Perspectives on Skill Gaps, Shortages, and Mismatches
Oregon Talent Assessment Perspectives on Skill Gaps, Shortages, and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Oregon Talent Assessment Perspectives on Skill Gaps, Shortages, and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Oregon Talent Assessment Perspectives on Skill Gaps, Shortages, and Mismatches Talent has supported strong job growth Total nonfarm employment, indexed (June 2009 = 100), Oregon and U.S. 125 Oregon U.S. 120 Oregon 115 110 U.S. 105 100
Talent has supported strong job growth
Data source: American Community Survey PUMS
80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120 125 2 9
- 6
- 1
2 9
- 1
2
- 1
2 1
- 6
- 1
2 1
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 1
- 6
- 1
2 1 1
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 2
- 6
- 1
2 1 2
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 3
- 6
- 1
2 1 3
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 4
- 6
- 1
2 1 4
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 5
- 6
- 1
2 1 5
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 6
- 6
- 1
2 1 6
- 1
2
- 1
2 1 7
- 6
- 1
2 1 7
- 1
2
- 1
Oregon U.S.
Total nonfarm employment, indexed (June 2009 = 100), Oregon and U.S. Oregon U.S.
Skill Problems
- Skill Gaps: Widespread shortfalls in basic skills
usually associated with a failure of the education system
- Skill Shortages: Shortfall of skills required by
specific occupations
- Skill Mismatches: Supply and demand for skills
is out of sync in either direction–oversupply or undersupply Categories of Skill Problems
Skill Gaps: Employers’ Perspectives
5 33% 57% 57% 71% 76% 77% 80% 83% 92% 100% 100% 77% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Outdoor Gear and Apparel Bioscience C
- nstruction
Food and Beverage T echnology and Software Development Healthcare Advanced Manufacturing Other W
- od Products
Energy Maritime All Sectors
Percent of survey respondents, by industry, who agree that applicants have the basic skills required for vacant positions
Agree Disagree Don't Know/ Not Applicable
Skill Gaps: What the Data Say
Data source: US Census; American Community Survey PUMS
Master's+ Bachelor's AA / some college No HS diploma HS diploma = 1
Skill Shortages: Employers’ Perspectives
7
13% 14% 24% 24% 32% 34% 63% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Basic computer literacy General office software C
- mputer software
Machine operation Basic communication/ writing Project management C ritical/ analy tical thinking
Percent of survey respondents who identified specific hard or occupation skills that are hard to find
Skill Shortages: Employers’ Perspectives
8
17% 36% 44% 57% 63% 65% 71% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Honesty T eamwork Leadership T ime management Dependability Motivation C
- mmunication skills
Percent of survey respondents who identified specific soft or interpersonal skills that are hard to find
Skill Shortages: What the Data Say
Data source: US Bureau of Labor Statistics
Distribution of Oregon occupations by percentage point change in real median hourly wage, 2016 to 2017
Skill Mismatches: What the Data Say
Data source: American Community Survey PUMS data and Oregon Employment Department
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% W Y HI VT NV NH SC FL OR KS NM MT AK RI ME C O KY NC OK AR T N NY LA IL MO C A NJ IN PA DE MD GA MN MI W A VA C T SD W I U T OH T X AZ NE ID MA AL IA W V MS ND DC U.S.: 56%
Share of college-educated 23-29 year old workers in occupations requiring college degrees
The Outlook
Source: American Community Survey PUMS data; Ross & Holmes (2017), The Brookings Institution.
Sidelined Talent Late in the Economic Expansion
Job Market Rewarding Humans for Being Human
Actual Predicted
Source: Deming, D.J. (2017). The Growing Importance of Social Skills in the Labor Market. Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 132 issue 4.
High Social, High Math High Social, Low Math Low Social, High Math Low Social, Low Math
2017-2027 Job Projections by Skill Emphasis
14
More emphasis on communication and critical thinking More emphasis
- n clerical and
service work More emphasis on physical work More emphasis on
- perating machines
and processes
2017-2027 Job Projections by Skill Emphasis
15
More emphasis on communication and critical thinking More emphasis
- n clerical and
service work More emphasis on physical work More emphasis on
- perating machines
and processes
Data sources: O*NET, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Oregon Employment Department, the Oregon Talent Plan
2017-2027 Job Projections by Skill Emphasis
16
More emphasis on communication and critical thinking More emphasis
- n clerical and
service work More emphasis on physical work More emphasis on
- perating machines
and processes
Data sources: O*NET, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Oregon Employment Department, the Oregon Talent Plan
The Work Ahead
- 1. Humans have to get better at being human, which
has broad implications for education and training delivery.
The Work Ahead
- 2. “Known knowns” in the occupational and skill
forecasts are limited—but exist. They create the space for employer-educator collaboration (e.g., around project management, communication, and writing skills, plus occupations that serve an aging demography, hard-to-automate occupations, and occupations that will serve a growing state).
The Work Ahead
- 3. Oregonians who are unemployed or underemployed