and management Dr Kirsty Carden, University of Cape Town 18 April - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

and management
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

and management Dr Kirsty Carden, University of Cape Town 18 April - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Resource guidelines for greywater use and management Dr Kirsty Carden, University of Cape Town 18 April 2016 Water Research Commission project K5/2592 Development of resource guidelines for greywater use and management 1 Agenda for workshop


slide-1
SLIDE 1

Resource guidelines for greywater use and management

Dr Kirsty Carden, University of Cape Town 18 April 2016 Water Research Commission project K5/2592 Development of resource guidelines for greywater use and management

slide-2
SLIDE 2

1

Agenda for workshop

  • 1. Welcome and introductions
  • 2. Background to project – status quo / definitions
  • 3. Identification of thematic areas / issues to be addressed
  • 4. Introduction to greywater resource guidelines
  • 5. Way forward / closure
slide-3
SLIDE 3

2

Strategic planning

“South Africa is a ‘water-stressed’ country, bordering on water scarce…water may become a binding constraint on development, at least in some parts of the country. There is a need for urgent attention to be given to the management and conservation of water resources, especially in stressed water catchments… Addressing supply and demand in the context of unevenly distributed and variable resources is a matter of central importance in national planning.” (National Planning Commission, 2011) ‘In many parts of the country, we are fast approaching the point at which all of

  • ur easily accessible freshwater resources are fully utilised. All South Africans

must recognise this situation so that necessary steps are taken to assess current and future demands for water. This will not be an easy task, but with the necessary resolve to plan and implement the required interventions, a secure water future can be achieved.’ – NWRS2, 2013, page 4

slide-4
SLIDE 4

3

National surface water storage levels

http://niwis.dwa.gov.za/niwis2/SurfaceWaterStorage

slide-5
SLIDE 5

4

Predicted total water withdrawals

(Source: Hedden, 2016)

slide-6
SLIDE 6

5

Resilience-based water management

Blue water Sector approach dominated by economics and engineering, emphasis on supply Integrated blue water An economic approach to freshwater including environmental flows Integrated blue and green water Adding land interactions, surface runoff and infiltration to food, energy, and ecosystem services Green and blue water with social and ecological interactions Resilience based, addressing the need to sustain rainfall, capture resource value, and cross scale interactions and feedbacks

IWRM / IUWM SuDS WSUD

Evolution from the 1990s to present day realisation

Adapted from Rockstrom et al., 2014

slide-7
SLIDE 7

6

Diversifying household water sources

Precipitation Evapo-transpiration Reduced volumes of runoff Increased Infiltration Reduced wastewater discharge Reduced Municipal potable water demand Stormwater Harvesting Rainwater Harvesting Groundwater Greywater reuse

slide-8
SLIDE 8

7

7

Household greywater - What is it?

Greywater is untreated wastewater from baths, showers, kitchen and handwash basin, and laundry (i.e. household wastewater excluding toilet waste) Class 1: Bathroom greywater – showers, basins, baths Class 2: Laundry greywater – laundry basins and washing machines Class 3: Kitchen greywater – kitchen sinks and dishwashing machines

Only applies to serviced settlements

slide-9
SLIDE 9

8

Greywater recycling

Source: Ana Delétic

slide-10
SLIDE 10

9

Simple home-based greywater systems

Photos courtesy: Kevin Winter

slide-11
SLIDE 11

10

Combined rain- and greywater harvesting

slide-12
SLIDE 12

11

Greywater and food security

slide-13
SLIDE 13

12

Greywater and food security (2)

Photos courtesy: Khanyisa Projects

slide-14
SLIDE 14

13

Greywater tower gardens

slide-15
SLIDE 15

14

Draft National Sanitation Policy (2016)

slide-16
SLIDE 16

15

slide-17
SLIDE 17

16

Quality issues

slide-18
SLIDE 18

17

Greywater management in informal settlements

slide-19
SLIDE 19

18

Greywater management in informal settlements

slide-20
SLIDE 20

19

Timeline of greywater research

slide-21
SLIDE 21

20

Project aims

Address (and mitigate) the risks associated with the management and use of domestic greywater, and support the wider uptake of this practice in South Africa, in order to realise diverse benefits such as:

  • building resilience into the water supply system;
  • managing water demand;
  • reducing volumes of greywater to wastewater

systems;

