Council on Earth Sciences: A Brief History, Current Activities and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

council on earth sciences a brief history current
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Council on Earth Sciences: A Brief History, Current Activities and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Council on Earth Sciences: A Brief History, Current Activities and Opportunities for Coordination John W. Rudnicki Department of Mechanical and Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Northwestern University History Began 1997,


slide-1
SLIDE 1

Council on Earth Sciences: A Brief History, Current Activities and Opportunities for Coordination

John W. Rudnicki Department of Mechanical and Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Northwestern University

slide-2
SLIDE 2

September 10, 2009 2

History

  • Began 1997, Chaired by Frank Richter (University of Chicago)
  • Of original members, Frank Richter, Don DePaolo, Kate Baker

remained on Council until 2007.

  • Various others have gone on and off to keep number of council

members around 10.

  • Nick Woodward has always been DOE contact
slide-3
SLIDE 3

September 10, 2009 3

Current Council Members

Chairperson (2008): Prof John Rudnicki Northwestern University (1997)

  • Prof. Susan Brantley (2009)

Pennsylvania State University

  • Prof. David A. Dixon (2003?)

The University of Alabama

  • Prof. Patricia M. Dove

Virginia Tech (2009)

  • Prof. John Eiler (2008)

California Institute of Technology

  • Dr. Joanne T. Fredrich

BP America, Inc. (2008)

  • Prof. Rosemary Knight (2003?)

Stanford University

  • Prof. Michael Manga (2008)

University of California at Berkeley

  • Dr. Christopher Neuzil (2008)
  • U. S. Geological Survey

Professor Roel K. Snieder (2003?) Colorado School of Mines

  • Dr. John Zachara (2008)

Pacific Northwest National Laboratory

slide-4
SLIDE 4

September 10, 2009 4

TYPICAL AGENDA

7:30 - 8:15 AM 8:15 - 8:30 AM 8:30 - 9:30 AM 9:30 -10:00 AM 10:00 -10:15 AM 10:15-12:00 AM 12:00 – 1:00 PM 1:00 – 3:00 PM 3:00 PM Coffee, Continental breakfast Welcome and Introductions Chemical Sciences, Geosciences and Biosciences Divisional Overview Geosciences Program Coffee Break 2 -3 presentations from other BES divisions, DOE labs, special reports, NSF, etc. Lunch Council Discussion: Workshop reports, proposals for new workshops, membership. Adjourn

slide-5
SLIDE 5

September 10, 2009 5

Spring 2002, 2006, 2009 TYPICAL 1.5 Day AGENDA

7:30 AM – 3 PM 3:30 – 5:30 PM Usual Future Directions in Geosciences – 10-15 minute discussions/presentations from each Council member Interests, workshop possibilities, etc.

Day One Dinner at local establishment Day 2

Council discussion: Organize the discussions/ideas floated on Day 1 into themes that could constitute workshops. The questions that need to answered are:

  • How do we make workshops out of these ideas?
  • Who would like to organize them?
  • What are the priorities?

What are the relationships among workshops?

slide-6
SLIDE 6

September 10, 2009 6

  • Processes in Fluid-Rock Systems: Bridging from Atomic to Field Scales,

September 1997

  • Terrestrial Sequestration of CO2: An Assessment of Research Needs,

May 1998

  • Optimization and Geophysical Inverse Problems, February 1999
  • Initiatives in High-Pressure Research (joint with MS&E), June 1999
  • Permeability Dependence of Seismic Amplitudes, December 2001
  • Integrating Numerical Models of Reactive Flow and Transport into

Fundamental Geosciences Research, June 2003

  • Geophysical Images of the Near-Surface of the Earth: What are we

really measuring? December 2003

  • Geosciences User Facilities – Enhancing Instrumentation Access, May

2004

  • Compaction Localization Phenomena, October 2004
  • Advanced Non-Invasive Monitoring, November 2005
  • Molecular Dynamics and Structure of Geofluids, December 2007
  • What Can Computational Geochemistry Do and What is Needed to

Address the Mineral Water Interface?, January, 2010

  • Revitalizing the Connections Between Fundamental Isotope Chemistry

and Isotope Geoscience, 2010

Council Council Workshops Workshops

slide-7
SLIDE 7

September 10, 2009 7

Selected Workshop Excerpts (1)

  • Molecular Dynamics and Structure of Geofluids, December 2007

“…to establish unifying themes in our understanding of water, silicate melts, and their chemical combinations in the form of aqueous solutions of hydrous melts over a wide range of pressure and temperature…recent results have challenged our compartmentalized view of geofluids as either silicate liquids or aqueous solutions and our view of the earth as being divided between a wetter, cooler surface and a drier, hotter interior.”

slide-8
SLIDE 8

September 10, 2009 8

Selected Workshop Excerpts (2)

