ast 1420 galactic structure and dynamics today galactic
play

AST 1420 Galactic Structure and Dynamics Today: galactic rotation - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

AST 1420 Galactic Structure and Dynamics Today: galactic rotation Brief overview of observations: velocity fields and rotation curves Quantitative understanding of velocity fields Rotation curves > dark matter Gas rotation


  1. AST 1420 Galactic Structure and Dynamics

  2. Today: galactic rotation • Brief overview of observations: velocity fields and rotation curves • Quantitative understanding of velocity fields • Rotation curves —> dark matter • Gas rotation in the Milky Way • Local observations of differential rotation

  3. Galactic rotation: observations • Gas: assumed to be on non-crossing, closed orbits —> trace circular(-ish) orbits —> trace galactic potential • Different setups: • Long-slit spectra: spectrum of galaxy at all points along a 1D slice (typically major axis) —> rotation curve along this axis • Optical gas emission lines like H α , [NII] • Observations of 2D velocity field: spectrum at each point of galaxy • Radio observations (1970s onwards) • Currently also possible in optical with IFUs • Important to take into account the beam (radio) or PSF when measuring velocity fields!

  4. Long-slit spectra Rubin et al. (1980)

  5. 2D velocity fields (radio) Bosma (1978)

  6. Walter et al. (2008)

  7. Forster-Schreiber et al. (2008) IFU

  8. 2D velocity fields

  9. Anatomy of 2D velocity fields • Just from looking at the contours, we can see that this galaxy has • a rising rotation curve at small radii • and a flat rotation curve at larger radii • We’ll learn why in the next slides!

  10. 2D velocity fields • Consider velocity field V(x,y): • Center of galaxy at (x,y) = (0,0) • Major-axis along y=0 • Peak recession at positive x • Can rotate any galaxy’s observations to satisfy this • Two planes: • Sky plane : (x,y): observed position on the plane of the sky • galaxy plane : (x’,y’) observed position in the galaxy disk, seen face- on • Related by the inclination i: i=0 (edge-on) to i=90 (face-on)

  11. Sky and galaxy planes sky galaxy

  12. Observed velocity field for circular rotation • rhat : line-of-sight direction • Rhat :from center of galaxy to observed (x’,y’) • nhat : perpendicular to galaxy • khat : perpendicular to rhat and nhat ( rhat x nhat ) +systemic motion V 0

  13. Examples • Solid-body rotation: v c (R) = Ω R • x = R cos θ

  14. Examples • Flat rotation: v c (R) = v 0 • Only depends on y/x 
 —> straight lines with intercept 0

  15. Examples • Rotation curve with peak: • At y=0: V(x,y) = v c (R) sin i —> velocities near the peak attained at two x • For this value, go to y > 0 • Get same V(x,y) from R closer to peak of the rotation curve —> still two x • At some y, require peak v c to keep following the contour —> no solutions for larger y • Contours therefore close

  16. Examples

  17. Examples: disk rotation curves

  18. Example: rising then flat rotation curve

  19. Reading velocity fields

  20. From velocity fields to rotation curves • Long-slit spectra: • 2D velocity fields: tilted-ring models

  21. Rotation curves

  22. Rubin et al. (1980)

  23. Do Rubin’s flat rotation curves imply the existence of dark matter? • Optical rotation curves typically get close to the ‘optical radius’, the radius which contains most of the light • If the disks were exponential, we expect a peak at R ~ 2.15 R d < optical radius • However, disks are not all exponential and a somewhat shallower radial profile could keep the rotation curve flat to the optical radius • Question: given surface photometry, can we fit the Rubin rotation curves with the rotation curve implied by the light profile and M/L that fits the inner part?

  24. Rotation curve for general bulge+disk light distribution • Bulge-disk decomposition of light: • Use results from last few weeks’ classes to calculate the rotation curve of the disk and bulge components • Bulge: assume spherical, 3D density from Abel inversion like two weeks ago

  25. Rotation curve for general bulge+disk light distribution • For spherical mass distribution, circular velocity determined by enclosed mass profile , so we calculate the enclosed light profile • v c (r) follows from M/L assumption (constant)

  26. Rotation curve for general bulge+disk light distribution • For the disk we start from the general expression for a razor-thin disk from last week: • Result is:

  27. Maximum-disk fits • We can obtain a fit to the rotation curve that contains as much (bulge+disk) matter as allowed as follows: • Compute the rotation curves from the bulge and disk components • Adjust the bulge and disk M/L such that the combined (bulge+disk) rotation curve does not go above the observed rotation velocity (in the center) • Because this fit has as much mass in the (bulge+) disk as allowed, these are known as maximum disk fits

