Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity Marc Vinyals Technion Haifa, - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity Marc Vinyals Technion Haifa, Israel FSTTCS Workshop on Extension Complexity and Lifting Theorems Supported by ERC project “HARMONIC”

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 1 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 Yes Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 1 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 Yes x 11 = 1 , x 12 = 0 , x 21 = 0 , x 22 = 1 , x 31 = 0 , x 32 = 1 . Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 1 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 2 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 No Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 2 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 No I promise Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 2 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula satisfiable? x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 No I promise Enumerate all 2 6 assignments Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 2 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 x 31 ∨ x 22 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 x 31 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 21 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 x 31 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 21 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 x 31 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 x 31 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ··· x 11 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Resolution x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 x 31 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ··· x 11 ⊥ Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 3 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 ∨ x 12 x 21 ∨ x 22 x 31 ∨ x 32 x 11 ∨ x 21 x 11 ∨ x 31 x 21 ∨ x 31 x 12 ∨ x 22 x 12 ∨ x 32 x 22 ∨ x 32 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 x 11 + x 21 ≥ 1 x 11 + x 31 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 31 ≥ 1 x 12 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 12 + x 32 ≥ 1 x 22 + x 32 ≥ 1 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 1 − x 11 + 1 − x 21 ≥ 1 1 − x 11 + 1 − x 31 ≥ 1 1 − x 21 + 1 − x 31 ≥ 1 1 − x 12 + 1 − x 22 ≥ 1 1 − x 12 + 1 − x 32 ≥ 1 1 − x 22 + 1 − x 32 ≥ 1 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 3 / 2 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 3 / 2 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 3 / 2 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 3 / 2 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 2 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 3 / 2 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 2 x 11 + x 21 + x 31 + x 12 + x 22 + x 32 ≥ 3 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist Cutting Planes x 11 + x 12 ≥ 1 x 21 + x 22 ≥ 1 x 31 + x 32 ≥ 1 − x 11 − x 21 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − 2 x 11 − 2 x 21 − 2 x 31 ≥ − 3 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 3 / 2 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 ≥ − 1 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 1 − x 11 − x 21 − x 31 − x 12 − x 22 − x 32 ≥ − 2 x 11 + x 21 + x 31 + x 12 + x 22 + x 32 ≥ 3 0 ≥ 1 Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 4 / 27

Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist A Few Proof Systems Resolution Lines are clauses Polynomial Calculus Lines are polynomials Cutting Planes Lines are linear inequalities Bounded Depth Frege Lines are AC 0 circuits Marc Vinyals (Technion) Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity 5 / 27

Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity Marc Vinyals Technion Haifa, - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Lifting Applied to Proof Complexity Marc Vinyals Technion Haifa, Israel FSTTCS Workshop on Extension Complexity and Lifting Theorems Supported by ERC project HARMONIC Proof Complexity Lifting Examples Wishlist SAT Is this formula

Hardness Escalation in Proof Complexity via Composition Marc Vinyals KTH Royal Institute of

Nonmonotonic Extensions of Low Complexity DLs: Complexity Results and Proof Methods Laura

I-Complexity and Discrete Towards Precise . . . Derivative of Logarithms: Our Result Proof A

Proof Systems and Proof Complexity Marijn J.H. Heule http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~mheule/15816-f19/

Proof Complexity and Computational Complexity Stephen Cook Eastern Great Lakes Theory Workshop

strongly equal k-tautologies in some proof systems. Anahit Chubaryan and Garik Petrosyan

Proof Complexity of Quantified Boolean Formulas Olaf Beyersdorff School of Computing, University

Proof Complexity Olaf Beyersdorff School of Computing University of Leeds, UK 1 Outline of

Lifting proof-relevant unification to higher dimensions Jesper Cockx Dominique Devriese 17

15-16/08/2009 Nicola Galesi 1 Organization Informal introduction and Overview Informal

Completeness (G odel 1929) Duality proof countermodels : either there exists a proof P

JEFFERSON JOBOY 27 November 2018 1 LIFTING AWARENESS 2 GROUND RULES 3 What is a lifting

A (Biased) Proof Complexity Survey for SAT Practitioners Jakob Nordstr om KTH Royal Institute

Relating Proof Complexity Measures and Practical Hardness of SAT Jakob Nordstr om KTH Royal

Complexity consideration on the existence of strategy-proof social choice functions Koji

On the complexity of fjnding cycles in proof nets Nguyn L Thnh Dng cole normale

Lift and Drag Lecture 7 ME EN 412 Andrew Ning aning@byu.edu Outline Definitions Lift and

An introduction to the algorithmic of p -adic numbers David Lubicz 1 1 Universt de Rennes 1,

Not necessarily algebraic topology Darryl McCullough University of Oklahoma April 1, 2000 1

Equivariant semidefinite lifts and sum of squares hierarchies Pablo A. Parrilo Laboratory for

Sieve, Enumerate, Slice, and Lift: Hybrid Lattice Algorithms for SVP via CVPP Emmanouil

Example 1 1. Find the equation of the line joining P = (1 , 1 , 1) to Q = (1 , 0 , 1) in vector

The Role of Interbank Lending in the Predication of Individual Bank Failure during a Bank Crisis:

RMTA Contract MR-2017 Miscellaneous Repairs Pre-Bid Meeting March 30, 2017 MR-2017 Agenda: