First-principles simulation of electrochemical reactions at solid- liquid interface
National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Japan Minoru Otani
07/03/2018 ISS2018@ISSP
1
First-principles simulation of electrochemical reactions at solid- - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
First-principles simulation of electrochemical reactions at solid- liquid interface National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Japan Minoru Otani 07/03/2018 ISS2018@ISSP 1 Outline Introduction
National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (AIST), Japan Minoru Otani
07/03/2018 ISS2018@ISSP
1
(ESM-RISM)
DFT)
2
Battery Manganese dry cell Lead battery NiCd, NiH secondary battery Fuel cell Lithium secondary battery Capacitor Electrolytic condenser Double layer condenser Supercapacitor Photovoltaic cell c-Si, a-Si solar cell Dye sensitized solar cell photoelectrochemical hydrogen production Sensor pH meter ion selective concentration meter glucose, etc. (using enzyme) gas (oxygen, etc.) Electroplating Cathodic protection Fe → Fe2O3 Electrolysis Aluminum, Copper, etc. Water, salt, etc. Organic chemicals tetraethyl lead
3
water-based electrolyte O2 out H2 out
sunlight in
ex) graphite
cathode electrolyte
e– e–
Load
Li Li Li+
Energy storage Energy harvesting
(Fuel cell) (Secondary battery) (PV, PEC)
500 nmSi SEI
Si anode Electrolyte
24
Electrolyte Carbon support Pt
24 hour
4
Electric field: 0.1~0.5 V/Å
25℃, 1.0M NaCl, Electrode: Pt
1 NaCl / 50 H2O
εf V∞ V z
EDL
electrode
+ + +
460Pt atoms 4 nm2 surface area Length scale of EDL: nm ~ μm 2 nm: 800 atoms ( 264 H2O, 5 NaCl) Depth 10 nm: 5000 atoms ( 1320 H2O, 25 NaCl) 0.1 μm: 50000 atoms (13200 H2O, 250 NaCl)
µ
Helmholtz layer: ~Å Diffuse layer
5
electrode
+ + +
µ V∞ V
z
EDL
1.Strong electric field in Helmholtz layer 3.Screening in diffuse layer 4.Origin of electrostatic potential 2.Bias potential control
Electrochemical interface Electrostatic potential
6
1.Strong electric field in Helmholtz layer 3.Screening in diffuse layer 4.Origin of electrostatic potential 2.Bias potential control
Effective Screening Medium method
Constant-μe method ESM-RISM method
Reference Interaction Site Model
ESM method
6
EC, LiPF6(1ML) Li+
e−
Li+
e− e−
Li+ Li+ Graphite, LCO
DFT RISM
e−
constant-μ
V
µext
Calculation cell
7
Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements
Typical EIS of Conventional LIB cell LiCoO2|EC3:EMC7 LiPF6 1M|Graphite
In the fully charged and discharged states as well as at the low temperatures (≤20◦C), the Rcell of the Li- ion cells is predominated by the Rct. Temperature-dependence of Rct @0.2 V vs. Li/Li+
A1120 (2004).
The activation energies were evaluated to be around 50-60 kJ/mol (0.5-0.6 eV). These values are very large compared to lithium ion conduction in active materials.
8
(ESM-RISM)
DFT)
9
Total energy functional in conventional method
Total energy functional
2⇥2 + V (r) + ˆ VNL + Vxc(r) ⇥ ψi(r) = εiψi(r)
Kohn-Sham equation
δE δρe = 0
E[ρe] = T[ρe] + Exc[ρe] + 1 2 ZZ drdr0 ρe(r)ρe(r0) |r − r0| + Z drvext(r)ρe(r) + EII V (r) = Z dr0 ρtot(r0) |r − r0| = Z dr0GPBC(r, r0)ρtot(r0) Kohn-Sham eq. {R}, ρin EII, vext(r) E, F I SCF V (r) INPUT OUTPUT
10
Poisson equation is solved with periodic boundary condition in advance and use the following expression Need to solve Poisson eq. with different BC.
z x y Open boundary condition (OBC) 2D periodic boundary condition (2D PBC)
11
z x y
we need to solve two equations.
2⇥2 + V (r) + ˆ VNL + Vxc(r) ⇥ ψi(r) = εiψi(r)
Kohn-Sham equation →3D PBC ρ(r)
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r)
Poisson equation →2D PBC + OBC Mixed boundary condition (MBC) + + + + V (r)
12
M.O. and O. Sugino, PRB 73, 115407 (2006)
How to solve the poisson equation under MBC?
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r) [⇧z{⇥(z)⇧} − ⇥(z)g2
||]G(g||, z, z) = −4⇤(g||, z − z)
[⇧z{(z)⇧} − (z)g2
||]V (g||, z) = −4⇥⇤(g||, z)
Laue representation
We can get Green’s function analytically with each boundary conditions.
13
(z) =
if z ≥ z1 ∞ if z ≤ z1 ⇥ V (g⇤, z1) = 0 ∂zV (g⇤, z)
(z) = ∞ if |z| ≥ z1 ⇤zV (g⇤, z)
(z) = 1
neutral surface, polarized surface... STM, gate electrode... nano-structure in capacitor, zigzag pot.
(i) (ii) (iii)
slab slab
electrode
slab
electrode electrode
V (g, −z1) = V0
M.O. and O. Sugino, PRB 73, 115407 (2006)
14
slab
electrode
slab
electrode electrode
G(i)(g⌅, z, z⇥) = 4π 2g⌅ eg⇥|zz| G(ii)(g⌅, z, z⇥) = 4π 2g⌅ eg⇥|zz| − 4π 2g⌅ eg⇥(2z1zz)
G(iii)(g⌅, z, z⇥) = 4π 2g⌅ eg⇥|zz| + 4π 2g⌅ e2g⇥z1 cosh{g⌅(z − z⇥)} − cosh{g⌅(z + z⇥)} sinh(2g⌅z1)
M.O. and O. Sugino, PRB 73, 115407 (2006)
15
E[⇤e, V ] = T[⇤e] + Exc[⇤e] + ⇤ dr
8⇥ |⇤V (r)|2 + ⇤tot(r)V (r) ⇥
Total energy functional
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r)
2⇥2 + V (r) + ˆ VNL + Vxc(r) ⇥ ψi(r) = εiψi(r)
Generalized Poisson equation Kohn-Sham equation
E[ρ] = T[ρ] + Exc[ρ] + 1 2
|r − r| +
V (r) =
|r − r| (r) = 1
conventional
V (r) =
(r) : model dependent
ESM
V ➠ variable
δE δρe = 0 δE δV = 0
16
Schematic animation of electrochemical interface simulation
17
Pt Pt
e-
Q=-0.95 (e/cell)
Hydrogen adsorption reaction
H3O+ + e− → H2O + Had
18
(ESM-RISM)
DFT)
19
Hydrogen adsorption reaction
Q=-0.95 (e/cell)
−2 2 4 6 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 −1 −0.9 −0.8 −0.7 −0.6 −0.5 −0.4 −0.3 −0.2 Fermi energy (eV) Excess charge Q(e) Time (ps)
Electron transfer
Pt Pt
e-
20
Limitation of the original conventional DFT-MD
conventional simulation experimental simulation
21
rnew
i
SCF calculation Output:
F i
Input:
˙ ri = pi mi , ˙ pi = Fi
Atoms
dynamics solver (dynamic) KS solver
rnew
i
Output: Input: ri, ne
Use the extended system method in molecular dynamics F i, Etot, µinst