  28. Kent maximum-disk fits to Rubin et al. data • Kent (1980) obtained good photometry for galaxies whose rotation curves were obtained by Rubin et al. • Many galaxies actually well represented by max-disk hypothesis • But last few v c (R) points typically somewhat high • Not all Rubin et al. optical rotation curves require large amount of dark matter

  29. Rotation curves from radio velocity fields • Radio observations typically extend well outside the optical radius (~2x optical radius) • No good photometry available at the time, so Kent-style forward analysis not possible Bosma (1978)

  30. Enclosed mass implied by rotation curves • For spherical mass distribution v c (r) —> M(<r) • Similarly, for razor-thin disk vc(R) —> 𝛵 (R) —> M(<r) [but more difficult!] • Enclosed mass profile differs by a few tens of percent, but overall trend the same • Flat rotation curves imply rising mass M(<r) ~ r out to twice the optical radius! —> dark matter Bosma (1978)

  31. NGC 3198 • Poster child for flat rotation curves • Disk scale length ~2.7 kpc • Optical radius ~10 kpc • Rotation curve flat at ~11x disk scale length! de Blok et al. (2008)

  32. Kinematics of the Milky Way’s interstellar medium

  33. Phase-space distribution of gas • Want to use gas to measure Milky Way’s rotation, but difficult to obtain distances to gas, so interpreting the velocity of the ISM in terms of v c (R) is difficult • For gas orbiting in a plane, phase-space is four- dimensional (x,y,v x ,v y ) • Because gas orbits cannot cross, at each (x,y) there can only be a single velocity [v x ,v y ](x,y) • Thus, the phase-space distribution of the ISM is only two dimensional

  34. The longitude-velocity diagram • ISM phase-space distribution is 2D, so if we can measure two (independent) phase-space dimensions, we can fully map its phase-space DF • We can take spectra (e.g., 21cm, CO) that show the distribution of v los at each Galactic longitude l • 2D distribution of (l,v los ) == direct phase-space map! [up to some degeneracies]

  35. The longitude-velocity diagram: HI Sparke & Gallagher (2007)

  36. The longitude-velocity diagram: CO

  37. Making sense of the longitude-velocity diagram • How does circular rotation v c (R) map onto (l,v)? • Makes sense: • For disk in solid-body rotation relative distance between any two points remains the same —> v los = 0 • Dependence on sin l gives correct v=0 at l=0,180 • Must have minus the local circular velocity (relative to LSR/ Sun)

  38. Ring of gas in the longitude- velocity diagram • Ring at R < R 0 subtends -asin(R/R 0 ) < l < asin(R/R 0 ) • vlos(l) ~ sin l between these limits, with amplitude depending on [ Ω (R)- Ω (R 0 )] • Ring at R > R 0 spans entire -180 < l < 180, also sinusoidal

  39. Ring of gas in the longitude- velocity diagram

  40. Molecular ring

  41. Circular velocity from (l,v)? • Observed vlos only depends on difference in rotation rates • Therefore, to derive v c (R) from vlos(l) we need to assume v c (R 0 ) • If we assume that Ω (R) —> 0 as R goes to infinity then vlos —> - Ω (R 0 )R 0 sin l = vc(R 0 ) sin l • Unfortunately, need to go to large R and very little gas exists at large R!

  42. Terminal velocity • For 0 < l < 90: distribution of v los terminates at positive value, because Ω (R) monotonically decreases with R (at -90 < l < 0; v los terminates at same negative value) • Termination at given l is at largest ring at R < R 0 that reaches l • At this ring • Can thus map [ Ω (R)- Ω (R 0 )] by tracing the terminal velocity curve

  43. Predicted terminal velocity curve for different rotation curves

  44. Oort constants

  45. Local velocity distribution • We can observe velocities for large samples of local stars —> galactic rotation ? • First discovery of differential rotation based on local stars • Consider mean velocity field near the Sun < v >( x ) • Can Taylor expand this wrt distance from the Sun

  46. Local velocity distribution • In cartesian Galactic coordinates • After subtracting the mean motion, can write • We observe v los and the proper motion

  47. Local velocity distribution • Proper motion • Thus, we can measure A,B,C,K from measurements of v los (D,l) and μ l (D,l) • But what are A,B,C,K?

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend


More recommend