Get the Lead Out David G. Johnson, CHMM-CP Paul R. Galdes, PE Don - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
get the lead out
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Get the Lead Out David G. Johnson, CHMM-CP Paul R. Galdes, PE Don - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Mar 06, 2024 165 likes •735 views

Get the Lead Out David G. Johnson, CHMM-CP Paul R. Galdes, PE Don DeVries, PE GE T T HE L E AD OUT MODE RAT OR: PAT RICK WAT E RMAN, CIT Y MANAGE R, CIT Y OF HUDSONVIL L E PRE SE NT E RS: PAUL R. GAL DE S, PE , F L

slide-1
SLIDE 1

Get the Lead Out

David G. Johnson, CHMM-CP Paul R. Galdes, PE Don DeVries, PE

slide-2
SLIDE 2

GE T T HE L E AD OUT

MODE RAT OR:

PAT RICK WAT E RMAN, CIT Y MANAGE R, CIT Y OF HUDSONVIL L E

PRE SE NT E RS:

PAUL

  • R. GAL

DE S, PE , F L E I S & VANDE NBRINK DAVID G. JOHNSON, CHMM-CP, F L E I S & VANDE NBRINK DON J. DE VRIE S, PE , F L E I S & VANDE NBRINK

slide-3
SLIDE 3

AGE NDA

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.

L e a d & Munic ipa l Wa te r Syste ms

3.

E stima te d Pro b le m Sta te & Na tio nwide

4.

E PA & MDE Q Rule s

5.

Do e s My Co mmunity Ha ve L e a d I n T he Syste m?

6.

Ho w Are Othe r Co mmunitie s De a ling With L e a d?

7.

De ve lo ping a n Ac tio n Pla n

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

slide-4
SLIDE 4
slide-5
SLIDE 5

WHE N I N ROME

DON’T

DO AS T HE ROMANS DI D!

slide-6
SLIDE 6
slide-7
SLIDE 7

PHYSICAL IMPACT OF L E AD ON HUMANS

slide-8
SLIDE 8

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.L

e ad & Munic ipal Wate r Syste ms

3.

E stima te d Pro b le m Sta te & Na tio nwide

4.

E PA & MDE Q Rule s

5.

Do e s My Co mmunity Ha ve L e a d I n T he Syste m?

6.

Ho w Are Othe r Co mmunitie s De a ling With L e a d?

7.

De ve lo ping a n Ac tio n Pla n

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

AGE NDA

slide-9
SLIDE 9

MUNICIPAL WAT E R SYST E MS ARE A COMPL E X NE T WORK

slide-10
SLIDE 10

WAT E R SOURCE & T RE AT ME NT T YPE

  • No t a ‘ so urc e ’ o f le a d, ho we ve r,
  • Wa te r c he mistry a ffe c ts Co rro sivity thro ug ho ut distrib utio n.
  • T

re a tme nt ne e ds to c o nside r po lypho spha te s to pre ve nt le a c hing

slide-11
SLIDE 11

DI ST RI BUT I ON SYST E M

L e a d so urc e s ma y inc lude :

  • Se rvic e le a ds
  • Go o se ne c ks
  • Plumb ing / piping
  • Ho use ho ld fixture s
  • So lde r & flux
slide-12
SLIDE 12

WHAT ARE T HE I SSUE S F OR MUNI CI PAL I T I E S?

slide-13
SLIDE 13

POL I CY I SSUE S

At wha t po int do e s the

Public wa te r syste m

b e c o me the

Priva te wa te r se rvic e ?

slide-14
SLIDE 14

F I NANCI AL I SSUE S

  • Ho w to de a l with pub lic le a d se rvic e s?
  • Ho w to de a l with priva te le a d se rvic e s?
  • Do yo u de a l with inte rna l plumb ing & fixture s?
slide-15
SLIDE 15

SAMPL I NG / T E ST I NG I SSUE S

E PA limit is 15 ppb I nc o nsiste nc ie s in sa mpling , fo r e xa mple , a t a sing le ho me in F lint:

  • Offic ia l Virg inia T

e c h study re c o rde d 158 ppb

  • City te st a t o ne ho me 397 ppb
  • Virg inia T

e c h te st a t sa me ho me 200  13,200 ppb

slide-16
SLIDE 16

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.

L e a d & Munic ipa l Wa te r Syste ms

  • 3. E

stimate d Proble m State & Nationwide

4.

E PA & MDE Q Rule s

5.

Do e s My Co mmunity Ha ve L e a d I n T he Syste m?

6.

Ho w Are Othe r Co mmunitie s De a ling With L e a d?

