➾✗➸✓➻✓➾✗Ó Ó ➪ ➩➭➲✲Ñ Ñ ➵ ➽✔➵ ➲✗➸✲➯✛➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✔➺➮➴✲Ñ⑥Ó ➾✗➚ ➺✓➲➼➴✗➚❇➽✠➴✗➷➬➘✗Ó ➲✩★➤➳✑➪✲➳✄➯ ➲✗➷❅➳➬➸✓➲✔➲✓➱✗➳ ➳✠➴✗➷❅➲➬➾✗➻✲➯ ➴❆➷❅➾✲➯ ➲✓➱➼➳✠➻✗➘✗➘✔➴❆➚ ➯
☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #4

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩Ý➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺➮➵ ➳✾➯ ❮✓➲➬➳✠➾✗➷❅➲➬➾✓➳✷➽✠➴✗➸✲Ï✲➲✗➸✲➯ ➵ ➴✗➸✓➾✗Ó✔➳✠➴✲Ñ ➯ ❐✾➾✗➚ ➲ ➩➭➾✗Ó Óß➪✲➴❆➻➼➸✓➲✔➲✓➱➮➵ ➳❅Þ✗Ó ➾✓➽✔Ú✽✼☞Þ✔➴✾★➤➳✑➪✲➳✄➯ ➲✗➷✼➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺ ✿✺❀✽❁❃❂ ❄ ❅✕❁✸❁❇❆✟❈ ❁❊❉ ❅✕❋✽●
  • ❍❏■✽❑✕▲
❁❊❉ ▼❃❋✽❑✽● ❁✳❑✕❁✽◆✕❋❃▼❇❄ ■❊❖✽❉P❈ ■✳❑✕❁✳◗✽❉ ■✕❀❊❖✕❘✟❁✕❀ ❂ ❉ ■✽❙❚❋❱❯❊❄ ▼❇❁✽❅❲❄ ❅✽◗✽❖❃❈ ✿✺❀✽■✽❅✕❳ ❈❨❅✕❁✕❁✽❀❲❄ ❅❃❂ ■❊❉ ❙❱❋❃❈ ❄ ■❊❅❱❋✽❑✕■❊❖❃❈❨❄ ❙❲◗✽● ❁✽❙❱❁✽❅❃❈ ❋❃❈ ❄ ■✽❅ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩➭➫✵➫Ð➽✠➴✓➱✗➲➬➳✑➯ ➚ ➻✓➽✑➯ ➻✓➚ ➲➮➷❅➾✲➯ ➯ ➲✗➚ ➳ ➩❼➘✓➴✗Ó ➪✻➷❅➴❆➚ ➘✗❮✗➵ ➳✠➷➬✃❅➵ ➸✗❮✓➲✗➚ ➵ ➯ ➾✓➸✓➽✠➲✓✃❅➲✗➸✔➽✠➾✗➘✓➳✔➻✓Ó ➾✲➯ ➵ ➴✗➸❰➘✓➚ ➲✓➳✠➲✗➸ß➯ ➴✗➘✗➘✓➴✗➚ ➯ ➻✗➸✓➵ ➯ ➵ ➲✓➳✾Ñ ➴✗➚✛➲✗➚ ➚ ➴✗➚❱✲ ➷❅➴❆➚ ➲➼Ó ➾✲➯ ➲✗➚ ✶
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #5

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩➭➽✠➴✗➸✲Ï✲➲✗➸✲➯ ➵ ➴✗➸✓➾✗Óß➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✔➺➮➵ ➳❅➻✓➳✠➲✗Ó ➲✓➳✠➳✾Ñ ➴❆➚✛➴✗Þ❇❩ ➲✓➽✑➯ ➳ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩Ý➯ ❮✓➲✗➚ ➲➼➵ ➳✷➾➼Ó ➾✗➚ ➺✓➲➮Þ✔➴✗➱✲➪✰➴✲Ñ⑥Ú✔➸✓➴✲❐➤Ó ➲✓➱✓➺✗➲➬➾✗Þ✓➴✗➻✲➯✛➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✓➺ ➩❼Þ✓➾✓➳✠➵ ➽❒➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✔➺ ➯ ➲✓➽✔❮✗➸✗➵ ❬✗➻✓➲✓➳❰➽✠➴✗➸✲➯ ➵ ➸✗➻✓➲✼➯ ➴✥➾✗➘✓➘✗Ó ➪✙❐➤➵ ➯ ❮ ➸✓➲✓➽✠➲✓➳✆➳✠➾✓➚ ➪✰➽✔❮✓➾✓➸✓➺✗➲✓➳ ➩❼➵ Ñ ➳✠➽✠➴✗➘✓➲ ➴✲Ñ ➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺ ➵ ➳ ➳✔➷❅➾✗Ó Ó ✃ ➵ ➲ ➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳✠➲✓➳ ➾✗➸✓➱ ➽✠➴✗Ó Ó ➾✗Þ✓➴✗➚ ➾✲➯ ➵ ➴✗➸✓➳ ✿❭❈ ❁✽▲ ❈ ❄ ❅✕❯P❈ ❁✕❘✕◆✽❅✽❄ ❪❊❖✕❁✕▲✫❋✽❉ ❁❫▼❇❁✽❉ ❍P❴✭❴✸▲✟◗✕❁✕❘✕❄ ❂ ❄ ❘❛❵P❙❱■❊❉ ❁❲● ❋❃❈ ❁✽❉ ➩➭➾✓➳✷➳✆➽✠➴❆➘✔➲➼➴✲Ñ✛➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺➼➺✗➲✲➯ ➳❅Ó ➾✗➚ ➺✗➲✗➚ ✿❭❈ ❁✽▲ ❈ ❄ ❅✕❯P❈ ❁✕❘✕◆✽❅✽❄ ❪❊❖✕❁✕▲❜❑✕❁✕❘✟■✕❙❱❁❱❙❱■❊❉ ❁❫❈ ❉ ❋✕❀❊❄ ❈ ❄ ■❊❅✕❋✽●
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #6

