2-day workshop on Research Question & Introduction to Literature - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

2 day workshop on research question
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

2-day workshop on Research Question & Introduction to Literature - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Yenepoya University-Fogarty International Center Research Ethics Masters Program for India (NIH Grant No. 1R25 2-day workshop on Research Question & Introduction to Literature Search We acknowledge the skills and resources provided by


slide-1
SLIDE 1

Yenepoya University-Fogarty International Center Research Ethics Master’s Program for India (NIH Grant No. 1R25 2-day workshop on Research Question & Introduction to Literature Search

We acknowledge the skills and resources provided by The Union and QMed, especially Dr Ajay MV, Dr Hemant Shewade and Ms Vasumathi Sriganesh

slide-2
SLIDE 2

Story of present times……

  • Where did you get this information from ??
  • The Internet
  • Where did you get this news from?
  • Whatsapp

29 Aug 2018 2 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-3
SLIDE 3

Types of Research

  • Qualitative vs. Quantitative
  • Observational vs. Experimental
  • Basic vs. Applied
  • Clinical vs. population based

29 Aug 2018 3 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-4
SLIDE 4
  • Research question vs. research interest

29 Aug 2018 4 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-5
SLIDE 5

Pathway of research

29 Aug 2018 5 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-6
SLIDE 6

Main domains of clinical research

  • Therapy : medical, surgical, counselling……..
  • Diagnosis:
  • Prognosis :
  • Harm: Unfavorable effects of therapy
  • Etiology

29 Aug 2018 6 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-7
SLIDE 7

Types of questions

Background questions/General questions : Broad questions about the disease, condition Source: Textbooks, Review articles Foreground questions/Focussed questions: Specific questions to inform clinical decisions . Source: Medline (PUBMED), Cochrane reviews

29 Aug 2018 7 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-8
SLIDE 8

Some broad questions of interest

  • 1. Role of cow-urine in treatment of cancer.
  • 2. Role of yoga in prevention of farmer suicides.
  • 3. Role of music in therapy of patients with heart disease

29 Aug 2018 8 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-9
SLIDE 9

Architecture of a focused question: a 4-part review question

P - Who is the patient or what problem is being addressed?

I - What is the intervention or exposure?

C – What is the comparison group? O - What is the outcome or endpoint?

29 Aug 2018 9 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-10
SLIDE 10

Problems with poorly focused research questions

  • 1. Choice of wrong design.
  • 2. Lack of clarity of protocol
  • 3. Difficult to analyse and interpret results.
  • 4. Difficult to publish.
  • 5. Reader may not be able to interpret the answer if the

question is not clear

29 Aug 2018 10 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-11
SLIDE 11

Architecture of a focused question: a 4-part review question

  • Patient/Problem/Population

–Disease or condition –Stage, Severity –Demographic characteristics (age, gender, etc.)

  • Intervention/Index test/Input variable/exposure

–Type of intervention or exposure –Dose, duration, timing, route, etc.

29 Aug 2018 11 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-12
SLIDE 12

Architecture of a focused question: a 4-part review question

  • Comparison/Comparator:

–Absence of risk or treatment –Placebo or Usual care –It could be internal comparison

  • Outcome:

–Patient important outcomes: Both beneficial and adverse effects –Type: mortality, morbidity, quality of life, etc

29 Aug 2018 12 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-13
SLIDE 13

Other variations

  • PECO : E= exposure .e.g. whether mobile use (E) causes brain

cancer(O)

  • PEO : Effect of BP on vascular events in adults
  • PO: In case there is no treatment for the condition. Or if the
  • utcome is a phenomenon, perception and behaviour. Effect
  • f patient admission in ICU on relatives’ feelings

29 Aug 2018 13 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-14
SLIDE 14

Therapy question template

In P (patients with a certain disease) what are (O) the effects (beneficial and adverse) of E (new or experimental intervention) as compared to C (control intervention)?

29 Aug 2018 14 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-15
SLIDE 15

Formulation of a therapy question

29 Aug 2018 15 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-16
SLIDE 16

Therapy question-2

Is papaya extract effective in dengue fever?

  • In patients of dengue fever with severe thrombocytopenia(P)
  • does administration of papaya extract(I)
  • reduce the rate of bleeding (O)
  • compared to placebo(C)?

