Enterprise Architecture: The Next 20 Years
- Dr. John Gøtze
Enterprise Architecture: The Next 20 Years Dr. John Gtze - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Enterprise Architecture: The Next 20 Years Dr. John Gtze Enterprise Architecture? A discipline A profession A mindset EA s purpose: Line of sight Strategy Technology Business 4 EA = The analysis and documentation of an enterprise
Enterprise Architecture: The Next 20 Years
Enterprise Architecture?
A discipline A profession A mindset
EA’s purpose: Line of sight
Business Technology
4Strategy
EA = The analysis and documentation
future states from a strategy, business, technology perspective.
TRANSFORMATION DESIGN
Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Optimized Networks and Infrastructure Integrated Systems and Applications Enhanced Data and Information Flows Improved Business Products and Services Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Updated Strategic Goals & Initiatives Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Optimized Networks and Infrastructure Integrated Systems and Applications Enhanced Data and Information Flows Improved Business Products and Services Network Infrastructure Network Infrastructure Updated Strategic Goals & Initiatives CURRENT CURRENT ARCHITECTURE ARCHITECTURE FUTURE FUTURE ARCHITECTURE ARCHITECTURE Architecture Management & Transition Plan Lines of Business C O M P O N E N T S Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks Networks & & Infrastructure Infrastructure Systems Systems & & Applications Applications Data Data & & Information Information Products Products & & Services Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals Goals & & Initiatives Initiatives Lines of Business Lines of Business C C O O M M P P O O N N E E N N T T S S Security / Standards / Workforce Security / Standards / Workforce Technology Technology – – Business Business – – Strategy Strategy Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks Networks & & Infrastructure Infrastructure Systems Systems & & Applications Applications Data Data & & Information Information Products Products & & Services Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals Goals & & Initiatives Initiatives Lines of Business Lines of Business C C O O M M P P O O N N E E N N T T S S Security / Standards / Workforce Security / Standards / Workforce Technology Technology – – Business Business – – Strategy StrategyPallab Saha: Components of GEA
National Government EA Approaches
US: Performance focus and legal enforcement NL: Clear goals, but low adoption and no measurementMandated Voluntary
DK: Voluntary approach, some adoption, but limited goal realization CA: Clear framework, but no measurements and limited adoption FI: Act on Information Management Governance in Public Administration (634/2011)US Federal Government EA
Aims
assets
agency’s strategic goals.
Clinger-Cohen Act, 1996
FEAF-II
The Common Approach
to Federal Enterprise Architecture
May 2, 2012
Common Approach to Federal EA
Danish Government’s EA: OIOEA
Danish Government’s EA vision 2017
The digitally coherent public sector The common architecture for digitisation must ensure secure cross-organisational processes and efficient sharing of data across the public sector and between the public and private sectors. The goal is that citizens and businesses experience services that are efficient, coherent, transparent and targeted at the individuals’ need, and also provide good conditions for innovation, growth and development in society. https://arkitektur.digst.dk/node/529
Example: CBS EA Cube
Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks Networks & & Systems Systems & & Applications Applications Data Data & & Information Information Products Products & & Services Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals Goals & & Initiatives Initiatives Lines of Business Lines of Business C C O O M M P P O O N N E E N N T T S S Technology Technology – – Business Business – – Strategy Strategy Network Network Network Network Network Network Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks & Systems & Data & Products & Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals & Education Research Communications AdministrationCBS EA
Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks Networks & & Systems Systems & & Applications Applications Data Data & & Information Information Products Products & & Services Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals Goals & & Initiatives Initiatives Lines of Business Lines of Business C C O O M M P P O O N N E E N N T T S S Security / Standards / Workforce Technology Technology – – Business Business – – Strategy Strategy Network Network Network Network Network Network Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks & Infrastructure Systems & Applications Data & Information Products & Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals & Initiatives Education Research Communications AdministrationStrategy
Business
Technology
Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks Networks & & Infrastructure Infrastructure Systems Systems & & Applications Applications Data Data & & Information Information Products Products & & Services Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals Goals & & Initiatives Initiatives Lines of Business Lines of Business C C O O M M P P O O N N E E N N T T S S Security / Standards / Workforce Security / Standards / Workforce Technology Technology – – Business Business – – Strategy Strategy Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks & Infrastructure Systems & Applications Data & Information Products & Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals & Initiatives Education Research Communications Administration”Cross-cutting threads”
Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks Networks & & Systems Systems & & Applications Applications Data Data & & Information Information Products Products & & Services Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals Goals & & Initiatives Initiatives Lines of Business Lines of Business C C O O M M P P O O N N E E N N T T S S Security / Standards / Workforce Technology Technology – – Business Business – – Strategy Strategy Network Network Network Network Network Network Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Networks & Infrastructure Systems & Applications Data & Information Products & Services Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Network Network Infrastructure Infrastructure Goals & Initiatives Education Research Communications AdministrationSe Secu curity ty & Privac acy Go Governanc ance
GDPR
The Generic Cube
extends EA beyond structuring, to include
enhanced to include areas for risk management, human capital, and valuation.
restructuring, such as Mergers & Acquisitions.