  • Computational Geochemistry, January, 2010

Co-chairs Randy Cygan (SNL), Jim Kubicki (Penn State), David A. Dixon (Alabama) “…Most geochemical reactions near the Earth’s surface and in the crust involve fluid phases and take place at fluid-solid interfaces or in confined spaces of mineral interlayers and nanopores. These …. important natural processes… are inherently multi-scale in time and space, and addressing the … problems they pose requires … the use of new computational science methodologies. A molecular-level understanding of the chemistry and physics of interfacial and confined aqueous solutions interacting with mineral surfaces is essential to understanding many of the crucial problems in energy and the environment… There is a growing consensus that the idealized mineral-fluid interfaces used in MD and MC simulations and the relatively small assemblages used in these models and in quantum calculations are at least an order of magnitude too small in characteristic length (three orders of magnitude in volume) to effectively address many critical questions ”

slide-9
SLIDE 9

September 10, 2009 9

Computational Chemistry Potential Participants

  • Susan Rempe (SNL) computational studies of ionic nanoconductors
  • Kathy Nagy (University of Illinois at Chicago) experimental geochemistry
  • Louise Criscenti (SNL) computational geochemistry
  • Nita Sahai (Wisconsin) interfacial biogeochemistry
  • Patricia Dove (Virginia Tech) geochemistry
  • Andrey G. Kalinichev (Michigan State) computational geochemistry
  • Kevin Rosso (PNNL) experimental and computational geochemistry
  • Jim Rustad (UC Davis) computational geochemistry
  • Jim Kirkpatrick (Michigan State) experimental geochemistry
  • Peter Cummings (Vanderbilt/ORNL) computational nanoscience
  • Eric Bylaska (PNNL) computational chemistry software development –

ab initio molecular dynamics with solution and geochemical applications

  • Glenn Waychunas (LBL) experimental and computational geochemistry
  • Udo Becker (Michigan) computational and experimental geochemistry
  • Dave Wesolowski (ORNL) computational and experimental geochemistry
slide-10
SLIDE 10

September 10, 2009 10

Selected Workshop Excerpts (3)

  • Revitalizing the connections between fundamental isotope

chemistry and isotope geoscience, 2010 Co-chairs: John Eiler, Bill Goddard (Caltech), Edwin Schauble (UCLA)

“…The nuclear, physical and biochemistry of isotopes have profoundly influenced the geosciences: They are the ultimate foundation of geological time scales, reconstructions of past climate, ‘tracer’ studies in the hydrosphere and atmosphere, and numerous other applied disciplines…. . Stable isotope geochemistry is in the midst of a sustained burst of analytical innovation and observational discovery … It has accumulated many peculiar new observations and is attempting to interpret them with familiar but decades-old physical and chemical theory. Chemistry has undergone a variety of recent innovations, including a striking jump in sophistication and demonstrable accuracy of first-principles theoretical modeling, particularly of complex structures and interfaces. This body of work succeeds on its own terms, but appears to be largely unaware of the set of new, often mysterious, observations coming from novel branches of stable isotope geochemistry.

slide-11
SLIDE 11

September 10, 2009 11

Revitalizing the connections between fundamental isotope chemistry and isotope geoscience, 2010

Representative Potential Participants

  • Jess Adkins (Caltech; paleoclimate research)
  • Michael Bender (Princeton; isotope geochemistry and climate research)
  • Jacob Bigeleisen (Stonybrook; physical chemistry of isotopes)
  • Joel Blume (University of Michigan; isotope geochemistry of Hg)
  • Kristie Boering (UC Berkeley; stratospheric photochemistry and isotope geochemistry
  • f ozone)
  • Nicolas Dauphas (University of Chicago; transition-metal isotope geochemistry)
  • John Eiler (Caltech; isotope geochemistry)
  • Bill Goddard (Caltech; theoretical physical and organic chemistry)
  • John Hayes (Retired to San Francisco area; isotope biogeochemistry)
  • Rudy Marcus (Caltech; physical chemistry, including isotope geochemistry of ozone)
  • Mitchio Okumura (Caltech; analytical and environmental chemistry)
  • Edwin Schauble (UC Los Angeles; chemistry of naturally occurring isotopes)
  • Alex Sessions (Caltech; isotope biogeochemistry)
  • Neil Sturchio (University of Illinois at Chicago; isotope geochemistry of Cl and O)
  • Mark Thiemens (UC San Diego; chemistry and isotope geochemistry)
slide-12
SLIDE 12

September 10, 2009 12

Biomolecular Interactions (Patricia Dove and John Zachara)

  • Future directions in microbially driven geochemical processes.
  • Biomolecular interactions involved in biomineralization.
  • Role of biochemistry in modulating growth and nucleation in simple model systems.
  • Controls on skeletal formation and signatures by this pathway.

Microscale imaging

  • Porosity, fluid flow, chemical and biological interactions.
  • What don’t we need to know?
  • How can computations be used to upscale information at the grain-contact scale?

Flow, transport, chemistry and microscale imaging in fine-grained clays (Chris Neuzil) Reaction-front scaling and heterogeneities (Sue Brantley)

Possible Future Workshops Topics

slide-13
SLIDE 13

September 10, 2009 13

Success of Earth Sciences Council

  • Good leadership (Richter, DePaolo)
  • Good guidance and prodding (Nick W.)
  • Careful selection of members (scientifically

high quality, eclectic, interactive, broad minded, diverse in age, interests and gender and nice).

  • Continuity
slide-14
SLIDE 14

September 10, 2009 14

Final Thoughts

  • Interaction between councils and BES

groups is, like motherhood, always good.

  • Interaction adds impact and is a good

selling point.

  • Collaboration begins with communication.
  • Much interesting science occurs in the

creases between disciplines.