<latexit sha1_base64="lEPxbaNMOrNWMCMRB0J6W/IosA=">ACHXicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62vqks3wSK4kDIVn7uCKC4rWFvolCGTpm1oMhmSO0IZ5kvc+CtuXKi4cCP+jZm2iLZeCDmcy/3nhNEghtw3S8nNze/sLiUXy6srK6tbxQ3t+6MijVldaqE0s2AGCZ4yOrAQbBmpBmRgWCNYHCR6Y17pg1X4S0MI9aWpBfyLqcELOUXj71AiY4ZSvslV6nPDzx86XuSQF/LBSklvBk/EPx0EDqF0tu2R0VngWVCSihSdX84ofXUTSWLAQqiDGtihtBOyEaOBUsLXixYRGhA9JjLQtDIplpJyN7Kd6zTAd3lbYvBDxif08kRJrMge3MjTWkb+p7Vi6J61raMoBhbS8aJuLDAonGWFO1wzCmJoAaGa21sx7RNKNhECzaEyrTlWVA/LJ+X3ZujUvVkYe7aBdtI8q6BRV0TWqoTqi6AE9oRf06jw6z86b8z5uzTmTmW30p5zPb29Io30=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="lEPxbaNMOrNWMCMRB0J6W/IosA=">ACHXicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62vqks3wSK4kDIVn7uCKC4rWFvolCGTpm1oMhmSO0IZ5kvc+CtuXKi4cCP+jZm2iLZeCDmcy/3nhNEghtw3S8nNze/sLiUXy6srK6tbxQ3t+6MijVldaqE0s2AGCZ4yOrAQbBmpBmRgWCNYHCR6Y17pg1X4S0MI9aWpBfyLqcELOUXj71AiY4ZSvslV6nPDzx86XuSQF/LBSklvBk/EPx0EDqF0tu2R0VngWVCSihSdX84ofXUTSWLAQqiDGtihtBOyEaOBUsLXixYRGhA9JjLQtDIplpJyN7Kd6zTAd3lbYvBDxif08kRJrMge3MjTWkb+p7Vi6J61raMoBhbS8aJuLDAonGWFO1wzCmJoAaGa21sx7RNKNhECzaEyrTlWVA/LJ+X3ZujUvVkYe7aBdtI8q6BRV0TWqoTqi6AE9oRf06jw6z86b8z5uzTmTmW30p5zPb29Io30=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="lEPxbaNMOrNWMCMRB0J6W/IosA=">ACHXicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62vqks3wSK4kDIVn7uCKC4rWFvolCGTpm1oMhmSO0IZ5kvc+CtuXKi4cCP+jZm2iLZeCDmcy/3nhNEghtw3S8nNze/sLiUXy6srK6tbxQ3t+6MijVldaqE0s2AGCZ4yOrAQbBmpBmRgWCNYHCR6Y17pg1X4S0MI9aWpBfyLqcELOUXj71AiY4ZSvslV6nPDzx86XuSQF/LBSklvBk/EPx0EDqF0tu2R0VngWVCSihSdX84ofXUTSWLAQqiDGtihtBOyEaOBUsLXixYRGhA9JjLQtDIplpJyN7Kd6zTAd3lbYvBDxif08kRJrMge3MjTWkb+p7Vi6J61raMoBhbS8aJuLDAonGWFO1wzCmJoAaGa21sx7RNKNhECzaEyrTlWVA/LJ+X3ZujUvVkYe7aBdtI8q6BRV0TWqoTqi6AE9oRf06jw6z86b8z5uzTmTmW30p5zPb29Io30=</latexit>nnew
e
Input: Need to introduce a new mechanism
loop. ⇓ Change the # of electron so that the Fermi energy render the target value
nnew
e
Output:
Fn ∝ µinst − µext
<latexit sha1_base64="YcGUrHjeV7bjYwnLi04DcOCD5/U=">ACFHicbVC7SgNBFJ2Nrxhfq5Y2i0Gw0LAR8dEFBLGMYEwgG5bZySQZMo9l5q4YlvyEjb9iY6Fia2Hn3zhJtoiJBwYO59zL3HOimDMDv/j5BYWl5ZX8quFtfWNzS13e+feqEQTWiOK92IsKGcSVoDBpw2Yk2xiDitR/2rkV9/oNowJe9gENOWwF3JOoxgsFLoHl2HMoi1ikEFIgkDgaGnRcqkgeHxtEIfYRi6Rb/kj+HNk3JGihDNXS/g7YiaASCMfGNMt+DK0Ua2CE02EhSAyNMenjLm1aKrGgpWOUw29A6u0vY7S9knwxur0RoqFMQMR2cnRjWbWG4n/ec0EOhctGzFOgEoy+aiTcA+UN6rIazNCfCBJZhoZm/1SA9rTMAWbAlGcjz5PaSemy5N+eFitnWRt5tIf20SEqo3NUQTeoimqIoCf0gt7Qu/PsvDofzudkNOdkO7voD5yvX28coG0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="YcGUrHjeV7bjYwnLi04DcOCD5/U=">ACFHicbVC7SgNBFJ2Nrxhfq5Y2i0Gw0LAR8dEFBLGMYEwgG5bZySQZMo9l5q4YlvyEjb9iY6Fia2Hn3zhJtoiJBwYO59zL3HOimDMDv/j5BYWl5ZX8quFtfWNzS13e+feqEQTWiOK92IsKGcSVoDBpw2Yk2xiDitR/2rkV9/oNowJe9gENOWwF3JOoxgsFLoHl2HMoi1ikEFIgkDgaGnRcqkgeHxtEIfYRi6Rb/kj+HNk3JGihDNXS/g7YiaASCMfGNMt+DK0Ua2CE02EhSAyNMenjLm1aKrGgpWOUw29A6u0vY7S9knwxur0RoqFMQMR2cnRjWbWG4n/ec0EOhctGzFOgEoy+aiTcA+UN6rIazNCfCBJZhoZm/1SA9rTMAWbAlGcjz5PaSemy5N+eFitnWRt5tIf20SEqo3NUQTeoimqIoCf0gt7Qu/PsvDofzudkNOdkO7voD5yvX28coG0=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="YcGUrHjeV7bjYwnLi04DcOCD5/U=">ACFHicbVC7SgNBFJ2Nrxhfq5Y2i0Gw0LAR8dEFBLGMYEwgG5bZySQZMo9l5q4YlvyEjb9iY6Fia2Hn3zhJtoiJBwYO59zL3HOimDMDv/j5BYWl5ZX8quFtfWNzS13e+feqEQTWiOK92IsKGcSVoDBpw2Yk2xiDitR/2rkV9/oNowJe9gENOWwF3JOoxgsFLoHl2HMoi1ikEFIgkDgaGnRcqkgeHxtEIfYRi6Rb/kj+HNk3JGihDNXS/g7YiaASCMfGNMt+DK0Ua2CE02EhSAyNMenjLm1aKrGgpWOUw29A6u0vY7S9knwxur0RoqFMQMR2cnRjWbWG4n/ec0EOhctGzFOgEoy+aiTcA+UN6rIazNCfCBJZhoZm/1SA9rTMAWbAlGcjz5PaSemy5N+eFitnWRt5tIf20SEqo3NUQTeoimqIoCf0gt7Qu/PsvDofzudkNOdkO7voD5yvX28coG0=</latexit>22
(constant-ne)
4 0 0 3 5 0 3 0 0 0 2 4 6 8 1 0 1 / p s 図 7 . 3 水 の 温 度 制 御 1=5psにおいて,温度7;,を300Kから350Kにあげた. E S に ` 6 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0
2 0 0 0
7 。 5 バ リ ネ ロ ・ ラ ー マ ン の 方 法 月 ア 0 2 4 6 8 1 0 1 / p s 図7.4水のJ1モカ制御 =5psにおいて,圧力/4を1000atmから3000au11にあげた.
こ こ で は , 立 方 休 セ ル に 対 し 休 秘 レ を 一 ・ 般 化 座 標 と し て 運 助 方 程 式 を 導 い た . も ち ろ ん , 体 秘 ド の 代 わ り に セ ル の 一 辺 の 長 さ 乙 = 副 ( 7 . 5 3 ) を 変 数 と し て も か ま わ な い . さ ら に は , 直 方 体 セ ル に 対 し , 各 辺 の 長 さ
回 口 し
を 一 般 化 座 標 と し て , 三 つ の 方 向 の 圧 力 が そ れ ぞ れ
j に 以
( 7 . 5 4 ) ( 7 . 5 5 )
となるように制御することもできる.たとえば,鳥・=几=h11111として,八= 0.5atmのようにとれば,表而張力-定のMD計拿1:力41呼能となる.次節ではこ れ を さ ら に 拡 張 し て , セ ル の 傾 き ま で 自 山 度 を 与 え る こ と に よ り 圧 カ テ ン ソ ル P を 制 御 す る 方 法 を 示 す. 7 . 5 パ リ ネ ロ ・ ラ ー マ ン の 方 法 ここでは,基本セルの各辺の長さが自山に変わると|・り時に,セルの傾きも変 化 し , 圧 力 の 平 均 値 が ハ と 一 定 と な る よ う な M D 計 算 に つ い て 説 明 す る . こ れ に よ り , 紘 品 系 が 界 な る j 川 休 間 で の 相 転 移 や, 不 均 ・ 系 で の ひ ず み の な い MD計算が可能となる. 基 本 セ ル を 記 述 す る の に , 図 7 . 5 に 示 すよ う に 平 行 六 而 体 セ ル の 各 辺 を 表 す ペ ク トル a , 6 , c を 川 いて 行 列 1 を 定 義 す る . £=(aろc)
Conventional NPT MD simulation If we can introduce a fictitious motion for amount of charge , we can realize NVTμe MD simulation μ (eV) t (ps)
ne
vcell ˙ vcell = Pvcell Mvcell ˙ Pvcell = P − Pext
: Cell volume
Mvcell : Fictitious mass for variable cell ˙ ncell = Pncell Mncell ˙ Pncell = µ − µext
from Virial theorem
23
Lagrangian for extended system
coordinates , and the time derivative of is defined as ˙ ri = V
1 3 ˙
˜ ri where, is the fictitious mass of the cell. The Euler-Lagrange equation becomes W Instantaneous pressure (Virial theorem)
ri = V
1 3 ˜
ri, (0 ≤ ˜ ri ≤ 1) LP = 1 2
N
X
i
miV
2 3 ˙
˜ r2
i − E({V
1 3 ˜
r}; ψ) + 1 2W ˙ V 2 − PextV 8 > > > > > < > > > > > : mi¨ ˜ ri = −V − 2
3 ∂E({V 1 3 ˜
r}; ψ) ∂˜ ri − 2 ˙ V 3V ˙ ˜ r W ¨ V = 1 3V " N X
i
miV
2 3 ˙
˜ r2
i − N
X
i
ri · ∂E({r}; ψ) ∂ri # − Pext ri ˜ ri ˜ ri
Pext L = V 1/3
time evolution
V 0
24
to keep the Fermi energy of the system as target Fermi energy . µext
Instantaneous Fermi energy Lµ = 1 2
N
X
i
mi ˙ r2
i − E({r}; ψ) + 1
2M ˙ n2 − (−µextn) 8 > > > < > > > : mi¨ ri = −∂E({ri}; ψ) ∂ri M ¨ n = − ✓∂E({ri}; ψ) ∂n − µext ◆ M where, is the fictitious mass of FCP. The Euler-Lagrange equation becomes Lagrangian for extended system n e− e−
V µext
Time evolution
n0
25
Constant pressure Constant chemical potential Pin < Pext Pin = Pext Pin > Pext V0 −δV δV V V n n δn −δn n0 µin > µext µin = µext µin < µext µext = hµini Pext = hPini Extensive var. Intensive var. Mean value Linearization at equilibrium W ¨ V = Pin Pext ! Wδ ¨ V ' B V0 δV M ¨ n = µin µext ! Mδ¨ n ' 1 C δn B = −V0 ∂P ∂V 1 C = ∂µ ∂n Bulk modulus: Capacitance: Restoring force yields the oscillation around the bottom
26
By connecting an appropriate thermostat, e.g. Nosé thermostat, scaling method…, we can realize an isobaric and grand canonical ensembles.
