MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
MCSAP Planning Conference & Grants Training Minneapolis - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
MCSAP Planning Conference & Grants Training Minneapolis - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training 2017 MCSAP Planning Conference & Grants Training Minneapolis Marriott City Center March 22, 2017 MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training 2017 Agenda Review of FAST Act Highlights
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Review of FAST Act Highlights & Implementation
- Multi-year CVSP’s
- Formula Working Group
- Other provisions
- MCSAP Grant Update
- Current funding increment
- Future Status
- High Priority Grant Update
- Inspection Modernization
- Overview of Conference Topics
4/7/2017 2
Agenda
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
FAST Act Review and Update
3
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Became law on December 4, 2015
- Pub. L. No. 114-94 (Dec. 4, 2015); Title V, Motor Carrier Safety
- Several provisions impacting FMCSA Grant Programs
- Consolidation – Seven programs restructured into two
MCSAP High Priority
Pre-FAST FAST
4
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- MCSAP Expanded:
- Now includes New Entrant, Border and components of other discretionary
enforcement programs
- High Priority Grant Program expanded to include:
- Information Technology Deployments (ITD)
- Data Quality
- Performance and Registration Information Systems Management (PRiSM)
- CMV Safety and Enforcement initiatives (classic High Priority Program)
- MCSAP Formula Working Group
- Development of new MCSAP allocation formula.
- Working Group scheduled to submit new formula recommendation April,
2017
Grant Program Changes – Highlights
5
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Interim Funding Formula
- Prior to development of new allocation formula (use in FY 2017 – FY2018?)
- Calculate funding using MCSAP formula used in FY 2016; PLUS
- Average funding awarded to a State for FY 2013, 2014, & 2015 for Border & New
Entrant grant awards
- Federal share for FMCSA grant programs is now at least 85 percent.
- States are required to establish a New Entrant Safety Audit Program
and participate in PRISM.
- Traffic Enforcement
- States may use up to 10% for non-CMV enforcement
- Ensuring safe operation of CMV’s
- Must maintain average minimum level of CMV safety activities from FY 2004 & 2005
- Higher percentage possible with Secretary approval
Grant Program Changes – Highlights
6
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Commercial Vehicle Safety Plans (required for MCSAP funds)
- CVSPs must be posted on FMCSA website within 30 days of approval
- Multi-year Plans may be submitted (FMCSA Beta testing this Fall)
- Must redact sensitive information the States request be removed
- Enroute inspection of CMVs transporting passengers – weigh
station excluded as acceptable location (unless imminent/obvious hazard)
- Bus station, terminal, border, crossing, maintenance facility, destination, or
- ther location where a motor carrier may make a planned stop.
- Non-Compliance Withholding
- Staggered for substantial noncompliance
- 5, 10, 25, then not more than 50%
7
Grant Program Changes – Highlights
4/7/2017 8
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
FAST Act Authorization Levels
FY 16 FY17 FY18 FY19 FY20
MCSAP *$218,000,000 $292,600,000 $298,900,000 $304,300,000 $308,700,000 High Priority Activities Program ** $15,000,000 $42,200,000 $43,100,000 $44,000,000 $44,900,000 CMV Operators ***$1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 CDLPI $30,000,000 $31,200,000 $31,800,000 $32,500,000 $33,200,000 CVISN $25,000,000 Collapses into High Priority Activities FY17-20 BEG $32,000,000 Collapses into MCSAP FY17-20 New Entrant **$32,000,000 Collapses into MCSAP FY17-20 PRISM $5,000,000 Collapses into MCSAP & HP - FY17-20 SADIP $3,000,000 Collapses into MCSAP & HP - FY17-20 Administrative Expenses $267,400,000 $277,200,000 $283,000,000 $284,000,000 $288,000,000 Outreach ****$4,000,000 $4,000,000 $4,000,000 $4,000,000 $4,000,000
*This figure is pre grant consolidation. ** Set aside from MCSAP for FY 2016 *** Set aside from General Operating Expenses (GOE) for FY 2016 **** Outreach’s numbers are a set aside from Administrative Expenses for FY 2016-2021. FY 2015 Administrative Expense levels were $259,000,000, all FY16 grant funding is at FY15 levels. 9
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- FMCSA released Federal Register notice
- October 20, 2016
- Fourteen questions relating to length of plan and other important
facets
- Received twenty-four responses from States and other stakeholders
- Official responses will be posted in Federal Register
- In final review now
- Break-out session to review beta-test plan
- Seeking ten States (have six) and one additional Territory
- Beta testing will start with FY 18 (this year).
