SLIDE 7 Session I : Management of the failure correction process
Customer Project Mngr. Product Devl. All types
Enhanced support Simple and easy to use processes Help in daily work Demonstrate visible results at high quality
Performer Supplier Management Organization Project Organization Project Project Manager Project PI Unit Organization Role Viewpoint Success in project
Strategic alignment Cost Customer and employee satisfaction
Dissemination of best practice Justify PI Improved quality
Developer Individual
Increased quality: less defects Simple & effective processes Best Practice
Expert Individual
Influence Engagement The results are in demand
Success in Use
More insight Better basis for decisions Better performance Better control More visibility Better predictability Agreement on project objectives Better process basis Gain more appreciation for the mission, accept and continuous PI Process design (operationally) Provide value for users Qualify More involvement Participation in more tasks – have the solution in demand Increased Quality
Dissemination
Obtain the mission Satisfying stakeholders expectations Achievement of project objectives
User Customer Project Mngr. Product Devl. All types
Enhanced support Simple and easy to use processes Help in daily work Demonstrate visible results at high quality
Performer Performer Supplier Supplier Management Organization Project Organization Project Project Manager Project PI Unit Organization Role Viewpoint Success in project
Strategic alignment Cost Customer and employee satisfaction
Dissemination of best practice Justify PI Improved quality
Developer Individual
Increased quality: less defects Simple & effective processes Best Practice
Expert Individual
Influence Engagement The results are in demand
Success in Use
More insight Better basis for decisions Better performance Better control More visibility Better predictability Agreement on project objectives Better process basis Gain more appreciation for the mission, accept and continuous PI Process design (operationally) Provide value for users Qualify More involvement Participation in more tasks – have the solution in demand Increased Quality
Dissemination
Obtain the mission Satisfying stakeholders expectations Achievement of project objectives
User
Figure 3. Roles with different success criteria’s. Red text can be directly traced back to research inter-
- views. Black text is based on knowledge and experience of the authors.
The rational goals for a project are normally agreed as success factors by all roles in the organization – such as the requirements for the project. The expected goals in relation to the stakeholders are normally related to specific roles. From figure 3 it can be seen, that the view on success is different from role to role, and different seen from a project perspective and from a user perspective. From the project point of view, the suppliers relate success more in direction of organizational benefits (rational goals). Whereas the performers relate success more in the direction of the end users (expected goals). Seen form a users point of view, success is more role specific (rational goals). To obtain a more detailed view, we will analyze which needs are in focus for the different roles.
5 Different needs and perspectives in relation to roles
Analysis of the project interview data in Talent@IT as well as several years (more then 25) as em- ployee, researcher and consultancy in many primarily Danish companies working with process im- provement can be expressed in the picture given in figure 4 of the different roles in a “play of change” game.
Customer Project Mngr. Product Devl. Performer Supplier Management Organization Project Organization Project Project Manager Project PI Unit Organization Role Viewpoint Developer Individual Expert Individual Focus
Improvement Economy and business development Overview and follow-up
management Plan, budget and results
Solution
More insight: The right Information, data and dialogue Better predictability: Higher maturity Operational processes: Methods and techniques
Horizon Vision and strategy Mission &
Objectives
Consistency
quality Process improvement: Organizational qualify
Mission Problem
Missing basis for decision making Missing control and security Missing stability
- moving target
- poor capacity
Missing trenchancy and accept Solutions, methods, techniques and career Qualify: Competence rewarding education
Tasks
Missing time and quality
Deliver value
the organization is missing More usable services and in demand: More intervention
Tasks
Missing continuously involvement
User Tasks
Solutions, efficiency, quality and security Product improvement: Efficient solutions Missing
results on a scanty basis
Customer Project Mngr. Product Devl. Performer Performer Supplier Supplier Management Organization Project Organization Project Project Manager Project PI Unit Organization Role Viewpoint Developer Individual Expert Individual Focus
Improvement Economy and business development Overview and follow-up
management Plan, budget and results
Solution
More insight: The right Information, data and dialogue Better predictability: Higher maturity Operational processes: Methods and techniques
Horizon Vision and strategy Mission &
Objectives
Consistency
quality Process improvement: Organizational qualify
Mission Problem
Missing basis for decision making Missing control and security Missing stability
- moving target
- poor capacity
Missing trenchancy and accept Solutions, methods, techniques and career Qualify: Competence rewarding education
Tasks
Missing time and quality
Deliver value
the organization is missing More usable services and in demand: More intervention
Tasks
Missing continuously involvement
User Tasks
Solutions, efficiency, quality and security Product improvement: Efficient solutions Missing
results on a scanty basis
Figure 4. Roles with different perspectives - focus, problems and solutions