- Prof. Priyani Paranagama
Senior Professor & Chair of Chemistry University of Kelaniya Kelaniya
Hardness, Arsenic and Prevalence of CKDu Prof. Priyani Paranagama - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Potential Link between Ground Water Hardness, Arsenic and Prevalence of CKDu Prof. Priyani Paranagama Senior Professor & Chair of Chemistry University of Kelaniya Kelaniya Members of the research team Prof. Priyani Paranagama
Senior Professor & Chair of Chemistry University of Kelaniya Kelaniya
Members of the research team
Celon.
Team of medical doctors
Initiated in December 2010
Sri Lanka.
individuals who have participated in the study.
Study areas; Endemic areas: Padavi-Sripura, Anuradhapura urban area, Polpithigama, Nikawewa, Mahawa-Siyambangamuwa, Medawachchiya, Matale, Kebithigollawa (Gonameriyawa) Nonendemic areas: Gampaha and Pasgoda
Endemic areas
Nonendemic areas: Gampaha and Pasgoda
information on CKDu patients among the villagers
characteristic, blood pressure and pulse recording of all subjects were obtained
area, controls in endemic and nonendemic area ; age, sex, education, occupation, type of agriculture, source of drinking water, use of agrochemicals were statistically analyzed .
water hardness and number of CKDu patients were statistically analyzed
significant.
were mapped using Global Positioning System (GPS) Moragollagama
Nikawewa
Siyabakangamuwa
– Male 85 % – Female 15 %
male female
85%
15%
50 100 150 200 250 15 - 20 21 - 25 26 - 30 31 - 35 36 - 40 41 - 50 51 - 60 61 -70 71 - 80 80-90
Age breakdown of the CKDu patients
Cases Age category
CKDu primarily affects middle-aged farmers.
– Grade 1 to grade 5
– Grade 6 to Grade 10
– Up to O/L 18.3 % – Up to A/L 13.5 % – Degree or above 0.6 %
Farmers 77.5 % House wives 14.2 % Office employee 08.3 % (farmers)
Single 38.4 % Married 61.6 %
Source of Drinking water Well water - 92 %
The farming communities are predominantly affected; of which more than 90% live in rural areas
Kristina Jakobsson & Channa Jayasuman (2013) Chronic Kidney Disease of Unknown origin in Sri Lanka, Proceedings of the First International Research Workshop on Mesoamerican Nephrophathy, Central American Institute for Studies on Toxic Substances (IRET-UNA) and Program on Work, Environment and Health in Central America (SALTRA), Editors: Catharina Wesseling, Jennifer Crowe, Christer Hogstedt, Kristina Jakobsson, Rebekah Lucas and David Wegman, 28-30 November, Costa Rica, pp 53.
Collection of water samples Endemic area (n = 381) Non endemic area (n = 232)
District
Sampling locations Number of samples Anuradhapura
Kebithigollewa Spring
10
Medawachchiya
40
Padaviya
36
Anuradhapura city
45
Kurunegala
Polpithigama, Nikawewa
60
Mahawa-Siyambalangamuwa
20
Mathale
Mathale
49
Ampara
Padiyathalawa, Dehiaththakandiya
83
Gampaha
Kadawatha, Ja - ela, Katunayaka, Biyagama, Kaduwela, Gampaha
212
Monaragala
Monaragala
38
Mathara
Pasgoda
20
District
Sampling locations
Number
Hardness (mg/L-1) Minimum and Maximum Hardness (mg/L-1) Median hardness (mg/L-1) Number
patients
Anuradhapura
Kebithigollewa Spring
10
9.2 9.1 - 9.3 9.2
Medawachchiya
40
376.2 160.2 - 685.2 384.6 2783
Padaviya
36
270.0 - 820.0 340 2378
Anuradhapura city
45
112.4 108.2 – 312.5 122.5 5
Kurunegala
Polpithigama, Nikawewa
60
352.5 90.0 - 615.0 307.5 2654
Mahawa-
Siyambalangamuwa
20
253 60.0 - 410.0 240 72
M.A.C.S. Jayasumana, P.A. Paranagama, M.D. Amarasinghe, S.I. Fonseka, Sri Lankan Agricultural Nephropathy and high ground water hardness Possible link, Proceedings of the First International Research Workshop on Mesoamerican Nephrophathy, Central American Institute for Studies on toxic Substances (IRET-UNA) and Program on Work, Environment and Health in Central America (SALTRA), Editors: Catharina Wesseling, Jennifer Crowe, Christer Hogstedt, Kristina Jakobsson, Rebekah Lucas and David Wegman, 28-30 November, Costa Rica, pp 195.
