JAKE POLLACK NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY STRUCTURAL OPTION COLLEGE - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
jake pollack
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

JAKE POLLACK NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY STRUCTURAL OPTION COLLEGE - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Nov 12, 2022 307 likes •658 views

JAKE POLLACK NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY STRUCTURAL OPTION COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK AE 897G SENIOR THESIS PRESENTATION OUTLINE INTRODUCTION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION PURPOSE AND FEATURES EXISTING

slide-1
SLIDE 1

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

JAKE POLLACK

STRUCTURAL OPTION AE 897G – SENIOR THESIS

slide-2
SLIDE 2

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PURPOSE AND FEATURES

FUNCTION: ACADEMY SCALE: 1,000,000 SF

$656 MILLION

CONSTRUCTION: DESIGN-BID-BUILD

OCTOBER 2010 – DECEMBER 2013 150’ 536’ 95’

INTRODUCTION

MAPS.GOOGLE.COM

slide-3
SLIDE 3

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PROJECT TEAM

OWNER: NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF

CONSTRUCTION AND DESIGN

CONSTRUCTION: TURNER CONSTRUCTION ARCHITECT: PERKINS + WILL STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: ROBERT SILMAN ASSOCIATES MEPF ENGINEER: WSP FLACK + KURTZ

INTRODUCTION

slide-4
SLIDE 4

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

EXISTING FOUNDATION EXISTING FLOOR SYSTEM

THE EXISTING SYSTEM

EXISTING FRAMING SYSTEM

15’ 30’ 30’

slide-5
SLIDE 5

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

X-FRAME

THE EXISTING SYSTEM

slide-6
SLIDE 6

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

Y

  • FRAME

THE EXISTING SYSTEM

slide-7
SLIDE 7

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THE PROBLEM

TYPICAL EXISTING MOMENT CONNECTION TYPICAL EXISTING HSS CBF CONNECTION

slide-8
SLIDE 8

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THE PROBLEM

TYPICAL EXISTING HSS CBF CONNECTION TYPICAL EXISTING MOMENT CONNECTION

slide-9
SLIDE 9

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THE SOLUTION

X-FRAME

slide-10
SLIDE 10

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THE SOLUTION

Y

  • FRAME
slide-11
SLIDE 11

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THE SOLUTION

ARCHITECTURE CONSTRUCTABILITY

  • MATERIAL COST (SHAPES)
  • FABRICATION SCHEDULING AND COST
  • LABOR SCHEDULING AND COST
slide-12
SLIDE 12

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS X-FRAME THESIS X-FRAME DETAIL

CONCENTRICALLY BRACED CONNECTIONS

INCLUDES:

  • BEAM: W30X99
  • COLUMN: W14X370
  • BRACE: 2L4X4X½”
  • GUSSET: ¾”

THE THESIS REDESIGN

slide-13
SLIDE 13

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS X-FRAME LOAD PATH

CONCENTRICALLY BRACED CONNECTIONS

THE THESIS REDESIGN

THESIS X-FRAME

slide-14
SLIDE 14

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS Y

  • FRAME DETAIL

CHEVRON BRACED CONNECTIONS

INCLUDES:

  • BEAM: W24X76
  • STIFFENERS: ¾”
  • BRACE: W14X82”
  • GUSSET: ¾”

THE THESIS REDESIGN

THESIS Y

  • FRAME
slide-15
SLIDE 15

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS Y

  • FRAME DETAIL

CHEVRON BRACED LOAD PATH

THE THESIS REDESIGN

THESIS Y

  • FRAME
slide-16
SLIDE 16

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS Y

  • FRAME DETAIL

DIAGONAL BRACED CONNECTIONS

INCLUDES:

  • BEAM: W24X76
  • COLUMN: W14X370
  • BRACE: W14X82”
  • GUSSET: ¾”

THE THESIS REDESIGN

THESIS Y

  • FRAME
slide-17
SLIDE 17

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS Y

  • FRAME DETAIL

DIAGONAL BRACED LOAD PATH

THE THESIS REDESIGN

THESIS Y

  • FRAME
slide-18
SLIDE 18

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

ARCHITECTURE

DESIGN INTEGRATION

slide-19
SLIDE 19

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

ARCHITECTURE

ORIGINAL NORTH ELEVATION THESIS NORTH ELEVATION

slide-20
SLIDE 20

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

ARCHITECTURE

ORIGINAL SOUTH ELEVATION THESIS SOUTH ELEVATION

slide-21
SLIDE 21

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

ARCHITECTURE

THESIS DESIGN WINDOW ELEVATION ORIGINAL DESIGN WINDOW ELEVATION

3D ELEVATION

15’ 30’ 15’

slide-22
SLIDE 22

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

ARCHITECTURE

3D ELEVATION

slide-23
SLIDE 23

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

ARCHITECTURE

CONSTRUCTABILITY 3D ELEVATION

slide-24
SLIDE 24

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

COST AND SCHEDULE

FABRICATION, LABOR AND MATERIAL NEEDS

slide-25
SLIDE 25

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

COST AND SCHEDULE

FABRICATION AND LABOR MAN-HOURS

slide-26
SLIDE 26

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

COST STUDY

ORIGINAL COST THESIS COST

slide-27
SLIDE 27

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

COST STUDY

ORIGINAL COST THESIS COST

slide-28
SLIDE 28

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

COST AND SCHEDULE

ORIGINAL DESIGN

TOTAL SYSTEM COST: $1,606,325.97 LABOR: 4,116 MAN HOURS

THESIS REDESIGN

TOTAL SYSTEM COST: $827,408.92 LABOR: 1,320 MAN HOURS

slide-29
SLIDE 29

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

THESIS REDESIGN

PERCENTAGE OF TIME SAVED: 68% PERCENTAGE OF COST SAVINGS: 48% TOTAL TIME SAVED: 2,796 HOURS TOTAL COST SAVINGS: $778,917.05

COST AND SCHEDULE

slide-30
SLIDE 30

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

MOMENT CONCENTRICALLY BRACED X-FRAME

slide-31
SLIDE 31

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

HSS CONCENTRICALLY BRACED W-SHAPED CHEVRON BRACED Y

  • FRAME
slide-32
SLIDE 32

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

ORIGINAL NORTH ELEVATION THESIS NORTH ELEVATION

slide-33
SLIDE 33

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

CONCLUSION

THESIS REDESIGN

TIME PERCENTAGE SAVINGS: 68% COST PERCENTAGE SAVINGS: 48% TIME TOTAL SAVINGS: 2,796 HOURS TOTAL COST SAVINGS: $778,917.05

slide-34
SLIDE 34

NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY

COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

QUESTIONS

SPECIAL THANKS TO: