BASIX
Equity for Equity
HOUSING MICROFINANCE PRACTITIONERS WORKSHOP Presented by: B.S.Vasu - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
BASIX Equity for Equity HOUSING MICROFINANCE PRACTITIONERS WORKSHOP Presented by: B.S.Vasu BASIX Why one should have the house? BASIX Equity for Equity Housing is one of the three basic human needs viz ; Roti(Bread), Kapda(Cloths)
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Roti(Bread), Kapda(Cloths) and Makan(House).
arrange for these basic requirements and continues to do so even today.
more social, Law-abiding and conscientiousness about the
contented life.
&economical growth and social stability.
Equity for Equity
Source: NHB report
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Particulars Housing Requirements (2007-12) (in million units) Funds Requirements (2007-12) (INR in ‘000 Millions ) R U T R U T Additional Houses 32 16 48 3440 6450 9890 Of which EWS including BPL, MAPL 14 7 22 360 740 1100 Upgradation of Existing Pucca/ Semi Pucca/ Katcha Houses 23 9 32 350 240 590 Total (Additional Houses + Upgradation / Repairs etc.) 55 25 80 3790 6690 10480
Source: NHB report
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
large, by-passed the poor.
Equity for Equity
◊Housing has direct impact on employment and
◊Impact is in terms of improved habitat, living,
◊Improved productivity leading to enhanced
Equity for Equity
– LIVELIHOOD – SYNERGY
Equity for Equity
FX1 FX2 FX3 FX4 FX5 LSA1 LSA2 LSA3 LSA4 LSA5 LSP5 LSP4 LSP3 LSP2 LSP1
FX: FIELD EXECUTIVE LSA: LIVELIHOOD SERVICE ADVISOR LSP: LIVELIHOOD SERVICE PROVIDER UA: UNIT ACCOUNTANT TA: TRANSACTION ASSISTANT OA: OFFICE ASSISTANT UA, TA and OA
UNIT HEAD
BASIX UNIT STRUCTURE
Equity for Equity
24 18 36 24 24 24&36 36 36 18 11
DURATION (Months)
100000(Max) 8000(Max.) 200000(Max.) 50000(Max.) 50000(Max.) 150000(Max.) 150000(Max.) 150000(Max.) 25000(Max.) 25000(Max.) LOAN SIZE (Rs) Vehicle Loan Employees(114) Education loan for Vocational(122) Education Loan for Professional (120) Water &sanitation(127) Energy Loan(126) Gruha Samruddhi (for new Houses & Extension)- (123) House repairs & extension(113)
SHG’s/CAG’s/CIGs (107) LOAN PRODUCT ROSCAS(110)
JLG.(108) Growth Micro Enterprise (106) Micro Enterprise(104)
Non dairy(117)
Agri.-invest- Irrigation(125) Agri.-invest-land development(102) Crop loans-veg(121) Crop loans(101) LOAN PRODUCT 20000 & 40000 50000 (Max) 150000 (Max) 25000 (Max.) 25000 (Max.) 150000 (Max) 25000 (Max.) No Limit No Limit LOAN SIZE (Rs) 36 24 48 36 36 84 36 36 24
DURATION
(Months)
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Demand Survey Releasing of final product
Need of Housing Product for BASIX
Data Analysis Product Design Product Pilot
Collaboration With DID
1
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
1) survey with questionnaire. 2) Focus group discussions.
three locations .
meeting, we have redesigned the housing demand questionnaire and conducted the actual survey in all the three locations
sample locations
sample areas.