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩❼➵ ➸✗❮✓➲✓➚ ➵ ➯ ➾✗➸✓➽✠➲☛➷❅➲✓➾✗➸✓➳Ð➸✓➲✲Ï✲➲✗➚➮❮✓➾✲Ï✻➵ ➸✓➺✼➯ ➴✙➳✆➾✲➪❰➪✻➴✗➻✙➾✗➚ ➲ ➳✠➴✗➚ ➚ ➪ ➩➭➳✔➘✔➲✓➽✔➵ ➾✗Ó ➵ ❝✠➵ ➸✓➺❑Ñ ➚ ➴❆➷ ➾❼➯ ➚ ➻✓➳✄➯ ➲✓➱❰➳✠➻✗➘✔➲✗➚ ➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳✞➷❅➲✓➾✗➸✔➳➭➯ ❮✓➲ ➵ ➸✗❮✓➲✓➚ ➵ ➯ ➲✓➱➮➘✓➾✗➚ ➯✴➴✲Ñ✴➳✔➻✗Þ✔➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✠➳✆➲✓➳✾❐Ò➵ Ó Ó✓➾✓Ó ➳✠➴➮Þ✔➲➼➽✠➴✗➚ ➚ ➲✔➽✑➯ ➩Ý❐✾➲➼➱✓➴❆➸✧✦ ➯⑥➸✓➲✓➲✓➱✰➯ ➴➮➚ ➲✲➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✗❮✓➲✗➚ ➵ ➯ ➲✓➱✰Ñ ➲✓➾✲➯ ➻✗➚ ➲✓➳ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩➭➳✔➻✓Þ✓➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳✠➲✓➳ ➽✔➚ ➲✓➾✲➯ ➲✙➸✓➲✲❐ ❐Ò➾✲➪✲➳❼➯ ➴✙➷➼➵ ➳✠➻✓➳✆➲☛➵ ➸✓❮✓➲✗➚ ➵ ➯ ➲✓➱ Ñ ➲✔➾✲➯ ➻✗➚ ➲✓➳ ➩➭➱❆➵ Ñ Ñ ➲✗➚ ➲✗➸✲➯✷➯ ➲✓➳✑➯Ò➽✠➾✓➳✆➲✓➳➮➾✗➚ ➲✞➸✓➲✔➲✓➱✗➲✓➱❼Ñ ➴❆➚✷➲✓➾✓➽✔❮ ➳✠➻✗Þ✓➽✔Ó ➾✔➳✠➳ ✲☞➷❅➴✗➚ ➲➼Ó ➾✲➯ ➲✗➚ ✶
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #7

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩❼➚ ➲✗➻✓➳✆➲➼➷➬➲✔➾✗➸✓➳❅➸✓➲✲Ï✲➲✗➚❇❮✓➾✲Ï✻➵ ➸✔➺ ➯ ➴➬➳✠➾✲➪❅➪✲➴❆➻➬➾✗➚ ➲➬➳✆➴❆➚ ➚ ➪ ➩❼➚ ➲✗➻✓➳✠➵ ➸✓➺Ý➾ ➯ ➚ ➻✓➳✄➯ ➲✓➱Ý➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✠➳➼➷❅➲✓➾✗➸✔➳➼Þ✓➲✗❮✓➾✲Ï✻➵ ➴✗➻✗➚✵➴✲Ñ ➳✠➲✗➚ Ï✲➲✗➚ ➴✗Þ❇❩ ➲✓➽✑➯✼➵ ➳ ➯✄➚ ➻✓➳✑➯ ❐✾➴❆➚ ➯ ❮✲➪ ➾✗➸✓➱ ➱✓➴✗➲✓➳✠➸✧✦ ➯✼➸✓➲✓➲✓➱ ➯ ➴ Þ✓➲ ➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➲✓➱ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩❼➸✓➴✲➯ ❮✗➵ ➸✓➺➮➘✗➚ ➲✲Ï✲➲✗➸✲➯ ➳✷➾➮➸✓➲✲❐✼➽✔Ó ➵ ➲✓➸✲➯ ➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✠➳ÒÑ ➚ ➴✗➷ ➻✓➳✠➵ ➸✓➺ ➯ ❮✓➲ ➳✠➲✓➚ Ï✲➲✗➚✛➴❆Þ❃❩ ➲✓➽✑➯⑥➵ ➸✓➽✠➴✗➚ ➚ ➲✓➽✑➯ Ó ➪ ➩➭➾✗Ó ÓÝ➽✔Ó ➵ ➲✗➸✲➯✼➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✆➳ ➻✓➳✠➲ ➴✻Ñ✎➾ ➳✆➲✗➚ Ï✲➲✗➚☛➸✓➲✓➲✔➱✗➳ ➯ ➴ Þ✓➲ ➲✩★✲➲✗➚ ➽✔➵ ➳✠➲✓➱
slide-20
SLIDE 20