7.

De ve lo ping a n Ac tio n Pla n

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

AGE NDA

slide-17
SLIDE 17

E ST I MAT E D PROBL E M ST AT E & NAT I ONWI DE

  • E

ng ine e ring Stud y:

  • F

lint – a s hig h a s $216 millio n

  • Wa shing to n DC – spe nt $400 millio n o n a b o ut ha lf; a b a ndo ne d pro g ra m
  • Curre ntly:
  • L

a nsing – spe nt $42 millio n sinc e 2004

  • Re pla c ing 13,500 se rvic e s fro m ma in to b a se me nt/ ho use
  • Study:
  • AWWA e stima te s:
  • 460,000 le a d se rvic e s ne e d to b e re pla c e d in MI

(o nly surpa sse d b y OH & I L )

  • T

he US – a s hig h a s $300 b illio n

slide-18
SLIDE 18

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.

L e a d & Munic ipa l Wa te r Syste ms

3.

E stima te d Pro b le m Sta te & Na tio nwid e

  • 4. E

PA & MDE Q Rule s

5.

Do e s My Co mmunity Ha ve L e a d I n T he Syste m?

6.

Ho w Are Othe r Co mmunitie s De a ling With L e a d?

7.

De ve lo ping a n Ac tio n Pla n

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

AGE NDA

slide-19
SLIDE 19

SE RVI CE L I NE S & SAMPL I NG

L e a d- F re e De finition Unde r the Sa fe Drinking Wa te r Ac t (Ame nd. 1986)

Curre nt rule s pro hib it insta lla tio n o r re pa ir o f a ny:

  • Pipe
  • F

itting

  • F

ixture

  • So lde r
  • F

lux T ha t is no t “le a d fre e ”

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-20
SLIDE 20

L E AD & COPPE R RUL E (L CR) SAMPL I NG PROT OCOL

  • Se le c tio n T

ie r 1, 2 o r 3 site s

  • Sta g na tio n o f a t le a st 6 ho urs
  • K

itc he n o r b a thro o m sinks

  • 1 lite r sa mple size
  • F

irst dra w sa mple

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-21
SLIDE 21

SAMPL I NG I SSUE S

  • 1 L

ite r sa mple size

  • I

nte rio r plumb ing o nly

  • F

a uc e ts

  • Pa rtic ula te s
  • Ae ra to r/ sc re e n tra pping pa rtic ula te s
  • Bre a king fre e fro m inte rio r plumb ing
  • E

xc e ssive Sta g na tio n

  • Be a r L

a ke – 7 Mo nths

  • I

nte ntio na l Sa mple Sa b o ta g e

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-22
SLIDE 22

MARCH 2016 CHANGE S

  • No pre -flushing
  • Sta nda rd Use
  • Do n’ t re mo ve a e ra to rs
  • Wide Mo uth Bo ttle s
  • Co nfirma tio n o f T

ie r Sta tus

  • L

e a d g o o se ne c ks a re no w T ie r 1 site s

  • E

mpha sis o n the pub lic he a lth o b lig a tio n to no tify/ e duc a te individua l c usto me rs whe n the re a re hig h re sults re g a rdle ss o f the c o mplia nc e sta tus

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-23
SLIDE 23

POT E NT I AL CHANGE S

  • Re q uire d fo llo w up fo r a ny le a d sa mple s > 15 ppb
  • No tific a tio n o f e a c h re side nc e o f pre c a utio ns
  • No tific a tio n o f DHHS
  • Ma nda te Co mmunity Wa te r Supplie s (CWS) Re pla c e E

ntire Se rvic e L ine

  • No lo ng e r to c urb sto p
  • Give CWS le g a l c o ntro l o f e ntire se rvic e line

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-24
SLIDE 24

POT E NT I AL CHANGE S

  • Po te ntia l Sta te Cla rific a tio ns o f L

e a d & Co ppe r Rule 28 (L CR) Prio r to E PA

  • Optima l Co rro sio n Co ntro l T

re a tme nt E va lua tio n (OCCT ) fo r a ny so urc e c ha ng e

  • > 5 ppb a c tio ns
  • DWRF

c ha ng e s fo r le a d se rvic e re pla c e me nts

  • Co nsume r ta x c re dits fo r fixture re pla c e me nts

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-25
SLIDE 25

OWNE RSHI P I SSUE S

  • I

nitia l E PA Po sitio n

  • Co urt De c isio n
  • So me CWS L

ia b ilitie s:

  • L

a wn & Pa ve me nts

  • F
  • unda tio n
  • I

nte rna l Plumb ing

  • So me E

xc e ptio ns

  • L

BWL

Slide pro vide d b y MDE Q

slide-26
SLIDE 26

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.

