Extreme decoherence and quantum chaos
Adolfo d del C Campo DIPC & & Ike kerbasque Bilbao, S Spain QI QIST2019 Yuka kawa I Institute f for T Theoretical P Physics, Kyoto U University, M May 2 29th
th, 2
2019
Adolfo d del C Campo
Extreme decoherence and quantum chaos Adolfo d del C Campo DIPC - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Extreme decoherence and quantum chaos Adolfo d del C Campo DIPC & & Ike kerbasque Bilbao, S Spain QI QIST2019 Yuka kawa I Institute f for T Theoretical P Physics, 29 th th , 2 Kyoto U University, M May 2 2019 Adolfo d
Adolfo d del C Campo DIPC & & Ike kerbasque Bilbao, S Spain QI QIST2019 Yuka kawa I Institute f for T Theoretical P Physics, Kyoto U University, M May 2 29th
th, 2
2019
Adolfo d del C Campo
Adolfo d del C Campo
Adolfo d del C Campo
A Chenu AdC F Gomez-Ruiz L Dupays Dr N Gentil TY Huang J Zhu
Quantum open Systems Time, Quantum Speed Limits & Metrology Quantum Control: Shortcuts to Adiabaticity Dynamics of phase transitions: Kibble Zurek mechanism Quantum Computation: adiabatic, open Quantum Thermodynamics: engines, finite-time Trapped ions, cold atoms Integrable models, RMT, …
Adolfo d del C Campo: ad adolfo.delcam ampo@umb.edu
Adolfo d del C Campo
e.g. Zurek, Physics Today
u Extreme decoherence
Noise as a resource for Open Quantum Systems Noise coupled to local interactions Noise coupled to Random Matrix Theory
u Work statistics of complex systems
Loschmidt echo and p(W) P(W) and scrambling Work pdf & chaos/RMT Work pdf for time-reversal
Adolfo d del C Campo: ad adolfo.delcam ampo@umb.edu
System of interest embedded in an environment: composite system-environment Reduced dynamics via master equation Markovian limit: Universal Lindblad form
Adolfo d del C Campo
ρ(t) = ˆ USE(t, 0)ρS(0) ⊗ ρE ˆ USE(t, 0)† d dtρS = −i ~ h ˆ HS, ρS i + X
α
γα LαρSL†
α − 1
2
αLα, ρS
dtρS = −i ~ h ˆ HS, ρS i + D(ρS)
Adolfo d del C Campo
e.g. Zurek, Physics Today
Decay of coherences of density matrix, e.g. of a Schrodinger cat state
ψ0(x) = Nσ e− (x−r)2
2σ2
+ e− (x+r)2
2σ2
Adolfo d del C Campo
e.g. Zurek, Physics Today
Decay of coherences of density matrix, e.g. of a Schrodinger cat state Quantum Brownian Motion Decoherence time in the high-temperature limit
τD = λ2
β
2γ∆x2
d dtρS(t) = 1 i~[H, ρS(t)] − iγ ~ [x, {p, ρS(t)}] − 2mγkBT ~2 [x, [x, ρS(t)]]
Adolfo d del C Campo
Survival probability Master equation Short time decay Universal decoherence time for Markovian evolutions
S(t) := F[ρS(0), ρS(t)] = hΨ0|ρS(t)|Ψ0i d dtρS = −i ~ h ˆ HS, ρS i + X
α
γα LαρSL†
α − 1
2
αLα, ρS
1 P
α γαCov
⇣ Lα, L†
α
⌘ Cov(A, B) = hABi hAihBi
S(t) = 1 − t τD + O(t2)
Adolfo d del C Campo
Purity Master equation Short time decay Universal decoherence time & rate
d dtρS = −i ~ h ˆ HS, ρS i + X
α
γα LαρSL†
α − 1
2
αLα, ρS
1 P
α γαCov
⇣ Lα, L†
α
⌘
Pt = P0[1 − Dt + O(t2)]
D = 2 P0 1 τD
Pt = trρ2
S ∈ [1/d, 1]
Adolfo d del C Campo
Survival probability Quantum Brownian motion Short time decay Recover Zurek’s estimate for decoherence time
S(t) := F[ρS(0), ρS(t)] = hΨ0|ρS(t)|Ψ0i S(t) = 1 − t τD + O(t2)
d dtρS(t) = 1 i~[H, ρS(t)] − iγ ~ [x, {p, ρS(t)}] − 2mγkBT ~2 [x, [x, ρS(t)]]
τD = λ2
β
2γ∆x2
Adolfo d del C Campo
Adolfo d del C Campo
System Environment
Adolfo d del C Campo
Wavefunction Collapse models (GRW theory, Milburn model, …)
(2013)
Generic Many-Body Open System Dynamics Using Classical Noise, PRL 118, 140403 (2017).