20

☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

Myth #8

➠✥➡➤➢➦➥✆➧✵➨ ➩❼Þ✗Ó ➾✔➽✔Ú➬Þ✓➴✩★❅➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✔➺Ý➵ ➳✷➳✔➻✲Ñ Ñ ➵ ➽✔➵ ➲✗➸ß➯ ➩➭➱✗➲✓➳✠➵ ➺❆➸✓➵ ➸✓➺ ➯ ➲✓➳✑➯❒➽✠➾✓➳✆➲✓➳ ➻✓➳✔➵ ➸✓➺ ➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✠➳ ➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✓➚ Ñ ➾✓➽✠➲ ➾✗➸✓➱ ➳✔➘✔➲✓➽✔➵ Ñ ➵ ➽✠➾✲➯ ➵ ➴❆➸➬➾✓➳✆➳✔➻✗➚ ➲✓➳✾➯ ❮✓➲➬➽✔Ó ➾✓➳✠➳❅➵ ➳✾Ñ ➻✗Ó Ó ➪➤➲✩★✲➲✗➚ ➽✔➵ ➳✠➲✓➱ ➩Ý❐Ò❮✗➵ ➯ ➲➮Þ✔➴✾★❅➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺✰Ï✻➵ ➴✗Ó ➾✲➯ ➲✓➳✷➲✗➸✓➽✠➾✗➘✔➳✔➻✗Ó ➾ß➯ ➵ ➴❆➸ ➠✥Ô❇Õ❆Ö❇× Ø ➥ ➢⑥➨ ➩➭➳✑➯ ➻✔➱❆➵ ➲✓➳✞➳✠❮✓➴✲❐ Þ✗Ó ➾✓➽✔Ú✽✼☞Þ✔➴✾★Ð➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➳✔➻✓➵ ➯ ➲✓➳❼➯ ➪✻➘✗➵ ➽✠➾✗Ó Ó ➪❒➴❆➸✓Ó ➪ ➲✩★✲➲✗➚ ➽✔➵ ➳✠➲✂✁☎✄ ✆❒➯ ➴✂✁☎✄✞✝Ð➴✲Ñ➬➯ ❮✓➲Ð➳✑➯ ➾✲➯ ➲✗➷❅➲✗➸✲➯ ➳ ✲ Ó ➲✲➯ ➾✓Ó ➴❆➸✓➲ ➘✓➾✲➯ ❮✔➳✷➴❆➚✛➳✄➯ ➾✲➯ ➲✓➳❇✶ ➩Ý➯ ➪✻➘✗➵ ➽✠➾✗Ó Ó ➪ ➷➬➵ ➳✠➳ ➾✓Þ✗➸✓➴✗➚ ➷❅➾✗Ó✙➘✔➾✲➯ ❮✓➳✠✃☛➲✩★✲➽✠➲✗➘ß➯ ➵ ➴❆➸ ➾✗➸✓➱ ➲✗➚ ➚ ➴✗➚ ✼☞❮✓➾✓➸✓➱❆Ó ➵ ➸✔➺
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

XP’s Approach to Testing

➠✡✠☞☛✍✌☞✎✏☛☞Ö☞✑✒✑ÝÕ✓☛✕✔✗➧☞✌✓✖❇× ✗ ➩ÝÑ ➴✓➽✔➻✓➳✷➴✗➸➤➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✔➺Ý➵ ➸➼➴✗➚ ➱✓➲✗➚✴➯ ➴➬➺❆➵ Ï✲➲➬➽✔❮✓➾✗➸✓➽✠➲➤➯ ➴✰➯ ❮✗➵ ➸✗Ú ➾✗Þ✓➴✗➻✲➯✛❐➤❮✔➾✲➯⑥➽✠➴✓➱✗➲➤❐➤➵ Ó Ó✓➱✓➴✗✃✛➵ ➸✓➱✗➲✓➘✓➲✗➸✓➱✓➲✗➸✲➯ Ó ➪✰➴✲Ñ⑥❮✓➴✲❐✼➵ ➯ ➵ ➳❅➵ ➷➬➘✗Ó ➲✓➷➬➲✗➸ß➯ ➲✔➱ ➩Ý❐Ò➚ ➵ ➯ ➲➼➲ßÏ✻➲✓➚ ➪➬➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ❮✔➲✘✄✄➳✠❮✓➲➬➽✠➾✗➸➤➯✄❮✓➵ ➸✗Ú❅➴✲Ñ✛➯ ❮✓➾✲➯✛❐Ò➴✗➸✧✦ ➯ ➚ ➻✓➸ ➵ ➷➬➷❅➲✓➱❆➵ ➾✲➯ ➲✗Ó ➪➤➴✗➸➼➲✩★✻➵ ➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✓➺➼➽✠➴✓➱✗➲ ➩➭➽✠➴✗➸✓➳✔➵ ➱✓➲✗➚➦➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➳✷➾✓➳✷➺✗➵ Ï✻➵ ➸✓➺➼➽✠➴✗➸✲Ñ ➵ ➱✓➲✗➸✓➽✠➲➤➯ ❮✓➾✲➯✛➯✄❮✓➵ ➸✓➺✗➳✷➾✗➚ ➲ ❐✾➴❆➚ Ú✔➵ ➸✔➺ ✿ ❉ ❁✕❀❊❖✕❘✟❁✕▲✵❈ ❄ ❙❱❁❱▲✕◗✟❁❊❅❃❈✾❀✽❁✽❑✽❖✕❯✕❯❊❄ ❅✕❯ ➩➭➽✠➴✗➸✓➳✔➵ ➱✓➲✗➚➦➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✓➺➼➾✔➳✷➾✰➯ ➪✻➘✓➲➬➴✲Ñ⑥➷❅➲✲➯ ➚ ➵ ➽✚✙ ✿✺▲ ■❇❂ ❈ ✛❛❋✽❉ ❁❫❂ ❁✽❋❃❈ ❖✽❉ ❁✽▲✵❈ ◆✕❋❃❈❨❘ ❋✽❅✕❳ ❈❨❑✕❁❱❀✽❁✕❙❱■❊❅✕▲ ❈ ❉ ❋❇❈ ❁✕❀✺❑❃❍ ❋✽❖❃❈ ■✕❙❱❋❇❈ ❁✕❀P❈ ❁✽▲ ❈ ▲ ✜✧❀✽■✽❅✕❳ ❈✾❁❃❆ ❄ ▲ ❈
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

