IDENTITY BRANDING
The Effect of Packaging Design for Eco-Conscious Cleaning Products
- n Consumer Self-Expression
and Brand Identity
Tate Ragland
IDENTITY BRANDING The Effect of Packaging Design for Eco-Conscious - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
IDENTITY BRANDING The Effect of Packaging Design for Eco-Conscious Cleaning Products on Consumer Self-Expression and Brand Identity Tate Ragland the premise. Buyers adopt products, not just as consumer choices, but as conscious
The Effect of Packaging Design for Eco-Conscious Cleaning Products
and Brand Identity
Tate RaglandBuyers adopt products, not just as consumer choices, but as conscious expressions
Buyers adopt products and brands, not just as consumer choices, but as conscious and unconscious expressions of their identities.
FRAMEWORK
PRODUCTION OF IDENTITY
PACKAGE DESIGN
physical cognitive emotional social
BRAND IDENTITY
value propositions image
associations
CONSUMER IDENTITY
performing displaying creating
position track consume incorporate appropriate execute (Saren, 2007) (Aaker, 1996)SIGNIFICANCE 32%
eco-friendly household cleaners
meat
supplements eco-friendly fibers and apparel eco-friendly personal care items
RECENT GROWTH
(Meyers, 2008)What consumer and brand profiles can be developed from this investigation? How do packages reflect intangible attributes of consumer identity? How do packages communicate intangible attributes of brand identity to consumers? What are the roles of brand and consumer value propositions in the production of a visual language to communicate identity? Which physical elements of packaging have the most impact on brand and consumer identity?
GREEN WORKS™
■ Established in 2008 ■ Subsidiary brand of Clorox
BRAND STATEMENT: We learned there was a great deal of interest in natural cleaning products but that there were four big issues in the way: 1 When people tried natural cleaners, they were often disappointed – they found natural cleaners didn’t work as well as conventional cleaners; 2 Worse, natural cleaners were expensive, sometimes with a price premium of 100 percent compared to regular cleaners; 3 On top of that, natural cleaners were hard find, available mostly in specialty stores or perhaps online; 4 And people weren’t sure about all of the new brands they wereMETHOD™
■ Established in 2000 ■ Efficacy, Safety, Environment, Design, Fragrance
BRAND STATEMENT: At Method, we call ourselves “people against dirty.” Method isn’tSEVENTH GENERATION™
■ Established in 1989 ■ Self-described “socially responsible” company
BRAND STATEMENT: Seventh Generation is committed to becoming the world’s most trusted brand of authentic, safe, and environmentally-responsible products for a healthy home. For 20 years, the closely held Burlington, Vermont-based company has been at the forefront of a cultural change in consumer behavior and business ethics. Seventh Generation is a business that operates according to a new and different set of principles and values that in many ways are a marked departure from those long considered “traditional.”ONLINE QUESTIONNAIRE
(Robson, 2002; O'Leary, 2004)
■ questionnaire administered
■ participants solicited from
brand’s website ■ respondents were familiar with the brands and their packaging ■ data collected over two weeks in late January 2009
GREEN WORKS
19
METHOD
20
SEVENTH GENERATION
16 55 PARTICIPANTS
■ consumption practices ■ package design ■ brand perceptions ■ consumer self-expression ■ demographics (optional)
36 QUESTIONS
P a g e 1 GreenWorks GreenWorks GreenWorks GreenWorksPHOTO JOURNAL
(Collier & Collier, 1986)
20 PROMPTS
“items that represent your commitment to sustainable lifestyle practices” “cleaning products currently in your home” “branded packages that represent your identity in some way” 10 5 5
19 PARTICIPANTS
■ self-professed, eco-conscious consumers with an interest in sustainable lifestyle practices ■ ASU graduate student listserv ■ message boards at local
DIY PACKAGE DESIGN
(Sanders, 2000)
PACKAGE DESIGN KIT
■ 3 shape templates ■ 4 font styles ■ construction paper ■ markers ■ 50 images in five categories
11 PARTICIPANTS
■ recruited by “snowball” strategy ■ began with a core group of individuals very involved in local sustainability efforts ■ no formal design background ■ respondents were self-described "eco-conscious" consumers
CODE
SORT & CLUSTER
VISUALIZE
VALUES
What are the roles of brand and consumer value propositions in the production of a visual language to communicate identity?