1 3 4 1 4 5 6 2 3 6 3 1
Organizational Structure3
Functional Domains4 2 1 5 6
Cube Framework
6 2 3 4 5 1
Framework Faces
Organizational Structure
Business Unit B Business Unit C Business Unit D Business Unit X Organizational Structure. Depicts the major business units (BUs) that make up theLog
Products & Services
Tradition al & Online Storefro nts Supply Chains Marketing & Communicatio nsFace 2
Risk Management
Tolerance, Triggers, Disruption, Mitigation Uncertainty ControlFace 3
Supporting Infrastructure Business Activities Information Exchanges Technology Enablement Strategy & Governance
Functional Domains
Performance Capability
Face 4
Markets & Valuation
Real Property Financials & Talent Intellectual Property Systems & Capabilities Competitive Position Markets & Valuation. Depicts the public and private sector markets and/or mission areas that the organization is active in. For private sectorFace 5
Human Capital
Leadership & Governance Human Capital. Depicts the knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSAs) needed in each functional domain of the organization. The KSAs are different for executives, managers, and staff in each area. There is a “cultural core” in eachCultural Core
Engineering Business Manageme nt Knowledge Management Project Management Recruitment , Retention, & Rewards Knowledge , Skills, and Abilities BeliefsFace 6
Small Cube Cutout
EA Schools of Thought
TOGAF
Enterprise IT Architecting
Scope Purpose
The enterprise-wide IT platform, including all components (software, hardware, and so on) of the enterprise IT assets Effectively execute and operate the overall enterprise strategy for maintaining a competitive advantage by aligning the business and IT strategies such that the proper IT capabilities are developed support current and future business needsEnterprise Integrating
Scope Purpose
The enterprise as a social-cultural, techno-economic system, including all facetsEnterprise Ecological Adaptation
Scope Purpose
The enterprise in its environment, including not only the enterprise but also its environment and the bidirectional relationship and transactions between the enterprise and its environment Help the organization innovate and adapt by designing the various enterprise facets to maximize organizational learning throughout the enterpriseEnterprise -> Ecosystem
James Lapalme, 2011, in IT Professional (Vol14,Issue6)
”So Ein Ding …” We just need to …
Do SOA Use TOGAF Become agile
Agile, lean, UX, SD, DT...
Christopher Webb Deloitte 2016ScaledAgileFramework.com
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/architectural-runway-safe-agile-landings-har-gootzen/
SAFe Principles
A Bad System Will Beat a Good Person Every Time
Ambidexterous approach
Alignment of Exploitative Explorative Strategic intent Cost, profit Innovation, growth Critical tasks Operations, efficiency, incremental innovation Adaptability, new products, breakthrough innovation Competencies Operational Entrepreneurial Structure Formal, mechanistic Adaptive, loose Controls, rewards Margins, productivity Milestones, growth Culture Efficiency, low risk, quality, customers Risk taking, speed, flexibility, experimentation Leadership roles Authoritative, top-down Visionary, involvedSource: Michael Rosemann
BPM
Challenge
It is not about how customers participate in
processes, but about how we participate in the customers processes.
Chris Potts (2010) RecrEAtion: Realizing the Extraordinary Contribution of your Enterprise
Enterprise Design
Customer Journey Map
Business Eco-system
Business Model Canvas
Alexander Osterwalder
Architecture for Industry 4.0
“Digital Twin”
08-08-2018 52 Integration view Asset view Virtual representation of the asset Relation between physical world and the information worldDigital representation of smart products
08-08-2018 53 Business view Business goals, processes, legal and regulatory conditions Communication view Access to information and functions of a connected asset by other assets. Information view Data related to the technical functionality: Real-time (e.g. asset current status) Non-real-time (e.g. asset interfaces) Functional view Digital description of equipment functions (including asset’s production parameters and attributes) Production process with real- time production data (e.g. last activity performed on the product) Integration view Relation between physical world and the information world Asset view Virtual representation of the assetDigital representation of smart production
08-08-2018 54 Business view Business goals, processes, legal and regulatory conditions Communication view Access to information and functions of a connected asset by other assets. Information view Data related to the technical functionality: Real-time (e.g. asset current status) Non-real-time (e.g. asset interfaces) Functional view Digital description of equipment functions (including asset’s production parameters and attributes) Real-time production data (e.g. number of errors in the last hour) Integration view Relation between physical world and the information world Asset view Virtual representation of the assetDigital representation of smart factory
08-08-2018 55 Business view Functional view Information view Communication view Integration view Asset view Smart Production Asset view Smart ProductReference Architecture for Industry 4.0 (RAMI 4.0)
IEC PAS 63088
LayersIndustry 4.0 Demonstrator
57 Operational view Process without real-time information Process with real-time information (error) Digital description of equipment functions Real-time production data (e.g. error in the last hour) Nardello, M., Møller, C., Gøtze, J. (2017) Organizational Learning Supported by Reference Architecture Models: Industry 4.0 Laboratory Study Complex Systems Informatics and Modeling Quarterly https://csimq-journals.rtu.lv/Marc Kerremans, Gartner
Use a business operating system (BOS) — the organizational equivalent
guide you in planning and executing your strategy and achieving your
Make your BOS dynamic and create situational awareness by connecting its business operating model with real- life data. This will close the strategy- to-execution "loop."
The Business Operating System
Gartner (October 2016)
John Gøtze
jogo@itu.dk