CCC COUNCIL MEETING November 29, 2017 AGENDA Morning Welcome and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

November 29, 2017

CCC COUNCIL MEETING

AGENDA

• Morning

– Welcome and Introductions – Task Forces: PMLC, Privacy, Security – CISE Update and Looking Forward – Connections between CISE and SBE

• Lunch
• Afternoon

– Task Forces: II, HTF, AI – CCC Planning: Looking Forward to 2018 – Closing Discussions

INTRODUCTIONS

POST MOORE’S LAW COMPUTING TASK FORCE

!"#$%&'("#$%!&'((!#)*!+#,-.!/0('1%!

!

)#%*(+$,,( 2'314)3')5! "#*'34)!

• #."/(01,$2*(

67!80$%0(0.! 345(!46.1( 904$:'#!;01-!

!7%%16.()1581%&'(( 94#,'(;-0!<43,!"44$0=3!>#?!

74@AB,'):!,#3%!C4$10!(0#*3! #1,'D','03!,4!#**$033!,-0!CB,B$0!4C! 14@AB,'):!#3!?0!$0#1-!,-0!('@',!4C! "44$0=3!>#?!E!,-0!4F30$D#F(0!,$0)*! ,-#,!,-0!)B@F0$!4C!,$#)3'3,4$3!A0$! 3GB#$0!')1-!4)!'),0:$#,0*!1'$1B',3!

• #*!*4BF(0*!0D0$.!.0#$!3')10!,-0'$!

')D0),'4)H!I)!4$*0$!,4!@4D0!A#3,!,-0! 0$#!4C!"44$0=3!(#?5!)0?! 14@AB,#,'4)#(!,44(3!#)*!3.3,0@3! @B3,!F0!*0D0(4A0*H!

:;245$6<(=2.$>$.$1&'(

• ! !"#$%&'($)'"*+,-.")/0--+12"340-546"7$6)45,-.8"

9)+:,0/,;+1"0%:(,5+:54%+'8"0-1"*%0,-<,-'),%+1" =5(+%6$1>-06,:?":$6)45,-."

Workshop #1: Specialized Digital Computing

!4?!"#$%&'(7-$'3,43!+4J.$#%'3!#)*! +#,-.!/0('1%!

!

!"%$&.4&(

• 4@/%#*$&(

K,#)C4$*!

• #."/(01,$2*(

67!80$%0(0.!

=;;%4#2"'(630!#AA('1#,'4)L *$'D0)!*'31B33'4)3!4$:#)'J0*! #$4B)*!M!1#30!3,B*'03N! OP! "#1-')0!(0#$)'):!F0.4)*! *00A!(0#$)'):! QP! K1'0),'C'1!3'@B(#,'4)!#)*! #)#(.3'3!#,!0R,$0@0!31#(03! MP! K,$0#@'):!'@#:0SD'*04! #)#(.3'3!C$4@!BF'GB',4B3! 1#@0$#3! 630!F$0#%4B,3!,4!'*0),'C.! $030#$1-!A$4F(0@3!')!,-0! 3A01'#('J0*!34C,?#$0!3,#1%!,4! ')C4$@!CB)*'):!#:0)1'03! 94#,&'(

• ! @'"5%0-','5$%"1+-',5>".%$#5("'50//'8"5(+%+"#,//"*+"0"

5%+-1"5$#0%1"')+:,0/,;+1"0%:(,5+:54%+'"0'"$-+"$A" 5(+"/0'5"#0>'"5$".0,-")+%A$%60-:+B"C1+-5,A>"5(+" $)+-"%+'+0%:("D4+'5,$-'",-"0''$:,05+1"/0-.40.+'8" :$6),/+%'8"0/.$%,5(6'8"0-1"$)+%05,-."'>'5+6'E" A$:4'"$-")%$*/+6'"'4,5+1"5$"0-"0:01+6,:"%+'+0%:(" +-F,%$-6+-5"%05(+%"5(0-",-14'5%>B" A#.1&(#6B(,42#.$46'(

• ! G0%:("HI<HJ8")%$*0*/>",-"K+%&+/+>"

Workshop #2: Quantum Computing

!4?!"#$%&'("#$:#$0,!"#$,4)43'!#)*! "#$,')!T40,,0(0$!

)#%<#%1.( )#%.464&$( <$')10,4)! Martin Roetteler "'1$434C,!U)4,! 14)C'$@0*P!

=;;%4#2"'(8$'):!,4:0,-0$! 0RA0$,3!')!GB#),B@!14@AB,'):! ?',-!14@AB,0$!31'0)10!3.3,0@! $030#$1-0$3!,4!'*0),'C.!$030#$1-! #$0#3!')!,-0!:#A!F0,?00)! A-.3'13S*0D'10!#)*!,-04$.S #(:4$',-@3! A#.1&(#6B(,42#.$46'(

• ! L05+"')%,-."M"+0%/>"'466+%N"L$:05,$-"OKP"

94#,&'(

• ! 340-546"1+F,:+'"#,5("HQ'"$A"D4*,5'"0%+"*+:$6,-."0F0,/0*/+8"

*$5("0'":/$41<0550:(+1"%+'$4%:+'"0-1":$-A,.4%0*/+"5+'5*+1'8" 0-1"5(+%+"0%+"'$6+")$5+-5,0/"0))/,:05,$-'"=:(+6,'5%>8")(>',:'8" 60:(,-+"/+0%-,-.8"$)5,6,;05,$-?"#(+%+"0"D40-546"1+F,:+"60>" '$$-"$45)+%A$%60-:+":$-F+-5,$-0/"$-+'B"""C-A$%6"5(+":$6)45+%" ':,+-:+"%+'+0%:(":$664-,5>"$-"5(+"+6+%.,-."D40-546" 5+:(-$/$.>"0-1"%$0160)'8"0-1",1+-5,A>"%+'+0%:(")%$*/+6'",-" )%$.%066,-.8"+5:B" "

Workshop #3: Thermodynamic Computing

!4?!"#$%&'(;4@!74),0!#)*!;4**!&.(,4)!

!

345(!46.1( 904$:'#!;01-! Todd Hylton 67!K#)!V'0:4!

94#,'("#%0!#!A43','4)! 3,#,0@0),!#F4B,!,-0! '@A4$,#)10!4C!#*D#)1'):!,-'3! #$0#!4C!$030#$1-!F.!-':-(':-,'):! ,-0!1-#((0):03!#)*!)00*3!C4$! #*D#)10@0),!4C!,-030!)4D0(! 14@AB,'):!#AA$4#1-03H! ! A#.1&(#6B(,42#.$46'(

• ! L05+"'466+%"M"+0%/>"A0//N"L$:05,$-"OKP"

94#,&'(

• ! RS)/$%+")4)LD4)!W0B@#))!14@AB,'):!#AA$4#1-03!UF0.4)*!

GB#),B@!#)*!)0B$4@4$A-'1P!,4!B30!A-.3'1#(!A$4103303!,4! A0$C4$@!14@AB,#,'4)5!0H:H5!,-0$@4*.)#@'1!@4*0(3!4C! 14:)','4)H!74)3'*0$!#AA$4#1-03!,-#,!XB)F4RX!,-0!14@AB,0$! F.!(0D0$#:'):!#)*!0@F$#1'):!,-0!0)D'$4)@0),!,-0! 14@AB,0$!'3!0@F0**0*!')5!$#,-0$!,-#)!#33B@'):!I4;! 30)34$3!30)*!*#,#!,4!#!1(4B*!0)D'$4)@0),!C4$!14@AB,#,'4)H! "

PRIVACY AND FAIRNESS TASK FORCE

!"#$%'(Y('J#F0,-!8$#*(0.!

!

C,$@#81."( D%#B,1/(

74(4$#*45! 84B(*0$!

