LIFE NARRATIVES OF VOLUNTARILY CHILDLESS HETEROSEXUAL AND - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

FAMILIES WITHOUT CHILDREN: LIFE NARRATIVES OF VOLUNTARILY CHILDLESS HETEROSEXUAL AND NON-HETEROSEXUAL WOMEN

DR NIKKI HAYFIELD SENIOR LECTURER IN SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL SCIENCES, UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF ENGLAND (UWE) DR VICTORIA CLARKE ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR IN SEXUALITY STUDIES, DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL SCIENCES, UWE

TERMINOLOGY

“Child-less’ sounds too loaded, like there is a norm and you’ve not met it, you’re bereft, barren etc. But ‘child-free’ could sound smug (like saying you’re ‘car-free’). Child-less sounds like you don’t have children but might have wanted them, whereas child-free sounds as though you don’t have or want children and are celebrating it – neither seems to fit me, as I’m neither bemoaning nor celebrating my status. I can’t think of a better term though.” (Rosa, P23, aged 43, queer)

OVERVIEW

• The broader context and an overview of voluntary

childlessness research

• Our study and analyses
• Women’s experiences of being childfree
• Conclusions
• Questions

DEMOGRAPHIC TRENDS

• Broadly similar patterns of family change have occurred

across Europe, North American and Australasia in the last 50 years or so – including rises in:

• divorce
• births outside of marriage and lasting heterosexual relationships
• single parents
• single person households
• childlessness (Roseneil & Budgeon, 2004)
• Voluntary childlessness (e.g., Basten, 2009; Blackstone & Stewart, 2012)
• From family-as-a-noun to family-as-a-verb (Golombok, 2015;

Morgan, 2011)

THE CHILDFREE CHOICE IN POPULAR CULTURE

• Some media interest in the topic
• Celebrities discussing their decision to be childfree
• Some newspaper articles and blogs written by childfree women discussing

their right to be childfree and highlighting stigmatisation of childfree women

• New Zealand – Seven Sharp current affairs programme feature:

http://tvnz.co.nz/seven-sharp/child-free-video-5878477

• Media analysis
• Graham & Rich (2011) – Australian print media
• Giles, Shaw and Morgan (2009) – UK press

THE MOTHERHOOD MANDATE / IMPERATIVE

• Motherhood as an ‘institution’ (Rich, 1976)
• Pronatalism:

Being a woman conflated with being a mother (Peterson & Engwall, 2013)

• Having children understood as ‘natural’ and ‘biological’
• Chiildbearing understood as a developmental milestone
• Children marker of adulthood and of normal gender development (Morison et

al., 2015)

• Coercive pronataism – encouragement of procreation among the socially

privileged (e.g., white, middle class, able-bodied) and discouragement of procreation among those who are less socially privileged

PERCEPTIONS OF CHILDFREE WOMEN

• Voluntarily childfree women understood as:
• Deviant, maladjusted and emotionally unstable
• Unfeminine, unnatural and unhappy
• Immature, selfish, and self-centred (Blackstone & Stewart, 2012; Jamison et al., 1979; Morison et

al., 2015; Rich et al., 2011)

• Reasons include:
• Career focus
• Independent and freedom from responsibilities
• Dislike of, or disinterest in, children
• Self-fulfilment and disposable income
• Altruistic reasons (Agrillo & Nelini, 2008; Blackstone & Stewart, 2012; Park, 2005).

REASONS TO BE CHILDFREE

With thanks to our collaborators – Dr Sonja Ellis and Dr Gareth Terry Funded by the British Academy / Leverhulme Trust

PARTICIPANTS

• 23 women aged 35-65 years (average = 45 years)
• 13 heterosexual (11 married/in a relationship)
• 4 bisexual (3 in relationships)
• 6 lesbian/queer/non-heterosexual (2 in a relationship)

RESULTS

• Thematic analysis (Braun & Clarke, 2006) and analysing all

the data (heterosexual and non-heterosexual)

• Three main themes:

1. Ambivalence: It’s not set in stone 2. Freedom? 3. Minimisation of stigmatisation

(1) AMBIVALENCE

We haven’t done anything permanent about it and so Barry’s been quite interested in the past in having a vasectomy and at that point I said “no, I don’t want to have children but I don’t want to be making a decision for my future self right now”. [...] I guess my point is it’s been a gradual thing. It hasn’t been a sudden decision that always felt (pause) absolute, a growing realisation, but also, you know, some days you might think “am I certain about this?”, and other days you absolutely are. We’d always said that we had to, you know, “if you ever change your mind you have to say”, we have to be really open and honest about it, and sometimes we even use percentages, so “are you still sure” and he’s like “yeah I’m eighty percent sure today” (laughs). We might have a really nice interaction with a child and you’re like “ooh I’m seventy-five percent today” or “sixty percent today “so, yeah, we do try and be really open and honest about

• that. (Mary, aged 36, heterosexual)

(2) FREEDOM?