XP’s Design through Refactoring

➠✤✣✛Ö✥✔✓Õ☞✗✒✌✓✦✞➥☞Õ✥✔✓➥★✧✓Ö✥✔✓Õ☞✔ ➩❼➘✗➵ ➽✔Ú❅➻✗➘➤Ñ ➵ ➚ ➳✑➯✛➯ ➲✓➳✑➯✴➽✠➾✓➳✠➲ ➩❼➵ ➷➬➘✗Ó ➲✗➷❅➲✗➸✲➯✴➽✠➴✓➱✗➲➤➯ ➴➼➺✗➲✲➯✛➯ ➲✓➳✑➯✴➽✠➾✓➳✆➲➮➚ ➻✓➸✗➸✗➵ ➸✓➺ ➩❼➘✗➵ ➽✔Ú❅➻✗➘➼➸✓➲✩★✔➯✛➯ ➲✓➳✄➯⑥➽✠➾✓➳✆➲ ➩❼➚ ➲✲Ñ ➾✓➽✑➯ ➴❆➚✛➽✠➴✓➱✗➲➤➯ ➴➼➺✗➲ß➯⑥➳✠➵ ➷➼➘✓Ó ➲✓➳✑➯⑥➵ ➷➬➘✗Ó ➲✗➷❅➲✗➸✲➯ ➾✲➯ ➵ ➴✗➸➤➯ ➴ ➺✗➲✲➯⑥Þ✓➴✲➯ ❮➤➯ ➲✓➳✑➯✴➽✠➾✓➳✠➲✔➳❅➚ ➻✗➸✗➸✗➵ ➸✔➺ ➩❼➚ ➲✗➘✔➲✓➾✲➯❇Ñ ➴✗➚✵➚ ➲✔➳✑➯✴➴✻Ñ✛➯ ➲✓➳✄➯⑥➽✠➾✓➳✆➲✓➳ ➠✡✠☞☛✍✌✓✩✛Ö☞✩❇× ➢✫✪✬✌✓✦☞✭ ➥★✪✮✌✓☛✍✯✱✰ ✌✓☛❅× Ö✓☛ ✎❇Õ✲✔✲➢✳✔✔➥☞Õ✓✑✱✔ ➩ÝÑ ➴✓➽✔➻✓➳✷➴✗➸➤➯ ➲✓➳✑➯ ➵ ➸✔➺Ý➻✓➘➤Ñ ➚ ➴✗➸✲➯⑥➵ ➳❅➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✗➚ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔

OO Testing in Four Phases

✵☞✶ ✑✱✌✓✗✛Õ❇× Ø ✦✥✎Ð➥☞➧✛Õ✒✔✷✌✓✰ ➥ ✪➮Ö☞☛☞Õ Õ✓✦✳✸➦Ø ☛✍✌✓✦✓✑ÝÕ✓✦❆➥ ✹ ✶ ✔✓Õ✛× Õ☞✧✓➥✆Ø ✦✥✎Ð➥☞Õ✥✔✓➥★✔✷✧✓Õ✓✦✛Ö☞☛✆Ø ✌☞✔ ➩Ý❐✾➲✰❐Ò➵ Ó Ó✓Ó ➴✗➴✗Ú✷➾✲➯ ➻✗➸✓➵ ➯❇➯ ➲✓➳✄➯ ➵ ➸✓➺➼➴✗➸✗Ó ➪ ✺ ✶ ☛✻✖☞✦✓✦✛Ø ✦☞✎ÐÖ☞✦☞✗✞Õ✳✸➹Ö❇× ✖✛Ö❆➥✆Ø ✦☞✎✞➥☞Õ✥✔✓➥★✔✼✧✓Õ☞✦✛Ö☞☛✆Ø ✌☞✔ ✽✏✶ ✑ÝÕ✛Ö✥✔✚✖✓☛✆Ø ✦✥✎Ð➥ Õ☞✔✓➥☞Ø ✦☞✎✾✠☞☛✍✌☞✎✓☛☞Õ☞✔✷✔
✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔
  • 1. Modelling the Software Environment
➠✡✑✒✖✥✔✓➥❅Ø ✗✛Õ✓✦❆➥✆Ø ✰ ➢❼Ö☞✦☞✗✿✔✓Ø ✑✒✖✛× Ö✛➥☞Õ✞Ø ✦✛➥☞Õ☞☛✍✰ Ö☞✧✓Õ✥✔ ✔✼✌☞✰ ➥✍✪➼Ö☞☛☞Õ✒✔ß➢✳✔✓➥ Õ✓✑❀✖✥✔✓Õ✥✔ ➩❼❮✗➻✗➷❅➾✗➸➼➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✗➚ Ñ ➾✓➽✠➲✓➳ ✿✺❙❱❁❃❈ ◆✕■✕❀✽▲❜◗✕❁✕■❊◗✽● ❁❲❖✕▲ ❁❫❈ ■❲❘ ■✽❙❱❙❲❖✽❅✽❄ ❘✟❋❃❈ ❁❁✛❫❄ ❈ ◆❱▲ ■❇❂ ❈ ✛❛❋✽❉ ❁ ✿✺❙❲❖✕▲ ❈❨❘ ■❊❅✕▲✟❄ ❀✽❁✽❉✭◆✕■✞✛✱❈ ■P❈ ❁✽▲ ❈❨❄ ❅✽◗✽❖❃❈✧❂ ❉ ■✽❙❚❀❊❄ ❂ ❂ ❁❊❉ ❁✽❅❃❈✾❀✽❁❃▼ ❄ ❘ ❁✕▲ ➩➭➳✠➴✲Ñ ➯ ❐Ò➾✗➚ ➲➼➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✗➚ Ñ ➾✓➽✠➲✓➳ ✿ ◆✕■❂✛❏▲ ■❇❂ ❈ ✛✵❋✽❉ ❁❲❖✕▲ ❁✕▲✫■❊◗✟❁❊❉ ❋❃❈ ❄ ❅✕❯❲▲ ❍❇▲ ❈ ❁✕❙✏✜✧❀✽❋❃❈ ❋❊❑✟❋✽▲ ❁✻✜✧❉ ❖✽❅❃❈ ❄ ❙❱❁
❑✕❉ ❋✽❉ ❍ ✿✺❙❲❖✕▲ ❈✭❈ ❁✕▲ ❈❨❁❃❆❇◗✕❁✕❘ ❈ ❁✽❀❱❋❊❅✟❀✺❖✽❅✕❁❃❆ ◗✕❁✕❘ ❈ ❁✕❀❲❋✕❘ ❈ ❄ ▼❇❄ ❈ ❄ ❁✕▲✫■❃❂✾▲ ❁❊❉ ▼❇❄ ❘✟❁ ❘✕● ❋✽▲ ▲ ❁✕▲
✁ ✄ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔
  • 1. Modelling the Software Environment
➩ÝÑ ➵ Ó ➲➼➳✄➪✲➳✑➯ ➲✗➷☛➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✗➚ Ñ ➾✔➽✠➲✓➳ ✿ ❉ ❁✕❋✽❀✕▲✫■❊❉✘✛❫❉ ❄ ❈ ❁✕▲✵❈ ■❱❁❃❆✕❈ ❁❊❉ ❅✕❋✽●❃❂ ❄
  • ❁✕▲
✿✺❙❲❖✕▲ ❈❨❘✟◆✕❁✕❘✻❃✵❈ ■❱▲✟❁✕❁❲❄ ❂✩❀✽❋❃❈ ❋❫❂ ❉ ■✽❙ ❈ ◆✕❁❫❂ ❄
  • ❁❲❄
▲✫❋✽◗✽◗✽❉ ■✽◗✽❉ ❄ ❋❃❈ ❁❲❄ ❅ ❘✟■✽❅❃❈ ❁✽❅❃❈✾❋✽❅✕❀P❂ ■❊❉ ❙❱❋❃❈ ❈ ❄ ❅✕❯ ➩➭➽✠➴✗➷➼➷➬➻✗➸✗➵ ➽✠➾✲➯ ➵ ➴❆➸➼➵ ➸✲➯ ➲✓➚ Ñ ➾✓➽✠➲✓➳ ✿✺❀❊❄ ❉ ❁✕❘ ❈✾❋✕❘✟❘ ❁✽▲ ▲✵❈ ■✺◗✽◆❃❍❃▲✟❄ ❘✟❋✽●✕❀✕❁❇▼❇❄ ❘✟❁✕▲ ❄ ❁✕❯✷❅✷❆✭❉ ❄ ▼❇❁✽❉ ▲ ✜❊❘✟■❊❅❃❈ ❉ ■❊●
  • ❁✽❉
▲ ✜ ■❇❈ ◆✕❁✽❉✧❁✕❙✺❑✟❁✽❀✕❀✽❁✕❀❲▲ ❍❇▲ ❈ ❁✽❙❱▲✍❇ ✿✺❙❲❖✕▲ ❈✵❑✟❁❱❋❊❑✕● ❁❫❈ ■❱❯✽❁✽❅✕❁✽❉ ❋❃❈ ❁❫▼❇❋✽● ❄ ❀❱❋❊❅✕❀❲❄ ❅❃▼❇❋✽● ❄ ❀✺◗✽❉ ■❇❈ ■✽❘✟■✽● ▲ ❈ ❉ ❁✕❋✕❙❱▲ ✜✧❁✕❯✺◗✟❋✽❘✍❃✟❁❃❈ ▲
slide-21
SLIDE 21

21

☎ ✆ ✆ ✝✟✞✠✟✡ ✝ ☛ ☞ ✆ ✌ ✠ ☛ ✍ ✎ ✏ ✑ ✒ ✓ ✑✕✔ ✖ ✔ ✗ ✍ ✍ ✘ ✙ ✚ ✚ ✛ ✛ ✛ ✜ ✢ ✠ ✜ ✣ ☎ ✆ ✆ ✝ ✠ ☎ ✜ ✢ ✤ ✚ ✥ ✢ ☛ ✠ ✢ ✔ ✖ ✔
  • 2. Selecting Test Scenarios
  • ➽✠➴✗➸✓➳✔➵
➱✓➲✗➚✛➾✗➘✗➘✗Ó ➵ ➽✠➾✲➯ ➵ ➴✗➸➼➱✓➴❆➷❅➾✗➵ ➸➬➾✗➸✓➱✰Ï✲➾✗➚ ➵ ➾✗Þ✗Ó ➲✓➳ ❵✯❉ ❁✽◗✽❉ ❁✕▲✟❁✽❅❃❈ ▲❜❄ ❅❃❂ ❄ ❅✽❄ ❈ ❁❲❅✽❖✕❙❲❑✕❁✽❉✧■❇❂✧❈ ❁✕▲ ❈✾▲ ❘✟❁✽❅✕❋✽❉ ❄ ■✽▲ ❵✯◆✕■❂✛❏❀✽■✽❁✕▲✵❈ ❁✽▲ ❈ ❁✽❉✧❘✕◆✕■✽■✕▲ ❁❲❋✂✁❃❉ ❁✕❋✕▲ ■❊❅✕❋✽❑✽● ❁☎✄ ▲✟❖✽❑✕▲ ❁❃❈ ✆✞✝☎✟☎✠ ✟☎✡ ☛☎☞ ☞ ✌✎✍ ☛✑✏ ✟✑✒✎✓☎✠✕✔ ✓☎✖ ✟☎✡ ☛✑✝✑✟ ✗✞✘ ✙ ✚ ✛✜✘ ✙ ✢ ✛ ✣ ✤ ✥ ✛✧✦✑✛ ★ ✛ ✘ ✩ ✪ ✫ ✙✑✬✧✭ ✤ ✪ ✮ ✯ ✰✲✱ ✳✲✮ ✫ ✪ ✛✧✴ ✙ ★✲✪ ✛ ✯ ✪ ✫ ✬ ✥✑✵ ✶ ✘ ✤✑✬✜✴ ✛✧✫ ✬ ✷ ✫ ✬ ✫ ✪ ✛ ✗✸✫ ✬ ✭ ✩ ✪☎✚ ✙✑✹✲✤✑✫ ✬✜✘ ✙ ✢ ✛✑✣ ✤ ✥ ✛✧✱ ✴ ✺ ✤ ✘ ✻✜✴ ✙ ★✲✪ ✛ ✯ ✪ ✫ ✬ ✥✑✵ ✶ ✬ ✙ ✪✼✫ ✬ ✚✑✫ ✢ ✫ ✚✑✩ ✤ ✺ ✫ ✬✑✭ ✩ ✪ ✯ ✽✑✴ ✩ ✪✼✫ ✬ ✭ ✩ ✪☎✯ ✛ ✾✑✩ ✛✑✬ ✘ ✛ ✯ ✶ ✬ ✙ ✪☎✙✑✬ ✺ ✿✜✫ ✬ ✭ ✩ ✪ ✯✲✴ ✩ ✪☎✯ ✪ ✤ ✪ ✛✲✙✑✷✑✙✑✴ ❀ ✛ ✘ ✪✼✹✲✤ ✪ ✪ ✛ ✣ ✯ ✶ ✯ ✘ ✛✑✬ ✤ ✣ ✫ ✙ ✯❁✪ ✙✜✳✲✮✑✫ ✘ ✮✧✭ ✣ ✙ ✥✑✣ ✤ ✹✞✹✜✩ ✯ ✪✼✣ ✛ ✯ ✭ ✙✑✬ ✚ ✶ ✤✑✺ ✯ ✙✜✘ ✤ ✬✧✴ ✛✧✫ ✬ ✷ ✫ ✬ ✫ ✪ ✛ ❂❄❃ ❅ ❆✎❃ ❇❉❈✼❅ ❅ ❊ ❋❍●❉❈■❃❑❏☎●☎▲ ❃❑▼☎❇☎▲✑▲✑❊ ❏☎◆
  • ❖❃
  • ☎▲
❃◗P✼❈■❃ ❈❉❈☎P✼●☎❘❁❙☎❈☎❚ ❆❖❚☎❅ ❊ ❃
  • ✼❅
❊ ❈ ❯✞❱ ❲☎❳ ❨✕❩ ❬✑❭ ❪ ❲✑❫ ❴ ❵ ❱✑❲ ❛ ❜ ❜ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✑❣❤✑✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣☎s ❜ s t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ s ❜ s