Partition function Fluctuation of extensive variable
Isobaric Grand canonical (for electron)
H = 1 2
N
X
i
mir2
i + E({r}; ψ)
κ = 1 hV i ∂hV i ∂Pext = hδV 2i kBThV i C = ∂hni ∂µext = hδn2i kBT Compressibility Capacitance Y = ZZZ exp [−(H + PextV )/kBT] drdqdV H = 1 2
N
X
i
mir2
i + E({r}; ψ)
Ξµ = ZZZ exp [−(H − µextn)/kBT] drdqdn
Johnson-Nyquist noise
27
(FCP) is introduced with fictitious mass.
grand potential.
evolved by equation of motion for FCP. We can obtain the grand canonical ensemble.
nnew
e
rnew
i
SCF calculation (constant-N) Output:
F i
Input: Input:
˙ ri = pi mi , ˙ pi = Fi
Atoms
dynamics solver (dynamic) KS solver
rnew
i
Output:
nnew
e
Output: Input: ri, ne
˙ ne = Pne Mne ,
Fictitious charge particle (FCP)
(static)
solver (dynamic)
˙ Pne = F FCP = µ − µext
Etot, F i, F FCP F FCP
28
F atom
i
, F FCP F atom
i
, F FCP F atom
i
, F FCP F atom
i
, F FCP
Constrained geometry optimisation
˜ E
FCP is also updated at each atomic step. ⇒no additional calculation cost
Searching the minimum energy path (MEP) using NEB with constant-μ
29
ΩP
<latexit sha1_base64="7mvphwLNiCpKPk8Tv0BK9AvHQs=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFL3xWesr1aWbYBFclUQEXbgouHFnBfuAJoTJdNIOnZmEmYlSYj/FjQtF3Pol7vwbJ20W2npg4HDOvdwzJ0oZVdp1v62V1bX1jc3KVnV7Z3dv364dFSUzaOGJ7EVIEUYFaWuqGemlkiAeMdKNxteF30gUtFE3OtJSgKOhoLGFCNtpNCu+becDFHoc6RHkuetaWjX3Y7g7NMvJLUoUQrtL/8QYIzToTGDCnV9xUBzmSmJGplU/UyRFeIyGpG+oQJyoIJ9FnzonRhk4cSLNE9qZqb83csSVmvDITBYJ1aJXiP95/UzHl0FORZpIvD8UJwxRydO0YMzoJgzSaGICypyergEZIa9NW1ZTgLX5mXTOGp7b8O7O682rso4KHMExnIHF9CEG2hBGzA8wjO8wpv1ZL1Y79bHfHTFKncO4Q+szx9/wpQg</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7mvphwLNiCpKPk8Tv0BK9AvHQs=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFL3xWesr1aWbYBFclUQEXbgouHFnBfuAJoTJdNIOnZmEmYlSYj/FjQtF3Pol7vwbJ20W2npg4HDOvdwzJ0oZVdp1v62V1bX1jc3KVnV7Z3dv364dFSUzaOGJ7EVIEUYFaWuqGemlkiAeMdKNxteF30gUtFE3OtJSgKOhoLGFCNtpNCu+becDFHoc6RHkuetaWjX3Y7g7NMvJLUoUQrtL/8QYIzToTGDCnV9xUBzmSmJGplU/UyRFeIyGpG+oQJyoIJ9FnzonRhk4cSLNE9qZqb83csSVmvDITBYJ1aJXiP95/UzHl0FORZpIvD8UJwxRydO0YMzoJgzSaGICypyergEZIa9NW1ZTgLX5mXTOGp7b8O7O682rso4KHMExnIHF9CEG2hBGzA8wjO8wpv1ZL1Y79bHfHTFKncO4Q+szx9/wpQg</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7mvphwLNiCpKPk8Tv0BK9AvHQs=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFL3xWesr1aWbYBFclUQEXbgouHFnBfuAJoTJdNIOnZmEmYlSYj/FjQtF3Pol7vwbJ20W2npg4HDOvdwzJ0oZVdp1v62V1bX1jc3KVnV7Z3dv364dFSUzaOGJ7EVIEUYFaWuqGemlkiAeMdKNxteF30gUtFE3OtJSgKOhoLGFCNtpNCu+becDFHoc6RHkuetaWjX3Y7g7NMvJLUoUQrtL/8QYIzToTGDCnV9xUBzmSmJGplU/UyRFeIyGpG+oQJyoIJ9FnzonRhk4cSLNE9qZqb83csSVmvDITBYJ1aJXiP95/UzHl0FORZpIvD8UJwxRydO0YMzoJgzSaGICypyergEZIa9NW1ZTgLX5mXTOGp7b8O7O682rso4KHMExnIHF9CEG2hBGzA8wjO8wpv1ZL1Y79bHfHTFKncO4Q+szx9/wpQg</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7mvphwLNiCpKPk8Tv0BK9AvHQs=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFL3xWesr1aWbYBFclUQEXbgouHFnBfuAJoTJdNIOnZmEmYlSYj/FjQtF3Pol7vwbJ20W2npg4HDOvdwzJ0oZVdp1v62V1bX1jc3KVnV7Z3dv364dFSUzaOGJ7EVIEUYFaWuqGemlkiAeMdKNxteF30gUtFE3OtJSgKOhoLGFCNtpNCu+becDFHoc6RHkuetaWjX3Y7g7NMvJLUoUQrtL/8QYIzToTGDCnV9xUBzmSmJGplU/UyRFeIyGpG+oQJyoIJ9FnzonRhk4cSLNE9qZqb83csSVmvDITBYJ1aJXiP95/UzHl0FORZpIvD8UJwxRydO0YMzoJgzSaGICypyergEZIa9NW1ZTgLX5mXTOGp7b8O7O682rso4KHMExnIHF9CEG2hBGzA8wjO8wpv1ZL1Y79bHfHTFKncO4Q+szx9/wpQg</latexit>ΩR
<latexit sha1_base64="JkDSexY1ZAhPDgAORGgqmgnA9to=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vVJdugkVwVRIRdOGi4MadVewDmhAm09t26MwkzEyUEvspblwo4tYvcefOGmz0NYDA4dz7uWeOVHCqNKu+2VlbX1jfKm5Wt7Z3dPbu631ZxKgm0SMxi2Y2wAkYFtDTVDLqJBMwjBp1ofJX7nQeQisbiXk8SCDgeCjqgBGsjhXbVv+EwxKHPsR5Jnt1NQ7vm1t0ZnGXiFaSGCjRD+8vxyTlIDRhWKme5yY6yLDUlDCYVvxUQYLJGA+hZ6jAHFSQzaJPnWOj9J1BLM0T2pmpvzcyzJWa8MhM5gnVopeL/3m9VA8ugoyKJNUgyPzQIGWOjp28B6dPJRDNJoZgIqnJ6pARlpho01bFlOAtfnmZtE/rnlv3bs9qjcuijI6REfoBHnoHDXQNWqiFiLoET2jV/RmPVkv1rv1MR8tWcXOAfoD6/MHgsyUIg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JkDSexY1ZAhPDgAORGgqmgnA9to=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vVJdugkVwVRIRdOGi4MadVewDmhAm09t26MwkzEyUEvspblwo4tYvcefOGmz0NYDA4dz7uWeOVHCqNKu+2VlbX1jfKm5Wt7Z3dPbu631ZxKgm0SMxi2Y2wAkYFtDTVDLqJBMwjBp1ofJX7nQeQisbiXk8SCDgeCjqgBGsjhXbVv+EwxKHPsR5Jnt1NQ7vm1t0ZnGXiFaSGCjRD+8vxyTlIDRhWKme5yY6yLDUlDCYVvxUQYLJGA+hZ6jAHFSQzaJPnWOj9J1BLM0T2pmpvzcyzJWa8MhM5gnVopeL/3m9VA8ugoyKJNUgyPzQIGWOjp28B6dPJRDNJoZgIqnJ6pARlpho01bFlOAtfnmZtE/rnlv3bs9qjcuijI6REfoBHnoHDXQNWqiFiLoET2jV/RmPVkv1rv1MR8tWcXOAfoD6/MHgsyUIg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JkDSexY1ZAhPDgAORGgqmgnA9to=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vVJdugkVwVRIRdOGi4MadVewDmhAm09t26MwkzEyUEvspblwo4tYvcefOGmz0NYDA4dz7uWeOVHCqNKu+2VlbX1jfKm5Wt7Z3dPbu631ZxKgm0SMxi2Y2wAkYFtDTVDLqJBMwjBp1ofJX7nQeQisbiXk8SCDgeCjqgBGsjhXbVv+EwxKHPsR5Jnt1NQ7vm1t0ZnGXiFaSGCjRD+8vxyTlIDRhWKme5yY6yLDUlDCYVvxUQYLJGA+hZ6jAHFSQzaJPnWOj9J1BLM0T2pmpvzcyzJWa8MhM5gnVopeL/3m9VA8ugoyKJNUgyPzQIGWOjp28B6dPJRDNJoZgIqnJ6pARlpho01bFlOAtfnmZtE/rnlv3bs9qjcuijI6REfoBHnoHDXQNWqiFiLoET2jV/RmPVkv1rv1MR8tWcXOAfoD6/MHgsyUIg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JkDSexY1ZAhPDgAORGgqmgnA9to=">AB+nicbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vVJdugkVwVRIRdOGi4MadVewDmhAm09t26MwkzEyUEvspblwo4tYvcefOGmz0NYDA4dz7uWeOVHCqNKu+2VlbX1jfKm5Wt7Z3dPbu631ZxKgm0SMxi2Y2wAkYFtDTVDLqJBMwjBp1ofJX7nQeQisbiXk8SCDgeCjqgBGsjhXbVv+EwxKHPsR5Jnt1NQ7vm1t0ZnGXiFaSGCjRD+8vxyTlIDRhWKme5yY6yLDUlDCYVvxUQYLJGA+hZ6jAHFSQzaJPnWOj9J1BLM0T2pmpvzcyzJWa8MhM5gnVopeL/3m9VA8ugoyKJNUgyPzQIGWOjp28B6dPJRDNJoZgIqnJ6pARlpho01bFlOAtfnmZtE/rnlv3bs9qjcuijI6REfoBHnoHDXQNWqiFiLoET2jV/RmPVkv1rv1MR8tWcXOAfoD6/MHgsyUIg=</latexit>Ω
<latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit>Minimize instead of the total energy includes the potential derived from an external potentiostat. Force acting on atoms Force acting on FCP We need to consider the generalized force acting on atoms & FCP to
E ˜ E µextn
30
Ω
<latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JhTC7aU4tLZ4qypXxicDFpjDL98=">AB7XicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avqKXNYhCswp0IWlgEbOyMYD4gOcLeZi5Zs7t37O4JIeQ/2FgoYuv/sfPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+v7397K6tr6xmZhq7i9s7u3Xzo4bJgk0wzrLBGJbkXUoOAK65Zbga1UI5WRwGY0vJn6zSfUhifqwY5SDCXtKx5zRq2TGp07iX3aLZX9ij8DWSZBTsqQo9YtfXV6CcskKsENaYd+KkNx1RbzgROip3MYErZkPax7aiEk04nl07IadO6ZE40a6UJTP198SYSmNGMnKdktqBWfSm4n9eO7PxVTjmKs0sKjZfFGeC2IRMXyc9rpFZMXKEMs3drYQNqKbMuoCKLoRg8eVl0jivBH4luL8oV6/zOApwDCdwBgFcQhVuoQZ1YPAIz/AKb17ivXjv3se8dcXLZ47gD7zPH1jvU=</latexit>Ω = E − µextn
<latexit sha1_base64="eAE4XJQURu6l30m3q+Lb2MW7/EQ=">ACA3icbVBNS8NAEN34WetX1ZteFovgxZKIoAeFgjerGA/oAls520S3eTsLsRSyh48a948aCIV/+EN/+NmzYHbX0w8Hhvhpl5fsyZ0rb9bc3NLywuLRdWiqtr6xubpa3thoSaFOIx7Jlk8UcBZCXTPNoRVLIMLn0PQHl5nfvAepWBTe6WEMniC9kAWMEm2kTmnXvRHQIxdXR65IOq4gui9FCg96ZMyXbHwLPEyUkZ5ah1Sl9uN6KJgFBTpRqO3asvZRIzSiHUdFNFMSEDkgP2oaGRIDy0vEPI3xglC4OImkq1His/p5IiVBqKHzTmR2pr1M/M9rJzo481IWxomGkE4WBQnHOsJZILjLJFDNh4YQKpm5FdM+kYRqE1vRhOBMvzxLGscVx64tyfl6nkeRwHtoX10iBx0iqroGtVQHVH0iJ7RK3qznqwX6936mLTOWfnMDvoD6/MHKMCX1g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="eAE4XJQURu6l30m3q+Lb2MW7/EQ=">ACA3icbVBNS8NAEN34WetX1ZteFovgxZKIoAeFgjerGA/oAls520S3eTsLsRSyh48a948aCIV/+EN/+NmzYHbX0w8Hhvhpl5fsyZ0rb9bc3NLywuLRdWiqtr6xubpa3thoSaFOIx7Jlk8UcBZCXTPNoRVLIMLn0PQHl5nfvAepWBTe6WEMniC9kAWMEm2kTmnXvRHQIxdXR65IOq4gui9FCg96ZMyXbHwLPEyUkZ5ah1Sl9uN6KJgFBTpRqO3asvZRIzSiHUdFNFMSEDkgP2oaGRIDy0vEPI3xglC4OImkq1His/p5IiVBqKHzTmR2pr1M/M9rJzo481IWxomGkE4WBQnHOsJZILjLJFDNh4YQKpm5FdM+kYRqE1vRhOBMvzxLGscVx64tyfl6nkeRwHtoX10iBx0iqroGtVQHVH0iJ7RK3qznqwX6936mLTOWfnMDvoD6/MHKMCX1g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="eAE4XJQURu6l30m3q+Lb2MW7/EQ=">ACA3icbVBNS8NAEN34WetX1ZteFovgxZKIoAeFgjerGA/oAls520S3eTsLsRSyh48a948aCIV/+EN/+NmzYHbX0w8Hhvhpl5fsyZ0rb9bc3NLywuLRdWiqtr6xubpa3thoSaFOIx7Jlk8UcBZCXTPNoRVLIMLn0PQHl5nfvAepWBTe6WEMniC9kAWMEm2kTmnXvRHQIxdXR65IOq4gui9FCg96ZMyXbHwLPEyUkZ5ah1Sl9uN6KJgFBTpRqO3asvZRIzSiHUdFNFMSEDkgP2oaGRIDy0vEPI3xglC4OImkq1His/p5IiVBqKHzTmR2pr1M/M9rJzo481IWxomGkE4WBQnHOsJZILjLJFDNh4YQKpm5FdM+kYRqE1vRhOBMvzxLGscVx64tyfl6nkeRwHtoX10iBx0iqroGtVQHVH0iJ7RK3qznqwX6936mLTOWfnMDvoD6/MHKMCX1g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="eAE4XJQURu6l30m3q+Lb2MW7/EQ=">ACA3icbVBNS8NAEN34WetX1ZteFovgxZKIoAeFgjerGA/oAls520S3eTsLsRSyh48a948aCIV/+EN/+NmzYHbX0w8Hhvhpl5fsyZ0rb9bc3NLywuLRdWiqtr6xubpa3thoSaFOIx7Jlk8UcBZCXTPNoRVLIMLn0PQHl5nfvAepWBTe6WEMniC9kAWMEm2kTmnXvRHQIxdXR65IOq4gui9FCg96ZMyXbHwLPEyUkZ5ah1Sl9uN6KJgFBTpRqO3asvZRIzSiHUdFNFMSEDkgP2oaGRIDy0vEPI3xglC4OImkq1His/p5IiVBqKHzTmR2pr1M/M9rJzo481IWxomGkE4WBQnHOsJZILjLJFDNh4YQKpm5FdM+kYRqE1vRhOBMvzxLGscVx64tyfl6nkeRwHtoX10iBx0iqroGtVQHVH0iJ7RK3qznqwX6936mLTOWfnMDvoD6/MHKMCX1g=</latexit>F i = − ∂Ω ∂ri = − ∂E ∂ri
<latexit sha1_base64="PUKONwg2TjWpA6lQSFSpf1Gp4FY=">ACWHicbVFbS8MwGE3r5i7e6nz0JTgEXxytCPqgMBDFNye4C6xlpFm6haVNSVJhlP5JwQf9K76YbkXn5gchJ+c7J5cTP2ZUKtv+MytUnm7Uq3Vd3b39g+sw0ZP8kRg0sWcTHwkSMRqSrqGJkEAuCQp+Rvj+7y/v9VyIk5dGLmsfEC9EkogHFSGlqZHX52ws56Ge0odsRG/P3UAgnLoxEoi5j6FZIKynzVcNQhtyNYd8P5XvSEeWU27ZS8KbgKnAE1QVGdkvbljpOQRAozJOXQsWPlpfn2mJGs7iaSxAjP0IQMNYxQSKSXLoLJ4KlmxjDgQo9IwQW76khRKPbaWI1FSu93Lyv94wUcG1l9IoThSJ8PKgIGFQcZinDMdUEKzYXAOEBdV3hXiKdEpK/0Vdh+CsP3kT9C5ajt1yni+b7Zsijio4BifgDjgCrTBI+iALsDgHXwZJaNsfJrArJi1pdQ0Cs8R+FNm4xtIVbe2</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PUKONwg2TjWpA6lQSFSpf1Gp4FY=">ACWHicbVFbS8MwGE3r5i7e6nz0JTgEXxytCPqgMBDFNye4C6xlpFm6haVNSVJhlP5JwQf9K76YbkXn5gchJ+c7J5cTP2ZUKtv+MytUnm7Uq3Vd3b39g+sw0ZP8kRg0sWcTHwkSMRqSrqGJkEAuCQp+Rvj+7y/v9VyIk5dGLmsfEC9EkogHFSGlqZHX52ws56Ge0odsRG/P3UAgnLoxEoi5j6FZIKynzVcNQhtyNYd8P5XvSEeWU27ZS8KbgKnAE1QVGdkvbljpOQRAozJOXQsWPlpfn2mJGs7iaSxAjP0IQMNYxQSKSXLoLJ4KlmxjDgQo9IwQW76khRKPbaWI1FSu93Lyv94wUcG1l9IoThSJ8PKgIGFQcZinDMdUEKzYXAOEBdV3hXiKdEpK/0Vdh+CsP3kT9C5ajt1yni+b7Zsijio4BifgDjgCrTBI+iALsDgHXwZJaNsfJrArJi1pdQ0Cs8R+FNm4xtIVbe2</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PUKONwg2TjWpA6lQSFSpf1Gp4FY=">ACWHicbVFbS8MwGE3r5i7e6nz0JTgEXxytCPqgMBDFNye4C6xlpFm6haVNSVJhlP5JwQf9K76YbkXn5gchJ+c7J5cTP2ZUKtv+MytUnm7Uq3Vd3b39g+sw0ZP8kRg0sWcTHwkSMRqSrqGJkEAuCQp+Rvj+7y/v9VyIk5dGLmsfEC9EkogHFSGlqZHX52ws56Ge0odsRG/P3UAgnLoxEoi5j6FZIKynzVcNQhtyNYd8P5XvSEeWU27ZS8KbgKnAE1QVGdkvbljpOQRAozJOXQsWPlpfn2mJGs7iaSxAjP0IQMNYxQSKSXLoLJ4KlmxjDgQo9IwQW76khRKPbaWI1FSu93Lyv94wUcG1l9IoThSJ8PKgIGFQcZinDMdUEKzYXAOEBdV3hXiKdEpK/0Vdh+CsP3kT9C5ajt1yni+b7Zsijio4BifgDjgCrTBI+iALsDgHXwZJaNsfJrArJi1pdQ0Cs8R+FNm4xtIVbe2</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PUKONwg2TjWpA6lQSFSpf1Gp4FY=">ACWHicbVFbS8MwGE3r5i7e6nz0JTgEXxytCPqgMBDFNye4C6xlpFm6haVNSVJhlP5JwQf9K76YbkXn5gchJ+c7J5cTP2ZUKtv+MytUnm7Uq3Vd3b39g+sw0ZP8kRg0sWcTHwkSMRqSrqGJkEAuCQp+Rvj+7y/v9VyIk5dGLmsfEC9EkogHFSGlqZHX52ws56Ge0odsRG/P3UAgnLoxEoi5j6FZIKynzVcNQhtyNYd8P5XvSEeWU27ZS8KbgKnAE1QVGdkvbljpOQRAozJOXQsWPlpfn2mJGs7iaSxAjP0IQMNYxQSKSXLoLJ4KlmxjDgQo9IwQW76khRKPbaWI1FSu93Lyv94wUcG1l9IoThSJ8PKgIGFQcZinDMdUEKzYXAOEBdV3hXiKdEpK/0Vdh+CsP3kT9C5ajt1yni+b7Zsijio4BifgDjgCrTBI+iALsDgHXwZJaNsfJrArJi1pdQ0Cs8R+FNm4xtIVbe2</latexit>F FCP = −∂Ω ∂n = −(µ − µext)