L e a d & Munic ipa l Wa te r Syste ms

3.

E stima te d Pro b le m Sta te & Na tio nwide

4.

E PA & MDE Q Rule s

  • 5. Doe s My Community Have L

e ad In T he Syste m?

6.

Ho w Are Othe r Co mmunitie s De a ling With L e a d?

7.

De ve lo ping a n Ac tio n Pla n

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

AGE NDA

slide-27
SLIDE 27

RE VI E W AGE OF T HE SYST E M

  • L

e a d se rvic e s we re c o mmo n b e fo re the e a rly 1950’ s

  • L

e a d g o o se ne c ks - with a nd witho ut le a d se rvic e s b e fo re e a rly 1950’ s

  • L

e a d fre e so lde r a nd flux no t b a nne d until 1986 E PA Sa fe Wa te r Drinking Ac t Ame ndme nt.

  • Go o se ne c ks le ft in pla c e
slide-28
SLIDE 28

L E AD PI PE SCRAT CH T E ST

slide-29
SLIDE 29

WHAT PHYSI CAL DAT A DO WE HAVE ?

  • Orig ina l Co nstruc tio n Dra wing s
  • Old Ca rds
  • Ma ps
  • Sa mpling Re sults (pro pe r sa mpling me tho ds)
  • Sta ff / Ope ra to r histo ric a l kno wle dg e
  • Ag e o f wa te rma in
slide-30
SLIDE 30

HAVE WE E VE R DUG UP A L E AD SE RVI CE ?

  • Did We Ma p / L
  • c a te it?
  • Wha t ne ig hb o rho o ds mig ht b e a ffe c te d?
  • Ba se d o n a g e , physic a l e vide nc e & sa mple s
slide-31
SLIDE 31

WHAT ARE YOUR L E AD RE SUL T S?

  • Do we ha ve e le va te d le ve ls?
  • 5 ppb c o nc e rn
  • 15 ppb E

PA L imit

  • Are the y c o nc e ntra te d in c e rta in a re a s?
slide-32
SLIDE 32

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.

L e a d & Munic ipa l Wa te r Syste ms

3.

E stima te d Pro b le m Sta te & Na tio nwide

4.

E PA & MDE Q Rule s

5.

Do e s My Co mmunity Ha ve L e a d I n T he Syste m?

  • 6. How Ar

e Othe r Communitie s De aling With L e ad?

7.

De ve lo ping a n Ac tio n Pla n

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

AGE NDA

slide-33
SLIDE 33

CASE ST UDY:

L ANSI NG BWL

  • Munic ipa lly-o wne d utility
  • Arc hive s
  • F

a irly a c c ura te re c o rd o f se rvic e line ma te ria ls

  • Aske d c usto me rs to se lf-ide ntify L

SL s in 2004

  • Pub lic E

duc a tio n

  • Bro c hure s, a rtic le s, b ill stuffe rs
  • Ope n Ho use s
  • So c ia l Me dia – inc re a se d sha ring po te ntia l
slide-34
SLIDE 34
  • Co st
  • $3,500 c o o rdina te d with o the r pro je c ts
  • $6,500 a lo ne

CASE ST UDY:

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT

slide-35
SLIDE 35

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-36
SLIDE 36

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-37
SLIDE 37

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-38
SLIDE 38

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-39
SLIDE 39

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-40
SLIDE 40

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-41
SLIDE 41

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-42
SLIDE 42

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-43
SLIDE 43

Slide pro vide d b y L a nsing BWL

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-44
SLIDE 44
  • Prio ritie s
  • Re pla c e physic a lly disturb e d le a d se rvic e

(dig -ins, e xc a va tio ns, le a k re pa ir)

  • Sc ho o ls, da y c a re c e nte rs, o the r se nsitive

po pula tio ns

  • Sa mple re sults a re >15 ppb
  • CSO re pla c e me nt o r stre e t re sto ra tio ns
  • Multiple se rvic e s within a c o mpa c t a re a
  • L

e ng th o f le a d pipe pre se nt in the se rvic e line

L ANSI NG BOARD OF WAT E R & L I GHT :

SE RVI CE L I NE RE PL ACE ME NT T E CHNI QUE

slide-45
SLIDE 45
slide-46
SLIDE 46
  • Be g a n re mo ving o nly le a d po rtio n (g o o se ne c k) 25 ye a rs a g o
  • Ab o ut 100 g o o se ne c ks re mo ve d
  • Are no t de a lt with priva te po rtio n o f se rvic e s
  • 2014 re sults fo r 52 site s a ll b e lo w a c tio n le ve l
  • Ha ve re mo ve d a ll pub lic le a d issue s
  • Allo c a te d $522k fro m wa te r supply syste m fund b a la nc e to re pla c e 118

g a lva nize d iro n se rvic e line s c o nta ining le a d piping .