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% METRO % URBAN % RURAL %
Sample areas
Multiple Construction Repair of Floor Repair of Walls Repair of Roof Construction of Bathroom Construction of Toilet Construction of Kitchen Additional room for Household Additional room for Rent Additional room for Business Construction of New house
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Estimated Cost of the Proposed Project
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% METRO % URBAN % RURAL % ALL % Below 50,000 50,000 - 1,00,000 1,00,000 - 1,50,000 Above 1,50,000
Equity for Equity
(3.Housing Loan Demand)
Equity for Equity
Housing Loan Demand
Amount willing to borrow METRO % URBAN % RURAL % All % Below 50,000 10 8% 30 27% 38 24% 78 20% 50,000 - 1,00,000 37 30% 47 43% 71 46% 155 40% 1,00,000 - 1,50,000 27 22% 13 12% 30 19% 70 18% above 1,50,000 46 37% 20 18% 17 11% 83 21% No Idea 3 2% 0% 0% 3 1% Grand Total 123 100% 110 100% 156 100% 389 100%
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Expected interest rates Location wise Expected Interest Rate Number and % of respondents METRO % URBAN % Rural % All % Below 12% 67 54% 67 61% 93 60% 227 58% 12%-24% 48 39% 40 36% 62 40% 150 39% 24%-36% 8 7% 1 1% 0% 9 2% Na 0% 2 2% 1 1% 3 1% Grand Total 123 100 % 110 100 % 156 100 % 389 100%
Equity for Equity
100 389 100 156 100 110 100 123 Grand Total 1 1 1 Others 4 14 1 1 2 2 9 11
2 8 1 2 3 3 2 3 Parents House 84 326 94 146 83 91 72 89 Own 10 40 4 6 13 14 16 20 Rented % All % Rural % URBAN % METRO Location wise Type of house lived in
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
100% 300 100% 118 100% 78 100% 104 Grand Total 41% 122 41% 48 45% 35 38% 39 RCC 25% 75 6% 7 8% 6 60% 62 Sheets 9% 26 20% 24 3% 2 0% Stones 25% 76 32% 38 45% 35 3% 3 Tiles 0% 1 1% 1 0% 0% Thatched % All % Rural % URBAN % METRO Type of Roof b Type of Roof
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
100 % 38 9 100% 156 100% 110 100% 123 Grand Total 15% 57 9% 14 8% 9 28% 34 above 1,50,000 21% 80 19% 29 19% 21 24% 30 1,00,000 – 1,50,000 46% 17 7 50% 78 48% 53 37% 46 50,000 - 1,00,000 19% 75 22% 35 25% 27 11% 13 Below 50,000 All % Al l Rural % Rura l Urban % Urban Metro % Metro Number and % of respondents Family Income Income Category
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
100% 555 100% 241 100% 144 100% 170 Total 11% 60 9% 21 9% 13 15% 26 Others 3% 16 2% 4 5% 7 3% 5 SHG 47% 261 43% 104 61% 88 41% 69 Banks 14% 75 17% 40 6% 8 16% 27 Money Lenders 3% 16 5% 11 0% 3% 5 Money Remittances 23% 127 25% 61 19% 28 22% 38 Savings % Grand Total % Rural % URBAN % METRO Number and % of respondents Source of Borrowing Various Sources of Borrowing Money to fulfill their Project
Equity for Equity
they can avail the loan. Multiple options have been opted by the respondents to fulfill their project needs. The above are some of the sources from which they avail the loan. 47% of the total respondents have expressed their willingness to avail loans from Banks, 23 % are willing to meet from their own savings and 14 % would borrow from money lenders.
Banks, 22 % from their savings and 16 % from money lenders.
Metro of availing loans from Banks, 61% of them are willing to avail from banks, the percentage of lending from money lenders is less with Urban,
is more when compared to Metro and Urban, 17 % of the respondents are availing from them and 43 % are availing through banks. Saving percentage is more in rural compared to urban and metro, 25% of the rural respondents are meeting housing needs from Savings.
Equity for Equity
12 6 10 23 Above Rs.3000/- 17 12 15 24
40 42 43 36
29 40 31 13 Below Rs. 1000/- All % Rural % Urban % Metro % Amount
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
the total respondents majority of them (43%) are willing to Construct New Houses and an equal percentage of respondents 13% each have opted Extensions for Rental and Household Purpose as second option and 11% have opted for Repair of Roof as third priority.
Houses and second majority of the respondents are willing to do Extensions for Rental.
Extensions for Rental and Household.
House second priority was given to do Extensions for Household Purpose.
Housing Project seems to be high in Metro’s as compared to Urban and Rural sample areas. The reason may be due to increase in cost
their project cost to be above Rs. 1,50, 000/-. Whereas in Urban and Rural areas more than 70% of the respondents have estimated their project cost to be below Rs. 1,50,000/-.
Equity for Equity
construct houses or additional room for extension or repairs and also avail housing loan for the proposed construction
respondents, more than 78% of the respondents are willing to borrow below Rs. 1,50,000/-.
loan above Rs. 1,50,000/- and 60% of them are willing to borrow below Rs. 1,50,000/-
more than 80% of the respondents are willing to borrow below Rs. 1,50,000/-.
2,00,000/- p.a., have opted for a loan size below Rs. 1,50,000/- and the households with income Rs. 2,00,000/- p.a., have opted for loan above Rs. 2,00,000/-.
that in all the three sample areas, majority of the respondents in the income category of below Rs.1,00,000/- p.a., are willing to pay a monthly installment of Rs. 1000/- to 2,000/-. Only in Metro the households whose income is above Rs. 1,00,000/-, p.a. are willing to pay a month
Equity for Equity
Rs.50, 000 to Rs. 1, 00,000.
when they have the money.
proposed from Banks and 23% have done savings for the proposed project.
interest rate of below 12%.
wanted to do extensions for business purpose.
to 1,00,000 expected a monthly installment of Rs.1,000 to 2,000
willing to borrow an amount of Rs. 50,000 to 1, 00,000.
willing to construct new house and willing to avail ranging between Rs. 50,000 to 1, 00,000.