Complications From Inheritance (1)

⑦⑨⑧ ⑩✲❶■⑧❖❷❁❸ ❹✲❶☎❶ super ❺ ❻ ❼ ❶❍⑧ ❽ ❻ ❾ ❷❁❸ ❿✲➀ ❻ ❾✲➁➃➂ ⑩➄⑧ ➅✲➆✜➀✲❶ A ❹ ❾ ➀

B

⑦ ❾ ➆➄➇➈⑧ ⑩✲❶■⑧❖❷❁❸ ❹✲❶☎❶✞❶❁❿✲➉ ⑦ ❾ ⑩➄➇➈➊➄⑩ ❼ ❶ ❻ ➆ ❾ ➆ ❺❖➋➍➌➎❾ ⑩❁⑩✲➀➍⑧ ➆➍⑧ ⑩✲❶❍⑧ ❻ ❾ ❶❁❿✜➉ ⑦➏❶❁❿✲➉ ❻ ❾ ➅✲⑩ ❼ ❻ ⑧ ❶➑➐ ➌➎❾ ➆ ❾ ⑩✲⑩✲➀➍⑧ ➆ ❼ ⑩✲➒ ⑧ ⑩✲❶■⑧ ❻ ❾ ❶✼❿✜➉ ⑦➏❶❁❿✲➓✜➓✲➆✲❶☎⑩→➔➃❷✼❹✜❸ ❸ ❶➑➐↔➣ ➌↕❾ ➆ ➁ ❿✲❹ ❼ ❹ ❾ ⑧ ⑩✲⑩➍⑧ ➅✲❹➙⑧❖➔➃❷✼❹✜❸ ❸ ❶➑➐➛➓ ❼ ➆✜➓✲⑩ ❼ ❸ ➜ ➌ ➇➑⑩→❶■⑧ ❻ ❸ ❸✲➅✲❹➄➊➄⑩➍⑧ ➆➝⑧ ⑩✲❶❍⑧✂➔✕➞ ❶✸❿✲❶☎⑩➟➆ ❺ ➐

super int A(int x) int B(int x) sub int B(int x) int C(int x)

❛ ❜ s ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✑❣❤✑✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣☎s ❜ s t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ s ❜ s

Complications From Inheritance (2)

⑦⑨⑧ ⑩✲❶■⑧❖❷❁❸ ❹✲❶☎❶ super ❺ ❻ ❼ ❶❍⑧ ❽ ❻ ❾ ❷❁❸ ❿✲➀ ❻ ❾✲➁➃➂ ⑩➄⑧ ➅✲➆✜➀✲❶ A ❹ ❾ ➀

B

⑦ ❾ ➆➄➇➈⑧ ⑩✲❶■⑧❖❷❁❸ ❹✲❶☎❶✞❶❁❿✲➉ ⑦ ❾ ⑩➄➇➈➊➄⑩ ❼ ❶ ❻ ➆ ❾ ➆ ❺❖➋➍➌➎❾ ⑩❁⑩✲➀➍⑧ ➆➍⑧ ⑩✲❶❍⑧ ❻ ❾ ❶❁❿✜➉ ⑦ ➂➟❻ ➁ ➅➄⑧✂❹✲❶✼❶✼❿ ➂ ⑩ ❾ ➆ ❾ ⑩✲⑩✲➀➍⑧ ➆➝⑧ ⑩❁❶❍⑧✕➐ ❻ ❾ ❶ ❻ ➀✜⑩➟❶✼❿✜➉ ⑦➠➉✜❿➙⑧✎➇➡➅✲❹➄⑧ ❻ ❺ ➐➛❷✼❹✜❸ ❸ ❶ ➋✜➢❁➢ ⑦ ❾ ⑩✲⑩✲➀➍⑧ ➆➝⑧ ⑩✲❶❍⑧✕➐❄➇ ❻ ⑧ ➅➍⑧ ➅❁⑩ ❾ ⑩➄➇ ➋

super int A(int x) int B(int x) sub int B(int x)

❛ ❜ ➤ ❝ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢✑❣❤✑✐ ❢ ❥ ❦ ❡ ❧ ❤ ❥ ♠ ♥ ♦ ♣ q r ♣☎s ❜ s t ♠ ♠ ✉ ✈ ✇ ✇ ① ① ① ② ③ ❤ ② ④ ❞ ❡ ❡ ❢ ❤ ❞ ② ③ ⑤ ✇ ⑥ ③ ❥ ❤ ③ s ❜ s

