improvements to the co simulation interface for
play

Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation 45th Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society (IECON) 15th 17th October 2019, Lisbon Paper: LD-029874 1 Improvements to the


  1. Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation 45th Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society (IECON) 15th – 17th October 2019, Lisbon Paper: LD-029874 1 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation M.Sc. Steffen Vogel Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  2. Contents ■ ERIGrid Transnational Access Exchange ■ The concept of Geographically Distributed Co-simulation ■ System Architecture ■ Test case description ■ Main contributions 1. Improved calculation of Dynamic Phasor Coefficients by moving window average 2. Investigation of IETF RTP protocol for streaming real-time simulation data 3. Fidelity Improvements / Bug Fixes 4. CoSiF – A reusable library for distributed real-time simulation ■ Future plans 2 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  3. Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation (GD-RTS) ■ A single digital real-time simulation spanning multiple simulators / simulation Subsystem 1 Subsystem 2 sites Digital ■ Motivation Real-Time Simulator Subsystem 3 ≡ Large-scale system-level simulatoins (DRTS) ≡ Exchange of Knowledge, Human- and Hardware Ressources From monolithic RTS to GD-RTS ≡ Overcome constraints caused by data confidientiality Subsystem 2 Subsystem 1 Comm. network DRTS 1 DRTS 2 Subsystem 3 DRTS 3 3 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  4. Background / Motivation ■ Global Real-time SuperLab: ≡ 8 sites, 10 simulators, 8 links ■ Simple ITM or P/Q, Vrms, f Interface Algorithms ■ Long setup time ■ Huge variations in network quality M. Stevic et al., “Virtual integration of laboratories over long distance for real-time co-simulation of power systems,” in IECON 2016 - 42nd Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society , 2016, pp. 6717–6721. 4 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  5. System Architecture ■ 2 Labs: ≡ 2 RTDS Simulators ≡ 2 VILLASnode Gateways ≡ Decentral / Fully-meshed VPN for optimal point-to-point connection with lowest latency 5 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  6. Network Connectivity ■ National Research and Education Networks (NRENs) ≡ DFN, SURFnet, GÉANT ■ Mean Round-trip time: 𝟐𝟑 𝒏𝒕 ■ Routing hops: 𝟐𝟒 ■ Sending rate: ≤ 𝟐𝟏 𝒍𝑸𝒍𝒖/𝒕 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 Probability 0.5 500 Packets/sec 1000 Packets/sec 2000 Packets/sec 0.4 5000 Packets/sec 10000 Packets/sec 0.3 15000 Packets/sec 17000 Packets/sec 0.2 20000 Packets/sec 0.1 0 10 15 20 25 30 RTT [ms] 6 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  7. Real-time Transport Protocol (RTP) ■ Different co-sim links vary significantly 1 1 1 1 r r r r 8 16 2 4 in quality of serivce (QoS) sending rate [kHz] 3 ■ Adaptive adjustment of communication parameters is helpful 2 ■ Additive Increase – 1 Packet Loss Multiplicate Decrease (AIMD) 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 10 6 -6.2249 time [s] Sequence Difference -6.22492 ■ Discontinuties in sending rate cause -6.22494 frequency disturbances in simulation -6.22496 -6.22498 ■ Only useful for initial estimation, not 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 during live simulation 60.02 Frequency [Hz] 60 59.98 59.96 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 Time [s] 7 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  8. Test Scenario & Methodology ■ Simple scenario helped debugging and understanding ■ 3 Stages: monolithic, decoupled, distributed 13.8/230 kV 230/115 kV ~ Line 1 Line 2 Load 2 Load 1 a) Monolithic Model 13.8/230 kV 230/115 kV ~ ~ Load 2 Load 1 SS1 SS2 b) Decoupled / Distributed Model 8 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  9. Dynamic Phasor Interface Algorithm (DP-IA) Window Mean Mean Mean . . . . . . Mean Mean Calculation of Dynamic Phasor Coefficients from Time-domain Signals. 