<latexit sha1_base64="HYxdAT7p2jlM0UsXe2nXM72dc4=">ACMnicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLEI9WHZF0IOCIierGBboVtLNp2twS7JFmxLPubvPhLBA96UMSrP8JsraLWgYE3b+YxMy+IOdPGdR+dkdGx8YnJqenCzOzc/EJxcamuo0RqNGIR+o8IBo4k1AzHA4jxUQEXBoBFcHeb9xDUqzSJ6ZXgwtQbqShYwSY6l28fjwhfEXCqRHh5Us70NP1SEpn5MlGE+ycCuiT7rG0I2VfJBs219KuDHZertYcituP/Aw8AaghAZRbRfv/U5EwHSUE60bnpubFpvohyAp+oiEm9Ip0oWmhJAJ0K+2/nOE1y3RwGCmb0uA+1OREqF1TwR2Mj9S/+3l5H+9ZmLCnVbKZJwYkPRzUZhwbCKc+4c7TAE1vGcBoYrZWzG9JNYzY10uWBO8vy8Pg/pmxXMr3ulWaX93YMcUWkGrqIw8tI320RGqohqi6BY9oGf04tw5T86r8/Y5OuIMNMvoVzjvH4Heq4E=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HYxdAT7p2jlM0UsXe2nXM72dc4=">ACMnicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLEI9WHZF0IOCIierGBboVtLNp2twS7JFmxLPubvPhLBA96UMSrP8JsraLWgYE3b+YxMy+IOdPGdR+dkdGx8YnJqenCzOzc/EJxcamuo0RqNGIR+o8IBo4k1AzHA4jxUQEXBoBFcHeb9xDUqzSJ6ZXgwtQbqShYwSY6l28fjwhfEXCqRHh5Us70NP1SEpn5MlGE+ycCuiT7rG0I2VfJBs219KuDHZertYcituP/Aw8AaghAZRbRfv/U5EwHSUE60bnpubFpvohyAp+oiEm9Ip0oWmhJAJ0K+2/nOE1y3RwGCmb0uA+1OREqF1TwR2Mj9S/+3l5H+9ZmLCnVbKZJwYkPRzUZhwbCKc+4c7TAE1vGcBoYrZWzG9JNYzY10uWBO8vy8Pg/pmxXMr3ulWaX93YMcUWkGrqIw8tI320RGqohqi6BY9oGf04tw5T86r8/Y5OuIMNMvoVzjvH4Heq4E=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HYxdAT7p2jlM0UsXe2nXM72dc4=">ACMnicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLEI9WHZF0IOCIierGBboVtLNp2twS7JFmxLPubvPhLBA96UMSrP8JsraLWgYE3b+YxMy+IOdPGdR+dkdGx8YnJqenCzOzc/EJxcamuo0RqNGIR+o8IBo4k1AzHA4jxUQEXBoBFcHeb9xDUqzSJ6ZXgwtQbqShYwSY6l28fjwhfEXCqRHh5Us70NP1SEpn5MlGE+ycCuiT7rG0I2VfJBs219KuDHZertYcituP/Aw8AaghAZRbRfv/U5EwHSUE60bnpubFpvohyAp+oiEm9Ip0oWmhJAJ0K+2/nOE1y3RwGCmb0uA+1OREqF1TwR2Mj9S/+3l5H+9ZmLCnVbKZJwYkPRzUZhwbCKc+4c7TAE1vGcBoYrZWzG9JNYzY10uWBO8vy8Pg/pmxXMr3ulWaX93YMcUWkGrqIw8tI320RGqohqi6BY9oGf04tw5T86r8/Y5OuIMNMvoVzjvH4Heq4E=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HYxdAT7p2jlM0UsXe2nXM72dc4=">ACMnicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLEI9WHZF0IOCIierGBboVtLNp2twS7JFmxLPubvPhLBA96UMSrP8JsraLWgYE3b+YxMy+IOdPGdR+dkdGx8YnJqenCzOzc/EJxcamuo0RqNGIR+o8IBo4k1AzHA4jxUQEXBoBFcHeb9xDUqzSJ6ZXgwtQbqShYwSY6l28fjwhfEXCqRHh5Us70NP1SEpn5MlGE+ycCuiT7rG0I2VfJBs219KuDHZertYcituP/Aw8AaghAZRbRfv/U5EwHSUE60bnpubFpvohyAp+oiEm9Ip0oWmhJAJ0K+2/nOE1y3RwGCmb0uA+1OREqF1TwR2Mj9S/+3l5H+9ZmLCnVbKZJwYkPRzUZhwbCKc+4c7TAE1vGcBoYrZWzG9JNYzY10uWBO8vy8Pg/pmxXMr3ulWaX93YMcUWkGrqIw8tI320RGqohqi6BY9oGf04tw5T86r8/Y5OuIMNMvoVzjvH4Heq4E=</latexit>(FCP) is introduced with fictitious mass.
grand potential.
evolved by equation of motion for FCP. We can obtain the grand canonical ensemble.
nnew
e
rnew
i
SCF calculation (constant-N) Output:
F i
Input: Input:
˙ ri = pi mi , ˙ pi = Fi
Atoms
dynamics solver (dynamic) KS solver
rnew
i
Output:
nnew
e
Output: Input: ri, ne
˙ ne = Pne Mne ,
Fictitious charge particle (FCP)
(static)
solver (dynamic)
˙ Pne = F FCP = µ − µext
Etot, F i, F FCP F FCP
31
−10 −8 −6 −4 5 5.2 5.4 5.6 5.8 6 6.2 6.4 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 Fermi energy (eV) Excess charge Q(e) Time (ps)
constant-N
Tatom = 353 K Q = 0.35 (e/cell)
constant-μ
µext = −6.0 eV T = 300 K Mne = 300 cm−1 Mξe = 100 cm−1 µext = −4.9 eV T = 300 K Mne = 300 cm−1 Mξe = 100 cm−1
32
(ESM-RISM)
DFT)
33
ESM-RISM method
Reference Interaction Site Model
3.Screening in diffuse layer 4.Origin of electrostatic potential
Effective Screening Medium method
Constant-μ method ESM method 1.Strong electric field in Helmholtz layer 2.Bias potential control
34
ESM-RISM method
Reference Interaction Site Model
3.Screening in diffuse layer 4.Origin of electrostatic potential
electrode
+ + +
+ + +
35
Concept of DFT+continuum medium hybrid method
36
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r)
Generalized Poisson equation
ρtot = ρDFT + ρsolv E[⇤e, V ] = T[⇤e] + Exc[⇤e] + ⇤ dr
8⇥ |⇤V (r)|2 + ⇤tot(r)V (r) ⇥
Total energy functional
2⇥2 + V (r) + ˆ VNL + Vxc(r) ⇥ ψi(r) = εiψi(r)
Kohn-Sham equation
E[ρ] = T[ρ] + Exc[ρ] + 1 2
|r − r| +
V ➠ variable
δE δρe = 0 δE δV = 0
PCM: Environ RISM: ESM-RISM CDFT: JDFT
Concept of DFT+continuum medium hybrid method
36
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r)
Generalized Poisson equation
ρtot = ρDFT + ρsolv ρsolv ρDFT PCM, RISM, CDFT
Concept of DFT+continuum medium hybrid method
V (r) =
|r − r| (r) = 1
PCM, JDFT
(r) : model dependent
ESM
V (r) = Z dr0GMBC(r, r0)ρtot(r0)
Laue representation
h @z {✏(z)@z} − ✏(z)g2
k
i V (gk, z) = −4⇡⇢tot(gk, z)
Open boundary condition
8 > > > < > > > : GMBC(gk, z, z0) = 4π 2gk egk|zz0| GMBC(rk − r0
k, z, z0) =
1 q |rk − r0
k|2 + (z − z0)2
@zV (gk, z)
✏(z) = 1
37
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r)
Generalized Poisson equation
ρtot = ρDFT + ρsolv
Concept of DFT+continuum medium hybrid method
E[⇤e, V ] = T[⇤e] + Exc[⇤e] + ⇤ dr
8⇥ |⇤V (r)|2 + ⇤tot(r)V (r) ⇥
Total energy functional
⇥[(r)⇥]V (r) = 4⇥⇤tot(r)
2⇥2 + V (r) + ˆ VNL + Vxc(r) ⇥ ψi(r) = εiψi(r)
Generalized Poisson equation Kohn-Sham equation
E[ρ] = T[ρ] + Exc[ρ] + 1 2
|r − r| +
V (r) =
|r − r| (r) = 1
PCM, JDFT
(r) : model dependent
ESM
V ➠ variable
δE δρe = 0 δE δV = 0
V (r) = Z dr0GMBC(r, r0)ρtot(r0)
38
39