20 years
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
S.No Parameter BSFL KBSLAB 1 Disbursed Amount(in INRs 000’s) 9646 17170 2 Disbursed Accounts(No) 210 357 3 O/S Amount(in INRs 000’s) 8926 11010 4 O/S Accounts (No) 210 357 5
46 48 6 Female customers (%) 43 38 7 OTRR(%) 100 95.90 8 OD Accounts (No) 59 42
Equity for Equity
BASIX HOUSING PRODUCT MAIN FEATURES
2%+ST 2%+ST 3%+ST 3%+ST LPF 18% 18% 18% 24% Interest Rate Repairs, expansion and New construction Repairs Purpose 60 60 36(Min.) and 84( Max.) 24(Max.) Loan Tenure ( Months) 200000 100000 150000(Max.) 25 000 (Max.) Loan Amount( Rs) 90 days 90 days 60 days 60 days Moratorium period 3-4 3-4 3-4 1 Number of Disbursements Individual Group & Individual Individual Group & Individual Actual Nature of client 20% 20% 25% 25% Down payment 1 Good 1 Good 1 Good individual Mutual/1 Good individual Guarantors EC & DEED EC & DEED Above Rs 50000/- compulsory Not compulsory Collateral security
NEW OLD NEW OLD
KBSLAB BSFL
Equity for Equity
Product BSFL KBS BSFL KBS 123 113 123 113 % % % $ $ $ Loan size 150 000 INR 12 000 INR 100 000 INR Average loan duration 49 24 60 Gross interest income 18.00% 24.00% 18.00% 65 185 INR 3 267 INR 59 465 INR Cost of funds 12.00% 12.00% 9.60% 40 479 INR 1 435 INR 35 509 INR Net interest income 6.00% 12.00% 8.40% 24 706 INR 1 832 INR 23 956 INR Lost on loan 0.50% 0.50% 0.50% 750 INR 60 INR 500 INR Net interest income 5.50% 11.50% 7.90% 23 956 INR 1 772 INR 23 456 INR Loan processing fees 3.00% 3.00% 3.00% 4 500 INR 360 INR 3 000 INR Insurance income 0.30% 0.30% 0.30% 490 INR 240 INR 600 INR Total Income 11.50% 17.50% 13.90% 28 946 INR 2 372 INR 27 056 INR Operational Cost 12.00% 12.00% 10.00% 2 229 INR 1 435 INR 2 560 INR Net income
5.50% 3.90% 26 717 INR 937 INR 24 496 INR
Equity for Equity
Employees yearly Monthly Daily No of loans/day Cost Per loan LSA 100000 273.972603 1.5 182.6 FX 160000 438.356164 5 87.7
UH
250000 684.931507 23 29.8 FM 350000 958.90411 65 14.8 Home office 300000 821.917808 23 35.7 350.6 Premise 10000 10 Computer 100 Phone 12000 12 Stationary/Mail 75 Electricity 1500 12 209 Head office cost 200 Grand total 759.6 Miscellaneous expenses per month 30
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
1) Non 1) Non– –Availability of Property title Availability of Property title Many own possession rights but not
2) Non 2) Non– –Availability of Income proof Availability of Income proof
laborers, seasonal nature of income .
farm. 3) Non 3) Non– –Availability
House Availability
House estimates / expenditure budget estimates / expenditure budget Civil Engineers / Contractors are present rarely.
Equity for Equity
4) Repayment Schedule generation 4) Repayment Schedule generation
With seasonal nature of income and non‐regularity, projecting continuous income stream is difficult
5) Delay in House Construction 5) Delay in House Construction
Unavailability of Building materials like bricks.
6) Minimum margin contribution 6) Minimum margin contribution
There is initial delay in contributing the margin.
7) Abandoning of House Construction 7) Abandoning of House Construction in the middle in the middle
As it is not an income generating activity in most of the cases , they abandon it mid‐way
8) High cost of Administration 8) High cost of Administration
Low ticket size and more frequent need
awareness
Equity for Equity
documents to support the Field staff
customer and house
House)
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
50
Amount of Loan Generally 2 to 7 times larger than average micro-credit loans Term 2 - 5 years for improvement and up to 10 years for fresh construction Delivery Method HMF to SHGs / JLGs through MFIs Collateral Clear titles are generally not available, hence loan is against hypothecation of book debts of MFI. Other forms of security like Group Guarantees, FDRs, etc. Wherever title deeds are available, they are mortgaged. Selection of borrowers Poor people (in Urban and Rural areas) with means of repayment like artisans, craftsmen and people in the informal
3 loan cycles successfully with MFI. Other features Sometimes a productive loan is also offered (as co-finance) to enhance repayment capacity.
Equity for Equity
51
Risks
Mitigants
geographical concentration and to develop HMF as a standardized product
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity
Equity for Equity