JAKE POLLACK NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY STRUCTURAL OPTION COLLEGE - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

JAKE POLLACK NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY STRUCTURAL OPTION COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK AE 897G – SENIOR THESIS

PRESENTATION OUTLINE INTRODUCTION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION PURPOSE AND FEATURES EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM FUNCTION: ACADEMY 150’ PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION SCALE: 1,000,000 SF THESIS REDESIGN $656 MILLION ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT CONSTRUCTION: DESIGN-BID-BUILD MAPS.GOOGLE.COM COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT 536’ OCTOBER 2010 – DECEMBER 2013 CONCLUSION 95’

PRESENTATION OUTLINE INTRODUCTION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION PROJECT TEAM EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM OWNER : NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF CONSTRUCTION AND DESIGN PROBLEM STATEMENT CONSTRUCTION: TURNER CONSTRUCTION PROBLEM SOLUTION ARCHITECT : PERKINS + WILL THESIS REDESIGN STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: ROBERT SILMAN ASSOCIATES ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT MEPF ENGINEER : WSP FLACK + KURTZ COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE EXISTING SYSTEM NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK EXISTING FRAMING EXISTING FLOOR SYSTEM EXISTING FOUNDATION INTRODUCTION SYSTEM EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN 15’ ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT 30’ COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT 30’ CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE EXISTING SYSTEM NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK X-FRAME INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE EXISTING SYSTEM NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK Y -FRAME INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE PROBLEM NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK TYPICAL EXISTING INTRODUCTION TYPICAL EXISTING MOMENT HSS CBF EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM CONNECTION CONNECTION PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE PROBLEM NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK TYPICAL EXISTING INTRODUCTION TYPICAL EXISTING MOMENT HSS CBF EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM CONNECTION CONNECTION PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE SOLUTION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK X-FRAME INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE SOLUTION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION Y -FRAME THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE SOLUTION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK ARCHITECTURE INTRODUCTION CONSTRUCTABILITY EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM • MATERIAL COST (SHAPES) PROBLEM STATEMENT • FABRICATION SCHEDULING AND COST PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN • LABOR SCHEDULING AND COST ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE THESIS REDESIGN NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK THESIS X-FRAME INTRODUCTION THESIS X-FRAME DETAIL CONCENTRICALLY BRACED CONNECTIONS EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM INCLUDES: PROBLEM STATEMENT BEAM: W30X99 • PROBLEM SOLUTION COLUMN: W14X370 • • BRACE: 2L4X4X½” THESIS REDESIGN GUSSET: ¾” • ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE THESIS REDESIGN NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK THESIS X-FRAME INTRODUCTION THESIS X-FRAME LOAD PATH CONCENTRICALLY BRACED CONNECTIONS EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE THESIS REDESIGN NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK THESIS Y -FRAME INTRODUCTION THESIS Y -FRAME DETAIL CHEVRON BRACED CONNECTIONS EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT INCLUDES: BEAM: W24X76 • PROBLEM SOLUTION • STIFFENERS: ¾” BRACE: W14X82” • THESIS REDESIGN • GUSSET: ¾” ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE THESIS REDESIGN NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK THESIS Y -FRAME INTRODUCTION THESIS Y -FRAME DETAIL CHEVRON BRACED LOAD PATH EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE THESIS REDESIGN NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK THESIS Y -FRAME INTRODUCTION THESIS Y -FRAME DETAIL DIAGONAL BRACED EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM CONNECTIONS PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION INCLUDES: BEAM: W24X76 • THESIS REDESIGN • COLUMN: W14X370 • BRACE: W14X82” ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT GUSSET: ¾” • COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE THE THESIS REDESIGN NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK THESIS Y -FRAME INTRODUCTION THESIS Y -FRAME DETAIL DIAGONAL BRACED EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM LOAD PATH PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE ARCHITECTURE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK DESIGN INTEGRATION INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE ARCHITECTURE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK ORIGINAL NORTH ELEVATION INTRODUCTION THESIS NORTH ELEVATION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE ARCHITECTURE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK ORIGINAL SOUTH ELEVATION INTRODUCTION THESIS SOUTH ELEVATION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE ARCHITECTURE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK 3D ELEVATION ORIGINAL DESIGN WINDOW ELEVATION INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM 15’ PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION 30’ THESIS DESIGN WINDOW ELEVATION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT 15’ COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE ARCHITECTURE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK 3D ELEVATION INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE ARCHITECTURE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK 3D ELEVATION CONSTRUCTABILITY INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE COST AND SCHEDULE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK FABRICATION, LABOR AND MATERIAL NEEDS INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE COST AND SCHEDULE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK FABRICATION AND LABOR MAN-HOURS INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE COST STUDY NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK ORIGINAL COST THESIS COST INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE COST STUDY NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK ORIGINAL COST THESIS COST INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE COST AND SCHEDULE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION THESIS REDESIGN ORIGINAL DESIGN EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM TOTAL SYSTEM COST: $1,606,325.97 TOTAL SYSTEM COST: $827,408.92 PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION LABOR: 4,116 MAN HOURS LABOR: 1,320 MAN HOURS THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE COST AND SCHEDULE NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION THESIS REDESIGN EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PERCENTAGE OF TIME SAVED: 68% PERCENTAGE OF COST SAVINGS: 48% PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION TOTAL TIME SAVED: 2,796 HOURS TOTAL COST SAVINGS: $778,917.05 THESIS REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION

PRESENTATION OUTLINE CONCLUSION NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK INTRODUCTION X-FRAME EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION MOMENT THESIS REDESIGN CONCENTRICALLY ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT BRACED COST AND SCHEDULE IMPACT CONCLUSION