E#5;#."(

• #66#6(

6)'D0$3',.!4C! <0))3.(D#)'#!

!/6."$#( AF4%*(

&#$D#$*!

!7%%16.()1581%&'(( 94#,'(;-'3!,#3%!C4$10!#**$03303!,-0!

'@A4$,#),!*4@#')3!4C!A$'D#1.!#)*! C#'$)033!')!#)!'),0$14))01,0*!#)*! F':L*#,#!*$'D0)!?4$(*H!

:;245$6<(=2.$>$.$1&'(

• ! T/0--,-."0"'+%,+'"$A"U<!"#$%&'($)'",-:/41,-."$-+"

$-"A0,%-+''",-"G0%:(8"UQHV"

CYBERSECURITY TASK FORCE

!"#$%'(+0D')!ZB!

!

• 1>$6(G7(

"'1-':#)!

• 1$."(

)#%@7,,4( "#$.(#)*! H#B/#(D,$&&( [$'J4)#!K,#,0! 9%1<( )4%%$&1..( 74$)0((!

!7%%16.()1581%&'(( 94#,'(;-'3!,#3%!C4$10!#'@3!,4! 3-0*!(':-,!4)!1.F0$301B$',.! $030#$1-!#)*!F03,!A$#1,'1035! ?',-!#!C41B3!4)!1.F0$LA-.3'1#(! 3.3,0@3!#)*!,-0!I),0$)0,!4C! ;-'):3!')!#)!')1$0#3'):(.! 14))01,0*!?4$(*H(( :;245$6<(=2.$>$.$1&'(

• ! L$$&,-."5$"($/1"0"#$%&'($)"$%"#%,5+"0"#(,5+")0)+%"

0%$4-1"+6*+11+1"1+F,:+'" (

"

O\!

CYBERSECURITY TF PLANS FOR 2018

• Formal methods for security (Morrisett; next: blog)
• Embedded security (Fu; next: NUL)
• Testing to failure (Fu, Hill; next: NUL)

Discussion:

• Democracy & Disinformation (next: blog reaction)
• AI and Security (Marzullo)
• Approximation algorithms (Bliss; fairness)

See What Happens:

• Quantum (Bliss)
• Data Breaches, Cyber Risk, Economics

11

BREAK

CISE UPDATE AND LOOKING FORWARD

Jim Kurose, CISE AD

CONNECTIONS BETWEEN CISE AND SBE

Howard Wactlar, CISE Steven Breckler, SBE Tamera Schneider, SBE Sara Kiesler, SBE

LUNCH

HUMAN TECHNOLOGY FRONTIER TASK FORCE

!"#$%&'("#`#!"#,#$'a!#)*!K-?0,#%!<#,0(!

!

+4,,/( M7&"51$1%( /#(0! E"F1.#*(N#.1,( 2#3-'):,4)! D1."( )/6#..( 904$:'#! ;01-! C,$@#81."( !"7%2"$,,( 944:(0! )#O#( )#.#%$P( 6K7!

!7%%16.()1581%&'(( 94#,'(;-0!&B@#)!;01-)4(4:.!

Z$4),'0$!,#3%!C4$10!C41B303!4)!,-0! $4(0!4C!,01-)4(4:.!,4!#B:@0),'):!

• B@#)!A0$C4$@#)105!')1(B*'):!FB,!

)4,!('@',0*!,45!')!,-0!?4$%A(#105!')! ,-0!1(#33$44@5!#)*!,4!'@A$4D0!

• 0#(,-!4B,14@03H!

:;245$6<(=2.$>$.$1&'(

• ! T/0--,-."0"#$%&'($)"$-"L,A+/$-."L+0%-,-."M"

O%0,-,-."A$%"WOXB""

• ! T/0--,-."0"#(,5+)0)+%"$-"O+:(-$/$.>"0-1"G+-50/"

W+0/5("

WORKSHOP

Authoring Tools for Lifelong Learning or Content Creation for Education and Training

GOAL Bring together: Researchers in different areas of content creation tools (systems for creating various time-based media) Representatives of application domains where this media could be used in education and training. Application domains: Manufacturing service industries, medicine, government domains that are evolving rapidly with technology and require training tools. Users have no intrinsic interest in developing computer expertise, but are focused

• n their application.

