DAY 2
WASHINGTON, D.C. WEDNESDAY, MAY 15 – FRIDAY, MAY 17, 2019
DAY 2 WASHINGTON, D.C. WEDNESDAY, MAY 15 FRIDAY, MAY 17, 2019 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
DAY 2 WASHINGTON, D.C. WEDNESDAY, MAY 15 FRIDAY, MAY 17, 2019 RECAP FROM DAY 1 Daniel Herscovici | Partner David Nevas | Partner CEO SUMMIT 2O19 NEGOTIATION Professor Robert Bontempo Columbia University Graduate School of Business CEO
WASHINGTON, D.C. WEDNESDAY, MAY 15 – FRIDAY, MAY 17, 2019
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Daniel Herscovici | Partner David Nevas | Partner
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Professor Robert Bontempo Columbia University Graduate School of Business
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Professor Robert Bontempo Columbia University Graduate School of Business
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
A FRAMEWORK FOR SELF UNDERSTANDING AND INTERPERSONAL INFLUENCE
Professor Robert Bontempo Columbia University Graduate School of Business
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Andrew P. Gilbert | DLA Piper
the sale process will undoubtedly be slowed) if a company does not properly maintain its cap table, documentation of granted equity awards, records of board and stockholder actions and copies of executed employment and commercial agreements.
and every non-employee consultant, contractor and developer signs an agreement containing provisions regarding confidentiality and assignment of IP rights. The most valuable asset of many companies is their IP; it is crucial to be able to demonstrate clear ownership of such IP.
limitations on their ability to do business. Contractual restraints like non-competes and most favored nation clauses can chill a prospective buyer’s interest in a company. Contractual provisions triggering termination upon a change of control or limitations on contractual assignment will be problematic.
reduce indemnity obligations on a sale.
In an effort to ensure a smooth and successful transaction process, consider the following:
8Ordinary Course Best Practice
Thus, it is important to review any term sheet carefully with counsel before execution. Major economic matters and risk allocation should be agreed on in advance.
Companies should resist assuming a potential transaction is a “done deal.”
mitigate disruption to their operations and keep the sale process moving forward quickly and efficiently.
Transactional Preparation
A transaction usually begins with informal, preliminary and high-level discussions with one or more potential buyers. Many companies may also engage a banker to provide introductions to potentially interested buyers who may be interested and to guide you in these
Before engaging in any serious discussions with potential buyers, you will need to provide sensitive confidential information, and it is a best practice to require buyers to execute a non-disclosure agreement before providing. What you want to avoid is disclosing your sensitive information to prospective buyers, who suddenly walk away from the deal and then use your sensitive information for their own
team.
Once prospective buyers determine that they wants to move forward with a transaction, they will typically propose the terms of the acquisition in a term sheet or letter of intent. The letter of intent is a non-binding outline of the significant terms of the transaction, including transaction structure (impact on taxes now and in the future), purchase price (and its adjustments), earn-out structure, indemnification and escrow (rep and warranty insurance), special closing conditions and treatment of employees after closing. Often, the letter of intent may also contain an exclusivity or "no-shop" provision, meaning that the target may not engage in discussions with
points once the letter of intent has been signed. Upon signature of an LOI with exclusivity, a significant amount of leverage moves to the prospective buyer.
10What are the stages of a typical transaction?
(a) Negotiation of definitive documents – Buyer, target and their respective legal counsel negotiate the terms of the definitive
weeks, sometimes longer. (b) Completion of diligence – During this period, the potential buyer circulates a diligence list requesting certain documents from the target, including, among other matters, corporate formation documents, financing documents, key commercial contracts and a description
the requests in the buyer's list. This is the stage when the potential buyer is looking for skeletons in the closet that may impact the purchase price, result in closing conditions being added and special indemnities negotiated. (c) Population of disclosure schedules – The definitive document will contain pages of representations and warranties about the
representations are found to be untrue after closing, the potential buyer of a private company may have an indemnification claim. The disclosure schedules are designed to qualify these representations and warranties.
11What are the stages of a typical transaction?
5. Signing After the definitive agreement and the forms of certain important ancillary agreements are agreed upon, the documents are signed. Closing may occur simultaneously or, if certain actions must be taken prior to closing (such as obtaining government approvals or
If there is a period between signing and closing, the target and the buyer will prepare all closing deliverables and satisfy all closing conditions (e.g., obtaining government approvals and third-party consents, getting key employees to sign employment agreements with the buyer, buyer financing). The length of the pre-closing period can vary, depending on the closing conditions that need to be satisfied. 7. Closing When all the closing conditions are satisfied, the deal is ready to close and funds are exchanged. This is the moment when the transaction actually occurs. 8. Post-closing After a deal closes, the buyer goes into full-scale integration of your business and all this entails. Working capital adjustments, earn-outs and indemnification claims will need to be monitored and perhaps negotiated/resolved.
12What are the stages of a typical transaction?