Testing Objects

➥➏➦➨➧❑➦✎➩ ➫✜➭ ➯✲➦➳➲❄➦✕➵☎➸✧➺✕➻✎➯❄➼✕➩✑➺➨➽➨➭ ➻✕➦✕➻➳➾❑➚↕➺✎➾❑➪ ➦✧➫✲➵✞➶➃➭ ➵☎➸ ➹ ➺✎➘✕➴ ➯➃➺✕➷✞➬✎➮✧➫✜➺➨➽❑➦✎➩☎➭ ➮ ➹ ➦✕➩☎➩✑➺✎➩✑➯➃➭ ➮➳➩✑➦✧➯✜➬✎➴ ➵ ➯✲➱✃➯✲➵ ➘✕➵✑➦❐➺✕➷ ➺✎➾❑➪ ➦✧➫✲➵✑➱✃➺✎➩✸➾✧➺✕➵☎➸ ➥➠➲❒➬✧➯✲➵✞➵ ➦✕➯✲➵✞➭ ➮✕➵✑➦✕➩✑➘✕➫✲➵☎➭ ➺✎➮❒➾✕➦✕➵ ➶→➦✕➦✕➮➳➲❐➦✧➵☎➸✕➺✕➻✕➯❄➭ ➮ ➺✎➾❑➪ ➦✧➫✲➵ ➥➠➲❒➬✧➯✲➵✞➯❁➦✕➘✕➩✑➫✜➸❒➷ ➺✎➩✞➘✎➴ ➴✕➼✧➘✕➵ ➵✑➦✎➩✑➮✕➯➃➺✕➷✞➲❐➦✧➵☎➸✕➺✕➻ ➭ ➮➨➽❑➺✕➫✜➘✧➵☎➭ ➺✎➮❒➺✕➷✃➺✎➾❑➪ ➦✧➫✲➵ ❮↕❰✸Ï➄Ð Ñ✲Ò✲Ó✜Ô✞Õ✼Ö✜×→Ø✲Ï→Ù ×➄Ú➄Ò✜Û✼Ï✲Ó➃Ù ×➟Ö✜×➄Ü➍Ý Ö✜×✲Ó✜Ò✜❰➠Ò✜Ý Ó✜Ï✲Ý Þ Ï✲Ö✲Ó✜Ù ×✲ß➍Ð Ò→Ö Þ Ö✜Ý ß✲Ï➃×✜à✲❰→Ø❁Ï✜Ý✕Ò◗á✂Õ✼Ò✜❰➟Ø✜Ù ×✲Ö➄Ð Ù Ò✜×✲Ô â ã ä å æ ç ç è✑éê✑ë è ì í ç î ê ì ï ð ñ ò ó ô ò☎õ ã õ ö ï ï ÷ ø ù ù ú ú ú û ü ê û ý æ ç ç è ê æ û ü þ ù ÿ ü ì ê ü õ ã õ
  • 3. Running and Evaluating

Test Scenarios (1)

➥➠➲❐➘✕➮✎➬✧➘✎➴ ➴ ➚↕➦❑➧❑➦✕➫✜➬✕➵☎➭ ➮ ➹ ➵✑➦✧➯✲➵✞➯❁➫✲➦✎➮✕➘✕➩☎➭ ➺✕➯❄➭ ➯➃➴ ➘✕➾✕➺✎➬✕➩✁ ➭ ➮✕➵ ➦✎➮✕➯✲➭ ➽➨➦❐➘✎➮✕➻❒➦✎➩✑➩✑➺✎➩✸➼✕➩✑➺✎➮✕➦ ❮➛Ö✜à➄Ð Ò✜❰✸Ö➄Ð Ï→Ö❁Ô✞Ö ✂✄✂ Ý Ò ✂ Ý Ù Ö➄Ð Ï ☎✝✆ ✞✁✟✡✠✁☛✌☞✍✞✁✎✁✏✌☛✑✞✓✒✓☛✔✞✖✕✓✗ ✘✍✟✡✞✓✗ ✠✍✙✚✗ ✠✁☛ ✗ ☛✔✘✍✛✍✜ ✒✌✢ ✣ ✛✁✙✥✤✁✦✑✧★✘✓✢ ✠✍✩ ✩ ✘✖✩ ☛ ✪✬✫✮✭✁✯✁✰ ✭✁✱ ✲ ✳✑✴ ✲ ✴✄✵ ✶ ✯ ✷✌✸✑✲ ✹ ✳✁✺✖✻✑✼✑✽✿✾ ✾ ❮➛Ò➄á Ð Ï✜×→Ù ×✲Õ Þ à✲Ó✲Ï Ï❁❀❁Ð Ý Ö➟Õ✼Ò✲Ó✜Ï➝Ð Ò ✂ Ý Ò◗Ú◗Ù Ó✲Ï➃Ù ×➙á Ò✜Ý ❰✸Ö➄Ð Ù Ò✧× Ö✜Ø✲Ò✜à➄Ð✕Ú➄Ö✜Ý Ù Ö✜Ø Þ Ï✲Ô✍❂✧Ò✧Ø✓❃ Ï✲Õ❍Ð ✂ Ý Ò ✂ Ï✜Ý Ð Ù Ï✲Ô✍❂✧Ï➄Ð Õ✞Ó✧à✜Ý Ù ×❁ß Ð Ï❁Ô❍Ð Ý à✜×❁Ô ❮❅❄➡Ý Ù Ð Ï→Õ✼Ò✲Ó✜Ï➝á Ò✧Ý➨Ð Ï✲Ô■Ð Ö✲Ø✜Ù Þ Ù Ð Ü❇❆✜Õ✼Ò✜×➄Ð Ý Ò Þ Þ Ö✜Ø✜Ù Þ Ù Ð Ü➝Ö✜×✲Ó Ò✜Ø✲Ô✼Ï✲Ý Ú➄Ö✜Ø✜Ù Þ Ù Ð Ü â ã ❈ å æ ç ç è✑éê✑ë è ì í ç î ê ì ï ð ñ ò ó ô ò☎õ ã õ ö ï ï ÷ ø ù ù ú ú ú û ü ê û ý æ ç ç è ê æ û ü þ ù ÿ ü ì ê ü õ ã õ
  • 3. Running and Evaluating

Test Scenarios (2)