Endemic area
District
Sampling locations Number
Hardness (mg/L-1) Minimum and Maximum Hardness (mg/L-1) Median hardness (mg/L-1) Number
patients
Kurunegala
Polpithigama, Nikawewa
60
352.5 90.0 - 615.0 307.5 2654
Mahawa-
Siyambalangamuwa
20
253 60.0 - 410.0 240 72
Mathale
Mathale
49
228 60.0 - 460 252.5 55
Ampara
Padiyathalawa, Dehiaththakandiya
83
259.4 18.9 - 943 260 977
M.A.C.S. Jayasumana, P.A. Paranagama, M.D. Amarasinghe, S.I. Fonseka, Sri Lankan Agricultural Nephropathy and high ground water hardness Possible link, Proceedings of the First International Research Workshop on Mesoamerican Nephrophathy, Central American Institute for Studies on toxic Substances (IRET-UNA) and Program on Work, Environment and Health in Central America (SALTRA), Editors: Catharina Wesseling, Jennifer Crowe, Christer Hogstedt, Kristina Jakobsson, Rebekah Lucas and David Wegman, 28-30 November, Costa Rica, pp 195.
Endemic area
District
Sampling locations Number
Hardness (mg/L-1) Minimum and Maximum Hardness (mg/L-1) Median hardness (mg/L-1) Number
patients
Gampaha
Kadawatha, Kelaniya, Ja - ela, Katunayaka, Biyagama, Kaduwela, Gampaha
212 94.6 9.4 - 140.0 67.3
Mathara
Pasgoda
20 30.6 28.4- 54.6 33.7
M.A.C.S. Jayasumana, P.A. Paranagama, M.D. Amarasinghe, S.I. Fonseka, Sri Lankan Agricultural Nephropathy and high ground water hardness Possible link, Proceedings of the First International Research Workshop on Mesoamerican Nephrophathy, Central American Institute for Studies on toxic Substances (IRET-UNA) and Program on Work, Environment and Health in Central America (SALTRA), Editors: Catharina Wesseling, Jennifer Crowe, Christer Hogstedt, Kristina Jakobsson, Rebekah Lucas and David Wegman, 28-30 November, Costa Rica, pp 195.
nonendemic area
Relationship between water hardness and number of CKDu patients in sampling areas
M.A.C.S. Jayasumana, P.A. Paranagama, M.D. Amarasinghe, S.I. Fonseka, Sri Lankan Agricultural Nephropathy and high ground water hardness Possible link, Proceedings of the First International Research Workshop on Mesoamerican Nephrophathy, Central American Institute for Studies on toxic Substances (IRET-UNA) and Program on Work, Environment and Health in Central America (SALTRA), Editors: Catharina Wesseling, Jennifer Crowe, Christer Hogstedt, Kristina Jakobsson, Rebekah Lucas and David Wegman, 28-30 November, Costa Rica, pp 195.
Hardness of water in reservoirs in the endemic area
Location of the Reservoir
(ppm) Padaviya 115 - 135 Tissa wewa 120 - 135 Bulankulama 130 - 140 Olugolla 105 - 125 Nikawewa 140 - 155 Siyambalangamuwa 100 - 120 Medawachchiya 130 - 145
Measured in three occasion of the year as Values may vary due to different climetic conditions.
