Presentation to the Education Subcommittee
- f the Joint Committee on Ways and Means
2011-13 Governor’s Balanced Budget (GBB) March 14, 2011
1
Presentation to the Education Subcommittee of the Joint Committee on - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Presentation to the Education Subcommittee of the Joint Committee on Ways and Means 2011-13 Governors Balanced Budget (GBB) March 14, 2011 1 2011 -13 Governors Balanced Budget Overview Slides 3-9 I. II. Program
1
2
General Fund $5,281,669,587 77.1% Federal Funds-Limited $722,225,628 10.5% Federal Funds-Non Limited $285,380,254 4.2% Other Funds-Limited $47,585,138 0.7% Lottery Funds $427,416,330 6.3% Other Funds-Non Limited $84,024,055 1.2%
Overall, the 2011-13 GBB is a 9% reduction from the 2009-11 LAB (as of January 2011), but reductions vary widely among programs.
Positions 385 FTE 365.40
3
School Funding $5,557,623,124 81.1% Common School Fund $78,752,888 1.1% Debt Service $57,962,405 0.8% Department Operations $120,288,094 1.8% Special Schools $17,322,556 0.3% Youth Corrections $11,482,052 0.2% Grant-in-Aid $1,004,869,873 14.7%
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
264 Positions 259.59 FTE
14
Personal Services 50% State Government Service Charges and Rent 7% Special Payments 2% Capital Outlay 1% Other Services and Supplies 10% Professional Services 30%
15
16
Office Main Functions Office of Assessment and Information Services (OAIS)
including assessment of essential skills required by the Oregon Diploma;
accurate and timely reporting of student performance data;
Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation (EII)
education, and private K-12 school registration;
Diploma Office of Student Learning and Partnerships (SLP)
Youth Corrections Education, Long-Term Care and Treatment, Hospital, Regional, and Early Childhood programs;
including performance and compliance reviews as well as technical assistance and dispute resolution;
17
Office Main Functions Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction (OSPI)
national organizations;
appeals;
Office of Finance and Administration (OFA)
Jobs Fund grants;
Reinvestment reporting requirements;
and volunteers;
budgeting)
18
Office General Fund Reduction (Package O90)* Summary Description (Not intended to
be an exhaustive list; see slides 19-24 for detail and impact)
Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction (OSPI) $0.23 million Reductions in State Board support, dues to professional organizations, communications work, legal work supported by General Fund Office of Assessment and Information Services (OAIS, also uses acronyms of TIRM and ASSESS) $2.31 million Reductions in payments to regional data warehouses, payments to partner
technology staff to work on non-federal projects Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation (EII) $0.42 million Reductions in work on academic content areas, low-performing schools (non- federal support), Educator Professional Development Commission, Division 22 compliance, technical assistance to schools, private P-K school registration Office of Student Learning and Partnerships (SLP) $0.1 million Reductions in liaison services to Native Tribes, full-day kindergarten work, promotion and support of evidence-based practices Office of Finance and Administration (OFA) $0.45 million Reductions in accounting services, facilities support to other offices, and employee (human resources)services
* Not including statewide reductions in personal services and inflation allowance; numbers do not add to total due to rounding
19
Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 1 EII Staff development 20,000 $ Eliminates support for staff development of expertise to assist districts and other customers Y 2 EII GED 35,000 No impact--vendor cost reduction Y 3 All offices Vacancy Savings 752,848 Assumes vacancies will be held for 60 days, but in some cases this may not be viable since some may be mission-critical; vacancy will result in slower hiring time; reduced staff coverage during other staff absences; affects other offices' abilities to carry out missions by not hiring timely; reduces support for world languages Y 4 EII Office Operations 82,418 Reduces travel and other non-personal services expenditures Y 5 ASSESS Item Writing Expenditures 100,000 Reduces quality and validity of assessment and increases security risk due to item exposure Y 6 OFA Charge to State School Fund for federal State Fiscal Stabilization Fund and Ed Jobs work 100,000 Reduces state funding for schools; impact indeterminate but would help ensure federal funds are spent appropriately and do not have to be repaid N 7 OFA Charge to State School Fund for share of Budget and Management assessment 400,000 Reduces state funding for schools; impact indeterminate N
20
Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 8 TIRM Staff reassignment of work to State Longitudinal Data Systems Grant (SLDS) 300,000 Reduces ability to make enhancements to internal applications; delays turnaround of low-priority projects; creates funding cliff for 2013-15. Specific impacted internal applications which would be delayed or suspended are Timekeeping, Grants Management, Budget Reporting System, and Contract Management System. Y 9 EII SB 443-Professional Development Task Force 130,000 Eliminates support for the work of the professional development commission (SB443) Y 10 TIRM Regional data warehouse payments 100,000 Delays return on KIDS investment; reduces district/ESD personnel dedicated to data warehousing and consolidation work. This is the equivalent of .15 FTE at each regional data warehouse. Y 11 TIRM Education Enterprise Steering Committee (EESC) Dues 100,000 Eliminates a portion of one position and impacts work in critical area of school improvement, technology or scaling up; delays the integration of PK-20 educational services Y 12 OSPI Dues to Partner Organizations 20,000 Reduce dues to industry organizations. Organizations include but are not limited to: The Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSSO), Confederation of Oregon School Administrators (COSA), National Association of State Boards of Education. Reduces benefits to agency from research, collaboration, and partnering with these agencies. Y
21 Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 13 SLP Early Childhood (Kindergarten) 45,965 Eliminates support for the early childhood initiative of full-day kindergarten. This position is shifted to IDEA work with Response to Intervention and county contact work. Y 14 SLP Early Childhood (OR Pre- Kindergarten Services and Supplies) 36,071 Reduces oversight of OPK programs including capacity to support OPK programs through technical assistance, purchase of needed materials (including curricula, outcome reporting software), supplies and health/safety up-grades Y 15 EII Position Fund Shift 34,383 Eliminates support for tracking of required Division 22 annual school district assurances submissions required by law and administrative support for the implementation of the diploma. This is .40 FTE of an Office Specialist position. Y 16 EII Position Fund Shift 9,581 Eliminates an EII regional liaison that provide technical assistance to school district and parents. Fewer opportunities to mediate parent/district issues before they become adversarial. Little or no support to regional stakeholders regarding OARs, complaint procedures, state and federal policy. Reduces the communication and collaborative problem solving between ODE and constituents. Y 17 EII Staff Travel 20,000 Reduces travel for EII staff to provide technical assistance. Y 18 EII Position Fund Shift 76,655 Eliminates support to private K-12 school registration and complaint process. SB 26 will eliminate the option for private elementary or secondary schools to be registered with the Department of Education. Y
22 Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 19 OSPI Position Fund Shift 94,500 Shift some of the support of a position to federal
justify federal funds to support some of these efforts. Y 20 SLP Monitoring Systems and Coordination (Indian Education) 12,251 Eliminates agency liaison to Native tribes. This action will shift responsibility for these duties to other staff. The FTE associated with this cut will be shifted to federal IDEA funds and the person in the position will increase time spent on IDEA Dispute Resolution and monitoring activities. Y 21 OSPI State Board support 25,000 Reduces number of board meetings and impact the decision making process. We may shift to more phone and web-based meetings to continue work of the State Board. Y 22 OSPI Fund shift legal staff 94,500 Shifts position to federal and other funds, thereby reducing flexibility in the use of those funds. Makes this position, in part, more of an enterprise function, charging offices for a portion of the work done. Y 23 TIRM Staff reassignment of work to SLDS Grant 300,000 Eliminates ability to make enhancements to internal applications identified in item #9 above and reduces ability to make enhancements to data collections and
medium priority approved projects. Creates funding cliff for 2013-15. Y 24 TIRM EESC Dues 100,000 Eliminates a portion of one of the EESC director's positions and impacts work in critical area of school improvement, technology or scaling up; delays the integration of PK-20 educational services Y
23
Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 25 TIRM/OFA Vacancy Savings 298,635 Assumes vacancies will be held for 90 days; in some cases this may not be viable as some may be mission critical and the possibility exists that we don't have vacancy savings; results in reduced customer service, slower turnaround time for payments to vendors, reduced segregation of core, high-risk duties (cash receipts) and potential increased errors in financial record. Y 26 TIRM Regional data warehouse payments 150,000 Delays transition to state reporting using the data warehouse model and reduces district/ESD FTE dedicated to data warehousing and consolidation
