Developing a future for the CRC Energy & Sustainability Network - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Developing a future for the CRC

Energy & Sustainability Network Industry Led Review by EIC and Acclaro Advisory

28th February 2013 Sunil.shah@acclaro-advisory.com

About Acclaro Advisory

• We are an independent sustainability practice that provides policy

and strategic advice;

• Our relationship based approach develop long term partnerships

with our clients;

• We understand both the emerging policy trends and have the

technical experience to enable clients to implement practical and measurable solutions

Project Initiation

• Industry led project to capture options on how

the CRC Phase 2 and beyond should progress

• Project commenced in May 2012 following

discussions with HM Treasury and DECC

• Launched on 21st November with Tim Yeo MP and

Alan Whitehead MP

• Key areas of focus:

– longer term approach rather than short term fix – higher level discussion of meeting the original CRC

• bjectives

– Understand the value and benefits to the Green Economy – Understand the level of admin burden

Behaviour Change

• Two main drivers to promote behavioural economics:

– Report and payment requires Board level approval – Performance League Table

• More accurate data collection and governance has been developed
• The CRC is seen as a tax, which has missed an opportunity to

stimulate investment in carbon reduction and raise the profile at Board Level

Performance League Table

• The concept of the PLT is considered positive and should

ultimately demonstrate performance / good asset management and enable: – Benchmarking of CSR performance – Peer review by organisations to gain competitive advantage with meaningful information – sectorising including an undifferentiated list – Provision of a full list, using trade names and full details to enable market and media analysis – Provision of a series of mandatory and optional metrics tailored towards sectors – Media interest through the provision of useful information and data

Carbon Pricing

• Revenue from the CRC through the 5-year plan and OBR to

generate £1bn in 2014/15

• Need to provide a longer term price certainty for the CRC to

enable investments to be made

• Balance prices to account for the decarbonisation of the grid,

reduced energy use and raising of revenue

Carbon Reduction

Carbon Reduction

Trading System

• Trading is a requirement of the CRC underpinned by the Climate

Change Act. However, there is uncertainty from respondents on how this may operate

• Fixed price credits purchased at the beginning and end of the

year – based upon long term carbon process

• Incentivised forecasting of consumption

Energy Efficiency

• Development of a grant funded body that provides an oversight

function, supports equipment to ensure consistency and best practice

• Body similar to WRAP, which has successfully demonstrated

economic growth and tangible improvement in resources

• Investment will help to:

– Prioritise capital projects due to reduced payback times and potential savings that can be achieved – Provide an immediate job creation role for the retrofitting of equipment and technologies from the construction sector – Drive innovation across the UK to develop energy efficient technologies backed by the desire to purchase these systems

Consultation Response

• DECC response to the CRC Simplification consultation released in early December

2012 and Chancellors Autumn Statement announced a number of changes.

• Simplification to save 55% of costs on average – some will win, others will not

(property sector hit)

• The PLT will be abolished. A data table will be published comprising aggregated

energy use and emission data, enabling organisations and industry to see performance directly and in comparison to peers. This may retain an aspect of the reputational risk the CRC was designed to meet.

• The tax element of the CRC introduced at Spending Review 2010 will be a high

priority for removal when the public finances allow raising the potential for revenue recycling

• Long term carbon pricing - £16 per tonne of carbon dioxide in 2014-15 and will

increase in line with RPI from 2015-16

• Reducing overlap with the CCA and EU ETS – sites which include CCA facilities or

ETS installations will be removed from the scope of the CRC.

Consultation Response

• Reducing the number of fuels that participants have to report against from 29 to

2 (electricity and gas for heating)

• Withdrawing all state-funded schools in England from the scheme.
• Government will consider how the CRC can incentivise the uptake of new onsite

renewable self-supplied electricity.

• Two fixed price allowance sales – a forecast sale at the beginning of the year and

a ‘buy-to-comply’ sale after the end of the reporting year. The forecast sale price will be lower than the end of year sale to incentivise forecasting. Prices will be set through the budget process

• Reduced reporting will be required with only one annual reporting 2013/14 and

the abolition of footprint reporting. Records also only need to be kept for six years

• More flexible disaggregation, with any subsidiary undertaking able to disaggregate

for separate participation.

• The Government will review the effectiveness of the CRC in 2016

Summary

• The CRC is seen as having had a positive impact on the data

collection and governance of energy management

• But is a missed opportunity to drive behavioural change within
• rganisations to reduce carbon emissions
• Tweaks and amendments, in line with the consultation, will

improve the CRC – funding through an oversight body, long term carbon pricing and a robust PLT

• HM Treasury have reviewed alternatives to the CRC
• Need for some stability in the CRC without further regulatory

intervention

Next Steps

Further industry led project to develop a practical model for a grant funding body:

• Maximise green economy benefits and job creation through

targeted spending of a grant funding scheme focused on energy efficiency;

• Introduce an oversight body to provide targeted support at the

technology and delivery level;

• Align the CRC with local bodies, including LEPs and City Deal

Groups, to promote efficiency programmes;

• Improve governance structures including, for example, data from

energy suppliers and apportion costs between landlords and tenants.

www.CarbonBuzz.org

CarbonBuzz is the first platform that compares and benchmarks designed energy use with measured energy use and carbon side-by-side. The gap between design stage energy predictions and actual performance is significant and shows that buildings in the UK regularly and unnecessarily use more energy than they were designed to. CarbonBuzz focuses on making buildings operate at the level they were designed to:

• Find out how a building performs against its peers;
• Compare design estimates against operational energy use;
• Study the composition of other projects with good (or poor) energy performance;
• Track the design and actual CO2 emissions of a portfolio of buildings.
• Provide feedback to users about the likely robustness of their energy use predictions

– British Land’

“ Y een head office, is located in Marble ch, Central London. At our Head Office, we cut landlor influenced energy use by 51% last year d – due to small power ee zones; a) “ Common parts, b) S har services and c) Occupier consumption” . E nergy use is thought in easons – still not sur e have added the ability to attach ‘mini stories’ to allow users to explain the stories and assumptions database, filter

The Beta Platform – Pilots

, please send ‘unsubscribe’

CarbonBuzz Cycle

Market Survey

• CarbonBuzz is undertaking a study into how to

improve the benefits of the platform; to promote the platform across the built lifecycle; and also to identify where additional services could be delivered

• https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/CarbonBuzz_User
• Https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/CarbonBuzz_NonUsers

Many thanks for your time.

Developing a future for the CRC? Energy and Sustainability Network 27th February 2013 Sunil.shah@acclaro-advisory.com www.acclaro-advisory.com 07590 444 399