Born 1920 Bell 1931 Kirkwood 1934 Onsager 1936 Debye Huckel 1923 D-PCM 1981 COSMO 1993 IEF-PCM 1997 Fattebert Gygi 2002 Cococcioni 2005 SCCS 2012 Soft Sphere 2017 Joint-DFT 2005 dd-COSMO 2013 SVPE SS(V)PE 1997 I-PCM 1994 SCI-PCM 1995 ONETEP 2011 JDFT-PB 2012 SALSA 2015 CANDLE 2015 GB 1994 Scherlis 2006 Dabo PB 2008 ESM 2006 FHI 2016 Vasp-sol 2016 3D-RISM ESM 2017 SMX 2000-now
By courtesy of O. Andreussi
Classical Density Functional Theory (CDFT) Ornstein–Zernike (OZ) equation Reference Interaction Site Model (RISM)
Accuracy
Joint Density Functional Theory (JDFT) PCM · · · Variant of JDFT · · ·
41
Ornstein-Zernike equation
8 < : h(r1, r2) = c(r1, r2) + Z dr3c(r1, r3)ρ(r3)h(r3, r2) h(r1, r2) = g(r1, r2) − 1 h(12) = c(12) + Z d(3)c(13)ρ(3)c(32) + Z d(3)d(4)c(13)ρ(3)c(34)ρ(4)c(42) · · ·
1 2 3 4 ρ(4)
Z d(3) Z d(4)
42
Total correlation function Direct correlation function Pair distribution function
1D-RISM equation Closure relation (Kovalenco-Hirata) Interaction between atomic sites (Lennard-Jones + Coulomb)
8 > > > > > < > > > > > : hαγ(r) = X
µν
Z dr0 Z dr00ωαµ(|r − r0|)cµν(|r0 − r00|)χνγ(r00) ωαµ(r) = 1 4πr2 δ(r − lαµ) χνγ(r) = ωνγ(r) + ργhνγ(r)
gαγ(r) = ( exp [−βuαγ(r) + hαγ(r) − cαγ(r)] for gαγ ≤ 1 1 − βuαγ(r) + hαγ(r) − cαγ(r) for gαγ > 1
8 > > > > < > > > > : uαγ(r) = 4✏αβ ⇣αβ r ⌘12 − ⇣αβ r ⌘6 + qαqγ r ✏αβ = √✏α✏γ αγ = α + γ 2
43
Bulk liquid ex) 1ML NaCl@Water
!"($) !&($)
3D-RISM equation Closure relation (Kovalenco-Hirata) Interaction between atomic sites (Lennard-Jones + Coulomb)
gγ(r) = ( exp [−βuγ(r) + hγ(r) − cγ(r)] for gγ ≤ 1 1 − βuγ(r) + hγ(r) − cγ(r) for gγ > 1
uγ(r) = X
A
4✏γA "✓ γA |r − RA| ◆12 − ✓ γA |r − RA| ◆6# + Z dr0 qγ⇢DF T |r − r0| 8 > > > < > > > : χνγ(r) = X
g
χνγ(g)eig·r hγ(r) = X
ν
Z dr0cν(r0)χνγ(r0 − r)
From 1D-RISM
44
ρsolv ρDFT RISM
χ
Laue-RISM equation Closure relation (Kovalenco-Hirata) Interaction between atomic sites (Lennard-Jones + Coulomb)
gγ(r) = ( exp [−βuγ(r) + hγ(r) − cγ(r)] for gγ ≤ 1 1 − βuγ(r) + hγ(r) − cγ(r) for gγ > 1
From 1D-RISM
8 > > > < > > > : χνγ(gk, z0 − z) = 1 2π Z 1
1
dgzχνγ(g)eigz(z0z) hγ(gk, z) = X
ν
Z dz0cν(gk, z0)χνγ(gk, z0 − z) uγ(r) = X
A
4✏γA "✓ γA |r − RA| ◆12 − ✓ γA |r − RA| ◆6# + Z dr0GMBC(r, r0)⇢DFT(r0)
45
QM cell Al 10Å 20Å RISM extend cell RISM(NaCl(aq), 5mol/L
1 2 3 4 Density (1/Å) gO(z) gH(z) 0.04 0.08 0.12 −15 −10 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Density (1/Å) Length(Å) gNa(z) gCl(z)
Electrostatic potential
−20 −15 −10 −5 Energy(eV) VQM 0.5 1 Energy (eV) Vsolv −20 −15 −10 −5 −15 −10 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Energy (eV) Length(Å) Vtot
QM RISM Total
46
−20 −15 −10 −5 Energe(eV) VQM 5 10 Energy (eV) Vsolv −20 −15 −10 −5 −15 −10 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Energy (eV) Length(Å) Vtot
1 2 3 4 Density (1/Å) gO(z) gH(z) 0.04 0.08 0.12 0.16 −15 −10 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Density (1/Å) Length(Å) gNa(z) gCl(z)
−20 −15 −10 −5 5 10 Energe(eV) VQM −10 −5 Energy (eV) Vsolv −20 −15 −10 −5 −15 −10 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Energy (eV) Length(Å) Vtot
1 2 3 4 Density (1/Å) gO(z) gH(z) 0.04 0.08 0.12 0.16 −15 −10 −5 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Density (1/Å) Length(Å) gNa(z) gCl(z)
Al -
+ + + +
+ + +
QM RISM QM RISM Total Total
47
LJ parameter of Pt is fitted by Xe-Pt DFT potential.
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Energy [meV] Xe-Pt distance [A]
vdW-DF2-B86R Lennard Jones
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Normarized distribution z-Ztop [Angstrom]
0uC/cm2 +0.24uC/cm2 +1.2uC/cm2
Double layer distance
@PZC
Na+ distribution (0.02M)
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Normarized distribution z-Ztop [Angstrom] Na+ 2M Na+ 0.2M Na+ 0.02M Cl- 0.02M
48
(ESM-RISM)
DFT)
49
EC, LiPF6(1ML) Li+
e−
Li+
e− e−
Li+ Li+ Graphite, LCO
DFT RISM
e−
constant-μ
V
µext
Calculation cell
50
Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) measurements
Typical EIS of Conventional LIB cell LiCoO2|EC3:EMC7 LiPF6 1M|Graphite
In the fully charged and discharged states as well as at the low temperatures (≤20◦C), the Rcell of the Li- ion cells is predominated by the Rct. Temperature-dependence of Rct @0.2 V vs. Li/Li+
A1120 (2004).
The activation energies were evaluated to be around 50-60 kJ/mol (0.5-0.6 eV). These values are very large compared to lithium ion conduction in active materials.
51
Definition of the electrode potential (Calculation)
Li reaction path LiC12 slab + Li (DFT) EC LiPF6 1M solution (RISM) r
Remove from bulk region Remove from edge
52
µe (eV)
<latexit sha1_base64="34bMzmBfMGtwpoTVSTbwW3drgs=">AB/HicbVDLSsNAFJ34rPUVHzs3g0Wom5KIoIKLghuXFUxbaEKZTG/boTNJmJkINR/xY0LFbd+iDv/xkmbhbYeGDicy/3zAkTzpR2nG9raXldW29tFHe3Nre2bX39psqTiUFj8Y8lu2QKOAsAk8zaGdSCAi5NAKRze53oAqVgc3etxAoEg4j1GSXaSF370BdpF3xc9QXRQykyaE5Ou3bFqTlT4EXiFqSCjS69pfi2kqINKUE6U6rpPoICNSM8phUvZTBQmhIzKAjqEREaCbJp+gk+M0sP9WJoXaTxVf29kRCg1FqGZzDOqeS8X/M6qe5fBhmLklRDRGeH+inHOsZ5FbjHJFDNx4YQKpnJiumQSEK1KaxsSnDnv7xIvLPaVc25O6/Ur4s2SugIHaMqctEFqNb1EAeougRPaNX9GY9WS/Wu/UxG12yip0D9AfW5w9KzJSn</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="34bMzmBfMGtwpoTVSTbwW3drgs=">AB/HicbVDLSsNAFJ34rPUVHzs3g0Wom5KIoIKLghuXFUxbaEKZTG/boTNJmJkINR/xY0LFbd+iDv/xkmbhbYeGDicy/3zAkTzpR2nG9raXldW29tFHe3Nre2bX39psqTiUFj8Y8lu2QKOAsAk8zaGdSCAi5NAKRze53oAqVgc3etxAoEg4j1GSXaSF370BdpF3xc9QXRQykyaE5Ou3bFqTlT4EXiFqSCjS69pfi2kqINKUE6U6rpPoICNSM8phUvZTBQmhIzKAjqEREaCbJp+gk+M0sP9WJoXaTxVf29kRCg1FqGZzDOqeS8X/M6qe5fBhmLklRDRGeH+inHOsZ5FbjHJFDNx4YQKpnJiumQSEK1KaxsSnDnv7xIvLPaVc25O6/Ur4s2SugIHaMqctEFqNb1EAeougRPaNX9GY9WS/Wu/UxG12yip0D9AfW5w9KzJSn</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="34bMzmBfMGtwpoTVSTbwW3drgs=">AB/HicbVDLSsNAFJ34rPUVHzs3g0Wom5KIoIKLghuXFUxbaEKZTG/boTNJmJkINR/xY0LFbd+iDv/xkmbhbYeGDicy/3zAkTzpR2nG9raXldW29tFHe3Nre2bX39psqTiUFj8Y8lu2QKOAsAk8zaGdSCAi5NAKRze53oAqVgc3etxAoEg4j1GSXaSF370BdpF3xc9QXRQykyaE5Ou3bFqTlT4EXiFqSCjS69pfi2kqINKUE6U6rpPoICNSM8phUvZTBQmhIzKAjqEREaCbJp+gk+M0sP9WJoXaTxVf29kRCg1FqGZzDOqeS8X/M6qe5fBhmLklRDRGeH+inHOsZ5FbjHJFDNx4YQKpnJiumQSEK1KaxsSnDnv7xIvLPaVc25O6/Ur4s2SugIHaMqctEFqNb1EAeougRPaNX9GY9WS/Wu/UxG12yip0D9AfW5w9KzJSn</latexit>0.0 0.5 1.0 Potential (V vs. Li/Li+)