➥➏➦➨➽❑➘✎➴ ➬✧➘✕➵☎➭ ➺✎➮❐➺✎➷✃➵✑➦✧➯✲➵✸➩ ➦✕➯✜➬✕➴ ➵✑➯ ❮➛Õ✼Ò✜❰ ✂ Ö✜Ý Ù Ô☎Ò✧×➟Ò➄á✂Ô✼Ò➄á Ð ❄➑Ö✜Ý Ï❊❉ Ô✞Ö✲Õ❍Ð à✲Ö Þ Ò✜à➄Ð ✂ à➄Ð✕Ð Ò➃Ù Ð Ô Ï❁❀ ✂ Ï✲Õ❍Ð Ï✲Ó→Ò✧à➙Ð ✂ à➄Ð ❮➛Ò➄á Ð Ï✜×➟Ó✧Ù á á Ù Õ❁à Þ Ð✎Ð Ò→Ó✲Ò ☎❋✠✁●✖❍✖■✄✕✁✟✡✞✖✛✌✘✖✩ ✞✁✎✁✜ ✠✚❏❑✣ ☛✑✕✁✞✖✜ ✜ ✒▲✟✡✘✍✛✍✣ ✗ ✘✍✩ ✣ ✛✁●▼☛ ✎✁✩ ✠✁✠✍✛✡✘✖✕✓✗ ◆✍✕✓✗❖✞✖✛✁✙ ◆✁✞✍✣ ✛✁☛ ✗ ✞✖P✑✣ ✛✁●✖✜ ✒✚✞✍✛✁✞✍✜ ✒❑◗✑✣ ✛✁●✡✙✍✞✓✗ ✞ ✪✬✹✑✸ ❘❙✳✑❚ ✳✁✺ ❯✖✹✁✰✑✫✮✭✁✯✔❱ ✭✁✯✔✴ ❲ ✸✁✲✍❳✍✱ ✶ ✲ ❱ ✹✑✳ ✴✔✶ ✯✮✲ ✳✑✴ ✲✖✷✑✭✑✲ ✭✑❯✍✲ ✳✑✴ ✲❊✺ ✳✑✴ ✰✑✱ ✲ ✴ ❯ ✴ ✰✁✶ ✲ ✳✔✸✁✵✍✲ ✳✑✴ ✲✖❱ ✭✑✴ ✳✑✴ ☎❋✠✁●✖❍✖❨❑❩❑◆✁✠✁✎ ✗ ✠✁✙▼✘✖✕✓✗ ◆✍✕✓✗❖✙✖✣ ✢ ✢ ✣ ✎✑✕✍✜ ✗❊✗ ✘✡✞✍✎ ✎✁✕✍✩ ✞✓✗ ✠✍✜ ✒▲◆✍✩ ✠✁✙✖✣ ✎ ✗❖✘✖✩
  • ✍✠✍✛✁✠✍✩
✞❑✗ ✠✡❬ ☛✑✕✁✎✑✏✡✞✁☛✔✠❑❩❑◆✁✠✁✎ ✗ ✠✁✙▼✘✖✕✓✗ ◆✍✕✓✗❊✢ ✘✖✩❊☛✑✣ ✟▼✕✍✜ ✞✓✗ ✣ ✘✖✛ ◆✍✩ ✘✍●✍✩ ✞✁✟✡☛❇✢ ✘✍✩✄◆✍✩ ✘✍✎✑✠✁☛ ☛ ✠✁☛✔✞❑✗❖✞▼✛✍✕✁✎✁✜ ✠✍✞✍✩❊●✍✠✍✛✁✠✍✩ ✞✓✗ ✣ ✛✁●✡☛ ✗ ✞✓✗ ✣ ✘✖✛✍❭
slide-22
SLIDE 22

22

â ã
  • å
æ ç ç è✑éê✑ë è ì í ç î ê ì ï ð ñ ò ó ô ò☎õ ã õ ö ï ï ÷ ø ù ù ú ú ú û ü ê û ý æ ç ç è ê æ û ü þ ù ÿ ü ì ê ü õ ã õ
  • 4. Measuring Testing

Progress

➥➏➻✕➦✕➵✑➦✕➩☎➲❒➭ ➮✕➭ ➮ ➹ ❮❅❄➡Ñ✲Ï✜×➝Ð Ò→Ô❍Ð Ò ✂ Ð Ï✲Ô❍Ð Ù ×❁ß ☎✥✕✁☛✑✕✁✞✍✜ ✜ ✒✂✁✚✏✁✠✍✛✚✒❑✘✍✕▼✩ ✕✍✛✡✘✖✕✓✗❖✘❑✢❊✗ ✣ ✟✡✠✡✞✍✛✁✙☎✄ ✘✍✩✄✩ ✠✍☛ ✘✍✕✍✩ ✎✑✠✁☛ ❮❅❄➡Ñ✲Ï✜×➝Ð Ñ✲Ï ✂ Ý Ò✲Ó✧à✲Õ❍Ð❖Ù Ô✸Ý Ï✲Ö✲Ó➄Ü➟Ð Ò➃Ý Ï Þ Ï✲Ö✲Ô✼Ï ☎✝✆✁✞✁☛ ✠✁✙▼✘✖✛✞✆✁✕✁☛✁✣ ✛✁✠✍☛ ☛✠✟ ✕✁✙✍●✁✠✍✟✡✠✍✛✓✗ ➥➠➮✕➦✧➦✕➻☛✡❉➬✧➘✎➮✧➵☎➭ ➵✑➘✕➵✑➭ ➽➨➦➳➲❄➦✕➘✧➯✜➬✕➩✑➦✕➯ ❮➛Ï✲Ô■Ð Ù ❰➟Ö➄Ð Ù Ò✧×➟Ò➄á❖×✜à✜❰➟Ø✲Ï✜Ý✕Ò➄á❖Ø✜à✲ß✜Ô Þ Ï➄á Ð❖Ù ×➟Ô✼Ò➄á Ð ❄➑Ö✜Ý Ï ☎✝✆✁✞✁☛ ✠✁✙▼✘✖✛ ☞ ✩ ✞✓✗ ✠✡✞✓✗✌✁✚✏✍✣ ✎✑✏✞✆✍✕✁●✍☛✔✞✍✩ ✠✡☛ ✗ ✣ ✜ ✜✍✆✁✠✍✣ ✛✁●▲✢ ✘✍✕✍✛✁✙ ☞ ✁✚✏✁✠✍✩ ✠▼✣ ✛✡☛ ✘❑✢ ✗ ✁ ✞✍✩ ✠✞✆✍✕✁●✍☛✔✞✍✩ ✠✞✆✁✠✍✣ ✛✁●▲✢ ✘✍✕✍✛✁✙ ☞ ✩ ✞✓✗ ✠✡✘❑✢✎✆✍✕✁●▲✢ ✣ ❩❑✣ ✛✁●