Authoring tools should blend in with their current work, rather than demanding new skill sets. Researchers: Computer science and education technology Focusing on new domains will inspire new approaches in authoring and result in

7$0#,0!D'3B#(3!,4!#33'3,!U)4,!$0A(#10P!A04A(0!')!14@@B)'1#,'4)!U'@#:03!4C!&#)3!T43('):!C$4@K,0D0!V$B1%0$5!"KP! RS06)/+'"$A"4'+N! 7$0#,0!'),0$#1,'D0!*0@43N!<'R#$!')!#!84R!T4F4,!74@F')#,4$'13! 7$0#,0!0)D'$4)@0),3!C4$!14@A#$'):!310)#$'43N! !YKTI!!7',.!Y):'0):!

RS06)/+'"$A"5$$/&,5'N! *MH`3!!!C4$!*#,#!D'3B#('J#,'4)3! V03':)0$=3![B:@0),0*!T0#(',.!;44(%',!"#1I),.$0!9#;01-!

7&YTLbF!D'*04!:0)0$#,4$5!/#(0! RS06)/+'",-:$%)$%05+1",-5$"0-0/>','"'>'5+6'N! c'3;$#'(3!A$4D0)#)10!@#)#:0@0),5!W/6!

Fit with CCC goals: Both top down (need for rapid training in face of technological advances) And bottom up (new research in content creation) Engage with ACM SIGGRAPH, SIGCHI and IEEE TVCG Engage with industry End products: The product that is authored could be a wide range of media including videos, AR and VR applications, games and other interactive media. For the application domains, there would be a new interest in employing new media in education if the substantial learning curve for developing customized materials were flattened.

Steering committee members- Jessica Hodgins (CMU, ACM SIGGRAPH president) (agreed) Tony DeRose (Pixar) (agreed) Blair MacIntyre (GaTech) (agreed) Holly Rushmeier -- CCC liaison (graphics focus) Juliana Freire -- CCC liaison (visualization focus) Beth Mynatt – CCC liaison (HCI focus) Educational Technology –

AI TASK FORCE

94#,'(<$4D'*0!#!@01-#)'3@!C4$!

#$,'1B(#,'):!F4,-!,-0!3,#,0!4C!,-0!#$,! #)*!,01-)'1#(!('@',#,'4)3!4C![I5!,4!

• 0(A!*0D0(4A!C4$?#$*L(44%'):!

$030#$1-!#:0)*#3!C4$!,-0!C'0(*5!#)*! ,4!F0,,0$!B)*0$3,#)*!,-0!A4,0),'#(! 4C![I!,4!A$4D'*0!,$0@0)*4B3!341'#(! :44*!')!,-0!CB,B$05!')1(B*'):!FB,! )4,!('@',0*!,4!B$F#)!14@AB,'):5!

• 0#(,-5!0)D'$4)@0),#(!

3B3,#')#F'(',.5!#)*!ABF('1!?0(C#$0H!

:;245$6<(=2.$>$.$1&'(

• !

X%06,-."0"#$%&'($)"$-"O%0-')0%+-5"0-1"O%4'5#$%5(>"@C"

• !

T/0--,-."0"#(,5+)0)+%"$-"5(+":$-5,-4+1"-++1"A$%" X$4-105,$-0/"Y+'+0%:(",-"

• !

O(,-&,-."0*$45"5(+",''4+'"$A"#$%&A$%:+"M"+14:05,$-"M" 5%0,-,-."A$%"@C"

!"#$%&'(9$0:!&#:0$!#)*!"#)B0(#!c0(434!

!

