Academic Excellence and Bibliometric Tools David PONTILLE and Didier - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Academic Excellence and Bibliometric Tools

David PONTILLE and Didier TORNY *

* Random name order

The authors equally contributed to this communication No metrics could measure the respective contribution of each author By gentlemenʼs agreement, a la Lennon/McCartney, any production is coauthored whatever the actual contributions are

journal rankings

bibliometrics

databases algorithms bibliometric tools

Journal Impact Factor

1963

journal X journal X journal X journal X

…

+ + +

(Gross & Gross 1927 ; Bradford 1934)

counting citations

article A article C article E article N-1

…

+ + +

research potential realized

article A

+

article B

+

article C

+

article N

…

(Raisig 1960)

journal X journal X journal X journal X

…

+ + +

journal impact factor

article A

+

article B

+

article C

+

article N

…

(Garfield and Sher 1963)

Science Citation Index

1964

Journal Citation Reports

1975

institute for scientific information

Journal Impact Factor

1963

Science Citation Index

1964

Journal Citation Reports

1975

ISI

institute for scientific information

new data providers (1)

new data providers (2)

“new” algorithms (1)

influence weight

1975

all citations are not born equal

all citations are not born equal

all citations are not born equal

influence weight

1975

Scopus Elsevier

2005

eigen factor

2007

ISI - WoS

1998

SCImago journal ranking

2007

“new” algorithms (2)

h index

2005

h-index

h-index

h-index

2005

Google Scholar

2005

Publish

• r

Perish

2006

PoP (Publish or Perish)

PoP (Publish or Perish)

• pen repositories

downloads

database total impact

views citations hyperlinks

bibliometrics 1 2 3

1