Sophie: I like to do what I want to do (laughs) Gareth: Yeah yeah yeah yeah for sure. Um, so what are those the things that you like to do ? Sophie: Um, work (mmn) be completely autonomous (mmn) in as much as I can be (mmn) um (in breath) enjoy myself, eat when I want to, get up when I want to, you know, not have anybody relying on me (mmn). ‘Cause both my husband and I, we’re quite (pause), you know, we’re very close but he likes his work as well and, you know, I’m down here in my study and he would normally be upstairs in his (mmn), you know, so we could spend the entire day and we’re happy like that (mmn) you know, but we come together in the evening, have a drink, cook dinner, go on holiday, go for walks with the dog (mmn) this that and the other (mmn). But it’s like I don’t feel

• controlled. I feel terrified of being pushed into a corner (mmn mmn) you know, um, and to have

this level of responsibility for somebody or something else, you know. I’ve got a dog and a cat (mmn) and obviously dogs you have to be responsible for and I do feel responsible for her (mmn) [but] it’s a different type of thing (aged 56, heterosexual).

(2) FREEDOM?

I don’t think I would have wanted to be a single parent because as I say that really impacts on your freedom to go on holiday, do all sorts of things really, you know, (mmn mmn). And I gave up a job I had in London, I worked part time, and I couldn’t have had that freedom (mmn) with children, because a part time income was enough for me to live on, but wouldn’t have been, you know, if I’d had a family (mmn mmn mmn). I would have had to work harder (Joanne, aged 65, lesbian).

(3) MINIMISATION OF STIGMATISATION

Gareth: Have you experienced any negative stuff related to being childfree? Sarah: Um, apart from the odd comments (mmn) and the assumption that I will have children (mmn), um no (mmn) no, no, not anything negative, um, other people’s assumptions get frustrating at times (yeah), but other than that, no I’ve I don’t feel bad about not having children (mmn) um, and although people kind of expect that you’re female and therefore you must want a child (in breath) um no [...] Gareth: Any other strategies that you have in terms of dealing with people who make assumptions? Sarah: Well one of the things that I did do in China is, I was having a foot massage and my colleague was translating. I could see it was getting difficult for my colleague translating ‘cause she said "but why don’t you have children, is there something wrong?" and eventually I just said “I can’t have children” (mmn) um, she gave me a sympathetic look but it stopped the conversation (mmn) and it was a lie (yeah) um, but it was just easier (aged 39, bisexual).

(3) MINIMISATION OF STIGMATISATION

Nikki: Some people have talked about feeling their friendships have been affected by their friends having children, how has that been for you? Arabela: (pause) I wouldn’t say so, just one person I (pause) I have sort of fallen out with (mnhmn) . It was because of a comment she made about me not having children that I felt was (pause) over the top and you know, not (pause) really nice ah but no. So when we got our dog (pause) (mmn) she made a comment that I shouldn’t be thinking about dogs, but children, which is a ridiculous thing to say because (right right) you know you can have dogs and children (yes). But anyway I didn’t think (pause) too much of it (mmn) but then a couple of years ago she had a baby, um because I don’t see her very often - she’s back in my home country - I emailed, you know, just asking how are they getting on (mmn) and she emailed me back with um, they have um a few problems with feeding I think (okay) and she says “I don’t know if you’re” (out breath) it was something about that it was hard work, and she said something like "well I don’t know if you’re finally grown up enough (laughing) to think about having children" and I just left it and never got back because that was (oh gosh) extremely upsetting (yeah). So I think I am a grown up because I know my decisions are right (mmn) in my situation (mmn mmn) um, you know, and I don’t want to have children just because everyone else has (yep) and because maybe some people think that that’s what is expected (mmn) from a woman who is in a stable relationship (aged, 38, SEXUALITY DATA????).

