Robert (Bob) DeBroux, Chair Kim Keenan, Vice Chair July 20, 2017 - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Robert (Bob) DeBroux, Chair Kim Keenan, Vice Chair July 20, 2017

 Ident ntify p patte tterns of of specific i ins nstances of of acti tion ons a at t the the s sta tate a and nd lo local l le level t l that s serv rve as ba barrie rriers t to bro broadba dband de d deplo ployment For example, deployment moratoria, unfair or burdensome rights-of-way negotiation ◦ and approval processes, excessive fees and other costs, unreasonable conditions, and bad faith negotiation practices Provide recommendations to the Commission on how to address the patterns of ◦ specific instances identified.  Ident ntify e examp mples a and nd d discus uss the the c cons onsequences of of loc ocal gov overnmental r restricti tion ons tha that ma may “p “prohi ohibit or t or ha have the the e effect of t of pro prohibit ibitin ing” s service For example, requiring “undergrounding for wireless facilities,” placing restrictions on ◦ the placement of communications facilities in a right of way, prohibiting upgrades to facilities, and prohibiting the placement of new poles in a right-of-way Recommend solutions ◦  Exami mine the the e extent to to whi hich muni municipalities ma may sing ngle out out communi unicati tions ons-rela lated de d deplo ployments f for r more re bu burde rdensome tr treatm tment t tha than othe other d deploy oyments tha that ha t have the the s same me or or simi milar imp mpacts ts on on land nd us use Make recommendations for addressing such disparate outcomes ◦ 2

 Work rking Gro Group ( p (WG) G) m meets w weekly ly  Effor orts to to date te ha have f foc ocus used on on ident ntifying s sta tate/loc ocal b barriers to to bro broadba dband de d deplo ployment f fro rom WG G membe bers ◦ Responded to an internally designed survey regarding stakeholders experiences and suggested recommendations with state/local entities ◦ 189 examples provided  Recent e effor orts ts ha have f foc ocus used on on the the F FCC comme omments f filed i in n tw two o recen ent p proceed eedings gs ◦ Created a data subgroup to review and summarize 202 sets of comments  Completion date: July 24 th ◦ Qualitative analysis will be undertaken to identify patterns, root causes, and recommended solutions 3

Quantitativ ive and d qu qualit litativ ive a analy lysis o of the da data will ill le lead d to for ormul mulating r recom ommendation ons  Quantitative Analysis ◦ Tabulate the number of comments citing barriers by the main categories and other factors ◦ Identifies the patterns that exist but does not fully describe the root causes and rationale for such barriers  Qualitative Analysis ◦ Provides a method for evaluating the information to determine—  Why does the barrier exist-root causes and rationale?  What is the consequence of the barrier?  How have some states/localities dealt with such barriers?  What solutions have been recommended? Result ltant f fin indin dings w will ill be be dis discussed t d to form rmulate recomme mmend ndati tions ons 4

April 21 June 6 Initial BDAC meeting July 20 Working Group (WG) Initial Meeting July 24 Mid-term BDAC Weekly WG Status meeting August 16 and Updates calls FCC comment review completed. Face-to-Face Begin analysis of Meeting to regulatory barriers continue analysis and develop recommendations 5

 Recommendations Format  Questions? 6

Chair: r: Robert rt DeBrou roux, TD TDS Te Telecom Mar ark Johnson, The Quilt Tim im U Ulr lrich* Virg rginia Lam Abra rams, Starry rry Vice ce-Cha hair: Kim Keena nan, n, Multicul ultur ural Sam m Licc ccard rdo, Mayor or - Cit ity of of San Jos ose, Media ia, T Tele lecom and Inte ternet C t Council il Calif ifornia ia Christ stianna nna Barnhar nhart, Char arter Dolan Beckel el* Audrey ey Conner ers* Shiree een Sant ntosham ham* Eliz izabeth th B Bowle les, A Aris isto totl tle Danna nna MacKenzie ie, Min innesota Office of of Randy ndy Brog rogle, Zayo yo Broadban adband d Deve velopm pment nt Kyle Burgess, s, Consum nsumers' Rese search Rebe becca Murphy phy Thomps pson, n, Compe petitive Rick k Cime merma man, N NCTA CTA Carrie iers rs A Associa iation on Bill ill Esbeck, Wis isconsin Sta tate te Kevin in Pa Pagan, C City ty Att Attorney, Mc McAllen, Texas Telecommuni unicat ations A s Asso ssociation Vict ctor or Flore ores* Valerie Fast st Horse se, Coeur ur d'Alene ne Tribe be Aust ustin Stevens nson* n* Dr. G Georg orge F Ford rd, T The P Phoe oenix Center f r for Mark k Radaba dabaug ugh, W Wireless I Internet S Service Adva vanc nced d Legal and d Econo nomic Publ blic Policy Prov oviders rs A Associ ociation on Studi udies Michael l Santorelli lli, Director, Advanc dvanced d Marc rc Gan Ganzi, , ExteN eNet Systems ms Communi unicat ations ns Law & Policy Inst stitut ute, New Antho hony ny Le Lehv* York Law S School ool Carl rlos os Gutierre rrez, LGBT Tech chnol olog ogy Dr. John Saw Dr aw, Spr print Partne nershi ship & p & Inst stitut ute Charles M McKee* e* Micha hael Hain, n, Nitta ttany Media ia Berin in Szo Szoka, , TechFre reedom om Andy dy Huckaba aba, C City of Lene nexa K a KS Graha aham Owens* Marc rc Hudson on, Rock cket Fiber Sanj njay ay Udan dani, Verizo zon Paul l Vasin ingto ton* * = A Alte lternate te 7