29 Aug 2018 16 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-17
SLIDE 17

Formulation of an etiology question

29 Aug 2018 17 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-18
SLIDE 18

Harm Question

  • In (P) patients with snake bite ,
  • Does applying a tight tourniquet (E) increase the
  • Risk of complications in the limb (O)

29 Aug 2018 18 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-19
SLIDE 19

Characteristics of a good research question:

The FINER criteria:

  • Feasible: Adequate subjects, common outcomes, feasible skills,

time, money

  • Interesting : Interests you, interests others(funders)
  • Novel – new findings, confirms, refutes old findings, new

knowledge, may lead to innovations

  • Ethical –Harm to patients? Protection of confidentiality
  • Relevant : likely to have significant impact on knowledge, practice

and policy

29 Aug 2018 19 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-20
SLIDE 20

29 Aug 2018 20 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Where do good questions come from ??

  • Observations and experiences
  • Scholarship and mastering the literature.
  • Being alert to new ideas and techniques
  • Keeping the imagination roaming
  • Choosing and working with a mentor

Hulley Stephen etal.Designing clinical research. 4th edition

29 Aug 2018 21 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-22
SLIDE 22

SEARCHING SCIENTIFIC LITERATURE

29 Aug 2018 22 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-23
SLIDE 23

POINTS TO PONDER

What do you mean by:

  • Websites
  • Search engines
  • Databases

29 Aug 2018 23 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-24
SLIDE 24

What is your experience when you search:

  • Online shopping websites
  • Documents on web
  • A name of an old friend from

school

29 Aug 2018 24 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-25
SLIDE 25

Understanding the needs and available resources

Examples:

  • What is bioethics?
  • What are the current advances in stem cell research?
  • What are the available national and international guidelines
  • n stem cell research?

29 Aug 2018 25 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-26
SLIDE 26

Understanding the needs and available resources

Examples:

  • What is bioethics?
  • What are the current advances in stem cell research?
  • What are the available national and international guidelines
  • n stem cell research?

Dictionary, Wikipedia, textbook, encyclopedia, etc Journals, theses, clinical trials reports, etc National Guidelines, guidelines from

  • ther countries, NIH website, etc

29 Aug 2018 26 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-27
SLIDE 27

Types of resources

When we visit a website there are three types of resources:

  • Type I, II and III resources
  • It may a combination of some or all of these
  • Textbooks are Type I resources
  • Journal articles are Type II resources
  • Systematic reviews are called Type III resources
  • ‘Clinical Key’ is a website which has books, journals,

monographs, guidelines: Mix of all types of resources

29 Aug 2018 27 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-28
SLIDE 28

Important to know

  • What is your need?
  • Is the resource that you have selected useful or not?

KNOW YOUR RESOURCES!!

29 Aug 2018 28 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-29
SLIDE 29

Then ……………..INDEX MEDICUS

29 Aug 2018 29 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-30
SLIDE 30

AND NOW ……………..PUBMED

29 Aug 2018 30 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-31
SLIDE 31

29 Aug 2018 31 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-32
SLIDE 32

Comparing Google Scholar & PubMed

Google Scholar

  • It is a search engine & not

database

  • It includes conference proceedings,

books, reports , etc

  • Author, data, journal info accuracy

is variable

  • There is no ‘tagging’ possible as it

takes it as keyword eg: ‘review’

  • Search is not reproducible

PubMed

  • It is a human-curated database of

journal articles

  • Journals are included after a

literature review committee

  • Author, title, date, journal name

entered in a uniform structured way

  • Tags are possible
  • Search is reproducible

29 Aug 2018 32 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-33
SLIDE 33

LET US ALL EXPLORE GOOGLE SCHOLAR

29 Aug 2018 33 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-34
SLIDE 34

What is PubMed

  • Is it a search engine?
  • Is it a collection of journals?
  • Is it a collection of journal articles?
  • Does it have only ‘English’ journal articles?

THE ANSWER TO ALL THESE IS NO

29 Aug 2018 34 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-35
SLIDE 35

It is an INDEX to published articles What is an INDEX? Where is it located in a textbook?

29 Aug 2018 35 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-36
SLIDE 36

Index

  • An “index” is a resource that tells us what is published about

a topic, in one or more resources.

  • A book’s index is usually found at the end of the book.

Various topics are listed alphabetically.

  • Aspects of each topic may also be listed. For every topic or its

aspect, the indexer indicates in which page/s of the book we will find coverage about them.