  • reducing diffuse pollution loads from un-serviced

settlements

slide-22
SLIDE 22

21

Technical background report

  • Definition of terms and concepts
  • Role of greywater management in water supply and

food security

  • Applicable regulations / policy / guidelines on

greywater use and management

  • Existing greywater use and management systems
  • Recommendations for sustainable greywater use

and management

slide-23
SLIDE 23

22

Greywater guidelines

  • Greywater quantity / quality and fitness for use /

application

  • Managing risks and uncertainty in greywater use /

reuse

  • Use of greywater to supplement irrigation activities
  • Greywater management options, including:

treatment, disposal and reuse

  • Planning for (municipal) programme implementation
slide-24
SLIDE 24

23

Method

  • Compile relevant research findings
  • Survey greywater system users at household scale
  • Local and national stakeholder workshops
  • Review of legislative and health aspects
  • Focus group discussions
  • Develop guidelines, including simple ‘operations and

maintenance’ information, as well as strategic technical background document

slide-25
SLIDE 25

24

Thematic areas to be addressed

  • Health aspects
  • Legislative issues
  • Risk management / quantification
  • Socio-cultural issues
  • Appropriate applications / uses
  • Key design considerations
slide-26
SLIDE 26

25

Health aspects

  • Is greywater a health risk?
  • What are the pathways to infection?
  • What preventative barriers are there?
  • What about treatment options?
  • Is hygiene education important?
slide-27
SLIDE 27

Health aspects of re-use of household wastewater (greywater)

Dr Jo M Barnes

Division of Community Health Faculty of Health Sciences University of Stellenbosch TYGERBERG

slide-28
SLIDE 28

27

Household greywater - What is in it?

  • Soaps, detergents, fabric softeners
  • Hair products (shampoo, hair conditioner)
  • Toothpaste
  • Medicines
  • Disinfectants
  • Pesticides
  • Dyes
  • Cosmetics
  • Lint and other fibres
  • Food particles as well as fats, oils, blood
  • Human waste products: saliva, sweat, body oils, hair,

blood, and some urine and faecal matter

slide-29
SLIDE 29

28

28

Greywater is NOT a “safe” substance

  • Contains bacteria, viruses, parasites - pathogens able to

cause disease in humans or animals

  • Species and total counts vary widely according to climatic

conditions, season, sanitation technology available, sanitation habits of the people living in the dwelling and the disease incidences in the area

  • Potential re-use of greywater is as much a public health

issue as it is a water conservation priority

Implementation involves balancing risks

slide-30
SLIDE 30

29

29

International restrictions on re-use (1)

  • Water used to wash articles contaminated with faeces should not

be used

  • Greywater should not be allowed to leave the boundaries of the

property and should under no circumstances be allowed to enter the stormwater system

  • Provision must be made for the safe disposal of excess

greywater into the sewage system during rainfall or when too much greywater is produced for the garden to absorb

  • Greywater should never be allowed to pond or pool where

mosquitoes can breed or where it can develop foul smell

  • “Fail-safe" disposal system required – PRECAUTIONARY

PRINCIPLE to be applied

slide-31
SLIDE 31

30

30

International restrictions on re-use (2)

  • Never apply to edible crops
  • Withhold from areas where children play, such as lawns – as

children are highest risk group for acquiring infection.

  • Withhold if anybody living on the premises is suffering from

diarrhoea, ear or skin infections, etc.

  • Warm water should be stored in a holding tank to cool down.

Use within 24 hours; otherwise the bacterial load will rise too high for safety.

  • Everybody living on the premises where gardens are irrigated

with greywater should wash their hands without fail before eating or drinking.

slide-32
SLIDE 32

31

31

Realities in developing countries

  • Far larger proportion of population poverty-stricken
  • Burdens of disease predominated by infectious diseases
  • 40% of women aged 25 - 35 HIV+ in South Africa
  • Very poor sanitation - high infection pressure
  • Direct link between food and contaminated water
  • Populations more inclined towards 'civil disobedience' due to

lack of enforcement of regulations

slide-33
SLIDE 33

32

Who is most at risk of water-related disease?

  • Newborns, babies and children
  • Pregnant women and their developing foetuses
  • Old people
  • Individuals with compromised immunity such as those with TB,

HIV/AIDS

  • Persons who are chronically malnourished
  • Patients on long-term medication
  • Persons with pre-existing chronic diseases such as diabetes,

kidney failure, liver failure

  • Persons who abuse alcohol or other drugs

= Large proportion of SA population

slide-34
SLIDE 34

33

33

Risks related to irrigating edible crops

  • Never apply directly to edible crops - especially not to

vegetables eaten raw or lightly cooked, such as in salads

  • Avoid for root crops such as carrots, since pathogens

accumulate in the topsoil and in the roots

  • Irrigation carried out under plastic sheeting or buried under the

soil surface significantly reduces crop risks, but microbial contamination still persists

  • Survival of E. coli O157:H7 was greatest in soil under rooted

grass - moderate decline occurred only after 130 days. Edible crops should only be irrigated with greywater when risk of disease becomes less than the risk of hunger.

slide-35
SLIDE 35

34

34

Reuse of greywater already happens

Different liability when officially sanctioned - when initiated by citizens themselves they carry the risk

slide-36
SLIDE 36

35

35

Greywater systems - problems increase risks

  • High levels of commitment and sophisticated understanding
  • Strict supervision - luxury in developing countries
  • Proper, safe systems (filters, directional valves, etc.)
  • During outbreaks or health hazards, how can use be stopped?

(No 'undo button')

  • What if subsequent owners do not comply with safety rules?
  • Who will carry costs if health risks rise to unacceptable levels or
  • utbreaks occur?
  • If stopped, who will compensate the poor who make a living

selling the produce grown with greywater?

slide-37
SLIDE 37

36

Legislative issues

  • What legislation is relevant?
  • How important is a legislative framework?
  • Should legislation be developed?
  • What about enforcement?
  • Are there any relevant building codes?
  • What about plumbing ‘sign-off’ on home-based

systems?

slide-38
SLIDE 38

Legislative review

Dr C Young Department of Private Law University of Cape Town

slide-39
SLIDE 39

CONSTITUTION

NATIONAL WATER ACT WATER SERVICES ACT REGULATIONS STRATEGIES/POLICIES/GUIDELINES

slide-40
SLIDE 40

CONSTITUTION OF THE REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA, 1996 S 27

  • Everyone has the right of access to water
  • Sanitation?
slide-41
SLIDE 41

NATIONAL WATER ACT No mention of grey water specifically Preamble:

  • “water is a scarce and unevenly distributed national resource which occurs in many

different forms which are all part of a unitary, interdependent cycle”

  • “the ultimate aim of water resource management is to achieve the sustainable use of water

for the benefit of all users”

  • “the need for the integrated management of all aspects of water resources”

S 2 read with s 3:

  • water must be used, protected, developed, conserved, controlled and managed in such a

way as to promote “the efficient, sustainable and beneficial use of water in the public interest”

slide-42
SLIDE 42

NATIONAL WATER ACT

S 38 of the NWA: Specific authorization

  • Reuse of water for the purposes of irrigation of land - waste water generated by industrial activities / waterwork

Revision of General Authorisations in terms of section 39: GN 665 of 6 September 2013: Government Gazette No. 36820]: Disposal and re-use of waste water

  • Reference to “grey water”: Disposal to an onsite facility and the permission to reuse domestic wastewater
  • Grey water definition: “wastewater generated through domestic activities and premises, including washing, bathing and

food preparation, but does not contain sewage”

  • No explicit guidelines

The Regulations Relating to Compulsory National Standards and Measures to Conserve Water (GNR.509 of 8 June 2001): disposal of grey water:

  • WSI empowered to provide the limitations for the use of grey water where use will have negative impact of the

environment, health or other water resources

  • Grey water is defined as “waste water resulting from the use of water for domestic purposes, but does not include human

excreta”

  • Grey water included within the definition of “effluent” = permissible to use effluent upon approval from WSI
  • The obligation falls on the WSI to ensure that use of such effluent does not pose a health risk, prior to approval of this use
  • Where effluent or non-potable water, including grey water, is accessible via a tap, a sign must be clearly and permanently

displayed that states that the water is non-potable.

slide-43
SLIDE 43

WATER SERVICES ACT No mention of grey water specifically The Draft National Sanitation Policy (GN 70 of 12 February 2016: Government Gazette No 39688)

  • Grey water defined as “wastewater resulting from the use of water for domestic purposes,

but does not include human excreta”

  • Policy approach to grey water:
  • Proper management, storage and treatment of grey water required because of

potential health implications

  • Reuse of grey water important to alleviate pressures on demand for water resources
  • Minister will develop regulations for the “use, re-use recycling and recovery of the

liquid, solid and gaseous constituents of human wastewater and excreta”

  • WSA’s responsible for ensuring that national grey water guidelines are adhered to, and

DWA monitors this adherence.