CASE ST UDY:

ANN ARBOR, MI

slide-47
SLIDE 47

1.

E ffe c ts o f L e a d

2.

L e a d & Munic ipa l Wa te r Syste ms

3.

E stima te d Pro b le m Sta te & Na tio nwide

4.

E PA & MDE Q Rule s

5.

Do e s My Co mmunity Ha ve L e a d I n T he Syste m?

6.

Ho w Are Othe r Co mmunitie s De a ling with L e a d?

  • 7. De ve loping an Ac tion Plan

8.

Que stio ns & Disc ussio n

AGE NDA

slide-48
SLIDE 48

T E ST I NG F OR L E AD & AL K AL I NI T Y OF YOUR WAT E R

  • Co nfirm tha t yo u a re a dhe ring to ne w L

e a d & Co ppe r Rule

  • L
  • o k fo r upc o ming c ha ng e s to L

e a d & Co ppe r Rule s

slide-49
SLIDE 49

DE VE L OPI NG AN ACT I ON PL AN:

  • Org a nize Sta ff
  • Co nfirm with sta ff wha t da ta the y ha ve
  • Org a nize Re c o rds/ Da ta
  • Wha t do yo u ha ve ?
  • Re q uire a ll fie ld da ta is lo g g e d
  • Pa y a tte ntio n to wa te r c he mistry
  • Antic ipa te Additio na l Rule Cha ng e s
  • F
  • rm a n Ac tio n Pla n
slide-50
SLIDE 50

F I NANCI NG I DE AS

  • Whe re do e s the se rvic e le a d typic a lly e nd?
  • Po lic y o n re spo nsib ility
  • Split c o sts
  • Pa y o ve r time
  • Ho me o wne rs o ffe re d a 0% lo a n fo r priva te se rvic e . (Phila de lphia )
  • I

nc lude in pub lic wa te rma in pro je c ts

  • Wha t’ s inside the c usto me r’ s ho use tha t a ffe c ts le a d?
  • I

nc e ntive s to re pla c e le a d c o nta ining fixture s a nd plumb ing

slide-51
SLIDE 51

PUBL I C RE L AT I ONS

  • De te rmine if the re a re like ly to b e le a d se rvic e line s re ma ining in yo ur

se rvic e a re a o wne d b y utility OR c usto me rs.

  • Ga ug e e xte nt o f le a d se rvic e line pre se nc e in c o mmunity
  • E

va lua te c urre nt c o mmunic a tio n ma te ria ls o n le a d.

  • Ob ta in o rg a niza tio na l suppo rt fro m pro g ra m a nd c o mmunic a tio ns a b o ut

le a d se rvic e line s

slide-52
SLIDE 52

PUBL I C RE L AT I ONS

  • E

ng a g e yo ur lo c a l pub lic he a lth a nd/ o r prima c y a g e nc y

  • Cre a te imple me nta tio n pla n Re vie w / de ve lo p o rg a niza tio n po lic y a nd

pro c e dure s

  • Pre pa re c o mmunic a tio n ma te ria ls
  • T

e st c o mmunic a tio n ma te ria ls

slide-53
SLIDE 53

VI DE OS

  • E

RI N BROCK OVI CH E XPL AI NS T HE F L I NT WAT E R CRI SI S

slide-54
SLIDE 54

PAT RICK WAT E RMAN, CI

T Y MANAGE R, CI T Y OF HUDSONVI L L E P: 616.669.0200 E : pwa te rma n@ hud so nville .o rg

PAUL

  • R. GAL

DE S, PE, F

L E I S & VANDE NBRI NK P: 616.977.1000 E : pg a lde s@ fve ng .c o m

DAVID G. JOHNSON, CHMM-CP, F

L E I S & VANDE NBRI NK P: 616.616.915.0272 E : djo hnso n@ fve ng .c o m

DON J. DE VRIE S, PE, F

L E I S & VANDE NBRI NK P: 616.977.1000 E : dde vrie s@ fve ng .c o m

slide-55
SLIDE 55

T HANK YOU!

slide-56
SLIDE 56

Your Feedback is Important to Us!

Please fill out your session evaluation:

Evaluations are located in the Convention App or a paper copy is available at the front of the room.