  • Eg – “Diabetic neuropathy – 59”. This means that we will find

something about diabetic neuropathy in page 59

29 Aug 2018 36 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-37
SLIDE 37

PubMed is an Index

  • We can search and discover articles about the term or

concept we are searching for

  • Result of the search includes ‘bibliographic details’
  • These include: title of article, author name/s, journal,

volume, issue, page number etc.

  • It has more than 27 million records in its database
  • It is created and maintained by the National Library of

Medicine, located in Maryland, USA

29 Aug 2018 37 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-38
SLIDE 38

29 Aug 2018 38 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-39
SLIDE 39

29 Aug 2018 39 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-40
SLIDE 40

FOUR PRINCIPLES OF SEARCHING PUBMED:

29 Aug 2018 40 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-41
SLIDE 41

Principle I (Word Search)

29 Aug 2018 41 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-42
SLIDE 42
  • There are 27.3 million records
  • Each record contains words like:
  • Euthanasia
  • Stem cell research
  • Vulnerable population
  • Children
  • Pregnant mothers
  • Animal rights

29 Aug 2018 42 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-43
SLIDE 43

29 Aug 2018 43 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-44
SLIDE 44

It only CONTAINS the word ‘vulnerable’ and ‘population

29 Aug 2018 44 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-45
SLIDE 45

Word search

When we search PubMed with a word or a phrase, the results contain our search It may not be about our search To make it about our search : MeSH Medical Subject Headings

29 Aug 2018 45 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-46
SLIDE 46

Principle II: MeSH Search

For results that are about our search terms and not ‘contain’ or search term:

  • Introducing ‘tags’ that describe records
  • MeSH is a ‘controlled vocabulary’ used to index articles for

MEDLINE

  • Consistent way to retrieve information that may use different

terminology to describe the same concept

  • If an article is indexed in MEDLINE, the MeSH term will be

assigned

29 Aug 2018 46 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-47
SLIDE 47

Click this

29 Aug 2018 47 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-48
SLIDE 48
  • This article is about:
  • Ethics of Biomedical Research
  • History of Biomedical Research
  • History of Ethics, Research
  • Star or * indicates these topics

have a ‘MAJOR’ coverage

29 Aug 2018 48 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-49
SLIDE 49

Principle III: Field Search

Asthma IN the Title White as the Author

1302 as Page No 2015 – as Date

29 Aug 2018 49 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-50
SLIDE 50

Understanding the fields in PubMed

Title Author Journal name Year Volume Issue Page Perceptions of people living with HIV/AIDS regarding access to health care Vaswani V Vaswani R Med Law 2014 33 1 64-73

29 Aug 2018 50 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-51
SLIDE 51

Field search

With the anatomy of PubMed entry thus understood, we can instruct it to search words/number in specific fields We do this by ‘tagging’ of by using field names as follows: Social[TI] Social[tiab] Social[Jour] Social[Au] Social[MeSH] 143[page] 2016[pdat] Title Title + abstract Journal title Author List of Mesh terms Page number Date/Year

29 Aug 2018 51 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-52
SLIDE 52

When tagging/field searching

Remember to use:

  • Square brackets []
  • What you type inside is not case sensitive

Principle III: Every item in PubMed is in a structured format, and so can be represented in a structured format like a table. We can search for our search term in specific parts of the record

29 Aug 2018 52 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-53
SLIDE 53

Principle IV: Boolean Operators

29 Aug 2018 53 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-54
SLIDE 54

Using Boolean Operators

  • If I want to find records in PubMed for BOTH:
  • 1. Articles in medical ethics
  • 2. Articles in nursing ethics

Can I search: medical ethics and nursing ethics? Try and search this way and note the numbers that you get About 4500…………..?

29 Aug 2018 54 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-55
SLIDE 55
  • Now try this:

medical ethics[mesh] AND nursing ethics[mesh]

  • Also note the changes in

the ‘search details’ box on the right side

29 Aug 2018 55 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-56
SLIDE 56

Boolean operators

They are the prepositions/conjunctions in the language of PubMed AND OR NOT All in capitals i.e. it is case sensitive

29 Aug 2018 56 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-57
SLIDE 57

Using Boolean operators

Results in PubMed CONTAINING these: 4505 Results in PubMed ABOUT these: 420 Results in PubMed >5500 The records are about minimum one term Results are about medical ethics but NOT nursing ethics