  • BUT: no enforcement mechanism to ensure compliance!
slide-44
SLIDE 44

OTHER LEGISLATION?

Publication of the Environmental Impact Assessment Guideline for Aquaculture in South Africa

  • Encourages the use of grey water for irrigation of

landscapes

  • Water “generated by washing and other non-sewerage

activities” Environmental Impact Assessment Guideline for Renewable Projects

  • Encourages consideration of the use of grey water =

mitigating environmental impacts in the context of biomass energy projects Application of the National Building Regulations (SANS 10400-Q: 2011, Third Edition)

  • “domestic waste water excluding toilet water”
  • Grey water must be disposed of in a separate system to a

ventilated pit toilet National Environmental Health Norms and Standards for Premises and Acceptable Monitoring Standards for Environmental Health Practitioners (GN 1229 of 24 December 2015: Government Gazette No. 39561 (National Heath Act)

  • “Refers to waste water that does not contain significant

amounts of faecal pollution (i.e. not sewage discharges). Typically, it consists of water discharged from baths, showers and/or sinks”

slide-45
SLIDE 45

OTHER LEGISLATION Standards For Health Related Water Quality Management On Premises

  • Safe water = “water that has been tested and does not present any

significant risk to health over a lifetime of consumption (microbiological, physical and chemical quality)”

  • Standards are provided for use of grey water:
  • Use = flushing of toilets/irrigation
  • NOT for drinking, cooking, personal hygiene
  • Grey water created from laundry, dishwashing and bathing = recycled prior

to use for irrigation / constructed wetlands.

  • Disposal = safe
  • Education of users and communities is required in terms of the health and

hygiene implications of the use thereof.

  • Any use of grey water should be subject to prior approval being obtained

from WSI

  • WSI should consult with an Environmental Health Practitioner prior to

granting any approval = EHP should test the effluent for compliance monitoring purposes.

  • Any point at which the grey water could be accessed must be clearly marked

indicating the presence of effluent and its non-potability.

  • Cross-connection of systems cautioned against - avoid contamination of

potable water

slide-46
SLIDE 46

MUNICIPALITIES WITH BYLAWS

Western Cape City of Cape Town Metropolitan Municipality Drakenstein Local Municipality Bitou Local Municipality George Local Municipality Hessequa Local Municipality Knysna Local Municipality Mossel Bay Local Municipality Overstrand Local Municipality Swellendam Local Municipality Theewaterskloof Local Municipality West Coast District Municipality Bergriver Local Municipality Saldhana Bay Local Municipality Swartland Local Municipality Cederberg Local Municipality Breede Valley Local Municipality Gauteng Kungwini Local Municipality Mogale City Local Municipality North-West Madibeng Local Municipality Moses Kotane Local Municipality Moretele Local Municipality Ramotshere Moiloa Local Municipality Eastern Cape Buffalo City Local Municipality Ntabankulu Local Municipality Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality Joe Gqabi District Municipality Mpumalanga Thaba Chweu Local Municipality KwaZulu Natal Umzimkhulu Local Municipality Umhlathuze Local Municipality uThungulu District Municipality Limpopo Vhembe District Municipality Mogalakwena Local Municipality Greater Sekhukhune District Municipality