<latexit sha1_base64="v4cL71KPWB37Q7aF4NE9MpoAK0=">ACH3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3g0WoCDERoQouCm5cdFHBtIUmlsl0g6dPJiZFErop7jxV9y4UBF3/RsnbQpaPTBw5tx7ufcL2ZUSNOcaoWV1bX1jeJmaWt7Z3dP3z9oijhmNg4YhFve0gQRkNiSyoZacecoMBjpOUNb7N6a0S4oFH4IMcxcQPUD6lPMZJK6upVJ0BywIO0EUkSorYxIGVhdhUn5EwHLgQ6vS8TiePZ6dvWwa5gzwL7FyUgY5Gl39y+lFOAnUEsyQEB3LjKWbIi4pZmRSchJBYoSHqE86ioYoIMJNZwYn8EQpPehHXL1Qwpn6cyJFgRDjwFOd2aFiuZaJ/9U6ifSv3JSGcaLc4/kiP2FQRjBLC/YoJ1iysSIc6puhXiAOMJSZVpSIVjLlv8S+8K4Nsz7y3LtJk+jCI7AMagAC1RBDdyBrABk/gBbyBd+1Ze9U+tM95a0HLZw7BL2jTb1j0ozk=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="v4cL71KPWB37Q7aF4NE9MpoAK0=">ACH3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3g0WoCDERoQouCm5cdFHBtIUmlsl0g6dPJiZFErop7jxV9y4UBF3/RsnbQpaPTBw5tx7ufcL2ZUSNOcaoWV1bX1jeJmaWt7Z3dP3z9oijhmNg4YhFve0gQRkNiSyoZacecoMBjpOUNb7N6a0S4oFH4IMcxcQPUD6lPMZJK6upVJ0BywIO0EUkSorYxIGVhdhUn5EwHLgQ6vS8TiePZ6dvWwa5gzwL7FyUgY5Gl39y+lFOAnUEsyQEB3LjKWbIi4pZmRSchJBYoSHqE86ioYoIMJNZwYn8EQpPehHXL1Qwpn6cyJFgRDjwFOd2aFiuZaJ/9U6ifSv3JSGcaLc4/kiP2FQRjBLC/YoJ1iysSIc6puhXiAOMJSZVpSIVjLlv8S+8K4Nsz7y3LtJk+jCI7AMagAC1RBDdyBrABk/gBbyBd+1Ze9U+tM95a0HLZw7BL2jTb1j0ozk=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="v4cL71KPWB37Q7aF4NE9MpoAK0=">ACH3icbVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3g0WoCDERoQouCm5cdFHBtIUmlsl0g6dPJiZFErop7jxV9y4UBF3/RsnbQpaPTBw5tx7ufcL2ZUSNOcaoWV1bX1jeJmaWt7Z3dP3z9oijhmNg4YhFve0gQRkNiSyoZacecoMBjpOUNb7N6a0S4oFH4IMcxcQPUD6lPMZJK6upVJ0BywIO0EUkSorYxIGVhdhUn5EwHLgQ6vS8TiePZ6dvWwa5gzwL7FyUgY5Gl39y+lFOAnUEsyQEB3LjKWbIi4pZmRSchJBYoSHqE86ioYoIMJNZwYn8EQpPehHXL1Qwpn6cyJFgRDjwFOd2aFiuZaJ/9U6ifSv3JSGcaLc4/kiP2FQRjBLC/YoJ1iysSIc6puhXiAOMJSZVpSIVjLlv8S+8K4Nsz7y3LtJk+jCI7AMagAC1RBDdyBrABk/gBbyBd+1Ze9U+tM95a0HLZw7BL2jTb1j0ozk=</latexit>2.0 3.0 4.0 µpzc
<latexit sha1_base64="jL4P1IyzrK5NoIs0Brlex4aRo=">AB+HicbVBNS8NAFHypX7V+RT16CRbBU0lEUMFDwYvHCkYLTQib7aZdursJu5tCDf0nXjyoePWnePfuGlz0NaBhWHmPd7sxBmjSrvut1VbWV1b36hvNra2d3b37P2DB5XmEhMfpyV3RgpwqgvqakW4mCeIxI4/x6Kb0H8dEKpqKez3JSMjRQNCEYqSNFNl2wPMo4EgPJS+yJzyN7KbcmdwlolXkSZU6ET2V9BPc6J0JghpXqem+mwQFJTzMi0EeSKZAiP0ID0DBWIExUWs+RT58QofSdJpXlCOzP190aBuFITHpvJMqNa9ErxP6+X6+QyLKjIck0Enh9Kcubo1ClrcPpUEqzZxBCEJTVZHTxEmFtymqYErzFLy8T/6x1XLvzpvt6qNOhzBMZyCBxfQhlvogA8YxvAMr/BmFdaL9W59zEdrVrVzCH9gf4Ar6qT3w=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="jL4P1IyzrK5NoIs0Brlex4aRo=">AB+HicbVBNS8NAFHypX7V+RT16CRbBU0lEUMFDwYvHCkYLTQib7aZdursJu5tCDf0nXjyoePWnePfuGlz0NaBhWHmPd7sxBmjSrvut1VbWV1b36hvNra2d3b37P2DB5XmEhMfpyV3RgpwqgvqakW4mCeIxI4/x6Kb0H8dEKpqKez3JSMjRQNCEYqSNFNl2wPMo4EgPJS+yJzyN7KbcmdwlolXkSZU6ET2V9BPc6J0JghpXqem+mwQFJTzMi0EeSKZAiP0ID0DBWIExUWs+RT58QofSdJpXlCOzP190aBuFITHpvJMqNa9ErxP6+X6+QyLKjIck0Enh9Kcubo1ClrcPpUEqzZxBCEJTVZHTxEmFtymqYErzFLy8T/6x1XLvzpvt6qNOhzBMZyCBxfQhlvogA8YxvAMr/BmFdaL9W59zEdrVrVzCH9gf4Ar6qT3w=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="jL4P1IyzrK5NoIs0Brlex4aRo=">AB+HicbVBNS8NAFHypX7V+RT16CRbBU0lEUMFDwYvHCkYLTQib7aZdursJu5tCDf0nXjyoePWnePfuGlz0NaBhWHmPd7sxBmjSrvut1VbWV1b36hvNra2d3b37P2DB5XmEhMfpyV3RgpwqgvqakW4mCeIxI4/x6Kb0H8dEKpqKez3JSMjRQNCEYqSNFNl2wPMo4EgPJS+yJzyN7KbcmdwlolXkSZU6ET2V9BPc6J0JghpXqem+mwQFJTzMi0EeSKZAiP0ID0DBWIExUWs+RT58QofSdJpXlCOzP190aBuFITHpvJMqNa9ErxP6+X6+QyLKjIck0Enh9Kcubo1ClrcPpUEqzZxBCEJTVZHTxEmFtymqYErzFLy8T/6x1XLvzpvt6qNOhzBMZyCBxfQhlvogA8YxvAMr/BmFdaL9W59zEdrVrVzCH9gf4Ar6qT3w=</latexit>µe(LiC12) − µe(Li) = ∆G/nF
<latexit sha1_base64="32aHwlMucKyuWDvcBvzmL8WsDM8=">ACIXicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLIerLsiqKAgVNSDhwrWFrplyabTNjTJLklWKMv+Fi/+FS8eVHoT/4zpx0GrDwYe780wMy+MOdPGdT+dqemZ2bn5hcXc0vLK6lp+feNBR4miUKERj1QtJBo4k1AxzHCoxQqICDlUw25p4FcfQWkWyXvTi6EhSFuyFqPEWCnIn/oiCWDXF8R0lEhvWSkLUu8w29ufNLI93z/3L4Ebgq8P5FWQL7hFdwj8l3hjUkBjlIN8329GNBEgDeVE67rnxqaREmUY5ZDl/ERDTGiXtKFuqSQCdCMdvpjhHas0cStStqTBQ/XnREqE1j0R2s7BxXrSG4j/efXEtE4aKZNxYkDS0aJWwrGJ8CAv3GQKqOE9SwhVzN6KaYcoQo1NWdD8CZf/ksqh8XTont3VLg4G6exgLbQNtpFHjpGF+gGlVEFUfSEXtAbenenVfnw+mPWqec8cwm+gXn6xt7c6Mr</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="32aHwlMucKyuWDvcBvzmL8WsDM8=">ACIXicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLIerLsiqKAgVNSDhwrWFrplyabTNjTJLklWKMv+Fi/+FS8eVHoT/4zpx0GrDwYe780wMy+MOdPGdT+dqemZ2bn5hcXc0vLK6lp+feNBR4miUKERj1QtJBo4k1AxzHCoxQqICDlUw25p4FcfQWkWyXvTi6EhSFuyFqPEWCnIn/oiCWDXF8R0lEhvWSkLUu8w29ufNLI93z/3L4Ebgq8P5FWQL7hFdwj8l3hjUkBjlIN8329GNBEgDeVE67rnxqaREmUY5ZDl/ERDTGiXtKFuqSQCdCMdvpjhHas0cStStqTBQ/XnREqE1j0R2s7BxXrSG4j/efXEtE4aKZNxYkDS0aJWwrGJ8CAv3GQKqOE9SwhVzN6KaYcoQo1NWdD8CZf/ksqh8XTont3VLg4G6exgLbQNtpFHjpGF+gGlVEFUfSEXtAbenenVfnw+mPWqec8cwm+gXn6xt7c6Mr</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="32aHwlMucKyuWDvcBvzmL8WsDM8=">ACIXicbVBNSwMxEM36bf2qevQSLIerLsiqKAgVNSDhwrWFrplyabTNjTJLklWKMv+Fi/+FS8eVHoT/4zpx0GrDwYe780wMy+MOdPGdT+dqemZ2bn5hcXc0vLK6lp+feNBR4miUKERj1QtJBo4k1AxzHCoxQqICDlUw25p4FcfQWkWyXvTi6EhSFuyFqPEWCnIn/oiCWDXF8R0lEhvWSkLUu8w29ufNLI93z/3L4Ebgq8P5FWQL7hFdwj8l3hjUkBjlIN8329GNBEgDeVE67rnxqaREmUY5ZDl/ERDTGiXtKFuqSQCdCMdvpjhHas0cStStqTBQ/XnREqE1j0R2s7BxXrSG4j/efXEtE4aKZNxYkDS0aJWwrGJ8CAv3GQKqOE9SwhVzN6KaYcoQo1NWdD8CZf/ksqh8XTont3VLg4G6exgLbQNtpFHjpGF+gGlVEFUfSEXtAbenenVfnw+mPWqec8cwm+gXn6xt7c6Mr</latexit>µe(Li/Li+) = −3.08 eV