Distribution and prevalence of CKDu in Sri Lanka Distribution of hardwater in Sri Lanka (Technical data for groundwater hardness in Sri Lanka, Water Resources Board, Colombo 7)
Average values of total hardness and other ions in water samples of sampling areas
Location
Avg. Hardness mg/L Avg. PO43- mg/L Avg. SO42- mg/L Avg. NO3- mg/L Avg. CO32- mg/L
mg/L Avg. Fe mg/L
Pasgoda
30.60 0.14 2.40 0.21 60.82 0.20 0.22
Gampaha
94.60 0.93 25.10 1.02 82.38 0.20 0.28
Anuradhapura city
112.40 0.51 16.93 0.45 186.17 1.04 0.02
Monaragala
142.90 0.60 20.31 1.60 110.80 1.80 0.10
Mathale
228.00 0.37 9.57 0.41 294.27 0.72 0.09
Mahawa - Siyambalangamuwa
253.00 10.41 63.79 3.07 178.58 1.40 0.24
Ampara
259.40 9.60 54.58 1.25 346.00 1.02 0.11
Padaviya
323.80 12.63 76.80 3.72 324.20 1.20 0.26
Polpithigama
352.50 11.21 72.89 4.07 192.77 1.20 0.36
Medawachchiya
376.20 12.80 80.10 4.86 366.75 1.50 0.60
Fonseka, S.I., Amarasinghe, M.D., Paranagama, P.A. (2013) Nitrate, phosphate and sulfate concentrations of well water in CKDu endemic areas and non endemic areas and their relation to water hardness, Proceedings of the 69
th annual sessions of Sri Lanka Association forthe Advancement of Science, Sri Lanka will be held on 2nd – 6th Dec. 2013, pp 271.
Fonseka, S.I., Amarasinghe, M.D., Paranagama, P.A. (2013) Nitrate, phosphate and sulfate concentrations of well water in CKDu endemic areas and non endemic areas and their relation to water hardness, Proceedings of the 69th annual sessions of Sri Lanka Association for the Advancement of Science, Sri Lanka will be held on 2nd – 6th Dec. 2013, pp. 271.
features and analysis the arsenic content in urine and hair samples
palms and soles of CKDu patients during clinical examinations of CKDu patients
in Bangladesh
IN BANGLADESH
Rajakaruna, K.D.L.M.P., Mahamithawa, A.M.P., Samarasinghe, U.D., Senanayake, V.K. (2013) Possible link of Chronic arsenic toxicity with Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown etiology in Sri Lanka, Journal of Natural Sciences Research, 3(1), 64-73.
Percentage dermal manifestation observed in the CKDu cases and control groups
Subjects from non-endemic area did not show hyperpigmentations or kerotosis
CKDu patients (n = 125) controls from endemic area (n = 180) controls from nonendemic area (n = 43)
CKDu patients (n = 125) controls from endemic area (n = 180) controls from nonendemic area (n = 43)
Measurement of Arsenic content in urine and hair samples
AAS (Australia) equipped with a hydride generation system (GBC 3000) and Graphite Furnace (GF 3000) with the background corrector Analysis of arsenic content
Atomic Absorption Spectrometer and Mercury Vapour Generator at Water Resources Board Colombo 07 -Sri Lanka
acid (70% AR) (Sigma Aldrich Pvt. Ltd),
(Sigma Aldrich Pvt. Ltd),
Ltd),
water and dried in a dust free environment.
recovery of biological samples
Urinary arsenic contents of CKDu patients and individuals of the control groups
L, Mahamithawa AMP, Samarasinghe UDS, Fonseka SI, Senanayake KV,Wijekoon, DVK (2012) Toxic levels of arsenic in hair and urine samples of patients of chronic kidney disease of unknown aetiology (CKDu) in Sri Lanka, Proceedings of the research symposium on Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown aetiology , Sri Lanka Medical Association, Sri Lanka, 11
th
March 2012, pp12.