slide-47
SLIDE 47

MUNICIPALITIES WITHOUT BYLAWS

Western Cape Cape Winelands District Municipality Central Karoo District Municipality Eden District Municipality Overberg District Municipality Breede River/ Winelands Local Municipality Langeberg Local Municipality Stellenbosch Local Municipality Witzenberg Local Municipality Beaufort West Local Municipality Laingsburg Local Municipality Prince Albert Local Municipality Kannaland Local Municipality Oudtshoorn Local Municipality Cape Aghulas Local Municipality Cederberg Local Municipality Matzikama Local Municipality Gauteng City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality City of Tswane Metropolitan Municipality Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality Metsweding District Municipality Sedibeng District Municipality West Rand Distric Municipality Emfuleni Local Municipality Lesedi Local Municipality Midvaal Local Municipality Merafong Local Municipality Randfontein Local Municipality Westonaria Local Municipality North-West Bonjanala District Municipality Dr Kenneth Kaunda District Municipality Dr Ruth Segomotsi District Municipality Ngaka Modiri Molema District Municipality Kgetlengrivier Local Municipality Rustenberg Local Municipality Maquassi Hills Local Municipality Matlosana Local Municipality Tlokwe Local Municipality Ventersdorp Local Municipality Greater Taung Local Municipality Kagisano-Molopo Local Municipality Lekwe-Teemane Local Municipality Mamusa Local Municipality Molopo Local Municipality Naledi Local Municipality Ditsobotla Local Municipality Mafikeng Local Municipality Ratlou Local Municipality Tswaing Local Municipality Mpumalanga Ehlanzeni District Municipality Gert Sibane District Municipality Nkangala District Municipality Bushbuckridge Local Municipality Mbombela Local Municipality Nkomazi Local Municipality Umjindi Local Municipality Albert Luthuli Local Municipality Dipaleseng Local Municipality Govan Mbeki Local Municipality Msukaligwa Local Municipality Pixley Ka Seme Local Municipality Dr JS Moroka Local Municipality Emakhazeni Local Municipality Emahaleni Local Municipality Steve Tshwete Local Municipality Thembisile Hani Local Municipality Victor Khanye Local Municipality

slide-48
SLIDE 48

MUNICIPALITIES WITHOUT BYLAWS

Northern Cape Frances Baard District Municipality, John Taolo Gaetsewe District Municipality, Namakwa District Municipality Pixley ka Seme District Municipality, Siyanda District Municipality, Dikgatlong Local Municipality, Magareng Local Municipality, Phokwane Local Municipality, Sol Plaatje Local Municipality, Gamagara Local Municipality, Ga-Segonyana Local Municipality, Joe Morolong Local Municipality Hantam Local Municipality, Kamiesberg Local Municipality Karoo Hoogland Local Municipality, Khai-Ma Local Municipality Nama-Khoi Local Municipality, Richtersveld Local Municipality Emthanjeni Local Municipality, Siyancuma Local Municipality Siyathema Local Municipality,Thembelihle Local Municipality Ubuntu Local Municipality Umsobomvu Local Municipality Khara Hais Local Municipality Kgatelopele Local Municipality Tsantsabane Local Municipality Kai! Garib Local Municipality Free State Fezile Dabi District Municipality Lejweleputswa District Municipality Motheo District Municipality Thabo Mofutsanyane District Municipality Xhariep District Municipality Mafube Local Municipality Metsimaholo Local Municipality Moquaka Local Municipality Ngwathe Local Municipality Masilonyana Local Municipality Mtjhabeng Local Municipality Nala Local Municipality Tswelopele Local Municipality Mangaung Local Municipality Mantsopa Local Municipality Naledi Local Municipality Dihlabeng Local Municipality Maluti a Phofung Local Municipality Nketoana Local Municipality Phumelela Local Municipality Setsoto Local Municipality Kopanong Local Municipality Letsemeng Local Municipality Mohokare Local Municipality Limpopo Bohlabela District Municipality, Capricon District Municipality Mopani District Municipality, Waterberg District Municipality Aganang Local Municipality, Blouberg Local Municipality Lepelle-Nkumpi Local Municipality, Molemole Local Municipality, Polokwane Local Municipality, Elias Motsoaledi Local Municipality, Ephraim Mogale Local Municipality, Fetakgomo Local Municipality, Greater Tubatse Local Municipality Makhuduthmanga Local Municipality, Ba-Phalaborwa Local Municipality Greater Giyani Local Municipality, Greater Letaba Local Municipality, Greater Tzaneen Local Municipality, Maruleng Local Municipality, Makhado Local Municipality, Musina Local Municipality, Mutale Local Municipality, Thulamela Local Municipality, Bela-Bela Local Municipality, Lephalale Local Municipality, Modimolle Local Municipality, Mookgophong Local Municipality, Thabazimbi Local Municipality

