impact of form factors and input condi2ons on absolute
play

Impact of Form Factors and Input Condi2ons on Absolute - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Impact of Form Factors and Input Condi2ons on Absolute Indirect-Touch Poin2ng Tasks Jrmie Gilliot, Gry Casiez & Nicolas Roussel LIFL & INRIA Lille University of


  1. Impact ¡of ¡Form ¡Factors ¡and ¡Input ¡ Condi2ons ¡on ¡Absolute 
 Indirect-­‑Touch ¡Poin2ng ¡Tasks ¡ Jérémie Gilliot, Géry Casiez & Nicolas Roussel LIFL ¡& ¡INRIA ¡Lille University ¡of ¡Lille, ¡FRANCE

  2. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect Relative Absolute 2

  3. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect Relative Absolute 2

  4. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect Relative + directness + multitouch Absolute - precision - fatigue 2

  5. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect Relative + directness + multitouch Absolute - precision - fatigue 2

  6. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect + precision + fatigue Relative - multitouch + directness + multitouch Absolute - precision - fatigue 2

  7. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect + precision + fatigue Relative - multitouch + directness + multitouch Absolute - precision - fatigue 2

  8. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect + precision + fatigue Relative - multitouch + fatigue + directness + multitouch + multitouch Absolute - precision - precision - fatigue 2

  9. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Direct Indirect + precision + fatigue Relative - multitouch + fatigue + directness + multitouch + multitouch Absolute - precision - precision - fatigue 2

  10. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng quire something completely different? (a) (b) Malik et al. UIST’05 Benko et al. GI’10 Schmidt et al. Interact’09 “clock” Figure 1: This user operates his mobile phone in his McCallum et al. UIST’09 Moscovich et al. GI’06 Gustafson et al. UIST’11 3

  11. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Screen 4

  12. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Screen 4

  13. Absolute ¡indirect ¡poin=ng Screen 4

  14. Form ¡Factors ¡and ¡Input ¡Condi=ons 5

  15. Form ¡Factors ¡and ¡Input ¡Condi=ons - input form factors (size and aspect ratio) 5

  16. Form ¡Factors ¡and ¡Input ¡Condi=ons - input form factors (size and aspect ratio) - input conditions (ability to look at the device, ability to use both hands) 5

  17. Form ¡Factors ¡and ¡Input ¡Condi=ons - input form factors (size and aspect ratio) - input conditions (ability to look at the device, ability to use both hands) - display form factors (device size and aspect ratio, target size) 5

  18. EXPERIMENT ¡1: ¡ device ¡size ¡and ¡input ¡condi=ons 6

  19. EXPERIMENT ¡1: ¡ device ¡size ¡and ¡input ¡condi=ons Hypothesis: 6

  20. 
 EXPERIMENT ¡1: ¡ device ¡size ¡and ¡input ¡condi=ons Hypothesis: 1. Despite the lack of feedback, looking at the input surface would help position the index finger 
 6

  21. 
 EXPERIMENT ¡1: ¡ device ¡size ¡and ¡input ¡condi=ons Hypothesis: 1. Despite the lack of feedback, looking at the input surface would help position the index finger 
 2. The non-dominant hand could act as a reference frame to position the finger if users were unable to look at the device 6

  22. Task 7

  23. Task 7

  24. Task 7

  25. Task 7

  26. Task 7

  27. Task 7

  28. Design 8

  29. Design 12 participants 8

  30. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) 8

  31. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) 8

  32. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) 8

  33. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) 8

  34. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) x 2 device size (iPod, iPad) 8

  35. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) x 2 device size (iPod, iPad) x 3 blocks 8

  36. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) x 2 device size (iPod, iPad) x 3 blocks x 3 target size (10, 20, 40 mm) 8

  37. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) x 2 device size (iPod, iPad) x 3 blocks x 3 target size (10, 20, 40 mm) x 9 target position 1 11 22 3 13 9 19 10 25 8

  38. Design 12 participants x 3 input conditions (1 hand, 1hand-blinders, 2handsBlinders) x 2 device size (iPod, iPad) x 3 blocks x 3 target size (10, 20, 40 mm) x 9 target position x 3 repetitions = 17,496 total trials 8

  39. Success ¡rate ¡and ¡number ¡of ¡failed ¡aKempts sig. diff. 100%# 90%# 80%# 70%# 60%# 50%# Number&of& 40%# failed&a<empts& 30%# 5# 4# 20%# 3# 2# 10%# 1# 0# 0%# 1H AND B LINDERS # 2H ANDS B LINDERS # 1H AND # S MALL # L ARGE # W S # W M # W L # 1# 3# 9# 10# 11# 13# 19# 22# 25# 10, 20, 40 mm 1 11 22 I NPUT & CONDITION &&&D EVICE & SIZE &&&&&&&T ARGET & SIZE &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&T ARGET & POSITION & 3 13 9 19 9 10 25