Spontaneous symmetry breaking induced by quantum monitoring, arXiv:1808.08343.
decoherence from quantum gravity: a pedagogical review, J. Gen Relativ Gravit 39, 1143 (2007).
according to real clocks, Phys. Rev. A 59, 3236 (1999).
System Environment
Full system Deterministic part + stochastic part with real Gaussian process Stochastic Schrodinger equation Extensive literature
Adolfo d del C Campo
[…]
Density matrix averaged over realizations Master equation requires stochastic unravelling Simplified via Novikov’s theorem for white noise
Adolfo d del C Campo
d dtρ(t) = −i[H0(t), ρ(t)] − W 2 2 [V, [V, ρ(t)]]
d dtρ(t) = i[H0(t), ρ] Z t dshγ(t)γ(s)i h V, h[ ˆ Ust(t, s)V ˆ U †
st(t, s), ρst(t)]i
i
hγ(t)γ(t0)i = W 2δ(t t0)
Quantum simulation of open systems with many-body dissipators Target Hamiltonian: Ising chain
Adolfo d del C Campo
ˆ HI = − X
i<j
Jij σz
i σz j − h N
X
i=1
σx
i .
Quantum simulation of open systems with many-body dissipators Target Hamiltonian: Ising chain
Adolfo d del C Campo
ˆ HI = − X
i<j
Jij σz
i σz j − h N
X
i=1
σx
i .
Quantum simulation of open systems with many-body dissipators Target Hamiltonian: Ising chain Modulating magnetic field Nonlocal “2-body” dissipator
Adolfo d del C Campo
ˆ HI = − X
i<j
Jij σz
i σz j − h N
X
i=1
σx
i .
D[ρ(t)] = −γ X
ij
[σx
i [σx j , ρ(t)]]
Quantum simulation of open systems with many-body dissipators Target Hamiltonian: Ising chain
Adolfo d del C Campo
ˆ HI = − X
i<j
Jij σz
i σz j − h N
X
i=1
σx
i .
Quantum simulation of open systems with many-body dissipators Target Hamiltonian: Ising chain Modulating ferromagnetic couplings Nonlocal “4-body” dissipator
Adolfo d del C Campo
ˆ HI = − X
i<j
Jij σz
i σz j − h N
X
i=1
σx
i .
D[ρ(t)] = −γ X
i<j
X
i0<j0
⇥ σz
i σz j ,
⇥ σz
i0σz j0, ρ(t)
⇤⇤ τD ∼ 1/N 4
Stochastic Hamiltonian k-body operators “2k-body” dissipators Double sum over indices vs usual single sum ~ correlated environment
Adolfo d del C Campo
α
i1<···<ik
i1,...,ik
α
i1<···<ik
i0
1<···<i0 k
i1,...,ik, [L(α,k) i0
1,...,i0 k, ρ]]
Stochastic Hamiltonian k-body operators “2k-body” dissipators Polynomial scaling
Adolfo d del C Campo
α
i1<···<ik
i1,...,ik
Adolfo d del C Campo
Chaotic systems as a paradigm of complex systems and test-bed for information scrambling Described by Random Matrix Theory Ensembles of random matrices Gaussian Unitary Ensembles (GUE): Hermitian Hamiltonians Gaussian Orthogonal Ensembles (GOE): Real Symmetric Hamiltonians with time-reversal symm
Adolfo d del C Campo
Heavy Nucleus Systems
Density of states: Universal for large Hilbert space dimension “d” Eigenvalues spacing
Adolfo d del C Campo
N=100 (GUE) ρ(E) = √ 2d π s 1 − ✓ E √ 2d ◆2
Stochastic Hamiltonian RMT-body operators Decoherence rate?