slide-49
SLIDE 49

MUNICIPALITIES WITHOUT BYLAWS

KwaZUlu Natal eThekwini Amajuba District Municipality, iLembe District Municipality, Sisonke District Municipality Ugu District Municipality, Umgungundlovu District Municipality, Umkhanyakude District Municipality, Umzinyathi District Municipality, Uthukela District Municipality Zululand District Municipality, eMadlangeni Local Municipality, Dannhauser Local Municipality Newcastle Local Municipality, KwaDakuza Local Municipality Mandeni Local Municipality, Maphumolo Local Municipality, Ndwedwe Local Municipality Greater Kokstad Local Municipality, Ingwe Local Municipality, Kwa Sani Local Municipality Ubuhlebezwe Local Municipality, Ezinqoleni Local Municipality, Hibiscus Local Municipality Umdoni Local Municipality, uMuziwabantu Local Municipality, Umzumbe Local Municipality Vulamehlo Local Municipality, Imendle Local Municipality,, Mkhambathini Local Municipality Msunduzi Local Municipality, Mpofana Local Municipality, Richmond Local Municipality uMngeni Local Municipality, uMshwati Local Municipality, Big Five False Bay Local Municipality Hlabisa Local Municipality, Jozini Local Municipality, Mtubatuba Local Municipality Umhlabuyalinga Local Municipality, Emdumeni Local Municipality, Msinga Local Municipality Nquthu Local Municipality, Emnambithi-Ladysmith Local Municipality, Imbabazane Local Municipality, Indaka Local Municipality, Okhahlamba Local Municipality, Umtshezi Local Municipality, Mthonjaneni Local Municipality, Nkandla Local Municipality Ntambanana Local Municipality, Umfolozi Local Municipality, Umlalazi Local Municipality Abaqulusi Local Municipality, Ulundi Local Municipality, uPhongolo Local Municipality eDumbe Local Municipality, Nongoma Local Municipality Eastern Cape Alfred Nzo District Municipality, Amatole District Municipality, Cacadu District Municipality Chris Hani District Municipality, O.R Tambo District Municipality, Alfred Nzo Local Municipality, Matatiele Local Municipality, Umzimvubu Local Municipality Amahlathi Local Municipality, Great Kei Local Municipality, Mbashe Local Municipality Mnquma Local Municipality, Ngqushwa Local Municipality, Nkonkobe Local Municipality Nxuba Local Municipality, Baviaans Local Municipality, Blue Crane Route Local Municipality Camdeboo Local Municipality, Ikwezi Local Municipality, Kouga Local Municipality Koukamma Local Municipality, Makana Local Municipality, Ndlambe Local Municipality Sunday’s River Local Municipality, Emalaheni Local Municipality, Engcobo Local Municipality Lukanji Local Municipality, Inkwanca Local Municipality, Intsika Local Municipality Inxuba Yethemba Local Municipality, Sakhisizwe Local Municipality, Tsolwana Local Municipality, Elundini Local Municipality, Gariep Local Municipality, Maletswai Local Municipality, Senqu Local Municipality, Ingquza Local Municipality King Sabata Dalindyebo Local Municipality, Mbizana Local Municipality Mhlonto Local Municipality, Nyandeni Local Municipality, Port St Johns Local Municipality

slide-50
SLIDE 50

THEMES IN MUNICIPAL BYLAWS Written permission required City of Cape Town, Drakenstein, Bitou, George, Hessequa, Knysna, Mossel Bay, Swellendam , West Coast, Bergriver, Saldhana Bay, Swartland, Cederberg, Breede Valley, Buffalo City Excludes kitchen water Drakenstein Excludes water from garbage grinder Bitou “Any device which entails the recycling or re-use of water shall not make use of water derived from any kitchen, excluding clothes washing machines, or from toilet discharges” Madibeng, Moses Kotane, Moretele, Thaba Chweu, Greater Sekhukhune, Umzimkhulu, uThungulu, Ntabankulu Only a definition provided Vhembe, Mogalakwena, Kungwini No cross-connection Umhlathuze Planning for low-cost housing to include access to grey water systems for irrigation Mogale City

slide-51
SLIDE 51

50

Risk Management / Quantification

  • Why have previous guidelines not been widely

adopted?