29 Aug 2018 57 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-58
SLIDE 58

Another example:

Records containing Asthma

10

Records containing Bronchitis

7

29 Aug 2018 58 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-59
SLIDE 59

Asthma AND Bronchitis

Records containing Asthma

10

Records containing Bronchitis

7

4

29 Aug 2018 59 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-60
SLIDE 60

Asthma OR Bronchitis

29 Aug 2018 60 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-61
SLIDE 61

Asthma NOT Bronchitis

29 Aug 2018 61 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-62
SLIDE 62

Principle IV

When searching for two or more terms, use ‘Boolean

  • perators’

AND Results contain terms together, there are less results OR Results contain at least one term of the both, there will be more results NOT Results contain the first term, and do not contain the rest , less results

29 Aug 2018 62 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-63
SLIDE 63

Quick recap and exercises

I want to read up articles by Prof Ruth Faden on social justice Faden, Ruth[Au] AND social justice[MeSH] I want to read up articles by her from journal of medical ethics Faden, Ruth[Au] AND Journal of Medical Ethics [jour]

29 Aug 2018 63 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-64
SLIDE 64

I need to quickly read something about professionalism and social justice professionalism[ti] AND social justice[ti] Search results: only 4 professionalism[tiab] AND social justice[tiab] Search results: 49

29 Aug 2018 64 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-65
SLIDE 65

SEARCHING WITH MESH TERMS

29 Aug 2018 65 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-66
SLIDE 66

MeSH..ing around……….

  • MeSH is the controlled vocabulary used to index

articles for MEDLINE.

  • It provides a consistent way to retrieve information

that may use different terminology to describe the same concept.

  • If an article is indexed for MEDLINE the MeSH terms

will be assigned as keywords to each of the indexed articles.

29 Aug 2018 66 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-67
SLIDE 67

MeSH..ing around……….

  • If we search for articles using MeSH headings alone, you will

find only those articles that have been indexed for MeSH terms.

  • We will miss those articles that are PubMed, but not indexed

for MEDLINE, as they will not have MeSH terms assigned to their records.

29 Aug 2018 67 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-68
SLIDE 68

Exploring the Mesh Data base

  • Two ways to access it:

29 Aug 2018 68 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-69
SLIDE 69

Where do these MeSH come from? What are they?

  • Trained indexers analyze the content of the articles
  • They assign MeSH terms and subheadings
  • Arranged in a hierarchical manner called MeSH Tree

Structure

  • It is updated annually

29 Aug 2018 69 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-70
SLIDE 70

Understanding the Anatomy of MeSH

Lets try and search: ‘professionalism’

29 Aug 2018 70 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-71
SLIDE 71

Understanding the Anatomy of MeSH

Scope Note

29 Aug 2018 71 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-72
SLIDE 72

Understanding MeSH terminologies

MeSH vocabulary:

  • 1. Scope Note
  • 2. Subheadings
  • 3. Entry terms
  • 4. MeSH tree
  • 5. Option to restrict to major topic
  • 6. Options for MeSH tree restriction

29 Aug 2018 72 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-73
SLIDE 73

MeSH Vocabulary

  • MeSH headings: Scope Note
  • It is just below the term we

chose

  • Tells us the meaning of the term
  • It also gives useful information
  • f what other MeSH terms that

describe the condition, what the indexers would not include, etc

  • Useful to read the scope note

when doing a focused research

29 Aug 2018 73 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-74
SLIDE 74

Scope Note: some unique examples

29 Aug 2018 74 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-75
SLIDE 75

MeSH Vocabulary

  • MeSH Subheadings
  • Describe a specific aspect of a

concept

  • When we view a MeSH term, we
  • nly see subheading applicable

to that MeSH term

  • Eg: For Bioethics
  • Education
  • History
  • Organization and administration
  • trends

29 Aug 2018 75 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-76
SLIDE 76

MeSH Vocabulary: Subheadings

29 Aug 2018 76 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-77
SLIDE 77

MeSH Vocabulary

  • MeSH Entry Terms
  • These are synonyms, alternate

forms and other closely related terms

  • These are generally used

interchangeably

  • Eg: For Bioethics
  • Health Care Ethics,
  • Ethics, Health Care
  • Biomedical Ethics