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Professor Robert Bontempo Columbia University Graduate School of Business
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
A FRAMEWORK FOR SELF UNDERSTANDING AND INTERPERSONAL INFLUENCE Professor Robert Bontempo Columbia University Graduate School of Business
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
KEYNOTE SPEAKER
The Molly Fletcher Company
THE MOLLY FLETCHER COMPANY
MOLLY FLETCHER
@mollyfletcher | www.mollyfletcher.com
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Molly Fletcher
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
Pricing for Growth
Professor of Marketing Tsai-Wan Tsai Professor Director of Penn Wharton China Center
zjzhang@Wharton.upenn.edu
29
F
30
Va lue Cre a tio n vs. Va lue Ca pturing
31
4
Pricing in action: your call?
10
Suppose a chemical plant uses O-rings to seal the valves on pipes that carry corrosive materials. The plant pays $5 for each O-ring. You develop a new O-ring that has twice the corrosive resisting power at a cost of $1 each. How much should you price it for?
Common Pricing Approaches
Cost plus pricing Competition based pricing Consumer based pricing
34
Smart Value Pricing?
35
Determine what drives value for your customers, how much value they place on your product, how you could enhance them how best you could communicate value to your customers, and then design pricing policies and metrics to capture a fair share of that value
SVP 3.0
36
Margin
O/ H Dire c t c o st Co st plus pric eBrand image
Se rvic e b e ne fits Pro duc t b e ne fits Na ïve va lue pric ingBrand image
Se rvic e b e ne fits Pro duc t b e ne fits Optima l va lue pric ingSVP 3.0
force your customers to admit the value of your product avoid unnecessary price competition avoid commoditizing your product focus on product and service innovation and differentiation that matter the most to your customers establish long-term mutually beneficial relationships with your customers achieve a higher price or/and higher volume
37
By doing so, you would
Value pricing: measure and enhance value
38
Identify value drivers and quantify product value
Pricing in action
10
Suppose a chemical plant uses O-rings to seal the valves on pipes that carry corrosive materials. The plant pays $5 for each O-ring. You develop a new O-ring that has twice the corrosive resisting power at a cost of $1 each. How much should you price it for?
Value Pricing
A rational consumer forms his or her willingness to pay for a product on the basis of the following three components:
» reference value » positive differentiation value » negative differentiation value
40
What is economic value analysis?
Value Pricing
41
Re fe re nc e Va lue Po sitive diffe re ntia tio n va lue Ne g a tive diffe re ntia tio n va lue Total Economic Value
Value Pricing
42
Suppose a chemical plant uses 200 O-rings to seal the valves on pipes that carry corrosive materials. The plant pays $5 for each O-ring and must change them every two months. The cost of shutdown is $5,000. A new O-ring has twice the corrosive resisting power at a cost of $1 each. However, to install the new O-rings properly, an adhesive must be applied to each O-ring, which costs about $1,000 per change. What is the economic value of this new O-ring?
In What Ways Is EVA Valuable? What price to charge? Whom to sell first? How to communicate and sell value? How to enhance value? How to capture value (pricing structure)?
43
Pharmacoeconomics
44 Before discounts, Gilead’s hepatitis medicine Sovaldi costs $84,000 for a 12-week course of treatment, and Harvoni, which combines Sovaldi with another medication, taken as a single pill, costs $94,500 for 12 weeks. Viekira Pak’s listed 12-week price is $83,319.
Pricing to Grow for Pharma
45
SVP 3.0: communicate and also enhance value
46
Value is in the eye of the beholder
Benj amin Franklin, in Poor Richard's Almanack, 1741, wrot e:
“ Beauty, like supreme dominion Is but supported by opinion”
Value communication—Birkin bag
47
48
Exclusivity is about scarcity
French high-skill, high-cost labor means that the Birkin can’t be mass-produced… ...resulting in a 2-6 year wait for customers and cost upwards of $17,000 Production facts
assemble, the same time needed to manufacture a BMW
be requested by customers
Value communication—Birkin bag
“ This week a Birkin bag broke records and became the most expensive handbag in the world.The rare Himalayan crocodile Birkin with white gold detailing and 245 diamonds was bought for $300,168 (£208,175) by an anonymous buyer at a Christie's auction in Hong Kong.” (June 3, 2015, The Telegraph)
$114k
Value communication—Michelin Tires
50
51
SVP 3.0: capture value
money left on the table vs. foregone profit MC
$10 $8 $6 $4 $2
SVP 3.0: capture value
Variable margins?
C p 1
*
− = ε ε
1 1 − = ε MU AC MU p ) 1 ( + =
SVP: capture value
Implementation: Versioning
56
Business Class Economy
Versioning
57
Consumer Self-Selection: Design your product in such a way that would induce, with proper incentives, consumers to choose what you desire them to choose.
Versioning
58
Consumer Self-Selection or firm incentivization?
Implementing Price Customization
Cargo Class?
59
Implementing Price Customization
Cattle Class?
Versioning in Practice
61
10 pages 5 pages Priority Overnight Standard Overnight
Ho t pric ing mo de ls fo r va lue c a pturing
Dyna mic pric ing T
a rg e te d pric ing
Big da ta , AI
…
62MC
$10 $8 $6 $4 $2
4
An E xa mple
Movie s Watc he d WT P pe r Movie Se gme nt Size
He a vy Use rs 12 $2 20 L ig ht Use rs 5 $3 80
Adva nta g e s
Movie s Watc he d WT P pe r Movie Se gme nt Size
He a vy Use rs 12 $2 20 L ig ht Use rs 5 $3 80 $3 $2 $1 400 640 Pro fit Po te ntia l = $1,040 Optima l L ine a r Pric e = $3 Pro fit Ca pture d = $800 Ca pture ra te = 76.9%
Flat Fee Pricing
Units T
Wha t F la t Ra te ?
Movie s Watc he d WT P pe r Movie Se gme nt Size
He a vy Use rs 12 $2 20 L ig ht Use rs 5 $3 80 $3 $2 $1 400 640 Pro fit = $860 Ca pture ra te 82.7% Optima l ra te = $15
68
Buffet pricing at AA
For a one-time fee of $250k ($560k in 2018 dollars), this pass gave a buyer unlimited first-class travel for life. A companion pass could be purchased for an additional $150k, allowing the pass holder to bring along anyone for the ride.
69
F la t F e e a t
69
“Last August it lowered the price of its
unlimited plan to $9.95 per month. For less than the price of a single movie ticket in New York City, subscribers could see up to thirty movies a month in theaters. ”
T wo Pa rt T a riff
Units T
Wha t two pa rt ta riff?
Movie s Watc he d WT P pe r Movie Se gme nt Size
He a vy Use rs 12 $2 20 L ig ht Use rs 5 $3 80 $3 $2 $1 400 640 Pro fit = $1,000 Ca pture Ra te = 96% Me mb e rship = $10 Co st Pe r Mo vie = $1 = MC
T wo T ie r Pric ing ?
Movie s Watc he d WT P pe r Movie Se gme nt Size
He a vy Use rs 12 $2 20 L ig ht Use rs 5 $3 80 $3 $2 $1 400 600 Pro fit = $1,040 Ca pture ra te = 100% T ie r 1 = $15, up to 5 mo vie s T ie r 2 = $24, up to 12 mo vie s
SVP 3.0 in Summary
73
74
CEO SUMMIT 2O19
LEVERAGING YOUR VENDORS: BEST PRACTICES
Brad Ellis | Stifel Bank
LEVERAGING YOUR VENDORS: BEST PRACTICES
The start-up ecosystem is live with resources that CEOs can leverage as part
HOW TO LEVERAGE YOUR VENTURING BANKING RELATIONSHIP
Beyond providing non-dilutive and flexible growth capital, venture banks can drive significant value in support of a broader partnership. VENTURE BANK INVESTMENT BANK RESEARCH PRIVATE BANK FUNDRAISING NETWORK
growth, working capital, or acquisitions.
the business.
tailored for growing businesses – advice
receivables management, asset allocation and yield driving products, and other products.
banking relationship, executives and employees can gain access to a multitude of commercial banking products outside of the business environment
financial planning, mortgages, securities based lending, real estate finance, etc.
partnership based) start early in a Company’s path. At growth stage – getting to know advisors is beneficial to understanding your competitive environment
market and know both sponsors and strategic investors / buyers that can be beneficial to the business.
number of ways, from simply having a better sense for macroeconomic trends, to understanding how competitive businesses are valued, evaluated and discussed on a public basis
available to the ecosystem and help to make more informed leadership team
equity and debt sources throughout the industry including follow-on and secondary sources of equity, growth / buyout investors, and subordinated debt
and can be helpful in thinking through alternative sources of capital as needed
for recruiting, real-estate advisory, accountants, law firms, outsourced accounting and CFO support, etc.
STIFEL OVERVIEW
Premier Growth Focused Investment Bank
Domain Leadership
Consumer & Retail Gaming, Lodging & Leisure Diversified Industrials Energy & Natural Resources Financial Institutions (Keefe, Bruyette & Woods) M&A Equity Capital Markets Debt Capital Markets Restructuring Advisory (Miller Buckfire) Private Capital Markets Research, Trading & DistributionSTIFEL VENTURE BANK
YOUR DEDICATED STIFEL VENTURE BANKING TEAM: Brad Ellis, Head of Venture Banking Managing Director, Founder belllis@stifelbank.com 212-271-3444 Nat Stone National Venture Banking Director, Founder nstone@stifelbank.com 212-271-3445 Alan Faulkner Southeast Coverage Director afaulkner@stifelbank.com 919-645-5904
Shuttle service provided in lobby at 6:15 PM