  • Are guidelines useful for managing risk?
  • Is the WHO approach to risk management useful?
  • What are the simplest ways to manage risk?
  • Is a “Greywater Harvesting Assessment tool” a good

idea in principle?

slide-52
SLIDE 52

Quantifying risk in a guideline

Dr Lloyd Fisher-Jeffes

www.wsud.co.za

slide-53
SLIDE 53

52

Overview

  • We know greywater can be dangerous
  • Microbiologically, chemically
  • SA Water Quality Guidelines
  • Old
  • Generalised
  • Relevance?
  • New approaches to risk management
  • DALY
  • Is it easily understood?
  • What parameters should we focus on
  • Environmental
  • Legal implications
slide-54
SLIDE 54

53

Varying quality of greywater

Reference Eriksson et al., 2003 Rose et al., 1991 Cassanova et al., 2001 Source Composite Shower Laundry wash Laundry rinse Composite Composite Concentration (mg/ℓ unless

  • therwise stated)

Range Range Range Faecal coliforms (CFU/100ml) 6.0×103 126 25 1.82×104- 7.98×108 5.63×105 Faecal Streptococci (Enterococci) (CFU/100ml) 2.38×102

  • E. coli

(CFU/100ml) <100-2800 For formal fully serviced residential houses – greywater in informal settlements will have very different characteristics

slide-55
SLIDE 55

54

SAWQG – Whats an appropriate standard?

According to the South African Water Quality Guidelines (DWAF, 1996), gastro-intestinal and other illnesses can be expected to rise when people are in contact with E. coli counts above 400 counts / 100 mℓ

slide-56
SLIDE 56

55

Managing risk internationally

  • WHO –
  • Australian guidelines for

water recycling

slide-57
SLIDE 57

56

Can it work in SA?

  • What does a DALY mean?
  • The disability-adjusted life year (DALY) is a measure of
  • verall disease burden, expressed as the number of

years lost due to ill-health, disability or early death. It was developed in the 1990s as a way of comparing the

  • verall health and life expectancy of different countries.
slide-58
SLIDE 58

57

Can it work in SA?

  • Typical reference microorganisms used by WHO

include:

  • Campylobacter - bacteria
  • Rotavirus - viruses
  • Cryptosporidium parvum - protozoa and helminths
  • Some studies have used E.coli as a reference micro-
  • rganism for bacteria – Howard et al.
slide-59
SLIDE 59

58

Greywater Harvesting Assessment Tool

𝐻𝑋𝑆𝑆 = 𝑁𝐵𝑌 𝑉𝑈𝑆 − 𝑈𝑆𝑆𝑇1 + 𝑈𝑆𝑆𝑇𝑜 + …

slide-60
SLIDE 60

59

Socio-cultural issues

  • Are socio-cultural-religious considerations

important? Education also

  • What are the most important socio-cultural

concerns? Desirability of greywater use

  • Who / what are the most important ‘influencers’ of

social acceptance? Community leaders, churches, entrepreneurs

  • Who are appropriate users? Those who demand it
  • What are the likely behavioural impacts?
slide-61
SLIDE 61

60

Appropriate applications / uses

  • What are appropriate uses? Garden, toilet, car wash
  • What are inappropriate uses? Depends on class and source
  • Is scale important when designing a greywater

system? Yes, retention time

  • How do you decide which risk preventative barriers

to adopt?

  • Is greywater harvesting appropriate in both serviced

and un-serviced settlements? Risk prevention very difficult in

unserviced areas

slide-62
SLIDE 62

61

Key design considerations

  • What are the key technical design considerations? Include
  • verflow to sewer, ease of use, minimal O&M
  • Centralised or decentralised systems; i.e. scale?
  • Are there basic handling rules for greywater?
  • What are the operation and maintenance issues; e.g.

signage and labelling? Registration/licensing of system installers,

responsibility of home-owner, sign-off of home systems on transfer

  • Is economic viability important? Also about making water available

for fit-for-purpose uses during times of water scarcity

  • Are there potential impacts on other water services?
slide-63
SLIDE 63

62

Greywater resource guidelines

1. Introduction to greywater harvesting

  • What is greywater?
  • Why harvest greywater?
  • Appropriate (and inappropriate) uses
  • General rules for harvesting greywater
  • Greywater harvesting techniques – bucketing, diversion

devices, treatment systems

  • 2. Calculating volumes and demand

3. Legal considerations 4. Health risks associated with greywater harvesting 5. Installation, signage and labelling best practice

slide-64
SLIDE 64

63

Greywater uses

slide-65
SLIDE 65

Thank you

To add to the debate go to www.wsud.co.za