Hot Topics in Wound Care
1
Hot Topics in Wound Care 1 Topical vs Transdermal 2 Topical / - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Hot Topics in Wound Care 1 Topical vs Transdermal 2 Topical / Transdermal Oxygen 3 Mechanism of Action Topical / Transdermal Oxygen Full thickness excisional wounds Seldinger technique to place a probe directly beneath the wound
1
2
3
Fries et al.; Mutat Res. 2005 4
Pre Treatment Post Treatment
5
6
7
8
Acinetobacter baumannii (In Vitro)
Pseudomonas Aeruginosa & MRSA
9
10
Reservoir Dressing Sustains Elevated Wound pO2 After Hyperbaric Oxygen Treatment 11
MI-730 and OM-4 oxygen monitor, Micro-Electrodes,
Type K thermocouple 5SC-TT-K-36-36 and HH11A
HBOT=90 min at 2 ATA
Reservoir Dressing Sustains Elevated Wound pO2 After Hyperbaric Oxygen Treatment 12
Reservoir Dressing Sustains Elevated Wound pO2 After Hyperbaric Oxygen Treatment 13
Even given high inspired O2
Reservoir Dressing Sustains Elevated Wound pO2 After Hyperbaric Oxygen Treatment 14
*All Day 3 and Day 7 primary endpoints demonstrated statistical significant differences (p < .001)
15
Results showed a significant difference in healing time of 30%
16
17
18
19
Kimberly F. Lairet, MD, Leopoldo C. Cancio, MD, Michelle L. Leas, RN, Chaya Galin, RN, David Baer, PhD, Evan M. Renz, MD Evaluation of an Oxygen Diffusion Dressing for Accelerating Healing of Donor Site Wounds. Journal of Burn Care and Rehabilitation 1997;18(4):353-5 United States Army Institute of Surgical Research, Fort Sam Houston, TX
20
Control Group = Xeroform dressing
21
Outcome OxyBand Xeroform
Healing Time (Blinded Evaluation of Photographic Evidence) (p<0.01) 9.4±1.7 days (range 6- 12 days) No Infection Significantly Faster Healing w/ OxyBand 12.4±2.7 days (range 8-20 days) No Infection Pain (0-10 Scale on Day 4,8,10,12) (p<0.05)
Day 4, 0.6 Day 8, O.4 Day 10, 0.3 Day 12, 0.2
Significantly Less Pain with OxyBand
Vs 1.6 (~ 3x more pain) Vs 1.4, (> 3x more pain) Vs 0.8, (> 2x more pain Vs 0.5 (> 2x more pain) Significantly
More Pain with Xeroform
Kimberly F. Lairet, MD, Leopoldo C. Cancio, MD, Michelle L. Leas, RN, Chaya Galin, RN, David Baer, PhD, Evan M. Renz, MD Evaluation of an Oxygen Diffusion Dressing for Accelerating Healing of Donor Site Wounds. Journal of Burn Care and Rehabilitation 1997;18(4):353-5 United States Army Institute of Surgical Research, Fort Sam Houston, TX
22
23 23
24
Control Cutimed Siltec B Eclypse Adherent Optifoam Aquacel Foam Tielle Plus Sacrum Tielle Essential Drawtex Surgical Drawtex Mepilex Border Mepilex Border Heel Allevyn Life Allevyn Life Sacrum OxyBand PR OxyBand Foam 100 200 300 400
Commerical Dressing Materials Average Pressure (mmHg)
Dunnett's multiple comparisons test Mean Diff. 95.00% CI of diff. Significant? Summary Adjusted P Value Control vs. Cutimed Siltec B 178 163 to 192 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Eclypse Adherent 25 11 to 40 Yes *** 0.0002 Control vs. Optifoam 157 142 to 171 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Aquacel Foam 157 142 to 171 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Tielle Plus Sacrum 194 180 to 209 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Tielle Essential 184 170 to 199 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Drawtex Surgical 35 21 to 50 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Drawtex 63 49 to 77 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Mepilex Border 156 142 to 171 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Mepilex Border Heel 160 146 to 175 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Allevyn Life 171 157 to 185 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Allevyn Life Sacrum 238 224 to 252 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. OxyBand PR 252 238 to 267 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. OxyBand Foam 253 238 to 267 Yes **** <0.0001