regional data warehouse. Y 27 ASSESS Item writing expenditures 150,000 Removes innovative (interactive and constructed response) item types from state assessment due to insufficient item bank. This is an activity that has been requested by districts to add value to our system. Y 28 ASSESS Suspension of 4th grade Writing 200,000 Sends inconsistent message to field regarding the importance of writing. Students may be less prepared to graduate from high school. Schools may not be prepared for common core standards, which emphasize writing. This is disruptive to those districts and schools that have built systems that depend on these data. N
24
Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 29 EII Position Fund Shift 10,840 Eliminates an additional EII regional liaison that provides technical assistance to school district and
parent/district issues before they become adversarial. Little or no support to regional stakeholders regarding OARs, complaint procedures, state and federal policy. Reduces the communication and collaborative problem solving between ODE and constituents. Y 30 ASSESS Suspension of 7th grade writing assessment 410,000 Sends inconsistent message to field regarding the importance of writing. Students may be less prepared to graduate from high school. Schools may not be prepared for common core standards, which emphasize writing. This is disruptive to those districts and schools that have built systems that depend on these data. N 31 TIRM Reassignment of staff to work on State Longitudinal Data Systems Grant 453,456 Eliminates ability to make enhancements to all applications and delays turnaround of all approved projects; creates funding cliff for 2013-15. Only mission-critical changes will be made to systems. Y but reduced from $900,000 32 EII Services & Supplies 162,329 S & S dollars that support the FTE being reduced. N
25
Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 33 EII Position Fund Shift 57,357 Eliminates physical education & health education content area and related duties from ODE. This is .25 FTE of an Education Program specialist who leads the development & implementation of content standards & provides technical assistance to teachers, coaches, athletic directors and administrators on the implementation of OARs and meeting health and PE goals for students. N 34 EII Position Fund Shift
35 EII Position Fund Shift 57,357 Reduces ODE staff support for implementation of new social science content standards. This is .25 FTE of an Education Program Specialist provides technical assistance and guidance to school districts in the ares
literacy. N 36 EII Position Fund Shift 22,943 Eliminates staff support for Division 22 technical assistance and response to complaints. This is .10 FTE of Education Program Specialist . This person provides technical assistance to school districts in interpreting OARs, response to parent complaints and completes the analysis of the division 22 assurance reports. N
26 Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 37 EII Position Fund Shift 115,000 Reduces the ability to monitor districts for compliance, support alternative education programs and address complaints and appeals. Reduces technical assistance in helping teachers and administrators develop and sustain quality programs, identify and use research practices, and develop
students. N 38 EII Position Fund Shift 57,357 Eliminates the Arts content area and related duties from ODE. This is .25 FTE of an Education Program Specialist who leads the development & implementation of content standards and assessments and identifying professional development
assistance to teachers, administrators and numerous arts organizations. N 39 TIRM Discontinuance of E-Rate Coordinator Contract 66,000 Shifts statewide E-Rate coordination work from contractor back to the department and would significantly reduce the level of service delivered to districts relative to the E-Rate program N 40 SLP Early Childhood (Personal Services) 68,500 Temporary workforce reduction and additional reduction to oversight of OPK programs N 41 SLP Special Education (Personal Services) 127,500 Temporary workforce reduction -- negative effect on MOE* N 42 SLP Special Education (Personal Services) 89,000 Switches funding source for some staff from GF to FF -
N