Adolfo d del C Campo
α
i1<···<ik
i1,...,ik
GUE average
Adolfo d del C Campo
d
k=1
U(d)
GUE average Decoherence rate of “fixed” initial state
Adolfo d del C Campo
d
k=1
U(d)
µ
µ
Noise-averaged master equation Decoherence rate Exponential dependence on particle number! Extreme decoherence
Adolfo d del C Campo
Ensemble average
d dtρ(t) = 1 i~[ ˆ HT , ρ(t)] − X
α
λα(t)[ˆ Lα, [ˆ Lα, ρ(t)]]
D = 2 P0 1 τD = X
α
λα(t)∆ˆ L2
α
Γ = X
α
λα
Stochastic k-body Hamiltonians lead to k-body Lindblad operators Decoherence rate scales polynomially on system size
Adolfo d del C Campo
2-body 4-body 3-body ( ) Not Extreme!
Two copies of the system, independent fluctuations
Adolfo d del C Campo
t H ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ ξR t H)
Two copies of the system, independent fluctuations Lindblad operators Initial state: purified thermal density matrix, defined via the Hamiltonian (not fixed)
Adolfo d del C Campo
t H ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ ξR t H)
˜ V1 = H ⊗ 1 ˜ V2 = 1 ⊗ H |Φ0i := 1 p Z(β) X
k
e−
βEk 2
|ki |ki
Time-dependent density matrix Decay of the purity Decoherence rate
Adolfo d del C Campo
j,k
2 (Ej+Ek)−i 2t ~ (Ej−Ek)−γt(Ej+Ek)2|ji|jihk|hk|
Pt = r 1 8πγt Z ∞
−∞
e− y2
8γt
Z(β)
˜ D = 4γvarρβ(H) = 4γ d2 dβ2 ln [Z(β)]
Adolfo d del C Campo
Adolfo d del C Campo
) )
Adolfo d del C Campo
Adolfo d del C Campo
For a TDS extreme decoherence is restricted to infinite temperature or small system sizes
Decoherence rate proportional to heat capacity of CFT Heat capacity proportional to entropy/scales with #dof [Papadodimas & Raju]
Adolfo d del C Campo
Noise a resource for quantum simulation of open systems
polynomial scaling of decoherence rate with system size In RMT Operators exponential scaling of decoherence rate with system size
Adolfo d del C Campo: ad adolfo.delcam ampo@umb.edu
Xu et al., PRL 122, 014103 (2019) Chenu et al. PRL 118, 140403 (2017); 119,130401 (2017)
Adolfo d del C Campo: ad adolfo.delcam ampo@umb.edu
Driven isolated system Unitary evolution: physical time of evolution “s” Work probability distribution
Adolfo d del C Campo
n
n|nsihns|
ˆ U(τ) = T exp −i Z τ ds ˆ Hs
n,m
n pτ m|nδ
m − E0 n
Fourier transform = moment-generating function Variable “t” different from the physical time of evolution “s” Explicit expression resembles a Loschmidt echo
Adolfo d del C Campo
χ(t, τ) = Z ∞
−∞
dWpτ(W) eiW t. χ(t, τ) = X
n
p0
nhn0|eit ˆ Heff
τ e−it ˆ
H0|n0i
ˆ Heff
τ
= ˆ U †(τ) ˆ Hτ ˆ U(τ)
Silva 2008: If system prepared in an eigenstate at s=0 sudden quench think of “t” as a second time of evolution in a Loschmidt echo Avoids explicit computation of transition probabilities in
Adolfo d del C Campo
Hτ e−it ˆ H0|n0i
n,m
n pτ m|nδ
m − E0 n
Chenu et al 2017: Purification of arbitrary initial mixed state purification
Adolfo d del C Campo
n
n |n0iL ⌦ |n0iR
Chenu et al 2017: Purification of arbitrary initial mixed state purification Characteristic function as a Loschmidt echo amplitude
Adolfo d del C Campo
n
n |n0iL ⌦ |n0iR
n
nhn0|eit ˆ Heff
τ e−it ˆ
H0|n0i
Heff
τ e−it ˆ
H0 ⌦ 1R|Ψ0i
Chenu et al 2017: Purification of arbitrary initial mixed state purification Characteristic function as a Loschmidt echo amplitude Loschmidt echo