- Three-year plan (goals, objectives, etc.) budget for
- Discussion/feedback during session
10
Multi-Year CVSP’s
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 11
MCSAP Formula Working Group
- Established: By Secretary 180 days after enactment.
- Consists of: FMCSA, State lead agencies (must be 51% of group),
an organization representing State agencies, and others
- Submit Recommendations: For new MCSAP allocation formula
within 1 year after establishment
- Interim Funding Formula: Prior to development of new
allocation formula
– Calculate funding amount using MCSAP formula used in FY 2016 – Award average funding to a State for FY 2013, 2014, & 2015 for BEG and NE
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 12
Working Group Members
- Lt. Donald C. Bridge, Jr.
Connecticut Department of Motor Vehicles, MCSAP Coordinator, Commercial Vehicle Safety Division
- Lt. Thomas Fitzgerald
Massachusetts State Police, Commanding Officer, Commercial Vehicle Enforcement Section
- Ms. Michelle N. Lopez
Colorado State Patrol, MCSAP Grants Administrator
- Mr. Alan R. Martin
Ohio Public Utilities Commission, Deputy Director
- Lt. Stephen Brent Moore
Georgia Department of Public Safety, Special Operations Coordinator, Motor Carrier Compliance Division
- Captain Brian Preston
Arizona Department of Public Safety
- Mr. John E. Smoot
Kentucky State Police, MCSAP/Federal Training Coordinator
- Colonel Leroy Taylor
South Carolina Department of Public Safety, Deputy Director
- Ms. Adrienne Gildea
Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance, Deputy Executive Director
- Mr. Stephen C. Owings
Road Safe America, President and Co-Founder
- Ms. Nancy Baugher
FMCSA, Grants Management Officer
- Ms. Caitlin Cullitan
FMCSA, Attorney-Advisor
- Mr. Thomas Liberatore
FMCSA, Chief, State Programs Division
- Ms. Courtney Stevenson
FMCSA, Senior Policy Advisor, Office of Field Operations
- Mr. Dan Meyer
FMCSA, Division Administrator, Illinois Division
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 13
Working Group –Timeline
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Working Group – Development Process
Systematic process for formula design:
- Establish guiding principles for the new formula
- Identify areas in the formula to improve
- Create alternative formula designs
- Evaluate their impacts with respect to the guiding principles
11
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Working Group – Guiding Principles
- Improves upon previous formula
- Addresses FAST Act changes to MCSAP grants
- Meets FAST Act formula requirements
- Safety-based (primary objective)
- Promotes stability in funding
- Responds to changes
- Uses quality data sources
- Responds to changes in overall funding levels
12
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Effort - Focused Analysis
- Considered previous MCSAP allocation formula’s design as
baseline for improvement
- Worked to analyze the elements of that formula and the data
sources used for calculations
- Considered impacts of the grant consolidation and new State match
- The actual percentage of the State match was not part of the Working
Group’s charge as the FAST Act already set forth this amount
- Worked to ensure the formula would continue to provide adequate
funding for the programs now combined into the MCSAP Basic program
13
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Guiding Formula Principles
- FAST Act requirements
- Relative State needs
- Administrative capacities and challenges
- New entrant motor carrier inventory
- Border inspection facilities and CMV border crossings
- Safety-Based
- Centered formula recommendations on safety
- Aimed to reflect today’s safety challenges and maintain valuable safety gains
- Use safety-based factors correlated with crashes and linked to crash-risk
exposure
- Stability
- Considered various provisions to limit wide swings in State funding from
year to year
15
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Working Group – I terative Process
- Identifying and obtaining data sources
- Evaluating data sources to determine if they met the criteria for
formula inclusion, e.g. through statistical analysis
- Reviewing and considering programmatic needs and trends
- Understanding the varying administrative needs of grant
recipients
- Reviewing published reports and studies
- Conducting simulations to evaluate funding impacts
20
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Working Group – Recommendations
- The Working Group is finalizing recommendations submission
- Meeting after conclusion of MCSAP Conference
- Recommendation will be submitted to FMCSA and the
Secretary Tentative Timeline
22
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 20
Fiscal Year 17 MCSAP Funds
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Increment (Phase) 1 Funds
- Total of $96.6 million
- Processing now
- FMCSA time commitment
- All NGA’s should be released by early April
- Future increments based on fund availability
- Current CR
- Grants funded under “pre-FAST” structure
21
Fiscal Year 2017 MCSAP Funds
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 22
B&I = $171M NE = $32M HP = $15M FY 2016 Appropriation BEG = $32M PRISM = $5M CVISN = $25M SADIP = $3M
- Current Appropriation does not align with program consolidation
- Provides approx. 57.5% annualized funding
- Based on FY 16 B & I apportioned amount (see above)
- FMCSA working with DOT-OST, OMB and Congress to address issue
- Requires legislative action
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- FMCSA has received over 100 applications
- HP-CMV (CMV Safety, PRISM, Data Quality)
- HP-ITD
- Currently undergoing evaluation
- Award amounts dependent on availability of funds
- Continuing Resolution
- Recommendations to be submitted for Agency
approval.