Toxic excretory level for arsenic in urine for south Asian population is 35μg/L. (http://www.mayomedicallaboratories.com).
Urinary arsenic Concentration (µg/L) CKDu patients (%) (n=125)
Controls 1 (%)
(n=180)
Controls 2 (%)
(n=43) 0-10 4.0 10.0 11.6 10-20 4.8 13.3 16.3 20-30 6.4 26.6 27.9 30-40 12.0 21.2 23.3 40-50 32.0 14.4 9.3 50-60 25.6 10.0 6.9 >60 15.2 4.5 4.6
Controls 1 – controls from endemic area control 2 – controls from nonendemic area
Arsenic content in hair samples of CKDu patients and individuals of the control groups
L, Mahamithawa AMP, Samarasinghe UDS, Fonseka SI, Senanayake KV,Wijekoon, DVK (2012) Toxic levels of arsenic in hair and urine samples of patients of chronic kidney disease of unknown aetiology (CKDu) in Sri Lanka, Proceedings of the research symposium on Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown aetiology , Sri Lanka Medical Association, Sri Lanka, 11th March 2012, pp12.
Hair samples Arsenic -mg/kg Mean-Normal (Muzumdar 2000) 0.46 Control group 1 0.22 to 4.58 Control group 2 0.15 to 2.59 CKDu patients 1.27 to 7.03
Controls 1 – controls from endemic area control 2 – controls from nonendemic area
Plant species As (µg/Kg)
Calotropis gigantean (Wara) 80.5±2.1 Asteracantha longifolia (Ikiriya) 5.55±0.1 Calotropis gigantean (Wara) 157.6±1.4 Eichhornia crassipes 553.5±2.4 Marsilea hirsuta 80±1.0 Syzygium cumini ( (Dan) Root 17.85±0.6 Cynodon dectylon (A grass) 84.05±1.1 Terminalia arjuna Bark 115±2.4 Tamarindus indica (Siyambala) bark 45.05±1.0 Gliricidia sepium (Gliricidia) root 38.45±0.7 Schleichera oleosa (Kon) root 160.1±2.8 Diospyros ebenum (Kaluwara) leaves 53.2±1.0 Bauhinia racemosa (Maila) leaves 87.0±1.3 Memecylon sp. (Kuratiya) 40.5±1.1 Pephrosia purpurea (Pila) root ND Schleichera oleosa (Kon) bark ND Bauhinia racemosa (Maila) bark ND Dichrostachys cinerea (Andara) root ND Ocimum sanctum (Maduruthala) ND Azadirachta indica (Kohomba) Bark high Terminalia arjuna Root high
Amarasinghe, MD, Fonseka SI, Jayalath, K, Senanayake KV, Paranagama PA, Jayasumana MACS (2012) Preliminary investigations on presence of arsenic in soils and plants from two CKDu prevalent areas in Sri Lanka, (2012) Proceedings of the 10th Annual Academic S essions of the College of Forensic Pathologists of Sri Lanka, 25th February 2012, Sri Lanka Medical Association, Sri Lanka, pp 15.
Sample name As g/L
253.73
256.94
262.07
257.31
Analyzed by Prof. Andrew A. Meharg, Institute for Global Food Security , Queen’s University Belfast, David Keir Building, Malone Road, Belfast, BT9 5BN, Northern Ireland, U.K.
(ICPMS)
Sample name As ug/L
8.17
8.07
8.12
7.99 Mean 8.09 Recovery 80.87 %
Analyzed by Prof. Andrew A. Meharg, Institute for Global Food Security , Queen’s University Belfast, David Keir Building, Malone Road, Belfast, BT9 5BN, Northern Ireland, U.K.