27 Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 43 SLP Special Education (Services and Supplies) 25,071 Reductions to office-related travel, supplies, professional development, and subscriptions and negative effect on MOE* N 44 SLP Interagency Educational Services (Long-Term Care and Treatment 30,000 Reduces oversight and technical assistance to LTCT providers and negative effect on MOE* N 45 TIRM Essential Office 2010 upgrade for agency 24,000 Delays essential Office 2010 upgrade for agency; decreases productivity for all staff and results in increased difficulty exchanging documents with partners using Office 2010 N 46 TIRM Essential OAIS desktop upgrade 50,000 Delays essential upgrade and reduces efficiency and effectiveness of OAIS workforce; also increases risk of downtime and poor data quality N 47 TIRM Data quality and visualization toolset upgrades 24,000 Delays upgrades, resulting in decreased quality of data and functionality of website; reduces ability for partners to use ODE data for decision making or reduces confidence in the validity of those decisions N 48 ASSESS Suspension of 3rd Grade Spanish Reading 26,000 Eliminates return on investment made by ODE and reduces services to ELL students and will impact school and district AYP/Report Card designations N 49 TIRM Suspension of Microsoft Premier Support contract 150,000 Increases risk of extended down time and security breaches; reduces efficiency and effectiveness of OAIS staff N 50 ASSESS Charge to districts for ELPA administration 2,200,000 Current ELPA contract is $2.2m; amount would be carved off of the SSF; effect on districts is varied and indeterminate N
28
Rank
Activity Initials Program Unit/Activity Description GF Impact of Reduction on Services (Organizational Capacity), Customers and Outcomes Taken in 2011-13 GBB? 51 TIRM Regional data warehouse payments 1,016,000 Halts the exchange of student records between data warehouses and ODE; puts at risk the continued existence of the six regional data warehouses and permanently damages the associated partnerships N 52 EII Position Fund Shift 34,414 Eliminates support to update and maintain the academic content standards website. This is the only database containing academic content standards and tools to assist districts in the implementation of the academic content standards. N 53 ASSESS Suspension of ESD Training and Helpdesk Contracts 825,000 Reduces services to schools and districts that may have rippling consequences; shifts technical and content support to OAIS staff reducing our ability to maintain and improve underlying systems to prevent future issues. OAIS does not have adequate resources to fulfill current service level. Currently the duties of 6 FTE in the field would need to be added to OAIS staffing to maintain essential services to districts. This reduction would affects student-level data collections; create data quality issues; and reduce accuracy, timeliness, and completeness. N
29
Reduction for quality assurance budget for KIDS project; can produce gaps in quality of transcript data shared between districts Office of Assessment and Information Services $25,775 Elimination of funds for ensuring technical adequacy of math assessment (math paper and pencil comparability) Office of Assessment and Information Services $20,620 Reduction in budget for second raters (scorers) of writing test in 4th and 7th grades Office of Assessment and Information Services $610,000 Reduction in budget for health and P.E. standards - curriculum work and prevention strategies Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation $43,725 Reduction in budget for development of new arts standards Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation $102,400 Reduction in budget for the Oregon Educator Professional Development Commission Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation $12,034 Reduction in budget for student vision screening program Office of Student Learning and Partnerships $13,884 Management/executive/unrepresented salary freezes and benefits reductions All offices $309,180
30 30
31
*Data for 2009-10; staffing is expressed in terms of FTE
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
Biennium General Fund Other Funds Federal Funds All Fund Types FTE 1999-2001 Actuals 42,682,787 $ 9,693,902 $ 22,368,494 $ 74,745,183 $ 259.06 2001-03 Actuals 34,814,836 $ 14,275,852 $ 27,690,596 $ 76,781,284 $ 269.06 2003-05 Actuals 34,405,543 $ 10,542,396 $ 32,149,820 $ 77,097,759 $ 259.68 2005-07 Actuals 34,460,859 $ 14,050,290 $ 45,392,227 $ 93,903,376 $ 260.27 2007-09 Actuals 47,008,798 $ 15,193,680 $ 46,357,560 $ 108,560,038 $ 273.74 2009-11 Estimated 35,795,572 $ 20,215,394 $ 50,000,000 $ 106,010,966 $ 265.70 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget 35,795,572 $ 20,215,394 $ 65,645,579 $ 121,656,545 $ 265.70 2011-13 Governor's Balanced Budget 34,031,784 $ 19,778,256 $ 66,478,054 $ 120,288,094 $ 259.59
Notes: 2007-09 Actuals: General Fund includes $4,996,081 in start-up costs for the Oregon Educator Benefits Board. This funding is a pass- through of dollars to the Department of Administrative Services; it is not an ODE program. 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget: Includes the Governor's June and September allotment reductions and December 2010 Emergency Board actions. Estimated federal expenditures are around $50 million; limitation is roughly $66 million.