9%1<4%/(+#<1%( d4-)3!&4A%')3! )#671,#(S1,4&4( 7#$)0:'0!"0((4)! C%$2(+4%>$.@( "'1$434C,! T030#$1-! )#O#( )#.#%$P( 6K7!

!7%%16.()1581%&'((

INTELLIGENT INFRASTRUCTURE TASK FORCE

!"#$%&'(V#)!>4A$03,'!#)*!80)!e4$)!

!

A#6$1,(R4;%1&.$( >0-':-!! D16(T46( "'1$434C,! T030#$1-! I166$U1%( M1VU4%B( <$')10,4)! H$6#()$&"%#(( 7#$)0:'0! "0((4)!

!7%%16.()1581%&'(( 94#,'(;-0!777!,#3%!C4$10!4)! I),0((':0),!I)C$#3,$B1,B$0! C41B303!4)!0RA(4$'):!,-0! 1-#((0):03!#)*!4AA4$,B)','03!')! ,-0!'),0$301,'4)!F0,?00)! ')C$#3,$B1,B$05!,-0!I),0$)0,!4C! ;-'):35!#)*!4,-0$!$0(0D#),! ,01-)4(4:'03!,-#,!#$0!D',#(!,4! ,-0!1$0#,'4)!4C!3@#$,!1','03!#)*! 14@@B)','03H(( :;245$6<(=2.$>$.$1&'(

• ! T/0--,-."0"#$%&'($)"=$%"'+%,+'?"0%$4-1":$--+:5,F,5>"

,-A%0'5%4:54%+"%+',/,+-:+"0-1"%+4'+"0-1"1,'0'5+%"%+')$-'+B""

A$6#(-#.#8$( "#33#1-B30,,3! I)3,',B,0!4C! ;01-)4(4:.!! +166$6<( E2"7,@%$661( 74(B@F'#! 6)'D0$3',.!

CONGRESSIONAL BRIEFING

• II Task Force planning for possible briefing for House

Committee on Science, Space, and Technology in January

• Important points to make:

– II will have enormous economic and societal impact – II needs to serve all citizens and provide both public and private benefits – II needs to be “future-proof” because once we build it, we won’t have another change for 50 years – II needs to provide 4 important properties:

• 1) Trustworthy
• 2) Robust and Interoperable
• 3) Resilient and Adaptable
• 4) Accessible

25

BREAK

CCC PLANNING: LOOKING FORWARD TO 2018

Increase and Structure Communication

• Disseminate to known venues (e.g.

ACM / IEEE)

• Structure writing (white papers,

workshop reports, agency responses)

• Provide actionable collaterals (Exec

summaries, Slides, Video)

• Target major media / press

Broaden Participation

• Increase reach to more universities /

labs / researchers

• Increase interactions with early

career researchers Increase Engagement

• Professional societies
• Industry
• Advisory Board

Task Force Process and Topics

• Pick topics strategically with balance

between top-down and bottom-up activities

Recent

• Advances in Geographic Information

Systems (ACM SIGSPATIAL)- November 2016

• Advancement of Artificial

Intelligence (AAAI)- February 2017

• Autonomous Agents and MutliAgent

Systems (AAMAS)- May 2017

• Material Robotics (MaRo) Robotics

Science and Systems (RSS)- July 2017

• Spatial & Temporal Databases

(SSTD)- August 2017

28

Future

• International Symposium on

Robotics Research (ISRR)- December 2017

• Advancement of Artificial

Intelligence (AAAI)- February 2018

• Association for Computational

Linguistics: Human Language Technologies- June 2018*

• ACM Hypertext- July 2018*

* Not your typical Blue Sky, but using Blue Sky Funds

NEXT STEPS FOR CCC

Plans to write

• Engagement and

Outreach Plan (2018)

• Site visit (April 2019)
• Strategic plan (April 2020)

Spring Meeting Summer Meeting / Snowbird

CLOSING DISCUSSIONS