Heritage Advisory Committee Virtual Meeting June 18th, 2020 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
ASI Heritage Advisory Committee Virtual Meeting June 18th, 2020 Archaeological Services Inc. 528 Bathurst Street Toronto, Ontario M5S 2P9 Town of East Gwillimbury Heritage Register Review ASI Introductions Project Objectives, Goals
ASI
Archaeological Services Inc. 528 Bathurst Street Toronto, Ontario M5S 2P9
ASI
ASI
Manager and Senior Cultural Heritage Specialist
Senior Project Manager and Public Engagement Lead
Project Manager and Cultural Heritage Specialist
Technical Lead and Heritage Register Advisor
ASI
ASI
Committee to focus their efforts on heritage education, outreach, designation, and other community cultural events, rather than on the need to continually process removal requests
ASI
ASI
ASI
ASI
ASI
ASI
Review of primary and secondary sources Review of historical mapping Identification of significant people Identification of key historical themes with significant dates and events Development of a historical narrative for East Gwillimbury
ASI
Are rooted in O.Reg. 9/06 and can be used to identify common qualities and characteristics of:
Period Statement of Significance Associated Building Types Eligibility Standards Character Defining/ Associative Features Integrity Considerations
ASI
Not recommended for removal Recommended for evaluation Recommended for removal Part IV Designated Cemetery Associated with the Sharon Temple National Historic Site Non-designated property and is not a ‘real’ property asset Property has recently been denied a removal request Non-designated property with sufficient integrity Non-designated property that is not visible from the ROW (integrity unknown)
With Town’s photos
Non-designated property with insufficient integrity or with conflicting information in the property file Duplicate entries or incomplete location information
integrity to determine if a property had sufficient integrity to demonstrate its potential or known cultural heritage value
not recommended for removal from the Heritage Register based on level of heritage protection, type, and/or historical associations
document properties from the public right-of-way
ASI
rooted in O.Reg. 9/06 and consider potential design/physical, historical/associative, and contextual values
with individualized information added as needed, in order to be consistent across all properties. The evaluation methodology does not constitute a complete evaluation against all O.Reg. 9/06 criteria. It has been developed to address key indicators of value to ensure that consistent and clear reasons for inclusion on the Heritage Register are expressed.
ASI
Properties considered to meet the evaluation criteria developed as part of this project:
expressed in the historical context statements
the potential or known heritage value of its associated theme and building type
ASI
Not recommended for removal Recommended for removal by staff Recommended for removal Part IV Designated 12 Cemetery 15 Associated with the Sharon Temple National Historic Site 7 Non-designated property and is not a ‘real’ property asset 2 Property has recently been denied a removal request 3 Meets evaluation criteria 280 8 Does not meet evaluation criteria 93 Evaluation could not be completed 2 14 Property with insufficient integrity/demolished 8 Property with conflicting information in the property file (e.g., address on the Register does not match the property description and/or photo) 10 Duplicate entries or incomplete location information 9 Total 321 22 120 % of current Heritage Register (463) 69% 5% 26%
ASI
ASI
ASI
ASI
ASI
ASI
Register as outlined in the Screening and Evaluation Results table
is recommended that HAC consider a Heritage Conservation District study for the area at a future date
designation
ASI
East Gwillimbury, 1811 (Archives of Ontario)