Adolfo d del C Campo
n
n |n0iL ⌦ |n0iR
n
nhn0|eit ˆ Heff
τ e−it ˆ
H0|n0i
Heff
τ e−it ˆ
H0 ⌦ 1R|Ψ0i
−∞
Scrambling: Spreading of quantum correlations across many degrees of freedom Papadodimas-Raju: decay dynamics of purified state, e.g., survival amplitude
Adolfo d del C Campo
K Papadodimas, S. Raju, PRL 115, 211601 (2015)
Scrambling: Spreading of quantum correlations across many degrees of freedom Papadodimas-Raju: decay dynamics of purified state, e.g., survival amplitude Decay dynamics in Loschmidt echo Scrambling from work pdf
Adolfo d del C Campo
−∞
Heff
τ e−it ˆ
H0
AdC, J. Molina-Vilaplana, J. Sonner, PRD 95, 126008 (2017)
Chaotic systems as a paradigm of complex systems and test-bed for information scrambling Described by Random Matrix Theory Ensembles of random matrices Gaussian Unitary Ensembles (GUE): Hermitian Hamiltonians Gaussian Orthogonal Ensembles (GOE): Real Symmetric Hamiltonians with time-reversal symm
Adolfo d del C Campo
Heavy Nucleus Systems
Example: Quantum quenches between two RMT Hamiltonians
arXiv:1711.01277
Work Statistics, Loschmidt Echo and Information Scrambling in Chaotic Quantum Systems arXiv:1804.09188 See related work: RMT large N asymptotics: M. Łobejko, J. Łuczka, P. Talkner PRE 95, 052137 (2017) Disordered many-body systems: Y Zheng and D. Poletti, arXiv:1806.02555
Adolfo d del C Campo
Initial thermal state Sudden quench:
Adolfo d del C Campo
|Ψ0i = 1 p Z(β) X
n
e− β
2 ˆ
H0 ⊗ 1R |n0iL ⌦ |n0iR
ˆ H0 → ˆ Hf ˆ H0, ˆ Hf ∈ GUE(N)
Short-times Long-times
Adolfo d del C Campo
1 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 0.01 0.1 1 10 100
hL(t)iGUE = ⌦ et2σ2
W +O(t4)↵
et2hσ2
W i+O(t4)
hL(t)iGUE ! hZ(2β)i hZ(β)2i 2 (N + 1) hL(t)i
Time-reversal operation Negation of system Hamiltonian (e.g. in GOE) Loschmidt echo from partitio function Work pdf Mean work
Adolfo d del C Campo
L(t) = |hΨ0|Ψ0(t)i|2 =
Z (β)
ˆ H0 → ˆ Hf = − ˆ H0 ˆ H0 ∈ GOE(N)
Adolfo d del C Campo
L(t) = |hTDS(0)|TDS(t)i|2 =
dWp(W)eiW t
=
Z(β)
ˆ H0 → ˆ Hf = − ˆ H0 ˆ H0 ∈ GOE(N)
GUE averaged Loschmidt echo Spectral form factor
Adolfo d del C Campo
hL(t)i = 1 hZ(β)2i 1 N 21 ⇣ g(0, t)g(β, t) + NhZ(2β)i 1 N hZ(2β)ig(0, t) 1 N g(β, t)N ⌘
g(β, t) ⌘ hZ(β + it)Z(β it)i
GUE averaged Loschmidt echo: infinite temperature Frame potential
Adolfo d del C Campo
E
ˆ A, ˆ B∈E
GUE(t)
GUE averaged Loschmidt echo: infinite temperature Frame potential
Adolfo d del C Campo
E
ˆ A, ˆ B∈E
GUE(t)
Cotler et al JHEP 1711 (2017) 048
u Extreme decoherence
Noise as a resource for QOS Noise coupled to local interactions Noise coupled to RMT
u Work statistics of complex systems
Loschmidt echo and p(W) P(W) and scrambling Work pdf & chaos/RMT Work pdf for time-reversal
Adolfo d del C Campo: ad adolfo.delcam ampo@umb.edu
The DIPC-Bilbao Group
Aurelia Chenu (group co-leader)
Leonce Dupays Tanyou Huang Jinxiun Zhou Fernando Gomez Ruiz (UMass => Bilbao)
Adolfo d del C Campo: ad adolfo.delcam ampo@gmai ail.com
Collaborators
Jiashu Cao (MIT) Íñigo L. Egusquiza (Bilbao) Chuan-Feng Li (Hefei) Norman Margolus (MIT) Javier Molina-Vilaplana (Cartagena) Julian Sonner (Geneve) Masahito Ueda (Tokyo) Haibin Wu (ECNU) Wojciech H Zurek (LANL)