Sample As g/kg
1 101.5 2 183.0 3 115.9 4 100.6 6 179.2 7 87.9 8 55.9 9 122.9 10 68.2 14 114.5 14 77.4 15 108.8 16 71.3 110.4 17 18 51.2 19 79.5 20 106.3 21 51.9 22 67.7 23 92.7 24 76.1 25 51.9 26 64.3
Arsenic content in Rice samples collected from endemic and nonendemic area
(n= 75)
University of Ruhuna
Andrew A. Meharg, Gareth Norton, Claire Deacon,‡ Paul Williams, Eureka E. Adomako, Adam Price, Yongguan Zhu, Gang Li, Fang-Jie Zhao, Steve McGrath, Antia Villada Alessia Sommella, P. Mangala C. S. De Silva, Hugh Brammer, Tapash Dasgupta and M. Rafiqul Islam (2013) Variation in Rice Cadmium Related to Human Exposure, Environmental Science and Technology, in press.
University of Ruhuna
Concentration of Arsenic in different water sources in endemic and non endemic areas DW(EN) = Dug wells in endemic areas; TW(EN) = Tube wells in endemic areas; PF(EN) = Paddy field water in endemic areas; DW(nEN) = Dug wells in non endemic areas; PF(nEN) = Paddy field water in non endemic areas (Reference limit for As: 10 µg/L)
Fonseka, S., Paranagama, P.A., Jayalath, K, Amarasinghe, M., Senanayeke, K., Jayasumana, C., Mahamithawa, P., Wijewardhane, C., Samarasinghe, D ., Dahanayake, K. Preliminary investigations on the presence of arsenic in groundwater surface water and soils around Siyambalangamuwa and Moragolla in the Kurunegala district, Proceedings of the International Conference on Chemical Sciences, Sri Lanka Foundation Institute, Colombo 07, Sri Lanka, 20 – 22 June, 144.
Location As (ppb) PF(nEN) DW(nEN) PF(EN) TW(EN) DW(EN) Reservoir 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
As Content μg/ kg
Depth (feet)
"C Yaya" Paddy field
200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
As Content μg/ kg
Depth (feet)
Padaviya lake
n= 10
Amarasinghe, MD, Fonseka SI, Jayalath, K, Senanayake KV, Paranagama PA, Jayasumana MACS (2012) Preliminary investigations on presence of arsenic in soils and plants from two CKDu prevalent areas in Sri Lanka, (2012) Proceedings of the 10th Annual Academic Sessions of the College of Forensic Pathologists of Sri Lanka, 25th February 2012, Sri Lanka Medical Association, Sri Lanka, pp 15.
Gampaha paddy field
Amarasinghe, MD, Fonseka SI, Jayalath, K, Senanayake KV, Paranagama PA, Jayasumana MACS (2012) Preliminary investigations on presence of ars enic in soils and plants from two CKDu prevalent areas in Sri Lanka, (2012) Proceedings of the 10th Annual Academic Sessions of the College of Forensic Pathologists of Sri Lanka, 25th February 2012, Sri Lanka Medical Association, Sri Lanka, pp 15.
n= 10
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Pasgoda paddy field
soil show gradual decline with depth.
surface, more data will be collected for its confirmation.
