A Year in Review Part II- Court Cases and Other Rulings Presented - - PDF document

1

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA 23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

A Year in Review Part II- Court Cases and Other Rulings

1

Presented by Kimberly A. Fanniff Senior Staff Counsel

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Fox v. Costco Wholesale Corp.

• 2nd Cir. joined other federal appellate courts in

ruling that hostile environment claims may be brought under the Americans with Disabilities Act

– Harassment sufficiently severe or pervasive to create abusive environment – Specific basis for imputing the objectionable conduct to the employer

2

2

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Bender v. Lancaster CSD

• Termination of assistant principal for violation of

last chance agreement related to alcohol

• ffenses reinstated by appellate court

– Lower court had vacated guilt determination for charges related to last chance agreement and determined penalty shocked the conscience – 4th Dep’t found termination did not shock the conscience given seriousness of misconduct and position as role model

3

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Blythe-Blaugh v. City of NY

• First department ruled termination did not shock the

conscience in case where teacher found guilty of excessive absenteeism and corporal punishment

– Teacher failed to seek medical exemption for absences until shortly before charges brought and never actually supplied documentation that her absences or tardiness were due to a medical condition – Teacher previously found guilty in two prior 3020-a proceedings related to absenteeism

4

3

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Ansley v. Jamesville-DeWitt CSD

• Bus driver’s termination for slapping special education

student after he punched her overturned by a divided court (Case is on appeal to NYS Ct of Appeals)

– Majority found termination excessive penalty in light of driver’s unblemished employment record and she had never made any physical contact with a student previous to this despite 20 incidents in which she had been struck or injured by student – 2 dissenters felt termination was appropriate due to seriousness

• f incident, violation of school policy and lack of remorse

displayed by the driver

5

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

UPSEU v. Enlarged City SD of Troy

• PERB affirmed ALJ decision removing nurses,
• ccupational and physical therapists from a unit of

nonprofessional titles

– Nurses and therapist positions required college degrees & specialized licensing – Daily contact with students, teachers, administrators & parents; collaboration between 3 positions to co-treat common patients – Employee preference not a factor in unit placement

6

4

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Amalgamated Transit Union v. CENTRO

• Employer’s unilateral change regarding procedures

for granting requests for use of intermittent leave under FMLA violated the Taylor Law

– FMLA and implementing regulations do not preclude bargaining with respect to procedures – Past practice existed such that CENTRO only questioned employees about intermittent FMLA leave where there was individualized suspicion of abuse – CENTRO violated duty to negotiate when it unilaterally implemented procedures where all employees were questioned regarding intermittent use of FMLA leave

7

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Matter of Brocton CSD

• ALJ ordered the union to execute a CBA after ruling

a member of the union’s bargaining team publicly failed to support ratification of the CBA and the union vote to ratify subsequently failed

– Teacher violated affirmative duty to support tentative agreement (unless give advance notice will not support) – Negative statements regarding increase in pay v. the increase in length of school day both prior to and at ratification meeting

8

5

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

V.W. v. Middle Country CSD

• Personal injury claim regarding negligent

maintenance of monkey bars may proceed

– Student fell from monkey bars at recess & was injured – District’s expert witness testimony was only speculative because monkey bars had been removed from playground when she conducted her inspection

• Conclusions regarding installation and appropriate

ground cover insufficient to support claim district appropriately maintained premises

9

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of Bd. of Educ. of Massapequa

• A recount will only be ordered when there is

evidence of substantial attack on integrity of tallies such as a showing of fraud or improper conduct

– Board sought recount by hand of ballots from one machine wherein 2 sets of candidates eqach received the exact same number of votes based on claim that such result was highly unusual and indicated machine malfunction – Recount denied as no evidence of fraud or improper conduct

10

6

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of Hubbard

• Bond vote upheld despite claims of improper

advocacy and argument that December date for vote was improper

– Mailer stating there would be zero tax increase was not false or misleading (new debt would replace that rolling off books) – Radio ads and informational materials urged voters to learn about project and did not improperly advocate for yes vote – December date in compliance with Education Law

11

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of Bd. of Educ. of Liverpool CSD

• Vote approving a proposition to utilize capital

reserve funds for certain projects annulled based upon error in wording of proposition

– Money district intended to utilize was from a 2016 capital reserve fund but proposition referred to 2009 capital reserve fund – No evidence in record to conclude voters’ approval of expenditure from 2009 fund would extend to 2016 fund – Error vitiated fundamental fairness of the vote

12

7

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of a Student with a Disability

• Commissioner concluded that the board erred

by finding the student guilty of a materially different charge than what was presented to student and his parents

– Modification of the charge was material and violated petitioner’s and the student’s rights to a fair hearing pursuant to the Education Law. – Short term and long term suspension expunged.

13

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of J.D.

• Student long term suspension for buying and consuming

marijuana brownie at school upheld

– Presentation of arguments in person to board regarding appeal

• f long term suspension not required by education law

– No evidence superintendent’s presence at executive session where appeal discussed resulted in improper ex parte communications but SD should take steps in future to avoid appearance of impropriety – No right to discovery in long term suspension hearing thus petitioners could not compel district to identify or produce witnesses

14

8

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of the Bd. of Educ. of Horseheads CSD

• Education Law §912 requires a school district to

provide health services to pre-K students enrolled in non public schools in the district

– When student is attending non-public school for purposes

• f receiving instruction the student is attending school for

purposes of entitlement to health services under §912 – School districts must enter contracts as required by §912 that specifies the kind of information and documents that will constitute sufficient proof of residency and the consideration to be paid for provision of health services

15

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of E.C.

• Denial of medical exemption upheld by

commissioner

– District may investigate to identify medically necessary reason for exemption – Consultation with medical professional at NYSDOH as well a school medical personnel was reasonable method to obtain guidance about potential dangers if student received a live vaccine

16

9

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of C.V. and Appeal of F.V.

• Commissioner determined school district improperly

decided students were not homeless

– Family left in district apartment when could not afford rent and moved to a basement apartment in another district – Basement apartment lacked a kitchen, is infested with rodents and experiences frequent losses of electricity – Current apartment was temporary accommodation and was not fixed adequate nighttime residence – Such an inadequate residence cannot become fixed and regular simply by length of time inhabitants have resided therein

17

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of J.L. and C.V.

• Family was no longer residing in district but was

briefly homeless such that the students were entitled to attend school in the district through the end of the 2018-19 school year

– Portion of time family resided with relatives or in a camper

• n grounds of uninhabitable house rendered them

homeless – Rental outside the district was not temporary, transitional

• r inadequate

18

10

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of Dumerlin

• Belated request for transportation based upon

decision to transfer students midyear was properly denied

– Belated decision to enroll in private school and belief that private school would better meet needs of student are not reasonable excuses for late request – Cost more than $16,500 to transport for remainder of school year

19

23rd Annual Pre-convention School Law Seminar • Co-hosted by NYSSBA and NYSASA

Appeal of Radano

• District’s distance measurement procedures for

determining eligibility for transportation upheld

– Transportation software calculation & calibrated odometer readings upon request were reasonable methods – No evidence to explain why petitioner’s internet mapping calculation should be substituted for that of calibrated

• dometer

– Hardship or inconvenience to parents not legal basis for entitlement to transportation

20