- Targeted for early May.
High Priority Grant Status
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 24
Inspection Modernization
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Originally launched in September of 2014
- Formalized project in Summer of 2016
- Recognizes the importance of CMV inspections to FMCSA’s
safety mission
- Project Mission – to improve the current state of FMCSA’s
roadside inspection process and the data infrastructure utilized to conduct and support CMV inspections.
25
Integrated Inspection Management System (IIMS)
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Goals
- Streamline inspection documentation processes to increase
efficiency and effectiveness;
- System(s) integration to improve data communication, reliability and
access; and
- Enhance inspection-related data to support FMCSA safety mission.
- Three Project Phases
- Phase 1: Roadmap/Planning Phase
- Phase 2: Selection/Development Phase – Tentative completion FY
2019/2020 (dependent on agency need and requirements)
- Phase 3: Deployment – FY 2020 (dependent on completion of prior
phases)
26
IIMS - Continued
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
- Outreach to stakeholders
- Contractor - Battelle
- Survey to both Federal and State users
- Both Aspen and third party software States
- Focus-group discussion at CVSA in February
- Battelle working with FMCSA on two reports
- Current State: Assessment of current inspection and data
systems (Due March/April, 2017)
- IIMS Roadmap: Current State plus recommendations on
development solutions (Due May, 2017)
27
IIMS – Current Status
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 28
- “Current State Report” under
FMCSA Review
- Compiles results of outreach
and system assessments
- Summary of “Key Issues”
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 29
Wednesday, March 22 MCSAP PARTNER AND FMCSA MEETING
9:15 – 10:15 Breakout Sessions:
- FMCSA Rulemakings – Updates for MCSAP Partners - (Ballroom 1)
- High Priority Grant – Updates and Information (Ballroom 2)
- Multi-year CVSP’s – Overview and Implementation (Deer/Elk Lake)
10:30 – Noon State Partner Panel Discussion – Activities and Outcomes (Ballroom 3-4) Noon – 1:15 Lunch (on your own) 1:15 – 2:30 Commercial Vehicle Crash Reporting – Accuracy and Analysis (Ballroom 3-4) 2:45 – 4:00 Breakout Sessions:
- Midwestern Service Center Partner Session - (Deer/Elk Lake)
- Western Service Center Partner Session - (Ballroom 2)
- FY 2018 eCVSP - Training and Updates (Ballroom 1)
4:00 – 5:00 Minimum Standards for FAST Act - (Ballroom 3-4)
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017 30
Thursday, March 23 MCSAP PARTNER AND FMCSA MEETING
8:00 – 9:15 Federal Grants Updates and Overview – (Ballroom 3-4) 9:15 – 10:15 Breakout Sessions:
- FMCSA Rulemakings – Updates for MCSAP Partners - (Ballroom 1)
- Performance Measurements and Benchmarking in Grant Programs – (Deer/Elk
Lake)
- High Priority Grant – Updates and Information – (Ballroom 2)
10:30 – 11:45 Breakout Sessions:
- Southern Service Center Partner Session – (Deer/Elk)
- Eastern Service Center Partner Session – (Ballroom 2)
- FY 2018 eCVSP - Training and Updates (Ballroom 1)
11:45 – 1:00 Lunch (on your own) 1:00 – 2:30 Understanding the MCSAP Comprehensive Policy – (Ballroom 3-4) 2:45 – 4:00 Breakout Sessions:
- Performance Measurements and Benchmarking in Grant Programs – (Deer/Elk
Lake)
- Multi-year CVSP’s – Overview and Implementation - (Ballroom 1)
4:00 – 5:00 Open Forum and Wrap-Up - (Ballroom 3-4)
MCSAP Planning Meeting and Grants Training – 2017
Tom Liberatore thomas.liberatore@dot.gov (202) 366-3030
31