9 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  10. Dynamic Phasor Interface Algorithm (DP-IA) Magnitude Cartesian to Phase Polar . . . . . . Magnitude Cartesian to Phase Polar Reconstruction of Time-domain Signals from Dynamic Phasor coefficients. 10 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  11. Simulation Results: Instantaneous V/I ■ Test cases: ≡ Voltage Source in SS1 (left) ����������� ���������������� ����������� ����������� ����������� ��� ≡ Change of magnitude, freuquency, phase ��� �� ■ No error in steady-state � ���� ■ Delayed update of ���� ≡ Voltage magnitude SS1 ����������� ������������ ����������� ����������� ����������� ��� (1/2 RTT) ≡ Current magnitude on left side ���� (1 RTT) � �� ����� ���� � ������� ������� � ������� ������� � 11 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  12. Simulation Results: P/Q RMS ■ Change of source magnitude in SS1 (left side) 20 Original 19 Dcpl. SS1 P [ M W] Dcpl. SS2 18 Dist. SS1 17 Dist. SS2 16 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2 8 7.5 Q [ M VAr] 7 6.5 6 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2 Time [s] 12 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  13. Limits of GD-RTS ■ Phase jump of 𝜌 of 𝑊 ./0 400 SS1 dcpl SS1 dist Original Voltage [kV] 200 SS2 dcpl SS2 dist 0 -200 0.34 0.36 0.38 0.4 0.42 0.44 0.46 0.1 0.05 Current [kA] 0 -0.05 -0.1 0.34 0.36 0.38 0.4 0.42 0.44 0.46 Time [s] 13 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  14. Fidelity Improvements I ■ Mismatch in DFT window length for 60 Hz systems ■ Fundamental period of 60 Hz is not evenly dividable by a 𝑈 . = 50 𝜈𝑡 time-step ■ Optimal Simulation Timestep: ■ Uneven time-steps might cause other issues in relation to synchronization of simulators 14 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  15. Fidelity Improvements II ■ Mismatch in active / reactive power due to internal time-step delays between network solution and control systems of DRTS ■ Phase compensation for controlled sources required Phase Compensation for Controlled Sources dp1_phase Mag 2* (pk) compensation_steps Freq + sin + t X 60.0 (rad) (Hz) AbsPhase X 2* X (rad) compensation dp1_mag recon_dp1 60.0 15 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  16. Usability Improvements ■ Use of GPS time (GTSYNC) to coordinate synchronized simulation start ≡ Alignment of measurements ≡ Synchronized reference phasors ■ Open problem for OPAL-RT systems 16 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  17. Co-Simulation Interface Library: „CoSiF ■ Re-usable library blocks for different: ≡ Interface Algorithms: Dynamic Phasors, PQ + 𝑊 /:. , 𝑔, 𝜚 ≡ Simulation Platforms: RTDS, OPAL+RT Subsystem D - SSD Subsystem H - SSH Processor Assignment Auto IN THIS SUBSYSTEM CONTROL AND MONITOR ssD_SRCBUS ssD_IFBUS fHYKxgK DOKHYPy x_ HdOHbDgg DOKHKKu x_ HyOYHYKd LINE CONSTANTS ssD_VsrcC ssD_VsrcA ssD_VsrcB ifH_phA ifH_phB ifH_phC ssD_TLINE T-LINE NAME CALCULATION BLOCK TLINE ssD_IAtlineSE ssD_IAtlineRE D D GEN ssD_IBtlineSE ssD_IBtlineRE Co-sim interface H H vKOu ssD_ICtlineSE ssD_ICtlineRE Y Y A B C Dynamic Load RxxL dist_ssD_DLD ■ Open Source: GPLv3 ≡ https://fein-aachen.org/projects/cosif/ 17 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

  18. Future Plans ■ More tests with off-nominal frequencies at the interface ■ Ongoing ERIGrid Transnational Access with DTU Denmark ≡ Distributed-PHIL with Quasi Stationary Back-to-Back Converter ≡ Energy Based Metric (EBM) for error quantification ■ FPGA / PCIe-based DRTS interfaces ≡ Migration of DP-IA into VILLASnode 18 Improvements to the Co-simulation Interface for Geographically Distributed Real-time Simulation Steffen Vogel | 16.10.2019

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend


More recommend