<latexit sha1_base64="V483h094Se6E18QVxU0FiarEu4=">ACEXicdVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3wSK0iDVRwQoKBTcuqhgaqGtZTK9bYfOJGFmIpQf8GNv+LGhYpbd+78G5M+oL4OXDicy/3uP4jEplmp9amZ2bn4hvZhZWl5ZXdPXN6rSCwQBm3jMEzUHS2DUBVtRxaDmC8DcYXDt9M8T/oWhKSe6UGPjQ57rq0QwlWsdTS8w0etCDX4Fj1BA/LdL9Mo5vd/NneYcEs3k10qEYtPWsVzCEM8xeZWFk0RqWlfzTaHgk4uIowLGXdMn3VDLFQlDCIMo1Ago9JH3ehHlMXc5DNcPhSZOzEStvoeCIuVxlDdXoixFzKAXfizuRE+dNLxL+8eqA6xWZIXT9Q4JLRok7ADOUZST5Gmwogig1igomg8a0G6WGBiYpTzEyH8D+xDwonBevyKFs6HaeRltoG+WQhY5RCV2gCrIRQfoET2jF+1Be9JetbdRa0obz2yib9DevwAct5yv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="V483h094Se6E18QVxU0FiarEu4=">ACEXicdVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3wSK0iDVRwQoKBTcuqhgaqGtZTK9bYfOJGFmIpQf8GNv+LGhYpbd+78G5M+oL4OXDicy/3uP4jEplmp9amZ2bn4hvZhZWl5ZXdPXN6rSCwQBm3jMEzUHS2DUBVtRxaDmC8DcYXDt9M8T/oWhKSe6UGPjQ57rq0QwlWsdTS8w0etCDX4Fj1BA/LdL9Mo5vd/NneYcEs3k10qEYtPWsVzCEM8xeZWFk0RqWlfzTaHgk4uIowLGXdMn3VDLFQlDCIMo1Ago9JH3ehHlMXc5DNcPhSZOzEStvoeCIuVxlDdXoixFzKAXfizuRE+dNLxL+8eqA6xWZIXT9Q4JLRok7ADOUZST5Gmwogig1igomg8a0G6WGBiYpTzEyH8D+xDwonBevyKFs6HaeRltoG+WQhY5RCV2gCrIRQfoET2jF+1Be9JetbdRa0obz2yib9DevwAct5yv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="V483h094Se6E18QVxU0FiarEu4=">ACEXicdVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3wSK0iDVRwQoKBTcuqhgaqGtZTK9bYfOJGFmIpQf8GNv+LGhYpbd+78G5M+oL4OXDicy/3uP4jEplmp9amZ2bn4hvZhZWl5ZXdPXN6rSCwQBm3jMEzUHS2DUBVtRxaDmC8DcYXDt9M8T/oWhKSe6UGPjQ57rq0QwlWsdTS8w0etCDX4Fj1BA/LdL9Mo5vd/NneYcEs3k10qEYtPWsVzCEM8xeZWFk0RqWlfzTaHgk4uIowLGXdMn3VDLFQlDCIMo1Ago9JH3ehHlMXc5DNcPhSZOzEStvoeCIuVxlDdXoixFzKAXfizuRE+dNLxL+8eqA6xWZIXT9Q4JLRok7ADOUZST5Gmwogig1igomg8a0G6WGBiYpTzEyH8D+xDwonBevyKFs6HaeRltoG+WQhY5RCV2gCrIRQfoET2jF+1Be9JetbdRa0obz2yib9DevwAct5yv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="V483h094Se6E18QVxU0FiarEu4=">ACEXicdVDLSsNAFJ3UV62vqEs3wSK0iDVRwQoKBTcuqhgaqGtZTK9bYfOJGFmIpQf8GNv+LGhYpbd+78G5M+oL4OXDicy/3uP4jEplmp9amZ2bn4hvZhZWl5ZXdPXN6rSCwQBm3jMEzUHS2DUBVtRxaDmC8DcYXDt9M8T/oWhKSe6UGPjQ57rq0QwlWsdTS8w0etCDX4Fj1BA/LdL9Mo5vd/NneYcEs3k10qEYtPWsVzCEM8xeZWFk0RqWlfzTaHgk4uIowLGXdMn3VDLFQlDCIMo1Ago9JH3ehHlMXc5DNcPhSZOzEStvoeCIuVxlDdXoixFzKAXfizuRE+dNLxL+8eqA6xWZIXT9Q4JLRok7ADOUZST5Gmwogig1igomg8a0G6WGBiYpTzEyH8D+xDwonBevyKFs6HaeRltoG+WQhY5RCV2gCrIRQfoET2jF+1Be9JetbdRa0obz2yib9DevwAct5yv</latexit>µe(LCO)
<latexit sha1_base64="VmZBEKfbfKDRzjKrKnb25K35Zs=">AB/HicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62v0S7dBItQN2VGBF24KHTjQrCfUBnGDJp2oYmSHJCMNQf8WNC0Xc+iHu/Bsz7Sy09UDgcM693JMTxowq7TjfVmltfWNzq7xd2dnd2z+wD4+6KkokJh0csUj2Q6QIo4J0NWM9GNJEA8Z6YXTVu73HolUNBIPOo2Jz9FY0BHFSBspsKseTwJS9zjSE8mz29bd7Cywa07DmQOuErcgNVCgHdhf3jDCSdCY4aUGrhOrP0MSU0xI7OKlygSIzxFYzIwVCBOlJ/Nw8/gqVGcBRJ84SGc/X3Roa4UikPzWQeUi17ufifN0j06MrPqIgTQReHBolDOoI5k3AIZUEa5YagrCkJivEyQR1qavinBXf7yKumeN1yn4d5f1JrXR1lcAxOQB24BI0wQ1ogw7AIAXP4BW8WU/Wi/VufSxGS1axUwV/YH3+ADNolHE=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="VmZBEKfbfKDRzjKrKnb25K35Zs=">AB/HicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62v0S7dBItQN2VGBF24KHTjQrCfUBnGDJp2oYmSHJCMNQf8WNC0Xc+iHu/Bsz7Sy09UDgcM693JMTxowq7TjfVmltfWNzq7xd2dnd2z+wD4+6KkokJh0csUj2Q6QIo4J0NWM9GNJEA8Z6YXTVu73HolUNBIPOo2Jz9FY0BHFSBspsKseTwJS9zjSE8mz29bd7Cywa07DmQOuErcgNVCgHdhf3jDCSdCY4aUGrhOrP0MSU0xI7OKlygSIzxFYzIwVCBOlJ/Nw8/gqVGcBRJ84SGc/X3Roa4UikPzWQeUi17ufifN0j06MrPqIgTQReHBolDOoI5k3AIZUEa5YagrCkJivEyQR1qavinBXf7yKumeN1yn4d5f1JrXR1lcAxOQB24BI0wQ1ogw7AIAXP4BW8WU/Wi/VufSxGS1axUwV/YH3+ADNolHE=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="VmZBEKfbfKDRzjKrKnb25K35Zs=">AB/HicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62v0S7dBItQN2VGBF24KHTjQrCfUBnGDJp2oYmSHJCMNQf8WNC0Xc+iHu/Bsz7Sy09UDgcM693JMTxowq7TjfVmltfWNzq7xd2dnd2z+wD4+6KkokJh0csUj2Q6QIo4J0NWM9GNJEA8Z6YXTVu73HolUNBIPOo2Jz9FY0BHFSBspsKseTwJS9zjSE8mz29bd7Cywa07DmQOuErcgNVCgHdhf3jDCSdCY4aUGrhOrP0MSU0xI7OKlygSIzxFYzIwVCBOlJ/Nw8/gqVGcBRJ84SGc/X3Roa4UikPzWQeUi17ufifN0j06MrPqIgTQReHBolDOoI5k3AIZUEa5YagrCkJivEyQR1qavinBXf7yKumeN1yn4d5f1JrXR1lcAxOQB24BI0wQ1ogw7AIAXP4BW8WU/Wi/VufSxGS1axUwV/YH3+ADNolHE=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="VmZBEKfbfKDRzjKrKnb25K35Zs=">AB/HicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62v0S7dBItQN2VGBF24KHTjQrCfUBnGDJp2oYmSHJCMNQf8WNC0Xc+iHu/Bsz7Sy09UDgcM693JMTxowq7TjfVmltfWNzq7xd2dnd2z+wD4+6KkokJh0csUj2Q6QIo4J0NWM9GNJEA8Z6YXTVu73HolUNBIPOo2Jz9FY0BHFSBspsKseTwJS9zjSE8mz29bd7Cywa07DmQOuErcgNVCgHdhf3jDCSdCY4aUGrhOrP0MSU0xI7OKlygSIzxFYzIwVCBOlJ/Nw8/gqVGcBRJ84SGc/X3Roa4UikPzWQeUi17ufifN0j06MrPqIgTQReHBolDOoI5k3AIZUEa5YagrCkJivEyQR1qavinBXf7yKumeN1yn4d5f1JrXR1lcAxOQB24BI0wQ1ogw7AIAXP4BW8WU/Wi/VufSxGS1axUwV/YH3+ADNolHE=</latexit>Fermi energy Electrode pot.
simulate the electrode/electrolyte interface.
consistent with thermodynamics and electrochemistry.
electrochemical systems, such as secondary ion batteries, fuel cells, collision, electroplating, ion exchange membrane
53