energy efficiency policies in the EU The MURE database for energy - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶

Feb 11, 2023 34 likes •285 views

Evaluating energy efficiency policies in the EU The MURE database for energy efficiency policies Wolfgang Eichhammer, Fraunhofer ISI (Germany) and Utrecht University (Netherlands) July 2016 About Fraunhofer : Europes largest Organisation

SLIDE 1

Evaluating energy efficiency policies in the EU

The MURE database for energy efficiency policies

July 2016 Wolfgang Eichhammer, Fraunhofer ISI (Germany) and Utrecht University (Netherlands)

SLIDE 2

About Fraunhofer: Europe’s largest Organisation for Applied Research

Energy efficiency policies in EU – July 2016 2

67 Fraunhofer Institutes in Germany 24 000 employees (mainly natural or engineering science training) € 2.2 billion research volume annually: 70% of income generated from contracts 30% provided by the federal government and federal states as basic funding International cooperation via affiliated offices in Europe, USA, Asia and in the Near East

SLIDE 3

The 2015 synthesis brochure

Energy efficiency polices in EU – July 2016 3

The MURE data tools

http://www.measures-odyssee-mure.eu/

http://www.odyssee- mure.eu/publications/br/energy- efficiency-trends-policies-in-europe.html

The following analysis is based on the 2015 ODYSSEE MURE synthesis brochure with energy efficiency up to 2014

SLIDE 4

Content

Energy efficiency polices in EU – July 2016 4

EU Energy Efficiency

Policies

Identify Successful

Policies

Policy Mapper/Policy

Interaction

Energy Efficiency Policy

Scoreboard

SLIDE 5

EU Energy Efficiency Policies

Energy efficiency policies in EU – July 2016

SLIDE 6

Analyzing Energy Efficiency Measures in MURE

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 6

SLIDE 7

Preferential energy efficiency measures households

(left all measures from 1995, right NEEAP3 /Art.7 measures)

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 7

SLIDE 8

Country-specific preferential energy efficiency measures households

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 8

SLIDE 9

Main EU energy efficiency policy measures and their impacts

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 9

SLIDE 10

Energy efficiency policies in EU – July 2016

Successful Policy Measures

SLIDE 11

Criteria for Successful Measures (High Priority Criteria)

1. High impact / high number of applicants
2. Cost efficiency for the implementor /

necessary administrative support

3. Potential for market transformation and

for promotion of energy service market

4. Suitability to overcome barriers for

energy efficiency

5. Ease and stability of re-financing
6. Persistency of the savings induced by the

measure

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 11

SLIDE 12

Criteria for Successful Measures (Low Priority Criteria)

7. Transferability between countries
8. Link to other measures / policy packages
9. Some experience with measure

10.Avoidance of negative side-effects 11.Support of positive side-effects 12.Ease of acceptance by relevant stakeholders

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 12

Quantitative evaluation of each policy with a score between 1 (worst) and 5 (best) for each of the 12 criteria

SLIDE 13

Learning to evaluate through National Energy Efficiency Action Plans NEEAPs

Share of measures with quantitative impact evaluations (by sector)

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 13

SLIDE 14

Energy efficiency policies in EU – July 2016

Policy Mapper / Policy Interaction

SLIDE 15

Policy Mapping

(Example Space Heating Existing Dwellings Finland)

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 15

SLIDE 16

Link Policies/Indicators

(Example Space Heating Existing Dwellings Finland)

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 16

SLIDE 17

Measure Interactions

(Example Space Heating Existing Dwellings Finland)

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 17

SLIDE 18

Measure Interaction Matrix

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 18

SLIDE 19

Most successful energy efficiency measures Germany

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 19

SLIDE 20

Energy efficiency policies in EU – July 2016

Policy Scoreboard

SLIDE 21

Four main scoring approaches

Output-based scoring (based on energy savings)
Output-based scoring (related to energy

efficiency potentials)

Output-based scoring ( related to 2020 energy

efficiency targets)

Input-based scoring (based on financing

volumes)

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 21

SLIDE 22

Input-based Scoreboard: ACEEE

Energy efficiency policies– MURE– July 2016 22

SLIDE 23

Basic methodology for the Output- based Scoreboard

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 23

SLIDE 24

Combined Energy Efficiency Scoreboard presented in Germany

Energy efficiency policies– MURE – July 2016 24

Status: left, trend: middle, energy efficiency policies: right

SLIDE 25

www.isi.fraunhofer.de

Thank you for your attention !

Contact:

Wolfgang Eichhammer Fraunhofer Institute for Systems and Innovation Research ISI and Utrecht University Technical Coordinator Odyssee-MURE wolfgang.eichhammer@isi. fraunhofer.de 25 Energy efficiency policies– MURE– July 2016