Frequency of Value Propositions Connecting Packages and Consumer Identity:■ the visual language used by brands in their packaging designs determines consumer understanding of brand value propositions ■ overlapping brand and consumer values play a strong role in the incorporation of brands into consumer identity
PRODUCTION OF IDENTITY
PACKAGE DESIGN physical cognitive emotional social BRAND IDENTITY value propositions image■ the visual language used by brands in their packaging designs determines consumer understanding of brand value propositions ■ overlapping brand and consumer values play a strong role in the incorporation of brands into consumer identity
PRODUCTION OF IDENTITY
PACKAGE DESIGN physical cognitive emotional social BRAND IDENTITY value propositions imagefair trade practices ■ US company ■ ethical treatment of workers ■ local business ■ avoid animal testing ■
Brand Values Connection
nostalgic ■ happy ■ refreshed ■ responsible ■ proud ■ confident ■
Emotional Connection
sleek ■ simple ■ color ■ graphics ■ funky ■ classic ■
Form Connection
easy to grasp ■ efficient ■ effective ■ safe ■
Functional Connection
PHYSICAL ATTRIBUTES
Which physical elements of packaging have the most impact on brand and consumer identity?
Green Works Method Seventh Generation
■ the attributes that reflect brand promises: simple, honest, natural
PRODUCTION OF IDENTITY
PACKAGE DESIGN physical cognitive emotional social BRAND IDENTITY value propositions imageBRAND IDENTITY
How do packages communicate intangible attributes of brand identity to consumers?
Green Works Method Seventh Generation
Package Attributes That Communicate Brand Identity:■ attributes are interpreted by consumers and those interpretations are incorporated into the
PRODUCTION OF IDENTITY
PACKAGE DESIGN physical cognitive emotional social BRAND IDENTITY value propositions imageCONSUMER IDENTITY
How do packages reflect intangible attributes of consumer identity?
Green Works Method Seventh Generation
consumer identity...
■ aspects of consumer identity are reflected in the package attributes that communicate overlapping brand value propositions
PRODUCTION OF IDENTITY
PACKAGE DESIGN physical cognitive emotional social BRAND IDENTITY value propositions imagePROFILES
What consumer and brand profiles can be developed from this investigation?
ROUTINE
■ high level of concern for product function ■ generally low level of engagement in eco-lifestyle practices ■ just want to get the job done ■ do not see products as a reflection of their identity ■ see cleaners as inconsequential purchases
PROFILES
TASK-ORIENTED
■ moderate level of concern for product function and aesthetics ■ generally high level of engagement in eco-lifestyle practices ■ have a strong concern for value and safety ■ do moderate product research ■ tend to overlook or ignore product aesthetics
PROFILES
DISCERNING
■ high level of concern for product aesthetics ■ generally high level of engagement in eco-lifestyle practices ■ research products ■ have a clear idea of what they want ■ see products as reflection
■ take their purchases seriously
PROFILES
BRAND SNOB
■ high level of concern for product aesthetics ■ generally low level of engagement in eco-lifestyle practices ■ do little product research ■ will pay more for aesthetics ■ concerned with looks over function
PROFILES
PROFILES
BRANDS
GREEN WORKS™
METHOD™
SEVENTH GENERATION™
INSIGHTS
simple product = simple design (attributes) packages that appeal to specific "types" risk alienating other consumers consumers want to be responsible, but many don't know how—packaging can educate form attributes can send the wrong message, and should be carefully considered
PACKAGES
"Packages that have an opaque bottle make me a little bit suspicious."
each brand culture has a unique relationship with packaging and design consumers expect brands to “walk the talk” consumers have diverse opinions about the importance of brands to their identity brands need to understand consumers as individual identities, not just as consumers many eco-conscious consumers value human safety over harm caused to the environment brand ownership is beyond company control
INSIGHTS
BRAND CULTURES
"We're concerned about what we expose ourselves and
many shoppers consume eco-products in
consumers want to trust brands but are skeptical—brands need to prove themselves “eco” products mean different things to different people—expanded community involvement is needed to increase understanding truly sustainable brands must move beyond function to create enduring relationships
INSIGHTS
FUTURE IMPLICATIONS
"People have good intentions about things that are organic or sustainable, but most people don't really know what that means."
DIY opportunities for variation:
■ larger sample size ■ more and/or different images ■ groups or pairs ■ design for an actual product ■ eliminate shape templates ■ interview throughout the processPhoto Journal areas for variation:
■ conduct in-person ■ use in combination with interviews ■ more even gender distribution ■ compare against non eco-consumersINSIGHTS
METHODS
this research... provides evidence-based insights into consumer/brand relationships shines a light on the importance of packaging, particularly for eco-conscious products attempts to address larger issues of consumer culture identity and consumption develops and tests new and different methods for brand research
WRAP UP
SIGNIFICANCE
Collect data regarding consumer identity in both direct and indirect ways (what consumers say about themselves versus how they present themselves). Understand the individual challenges
different perspectives as possible. Identities are constantly changing, be prepared to work in an iterative cycle. Be clear about what is meant by “packaging” and “brand.” Acknowledge the limitations of the methods, but be willing to try new and different approaches.
REFLECTION
RECOMMENDATIONS