10/13/2011 Promoting Comprehension for Students with for Students with Severe Disabilities Melissa Hudson, MA.Ed, ABD Diane M. Browder, PhD Idaho Webinar October 19, 2011 1 Reading and Comprehension • Reading requires: o Decoding written text o Can compensate for lack of skill with AT or peers o AND o Comprehending meaning o Hard to augment if skills are lacking Hudson & Browder 2011 2 1
10/13/2011 Comprehension Applies to All Levels of Literacy • Early Literacy • Beginning Readers – Engagement with books E t ith b k – Students who can St d t h and read alouds independently decode the text • Can be promoting understanding of text • Some students may be during these shared “word readers” with little readings understanding • Comprehension strategies are critical for these skills to be useable Hudson & Browder 2011 3 Reading and Comprehension • Most research on reading comprehension for students with significant intellectual disability t d t ith i ifi t i t ll t l di bilit focused on word recognition and picture identification (Browder, Wakeman, Spooner, Ahlgrim ‐ Delzell, & Algozzine, 2006) Browder, D., Wakeman, S., Spooner, F., Ahlgrim-Delzell, L., & Algozzine, B. (2006). Research on reading instruction for individuals with significant cognitive disabilities. Exceptional Children , 72 , 392-408. Hudson & Browder 2011 4 2
10/13/2011 Promoting Comprehension • NRP recommends 6 strategies for promoting comprehension comprehension 1. Comprehension monitoring 2. Cooperative learning 3. Graphic and semantic organizers 4. Question answering* 5 5. Question generation Q ti ti 6. Summarizing * Most research for this population done in question answering National Institute of Child Health and Human Development. (2000). Report of the National Reading Panel. Hudson & Browder 2011 5 Two Types of Text • Narrative text • Expository text – Purpose is to tell a story P i t t ll t – Primary purpose is to P i i t inform – Examples: – Examples: • Novels • Short stories • Content like science, social studies • biographies • News articles Hudson & Browder 2011 6 3
10/13/2011 Narrative Text has Story Elements • Character • Setting • Problem or conflict ‐ goal of the main character • Plot ‐ sequence of events • Ending or resolution • Main idea ‐ what the story is about (the ‘gist’) • Theme encompassing concept • Theme ‐ encompassing concept • Author’s point of view Hudson & Browder 2011 7 Expository Text • Some expository text (e.g., history) also has story elements (e.g,. Characters, setting, plot) t l t ( Ch t tti l t) • All expository text has: – Main idea – Theme – Information Information – Author’s point of view Hudson & Browder 2011 8 4
10/13/2011 Check for Understanding • As Agnes turned onto Green Pond Rd, she was looking forward to her warm house She might looking forward to her warm house. She might eat some cookies. After she passed the house on the corner, she saw it. Her front door was open! She gasped and felt her stomach leap. She began to run towards the door. Who was in her house? As she got close, there was her in her house? As she got close, there was her neighbor’s goat looking out the window. She laughed. Once gain Speckles, the neighborhood pest, had come for a visit. Hudson & Browder 2011 9 Bloom’s Taxonomy • Comprehension involves acquiring knowledge • Bloom’s cognitive objectives are universal and apply to all populations l t ll l ti • Sequential ‐ all levels are not introduced at once • Instruction is differentiated by: o Increasing text difficulty o Type of Questions o Vocabulary o Question format o Response mode Hudson & Browder 2011 10 5
10/13/2011 Bloom’s Taxonomy Bloom, Englehart, Furst, Hill, & Krathwohl, 1956 Bloom’s Taxonomy Evaluation Judge according to some standard S Synthesis th i Combine parts into a C bi t i t whole Analysis Break down into parts Application Use materials in a new way or slant Comprehension Translate, interpret, and extrapolate extrapolate Knowledge Recall, recognize, draw out facts Hudson & Browder 2011 11 Comprehension Questions Based on Bloom’s Taxonomy • Knowledge • Answers are “on the page” A “ h ” Easy Medium More Difficult Point to title, “Who is the story “Who else is in the author . . about?” story?” (supporting Point to picture “What did they put characters) of . . . in the soup? I Immediate recall: di t ll “Jill went up the hill. Who went up the hill?” Hudson & Browder 2011 12 6