52 $- $5,000,000 $10,000,000 $15,000,000 $20,000,000 $25,000,000 $30,000,000 $35,000,000 $40,000,000 $45,000,000 $50,000,000 1999-2001 Actuals 2001-03 Actuals 2003-05 Actuals 2005-07 Actuals 2007-09 Actuals 2009-11 Estimated 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget 2011-13 Governor's Balanced Budget
53 0.00 50.00 100.00 150.00 200.00 250.00 300.00 1999-2001 Actuals 2001-03 Actuals 2003-05 Actuals 2005-07 Actuals 2007-09 Actuals 2009-11 Estimated 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget 2011-13 Governor's Balanced Budget
FTE
54 $- $2,000,000 $4,000,000 $6,000,000 $8,000,000 $10,000,000 $12,000,000 $14,000,000 $16,000,000 1999-2001 Actuals 2001-03 Actuals 2003-05 Actuals 2005-07 Actuals 2007-09 Actuals 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget 2011-13 Governor's Balanced Budget
55 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 120.00 140.00 1999-2001 Actuals 2001-03 Actuals 2003-05 Actuals 2005-07 Actuals 2007-09 Actuals 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget 2011-13 Governor's Balanced Budget FTE Student Count
56 $- $10,000.00 $20,000.00 $30,000.00 $40,000.00 $50,000.00 $60,000.00 $70,000.00 $80,000.00 1999-2001 Actuals 2001-03 Actuals 2003-05 Actuals 2005-07 Actuals 2007-09 Actuals 2009-11 Legislatively Approved Budget 2011-13 Governor's Balanced Budget
$69,021 $65,082 $61,337 $58,792 $46,611 $53,449 $50,534
57
Program Current Service Level In 2011-13 Governor's Budget NOTES on Governor's Budget Early Intervention/Early Childhood Special Education 123,842,228 $ $0 moved to ELC OR Head Start Prekindergarten 112,725,087 $ $0 moved to ELC Breakfast/Nutrition Programs 2,567,332 $ $2,567,332 0% reduction from CSL Regional Programs 32,631,822 $ $26,758,094 18% reduction from CSL Long-term Care and Treatment Programs 18,650,229 $ $15,293,188 18% reduction from CSL Hospital Programs 1,612,209 $ $1,322,012 18% reduction from CSL Teacher/Administrator Mentoring 5,191,680 $ $3,893,760 25% reduction from CSL Connectivity 651,183 $ $488,387 25% reduction from CSL Student Leadership Centers 512,000 $ $384,000 25% reduction from CSL Physical Education 512,000 $ $384,000 25% reduction from CSL TOTAL 298,895,770 $ $51,090,773
58
Child Nutrition $285.38 Million NCLB $416.78 Million Advanced Placement $1.12 Million Perkins $27.6 Million Learn and Serve $0.43 Million Other Grants $3.45 Million IDEA $203.79 Million
59
60
61
62
63