29 Aug 2018 77 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-78
SLIDE 78

Understanding MeSH: Hierarchy/Tree

29 Aug 2018 78 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-79
SLIDE 79

MeSH Tree

  • From broad to narrow terms like

branches of a tree

  • Lower terms become more

specific

  • Sometimes it may not have

lower terms

  • Differentiate it with subheadings

which are aspects of a MeSH term

29 Aug 2018 79 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-80
SLIDE 80

MeSH: Restrict to Major Topic

  • When we choose a MeSH term

and search, it automatically includes a search of all the lower terms

  • Check: Restrict to MeSH Major

topic

  • It will include articles where the

article is majorly about it

  • It will have star * in the MeSH

terms below the abstract

29 Aug 2018 80 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-81
SLIDE 81

Restrict to major & Do not include MeSH below this term

29 Aug 2018 81 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-82
SLIDE 82

Recap

We just learned:

  • The MeSH terms
  • Subheadings
  • Entry terms
  • MeSH tree
  • Restrict to major option
  • Do not include MeSH terms found below this term in MeSH

hierarchy

29 Aug 2018 82 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-83
SLIDE 83

Hands On exercises

Do the following searches:

  • 1. History of human rights
  • 2. Focused search on history of human rights
  • 3. Human rights: general articles, not the more specific types
  • f child rights, patient rights, etc

29 Aug 2018 83 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-84
SLIDE 84

Building search using MeSH

The PubMed search box here

29 Aug 2018 84 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-85
SLIDE 85

Using the MeSH search box

  • Search one term at a time
  • Add each term to the search builder
  • Search PubMed after building the search
  • One can also choose subheadings under the MeSH term

29 Aug 2018 85 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-86
SLIDE 86

PUBMED: Narrowing or Focusing Search

Let us explore the following:

  • Understanding the available filters
  • Applying filters
  • Applying filters with Boolean operators
  • Single citation matcher page

29 Aug 2018 86 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-87
SLIDE 87

Scope of filters

  • By default two types of articles are available
  • Clinical trials and review
  • You can even customize
  • Click and explore the customize option

29 Aug 2018 87 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-88
SLIDE 88

Scope of filters

  • Abstract: the results will contain only those

that have an abstract

  • Free full text: what does it mean
  • Full text: Free as well non-free full text
  • Everytime you apply the filter, note the

changes that occur in the search box

29 Aug 2018 88 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-89
SLIDE 89

Scope of filters

  • Filter by dates helps in further narrowing
  • Explore the customize range
  • Combines the search with AND

humans[mesh]

29 Aug 2018 89 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-90
SLIDE 90

Scope of filters

  • Languages: PubMed has articles in other

languages other than English

  • Sex
  • Subjects: It has nine different subjects
  • Journal categories: helps in finding nursing,

dental journals and core clinical journals

  • Ages

29 Aug 2018 90 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-91
SLIDE 91

PubMed: Display Formats

  • The default display when we search is the ‘Summary format’
  • The results are shown in the order of ‘Most Recent’
  • There will be 20 results per page
  • All these can be changed

29 Aug 2018 91 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-92
SLIDE 92

29 Aug 2018 92 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-93
SLIDE 93

29 Aug 2018 93 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-94
SLIDE 94

CREATING MY NCBI ACCOUNT AND SAVING SEARCH STRATEGIES AND SEARCH RESULTS

29 Aug 2018 94 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-95
SLIDE 95
  • Go to PubMed – www.pubmed.gov
  • Click Sign in to NCBI

29 Aug 2018 95 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-96
SLIDE 96
  • If you have a gmail / google account,

click “sign in with google” and follow steps to register

  • If not, click “Register for an NCBI

Account” and create your account

29 Aug 2018 96 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-97
SLIDE 97

Steps for My NCBI Account

  • Choose “Sign in with google”
  • Enter your gmail / google login

and password

  • In the next screen click ‘accept’
  • In the next screen click ‘Create a

new NCBI account’ and click ‘continue’.

  • In 5 second the page will

automatically redirect to the PubMed Home page.