25
Control Cutimed Siltec B Eclypse Adherent Optifoam Aquacel Foam Tielle Plus Sacrum Tielle Essential Drawtex Surgical Drawtex Mepilex Border Mepilex Border Heel Allevyn Life Allevyn Life Sacrum OxyBand PR OxyBand Foam 10 20 30
Commerical Dressing Materials Contact Area (cm2)
26
Control Cutimed Siltec B Eclypse Adherent Optifoam Aquacel Foam Tielle Plus Sacrum Tielle Essential Drawtex Surgical Drawtex Mepilex Border Mepilex Border Heel Allevyn Life Allevyn Life Sacrum OxyBand PR OxyBand Foam 200 400 600 800 1000
Commerical Dressing Materials Peak Pressure (mmHg)
**** **** **** **** ****
***p<0.0001, significantly different from Coontrol
Dunnett's multiple comparisons test Mean Diff. 95.00% CI of diff. Significant? Summary Adjusted P Value Control vs. Cutimed Siltec B 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Eclypse Adherent 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Optifoam 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Aquacel Foam 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Tielle Plus Sacrum 118 80.44 to 155.6 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Tielle Essential 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Drawtex Surgical 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Drawtex 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Mepilex Border 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Mepilex Border Heel 0 -37.56 to 37.56 No ns >0.9999 Control vs. Allevyn Life 344 306.4 to 381.6 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. Allevyn Life Sacrum 359.7 322.1 to 397.2 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. OxyBand PR 516.7 479.1 to 554.2 Yes **** <0.0001 Control vs. OxyBand Foam 199.3 161.8 to 236.9 Yes **** <0.0001
27
Control Cutimed Siltec B Eclypse Adherent Optifoam Aquacel Foam Tielle Plus Sacrum Tielle Essential Drawtex Surgical Drawtex Mepilex Border Mepilex Border Heel Allevyn Life Allevyn Life Sacrum OxyBand PR OxyBand Foam 200 400 600 800 1000
Commerical Dressing Materials Peak Pressure (mmHg)
**** **** **** **** ****
***p<0.0001, significantly different from Control #p<0.05, significantly different from Tielle Plus Sacrum @p<0.05, significantly different from Allevyn Life(AL), AL Sacrum, Oxyband Foam
# # # #
@
Tielle Plus Sacrum vs. Allevyn Life 226 151.9 to 300.1 Yes **** <0.0001 Tielle Plus Sacrum vs. Allevyn Life Sacrum 241.7 167.5 to 315.8 Yes **** <0.0001 Tielle Plus Sacrum vs. OxyBand PR 398.7 324.5 to 472.8 Yes **** <0.0001 Tielle Plus Sacrum vs. OxyBand Foam 81.33 7.217 to 155.5 Yes * 0.0318 Allevyn Life vs. Allevyn Life Sacrum 15.67
No ns 0.9433 Allevyn Life vs. OxyBand PR 172.7 98.55 to 246.8 Yes *** 0.0003 Allevyn Life vs. OxyBand Foam
Yes *** 0.001 Allevyn Life Sacrum vs. OxyBand PR 157 82.88 to 231.1 Yes *** 0.0006 Allevyn Life Sacrum vs. OxyBand Foam
Yes *** 0.0005 OxyBand PR vs. OxyBand Foam
Yes **** <0.0001
28
10 20 30 100 200 300 400
Contact Area (cm2) Average Pressure (mmHg) R2=0.73 p<0.0001
29
30
Chronic 2 Y ear Wound OxyBand- 30 Day OxyBand- 90 Day
32
32
Post operative, Donor Sites, SSSI
33
34