CONCLUSIONS

• Stigmatisation of childfree women’s experiences
• The persistence of the motherhood mandate
• ‘Family’ understood as nuclear - including (biological) children
• Implications for later life
• Mothers ‘versus’ non-mothers

REFERENCES

Agrillo, C. and Nelini, C. (2008). Childfree by choice: A review. Journal of Cultural Geography, 25(3), 347-363. Albertini, M., & Mencarini, L. (2014). Childlessness and support networks in later life: New pressures on familistic welfare states? Journal of Family Issues, 35(3), 331-357. Basten, S. (2009). Voluntary childlessness and being Childfree. The Future of Human Reproduction: Working Paper, 5, 1-23. Berube, J. (2014). You shouldn’t need a reason for not having kids. Thoughtcatalog (blog). 10 February. Available from: http://thoughtcatalog.com/jamie-berube/2014/02/you- shouldnt-need-a-reason-for-not-having-kids/ [Accessed 22 May 2015]. Blackstone, A. and Stewart, M. D. (2012). Choosing to be childfree: Research on the decision not to parent. Sociology Compass, 6(9), 718-727. Doyle, J., Pooley, J. A., & Breen, L. (2012). A phenomenological exploration of the childfree choice in a sample of Australian women. Journal of Health Psychology, 18(3), 397-407. Freeman, H. (2015). Why do we still have to justify the choice to be child-free? The Guardian (online). 8 April 2015. Available from: http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/apr/08/why-justify-decision-child-free-culture-war-parenting [Accessed 22nd May 2015]. Giles, D., Shaw, R. L., & Morgan, W. (2009). Representations of voluntary childlessness in the UK press, 1990—2008. Journal of Health Psychology, 14(8), 1218-1228. Gillespie, R. (2001). Contextualizing voluntary childlessness within a postmodern model of reproduction: Implications for health and social needs. Critical Social Policy, 21(2), 139- 159. Golombok, S. (2015). Modern families: Parents and children in new family forms. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Graham, M., & Rich, S. (2014). Representations of childless women in the Australian print media. Feminist Media Studies, 14(3), 500-518. Jamison, P. H., Franzini, L. R. and Kaplan, R. M. (1979). Some assumed characteristics of voluntarily childfree women and men. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 4(2), 266-273. Kelly, M. (2009). Women's voluntary childlessness: A radical rejection of motherhood? Women's Studies Quarterly, 37(2), 157-172. Lee, K. H., & Zvonkovic, A. M. (2014). Journeys to remain childless A grounded theory examination of decision-making processes among voluntarily childless couples. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 31(4), 535-553. Moore, J. (2014). Reconsidering childfreedom: A feminist exploration of discursive identity construction in childfree LiveJournal communities. Women's Studies in Communication, 37(2), 159-180. Morell, C. (2000). Saying no: Women’s experiences with reproductive refusal. Feminism & Psychology, 10(3), 313-322. Morgan, D. H. (2011). Locating ‘family practices'. Sociological Research Online, 16(4) 14. Morison, T., Macleod, C., Lynch, I., Mijas, M., & Shivakumar, S. T. (2015). Stigma resistance in online childfree communities: The limitations of choice rhetoric. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 40(2), 184-198. Park, K. (2005). Choosing childlessness: Weber's Typology of action and motives of the voluntarily childless. Sociological Inquiry, 75(3), 372-402. Peterson, H., & Engwall, K. (2013). Silent bodies: Childfree women’s gendered and embodied experiences. European Journal of Women's Studies, 20(4), 376-389. Rich, A. (1978). ‘Motherhood: The Contemporary Emergency and the Quantum Leap’, pp. 259–73 in A. Rich (1984) On Lies, Secrets and Silences: Selected Prose 1966–1978. London: Virago. Rich, S., Taket, A., Graham, M. and Shelley, J. (2011). ‘Unnatural’,‘unwomanly’,‘uncreditable’and ‘undervalued’: The significance of being a childless woman in Australian society. Gender Issues, 28(4), 226-247. Roseneil, S., & Budgeon, S. (2004). Cultures of intimacy and care beyond ‘the family’: Personal life and social change in the early 21st century. Current Sociology, 52(2), 135-159. Veevers, J. E. (1973). Voluntarily Childless Wives-Exploratory Study. Sociology and Social Research, 57(3), 356-366.