  • Click – ‘Register for an NCBI

account’

  • Fill in all details and create your

account

  • (Look out for any message that

says your user name is already taken)

29 Aug 2018 97 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-98
SLIDE 98

Setting Preferences

  • Under Common Preferences

– Click Highlighting – Choose a colour – Click Save (at the end of the page)

  • Click the Back button to go to the PubMed Home Page

29 Aug 2018 98 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-99
SLIDE 99

Saving Search Strategies

Demonstration: ("Nursing Care"[Mesh]) AND "Bioethics"[Mesh]

29 Aug 2018 99 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-100
SLIDE 100

Saving Search Strategy

  • We got 58 search results
  • Click create alert just below the search box
  • In the next page: choices are available
  • By default the name of the search will be search strategy
  • You can change it to more meaningful title

29 Aug 2018 100 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-101
SLIDE 101

Type meaningful title here You can even receive email alerts You can choose the format of your search results with or without abstracts, HTML, etc Number you want to receive

29 Aug 2018 101 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-102
SLIDE 102

Saving Search results

  • The options available are:
  • Emails
  • File if you want it saved in your computer
  • Clipboard allows temporary storage

29 Aug 2018 102 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-103
SLIDE 103
  • Summary: same as it appears in

default PubMed search

  • Abstract: along with abstracts
  • MEDLINE format: Reference

management

  • XML format if to be taken to a

website

  • PMID list
  • CSV format: to bring it to Excel

format

29 Aug 2018 103 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-104
SLIDE 104
  • If large number of results you

can use the check boxes

  • If you copy to clip board: next

page with show the message: copied to clip board

  • You can even remove from clip

board

29 Aug 2018 104 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-105
SLIDE 105
  • You may choose to add it

your NCBI account

  • Click on Collections
  • Next: Add to collections
  • Here the page is

redirected

  • If it is a new collection,

‘create new collection’

  • Save
  • Access any time from My

NCBI

29 Aug 2018 105 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-106
SLIDE 106

29 Aug 2018 106 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-107
SLIDE 107

Managing collection

  • Collections are on the right lower corner
  • As you create more collections, you may delete the old ones

that are not required

  • Manage collection offers merging and deleting options

29 Aug 2018 107 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-108
SLIDE 108

Saving search results: Email

  • Choosing display format
  • Sort order
  • Number of items: Max is 200
  • Start from citation: this option is

because it allows only 200 items

  • So the next batch of items can

be from 201

  • You make the subject more

readable

29 Aug 2018 108 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-109
SLIDE 109
  • Option ‘Order’ not very usefult

in India, but in US you can order through the libraries

  • My Bibliography: to save your
  • wn publications

29 Aug 2018 109 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-110
SLIDE 110

Explore the Single Citation Matcher

29 Aug 2018 110 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-111
SLIDE 111

Exercises for Single Citation Matcher

Search the following:

  • 1. Articles by Dr Anant Bhan on trials
  • 2. Article on publication ethics in Indian Journal of Medical

Ethics

  • 3. Articles on publication ethics in 2017
  • 4. Indian journal of ophthalmology: 2017 Jun; 65(6)

29 Aug 2018 111 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-112
SLIDE 112

PubMed Advanced Search

If we choose to add MeSH terms or entry terms and use Boolean Operators

29 Aug 2018 112 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-113
SLIDE 113

Exercise and Demonstration

Building search using a research question RQ: What is the treatment outcome patients with tuberculosis and diabetes? Tease out the following:

  • Important concepts
  • MeSH terms
  • Text words
  • Make a table for ready reference at later date

29 Aug 2018 113 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-114
SLIDE 114

Concept MeSH terms Text words (can copy paste entry terms)

29 Aug 2018 114 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-115
SLIDE 115

Concept MeSH terms Text words (can copy paste entry terms)

tuberculosis Tuberculosis[MeSH] Tuberculosis TB Koch’s disease diabetes Diabetes Mellitus[mesh] Diabetes Mellitus DM Hyperglycemia Hyperglycaemia High blood sugar Treatment

  • utcomes

Treatment

  • utcome[mesh]

Death[mesh] Treatment outcome Loss to follow-up Death Clinical effectiveness* Patient relevant outcome* *means truncation and can have things such as clinical effectivenesses

29 Aug 2018 115 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-116
SLIDE 116

Hands-on practice

Exercise: We need to find articles by Prof Ruth Faden in the field of women’s health

29 Aug 2018 116 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-117
SLIDE 117

29 Aug 2018 117 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-118
SLIDE 118

To Sum up

  • Focused research question
  • Identifying PICO
  • Identifying MeSH terms
  • Searching efficiently in PubMed
  • Single citation matcher
  • Advance builder
  • Saving searches in various ways

29 Aug 2018 118 Anurag & Madhavi Bhargava

slide-119
SLIDE 119

HAPPY SEARCHING