Place Feets pH N (mg/Kg) P (mg/Kg) SO4 (mg/Kg) Cd (mg/Kg) As (mg/Kg) Fe (mg/Kg) 1 1 7.3 48.447 78.90 237.43 0.005 0.034 802.66 2 7.3 21.895 78.11 237.00 0.005 0.017 960.28 3 7.1 16.421 76.61 232.00 0.002 0.008 940.45 4 7.1 7.974 65.20 218.86 ND 0.004 864.14 5 6.9 5.158 40.24 206.86 ND ND 702.53 6 6.7 3.053 38.74 180.43 ND ND 806.74 7 6.6 2.132 30.42 163.22 ND ND 795.49 8 6.6 0.204 30.37 132.54 ND ND 743.31
Soil profile from Nikawewa area
Jayasumana MACS, Paranagama PA, Fernando A, Jayalath K, Fons eka SI, Amarasinghe MD, Presence of ars enic in fertilizers and its association with the agricultural kidney disease in Sri Lanka, (2013) The Journal of Toxicology and Health
fertilizer available in Sri Lanka
by Hydride generation atomic absorption spectrometry (HGAAS)
agrochemical samples
No. Active ingredient company Arsenic content (µg/kg) 1
Carbofuran
A A A B B 331 ±12 2458 ±78 554 ±16 854 ±21 1654 ±35 2
Imidacloprid
A A 180 ±14 359 ±12 3
Methoxyfenozide
A A 911 ±24 872 ±18 4
Tubuconazole
A A 288 ±23 680 ±14 5
Etofenprox
C C 757 ±18 2584 ±28 7
Diazinon
C C 625 ±42 995 ±21
Jayasumana MACS, Paranagama PA, Fernando A, Jayalath K, Fons eka SI, Amarasinghe MD, Presence of ars enic in fertilizers and its association with the agricultural kidney disease in Sri Lanka, (2013) The Journal of Toxicology and Health
Approximately 50 % contaminated with Arsenic
8
Fenoxaprop-p-ethyl +Ethoxysulfuron
C C 1254 ±26 2578 ±39 9
Diazinon
C C 625 ±42 995 ±21 10
Quinalphos
C C 928 ±08 1893 ±15 11
Thiamethoxam
D E 542 ±19 1024 ±25 12
Penthoate
E E E 698 ±36 565 ±31 1258 ±44 13
Dimethoate
B B 965 ±25 2457 ±59 14
Profenofos
A A C C C 1452 ±45 865 ±21 458 ±12 569 ±22 987 ±32
Jayasumana MACS, Paranagama PA, Fernando A, Jayalath K, Fons eka SI, Amarasinghe MD, Presence of ars enic in fertilizers and its association with the agricultural kidney disease in Sri Lanka, (2013) The Journal of Toxicology and Health
15 Oxyfluorofen D 788 ±32 16 Ispyribac Na E E 721 ±21 1458 ±36 17 Methomyl F F 1112 ±29 1458 ±35 18 Chlophyriphos B B C C 1365 ±42 654 ±09 865 ±31 1008 ±24 19 MCPA A A C C D D D 858 ±15 458 ±12 895 ±11 478 ±13 1258 ±18 1496 ±24 789 ±20 20 Carbendazim A C 1458 ±23 1163 ±25
Jayasumana MACS, Paranagama PA, Fernando A, Jayalath K, Fons eka SI, Amarasinghe MD, Presence of ars enic in fertilizers and its association with the agricultural kidney disease in Sri Lanka, (2013) The Journal of Toxicology and Health
Arsenic content in synthetic fertilizer
Sample Arsenic content (mg/kg) Triple super phosphate1 43.25+2.5 Triple super phosphate 2 25.49+4.3 Triple super phosphate 3 33.58+7.6 Single super phosphate 26.75 + 4.12 Eppawala rock phosphate 15.25 + 3.67 Urea 0.88 + 0.32 Muriate Of Potash 1.2 + 0.19 Vegetable fertilizer 1 14.75+1.04 Flower fertilizer 1 16.46+5.2 Flower fertilizer 2 11.28+7.9 Dolomite 30.46 + 5.82 Calcium carbide 16.30 + 3.08
N = 39
Sample Arsenic content (µg/kg) Compost mixture 1 2.32 + 0.43 Compost mixture 2 ND Chicken manure 1.77 + 0.41 Cow dung mixture 1.48 + 071 Natural flower fertilizer mixture ND Wood charcoal 3.54 + 0.58 Paddy husk charcoal 1.23 + 0.34
N = 35
3 ppt
Jayasumana, M.A.C.S., Paranagama, P.A., Amarasinghe, M. D., Wijewardane, K.M.R.C., Dahanayake, K.S., Fonseka, S.I., Rajakaruna, K.D.L.M.P., Mahamithawa, A.M.P., Samarasinghe, U.D., Senanayake, V.K. (2013) Possible link of Chronic arsenic toxicity with Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown etiology in Sri Lanka, Journal of Natural Sciences Research, 3(1), 64-73.