  40. Success ¡rate ¡and ¡number ¡of ¡failed ¡aKempts sig. diff. 100%# 90%# 80%# 70%# 60%# 50%# Number&of& 40%# failed&a<empts& 30%# 5# 4# 20%# 3# 2# 10%# 1# 0# 0%# 1H AND B LINDERS # 2H ANDS B LINDERS # 1H AND # S MALL # L ARGE # W S # W M # W L # 1# 3# 9# 10# 11# 13# 19# 22# 25# 10, 20, 40 mm 1 11 22 I NPUT & CONDITION &&&D EVICE & SIZE &&&&&&&T ARGET & SIZE &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&T ARGET & POSITION & 3 13 9 19 9 10 25

  41. Success ¡rate ¡and ¡number ¡of ¡failed ¡aKempts sig. diff. 100%# 90%# 80%# 70%# 60%# 50%# Number&of& 40%# failed&a<empts& 30%# 5# 4# 20%# 3# 2# 10%# 1# 0# 0%# 1H AND B LINDERS # 2H ANDS B LINDERS # 1H AND # S MALL # L ARGE # W S # W M # W L # 1# 3# 9# 10# 11# 13# 19# 22# 25# 10, 20, 40 mm 1 11 22 I NPUT & CONDITION &&&D EVICE & SIZE &&&&&&&T ARGET & SIZE &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&T ARGET & POSITION & 3 13 9 19 9 10 25

  42. Success ¡rate ¡and ¡number ¡of ¡failed ¡aKempts sig. diff. 100%# 90%# 80%# 70%# 60%# 50%# Number&of& 40%# failed&a<empts& 30%# 5# 4# 20%# 3# 2# 10%# 1# 0# 0%# 1H AND B LINDERS # 2H ANDS B LINDERS # 1H AND # S MALL # L ARGE # W S # W M # W L # 1# 3# 9# 10# 11# 13# 19# 22# 25# 10, 20, 40 mm 1 11 22 I NPUT & CONDITION &&&D EVICE & SIZE &&&&&&&T ARGET & SIZE &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&T ARGET & POSITION & 3 13 9 19 9 10 25

  43. Success ¡rate ¡and ¡number ¡of ¡failed ¡aKempts sig. diff. 100%# 90%# 80%# 70%# 60%# 50%# Number&of& 40%# failed&a<empts& 30%# 5# 4# 20%# 3# 2# 10%# 1# 0# 0%# 1H AND B LINDERS # 2H ANDS B LINDERS # 1H AND # S MALL # L ARGE # W S # W M # W L # 1# 3# 9# 10# 11# 13# 19# 22# 25# 10, 20, 40 mm 1 11 22 I NPUT & CONDITION &&&D EVICE & SIZE &&&&&&&T ARGET & SIZE &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&T ARGET & POSITION & 3 13 9 19 9 10 25

  44. Targe=ng ¡error 10

  45. Targe=ng ¡error 10

  46. Targe=ng ¡error 14" S MALL " 12" L ARGE " T ARGETING ( ERROR (((((((()( 10" 8" 6" 4" 2" 0" 1H AND B LINDERS " 2H ANDS B LINDERS " 1H AND " I NPUT ( CONDITION ( 11

  47. Targe=ng ¡error 14" S MALL " 12" L ARGE " T ARGETING ( ERROR (((((((()( 10" 8" 6" 4" 2" 0" 1H AND B LINDERS " 2H ANDS B LINDERS " 1H AND " I NPUT ( CONDITION ( 11

  48. Targe=ng ¡error 14" S MALL " 12" L ARGE " T ARGETING ( ERROR (((((((()( 10" 8" 6" 4" 2" 0" 1H AND B LINDERS " 2H ANDS B LINDERS " 1H AND " I NPUT ( CONDITION ( 11

  49. Targe=ng ¡error 14" S MALL " 12" L ARGE " T ARGETING ( ERROR (((((((()( 10" 8" 6" 4" 2" 0" 1H AND B LINDERS " 2H ANDS B LINDERS " 1H AND " I NPUT ( CONDITION ( 11

  50. Targe=ng ¡error 14" S MALL " 12" L ARGE " T ARGETING ( ERROR (((((((()( 10" 8" 6" 4" 2" 0" 1H AND B LINDERS " 2H ANDS B LINDERS " 1H AND " I NPUT ( CONDITION ( 11

  51. Targe=ng ¡error 10" 9" 8" T ARGETING ( ERROR (((((((()( 7" 6" 5" 4" 1 11 3" 22 3 13 2" 9 19 1" 10 25 0" 1" 3" 9" 10" 11" 13" 19" 22" 25" T ARGET ( POSITION ( 12

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend


More recommend