10/13/2011 Comprehension Questions Based on Bloom’s Taxonomy • Comprehension • Answers can be inferred from what is on page Easy Medium Most Difficult “What happened “Put these events “Put these last?” in order as first, pictures in order second, last.” to show what happened in the pp story (more than 3 pictures).” Hudson & Browder 2011 13 Comprehension Questions Based on Bloom’s Taxonomy • Application • Requires student’s own background knowledge Easy Medium Most Difficult “The bear is eating. “Buck loved his “This article is Are you eating?” home. How do you about whales. feel about your feel about your Where do whales Where do whales home?” live? What else do you know about whales?” Hudson & Browder 2011 14 7
10/13/2011 Comprehension Questions Based on Bloom’s Taxonomy • Analysis • Breaking the information into parts B ki h i f i i Easy Medium Most Difficult “Let’s put these “Let’s make a “When the girls pictures into two picture diagram for laughed at Renee, columns. One what we know how did the girls column is for what about each person feel? How did Sara did in the story Sara did in the story in our story in our story. Renee feel?” Renee feel? and the other ‘hunting’ Who went column is for what hunting?” you do.” Hudson & Browder 2011 15 Comprehension Questions Based on Bloom’s Taxonomy • Synthesis • Combining the parts into a whole Easy Medium Most Difficult “Show me the “What might be “What will happen picture of what this another title for to people if they story was about.” this story? have no job?” (from a news ( story). Hudson & Browder 2011 16 8
10/13/2011 Comprehension Questions Based on Bloom’s Taxonomy • Evaluation • Making a judgment according to some • Making a judgment according to some standard Easy Medium Most Difficult “What did you “Did this really “Why did the think about this happen or is it author write this?” story?” (states an story?” (states an fiction?” fiction?” (to persuade (to persuade, opinion). entertain) Hudson & Browder 2011 17 Writing Objectives • Use language from Bloom’s taxonomy The student will . . . Knowledge Comprehension Application Analysis Synthesis Evaluation define describe articulate calculate adapt appraise describe discuss assess classify assemble assess identify estimate compute compare collaborate critique list explain construct contrast compose defend name generalize determine correlate create interpret recall eca locate oca e develop deve op diagram d ag a design des g judge judge record paraphrase employ differentiate formulate justify relate recognize relate discriminate integrate rate state restate solve infer model reframe select summarize translate outline rearrange support Browder, D. M., Spooner, F., & Meyer, C. (2011). Comprehension across the curriculum. In D. M. Browder & F. Spooner (Eds.), Curriculum and instruction for students with severe disabilities: Finding the balance . New York: Guilford Press. Hudson & Browder 2011 18 9
10/13/2011 Checking for Understanding • What level of Bloom’s is each question from th the story about Agnes ‐ t b t A – What might Agnes have been thinking when she saw the open door? – Who was looking out the window of Agnes house? – Who opened the front door? – Do you have any pests in your neighborhood like Speckles? What do they do? Hudson & Browder 2011 19 Teaching Comprehension • Select and prepare texts o Age ‐ and grade ‐ level appropriate o Adapt novels (narrative) and academic content (expository) literature using text summaries, embedded pictures, and repeated story lines Hudson & Browder 2011 20 10
10/13/2011 Before reading Strategies • Develop background knowledge o With activities to enrich students’ understanding of themes and concepts (e.g., movie clips, experiments, hands ‐ on activities) • Teach key vocabulary words and concepts Hudson & Browder 2011 21 Before and After Reading Strategies • Make predictions (be sure to review question and revise prediction if necessary) • Book walk Hudson & Browder 2011 22 11
10/13/2011 Using Questions • Questions can be: o Literal (e.g., pulled from the page) o Textually inferential (e.g., not right on the page, but can be inferred from the story alone) o Inferential (e.g., student must use background knowledge not contained in the text; from your head) Hudson & Browder 2011 23 Question Formats • Students who can • Students who need generate answers (e.g., generate answers (e g options (e.g., select options (e g select speak or type out pictures/words on AAC) response on AAC) – Use multiple choice – Ask the question and let – May use 4 choice array student give you the – May use response board answer with more options for p each story Hudson & Browder 2011 24 12
Recommend
More recommend
