Moving Beyond Market Moving Beyond Market Fundamentalism to a - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Moving Beyond Market Moving Beyond Market Fundamentalism to a Fundamentalism to a More Balanced Economy More Balanced Economy

By By Joseph E. Stiglitz Joseph E. Stiglitz

Moving Beyond Market Moving Beyond Market Fundamentalism to a More Fundamentalism to a More Balanced Economy Balanced Economy

Market Fundamentalism Market Fundamentalism

• !

! "#$ "#$

% % &$'$ &$'$( (# # $ $ % % '$## '$##

• )

)# # *#+ *#+

Rebirth after Great Depression Rebirth after Great Depression

• ,-+$

,-+$ "$+"+ "$+"+

% % '$$ '$$ # #. .

• %

% '# '#

• &/$

&/$ " "

• ,

,

• $

$

Neo Neo-

• classical synthesis

classical synthesis

• $#"

$#" #$$ #$$

• 0$

0$

• 1

1 ## ##

Information Economics Information Economics

• 2$

2$ ##"3# ##"3# #3# #3#

• 4++$++

4++$++ #+$" #+$" *"#+$ *"#+$

• 0+#+$

0+#+$ ++ ++

• +$+#+

+$+#+ # #) )+ +) )

• $$

$$ ++ ++

Implication Implication

• 5++

5++ $" $"

• ##

##

• 6$$#$+

6$$#$+ "$ "$

• )

)$ $. .# #. .# #

• #+

#+ #$ #$

• 1"#$

1"#$. .

• ++

++

Historical experiences confirmed Historical experiences confirmed this perspective this perspective

• !2

!2 $"#$ $"#$ #$ #$

• '+$

'+$ # #

• %

% 2$25+ 2$25+ $7 $7 % % 2$ 2$

• &+8$

&+8$

• 9#

9#

% % :$ :$ % % :# :#

• ;#$<=

;#$<=

• '$$#

'$$#

% % :$ :$

• :

:

• 1$$

1$$. .

• %

% :# :#

• 5#

5#

% % :#3 :#3 % % : : % % : :

New perspectives on growth New perspectives on growth

• '#;$#

'#;$# = = + +

% % > >( (

• :"#

:"#

• %

% * *. .

• :#

:# $ $) ) $# $#

• :#"

:#" "+" "+"

% % &" &"

America is now facing massive America is now facing massive micro micro-

• economic failure

economic failure

• 6+

6+. .## ## ,- ,-

• >+$

>+$) )$$$ $$$

• 9#"#$

9#"#$) )# # "#$$$& "#$$$& '$ '$

• +*#

+*#) )

• 626

626( ($ $ +*$ +*$

Central Point Central Point

• 6+$#

6+$# ## ##( ($ $

• 5##

5##. .#;$ #;$. .#$ #$ $=$$$+ $=$$$+. .

• ?"##+$$

?"##+$$

• %

% >$ >$ % % &$" &$") )$$# $$# % % $"" $"") )$$ $$ #;"$ #;"$ #+$$= #+$$= % % !$#"+"+ !$#"+"+ % % :$$ :$$ "" ""

• &$

&$) )$ $ #$ #$

Gap between Private Rewards and Gap between Private Rewards and Social Returns Social Returns

• !+$+$$

!+$+$$ #"$ #"$ $"$$ $"$$

% % $"# $"#

• .

.$$ $$ % % 9$ 9$( (

• ##$

##$

• '$#$"$

'$#$"$ $$ $$) )+$ +$ +$" +$" # #

Disastrous consequences Disastrous consequences

• @'$

@'$ * *

• %

% 1+# 1+# % % '$+ '$+ $ $

• 5

5 $+ $+

% % ?8+*$ ?8+*$ ABC ABC

Others are bearing the cost Others are bearing the cost

• 0D++

0D++

• 0D+"+D

0D+"+D

• 5*"$

5*"$. .

• 1$$1&

1$$1&

% % !$ !$( ("+++ "+++

• .

. . .

• %

% : :E E

• %

% 0$+$#ACF+ 0$+$#ACF+ &+##ABC5 &+##ABC5

• !*+"++

!*+"++ "$$$ "$$$ +$# +$# $ $

• 2++$'

2++$' $$ $$

Beyond these standard notions Beyond these standard notions

• f efficiency
• f efficiency
• 1"#$

1"#$ $$ $$

% % G#+" G#+" % % , ,

Success requires a more Success requires a more balanced economy balanced economy

'+ '+

B B

5$ 5$

• >

>

@ @

3 3 ;$ ;$. .# #. . #= #=

Not Not-

• for

for-

• profits/cooperatives/mutual

profits/cooperatives/mutual societies societies

• '#

'# #' #'

% % 8 8 % % #$ #$ ## ## % % :$" :$" $$ $$ ##0+H" ##0+H"

Reasons for success Reasons for success

• #
• #
• ?$*+

?$*+ + +

% % + + $ $ % % 6+# 6+#

• %

% 6+ 6+

• ,$#

,$# +" +" +" +") )$ $

• %

% 133 133

• %

% $ $ % % ### ### # # % % 4#+"$D 4#+"$D ##++D ##++D % % 4+" 4+" ##$ ##$

• >$#+##

>$#+##

• &#$$

&#$$

• ,##+$3#

,##+$3# #*+$ #*+$

% % #** #** +$ +$

• 7

7

Principles are playing out in Principles are playing out in New Economy New Economy

• ##+

##+

• $#

$#

• ,3

,3

Implication Implication

• !$

!$ ## ##

• '$+$$$#

'$+$$$# " "

• %

% 1#,->3# 1#,->3# $#$# $#$# 3 3

• :$D#$#+

:$D#$#+. .

• $"D
• $"D

#21# #21# >#$> >#$>

Joseph E. Stiglitz Joseph E. Stiglitz